Strudiella

Last updated

Strudiella
Temporal range: Famennian
Strudiella interpretation.png
Interpretation after Garrouste et al. (2012) and Hörnschemeyer et al. (2013)
Scientific classification
Kingdom:
Phylum:
Subphylum:
Class:
(unranked):
Genus:
Strudiella

Garrouste et al., 2012
Type species
Strudiella devonica
Garrouste et al., 2012

Strudiella devonica is a species of extinct arthropod from the Devonian. [1] It was recovered in the Strud (Gesves, Belgium) environment from the Bois des Mouches Formation, Upper Famennian. It was originally described as the first complete Late Devonian terrestrial insect, but due to its poor state of preservation, its affinity is discussed. [2]

Contents

Description

Strudiella is known from a single specimen. It is a small arthropod with length about 8 mm (0.31 in). Structures like antennae and a number of pairs of legs can be seen. [1] Due to the poorly preserved nature of this fossil, its interpretation and classification depend on the authors.

Garrouste et al. (2012)

In the first description by Garrouste et al. (2012), it was described as the first complete Devonian insect. The median abdominal structures are filled with guts, which excludes the possibility that is a molting shell. It is interpreted to have 3 pairs of legs from the thorax, the tibiae and femora are long and thin. The antennae are uniramous, the scape and pedicel are wider than the 10-segmented flagellum. The triangular mandibles have a continuous series of sharp, small irregular molar and incisor cusps. Its small head had large eyes. The large thorax had a rounded structure covering its head, corresponding to an expanded pronotum. The abdomen had 10 segments (while a drawing in the paper shows 11 segments [2] ), and the authors considered that it lacked any lateral leglets, gills or other appendicular structures. There is a rounded apical structure on the tip of the abdomen. The lack of wings and small size would indicate that it is a nymph. It is interpreted to be a terrestrial insect, and the mandible morphology suggests its diet would be fungivore and/or saprophagy. [1]

Hörnschemeyer et al. (2013)

However, Hörnschemeyer et al. (2013) questioned its interpretation as an insect. The mandible and its teeth cannot be confirmed, the mandibular teeth would be caused by the idiosyncratic way the rock parted. The eyes are vague, the indication of eye rims by Garrouste et al. is considered as arbitrary. The scape, pedicel and flagellum on its antennae cannot be confirmed, and the whole antennae is wider than the legs which is highly unusual for insects. The alleged subdivision of the trunk into thorax and abdomen is also questionable. Importantly, over 3 pairs of legs can be observed. This poor state of preservation allows numbers of alternate interpretations like a decayed crustacean. [2]

Garrouste et al. (2013)

In the same volume of Nature , Garrouste et al. replied to Hörnschemeyer et al. (2013). They supported mandibular teeth structure again. They argued that visible maxillary palps are abnormal under the crustacean hypothesis. They considered that scape, pedicel and flagellum can be confirmed from width of antennae, and antennae being wider than legs would not deny insect affinity. For the extra legs that Hörnschemeyer et al. confirmed, they considered as internal organs extruded during compression and decay. [3]

Other studies

Multiple later studies about Strud fossils call Strudiella as "putative insect". [4] [5] [6] Haug and Haug (2017) listed presumed Devonian insect fossils, and commented that "Its very incomplete preservation makes its interpretation problematic". [7]

Importance of discovery

The discovery of Strudiella as a Devonian insect reduces a previous gap of 45 million years in the evolutionary history of insects, part of the arthropod gap (the 'gap' still occurs in the early Carboniferous, coinciding and extending past the Romer's gap for tetrapods, which may have been caused by low oxygen levels in the atmosphere). [8] [1] However, Hörnschemeyer et al. (2013) which denied its interpretation as insect commented that it is crucial to prevent this fossil from entering entomology textbooks. [2] Most of fossil records of Devonian insects like Rhyniognatha or Leverhulmia are questionable, and the early fossil records of insects still remains scarce and problematic. [7]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Antenna (biology)</span> Paired appendages used for sensing in arthropods

Antennae, sometimes referred to as "feelers", are paired appendages used for sensing in arthropods.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Decapoda</span> Order of crustaceans

The Decapoda or decapods are an order of crustaceans within the class Malacostraca, and includes crabs, lobsters, crayfish, shrimp, and prawns. Most decapods are scavengers. The order is estimated to contain nearly 15,000 extant species in around 2,700 genera, with around 3,300 fossil species. Nearly half of these species are crabs, with the shrimp and Anomura including hermit crabs, porcelain crabs, squat lobsters making up the bulk of the remainder. The earliest fossils of the group date to the Devonian.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Notostraca</span> Order of small freshwater animals

The order Notostraca, containing the single family Triopsidae, is a group of crustaceans known as tadpole shrimp or shield shrimp. The two genera, Triops and Lepidurus, are considered living fossils, with similar forms having existed since the end of the Devonian, around 360 million years ago. They have a broad, flat carapace, which conceals the head and bears a single pair of compound eyes. The abdomen is long, appears to be segmented and bears numerous pairs of flattened legs. The telson is flanked by a pair of long, thin caudal rami. Phenotypic plasticity within taxa makes species-level identification difficult, and is further compounded by variation in the mode of reproduction. Notostracans are omnivores living on the bottom of temporary pools and shallow lakes.

<i>Yohoia</i> Extinct genus of arthropods

Yohoia is an extinct genus of megacheiran arthropod from the Cambrian period that has been found as fossils in the Burgess Shale formation of British Columbia, Canada. The type species, Yohoia tenuis, was described in 1912 by Walcott, who considered it an anostracan crustacean. 711 specimens of Yohoia are known from the Greater Phyllopod bed, where they comprise 1.35% of the community. In 2015, Conway Morris et al. reported another species, Y. utahana, from the Marjum Formation, Utah.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clam shrimp</span> Suborder of arthropods

Clam shrimp are a group of bivalved branchiopod crustaceans that resemble the unrelated bivalved molluscs. They are extant and also known from the fossil record, from at least the Devonian period and perhaps before. They were originally classified in the former order Conchostraca, which later proved to be paraphyletic, due to the fact that water fleas are nested within clam shrimps. Clam shrimp are now divided into three orders, Cyclestherida, Laevicaudata, and Spinicaudata, in addition to the fossil family Leaiidae.

The most recent understanding of the evolution of insects is based on studies of the following branches of science: molecular biology, insect morphology, paleontology, insect taxonomy, evolution, embryology, bioinformatics and scientific computing. It is estimated that the class of insects originated on Earth about 480 million years ago, in the Ordovician, at about the same time terrestrial plants appeared. Insects are thought to have evolved from a group of crustaceans. The first insects were landbound, but about 400 million years ago in the Devonian period one lineage of insects evolved flight, the first animals to do so. The oldest insect fossil has been proposed to be Rhyniognatha hirsti, estimated to be 400 million years old, but the insect identity of the fossil has been contested. Global climate conditions changed several times during the history of Earth, and along with it the diversity of insects. The Pterygotes underwent a major radiation in the Carboniferous while the Endopterygota underwent another major radiation in the Permian.

<i>Canadaspis</i> Extinct genus of arthropods

Canadaspis is an extinct genus of bivalved Cambrian arthropod, known from North America and China. They are thought to have been benthic feeders that moved mainly by walking and possibly used its biramous appendages to stir mud in search of food. They have been placed within the Hymenocarina, which includes other bivalved Cambrian arthropods.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cheloniellida</span> Order of arthropods (fossil)

Cheloniellida is a taxon of extinct Paleozoic arthropods. As of 2018, 7 monotypic genera of cheloniellids had been formally described, whose fossils are found in marine strata ranging from Ordovician to Devonian in age. Cheloniellida has a controversial phylogenetic position, with previous studies associated it as either a member or relative of various fossil and extant arthropod taxa. It was later accepted as a member of Vicissicaudata within Artiopoda.

<i>Rhyniognatha</i> Extinct genus of insects

Rhyniognatha is an extinct genus of arthropod of disputed placement. It has been considered in some analyses as the oldest insect known, as well as possibly being a flying insect. Rhyniognatha is known from a partial head with preserved mouthparts from the Early Devonian aged Rhynie chert around 400 million years ago, when Earth’s first terrestrial ecosystems were being formed. The type, and only species is R. hirsti, which was named and described in 1928. Other analyses have interpreted the specimen as a myriapod.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Euthycarcinoidea</span> Extinct order of arthropods

Euthycarcinoidea are an enigmatic group of extinct, possibly amphibious arthropods that ranged from Cambrian to Triassic times. Fossils are known from Europe, North America, Argentina, Australia, and Antarctica.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arthropod</span> Phylum of invertebrates with jointed exoskeletons

Arthropods are invertebrates in the phylum Arthropoda. They possess an exoskeleton with a cuticle made of chitin, often mineralised with calcium carbonate, a body with differentiated (metameric) segments, and paired jointed appendages. In order to keep growing, they must go through stages of moulting, a process by which they shed their exoskeleton to reveal a new one. They form an extremely diverse group of up to ten million species.

<i>Angustidontus</i> Extinct genus of crustaceans

Angustidontus is a genus of predatory pelagic crustaceans from the Late Devonian and Early Carboniferous periods, classified as part of the subclass Eumalacostraca. Fossils of the genus have been recovered in relative abundance from Canada, Germany, the Czech Republic, Poland, Belarus, Ukraine and large parts of the United States, including Oklahoma, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, Montana, Utah, Nevada.

<i>Cancrinos</i> Extinct genus of crustaceans

Cancrinos is a genus of fossil crustaceans closely allied with the slipper lobsters. One species is known, C. claviger from the Jurassic of southern Germany.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hexapoda</span> Subphylum of arthropods

The subphylum Hexapoda or hexapods comprises the largest clade of arthropods and includes most of the extant arthropod species. It includes the crown group class Insecta, as well as the much smaller class Entognatha, which includes three groups of wingless arthropods that were once considered insects: Collembola (springtails), Protura (coneheads) and Diplura. The insects and springtails are very abundant and are some of the most important pollinators, basal consumers, scavengers/detritivores and micropredators in terrestrial environments.

This list of fossil arthropods described in 2016 is a list of new taxa of trilobites, fossil insects, crustaceans, arachnids and other fossil arthropods of every kind that have been described during the year 2016, as well as other significant discoveries and events related to arthropod paleontology that occurred in the year 2016.

The arthropod gap is an apparent gap in the arthropod fossil record used in the study of evolutionary biology. It still occurs in the early Carboniferous, coinciding and extending past the Romer's gap for tetrapods, who were newly arriving on land.

This list of fossil arthropods described in 2018 is a list of new taxa of trilobites, fossil insects, crustaceans, arachnids, and other fossil arthropods of every kind that were described during the year 2018, as well as other significant discoveries, and events related to arthropod paleontology that are scheduled to occur in the year 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Angustidontidae</span> Extinct family of crustaceans

Angustidontidae is an extinct family of eucarid crustaceans and the sole representatives of the order Angustidontida. They were predators ranging in size from about 4 to 9 centimetres in length and lived during the Late Devonian and Early Carboniferous periods.

This list of fossil arthropods described in 2019 is a list of new taxa of trilobites, fossil insects, crustaceans, arachnids and other fossil arthropods of every kind that are scheduled to be described during the year 2019, as well as other significant discoveries and events related to arthropod paleontology that are scheduled to occur in the year 2019.

Leverhulmia is an extinct genus of arthropod, known from a single partial specimen with preserved gut contents, found in the Windyfield (Rhynie) chert.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Romain Garrouste, Gaël Clément, Patricia Nel, Michael S. Engel, Philippe Grandcolas, Cyrille D’Haese, Linda Lagebro, Julien Denayer, Pierre Gueriau, Patrick Lafaite, Sébastien Olive, Cyrille Prestianni and André Nel (2012). "A complete insect from the Late Devonian period". Nature. 488 (7409): 82–85. PMID   22859205, doi : 10.1038/nature11281
  2. 1 2 3 4 Hörnschemeyer, Thomas; Haug, Joachim T.; Bethoux, Olivier; Beutel, Rolf G.; Charbonnier, Sylvain; Hegna, Thomas A.; Koch, Markus; Rust, Jes; Wedmann, Sonja; Bradler, Sven; Willmann, Rainer (2013-02-20). "Is Strudiella a Devonian insect?". Nature. 494 (7437): E3–E4. Bibcode:2013Natur.494E...3H. doi:10.1038/nature11887. ISSN   1476-4687. PMID   23426326. S2CID   205232661.
  3. Garrouste, Romain; Clément, Gaël; Nel, Patricia; Engel, Michael S.; Grandcolas, Philippe; D’Haese, Cyrille A.; Lagebro, Linda; Denayer, Julien; Gueriau, Pierre; Lafaite, Patrick; Olive, Sébastien; Prestianni, Cyrille; Nel, André (2013). "Garrouste et al. reply". Nature. 494 (7437): E4–E5. Bibcode:2013Natur.494E...4G. doi:10.1038/nature11888. ISSN   1476-4687. S2CID   4321678.
  4. Gueriau, Pierre; Rabet, Nicolas; Hat, Eva Du Tien (2016). "The Strud crustacean fauna (Late Devonian, Belgium): updated review and palaeoecology of an early continental ecosystem". Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh. 107 (2–3): 79–90. Bibcode:2016EESTR.107...79G. doi:10.1017/S1755691017000275. ISSN   1755-6910. S2CID   133838663.
  5. Lamsdell, James C.; Lagebro, Linda; Edgecombe, Gregory D.; Budd, Graham E.; Gueriau, Pierre (2019). "Stylonurine eurypterids from the Strud locality (Upper Devonian, Belgium): new insights into the ecology of freshwater sea scorpions". Geological Magazine. 156 (10): 1708–1714. Bibcode:2019GeoM..156.1708L. doi:10.1017/S0016756818000936. ISSN   0016-7568. S2CID   135411044.
  6. Gueriau, Pierre; Rabet, Nicolas; Clément, Gaël; Lagebro, Linda; Vannier, Jean; Briggs, Derek E. G.; Charbonnier, Sylvain; Olive, Sébastien; Béthoux, Olivier (2016-02-08). "A 365-Million-Year-Old Freshwater Community Reveals Morphological and Ecological Stasis in Branchiopod Crustaceans". Current Biology. 26 (3): 383–390. Bibcode:2016CBio...26..383G. doi: 10.1016/j.cub.2015.12.039 . ISSN   0960-9822. PMID   26776738.
  7. 1 2 Haug, Carolin; Haug, Joachim T. (2017-05-30). "The presumed oldest flying insect: more likely a myriapod?". PeerJ. 5: e3402. doi: 10.7717/peerj.3402 . ISSN   2167-8359. PMC   5452959 . PMID   28584727.
  8. Ward, P.; Labandeira, C.; Laurin, M.; Berner, R. A. (2006). "Confirmation of Romer's Gap as a low oxygen interval constraining the timing of initial arthropod and vertebrate terrestrialization". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 103 (45): 16818–22. Bibcode:2006PNAS..10316818W. PMC 1636538 Freely accessible. PMID   17065318. doi : 10.1073/pnas.0607824103