Redskins Rule

The Redskins Rule is a spurious relationship ^[1] in which the results of National Football League (NFL) games correlated strongly with the results of subsequent United States presidential elections. Briefly stated, there was a strong correlation between the outcome of the last home game for the Washington Redskins (now known as the Washington Commanders) prior to the U.S. presidential election and the outcome of the election: when Washington won, the party of the incumbent president retained the presidency; when Washington lost, the opposition party won. This coincidence was noted by many sports and political commentators, used as a bellwether to predict the results of elections, and held true in every election from 1940 through 2000.

Since 2004, the rule appears to have become inverted, with the performance of Washington now forecasting the fate of the challenging party rather than the incumbent. For example, the 2016 and 2020 victories heralded the elections of Donald Trump, and Joe Biden, respectively, while the 2004 and 2012 losses were followed up by the incumbents, George W. Bush and Barack Obama, respectively, winning a second term. However, Obama's election in 2008 followed a Washington loss, in accordance with the original rule.

History

The Redskins relocated from Boston to Washington, D.C. in 1937. Since then, there have been 19 presidential elections. In 17 of those, the following rule applied:

If the Redskins win their last home game before the election, the party that won the previous election wins the next election and that if the Redskins lose, the challenging party's candidate wins.

The Redskins Rule was first noticed prior to the 2000 election by Steve Hirdt, executive vice president of the Elias Sports Bureau. ^{[2] [3] [4]} That year, the Redskins would begin what would become a four-game losing streak with retrospect to the rule when they lost to the Tennessee Titans. George W. Bush defeated Al Gore in the Electoral College, but lost the popular vote. This would cause problems for the original version of the rule after the 2004 election. ^[4]

In 2004 election, the Redskins lost their last home game before the presidential election, indicating that the incumbent should have lost. However, President George W. Bush (the incumbent) went on to defeat John Kerry. Steve Hirdt modified the rule, establishing Redskins Rule 2.0: ^[5]

When the popular vote winner does not win the election, the impact of the Redskins game on the subsequent presidential election gets flipped.

This changed the rule to be based on the popular vote outcome, as if Washington wins and the party that won the prior popular vote wins the election, the rule would be upheld, as it would if both lost.

In the election in 2000, Al Gore won the popular vote while Bush won the electoral vote, and thereby the revised Redskins Rule was upheld for the 2004 election.

In the 2008 election, the Redskins lost to the Pittsburgh Steelers, predicting a win for U.S. Senator from Illinois Barack Obama over U.S. Senator from Arizona John McCain, because George W. Bush won the popular vote in the previous election. ^[6]

Prior to the 2012 election, the Redskins lost against the Carolina Panthers on November 4. The Redskins Rule predicted an outright loss for incumbent Barack Obama against challenger Mitt Romney, or that Obama would win the popular vote but lose via the Electoral College. ^[7] However, incumbent Barack Obama won the election with 332 electoral votes to Romney's 206, ^[8] held the advantage in the popular vote by more than 4.7 million votes, and the Redskins Rule did not hold in 2012.

In 2016, the Redskins played their last designated home game prior to the election on October 16, defeating the Philadelphia Eagles 27–20. This outcome predicted a victory for Hillary Clinton of the Democratic Party, which was in power. Clinton's loss to Republican challenger Donald Trump in the election meant that the Redskins Rule did not hold in 2016 despite Clinton winning the popular vote.

The rule typically does not count the team's time playing in Boston (1932–1936). The team competed as the Boston Braves in 1932 when they won 19–6 over the Staten Island Stapletons. This game does not conform to the rule, as Franklin D. Roosevelt defeated incumbent Herbert Hoover in that election. However, in 1936, the first election year the team competed under its longtime nickname, they defeated the Chicago Cardinals and the incumbent Democratic president, Roosevelt, went on to win re-election.

It is unknown as to what the status of the rule would be if the final game ended in a tie, since the rule does not account for the last home game ending in a tie. However, as a tied game would end without a winner, it could be that the rule would be upheld if the election has no winner (meaning neither candidate gets the needed 270 electoral votes).

Results

Year	Electoral vote result [9]	Redskins (score)	Opponent (score)	Redskins result	Incumbent popular vote party result	Rule upheld?	Popular vote winner
1932	Roosevelt defeats Hoover 472–59	Boston Braves 19	Staten Island Stapletons 6	Win	Lose	No	Roosevelt
1936	Roosevelt defeats Landon 523–8	Boston Redskins 13	Chicago Cardinals 10	Win	Win	Yes	Roosevelt
1940	Roosevelt defeats Willkie 449–82	Redskins 37	Pittsburgh Steelers 10	Win	Win	Yes	Roosevelt
1944	Roosevelt defeats Dewey 432–99	Redskins 14	Cleveland Rams 10	Win	Win	Yes	Roosevelt
1948	Truman defeats Dewey & Thurmond 303–189–39	Redskins 59	Boston Yanks 21	Win	Win	Yes	Truman
1952	Eisenhower defeats Stevenson 442–89	Redskins 23	Pittsburgh Steelers 24	Lose	Lose	Yes	Eisenhower
1956	Eisenhower defeats Stevenson 457–73	Redskins 20	Cleveland Browns 9	Win	Win	Yes	Eisenhower
1960	Kennedy defeats Nixon 303–219	Redskins 10	Cleveland Browns 31	Lose	Lose	Yes	Kennedy
1964	Johnson defeats Goldwater 486–52	Redskins 27	Chicago Bears 20	Win	Win	Yes	Johnson
1968	Nixon defeats Humphrey & Wallace 301–191–46	Redskins 10	New York Giants 13	Lose	Lose	Yes	Nixon
1972	Nixon defeats McGovern 520–17	Redskins 24	Dallas Cowboys 20	Win	Win	Yes	Nixon
1976	Carter defeats Ford 297–240	Redskins 7	Dallas Cowboys 20	Lose	Lose	Yes	Carter
1980	Reagan defeats Carter 489–49	Redskins 14	Minnesota Vikings 39	Lose	Lose	Yes	Reagan
1984	Reagan defeats Mondale 525–13	Redskins 27	Atlanta Falcons 14	Win	Win	Yes	Reagan
1988	G. H. W. Bush defeats Dukakis 426–111	Redskins 27	New Orleans Saints 24	Win	Win	Yes	G. H. W. Bush
1992	B. Clinton defeats G. H. W. Bush 370–168	Redskins 7	New York Giants 24	Lose	Lose	Yes	B. Clinton
1996	B. Clinton defeats Dole 379–159	Redskins 31	Indianapolis Colts 16	Win	Win	Yes	B. Clinton
2000	G. W. Bush defeats Gore 271–266	Redskins 21	Tennessee Titans 27	Lose	Lose	Yes	Gore
2004	G. W. Bush defeats Kerry 286–251	Redskins 14	Green Bay Packers 28	Lose	Lose	Yes	G. W. Bush
2008	Obama defeats McCain 365–173	Redskins 6	Pittsburgh Steelers 23	Lose	Lose	Yes	Obama
2012	Obama defeats Romney 332–206	Redskins 13	Carolina Panthers 21	Lose	Win	No	Obama
2016	Trump defeats H. Clinton 304–227	Redskins 27	Philadelphia Eagles 20	Win	Lose	No	H. Clinton
2020	Biden defeats Trump 306–232	Washington 25	Dallas Cowboys 3	Win	Win	Yes	Biden

See also

• Curse of Tippecanoe
• Mierscheid law

References

1. Bruce, Peter C. (2014-12-03). Introductory Statistics and Analytics: A Resampling Perspective. John Wiley & Sons. p. xvii. ISBN   9781118881668.
2. Hofheimer, Bill (October 30, 2012). "'Redskins Rule': MNF's Hirdt on intersection of football & politics". ESPN. Retrieved October 16, 2016.
3. Manker, Rob (November 7, 2012). "Redskins Rule: Barack Obama's victory over Mitt Romney tackles presidential predictor for its first loss". Chicago Tribune . Retrieved November 8, 2012.
4. Pohl, Robert S. (2013-08-20). Urban Legends & Historic Lore of Washington. The History Press. pp. 78–80. ISBN   9781625846648.
5. Katzowitz, Josh (November 1, 2012). "A Redskins victory vs. Panthers means Obama wins, loss means Romney wins". CBS News . Retrieved November 8, 2012.
6. "Obama elected after Redskins omen". BBC News . November 5, 2012. Retrieved November 8, 2012.
7. Krieg, Gregory J. (November 5, 2012). "'Redskins Rule' Points to Romney Victory". ABC News . Retrieved November 8, 2012.
8. "President Barack Obama wins Florida, topping Romney in final electoral vote tally 332 to 206". Washington Post. November 10, 2012. Archived from the original on November 11, 2012. Retrieved November 10, 2012.
9. "Electoral College Results". Archives.gov. Retrieved October 4, 2020.