J. Harvie Wilkinson III

Lossie Grist Noell

​

(m. 1973)​

J. Harvie Wilkinson III
Wilkinson in 2022
Chief Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
In office February 14, 1996 –February 15, 2003
Children	2
Relatives	Jeff Wall (son-in-law)
Education	Yale University (BA) University of Virginia (JD)

James Harvie Wilkinson III (born September 29, 1944) is an American jurist who serves as a United States circuit judge on the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit. His name has been raised at several junctures in the past as a possible nominee to the United States Supreme Court.

Early and family life

Wilkinson was born in New York City, New York to J. Harvie Wilkinson Jr. and his wife. He was raised in Richmond, Virginia, where he attended St. Christopher's School during the state's Massive Resistance crisis concerning desegregation of the public schools. His father (CEO of State Planters Bank, later part of Crestar Bank) joined with Norfolk and Western Railroad CEO Stuart Saunders and Richmond School Board President (and later Supreme Court Justice) Lewis F. Powell and others to support Governor J. Lindsay Almond when he decided to break with the Byrd Organization and adhere to the decisions of the Virginia Supreme Court and a three judge federal panel on January 19, 1959, which declared certain new laws designed to maintain segregation unconstitutional. ^[1]

Wilkinson attended the Lawrenceville School in New Jersey, then Yale University, where he was a member of St. Anthony Hall, chairman of the Conservative Party of the Yale Political Union, and later the Political Union's president. He graduated with honors from Yale with a Bachelor of Arts degree in 1967, then published his first book, Harry Byrd and The Changing Face of Virginia Politics, 1945–1966 (1968) ^[2] Wilkinson enlisted in the United States Army in 1968 and served until 1969.

Upon leaving the army, Wilkinson began law school at the University of Virginia School of Law in Charlottesville. In 1970, after completing only one year, Wilkinson took a leave of absence to run (at age 25) for a Virginia seat in the United States House of Representatives. He ran as a Republican against 3-term incumbent Democrat David E. Satterfield III and later joked about losing by a significant margin, noting that Satterfield had a billboard urging voters to send Wilkinson back to law school. ^{[3] [4]} Wilkinson then resumed his legal studies and graduated with a Juris Doctor in 1972 (when Satterfield faced no opposition) and soon passed the Virginia bar exam.

Wilkinson and his wife have two children. ^[5] His daughter Porter Wilkinson also clerked for the United States Supreme Court, serving in the chambers of Chief Justice John Roberts in 2007–2008. ^[6] She is married to prominent appellate lawyer Jeff Wall.

Early legal, teaching and writing career

From 1972 to 1973, Wilkinson served as a law clerk to newly confirmed Justice Powell, long a family friend. Following his clerkship, Wilkinson declined joining a large law firm. Instead, he returned to Charlottesville and joined the University of Virginia School of Law faculty, where he taught as an associate professor for five years. Wilkinson also wrote and published his second book, about his clerkship with Justice Powell: Serving Justice: A Supreme Court Clerk's View (1974). ^[7]

Wilkinson also spent three years (1978–1981) working for Norfolk's The Virginian-Pilot , including as editorial page editor. ^[8] He later credited this with broadening his practical experience of both government at many levels, and with people in all walks of life, as well as helping his time management skills. ^[3] In 1979, Wilkinson published his third book, From Brown to Bakke. ^[9] In 1982, Wilkinson resumed his legal career, joining the Civil Rights Division of the U.S. Department of Justice, eventually becoming deputy assistant attorney general. He returned to teaching at the University of Virginia School of Law in 1983. ^[10]

Federal judicial service

On November 10, 1983, as Wilkinson briefly returned to teach at the University of Virginia School of Law as a full professor, President Ronald Reagan nominated him to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit seat vacated by Judge John D. Butzner Jr., who retired. Despite some controversy and after hearings on November 16, 1983, and February 22, 1984, the United States Senate confirmed Wilkinson on August 9, 1984, by a 58–39 vote. He received his commission on August 13, 1984. ^[10]

From 1996 to 2003, Wilkinson served as the court's chief judge, during which time he wrote and published his fourth book, One Nation Indivisible: How Ethnic Separatism Threatens America (1997). ^[11] In 2003, Judge Wilkinson wrote the majority opinion upholding the right of the United States government to detain Yaser Esam Hamdi indefinitely without access to counsel or a court. Hamdi was a U.S. citizen captured during the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan, and the U.S. Supreme Court ultimately overturned that decision.

With the announcement of Chief Justice Rehnquist's illness in the fall of 2004, many commentators^{[ who? ]} listed Wilkinson as a potential Bush nominee to the Supreme Court. Wilkinson agreed to an interview with The New York Times , reportedly undermining his candidacy amongst the Bush inner circle. ^[12]

In 2006, Wilkinson penned an op-ed article in The Washington Post , castigating both the left and right on the issue of gay marriage. Writing that the "American constitutional tradition" has been a "chief casualty in the struggle over same-sex marriage", Wilkinson opined that marriage should be regulated through ordinary legislative means and opposed "the rush to constitutionalize" the dispute. ^[13]

On June 24, 2008, Wilkinson authored a concurring opinion in Richmond Medical Center For Women v. Herring, which upheld the Virginia ban on partial-birth abortions. In his concurrence, he voiced a strong opposition to the practice of partial-birth abortions: "The fact is that we—civilized people—are retreating to the haven of our Constitution to justify dismembering a partly born child and crushing its skull. Surely centuries hence, people will look back on this gruesome practice done in the name of fundamental law by a society of high achievement. And they will shudder." ^[14]

In 2012, Wilkinson published his fifth book (and second through Oxford University Press), Cosmic Constitutional Theory: Why Americans Are Losing Their Inalienable Right to Self-Governance. ^[15] The following year, Wilkinson wrote an opinion upholding the Baltimore Ravens' use of its previously used "Flying B" logo in videos, photographs and displays as fair use. ^[16]

In 2016, Wilkinson dissented when Judge G. Steven Agee found that sectarian prayers offered by Rowan County, North Carolina commissioners at their meetings did not violate the Establishment Clause of the United States Constitution. That judgment was then rejected by the full circuit en banc by a vote of 10–5, with Wilkinson now writing for the majority while Agee and Paul V. Niemeyer authored dissents. ^{[17] [18]} In June 2018, the Supreme Court of the United States denied review, over the written dissent of Justice Clarence Thomas joined by Neil Gorsuch. ^{[19] [20]}

In 2017 Wilkinson published All Falling Faiths: Reflections on the Promise and Failure of the 1960s.

In March 2018, Wilkinson wrote a dissent when the circuit denied en banc rehearing to a divided panel's conclusion that the Bladensburg Peace Cross memorial from World War I now violated the Constitution's Establishment Clause. ^{[21] [22]} The Fourth Circuit's judgment was then reversed by the U.S. Supreme Court in American Legion v. American Humanist Association (2019). ^[23]

In August 2018, Wilkinson wrote for the panel majority when it found that the Constitution's Eighth Amendment did not prevent Virginia from criminally prohibiting those it identified as "habitual drunkards" from possessing alcohol. ^[24] Judge Diana Gribbon Motz specially concurred, arguing that the majority was ignoring Powell v. Texas (1968). ^[25] In July 2019, the full circuit en banc reversed the panel by a vote of 8–7, with Motz writing for the majority and Wilkinson now writing the principal dissent. ^{[26] [27]} The majority and concurring opinions criticized Wilkinson for incivility and "inflammatory language", which Wilkinson defended in an additional, special dissent. ^[28]

Writings

Wilkinson has published numerous editorials, law review articles ^[29] and six books:

• Harry Byrd and The Changing Face of Virginia Politics, 1945–1966, Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1968.
• Serving Justice: A Supreme Court Clerk's View, New York: Charterhouse, 1974.
• From Brown to Bakke: The Supreme Court and School Integration, 1954–1978 , New York: Oxford University Press, 1979, ISBN   0-19-502567-9 .
• One Nation Indivisible: How Ethnic Separatism Threatens America , Reading, MA: Addison Wesley Longman, 1997, ISBN   0-201-18072-3 .
• Cosmic Constitutional Theory: Why Americans Are Losing Their Inalienable Right to Self-Governance, New York: Oxford University Press, 2012, ISBN   978-0-19-984601-6 .
• All Falling Faiths: Reflections on the Promise and Failure of the 1960s, Description, preview, and book reviews. ^[30] Encounter, 2017. ISBN   9781594038914

Honors and awards

In 2004, the University of Virginia awarded Wilkinson the Thomas Jefferson Foundation Medal in Law, its highest external honor. ^[29]

In 2009, the Lawrenceville School awarded him its highest honor. ^[31]

In 2016, the John Barbee Minor Inn of Court in Charlottesville recognized Wilkinson's three decades of judicial service with a Certificate of Merit and Lifetime Achievement Award. ^[32]

See also

• George W. Bush Supreme Court candidates
• List of law clerks of the Supreme Court of the United States (Seat 1)
• List of United States federal judges by longevity of service

References

1. Linwood Holton, A former governor's reflections on Massive Resistance in Virginia, 49 Washington & Lee Law Review 15, 20 (1992) available at http://mlkcommission.dls.virginia.gov/va_school_closings/pdfs/Linwood_Holton_and_Massive_Resistance.pdf
2. J. Harvie Wilkinson III, Harry Byrd and The Changing Face of Virginia Politics, 1945–1966, (Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1968)
3. "Lives in the Law - Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson, III - Duke University School of Law". law.duke.edu.
4. "Virginia Elections Database » 1970 U.S. House General Election District 3". Virginia Elections Database.
5. "Who Is J. Harvie Wilkinson III?". ABC News. 6 January 2006.
6. "Wilkinson '07 to Clerk for U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts". 14 October 2007.^{[ permanent dead link ]}
7. J. Harvie Wilkinson III, Serving Justice: A Supreme Court Clerk's View (New York: Charterhouse, 1974)
8. "Judge J Harvie Wilkinson III". www.ca4.uscourts.gov.
9. J. Harvie Wilkinson III, From Brown to Bakke: The Supreme Court and School Integration, 1954–1978 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1979)
10. J. Harvie Wilkinson III at the Biographical Directory of Federal Judges , a publication of the Federal Judicial Center .
11. J. Harvie Wilkinson III, One Nation Indivisible: How Ethnic Separatism Threatens America (Reading, MA: Addison Wesley Longman, 1997.
12. Once More, Bush Turns To His Inner Circle Washington Post
13. Hands Off Constitutions J. Harvie Wilkinson III
14. 570 F. 3d 165, 183 (4th. Cir. 2009).
15. J. Harvie Wilkinson III, Cosmic Constitutional Theory: Why Americans Are Losing Their Inalienable Right to Self-Governance (New York: Oxford University Press, 2012)
16. "Old NFL Ravens Logo Won't Cost Team Again". Courthousenews.com. 2013-12-19. Retrieved 2018-04-26.
17. Note, Fourth Circuit Holds that County Commissioners’ Practice of Offering Sectarian Prayers at Public Meetings Is Unconstitutional , 131 Harv. L. Rev. 626(2017).
18. Lund v. Rowan County, 863F.3d268 (4th Cir.2017 (en banc).
19. Rowan County v. Lund, 138S.Ct.2564 (2018).
20. Note, Pressure to Pray? Thinking beyond the Coercion Test for Legislator-Led Prayer , 86 U. Chicago L. Rev. 151(2017).
21. Am. Humanist Ass’n v. Md.-Nat’l Capital Park & Planning Comm’n, 891F.3d117 (4th Cir.2018) (mem.).
22. Note, Recent Case: En Banc Fourth Circuit Denies Rehearing of Holding that Cross-Shaped World War I Memorial Violates Establishment Clause , 132 Harv. L. Rev. 1353(2019).
23. Note, The Supreme Court, 2018 Term — Leading Cases , 133 Harv. L. Rev. 262(2019).
24. Manning v. Caldwell, 900F.3d139 (4th Cir.2018).
25. Note, Recent Case: Fourth Circuit Declines to Apply Justice White’s Concurrence in Powell v. Texas as Binding Precedent , 132 Harv. L. Rev. 1089(2019).
26. Manning v. Caldwell, 930F.3d264 (4th Cir.2019) (en banc).
27. Weiss, Debra Cassens (17 July 2019). "Habitual drunkard law is struck down by full appeals court in closely divided opinion". ABA Journal . Retrieved 20 March 2020.
28. Sibilla, Nick (2 August 2019). "Federal Court Strikes Down Virginia's "Habitual Drunkard" Law That Criminalized Owning Alcohol". Forbes. Retrieved 20 March 2020.
29. Olson, Kent. "Law Library Guides: Our History: Former Faculty: Wilkinson, J. Harvie, III (1973-84)". libguides.law.virginia.edu.
30. • Lee Edwards (2017). "The Decade That Won’t End," Wall Street Journal, February 24, 2017.
    • Terry Eastland (2017). "Land of Disbelief," The Weekly Standard, March 27.
    • James Rosen (2017). "At Sea in the Sixties," National Review, April 3.
31. "J. Harvie Wilkinson III '63 Takes on Both Parties - the Lawrenceville School". Archived from the original on 2016-11-05. Retrieved 2016-11-05.
32. "Honoring U.S. Circuit Court Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson, III - Minor Inn 4/25/16 - The International Legal Honor Society of Phi Delta Phi". www.phideltaphi.org. Archived from the original on 2016-11-05. Retrieved 2016-11-05.

External links

• James Harvie Wilkinson III at the Biographical Directory of Federal Judges , a publication of the Federal Judicial Center .
• Appearances on C-SPAN

Legal offices
Preceded by John D. Butzner Jr.	Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit 1984–present	Incumbent
Preceded by Samuel James Ervin III	Chief Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit 1996–2003	Succeeded by William Walter Wilkins