Reflections of a Nonpolitical Man

Last updated

Reflections of a Nonpolitical Man
Thomas Mann Betrachtungen eines Unpolitischen 1918.jpg
1918 first edition
Author Thomas Mann
Original titleBetrachtungen eines Unpolitischen
TranslatorWalter D. Morris
Country German Empire
LanguageGerman
Publisher S. Fischer Verlag
Publication date
1918
Published in English
1983
Media typePrint
OCLC 3512292
838.91
LC Class PT2625.A44 B513
Original text
Betrachtungen eines Unpolitischen at Internet Archive
Translation Reflections of a Nonpolitical Man at Internet Archive

The Reflections of a Nonpolitical Man (German : Betrachtungen eines Unpolitischen) is a non-fiction work by German author Thomas Mann published in 1918. Unlike his brother Heinrich, Thomas Mann supported the German war effort during World War I. The book, which runs to almost six hundred pages, defends the authoritarianism and "culture" of Germany against the "civilization" of the West. It served to justify and distinguish his conservative political stance from that of his more liberally oriented brother. [1]

Contents

Writing and publication history

Background

Thomas Mann – like many of his fellow German writers – had a positive attitude towards the German war effort during World War I. In three essays written after the outbreak of the war in 1914 – Gedanken im Kriege  [ de ] ("Thoughts in Wartime" [August/September 1914]), Gute Feldpost ("Good News from the Front" [October 1914]) and Friedrich und die große Koalition ("Frederick and the Great Coalition" [September to December 1914]) – he defended German warfare and first promulgated his support for the Ideas of 1914  [ de ]. [2] [3]

Romain Rolland and other French authors criticised this literary support for Germany and in particular the support of the German invasion of neutral Belgium. Rolland from time to time also criticised Mann personally for his pro-war stance and substantiated this reproach in the essay Les Idoles, which was later published as part of the essay collection Au-dessus de la mêlée  [ fr ]. [2] [4] In this essay he criticised Thomas Mann's militarism and ill-advised fanaticism. [4] This reproach was a major impulse for Mann to begin writing the Reflections; he specifically answered Rolland in the chapter called "Against Justice and Truth". [4] From the summer of 1915 onwards, he started to arrange his material to support Germany in intellectual and cultural terms. [2]

The impulse for authoring the book was intensified by an essay on Émile Zola written by his brother Heinrich Mann, which appeared in René Schickele's pacifist journal Die Weißen Blätter in autumn 1915. [5] [2] This essay contained swipes at his unnamed brother and painted him as a patriotic propagandist. [2] According to the scholar Heinrich Kurzke  [ de ], this essay caused Thomas Mann to expand his material from a mere essay into a whole book. [2] [6]

Writing process

The writing (fall 1915 to February 1918) [7] of the Reflections has been divided into four phases by Alexander Honold  [ de ]: first, the beginning of the drafting process in the wake of Thomas Mann's war essays in the second half of 1915; second, his engagement with the Zivilisationsliteraten ("Civilization's Literary Men") and the elaboration of the dichotomy between "culture" and "civilisation", which deals with his brother after the publication of the Zola essay; third, the long discussion of a set of typological dichotomies; finally, the incorporation of aesthetic considerations (for example, the discussion of Hans Pfitzner's opera Palestrina). [8] The writing ended with the drafting of the prologue in February 1918, which gives commentary on the overall layout of the book. [8] [7]

Publication history and translations

The book was published shortly before the armistice in October 1918. [7] It was not translated into English during Thomas Mann's lifetime. According to Tobias Boes, the non-translation of the work during his lifetime was intentional on Mann's part due to chauvinistic content of the book which could have led to his abandonment by the American public. [9] The first English translation by Walter D. Morris under the title Reflections of a Nonpolitical Man was published in 1983 by Frederick Unger Publishing Company. [10] This translation was republished in 2021 as a NYRB Classic with an introduction by Mark Lilla. [11]

Motifs

The Reflections of a Nonpolitical Man have been recognised as a wartime treatise. [12] Thomas Mann saw his work as "intellectual military service" in the confrontation between German "culture" and French and British "civilisation". [13]

Christopher Beha argues that the central motif of the Reflections is the dichotomy between "civilization" and "culture". Civilization, according to Thomas Mann, "involves reason, enlightenment, moderation, moral education, skepticism". Culture represents the opposite for him, namely "the sublimation of the demonic". [14] He assaults Civilization’s Literary Men (Zivilisationsliteraten), because they treat "culture as a means, rather than an end in itself." [14]

Content

Prologue [Vorrede]

The "Prologue" is a reflection on the work written in previous three years. Mann provides the main reasons for the writing of this long treatise and introduces its main themes:

The difference between intellect and politics includes that of culture and civilization, of soul and society, of freedom and voting rights, of art and literature; and German tradition is culture, soul, freedom, art, and not civilization, society, voting rights, and literature. The difference between intellect and politics, as a further example, is the difference between cosmopolitan and international. The former concept comes from the cultural sphere and is German; the latter comes from the sphere of civilization and democracy and is – something quite different.

Thomas Mann [15]

Chapter 1: The Protest [Der Protest]

The first chapter of the book is noticeably short. In it, Mann uses Fyodor Dostoevsky to explain that Germany as the country has always protested against the Roman Catholic and Western world. [16]

Chapter 2: The Unliterary Country [Das unliterarische Land]

In the brief second chapter, the "Roman" Western world is described as being literary, while Germany is introduced as the "unliterary country". [16]

Chapter 3: Civilisation's Literary Man [Der Zivilisationsliterat]

In the third chapter, the "Francophile" progressive authors (his brother Heinrich being one of them) are introduced as Civilisation's Literary Men (Zivilisationsliteraten). The ideal of Civilisation's Literary Men is democratisation, which Mann considers to be antithetical to Germany's inner nature. [16]

Chapter 4: Soul-Searching [Einkehr]

In the chapter titled "Soul-Searching", Mann explains the significance of the "triumvirate" of Arthur Schopenhauer, Richard Wagner and Friedrich Nietzsche as the inspirators for his thinking. [17]

Chapter 5: Burgherly Nature [Bürgerlichkeit]

In "Burgherly Nature", Mann contrasts the solidity of burgherly individualist ethics with the bottomlessness of ethicists. [17]

Chapter 6: "Against Justice and Truth" ["Gegen Recht und Wahrheit"]

The chapter "Against Justice and Truth" has a paraphrased quotation from Heinrich Mann's Zola essay as its title. In it, Mann defends his early wartime essays against his brother Heinrich and Romain Rolland. [17]

Chapter 7: Politics [Politik]

The chapter on politics is by far the longest. Here Mann defines aestheticism as freedom from politics. [17] He then turns to deliberations inspired by Emil Hammacher and Paul de Lagarde about Bismarck, the state, conservatism, suffrage, democracy, politicised art and Germany in 1914. [17]

Chapter 8: On Virtue [Von der Tugend]

In his chapter on virtue, Mann opposes the virtue of Civilisation's Literary Men (Zivilisationsliteraten) which relies on buzzwords and contrasts it with the pessimistic ethos of Joseph von Eichendorff's Memoirs of a Good-for-Nothing , Paul Claudel's L'Annonce faite à Marie  [ fr ] and Hans Pfitzner's opera Palestrina. [17]

Chapter 9: Some Comments on Humanity [Einiges über Menschlichkeit]

In his comments on humanity, Mann develops a humanity of suffering and service. [17]

Chapter 10: On belief [Vom Glauben]

Fyodor Dostoevsky inspires the chapter "On belief". According to Mann, true faith is not faith in any principles, words and ideas such as freedom, equality, democracy, civilisation and progress, but faith in God, meaning, at the same time, faith in love, life and art. [17]

Chapter 11: On Aestheticism [Ästhetische Politik]

The last two chapters of the work deal with aestheticism. In "On Aestheticism", Mann explains that political artistry is false because he considers it to be half intellectual, intentional and artificial. The chapter ends with a notable critique of expressionism and satire. [17]

Chapter 12: Irony and Radicalism [Ironie und Radikalismus]

In the closing chapter on "Irony and Radicalism", Mann marks his work as being inspired by irony. The works of Civilisation's Literary Men (Zivilisationsliteraten) are in contrast characterised as works of radicalism. The scholar Hermann Kurzke  [ de ] explains that Mann sees irony as conservative self-denial of the spirit in favour of life, which is supposed to stand against the anti-life radicalism and activism of the spirit. [17]

Legacy and modern reception

Thomas Mann never fully denounced the views espoused in the Reflections, even after the 1929 Nobel laureate [18] had become one of the main opponents of Nazism among German expatriates in the United States. Instead, he viewed the work as a crucial step on his journey as a writer. [19]

Christopher Beha argues that the Reflections are "a strange, frequently off-putting book, a 500-page assault on democracy, enlightenment and reason", but sees value in the idea that "we do damage to life's most important elements when we use them instrumentally, for political ends". By exposing this he sees the book as posing "a real challenge to our moment, obsessed as it is with the political responsibility of the artist." [14]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oswald Spengler</span> German polymath (1880–1936)

Oswald Arnold Gottfried Spengler was a German polymath, whose areas of interest included history, philosophy, mathematics, science, and art, as well as their relation to his organic theory of history. He is best known for his two-volume work The Decline of the West, published in 1918 and 1922, covering human history. Spengler's model of history postulates that human cultures and civilizations are akin to biological entities, each with a limited, predictable, and deterministic lifespan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Mann</span> German novelist and Nobel Prize laureate (1875–1955)

Paul Thomas Mann was a German novelist, short story writer, social critic, philanthropist, essayist, and the 1929 Nobel Prize in Literature laureate. His highly symbolic and ironic epic novels and novellas are noted for their insight into the psychology of the artist and the intellectual. His analysis and critique of the European and German soul used modernized versions of German and Biblical stories, as well as the ideas of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, Friedrich Nietzsche, and Arthur Schopenhauer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heinrich Mann</span> German writer (1871–1950)

Luiz Heinrich Mann, best known as simply Heinrich Mann, was a German writer known for his socio-political novels. From 1930 until 1933, he was president of the fine poetry division of the Prussian Academy of Arts. His fierce criticism of the growing Fascism and Nazism forced him to flee Germany after the Nazis came to power during 1933. He was the elder brother of writer Thomas Mann.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Klaus Mann</span> German writer and dissident

Klaus Heinrich Thomas Mann was a German writer and dissident. He was the son of Thomas Mann, a nephew of Heinrich Mann and brother of Erika Mann and Golo Mann.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jacob Burckhardt</span> Swiss historian (1818–1897)

Carl Jacob Christoph Burckhardt was a Swiss historian of art and culture and an influential figure in the historiography of both fields. He is known as one of the major progenitors of cultural history. Sigfried Giedion described Burckhardt's achievement in the following terms: "The great discoverer of the age of the Renaissance, he first showed how a period should be treated in its entirety, with regard not only for its painting, sculpture and architecture, but for the social institutions of its daily life as well."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Christa Wolf</span> German novelist and essayist (1929–2011)

Christa Wolf was a German novelist and essayist. She is considered one of the most important writers to emerge from the former East Germany.

<i>The Magic Mountain</i> 1924 novel by Thomas Mann

The Magic Mountain is a novel by Thomas Mann, first published in German in November 1924. It is widely considered to be one of the most influential works of twentieth-century German literature.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Golo Mann</span> 20th-century German popular historian

Golo Mann was a popular German historian and essayist. Having completed a doctorate in philosophy under Karl Jaspers at Heidelberg, in 1933 he fled Hitler's Germany. He followed his father, the writer Thomas Mann and other members of his family in emigrating to France, Switzerland and the United States. From the late 1950s he re-established himself in Switzerland and West Germany as a literary historian.

The Conservative Revolution, also known as the German neoconservative movement, or new nationalism, was a German national-conservative movement prominent during the Weimar Republic and Austria, in the years 1918–1933.

<i>Doctor Faustus</i> (novel) 1947 novel by Thomas Mann

Doctor Faustus is a German novel written by Thomas Mann, begun in 1943 and published in 1947 as Doktor Faustus: Das Leben des deutschen Tonsetzers Adrian Leverkühn, erzählt von einem Freunde.

<i>Der Untertan</i> 1918 novel by Heinrich Mann

Der Untertan is one of the best known novels of German author Heinrich Mann. The title character, Diederich Hessling, a dedicated 'Untertan' in the sense of a person subservient to a monarch or prince, is an immoral man who is meant to serve as an allegory of both the reign of Kaiser Wilhelm II and German society of his time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wilhelm Heinrich Wackenroder</span> German jurist and writer

Wilhelm Heinrich Wackenroder was a German jurist and writer. With Ludwig Tieck and the Schlegel brothers, he co-founded German Romanticism.

<i>Untimely Meditations</i>

Untimely Meditations, also translated as Unfashionable Observations and Thoughts Out of Season, consists of four works by the philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, started in 1873 and completed in 1876.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nazi book burnings</span> 1930s campaign to destroy prohibited literature and research in Nazi Germany and Austria

The Nazi book burnings were a campaign conducted by the German Student Union to ceremonially burn books in Nazi Germany and Austria in the 1930s. The books targeted for burning were those viewed as being subversive or as representing ideologies opposed to Nazism. These included books written by Jewish, half-Jewish, communist, socialist, anarchist, liberal, pacifist, and sexologist authors among others. The initial books burned were those of Karl Marx and Karl Kautsky, but came to include very many authors, including Albert Einstein, Helen Keller, writers in French and English, and effectively any book incompatible with Nazi ideology. In a campaign of cultural genocide, books were also burned en masse by the Nazis in occupied territories, such as in Poland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henri Massis</span>

Henri Massis was a French conservative essayist, literary critic and literary historian.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Der Kanon</span> Canon of exemplary German literature

Der Kanon or more precisely Marcel-Reich-Ranickis Kanon is a large anthology of exemplary works of German literature. Edited by the literary critic Marcel Reich-Ranicki (1920–2013), he called the anthology, announced on 18 June 2001 in the German news magazine Der Spiegel under the title "The Canon of worthwhile German Works", his magnum opus. The five parts appeared from 2002 to 2006 published by Insel Verlag: 1. Novels (2002), 2. Tales/Stories (2003), 3. Dramatic Works (2004), 4. Poetry (2005), and 5. Essays (2006). As expected, the anthology met with opposition and criticism, and even the idea of an anthology was questioned, but Reich-Ranicki called this questioning "incomprehensible, because the lack of a canon would mean relapse into barbarism. Reich-Ranicki sought to differentiate his anthology from previous compilations in his hope to imagine a "reader judge" such as teachers, students, librarians, who would need to draw from this canon because they were in the "first line of those who deal with literature professionally."

<i>The Zürau Aphorisms</i>

The Zürau Aphorisms are 109 aphorisms of Franz Kafka, written from September 1917 to April 1918 and published by his friend Max Brod in 1931, after his death. They are selected from his writing in Zürau in West Bohemia where he stayed with his sister Ottla, suffering from tuberculosis. His friend Max Brod titled the book "Betrachtungen über Sünde, Hoffnung, Leid und den wahren Weg".

Frederick Ungar Publishing Company was a New York publishing firm which was founded in 1940.

Ernst August Bertram was a German professor of German studies at the University of Cologne, but also a poet and writer who was close to the George-Kreis and the lyricist Stefan George.

<i>A Man and His Dog</i> (narrative) 1918 narrative by Thomas Mann

A Man and His Dog is a 1918 narrative by Thomas Mann. It describes the adventures of the narrator with his dog Bauschan (Bashan) in the nature surrounding the author's home in Munich. It was written in the twilight of World War I and portrays an idealised and timeless world.

References

Citations

  1. "Thomas Mann, "Reflections of a Nonpolitical Man" (1918)". German History in Documents and Images. Archived from the original on 28 December 2022. Retrieved 28 December 2022.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Honold 2015, p. 157.
  3. Kunicki 2021, p. 6.
  4. 1 2 3 Kurzke 2010, p. 146.
  5. Mann 1915, p. 1312.
  6. Kurzke 2010, p. 150.
  7. 1 2 3 Kurzke 2010, p. 144.
  8. 1 2 Honold 2015, p. 157.
  9. Boes 2019, p. 20.
  10. Lehnert & Wessell 2004, p. XII.
  11. "Reflections of a Nonpolitical Man by Thomas Mann, translated from the German by Walter D. Morris, introduction by Mark Lilla". New York Review Books . Archived from the original on 4 December 2022. Retrieved 4 December 2022.
  12. Kunicki 2021, p. 10.
  13. Boes 2019, p. 53.
  14. 1 2 3 Beha 2021.
  15. Mann 2021, p. 23.
  16. 1 2 3 Kurzke 2010, pp. 160–161.
  17. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Kurzke 2010, p. 161.
  18. "The Nobel Prize in Literature 1929". Nobel Prize . 2022. Archived from the original on 2 July 2018. Retrieved 31 December 2022.
  19. Boes 2019, p. 36.

Sources

Further reading