Lillehammer affair

Ahmed Bouchikhi

The Lillehammer affair (Hebrew : פרשת לילהאמר, Parshat Lillehammer, Norwegian: Lillehammer-saken) was the murder of Ahmed Bouchikhi, a Moroccan waiter and the brother of the French musician Chico Bouchikhi, ^[1] by Mossad agents ^[2] in Lillehammer, Norway, on 21 July 1973. The Israeli agents had mistaken their target for Ali Hassan Salameh, the chief of operations for Black September. Six of 15 of the Mossad team were captured and convicted of complicity in the killing by the Norwegian justice system in a major blow to the intelligence agency's reputation.

Background

Undercover agents had been sent by Israel as part of series of planned assassinations following the 1972 Munich massacre to assassinate Ali Hassan Salameh, the head of Force 17 and an operative of the Black September Organization, the Palestinian militant group responsible. In the summer of 1973, Mossad received a tip that Salameh was working as a waiter in Lillehammer. Author and former Mossad katsa (case officer) Victor Ostrovsky wrote that Salameh was instrumental in leading Mossad off course by feeding it false information about his whereabouts. ^[3] A team of 15 Mossad agents was sent to Lillehammer to assassinate him, where they were joined by Mossad director general Zvi Zamir and operation commander Michael Harari. Lillehammer was a relatively small city, and the sudden arrival of more than a dozen strangers attracted attention from residents. The local police began to watch them. ^[4]

A known Palestinian courier in Lillehammer was identified and followed by Mossad agents to a public swimming pool, where he was seen speaking with Bouchikhi, who had no connection to Palestinian armed groups and whose conversation with the courier was coincidental. Bouchikhi, who resembled Salameh, was found to match the photographs of Salameh. A female Mossad agent then jumped into the pool and got close enough to Bouchikhi to hear him speaking French. The agents knew that Salameh was multilingual, and concluded that this had to be him. The Mossad team followed Bouchikhi to his home. His residence was placed under constant surveillance by Mossad agents sitting in hired cars. ^{[4] [5] [ page needed ]}

Assassination

On the evening of 21 July, a day after having misidentified Bouchikhi as Salameh, the Mossad agents carried out the assassination. Bouchikhi and his pregnant wife had gone to see a movie. After taking a bus back and getting off at a bus stop, they began slowly walking back home. As they were in sight of their home, a car with four Mossad agents pulled up beside them. While two stayed in the car to provide cover, the other two got out and shot Bouchikhi 13 times with a 22 caliber pistol, his wife witnessing the shooting. ^[6] They then jumped back into the car, which immediately drove away at high speed. Local police were close by, but by the time police and rescue arrived, Bouchikhi was dead. ^{[4] [5] [ page needed ] [7]}

The killing shocked the residents of Lillehammer, where there had not been a murder for 36 years. The Israelis learned that they had killed the wrong man after the story was publicized the following day. Nine members of the hit team, including the two actual killers, escaped and were out of Norway the day following the assassination. ^{[4] [7]} Six other members of the team, four men and two women, were arrested before they could escape. Two agents were caught in a getaway car they were using again without having changed the license plates while trying to get to an airport the day after the assassination. Their interrogations led to the arrests of the remaining members of the cell. ^[7] Incriminating documents and the keys to a network of safe houses were discovered. ^[8]

While the defence counsel said their clients played only minor roles such as shadowing and passing on information, five of the six agents were found guilty on a variety of charges and convicted of complicity in the killing, receiving sentences ranging from one year to five and a half years ^[7] but were released and returned to Israel in 1975. The Mossad later found Ali Hassan Salameh in Beirut and killed him on 22 January 1979 with a remote-controlled car bomb in an attack that also caused the deaths of eight other persons (including four of Salameh’s bodyguards) and injured 18 others. ^[9]

Later developments

The revelations of the captured agents dealt a massive blow to the secret infrastructure of the Mossad in Europe. The captured agents were interrogated over the operation. One of them, Dan Arbel, became extremely nervous as soon as his cell door shut due to his extreme claustrophobia; he provided many details on the operation in exchange for being transferred to a larger cell with a small window. Authorities discovered a key on one of the suspects for a Mossad safe house in Paris. It was handed over to the French police, who raided the flat and discovered keys to other Mossad safe houses in the city, along with evidence that several of those involved in the Lillehammer operation had been involved in other assassinations as part of Mossad assassinations following the Munich massacre. Information on Mossad safe houses, phone numbers and agents gathered during the interrogation of the agents was rapidly shared with its European counterparts. ^{[5] [ page needed ]} As a result, Mossad agents who had been exposed had to be recalled, safe houses abandoned, phone numbers changed and operational methods modified.^{[ citation needed ]}

For the first time, clear evidence had been found of Israel's involvement in the string of assassinations of Palestinians that had taken place on European soil as part of Operation Wrath of God. ^{[5] [ page needed ]} Under intense international pressure, Golda Meir ordered the operation suspended. ^[10] It was resumed under Prime Minister Menachem Begin. ^[11]

Israel never officially took responsibility for the assassination. ^[12] In January 1996, Prime Minister Shimon Peres said that Israel would never take responsibility for the killing but would consider compensation. The Government of Israel appointed an attorney, Amnon Goldenberg, to negotiate a settlement with Bouchikhi's widow Torill and daughter Malika, who were represented by attorney Thor-Erik Johansen. That same month, an agreement was reached; Israel paid compensation equal to US$283,000 split between Bouchikhi's wife and daughter. A separate settlement of US$118,000 was paid to a son from a previous marriage. An Israeli statement was also issued which stopped short of an apology but expressed "sorrow" over Bouchikhi's "unfortunate" death. ^{[13] [14]}

In 1990, Norway reopened the case. In 1998 it issued a global arrest warrant for the leader of the operation, Michael Harari, who had successfully escaped, but closed the case the following year after judging that it would be impossible to get a conviction. ^[15] According to the September 2004 book release of Mange liv (English: Many lives) by the former lawyer Annæus Schjødt, who represented two of the agents in the case and later married one of them (Sylvia Raphael), ^[7] information about the Israeli nuclear weapons program ^[16] was leaked to the Government of Norway by one of the arrested agents, Dan Arbel. However, the Norwegians decided to remain silent about their findings.

See also

• Lavon Affair
• Assassination of Mahmoud Al-Mabhouh
• Souhaila Andrawes

References

1. Schwartzbrod, Alexandra (12 July 2019). "Chico Bouchikhi, le Mossad et la Légion d'honneur". Libération (in French). Archived from the original on 30 September 2020. Retrieved 28 August 2020.
2. Ediciones El País (28 September 2014). "Michael Harari, oficial del Mosad". El País.
3. Ostrovsky, 206.
4. Green, David B. (21 July 2016). "When the Mossad's Revenge for the Munich Olympics Went Tragically Wrong". Haaretz. Retrieved 7 October 2017.
5. Reeve, Simon (2000). One Day in September: The Full Story of the 1972 Munich Olympics Massacre and the Israeli Revenge Operation "Wrath of God". Simon & Schuster. ISBN   9780571231812.
6. NOU 2000: 6. Lillehammer-saken. Omstendigheter rundt drapet på Ahmed Bouchikhi den 21. juli 1973 og sakens senere håndtering av norske myndigheter. p. 28
7. "Witness; The Lillehammer Hit". BBC World Service . 22 July 2013.
8. "An Eye For An Eye". CBS. 20 November 2001.
9. "MIDDLE EAST: Death of a Terrorist". Time. 5 February 1979. Archived from the original on 12 January 2007.
10. "Operation Wrath of God – Israeli assassination campaign". britannica.com. Retrieved 7 October 2017.
11. "'The Zionist James Bond': Mossad officer who hunted down those behind 1972 'Munich massacre' dead at 87". nationalpost.com. 18 March 2015. Retrieved 7 October 2017.
12. Mellgren, Doug (2 March 2000). "Norway solves riddle of Mossad killing". The Guardian . London.
13. World News Briefs;Israelis to Compensate Family of Slain Waiter New York Times (28 January 1996)
14. "ISRAEL COMPENSATES OSLO WIDOW". 27 January 1996. Retrieved 7 October 2017– via www.washingtonpost.com.
15. Mellgren, Doug (2 March 2000). "Norway solves riddle of Mossad killing". The Guardian. Retrieved 7 October 2017– via www.theguardian.com.
16. Schjødt, Annæus (2004). Mange liv (in French). Gyldendal. ISBN   978-82-05-32952-2.

Further reading

• Heradstveit, Per Øyvind (1974). De medskyldige – om israelsk etterretning og mordet på Lillehammer (in Norwegian). Aschehoug.
• Elvik, Halvor/Amundsen, Tor Mentz (1974): Da "Mossad" kom til Norge. Oslo (in Norwegian)
• NOU 2000: 6. Lillehammer-saken. Omstendigheter rundt drapet på Ahmed Bouchikhi den 21. juli 1973 og sakens senere håndtering av norske myndigheter. The official Norwegian report, 2000. (in Norwegian)

External links

• "The Israeli Response to the 1972 Munich Olympics Massacre and the Development of Independent Covert Action Teams" (includes an extensive overview of the Lillehammer Affair) Thesis submitted to the Faculty of the U.S. Marine Corps Command and Staff College by Alexander B. Calahan, GS-12, Graduate Class for the degree of Master of Military Studies, April 1995.
• Death in Lillehammer the video on YouTube
• Further names of individuals involved in the affair