| Episode title | Paranormal topic | True Crime topic | Release date |
|---|
| 1. | Frances Ford "Cupola" and the Off-Brand Kool-Aid | Winchester Mystery House | Jonestown Cult Suicide | 9 February 2017 |
| 2. | Clothesline Cookies and the Lone Band-Aid | Whaley House | Robert Durst | 15 February 2017 |
| 3. | Paranormal Bitchslaps and the Body Examiners | The Bell Witch | Black Dahlia | 19 February 2017 |
| 4. | Demon Pigs and a Call from Tamara | Amityville Haunting | Sodder Children | 26 February 2017 |
| 5. | The "Creepy Little Thing" and a Journey of Self-Destruction | Smurl Poltergeist | John Wayne Gacy | 5 March 2017 |
| 6. | The Human Hair Version and the Worst Social Studies Class Ever | Robert the Doll | Elizabeth Smart Kidnapping | 12 March 2017 |
| 7. | A Menorah Made of Lava and the Jerry Springer of Germany | Eastern State Penitentiary | Hinterkaifeck Massacre | 19 March 2017 |
| 8. | Our First Fight and Franzia Stains... or Blood | Queen Mary Ship | Maura Murray Disappearance | 26 March 2017 |
| 9. | The Wandering Cowboy and the Pregnancy Pact, but for Boys | The Sallie House | Michael Malloy | 2 April 2017 |
| 10. | Annabelle the Doll-y Parton Impersonator and the Tap Water Scammer | Annabelle the Doll | H. H. Holmes | 9 April 2017 |
| 11. | A Drunk Pandora's Box and How to Play the Elevator Game | The Dybbuk Box | Elisa Lam Death | 16 April 2017 |
| 12. | The 300-Year-Old Drama Queen and the Bitchy 7th Grader | Busby's Stoop Chair | Carl Tanzler | 23 April 2017 |
| 13. | The Cincinnati Mobsters and a PSA for Samsung | Bobby Mackey's Music World | Lisanne Froon and Kris Kremers | 30 April 2017 |
| 14. | The Old School House of Pies and Freud's Field Day | Hotel Monte Vista | Josef Fritzl | 7 May 2017 |
| 15. | A Sample of Our Outhouse and Catfished by Lucifer | St. Alban's Sanatorium | Gypsy Rose Blanchard | 14 May 2017 |
| 16. | Horse Grunts and the 1900s Policeman Who Was Also a Scarf Person | Lemp Mansion | Papin Sisters | 21 May 2017 |
| 17. | Flo & Frankenstein and Christine Has Another Stroke | Stanley Hotel | Katherine Mary Knight | 28 May 2017 |
| 18. | An Even Worse Eyeball Story and the Adventures of Captain Midnight | LaLaurie Mansion | Craigslist Killer | 4 June 2017 |
| 19. | A Great View of the DMV and There's No Such Thing as a Fun Best Friend Murder * | Hilltop House Hotel | Christine Paolilla | 11 June 2017 |
| 20. | Fun Times in the Body Chute and Em's Hairy Torso | Waverly Hills Sanitorium | Gregory Scott Hale | 18 June 2017 |
| 21. | Four Pounds of Uneaten Bacon and A Deeply Holy-Some Blonde | Villisca Axe Murders | Robert William Fisher | 25 June 2017 |
| 22. | Vicious Vices and a "Shaved Off" Shotgun | Trans Allegheny Lunatic Asylum | Robert Reldan | 2 July 2017 |
| 23. | A Demon Named Adelle and Oceans 11:06 | Roland Doe | George Joseph Smith | 9 July 2017 |
| 24. | A Ouija Board PSA and Lessons on Limes | Zozo | Xavier Dupont de Ligonnes | 16 July 2017 |
| 25. | Ghostly Frenemies and Alcala-ism | White House Ghosts | Rodney Alcala | 23 July 2017 |
| 26. | Homo-cidal Birdman and the Confessions of Shauna K. | Alcatraz | Mark Twitchell | 30 July 2017 |
| 27. | Mr. Carbunkle and A Science Class Murder | Monte Cristo Homestead | Skylar Neese | 6 August 2017 |
| 28. | Fannie and the Floppy Disk | Myrtles Plantation | Rebecca Schaeffer | 13 August 2017 |
| 29. | Seasonally Employed Ghosts and the Scottish Tim McGraw | Jefferson Hotel | Peter Thomas Anthony Manuel | 20 August 2017 |
| 30. | Slagpot Wormwood and Em's Nomadic Clown Life | Sloss Furnaces | Sylvia Likens | 27 August 2017 |
| 31. | Pretty Woman Status and the Paranormal Pirate | Driskill Hotel | The Bloody Benders | 3 September 2017 |
| 32. | Father Beelzebub and 4,000 Salutes | Anna Ecklund | Luka Magnotta | 10 September 2017 |
| 33. | Coughin' on Coffins and #WereTheBride ** | Rolling Hills Asylum | Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka | 17 September 2017 |
| 34. | A 200-lb Rat and the Dollar Store Plunger | San Pedro Haunting | Jack Unterweger | 24 September 2017 |
| 35. | A Popcorn Fortune and a Friend Named Squirrel | Summerwind Mansion | Rampart Street Murder House | 1 October 2017 |
| 36. | A German Socialist Airbnb and a Myspace Lesbian Porno | Franklin Castle | Bathtub Girls of Ontario | 8 October 2017 |
| 37. | Kyle Columbus and The Napoleon Complex but with Cannibalism | St. Augustine Lighthouse | Issei Sagawa | 14 October 2017 |
| 38. | An Alli-Ghost and the Gilded Eleventh Ballroom | Menger Hotel | John List | 21 October 2017 |
| 39. | A Girl Named German and La La Land 1 1/2 | Anneliese Michel | The Axeman of New Orleans | 29 October 2017 |
| 40. | A Fashion-Forward Victorian Ghost and Workplace Triangulation | Crescent Hotel | Edmund Kemper | 5 November 2017 |
| 41. | Dr. Carrot and the Score of Yore | Great Amherst Mystery | Herb Baumeister | 12 November 2017 |
| 42. | The Eternal Bromance and Pretty Little Liars 3:16 | Harvard Exit Theater | Ed Gein | 19 November 2017 |
| 43. | A Hell-Roaring Camp and a Chick-en-Training | Bullock Hotel | Wineville Chicken Coop Murders | 26 November 2017 |
| 44. | Turtle Tortoise and Frogger: IRL | Ashley's of Rockledge | Ursula and Sabina Eriksson | 3 December 2017 |
| 45. | Excessive Murder and Miss Vatican | June and Jennifer Gibbons | Joyce McKinney | 10 December 2017 |
| 46. | Cinnamontown (TM) and Pastor Detective | St. James Hotel | Pedro Lopez | 17 December 2017 |
| 47. | A Boozy, Goat-Horned Menace and an Unwashed Cup | Krampus | Tamara Samsanova | 24 December 2017 |
| 48 | The Island of Misfit Priests and the Easter Egg Rapist | George Lukins | East Area Rapist | 31 December 2017 |
| 49. | Bananas in Pajamas and Your Friendly Local Kioskman | Barney and Betty Hill | Lake Bodom murders | 7 January 2018 |
| 50. | Luvs 'N Laffs and an Alt-Right Turn | Loftus Hall | Jamison Family | 14 January 2018 |
| 51. | The One Where Ross Gets a Pager and a Moment of Silence for Google | South Shield Poltergeist | Ted Bundy | 21 January 2018 |
| 52. | A Reverse Pickpocket and There Goes Melinda | Fairmont Banff Springs Hotel | Michael Alig | 28 January 2018 |
| 53. | The Perm of the Century and A Call to the Apron Factory | Black Eyed Kids | Dolly Oesterrich | 4 February 2018 |
| 54. | THE ANNIVERSARY EPISODE *** | Jack the Ripper | Past Life Experiences | 11 February 2018 |
| 55. | Big (Frat) Brother and a Dixie Cup Stethoscope | Congress Plaza Hotel | Ward Weaver III | 18 February 2018 |
| 56. | Hell's Carpet and McDonald's Airbnb | Enfield Haunting | McStay Family Murders | 25 February 2018 |
| 57. | Harry Potter and the Chamber of Zombies and an Em-vis Impersonator | Russian Sleep Experiment | David and Louise Turpin | 4 March 2018 |
| 58. | Wicca-How.com and the Return of RicePudding9 **** | The House of 200 Demons | Richardson Family Murder | 11 March 2018 |
| 59. | The Spirit of AOL and Granola Silly Putto | Joshua Ward House | Slenderman Stabbings | 18 March 2018 |
| 60. | A Brief History of the Indianapolis Urgent Care and A Distorted View of Ice Cream | Central Indiana State Hospital for the Insane | Yorkshire Ripper | 25 March 2018 |
| 61. | A Human Lazy Susan and the Bloody Brunch | Squirrel Cage Jail | Leonarda Cianciulli | 6 April 2018 |
| 62. | The Musical History Algebra Podcast and Emvis Returns | Morris-Jumel Mansion | Barbara and Patricia Grimes | 8 April 2018 |
| 63. | A Good Old Canadian Gaol and the Summer of Like | Ottawa Jail | Robinson Family Murders | 15 April 2018 |
| 64. | Father Bob and Wrong Answers | Borley Rectory | Locked Room Mysteries | 22 April 2018 |
| 65. | A Gender-Neutral Wolf and Satan's Center Mouth | Dante's Inferno | Golden State Killer and Mandy Steingasser | 29 April 2018 |
| 66. | Snowflake Forest and the Bacon Society | Travis Walton Abduction | Robert Pickton | 5 May 2018 |
| 67. | The UK Office Alien and Too Much Mutton | Mothman | Lizzie Borden | 13 May 2018 |
| 68. | A Lazy River Cellar and a Buffett Tattoo | Barnstable House | Brian Shaffer | 20 May 2018 |
| 69. | The John Wick Effect and Funky Politics | Spontaneous Combustion | Wallace Souza | 27 May 2018 |
| 70. | Fall Out Walt and a Child Called Murder | Doris Bither Poltergeist | Belle Gunness | 3 June 2018 |
| 71. | Spicy Highways and the New Brazilian Evangelical Gay Church of Murderers | Yuma Territorial Prison | Suzane von Richtofen | 10 June 2018 |
| 72. | A Bonanza of Coal and the Wrong Way to Impress a Girl | Black Star Canyon | Daniel Wozniak | 17 June 2018 |
| 73. | Catholic Goosebumps and the Masked Blank | St. Louis Cathedral | Beast of Jersey | 23 June 2018 |
| 74. | A Polite Shadowman and a Phony Film School | Pantages Theater | Clara Phillips | 1 July 2018 |
| 75. | Pickled Bodies and the Grim Repo Woman | Payton Randolph Hou se | Marlene Warren Murder | 8 July 2018 |
| 76. | A Venn DiagRUM and Detective Constable Christine | Savannah Pirate House | Shannon Matthews Kidnapping | 15 July 2018 |
| 77. | A Baptized Wonton and Spiral Notebook-ing | Children of Woolpit | Jennifer Pan | 22 July 2018 |
| 78. | Paranormal Toontown and 40,001 Mystery Experiments | Skinwalker Ranch | Joseph Kallinger | 29 July 2018 |
| 79. | A Demonic Cold Sore and the World's Smallest Violin | Peggy the Doll | Mary Vincent | 4 August 2018 |
| 80. | Paranormal Justice and a Depressing High School Reunion | Rotherwood Mansion | Paula Herring | 12 August 2018 |
| 81. | Little Pilgrims and Astrological Issues | Flannan Isles Lighthouse | Charles Cullen | 19 August 2018 |
| 82. | Everyone's Ghostly Stepdad and a Tattoo of Frosted Tips | Lizzie Borden House | Amy Lynn Bradley Disappearance | 26 August 2018 |
| 83. | Ghost Goats and Horror-scopes | Goatman's Bridge | Donald Henry Gaskins | 2 September 2018 |
| 84. | A Powerful Chicken and a Techno Haunting | Aswang | Henry Lee Lucas | 8 September 2018 |
| 85. | Transgender Lemonade and Old Ass Bowling Balls | Ed Gein's Cauldron and Bela Lugosi's Mirror | David Edward Maust | 16 September 2018 |
| 86. | The Haunted Doll Market and 420 Zodiac | Harold the Doll | Zodiac Killer | 23 September 2018 |
| 87. | Paranormal Fun Facts and Your Sister's Pony | Casper the Friendly Ghost | Jack Gilbert Graham | 30 September 2018 |
| 88. | A Low Key Brothel and a Japanese Skater Boy | Cary Hotel | Setagaya Family Murders | 7 October 2018 |
| 89. | Violent Tickling and a Hollywood Bonfire | Cecil Hotel | William Desmond Taylor | 13 October 2018 |
| 90. | High Quality Excitement and a Serial Killer Crossover | Bloody Mary | Joel Rifkin | 21 October 2018 |
| 91. | Mad Lib Disease and an Everlasting Faint | Scary Linda Stories | Ouija Board Murders | 28 October 2018 |
| 92. | Twin Theybies and a Phone Call to the Mayor | La Llorona | Scary Renate Stories | 4 November 2018 |
| 93. | The Broad of Broadcast and a Love Rhombus | Rose Hall Manor | Lauren Giddings | 10 November 2018 |
| 94. | Cocoa Pebbles County and the Cannibal Cafe | Byberry Mental Hospital | Armin Meiwes | 18 November 2018 |
| 95. | A Wendigo Named Megan and a Winnebago in the Woods | Wendigo | Hannah Graham and Morgan Harrington | 25 November 2018 |
| 96. | A Garden in the Rear and a Rejection from ISIS | Octagon House | Selfie Killer (Amanda Taylor) | 2 December 2018 |
| 97. | A Rogue Cork and The Millennium Special | Popper the Poltergeist | Katy Harris and Krystal Surles | 9 December 2018 |
| 98. | Exorcism Colonics and a Hot Sauce Love Potion | Exorcist of the Vatican | Tina Watson | 16 December 2018 |
| 99. | Paranormal Swirl and Aura Imprinting | The Ramms Inn of Gloucestershire | Yogurt Shop Murders of Austin, TX | 22 December 2018 |
| 100. | Cryptids for 400 and a Best-Friend-Elope | Mary Celeste Ghost Ship | Andras Pandy | 29 December 2018 |
| 101. | A Ghost in the Nude and a Pasta Peddler | General Wayne Inn | The Philly Poison Ring | 6 January 2019 |
| 102. | Quantum Madness and an Abundance of Icicles | Time travel and Project Pegasus Part 1 | Paul Michael Stephani | 13 January 2019 |
| 103. | Martian Beer Pong and Sweat Glands of the Hand | Time travel Project Pegasus Part 2 | Altemio Anchez | 19 January 2019 |
| 104. | The Golden Girls Horror Crossover and a Cousin Cat | Borgvattnet Vicarage | Leslie Allen Williams | 27 January 2019 |
| 105. | The Great Non-Binary Owl and Kronk's Evil Twin | Elizabeth Bathory | Medieval Falling Sickness | 2 February 2019 |
| 106. | The Worst Toy Story and an Empty Wine Stockpile | Sleep Paralysis | John Frank Hickey | 10 February 2019 |
| 107. | Ghostly Cat Toes and A Box-in-a-Box-in-a-Box | Jerome Grand Hotel | Wendi Andriano | 17 February 2019 |
| 108. | The Kings of Banter and a Mummified Lemon | Dear David (story by Adam Ellis) | Viola Drath | 24 February 2019 |
| 109. | A Tornado of Cuddles and an Extra Ab | The Beast of Gevaudan | Evelyn Dick | 3 March 2019 |
| 110. | A Pretty Little Monster and a Planetary Enzyme | The Goatman of Maryland and The Pope Lick Monster | Ira Einhorn | 10 March 2019 |
| 111. | A Ghost Tour by Em and a Mother of Pearl Pie Tin | Shanghai Tunnels | D. B. Cooper | 16 March 2019 |
| 112. | The Age of Flurida and a Florida Man Floriscope | Fort Gary Hotel | Judy Buenoano | 24 March 2019 |
| 113. | Millennial Pink and Spanish Moss Red Bug Crayons | Flagler College | Diane Downs | 30 March 2019 |
| 114. | A Gnarly Rumor and Hysterical Historians | Pascagoula Abduction | John Christie | 7 April 2019 |
| 115. | A Digital Butler and Walls Full of Secrets | Pfister Hotel | The Watcher House | 14 April 2019 |
| 116. | The Pancake Witching Hour and the Ghost of Burritos Past | Ben Lomond Hotel | Lori Hacking | 21 April 2019 |
| 117. | The Buddy system Til Death and Sprinkles of Light in the Chicago Suburbs | Spooky Food Stories | Tylenol Murders | 28 April 2019 |
| 118. | A Demon in the Drain and Pentagrams on the Golf Course | Biltmore Estate | Dana Sue Gray | 5 May 2019 |
| 119. | A Shadow Figure Selfie and Inappropriate Dream Journaling | Salem Ghosts | Jane Toppan | 12 May 2019 |
| 120. | Burial Physics and the Troll of Jackass Hill | Gore Orphanage | Cleveland Torso Murders | 19 May 2019 |
| 121. | The Plumbing Dutchman and a Murderous Glow Down | The Flying Dutchman | Jake Bird | 26 May 2019 |
| 122. | Alien Bumper Cars and MTV Crypts | Navy UFO Reports | Susan Snow | 2 June 2019 |
| 123. | The Ignoramus of Nevada and a Poisoned Prune Cake | Advanced Aerospace Threat Identification Program | Nannie Doss | 9 June 2019 |
| 124. | A Birdless Penguin and The Wink Face Emoji | Tic-Tac Incident | Casey Anthony | 16 June 2019 |
| 125. | A Neighborhood of Haunted Houses and Codename Vanilla Lunch | Yesteryear Village | Isdal Woman | 23 June 2019 |
| 126. | Summer Camp at the Occult Vault and A Flintstone Motorcade | Edinburgh Vaults | Bryce Laspisa | 30 June 2019 |
| 127. | Human Wine and the Postal Service Bank | Poveglia Island | Alyssa Bustamante | 7 July 2019 |
| 128. | A Lasagna House and Scrapbooks of Destruction | The McRaven House | Michael Swango | 14 July 2019 |
| 129. | A Tipsy Alien and Your Least Favorite Word | Flatwoods Monster | Shari Faye Smith and Debra May Helmick | 21 July 2019 |
| 130. | A Creature's Femur and Giovani 3:16 | Varginha UFAO | Kristen Costas | 28 July 2019 |
| 131. | A Pretzel Worm and the 'That Was Easy' Button | Tatzelwurm | Tara Grant Murder | 4 August 2019 |
| 132. | A Lost Bitch and the Weirdest Thing Said in an Interview | Eloise Asylum | Karina Holmer Murder | 11 August 2019 |
| 133. | A Dumpy Tunnel and Dungeon Lite TM | Dover Castle | Max Gufler | 18 August 2019 |
| 134. | A "Quicker Than You Look" Trophy and a Threddit RabbitHole | Haunted Toys-R-Us Locations | Kristen Modafferi Disappearance | 25 August 2019 |
| 135. | The Ghost of Lamps Past and a Pumpkin Stealing Cryptid | Bridgewater Triangle | Mary Ashford and Barbara Forrest | 1 September 2019 |
| 136. | A French Toast Ghost and the Pepper Spray Squad | Hillview Mannor | Kate Stoffel and the Biddle Brothers | 7 September 2019 |
| 137. | Satan's Little Helper and the Year of the Microwave | Pukwudgie | Elizabeth Thomas Abduction | 15 September 2019 |
| 138. | Five-Dollar Geodes and Our Neverending Awkward Phase *****] | Hodag | Edward Wayne Edwards | 22 September 2019 |
| 139. | Lemon's Cousin and the Alien Frog Vendetta | Pier Fortunato Zanfretta | Stephen Peter Morin | 29 September 2019 |
| 140. | Psychedelic Conversations and the Frogman's Lazy River | Loveland Frogman | Rotherham Shoe Rapist | 6 October 2019 |
| 141. | Alligator Neck Looping and A Casual Last Minute Seance | Moon River Brewing Company | Sara Ambrusko Murder | 13 October 2019 |
| 142. | The Buffalo Plaid Anniversary and a Sweaty, Sweaty Witch | Grace Sherwood, The Witch of Pungo | Bruce McArthur | 20 October 2019 |
| 143. | Portal Ripping Muscles and Vampire Rumors | Ghosts of the Alamo | The Carter Brothers | 27 October 2019 |
| 144. | A Baby with Teeth and Another Pillar of the Community | Pittock Mansion | Jeanne Ann Childs Murder | 3 November 2019 |
| 145. | Octo-Puns and the Goose CamTM | Beattie Mansion | Helle Crafts | 10 November 2019 |
| 146. | Iceberg Feet and Valuable Skittles | James Dean Death Car | Durham Family Murders | 17 November 2019 |
| 147. | Catsgiving and a Sleeping Tuxedo | @gr3gory88 Twitter Feed | Lindbergh Kidnapping | 24 November 2019 |
| 148. | Fro-Yo Fridays and 15,000 Slices of Dirty Meatloaf | Kay's Cross | Franklin Bradshaw Murder | 30 November 2019 |
| 149. | An Unidentified Naked Object and the Girl Who Cried Jude Law | Ogopogo | Erika and Benjamin Sifrit | 8 December 2019 |
| 150. | Soul Stealing Otters and a Detector Inspector | Kushtaka | Shannon Siders | 15 December 2019 |
| 151. | The Penultimate Sisyphean Nightmare and Cursed Raisins | Kallikanzaros | Lawson Family Massacre | 21 December 2019 |
| 152. | A Cute Bread and Breakfast and Emotional Grilled Cheese Sandwiches | Sauer Castle | Susan Cox Powell | 29 December 2019 |
| 153. | An Ego Snack and a Lemon-napping | Hotel Galvez | Mary Morris Murders | 5 January 2020 |
| 154. | An Opera About Bread and A Fake Monogrammed Private Jet for Dogs | Omni Parker Hotel | Christian Gerhartsreiter | 12 January 2020 |
| 155. | A Teatime Seance and Lin-Manuel Miranda's Next Big Hit | Houdini Part 1 | Tweed Morris Murders | 19 January 2020 |
| 156. | The Chairman of the Haunted House Committee and Too Many Walters | Houdini Part 2 | Sharon Kinne | 26 January 2020 |
| 157. | A Hollywood Alien Correspondent and an Outer Space Lemon | The Akroyd Family | Kyle Fleischmann | 2 February 2020 |
| 158. | A Vodka Blanket and Radioactive Snow Angels | Dyatlov Pass | Kevin Bacon Murder | 9 February 2020 |
| 159. | A Sinister Vibe Check and the Governor of Noodletown | Ohio State Reformatory | Donald Harvey | 15 February 2020 |
| 160. | Parry Hotter and a Choose Your Own Sad-venture | Minnesota Iceman | Dorothea Puente | 23 February 2020 |
| 161. | Bald Anchovies and the Golden Birds | Thunderbird | Dorothy Jane Scott | 1 March 2020 |
| 162. | A Gaga-Damn Delight and Sense of Crohdar | Mandela Effect | Corey Breininger | 8 March 2020 |
| 163. | The Valedictorian of Space Camp and an Alien Princess | Poltergeist movie franchise | Jesse Pomeroy | 15 March 2020 |
| 164. | A Cold-Toed Ghost and an Impromptu Ski Waxing | Langham Hotel | Sherri Rasmussen | 22 March 2020 |
| 165. | Chaotic Riffing and Noodles All The Way To The Top | Hilary Porter | Anthonette Cayedito | 29 March 2020 |
| 166. | Banjo-less Banjo Lessons and Toddlers Learning How to Podcast | Thornton Heath Poltergeist | Lindsay Buziak | 5 April 2020 |
| 167. | The 69th Chakra and a Paranormal Insurance Family Plan Bundle | Mount Shasta | Heaven's Gate Cult | 12 April 2020 |
| 168. | Lemuria Studios and a Tarantula Millionaire | Lemurians | Nancy Moyer | 19 April 2020 |
| 169. | An Uncooked Goose and a B-Side Conspiracy | Omm Sety | Mitrice Richardson | 26 April 2020 |
| 170. | A La Croix Lobotomy and a Big Golden Eye | Aradale Mental Hospital | Bain Family Murders | 5 May 2020 |
| 171. | A Vegetarian Lake Monster and a Proud Consumptive | Pepie, the Lake Pepin Monster | Murder of Kitty Ging | 10 May 2020 |
| 172. | The Paranormal Cinematic Universe and a Cosmopolitan Globetrotter | Harry Price Part 1 | Lululemon Murder | 17 May 2020 |
| 173. | Mongoose Cam and a New Gemini Icon | Harry Price Part 2 | Smiley Face Killings | 24 May 2020 |
| 174. | A Diamond in the Wall and Untarnished Vibes | Harry Price Part 3 | Michelle Knotek | 31 May 2020 |
| 175. | A Ruined Candy Crush Score and a Birthday Jimmy Buffett | Anonymous (group) | Murder of April Kauffman | 14 June 2020 |
| 176. | A Cheesecake Business Meeting and a Pop Up Seance Nightclub | The Watseka Wonder | Kendrick Johnson | 21 June 2020 |
| 177. | Gio's Burner Phone and a Very Slow Steamship Tour | Congelier House | Sherri Dally abduction | 28 June 2020 |
| 178. | Christine's News Network and a Confused Conflagration | Cornelio Closa, The Invisible Boy | Murder of Dominique Fells | 5 July 2020 |
| 179. | Gio's Quantum Point and How to Spell Meghan Backwards | Radonautica App | Murder of Rhia Milton | 12 July 2020 |
| 180. | An Alien Silver Fox and Skeleton ASMR | Elizabeth Klarer | Jeffrey Dahmer | 19 July 2020 |
| 181. | Upside Down Eyes and Tiny Doll Hand Shaped Bruises | The Island of the Dolls | Rey Rivera Murder | 26 July 2020 |
| 182. | Meghan's Ghost Writer and a Glitter TikTok Box | Leap Castle | Kyron Horman | 2 August 2020 |
| 183. | A Deeply Warped Tour and Random Dan | The Fire Spook of Caledonia Mills | Whitaker Family Murders | 9 August 2020 |
| 184. | Cheesecake Drunk and Dog Fashion Swimming | Preston Castle | Angela Diaz | 16 August 2020 |
| 185. | The Presence of Emothy and a Wine Glass Planchette | Chupacabra | Tamla Horsford | 22 August 2020 |
| 186. | The Patron Saint of Podcasters and the Age of the Spinster | Poogan's Porch | Missy Bevers | 30 August 2020 |
| 187. | Lydia Chlamydia and Father Macaroni | Eleonora Zugun | Laurie Bembenek | 6 September 2020 |
| 188. | A Ouija Board Lemon and Poetized Martinis | Legend of Sleepy Hollow | Disappearance of Joshua Guimond | 13 September 2020 |
| 189. | A Poultry Ghost and a Manasshole | SS Ourang Medan | Lorena Bobbitt | 20 September 2020 |
| 190. | An After-Life Reality Show and a Hypnosis Session Spec Script | Nelly Butler, America's First Ghost | Keddie Cabin Murders | 27 September 2020 |
| 191. | Modern Trash And The Pantsless Burrito | Mercy Lena Brown, The Last American Vampire | Juana Barraza | 4 October 2020 |
| 192. | Comfy Chic and a Full Ass Exorcism | Snedeker Haunting | Bible John | 11 October 2020 |
| 193. | An Afterlife Guard and a Rose Colored Flag | The Night Marchers of Hawaii | Israel Keyes | 18 October 2020 |
| 194. | A Lisa Frank Ouja Board and Spider Egg Gum | Zak Bagans | Ronald O'Bryan | 25 October 2020 |
| 195. | Frankenstein's Ding Dong and Haphazardly Fermented Kraut | Frankenstein | East Coast Rapist | 1 November 2020 |
| 196. | Pop Icon Werewolves and Christine's Trash Can Cocktail | Werewolves Part 1 | Cindy Song Disappearance | 8 November 2020 |
| 197. | Satan's Sourdough Starter and a Fainting Couch | Werewolves Part 2 | Neil Stonechild and the Saskatoon Starlight Tours | 14 November 2020 |
| 198. | The Chef's Kiss of Death and Some Juice Covered News | Charleston Old City Jail | Watts family murders | 21 November 2020 |
| 199. | The Surgeon Sturgeon Named Spurgeon and Big Bert in the Million Acre Wood | Loch Ness Monster | Joshua Maddux | 29 November 2020 |
| 200. | The Burbank Fish-Flopper and a Homicidal Rhombus | Winchester Mystery House | Jonestown Cult Suicide | 6 December 2020 |
| 201. | Pi Day Advent Season and a Ouija Planchette Flasher | The Fox Sisters | Phoebe Handsjuk | 13 December 2020 |
| 202. | Spiritualist Chippendales and The Murder Situation Show | Davenport Brothers | Death of JonBenét Ramsey | 20 December 2020 |
| 203. | The Abdominal Snowman and Christmas on an Embered Ash | Abominable Snowman | The Grinch | 27 December 2020 |
| 204. | This Year's Sandwich Predictions and the Old Synaprague | Golem | Son of Sam | 3 January 2021 |
| 205. | A Zero Gravity Wine Bra and a Coffee Date with Slenderman | The Simpsons Predictions | Miriam Rodriguez Martinez | 10 January 2021 |
| 206. | A Vengeful Lady Fish and Biscuits with Bear | Pyramid Lake | Cleveland Kidnappings | 17 January 2021 |
| 207. | The Return of the Plunger Fort and the Paranormal Gossip Mill | Cheltenham Ghost | Betsy Faria | 24 January 2021 |
| 208. | Creepy Coats and a Party Lemon | Japan Airlines Flight 1628 Incident | Trang Ho | 31 January 2021 |
| 209. | A Ghost's Recliner and the PTA of Covens | Bettis House | Sean Vincent Gillis | 7 February 2021 |
| 210. | The Golden Plunger Award and the London Fog Cult | QAnon Part 1 | Rajneesh Movement | 14 February 2021 |
| 211. | The Echelon Twins and a Rotary Butt Dial | QAnon Part 2 | Kitty Genovese | 21 February 2021 |
| 212. | Conspiracy Theory Lasagna and the Migraine Episode | QAnon Part 3 | The Snowtown Murders | 28 February 2021 |
| 213. | A Trashy Bunny and the Podcast Built on a Thousand Demons | Arne Cheyenne Johnson | White House Farm Murders | 7 March 2021 |
| 214. | Em's Sleep Skin and Christine's Day Skin | Headless Nun of New Brunswick | Savannah LaFontaine-Greywind | 14 March 2021 |
| 215. | Bigfoot Geometry and Tin Can Fingerprints | Sasquatch | George Weyerhaeuser Kidnapping | 21 March 2021 |
| 216. | The Opposite of a Meet Cute and a Half-Sister in Space | Laura Clarke Alien Abductions | Anthony Sowell | 28 March 2021 |
| 217. | A Mantis Manifesto and a Serial Killer's Dentist | Mantis Alien | Richard Ramirez Part 1 | 4 April 2021 |
| 218. | A Skeleton's Waiting Room and Christine's New Screen Name | Bohemian Grove | Richard Ramirez Part 2 | 11 April 2021 |
| 219. | A Papier-Mache Nose Doll and Mothman's Grandchildren | Helen Duncan | The Somerton Man/Taman Shud Case | 18 April 2021 |
| 220. | Astrophysics Improv and the Owl Queen | Back Door theory | Joe Exotic | 25 April 2021 |
| 221. | Family Nuts and the Hitchhikers Guide to the Backrooms | Backrooms Theory | Abraham Shakespeare murder | 2 May 2021 |
| 222. | The Wine Kill Switch and the Paranormal Vagina Monologues | Eva Carriere | Lin Family murders | 9 May 2021 |
| 223. | Schiefesaurus and Balonatoons | The Kracken | Ted Kaczynski | 16 May 2021 |
| 224. | The Hogwarts of Prisons and Two Generations of Cringeworthy Screen Names | Mansfield Reformatory | The Circleville Letter Writer | 23 May 2021 |
| 225. | A Baby Barcalounger and the Water Tumbler of Doom | The Black Shuck | Harold Shipman | 30 May 2021 |
| 226. | Poisonous Sharks and the Patchsquatch | America's Hircine Shifter | The Wichita Massacre | 6 June 2021 |
| 227. | The Ghouls Next Door and the Criminal Pickle Barrell | Miss Molly's Hotel | Kayla Berg | 13 June 2021 |
| 228. | Goat Cheese Marshmallows and Bougie Gators | St. Augustine Old Jail | Icebox Murders | 20 June 2021 |
| 229. | Team Aliens and the Opposite of a Jolly Rancher | Westall UFO Sightings | Ronnie Long | 27 June 2021 |
| 230. | A Cauldron of Mac and Chees and Sugar Free Gummy Bear Consumption | Agnes Sampson | Jayme Closs | 4 July 2021 |
| 231. | A Royal Jalapeño Crib and The Worst Quilt Ever Quilted | The Brown Lad y of Raynham Hall | Shanda Sharer | 11 July 2021 |
| 232. | Paranormal Anxiety and a Seat in the Barking Room | Sorrel-Weed House | Charles Allen Jr. Disappearance | 18 July 2021 |
| 233. | Cryptid Smut and a Boy Boss Summer | Dover Demon | The Colts Neck Mansion Murders | 25 July 2021 |
| 234. | An Anxious Tooth Mouse and an Amateur Alligator Charmer | The Tooth Fairy | Lena Clarke | 1 August 2021 |
| 235. | Space Cowboys and Semantics Champions | The Rozwell Incident | Terrence Williams and Felipe Santos | 8 August 2021 |
| 236. | Ghostly Dog Breath and a Sardine and Sadness Sandwich | Pluckley Village | Magdalena Solis | 15 August 2021 |
| 237. | The Ghost With No Pants and a Matchmaking Serial Killer | Falcon Lake Incident | Glennon Engleman | 22 August 2021 |
| 238. | Bagelbites with Italian Seasoning and a Summer Camp Forensics Degree | Azzurrina | The Yoga Twins Murder | 29 August 2021 |
| 239. | A Trash Pile of Ghostly Magazines and the Paranormal DARE Program | Ed & Lorraine Warren Part 1 | Amanda Knox Part 1 | 5 September 2021 |
| 240. | A Haunted Hotline and a Vegan Doc Marten Sized Baby | Ed & Lorraine Warren Part 2 | Amanda Knox Part 2 | 12 September 2021 |
| 241. | Time Travel Art and Cubed Wombat Poop | Rudolph Fentz | Ivan Milat aka The Backpack Murders | 19 September 2021 |
| 242. | Ufo Potholes and Our Collective Eyebrow | Ariel School UFO Encounter | Laci and Scott Peterson Part 1 | 26 September 2021 |
| 243. | A Baker's Dozen No One Invited To The Party and A Bad Donut | Friday The 13th | Laci and Scott Peterson Part 2 | 3 October 2021 |
| 244. | A Demonic Cricut Cutter and Mercury's Mindflight | The Peabody-Whitehead Mansion | Michael and Suzan Carons aka The witch Killers | 10 October 2021 |
| 245. | Napkin Hating Ghosts and An Immortal Portal | The Ringcroft Poltergeist | Moses Sithole | 17 October 2021 |
| 246. | A Wall of Lava Lamps and Christine the Cackle Burger Witch | Hellfire Farm | Burger Chef Murders | 24 October 2021 |
| 247. | Roach Milk and Em-Raphobia | Perron Family Haunting Part 1 | Killer Clowns | 31 October 2021 |
| 248. | Paranormal Preschool Gossip and June's Podcast Calendar Models | Perron Family Haunting Part 2 | Joachim Kroll | 7 November 2021 |
| 249. | The Devil's Timeshare and Sleepwalking Mouths | Elizabeth Knapp Haunting | Trick or Treat Murder | 14 November 2021 |
| 250. | An Engineer of Good Times and Witches on Speed Dial | The Glenluce Devil | The Pillow Pyro | 21 November 2021 |
| 251. | Mercury in the Microwave and a Ghost's Attic Speakeasy | The Glenn Tavern Inn Part 1 | Susan Hamlin | 28 November 2021 |
| 252. | B-List Ghosts and French Diamond Thief Girlboss Energy | The Glenn Tavern Inn Part 2 and the Philip experiment | Jeanne De Valois-Saint Remi | 5 December 2021 |
| 253. | The Funcle Takeover and The Crime of Christine | Bunnyman Bridge Part 1 | Jurgen Bartsch | 12 December 2021 |
| 254. | The Bunnyman Bridge 5K and Pre-Halloween Santa Hats | Bunnyman Bridge Part 2 | Bathsheba Spooner | 19 December 2021 |
| 255. | Holiday Cryptid Friends and a Very Merry Christmas | Belsnickel | Santa Crimes | 26 December 2021 |
| 256. | The Quest for Vegan Fried Chicken And Waffles and a Ghost's Nightcap | The Olde Pink House | Fritz Haarman | 2 January 2022 |
| 257. | Xandy's Castle Roommate and Spicy Lighthouse Decor | Point Lookout Lighthouse | The Little Ross Lighthouse Murder | 9 January 2022 |
| 258. | One Titty Out History and Eternal Skinny Dipping | Castle of Good Hope | The Old Charleston Jail and Lavinia Fisher | 16 January 2022 |
| 259. | Ectoplasm Happy Hour and A Haunted Lawnmower | Ten Cent Beer Night | Pete the Poltergeist | 23 January 2022 |
| 260. | Detective Spatula and Beard Forensics | Old Baraboo Inn | Teresita Basa | 30 January 2022 |
| 261. | Supernatural Roaches and Ghost Potatoes | Curtis House Inn aka the 1754 House | Oscar Pistorius | 6 February 2022 |
| 262. | The Quadratic Formula for Our Crushes and AIM Screen Name Numerology | Numerology | Disappearance of Patti Adkins | 13 February 2022 |
| 263. | Best Friend TV Show Betrayal and the Era of Frappuccinos | Korner's Folly | Joyce Chiang | 20 February 2022 |
| 264. | Our Newfound Noodles and Christine's Quantum Thoughts | Urban legend of stairs in the woods that lead to nowhere | Élan School Part 1 | 27 February 2022 |
| 265. | Generation Xiinön and Intergalactic Instant Messages | Fermi paradox | Élan School Part 2 | 6 March 2022 |
| 266. | Em's Condemned Troll Hole and a Ouija Related Genital Bridge | History of Ouija boards | Nikko Jenkins | 13 March 2022 |
| 267. | Wooing Tactics and the Emothy Sunrise | Anansi's Goatman | Ramsay Scrivo | 20 March 2022 |
| 268. | A Sea Shanty for Christine and Paranormal FaceTime | Stone Lion Inn | Angel Makers of Nagyrév | 27 March 2022 |
| 269. | Cardiologically Speaking and a Magical Scarf Swoosh | Twin Bridges Orphanage | The Chess Board Killer Part 1 | 3 April 2022 |
| 270. | A Gold-Dipped Pickle and the Empurrress | The Palmer House | The Chess Board Killer Part 2 | 10 April 2022 |
| 271. | A Top-Heavy Brain and a Beer Can Easter | Barbro Karlén | Disappearance of Mekayla Bali | 17 April 2022 |
| 272. | The Most Emo Cryptid and the Emcyclopedia | Squonk | Hybristophilia | 24 April 2022 |
| 273. | The Jim Halpert of Ghosts and the People Pleasing Outlaw | Missouri State Penitentiary | Milton Sharp | 1 May 2022 |
| 274. | Psychic Clouds and a Literal Goldmine | Stone tape theory | 1976 Chowchilla kidnapping | 8 May 2022 |
| 275. | The Thneed of Kentucky and the Stigmata of Squidward Tentacles | Glamis Castle | Teresita Basa | 15 May 2022 |
| 276. | Christine Junior and Our Flatlined Sanity | Wyoming Frontier Prison | The Lego Murder | 22 May 2022 |
| 277. | A Grass-Fed Cryptid and Trash Snacks | Fresno Nightcrawler | Mantell UFO Incident | 29 May 2022 |
| 278. | A Birthday Demon and a Lunar Lemon | Alma Fielding/The Croyden Poltergeist | Cletus Hehmz | 5 June 2022 |
| 279. | Burnt Microphones and the Hauntland | Becker 1971 televised exorcism Part 1 | Richard Chase | 12 June 2022 |
| 280. | Emothy Phantom and the Walt Disney of Ghosts | Becker 1971 televised exorcism Part 2 | Bertha Gifford | 19 June 2022 |
| 281. | A Gossip Corner Dinner Trap and Facts Served Up on a Celery Dish | Emlen Physick Estate | Springfield Three | 26 June 2022 |
| 282. | A Sleep Zoo and a Big Gay Bathroom | Maringa Abduction aka AGRIPO Experiment | Belle Siddons aka Madame Vestal | 3 July 2022 |
| 283. | A Psychic Wordle Turtle and a Tangent Lasagna | Mirassol Abductions | Oklahoma Girl Scout murders Part 1 | 10 July 2022 |
| 284. | The Troll Hole Emporium and the Time Traveling Wedgie Patrol | Tizzie Whizie | Oklahoma Girl Scout murders Part 2 | 17 July 2022 |
| 285. | An Emergency Bag Escape Room and a Pantsless Recording | Afanc and the Lavellan | Lisa McVey | 24 July 2022 |
| 286. | A Middle Finger Lemon Manicure and the Devil's Night-Time Corn Walk | Devil's Tramping Ground (North Carolina) | Nicholas Barclay | 31 July 2022 |
| 287. | The Gay Bathroom Invite Revisited and a Selection of Mothman Mugs | Tarrare | Texarkana Moonlight Murders | 7 August 2022 |
| 288. | A Podcast Done via Ouija Board and a Bewitched Cow | Trial of Mary Webster (Witch of Hadley) | Van Breda Family Murder | 14 August 2022 |
| 289. | Jewish Deli Chocolate Milk and Microsoft PowerPoint Dissolve Ghosts | Spring-heeled Jack | Lake Oconee murders | 21 August 2022 |
| Special Episode: 2nd Annual Cryptids Unscripted Poetry Slam and Charity Auction | | | 21 August 2022 |
| 290. | Psychic Surgery Dreams and Christine's Principle's of Magic | Moundsville Penitentiary | Children of Thunder Part 1 | 28 August 2022 |
| 291. | Router Hauntings and Our Weekly World News Broadcasting Voices | Batsquatch | Children of Thunder Part 2 | 4 September 2022 |
| 292. | Hellhound Belly Rubs and Caveman Ghost Tchotchkes | U.S. Route 66 | Angela Hammond | 11 September 2022 |
| 293. | A Hottie Without a Body and the Fun Factory | Enfield Monster | Alferd Packer | 18 September 2022 |
| 294. | Strawberry Eyeballs and Our Wildest Autumnal Dreams | Crosswick Snake/Monster | The Scarlet Letter murder | 25 September 2022 |
| 295. | A Yak Attack and a Kidnapper's SoundCloud | Ghosts of Port Townsend | Abduction of Denise Huskins | 2 October 2022 |
| 296. | A Lemon Planchette Read-a-Long Graphic and a Material Girl Coffin | Manresa Castle | Alexander family and the Lorber Cult | 9 October 2022 |
| 297. | A Halloween Holiday Gift and Justice for Book | Selkie | Abduction of Shawn Hornbeck | 16 October 2022 |
| 298. | A Merch Bag of Dirt and the Latest Sensation for Jaded Lovers of Uncanny Things | Haunted coal mines | Pamela Smart | 23 October 2022 |
| 299. | A Lesson in Filaments and a Future Ghost Prank | Hotel del Coronado | Jane Marie Prichard | 30 October 2022 |
| 300. | Bougie Ghost Hunting and Wafts of Fog Friends | Winchester Mystery House, in person | Listener stories, paranormal equipment, EVPs | 6 November 2022 |
| 301. | Jack-o-lantern Moths and Spooky Smiles | History of Halloween traditions | Susan Kuhnhausen | 13 November 2022 |
| 302. | An Elbow Eyebrow and an Asparagus Salad | Berry Pomeroy Castle | Stacey Castor | 20 November 2022 |
| 303. | A Pumpkin Head and a Biased Bisexual | Disappearance of Frederick Valentich | Murder of Mandy Stavik | 27 November 2022 |
| 304. | Hand Paws and Wisconsinners | Beast of Bray Road | Athalia Ponsell Lindsley | 4 December 2022 |
| 305. | An Onion of a Drink and a Real Life Fish Flop | Greenbrier Ghost | Stalking of Laura Black | 11 December 2022 |
| 306. | Mailed Stale French Fries and Rogue Eyebrows | Greyfriars Kirkyard | Napa Valley Halloween Murders | 18 December 2022 |
| 307. | Secret Krampus and Creepy Cake | Perchta, Mari Lwyd, and Hans Trapp | Murders of Ed and Minnie Maurin | 25 December 2022 |
| 308. | Trenchfoot Animation and Ballhootin' Through the Holler | Dullahan | Murders along the Appalachian trail | 1 January 2023 |
| 309. | A Haunted Doll Book Club and a Murder Comic | Terrell Copeland UFO sightings | Cordelia Botkin | 8 January 2023 |
| 310. | The Town Shrieker and the Grape Escape | Banshee | Case that Stockholm Syndrome originated from Part 1 | 15 January 2023 |
| 311. | Vaudeville Canes and Hand-Clap Games | Tower of London | Case that Stockholm Syndrome originated from Part 2 | 22 January 2023 |
| 312. | Our AIM Renaissance and Our Cryptid Festival Year | Van Meter Visitor | Connecticut River Valley Killer | 29 January 2023 |
| 313. | Tommy Pickles Voice and Milkshake Throat | Haunted dorm rooms | Murder of Carole Garton | 5 February 2023 |
| 314. | Haircuts for Haunted Dolls and Christine's October Elf on the Shelf | Six haunted dolls | Christa Pike | 12 February 2023 |
| 315. | A Compendium on the Birds of Kentucky and a Celebrity Opossum | Torsåker witch trials of Sweden | Murder of Connie Dabate | 19 February 2023 |
| 316. | Em's Apothecary and a Tincture of Frenzy | The Seven Deadly Sins | Alice and Gerald Uden | 26 February 2023 |
| 317. | An Emergency Snuggie and a Vitaminute | Tallman House in Horicon, Wisconsin | Abduction of Katie Poirier | 5 March 2023 |
| 318. | Collateral Damage to Everyone's Misdeeds and Thor Peanut Butter Schiefer Schultz | Crossroads | Murder of Molly Watson | 13 March 2023 |
| 319. | Synchronicity Sandwiches and Long Lost Mustard Friends | Liminal spaces, Hecate | Murder of Janet Abaroa | 19 March 2023 |
| 320. | A Lucid Dreaming Banana Experience and the Famous Saint Jack-in-the-Box Ley Line | Ley lines | Disappearance of Lauren Spierer | 26 March 2023 |
| 321. | A Coffee Unboxing and a Boiling Milk Cocktail | Mollie Fancher aka the Brooklyn Enigma aka the Fasting Girl | Khalil Wheeler-Weaver Part 1 | 2 April 2023 |
| 322. | The Halloween House and the Woolper News | Mammoth Cave in Kentucky | Khalil Wheeler-Weaver Part 2 | 9 April 2023 |
| 323. | Em's Galactic Bartending and Christine's Grog Shoppe | The Scottish play | Burke and Hare | 16 April 2023 |
| 324. | Foot Pimples and Chicken Pox Parties | Stigmatized property law aka the Ghostbuster Ruling | Kathleen Peterson aka the Staircase Murder | 23 April 2023 |
| 325. | Last Minute Lasik and Nonsense for Your Mind | The Union Screaming House in Missouri | Jared Fogle | 30 April 2023 |
| 326. | Step-Stud Muffins and Microphone Kisses | Abductions in the story of Brian Scott | Murder of Angie Dodge | 7 May 2023 |
| 327. | Consensual Foot Blister Pics and the Speaking Your Mind Dance | Moffitt Family haunting | Lewis–Clark Valley murders | 14 May 2023 |
| 328. | A Wicked Birthday Card and a Vampirarchy | Highgate Vampire | Murder of Ellen Sherman | 21 May 2023 |
| 329. | Sad Happy Hour and Night Nuts | Doppelgänger | Red Barn Murder | 28 May 2023 |
| 330. | Psychic Grandma and Swimming in Jeans | Kinsella twins UFO encounters | Duggar family | 4 June 2023 |
| 331. | A Milky Way Martini and a Naughty Gaudy Party | Ghost stories of the University of Toronto | The Porco family murders | 11 June 2023 |
| 332. | The Mysterious Bisexual and the Sauce of Time | Time traveler Sergei Ponomarenko | Murder of Nona Dirksmeyer | 18 June 2023 |
| 333. | Glowing Green Spaghetti Bolognese and a Teeny Tiny Apothecary | David Grusch UFO whistleblower claims | Case of Ryan Waller | 25 June 2023 |
| 334. | Macarena of Veins and Casper's Foil | Hotel Alex Johnson | Murder of Grace Millane | 2 July 2023 |
| 335. | The Gospel of Chillax and a Plot Tornado | Sister Magdalena of the Cross | Lady of the Dunes | 9 July 2023 |
| 336. | An Armoire of Brandy Snifters and Mug Madness | UFO encounter of Snippy the horse | Hall–Mills murder case | 16 July 2023 |
| 337. | An Empire of Ems and a Sitcom about a Wizard's Origin Story | Dudleytown, Connecticut | eBay stalking scandal | 23 July 2023 |
| 338. | Caramel Apple Eating Ghosts and Moist Brains | Franz Mesmer | Malaysian Airlines Flight 370 | 30 July 2023 |
| 339. | A Time Capsule Era and a Weasel Break-In | 2012 doomsday prophecy | Viktoria Nasyrova | 6 August 2023 |
| 340. | Midnight Moon Bounces and Moody Away Messages | The Demon of Brownsville Road | Kelly Cochran | 13 August 2023 |
| 341. | Conversations with Fake Allison and Cast Iron Skeletons | Shaker's Cigar Bar in Milwaukee | Sherri Papini kidnapping hoax | 20 August 2023 |
| 342. | A Soft Launched Haunting and a Paranormal Rat King | Madison Seminary | Lori Arnold AKA the Queen of Meth | 27 August 2023 |
| 343. | Cute Mishaps and Emoticon Etiquette | Ghosts of Yosemite National Park | Costa Concordia disaster | 3 September 2023 |
| 344. | A Neon Parrot Beacon and a Hootenanny of Birds with Pigtails | La Lechuza aka the witch owl | Malcolm MacArthur | 10 September 2023 |
| 345. | Baba Yaga Barbie and Emergency Needlepoint | Baba Yaga | Lost Boys of Bucks County | 17 September 2023 |
| 346. | A Witch's Rap Battle and a Cursed Fart | John Darrell | Lucie Blackman | 24 September 2023 |
| 347. | A Lovely Villain Era and a Lasagna Horror | Hauntings of Lake Lanier | Billy the Kid | 1 October 2023 |
| 348. | Stolen Meditation Journals and Fun, Fruity Pond Water | The Catskills Crone | Barnes Mystery aka the murder of Julia Martha Thomas | 8 October 2023 |
| 3rd Annual Cryptids Unscripted Poetry Slam | | | 13 October 2023 |
| 349. | A Haunted Podcast Studio and a Space Boat | Project Blue Book | Disappearance of Susan Wolff | 15 October 2023 |
| 350. | Eyelid Licking Demons and Black Cat Broomsticks | Black cat lore | Heather Mayer | 22 October 2023 |
| 351. | Mongoose Sound-Waves and Halloween Caroling | Seven princes of Hell | Halloween pranks and crimes | 29 October 2023 |
| BONUS EPISODE: A Halloween Surprise with Roz Hernandez! | | | 31 October 2023 |
| 352. | A Vampire Castle Gift Shop and Millennial Secret Passageway Dreams | Vlad the Impaler and the hauntings of Bran Castle | Murder of Martha Moxley | 5 November 2023 |
| 353. | A Weird Date Agent and a Ghost Go Bag | Black Monk of Pontefract | The George Brothers | 12 November 2023 |
| 354. | A Tarot Therapy Session and a Ghost Cat Pawty | Old Idaho State Penitentiary | Disappearance of Kimberly Avila | 19 November 2023 |
| 355. | Ghouls, Gays, Theys and Cottage Core Lesbian Hauntings | Alton Towers | The Amityville Horror House | 26 November 2023 |
| 356. | Spam Artists and Interplanetary Gossip | Superstitions on mirrors | Case of Darlie Routier | 3 December 2023 |
| 357. | A Millennial Pause and a Scythe Tsunami | Psychopomps | Disappearance of Steven Kuback | 10 December 2023 |
| 358. | The Frenaissance and the Poopmonger | Mary King's Close | Dennis Rader - BTK Part 1 | 17 December 2023 |
| 359. | Secret Society Bullshit and Paranormal Rejection at the Front Desk | The Augustine Steward House | Dennis Rader - BTK Part 2 | 24 December 2023G |
| 360. | A Vampiric Stage Lipstick and a Nap Episode | Third man factor Syndrome | Murders of Dean and Tina Clouse | 31 December 2023 |
| 361. | Troll Hole To-Go and Naming Our ADHD | Possession of Clarita Villanueva | Murder of Brenda Powell | 7 January 2024 |
| 362. | An Identi-Tea Crisis and Wobbly Mountain | The Bennington Triangle | Harvey Glatman AKA the Glamour Girl Slayer | 14 January 2024 |
| 363. | A Failed Handstand and an Infestation of Prairie Dogs | Cheesman Park | The Spider Man of Denver | 21 January 2024 |
| 364. | A Boulder of Salt and a Shot Put of Horseradish | Acid Bridge and the 7 Gates of Hell | The Death of Natalie Wood | 28 January 2024 |
| 365. | Podcasting in Dog Years and Collecting Crows Feet | The Nodolf Incident | The Lipstick Killer Part 1 | 4 February 2024 |
| 366. | Troll Butter and Moon Spit | Kentucky Meat Shower | The Lipstick Killer Part 2 | 11 February 2024 |
| 367. | Millennial Road Signs and Yappucinos | Baba Vanga Prophecies | Case of Natalia Grace | 18 February 2024 |
| 368. | Whodunnit Hauntings and Three Lollipops in a Trench Coat | Haunting of Isabell Binnington | Murder of Sharron Prior | 25 February 2024 |
| 369. | Frankenstein's Monster's Ghost and Grunge Justice | The Dakota Apartments | Murder of Mia Zapata | 03 March 2024 |
| 370. | Therapy Book Club and Satan's Church Fonts | Rougarou | Malcolm Naden | 10 March 2024 |
| 371. | Warnings About File Organizing and Smooth Coffee Shop Compliments | Twin Flames Universe Cult | Holly K. Dunn | 17 March 2024 |
| 372. | A Trash Nap and a Clumsy Girl Ghost | King's Tavern | Murder of Seath Jackson | 24 March 2024 |
| 373. | The Thirsty Little Rat Inn and the Coowoo Girls | Longfellow's Wayside Inn | Anthony Broadwater and Alice Sebold | 31 March 2024 |
| 374. | A Big Queer Door and The Mulberry Bush of the Year | Dark side of nursery rhymes | Krystian Bala | 07 April 2024 |
| 375. | Joann's Haberdashery and Ghost Logic | The Merchant's House Museum | Ruby Franke/8 Passengers Part 1 | 14 April 2024 |
| 376. | Vintage Honks and Zoomies Screams | The Char Man of the Ojai Valley | Ruby Franke/8 Passengers Part 2 | 21 April 2024 |
| 377. | Carnival Cobblers and Time Travelling Text Messages | The Pollock Twins aka The Hexham Rebirth | Terry Rasmussen aka The Chameleon Killer | 28 April 2024 |
| 378. | The Butter Bar Lore and the Glass Peacock Yappers | Capitol Theatre Building (Flint, Michigan) | Murder of Cara Lea Farver | 05 May 2024 |
| 379. | A Never-ending Slumber Party and an ATWWD Bowling League (Live Show at Houston Improv, 2019) | The Spaghetti Warehouse (Haunted) and The Old Spaghetti Factory | Ana Trujillo aka The Stiletto Killer | 12 May 2024 |
| 380. | The Spookyeasy and the Crime Travelers, Partners in Time | The Hannah House | Disappearance of the Klein Brothers | 19 May 2024 |
| 381. | Drunk on Leaves and Resurrecting the Information SuperHighway | The Mongolian Death Worm | Murder of Greg Fleniken aka The Body in Room 348 | 26 May 2024 |
| 382. | Birthday Bummers and Haunted Emo Cowboys | The O.K. Corral and Boothill Cemetery | Murders of Kylen Schulte and Crystal Turner | 02 June 2024 |
| 383. | Pseudo Armchair Ear Experts and Flower Pot London Fogs | Ogden Union Station | Murder of Travis Alexander by Jodi Arias | 09 June 2024 |
| 384. | A Raccoon Bagel Infestation and a Birthday Shot in the Butt | Elias Henry Jones and Cedric Waters Hill | Inna Budnytska | 16 June 2024 |
| 385. | Dinosaur Spiritualism and Mediumship Advisors | Mediums of the Lily Dale Spiritualist Assembly | Nicholas Alahverdian | 23 June 2024 |
| 386. | A Telegram to our Exes and a Hell of a Case of Swamp Gas | The Allagash Four | Disappearance of Blanche Monnier | 30 June 2024 |
| 387. | Adulting Cheat Codes and Dramatic Readings of the Cha Cha Slide | The Old Licking County Jail | The Claypool Hotel | 07 July 2024 |
| 388. | Stress Rashes and Deranged Camera Angles | The Cock Lane Haunting | Suzanne Sevakis Part 1 | 14 July 2024 |
| 389. | Intriguing Event Schedules and Lukewarm Cans of Sparkling Water | The Gilcrease House | Suzanne Sevakis Part 2 | 21 July 2024 |
| 390. | A Noodle Room and a Doodle Competition | Sturdivant Hall | Wrongful Conviction of Juan Catalan and Murder of Martha Puebla | 28 July 2024 |
| 391. | A Penultimate Show and a Bonus Drinking Game Round (Live Show in Albany, 2019) | Fort William Henry at Lake George | Murder of Peter Porco | 04 August 2024 |
| 392. | Rat Girl Summer and Weepy Hollow | Buffalo Bill's Irma Hotel | Disappearance of Heather Teague | 11 August 2024 |
| 393. | A Feral Rat Summer and A Trench Coat Full of Snakes | Stepp Cemetery | Sally McNeil | 18 August 2024 |
| 394. | A Glitching Sim and a Yappy Hour | Black Hope Cemetery | Murders of Julie Williams and Lollie Winans | 25 August 2024 |
| 395. | Dessert Waters and Gullah, Gullah Island Medical Degrees | Exorcism of Gottliebin Dittus | Murder of Molly Bish | 01 September 2024 |
| 396. | A Curtain Fiesta and a Ghost's Fan Mail | Red Onion Saloon | Steven Stayner Part 1 | 08 September 2024 |
| 397. | A Poultrygeist and an En-gay-gement | The Highgate Hill Chicken | Steven Stayner Part 2 | 15 September 2024 |
| 398. | A Pink Panther Ghost and The Great Disappointment | Tomb of Colonel Jonathan Buck | Branch Davidians and the Siege of Mount Carmel | 22 September 2024 |
| 399. | Em’s Day O' Fun and a Ghost Renovator | Sylvester K. Pierce House | Case update from episode 15 on Gypsy-Rose Blanchard | 29 September 2024 |
| 400. | Dry Spaghetti Psychics and Gay Gasps | Dancing plague of 1518 | Alice Mitchell and her murder of Freda Ward | 6 October 2024 |
