1933 Spanish general election

1933 Spanish general election

←  1931 19 November 1933 1936  →
All 473 seats of the Congress of Deputies 237 seats needed for a majority
Turnout	67.31%
First party Second party Third party   Leader José María Gil-Robles y Quiñones Alejandro Lerroux Francisco Largo Caballero Party CEDA PRR PSOE Leader since 4 March 1933 1908 1932 Leader's seat Salamanca & León Valencia-capital Madrid-capital Last election 5 seats [nb 1] 90 seats 115 seats Seats won 115 102 59 Seat change 110 12 56   Fourth party Fifth party Sixth party   Leader José Martínez de Velasco Francesc Cambó The Count of Rodezno Party Agrarian minority Regionalist League Traditionalist Communion Leader since 1934 1918 1931 Leader's seat Burgos Barcelona capital Navarre Last election 15 seats 2 seats 4 seats Seats won 30 24 20 Seat change 15 22 16
Areas of most support: the right (dark blue), the centre-right (light blue), the centre (green) and the left (red).
Prime Minister before election Diego Martínez Barrio PRR Prime Minister after election Alejandro Lerroux PRR

Elections to Spain's legislature, the Cortes Generales, were held on 19 November 1933 for all 473 seats in the unicameral Cortes of the Second Spanish Republic. Since the previous elections of 1931, a new constitution had been ratified, and the franchise extended to more than six million women. The governing Republican-Socialist coalition had fallen apart, with the Radical Republican Party beginning to support a newly united political right.

The right formed an electoral coalition, as was favoured by the new electoral system enacted earlier in the year. The Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (Partido Socialista Obrero Español, or PSOE) won only 59 seats. The newly formed Catholic conservative Spanish Confederation of the Autonomous Right (Confederación Española de Derechas Autónomas or CEDA) gained 115 seats and the Radicals 102. The right capitalised on disenchantment with the government among Catholics and other conservatives. CEDA campaigned on reversing the reforms that had been made under the Republic, and on freeing political prisoners. Anarchists favoured abstention from the vote. These factors helped the election to result in significant victory for the right over the left.

Background

Elections in June 1931 had returned a large majority of Republicans and Socialists to the Cortes, with the PSOE gaining 116 seats and the Radical Republican Party 94. ^[1] The state's financial position was poor. Wealth redistribution supported by the new government attracted criticism from the wealthy. ^[2] The government also attempted to tackle poverty in rural areas by instituting an eight-hour day and giving security of tenure to farm workers, drawing criticism from landlords. ^{[3] [4]}

An effective parliamentary opposition was led by three groups. The first included Catholic movements such as the Catholic Association of Propagandists ( Asociación Católica de Propagandistas ). ^{[nb 2] [4]} The second group consisted of organisations that had supported the monarchy, such as the Renovación Española and Carlists, who wanted to see the new republic overthrown in a violent uprising. ^[5] The third group were fascist organisations. ^[5] Members of the National Confederation of Labour (Confederación Nacional del Trabajo, or CNT) trade union movement willing to cooperate with the Republic were forced out of the CNT, which continued to oppose the government. ^[6] Opposition parties had the support of the church. ^[7] A new constitution was ratified on 9 December 1931. ^[8] It included many controversial articles, some of which were aimed at curbing the influence of the Catholic Church. ^[9] The constitution was reformist, liberal, and democratic in nature, and was welcomed by the Republican-Socialist coalition, but opposed by landowners, industrialists, the organised church, and army officers. ^[8] In opposing educational and religious reforms, Spanish Catholics were forced to oppose the government. ^[10] The press criticised government actions as barbaric, unjust, and corrupt. ^[11]

In October 1931 Prime Minister Niceto Alcalá Zamora resigned and was succeeded by Manuel Azaña. Radical Party leader Alejandro Lerroux had wanted that job himself and became alienated, switching his party's support to the opposition. ^[10] This left Azaña dependent on the Socialists, but both the Socialists, who favoured reform, and the conservative right, who were against reform, were critical of the government. ^[12] Socialists continued to support Azaña, but the left became fractured, driving the Socialists to the left, while the right united into CEDA, which tacitly embraced fascism. ^{[11] [13]}

On 1 October 1933, Socialist left leader Largo Caballero spoke out against Lerroux's Republicans, suggesting the reform programme of the government, and thus the basis for the Republic itself, was under threat. He warned that if the government itself were the threat, the Socialists would have to withdraw support for it. ^[14] The following day another Socialist leader, Indalecio Prieto, declared that the Socialists would no longer participate in government, which precipitated its collapse. Alcalá Zamora, who became president in 1931, now requested that Republican Martínez Barrio form a new government. Socialist opposition on both constitutional and ideological grounds meant the PSOE withheld its support for the Barrio government, which was formed on 8 October, but called for fresh elections to be held on 19 November 1933. ^[15]

Election

Nobody should vote, because politics means immorality, shameful business practices, growing fat, excessive ambition, uncontrolled hunger to become rich, to dominate, to impose oneself, to possess the privileges of State, both in the name of democracy and in the name of God, the Fatherland and the King.

— From an anarchist newspaper in October 1933. ^[16]

In common with the 1936 election, Spain was divided into multi-member constituencies; for example, Madrid had 17 representatives. However, each member of the electorate could vote for somewhat less than that – in Madrid's case, 13. This favoured coalitions, as in Madrid when the Socialists won 13 members and the right, with only 5,000 votes less, secured only the remaining 4. ^[17] This system had been passed in 1933. There would be two rounds of voting; 40% of the vote was necessary in the first round to win. In the event that no list of candidates reached 40%, then a second round would be composed of those achieving at least 8% in the first round. ^[18] It was the first election in Spain where women had the vote, following the new constitution. ^[19] This incorporated a new 6,800,000 electors. ^[18] The elections were held under Republican electoral law, which would guarantee a certain percentage of seats in a district to a plurality of votes no matter how weak the plurality. This law was amended in July 1933 to make it even more disproportionate (winning a plurality guaranteed 67% of seats and winning a majority guaranteed 80% of seats). This meant it strongly favoured coalitions and it had been passed by the Azaña government in the hopes it would secure electoral victory for the Spanish left. ^{[20] [21]}

The governing leftist parties went to the polls divided. The political right, on the other hand, formed the Union of the Right (Spanish : Unión de Derechas) which incorporated CEDA, agrarian parties and traditionalists. It stood on a three-point programme: religious and social reforms would be examined and rolled back where needed; agrarian reform would be reversed; political prisoners would be released. ^[18] These parties threw vast resources into their campaign, with ten million leaflets, 300,000 posters, radio and cinema addresses and aerial propaganda drops. ^[16] They called upon Catholics to defend order and religion against the bourgeois Republic. ^[16] The Radical Party campaigned primarily against the Socialists, since they would need the help of the political right if in government. They used mass-appeal slogans such as 'Republic, order, freedom, social justice, amnesty' and were confident following successes at municipal level in 1933. ^[18] Anarchists such as the CNT-FAI called for abstention: politicians were 'vultures', who must be overthrown by revolution. ^[16] If the right were to win the election, there would be an uprising, they promised. Thus, anarchists should avoid voting for the left, since overthrowing the government would be preferable. Abstention was supported by Benito Pabón and Miguel Abós  [ es ]. ^[22]

Elections were held on 19 November 1933. ^[19] A second round of voting was held in sixteen constituencies ^[22] on 3 December. ^[23] The campaign and elections were not without violence; thirty-four people were killed and far more injured, primarily by the political left but also by the political right. ^{[24] [25]}

Outcome

It resulted in an overwhelming victory for the right, with the CEDA and the Radicals together winning 219 seats. ^{[nb 3]} Although the political situation was complicated, parties of the right won around 3,365,700 votes, parties of the centre 2,051,500 votes, and parties of the left 3,118,000 according to one estimate. Turnout was around 8,535,200 votes, 67.5% of the electorate. ^[26] The right had spent far more on their election campaign than the Socialists, who campaigned alone. ^[27] Women, in their first election, mainly voted for the centre-right. ^[19] Julián Casanova observes that while some republicans and socialists had argued in 1931 against women's suffrage on the grounds it would deliver votes to the right, the right's 1933 victory was the result of a general political rightward shift, rather than because of the female vote. ^[28] The Communist Party, with perhaps 3,000 members, were at this point not significant. ^[29] Nationalist Basques won twelve of seventeen Basque seats, a considerable victory. ^[30] Keeping their promise, the CNT proclaimed a revolution. ^[22] There were many reasons the Socialists and Republicans lost out; the female vote alone cannot explain the shift. Among them was the disunity of the political left compared to the right, in a system that favoured broad coalitions. The Radicals and their supporters had also shifted to the right. Abstentionalism hindered Socialist and Republican candidates. Overall, the political system in Spain had changed dramatically since the last election. ^[22] The failure of the Spanish left was also partially attributable to the 1933 electoral law. The second Azaña government had amended the law to give disproportionate seats to pluralities and majorities, which ended up favouring broad coalitions. However, the refusal for the Socialists to collaborate with the left Republicans made such a left-wing alliance impossible, while the Spanish right had managed to form its own coalition. ^[31]

The Renovación Española and the Spanish Nationalist Party (Spanish : Partido Nacionalista Español, PNE) formed the National Block (Spanish : Bloque Nacional), with a total of 14 deputies. Similarly, the Republican Left of Catalonia (Catalan : Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya, ERC), the Socialist Union of Catalonia (Unió Socialista de Catalunya, USC) and the Union of Rabassaires (Unió de Rabassaires, UdR) formed the Catalan Left (Esquerra Catalana) with 18 deputies. ^[23] Five independents joined the Agrarians and one joined CEDA. The other seven, along with one member of Conservative Republican Party (Spanish : Partido Republicano Conservador, PRC), formed a group of independents called the Independent Right (Independiente de Derechas). The Mallorcan Regionalist deputy joined the Catalan League (Lliga Catalana), and the independent in favour of the Estella Statute joined the Basque Nationalist Party (Partido Nacionalista Vasco). 5 members of the Agrarians and one of the PRC joined CEDA, although the Agrarians as a whole resisted pressure to join CEDA, and formed the Spanish Agrarian Party (Partido Agrario Español). ^[23]

The left Republicans and Socialists attempted to pressure Niceto Alcalá Zamora, the president of the Republic, into cancelling the election results. They did not contest the ballot results but simply rejected the center-right's victory; they argued the Republic was a leftist project and so only leftist parties should be allowed to govern. CEDA insisted it rejected violence and would follow the rules of the republic; Payne notes that while it had lost six members during the campaign to violence from the left, CEDA had not retaliated in kind. However, Payne also observed that CEDA had insisted on making constitutional changes to the republic that would make it much more conservative and Catholic in nature, which the political left equated to fascism. ^[32]

The president of the Republic, Niceto Alcalá Zamora entrusted the formation of a cabinet to Alejandro Lerroux, who was reliant on the support of CEDA. ^[19] This was because Zamora was concerned that CEDA had authoritarian tendencies and thus instead proposed a centrist government under Lerroux that would rely on CEDA's support, which Gil Robles accepted. The CNT responded with an insurrection attempt in December, in which almost one hundred people would die and over another hundred injured, though the deaths were confined to combatants. ^{[33] [34]} Two large bombs were detonated in Barcelona on 1 December while on 8 December, explosions and violence broke out in eight cities. Most fighting took place in Zaragoza and Barcelona but also occurred elsewhere, as did indiscriminate acts of terrorism; trains were derailed and in Valencia, a bridge was destroyed causing a wreckage. In the town of Villaneuva de la Serena, an army sergeant in charge of the local recruitment post mutinied, along with several soldiers and fifteen civilian anarchists. The mutiny was crushed the next day with seven of its members, including the sergeant, being killed. The CNT-FAI also took control of several small towns, declaring the establishment of libertarian communism, burning records and abolishing money. However, by 12 December the authorities had mostly regained control. ^[35]

Results

Summary of the 19 November 1933 Congress of Deputies election results [23] [36]
Electoral alliance			Votes	%	Seats
		Union of the Right (CEDA, Agrarians, CT, PRC, RE, Falange, PRLD, PRCe, PRM)	2,327,200	27.16	138
		Spanish Agrarian Party	152,400	1.78	6
		Liberal Democrat Republican Party–CEDA	124,500	1.45	13
		Traditionalist Communion	53,700	0.63	3
		Total Union of the Right:	2,657,800	31.02	160
	Spanish Socialist Workers' Party		1,858,300	21.68	63
		Radical Republican Party	1,208,700	14.10	70
		Conservative Republican Party	92,700	1.08	5
		Progressive Republican Party	7,400	0.08	0
		Total PRR and Centre:	1,308,800	15.26	75
	Union of the Right–Radical Republican Party		817,300	9.54	98
	Catalan Left (USC, ERC, UdR)		433,600	5.06	26
	Catalan League		413,700	4.83	28
	Basque Nationalist Party		183,000	2.14	11
	Coalition of the Republican Left (AR, PRRSI)		214,100	2.49	1
	Communist Party of Spain		154,100	1.80	1
		Galician Republican Party (OGRA, PG)	114,600	1.39	8
		Galicianist Party	25,000	0.29	0
		Total Galician Republican Party:	139,600	1.69	8
	Radical Socialist Republican Party		105,500	1.23	1
	Catalan Action–Left Republican Nationalist Party		74,200	0.87	0
	Federal Democratic Republican Party		34,200	0.40	0
	Workers and Peasants' Bloc		18,600	0.22	0
	Rural Action		10,600	0.12	0
	Iberian Revolutionaries		6,500	0.07	0
	Radical Socialist Left		1,400	0.02	0
	Independent Republicans		144,600	1.69	1
Totals:			8,575,900	100.00%	473

Seats

Party divisions at the start of the Cortes, after seats had been awarded between coalitions: ^[23]

Affiliation	Party		Name in Spanish or Catalan	Abbreviation	Seats
Marxist Left
		Spanish Socialist Workers' Party	Partido Socialista Obrero Español	PSOE	59
		Socialist Union of Catalonia	Unió Socialista de Catalunya	USC	3
		Communist Party of Spain	Partido Comunista de España	PCE	1
Republican Left
		Republican Action	Acción Republicana	AR	5
		Democratic Federal Republican Party	Partido Republicano Democrático Federal	PRD Fed.	4
		Independent Radical Socialist Republican Party	Partido Republicano Radical Socialista Independiente	PRSSI	3
		Radical Socialist Republican Party	Partido Republicano Radical Socialista	PRRS	1
Nationalist Left
		Republican Left of Catalonia	Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya	ERC	17
		Galician Republican Party	Partido Republicano Gallego	PRG	6
		Union of Rabassaires	Unió de Rabassaires	UdR	1
Republicans of the centre and of the Right
		Radical Republican Party	Partido Republicano Radical	PRR	102
		Conservative Republican Party	Partido Republicano Conservador	PRC	17
		Liberal Democrat Republican Party	Partido Republicano Liberal Demócrata	PRLD	9
		Progressive Republican Party	Partido Republicano Progresista	PRP	3
		Centre Republican Party	Partido Republicano de Centro	PRCe	2
		Independents of the Centre			5
Regionalists and Nationalists of the centre and of the Right
		Catalan League	Lliga Catalana	LC	24
		Basque Nationalist Party	Partido Nacionalista Vasco	PNV	11
		Mallorcan Regionalist Party	Partit Regionalista de Mallorca	PRM	1
		Independents (pro-Statute of Estella)			1
Parties of the Right
		Spanish Confederation of the Autonomous Right	Confederación Española de Derechas Autónomas	CEDA	115
		Spanish Agrarian Party	Agrarios (Minoría Agraria)	A	30
		Independents of the Right			13
Monarchist parties of the Right
		Traditionalist Communion	Comunión Tradicionalista (Carlista)	CTC	20
		"Spanish Renewal"	Renovación Española	RE	14
		Independent Monarchists			4
		Spanish Nationalist Party	Partido Nacionalista Español	PNE	1
Fascist parties
		Spanish Falange	Falange Española	FE	1
Total:					473

After reorganisation

This left the following divisions in the Cortes: ^[23]

Party		Name in Spanish or Catalan	Abbreviation	Seats
	Spanish Socialist Workers' Party	Partido Socialista Obrero Español	PSOE	59
	Communist Party of Spain	Partido Comunista de España	PCE	1
	Republican Left	Izquierda Republicana	IR	14
	Democratic Federal Republican Party	Partido Republicano Democrático Federal	PRD Fed.	4
	Radical Socialist Republican Party	Partido Republicano Radical Socialista	PRRS	1
	Catalan Left	Esquerra Catalana	EC	21
	Radical Republican Party	Partido Republicano Radical	PRR	102
	Conservative Republican Party	Partido Republicano Conservador	PRC	15
	Liberal Democrat Republican Party	Partido Republicano Liberal Demócrata	PRLD	9
	Independent Republicans	Republicano Independiente	RI	10
	Catalan League	Lliga Catalana	LC	21
	Basque Nationalist Party	Partido Nacionalista Vasco	PNV	12
	Spanish Confederation of the Autonomous Right	Confederación Española de Derechas Autónomas	CEDA	120
	Spanish Agrarian Party	Agrarios (Minoría Agraria)	A	31
	Independents of the Right			13
	Traditionalist Communion	Comunión Tradicionalista (Carlista)	CTC	20
	National Block	Bloque Nacional	RE	15
	Independent Monarchists			4
	Spanish Falange	Falange Española	FE	1
Total:				473

References

Notes

1. Compared to Popular Action results in 1931, which became part of the CEDA in 1932
2. See also: es:Asociación Católica de Propagandistas (in Spanish)
3. Thomas (1961). p. 66. allocates 207 seats to the political right.

Citations

1. Preston (2006). p. 50.
2. Preston (2006). pp. 41–42.
3. Preston (2006). p. 42.
4. Preston (2006). p. 43.
5. Preston (2006). p. 45.
6. Thomas (1961). p. 61.
7. Preston (2006). pp. 46–47.
8. Preston (2006). p. 53.
9. Thomas (1961). p. 46.
10. Thomas (1961). p. 47.
11. Preston (2006). p. 61.
12. Preston (2006). pp. 54–55.
13. Thomas (1961). p. 67.
14. Preston (1994). p. 177.
15. Preston (1994). p. 178.
16. Casanova (2010). p. 90.
17. Brenan (1950). p. 266.
18. Casanova (2010). p. 89.
19. Beevor (2006). p. 27.
20. Payne, Stanley G. The collapse of the Spanish republic, 1933-1936: Origins of the civil war. Yale University Press, 2008, p.39
21. Payne, Stanley G., and Jesús Palacios. Franco: A personal and political biography. University of Wisconsin Pres, 2014, p.84
22. Casanova (2010). p. 91.
23. "Elecciones a I Cortes de la República 19 de noviembre de 1933" (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 August 2011.
24. Payne, S.G. and Palacios, J., 2014. Franco: A personal and political biography. University of Wisconsin Pres. p. 84
25. García, Roberto Villa. "Political violence in the Spanish elections of November 1933." Journal of Contemporary History 48, no. 3 (2013): 446-462.
26. Enrique González. "A 75 años de la Revolución española (II)" (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 18 May 2019. Retrieved 6 August 2011.
27. Preston (2006). pp. 63–65.
28. Casanova, Julián. The Spanish republic and civil war. Cambridge University Press, 2010, p.92
29. Thomas (1961). p. 71.
30. Payne (1984). p. 195.
31. Payne, Stanley G. The collapse of the Spanish republic, 1933-1936: Origins of the civil war. Yale University Press, 2008, pp.39-40
32. Payne, S.G. and Palacios, J., 2014. Franco: A personal and political biography. University of Wisconsin Pres. p. 84-85
33. Payne, S.G. and Palacios, J., 2014. Franco: A personal and political biography. University of Wisconsin Pres. p. 85
34. Casanova, Julián. "Terror and Violence: The Dark Face of Spanish Anarchism." International Labor and Working-Class History, no. 67 (2005): 79-99. http://www.jstor.org/stable/27672986.
35. Payne, Stanley G. The collapse of the Spanish republic, 1933-1936: Origins of the civil war. Yale University Press, 2008, pp.43-44
36. "Votos por candidatura".

Sources

• Beevor, Antony (2006). The Battle for Spain: The Spanish Civil War 1936–1939. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson. ISBN   0-297-84832-1.
• Casanova, Juliàn (2010). The Spanish Republic and Civil War. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-73780-7 . Retrieved 9 August 2011.
• Brenan, Gerald (1950). The Spanish Labyrinth: an account of the social and political background of the Spanish Civil War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN   0-521-04314-X.
• Payne, Stanley G. (2006). The collapse of the Spanish Republic, 1933-1936: origins of the Civil War . Yale University Press. ISBN   0-300-11065-0.
• Preston, Paul (2006). The Spanish Civil War: Reaction, revolution and revenge (3 ed.). HarperCollins. ISBN   0-00-723207-1.
• Preston, Paul (1984). Revolution and war in Spain, 1931-1939. Methuen. ISBN   978-0-416-34960-3 . Retrieved 9 August 2011.
• Preston, Paul (1994). The coming of the Spanish Civil War: reform, reaction, and revolution in the Second Republic. Psychology Press. ISBN   978-0-415-06354-8 . Retrieved 9 August 2011.
• Thomas, Hugh (1961). The Spanish Civil War (1 ed.). London: Eyre and Spottiswoode. OCLC   395987.