Nonpartisan League

Last updated

North Dakota Nonpartisan League
Leader Arthur C. Townley
Founded1915 (1915)
Dissolved1956 (1956)
Preceded by Socialist Party of North Dakota
Merged into North Dakota Democratic–Nonpartisan League Party
Headquarters Patterson Hotel, Bismarck
Ideology Left-wing populism [1]
Social democracy [2]
Socialism [7]
Agrarian socialism [8]
Laborism [11]
Agrarianism [15]
Localism
Progressivism [18]
State ownership [19]
Women's suffrage [20]
Political position Left-wing [21]
National affiliation Socialist Party of America

The Nonpartisan League (NPL) was a left-wing political party founded in 1915 in North Dakota by Arthur C. Townley, a former organizer for the Socialist Party of America. On behalf of small farmers and merchants, the Nonpartisan League advocated state control of mills, grain elevators, banks, and other farm-related industries in order to reduce the power of corporate and political interests from Minneapolis and Chicago. [22]

Contents

The League adopted the goat as a mascot; it was known as "The Goat that Can't be Got". [23]

History

1919 cover of the League's newspaper, The Nonpartisan Leader, portraying organized farmers and workers standing tall against big business interests. The Nonpartisan Leader cover 1919-11-17.jpg
1919 cover of the League's newspaper, The Nonpartisan Leader, portraying organized farmers and workers standing tall against big business interests.

Origins

By the 1910s, the growth of left-wing sympathies was on the rise in North Dakota. The Socialist Party of North Dakota had considerable success. They brought in many outside speakers, including Eugene V. Debs, who spoke at a large antiwar rally at Garrison in 1915. By 1912, there were 175 Socialist politicians in the state. Rugby and Hillsboro elected Socialist mayors. The party had also established a weekly newspaper, the Iconoclast , in Minot. [24]

In 1914, Arthur C. Townley, a flax farmer from Beach, North Dakota, and organizer for the Socialist Party of America, attended a meeting of the American Society of Equity. Afterwards, Townley and a friend, Frank B. Wood, drew up a radical political platform that addressed many of the farmers' concerns, and created the Farmers Non-Party League Organization, which later evolved into the Nonpartisan League. Soon, Townley was traveling the state in a borrowed Ford Model T, signing up members for a payment of $6 in dues. Farmers were receptive to Townley's ideas and joined in droves.[ citation needed ] However, Townley was soon expelled from the Socialist Party due to this method of rogue operating. [24]

Rapid growth

The League grew in 1915. At that time, small farmers in North Dakota felt exploited by out-of-state companies. One author later described the wheat-growing state as "a tributary province of Minneapolis-St. Paul." Minnesota banks made its loans, Minnesota millers handled its grain, and Alexander McKenzie, North Dakota's political boss, lived in Saint Paul, Minnesota. [25] Rumors spread at a Society of Equity meeting in Bismarck that a state representative named Treadwell Twichell had told a group of farmers to "go home and slop the hogs." Twichell later said that his statement was misinterpreted. He had been instrumental in previous legislative reforms to rescue the state from boss rule by McKenzie and the Northern Pacific Railroad around the start of the 20th century.[ citation needed ]

Rise to power in North Dakota

Proposing that the state of North Dakota create its own bank, warehouses, and factories, [25] the League was supported by a populist groundswell. It ran its slate as Republican Party candidates in the 1916 elections. In the gubernatorial election, farmer Lynn Frazier won with 79% of the vote. In 1917, John Miller Baer won a special election for the United States House of Representatives.[ citation needed ] In the 1918 elections, the NPL won full control of both houses of the state legislature. [26]

The League politicians enacted a significant portion of its previous election platform. It established state-run agricultural enterprises such as the North Dakota Mill and Elevator, the Bank of North Dakota, and a state-owned railroad.[ citation needed ] The legislature also passed a statewide graduated income tax, which distinguished between earned and unearned income, authorized a state hail insurance fund, and established a workmen's compensation fund that assessed employers.[ citation needed ] The NPL also set up a Home Building Association, to aid people in financing and building houses.[ citation needed ]

During World War I, Townley demanded the "conscription of wealth", blaming "big-bellied, red-necked plutocrats" for the war. He and fellow party leader William Lemke received support for the League from isolationist German-Americans. [25]

Depression and decline

The NPL's success was short-lived. After the war ended, commodity prices dropped and the West was struck by a drought. This caused an agricultural depression.[ citation needed ] As a result of the depression, the new state-owned industries ran into financial trouble, and the private banking industry, smarting from the loss of its influence in Bismarck, rebuffed the NPL when it tried to raise money through state-issued bonds.[ citation needed ] The industry said that the state bank and elevator were "theoretical experiments" that might easily fail. Moreover, the NPL's lack of governing experience led to perceived infighting and corruption. Newspapers and business groups portrayed the NPL as inept and disastrous for the state's future.[ citation needed ]

In 1918, opponents of the NPL formed the Independent Voters Association (IVA). In 1921, the IVA organized a recall election which successfully recalled Frazier as governor. Frazier lost the recall election by a margin of 1.8%, becoming the first U.S. state governor to be recalled. However, a year later he was elected in the 1922 United States Senate election in North Dakota, serving until 1940.[ citation needed ]

The 1920s were economically difficult for farmers, and the NPL's popularity receded.[ citation needed ] By 1922, the NPL had retreated from all other states to just North Dakota.[ citation needed ]

Electoral survival and fusion with Democratic party

However, the populist undercurrent that fueled the NPL's meteoric growth revived with the coming of the Great Depression and Dust Bowl conditions of the 1930s. The NPL's William "Wild Bill" Langer was elected to the governorship in 1932 and 1936. Langer was later elected to the U.S. Senate, serving from 1940 until his death in 1959.[ citation needed ]

By 1950, two factions divided the traditionally left-wing NPL; on one side were the Insurgents, and on the other were the Old Guard. [24] The Insurgents aligned liberally with pro-farmers' union, organized labor, and Democratic Party groups. The Insurgents wanted to merge the NPL with the North Dakota Democratic Party. In 1952, the Insurgents formed the Volunteers for Stevenson Committee, to help elect Adlai Stevenson II, the governor of Illinois and Democratic nominee for president. The Old Guard, also known as the Capitol Crowd, were more conservative, anti-farmers' union, anti-labor, and pro-Republican segment of the league, these members wanted to keep the Nonpartisan League aligned with the Republican Party; they supported General Dwight D. Eisenhower in the 1952 presidential race. Over the following four years, legislative polarization grew and the Nonpartisan League eventually split in two. In 1956, the Nonpartisan League formally merged with the state Democratic Party, creating the North Dakota Democratic-Nonpartisan League Party, while much of the League's base joined the North Dakota Republican Party. The Democratic-Nonpartisan League Party introduced a unified slate of candidates for statewide offices and adopted a liberal platform that included the repeal of the Taft–Hartley Act, creation of a minimum wage of $1.25 an hour, and a graduated land tax on property worth $20,000 or more. In May 1956, the Democratic Convention accepted the Nonpartisan League's candidates and adopted its platform, fully unifying the two parties into one. [24]

Although the Democrats were still in the minority in the state government, the number of Democrats in the state legislature increased greatly. Before the league moved into the Democratic Party, there were only five Democrats among the 162 members of both houses of the legislature in 1955. By 1957, the number grew to 28, and in 1959 the numbers continued to grow, reaching 67. [24]

Notable members

Nonpartisan League meeting at Brush Lake, Montana. Nonpartisan League meeting at Brush Lake, Montana.jpg
Nonpartisan League meeting at Brush Lake, Montana.

Legacy

See also

Notes

  1. Endorsed, but not a member.

References

      • "La Follette lost 100 years ago, but his progressivism lives on". The Cap Times. November 5, 2024. Archived from the original on December 11, 2024. Retrieved January 14, 2025. In fact, the program that La Follette ran on — taxing the rich, cracking down on Wall Street abuses, empowering workers to organize unions, defending small farmers, breaking up corporate trusts, strengthening public utilities — fueled a resurgence of left-wing populist movements across the upper Midwest: the Non-Partisan League of North Dakota, the Farmer-Labor Party of Minnesota and the Progressive Party of Wisconsin.
      • Lansing, Michael J. (March 28, 2023). "North Dakota Has the Country's Oldest Public Bank. We Should Look to It as a Model". Jacobin.com. US: Jacobin. Retrieved April 15, 2025.
      • Greeley, Patrick (November 11, 2024). "The Rise and Fall of Midwest Populism". Jacobin.com. Jacobin. Retrieved April 15, 2025.
      • Savicki, Drew (August 10, 2020). "The Road to 270: Minnesota". 270towin.com. Minnesota. Retrieved April 16, 2025. In the 1920s, members of the national left-wing populist movement called the Nonpartisan League stood for election under a new banner, the Farmer Labor Party.
      • Fairchild, Jonathan (2023). "Planted in the Soil": The Homestead Act, Women Homesteaders, and the Nineteenth Amendment (PDF). Homestead National Historical Park Beatrice, Nebraska: U.S. Department of the Interior National Park Service. p. 109. Retrieved April 28, 2025. In 1919, the Nonpartisan League (NPL) took power in the state. The Nonpartisan League was newly formed left-wing populist political party in North Dakota created by A.C. Townley in 1915.
  1. Evans, Bryan; Schmidt, Ingo, eds. (2012). Social democracy after the cold war. Edmonton: AU Press. p. 103. ISBN   978-1-926836-88-1. OCLC   1015535562. In addition, some notable examples of social democratic third-party success at the subnational level are the Socialist Party in Oklahoma in the 1920s and 1930s, the Non-Partisan League in North Dakota, the Washington Co-operative Commonwealth in Washington State, the Minnesota Farmer-Labor Party, and the current Vermont Progressive Party, which has relationship with the Democratic Party.
  2. DeCarlo, Peter J. "Nonpartisan League". Mnopedia.org. Minnesota: MNOPEDIA. Retrieved March 21, 2025. In addition, those opposed to the NPL used its socialist principles against it, labeling all members "Bolsheviks."
  3. Erlandson, Henry (January 25, 2020). "Why is Minnesota's Democratic Party called the DFL?". Startribune.com. Minnesota, US: Star Tribune. Retrieved March 21, 2025. […], while North Dakotans started a socialist political organization called the Non-Partisan League.
  4. 1 2 Meduri, Matt (November 25, 2023). "America the Beautiful: How History Shapes Our Electorate". Messengerpapers.com. New York, US: Messenger Papers. Retrieved April 28, 2025. The creation of the Nonpartisan League (NPL) in 1915 advocated for progressive and socialist policies, chief among them being the government control of farming-adjacent industries, such as mills, banks, and railroads.
  5. Mayer, George H. (1987). The Political Career of Floyd B. Olson. St. Paul, Minnesota: Minnesota Historical Press (published 1951). p. 19. ISBN   0873512065 . Retrieved May 12, 2025. Its extraordinary appeal lay in the ability of the drafters to camouflage socialistic principles while playing up the orthodox features of agrarian reform. The organizational structure of the Nonpartisan League did not conceal its socialistic features so well.
  6. [3] [4] [5] [6]
  7. Mayer, George H. (1987). The Political Career of Floyd B. Olson. St. Paul, Minnesota: Minnesota Historical Press (published 1951). p. 18. ISBN   0873512065 . Retrieved February 23, 2025. […] the Nonpartisan League, a new protest movement containing strong elements of agrarian socialism.
  8. Lansing, Michael J. (March 28, 2023). "North Dakota Has the Country's Oldest Public Bank. We Should Look to It as a Model". Jacobin.com. US: Jacobin. Retrieved April 15, 2025.
  9. Mayer, George H. (1987). The Political Career of Floyd B. Olson. St. Paul, Minnesota: Minnesota Historical Press (published 1951). p. 22. ISBN   0873512065 . Retrieved May 12, 2025.
  10. [9] [10]
  11. "The Birth of the Nonpartisan League". Thebndsotry.nd.gov. The BND Story. Retrieved February 26, 2025.
  12. Saloutos, Theodore (1946). "The Rise of the Nonpartisan League in North Dakota, 1915-1917". Agricultural History. 20 (1). JSTOR: 43–61. ISSN   0002-1482. JSTOR   3739348 . Retrieved February 26, 2025.
  13. Delton, Jennifer Alice (2002). Making Minnesota Liberal: Civil Rights and the Transformation of the Democratic Party. MN: University of Minnesota Press. p. 2. ISBN   0816639221 . Retrieved May 14, 2025. […] great agrarian, anti-party protest movements of the late-nineteenth century. Townley's Nonpartisan League was one such movement.
  14. [12] [13] [14]
  15. Rossi, Marco Rosaire (2022). Municipal Governments and the Nonoccurrence of an American Socialist Party (Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science thesis). Chicago, Illinois: University of Illinois at Chicago. p. 255. Retrieved May 14, 2025. With its highly representative state government, it is unsurprising that North Dakota also has a history of left-wing third parties. However, unlike Vermont, the state has certain characteristics that discourage third parties. The most significant progressive third party in North Dakota's history was the Nonpartisan League, and before its fusion with the state Democratic Party in 1956, it was the last example of third-party progressivism in the state.
  16. Dreier, Peter (April 11, 2011). "La Follette's Wisconsin Idea". Dissent. University of Pennsylvania Press. Retrieved April 16, 2025. Though he died of a heart attack less than a year after the election, La Follette's success inspired other progressive movements and campaigns around the country, including farmer-labor parties in Minnesota and North Dakota, the Progressive Party in Wisconsin, and the American Labor Party in New York City.
  17. [16] [5] [17]
      • Lansing, Michael J. (March 28, 2023). "North Dakota Has the Country's Oldest Public Bank. We Should Look to It as a Model". Jacobin.com. US: Jacobin. Retrieved April 15, 2025.
      • Greeley, Patrick (November 11, 2024). "The Rise and Fall of Midwest Populism". Jacobin.com. Jacobin. Retrieved April 15, 2025.
      • Meduri, Matt (November 25, 2023). "America the Beautiful: How History Shapes Our Electorate". Messengerpapers.com. New York, US: Messenger Papers. Retrieved April 28, 2025. The creation of the Nonpartisan League (NPL) in 1915 advocated for progressive and socialist policies, chief among them being the government control of farming-adjacent industries, such as mills, banks, and railroads.
      • Mayer, George H. (1987). The Political Career of Floyd B. Olson. St. Paul, Minnesota: Minnesota Historical Press (published 1951). p. 19. ISBN   0873512065 . Retrieved May 12, 2025. Specifically the 1916 League platform in North Dakota proposed: (1) state ownership of terminal elevators, flour mills, packing houses and cold storage plants […] This was an amazing frank public ownership program […]
      • DeCarlo, Peter J. "Nonpartisan League". Mnopedia.org. Minnesota: MNOPEDIA. Retrieved March 21, 2025. The NPL advocated state-run mills, grain elevators, stockyards, and warehouses. In order to protect farmers further, it fought for state insurance programs, pensions, and employment bureaus.
  18. Greeley, Patrick (November 11, 2024). "The Rise and Fall of Midwest Populism". Jacobin.com. Jacobin. Retrieved April 15, 2025. The League's various goals included improved state services, women's suffrage, and state ownership of banks, mills, and elevators.
  19. Attributed to multiple sources:
      • Lansing, Michael J. (March 28, 2023). "North Dakota Has the Country's Oldest Public Bank. We Should Look to It as a Model". Jacobin.com. US: Jacobin. Retrieved April 15, 2025.
      • Olson, Daron William (1993). Norwegians, Socialism and the Nonpartisan League in North Dakota, 1904-1920: How Red was their Protest? (Master of Arts (MA) thesis). University of North Dakota. Retrieved April 15, 2025. Although its history has been largely ignored by scholars, North Dakota's radical period, the socialist and Nonpartisan League years between 1904 and 1920, has been the exception. To explain the success of these left-wing movements, scholars have developed a number of theories. One of the most popular theories attributes the success of leftist political movements to the large number of Norwegians who resided in the state.
      • Greeley, Patrick (November 11, 2024). "The Rise and Fall of Midwest Populism". Jacobin.com. Jacobin. Retrieved April 15, 2025.
      • Megan Torgerson (October 26, 2022). ""Groundwork" Episode 1: An interview with the "farmer's lawyer," Sarah Vogel" (Podcast). Reframing Rural. Event occurs at 2:30-2:40. Retrieved April 16, 2025. [...] beginning with a history of the Nonpartisan League, the left-wing political party founded by North Dakota socialist Arthur C. Townley to protect farmers during the Great Depression.
      • Haala, Cory (2020). The Progressive Center: Midwestern Liberalism in the Age of Reagan, 1978-1992 (Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) thesis). Wisconsin: Marquette University. Retrieved April 16, 2025. In the majority of these states, during either the 1890s or interwar years, left-wing third-party movements—the Populist Party, Minnesota Farmer-Labor Party, North Dakota Nonpartisan League, and Wisconsin Progressive Party
      • Scher, Abby (January 14, 2015). "This Rust-Belt Town's Survival Strategy Is All About Giving Workers Control". YES! . YES! . Retrieved May 14, 2025. […] like the state bank in North Dakota, which began in 1919 as a project of the left-wing Nonpartisan League.
      • Rossi, Marco Rosaire (2022). Municipal Governments and the Nonoccurrence of an American Socialist Party (Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science thesis). Chicago, Illinois: University of Illinois at Chicago. p. 255. Retrieved May 14, 2025. With its highly representative state government, it is unsurprising that North Dakota also has a history of left-wing third parties. However, unlike Vermont, the state has certain characteristics that discourage third parties. The most significant progressive third party in North Dakota's history was the Nonpartisan League, and before its fusion with the state Democratic Party in 1956, it was the last example of third-party progressivism in the state.
  20. Goldstein, Robert Justin (2001). Political Repression in Modern America. University of Illinois Press. p. 99. ISBN   0-252-06964-1.
  21. Vogel, Robert (2004). Unequal Contest: Bill Langer and His Political Enemies. Crain Grosinger Publishing. p. 2. ISBN   0-9720054-3-9.
  22. 1 2 3 4 5 Robinson, Elwyn (1966). History of North Dakota . University of Nebraska Press.
  23. 1 2 3 Lubell, Samuel (1956). The Future of American Politics (2nd ed.). Anchor Press. pp. 145–147. OL   6193934M.
  24. General election 11-05-1918 ip.sos.nd.gov/pdfs/Abstracts%20by%20Year/1910%20through%201919%20Statewide%20Election%20Results/1918/General%20Election%2011-05-1918.pdf accessed May 16, 2025
  25. Kodrzycki, Yolanda K; Elmatad, Tal (May 2011). The Bank of North Dakota: A model for Massachusetts and other states? (PDF) (Report). New England Public Policy Center. Retrieved December 6, 2011.
  26. 1 2 Waiser, Bill (2005). Saskatchewan: A New History. Calgary: Fifth House. p. 223. ISBN   9781894856492.
  27. Michelle L. Dennis (February 2006). "National Register of Historic Places Multiple Property Documentation: Nonpartisan League's Home Building Association Resources in North Dakota" (PDF).
  28. Garet Garrett (1927). "Harangue (The Trees Said to the Bramble Come Reign Over Us)" (PDF).
  29. Ryant, Carl (1989). Profit's Prophet: Garet Garrett (1878–1954). Selinsgrove: Susquehanna University Press. pp. 56–59. ISBN   0-945636-04-0.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: publisher location (link)

Further reading