The Years of Rice and Salt

Last updated

The Years of Rice and Salt
TheYearsOfRiceAndSalt(1stEdUK).jpg
Cover of UK hardcover edition
Author Kim Stanley Robinson
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Genre Alternate history
Publisher Bantam Books (US)
HarperCollins (UK)
Publication date
March 2002
Media typePrint (hardback & paperback)
Pages660
Awards Locus Award for Best Science Fiction Novel (2003)
ISBN 0-553-10920-0
OCLC 47894803
813/.54 21
LC Class PS3568.O2893 Y43 2002

The Years of Rice and Salt is an alternate history novel by American science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson, published in 2002. The novel explores how world history might have been different if the Black Death plague had killed 99 percent of Europe's population, instead of a third as it did in reality. Divided into ten parts, the story spans hundreds of years, from the army of the Muslim conqueror Timur to the 21st century, with Europe being re-populated by Muslim pioneers, the indigenous peoples of the Americas forming a league to resist Chinese and Muslim invaders, and a 67-year-long world war being fought primarily between Muslim states and the Chinese and their allies. While the ten parts take place in different times and places, they are connected by a group of characters that are reincarnated into each time but are identified to the reader by the first letter of their name being consistent in each life.

Contents

The novel explores themes of history, religion, and social movements. The historical narrative is guided more by social history than political or military history. Critics found the book to be rich in detail, realistic, and thoughtful. The Years of Rice and Salt won the Locus Award for Best Science Fiction Novel in 2003. In the same year it was nominated for the Arthur C. Clarke Award, a Hugo Award, and a British Science Fiction Award.

Background

At the time of publication in 2002, science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson was 49 years old and living in Davis, California. He had conceived of the premise for The Years of Rice and Salt in the 1970s while thinking about what alternate history scenario would result in "the biggest change that would still work in terms of comparison to our history". [1] He subsequently developed an interest in China and in Buddhism, which he would study for this project. [2]

Robinson's only other alternate history story prior to this project was the short story "The Lucky Strike" (1984), [lower-alpha 1] where the Enola Gay crashes in a training exercise and the secondary crew must complete the Hiroshima bombing. [3]

Robinson also wrote an essay titled "A Sensitive Dependence on Initial Conditions" (1991), [lower-alpha 2] comparing different theories of history and laws of science, such as the covering law model, to explain how alternate histories can be arrived at, using "The Lucky Strike" as an example. [lower-alpha 3]

He explored the idea of non-Western influences creating a new culture while working on his Mars trilogy, which involved a heavy Muslim influence in a Martian colony. [2] The Mars trilogy gave Robinson a reputation for quality of writing and a richness of detail comparable to James Michener, [4] as well as winning him a Nebula Award for Red Mars (1993) and two Hugo and Locus Awards for Green Mars (1994) and Blue Mars (1996). [5] Robinson followed the Mars trilogy with the novel Antarctica (1997), which won an Alex Award, and two short story collections, The Martians (1999) and Vinland the Dream (2001), before publishing The Years of Rice and Salt.

Plot

The story is divided into ten parts.

Book One: Awake to Emptiness

Bold and Psin, scouts in Timur's army, discover a Magyar city where all the inhabitants have died from a plague. Timur turns his army around and orders the scouting party executed to avoid the plague, but Bold escapes and wanders through the dead lands of Eastern Europe, encountering only one lone native. Upon reaching the sea he is captured by Turkish Muslim slave-traders and sold into Zheng He's Chinese treasure fleet. Bold befriends a young African slave, named Kyu, whom he cares for after the Chinese castrate him. In China, they are kept as kitchen slaves until escaping and eventually making their way north to Beijing where they find work at the palace of Zhu Gaozhi, heir to the Yongle Emperor. The vengeful Kyu hates the Chinese for what they have done to him, inciting violence between the eunuchs and the Confucian administrative officials until they assassinate him.

Book Two: The Haj in the Heart

In Mughal India, a Hindu girl named Kokila poisons her husband's father and brother after discovering their plot to defraud the village. She is executed for her crime, but is reincarnated as a tiger that befriends a man named Bistami, a Sufi mystic of Persian origin. Bistami goes on to become a judge for Mughal Emperor Akbar, but later falls into his disfavour, being exiled to Mecca. Bistami spends one year in Mecca before travelling overland to the Maghreb and Iberia (Al-Andalus). He then joins a caravan led by Sultan Mawji and his wife, Katima, who seek to leave Al-Andalus and found a new city on the other side of the Pyrenees, beyond the control of the Caliph of Al-Andalus. They build the city of Baraka on the abandoned former site of Bayonne, France, and create a model society in which Sultana Katima is highly influential. Katima seeks to change the Islamic religion to create equality between men and women, by rejecting the Hadiths and relying only on her interpretation of the Quran. She rules the community after her husband dies (something not allowed in normal Islamic practice), but the Caliph of Al-Andalus eventually hears of their "heresy" and sends an army against them. The community flees further to the north, where they build a new city named Nsara (near Nantes, France) and are able to defend it from further aggression in later years.

Book Three: Ocean Continents

The Wanli Emperor launches an invasion against Nippon (Japan) but the huge fleet is swept out to sea by the Kuroshio Current and they are set adrift on the unexplored Pacific Ocean. The fleet hopes to be brought back to China eventually by the great circular currents of the Pacific, but they accidentally discover the New World. The sailors make landfall on the West coast of North America and make contact with the peaceful Miwok people, but quickly leave once Admiral Kheim discovers they have inadvertently infected the indigenous people with devastating diseases. They sail south where they meet another civilization rich in gold. There they narrowly escape being ritually sacrificed by using their flintlock firearms, something the natives have never seen before. They eventually return to China and tell the Emperor that he could easily conquer this new land and gain its great wealth.

Book Four: The Alchemist

A 17th-century alchemist named Khalid from Samarkand attempts to fool the Khan into believing that he has discovered the Philosopher's stone, but his fraud is uncovered and his hand is severed as punishment. Khalid becomes depressed and disenchanted with alchemy and decides to destroy all his Alchemical books. His friend Iwang, a Tibetan Buddhist mathematician, and son-in-law Bahram, a Sufi blacksmith, instead convince him to test the claims in the books. They devote themselves to practical demonstrations and experiments that greatly improve knowledge of various aspects of physics, chemistry, mathematics, biology, and weaponry, and in the process create the scientific method. Their discoveries create interest amongst the religious madrasahs of the city, many of whom also go along with the new fashion of building and testing scientific apparatuses. But most of all, they catch the eye of the Khan's powerful advisor, who sees in their inventions the possibility of great military technology, to fight the rising Chinese threat to the East.

Book Five: Warp and Weft

A former samurai, fleeing from the Chinese conquest of Japan, travels to the New World to meet the Iroquois people. They name him "Fromwest" and make him a chief of their confederacy. He helps organize their society into a larger defensive alliance of all the North American tribes, and shows them how to make their own guns with which to resist the Chinese and Muslim colonizers.

Book Six: Widow Kang

Book Six follows the life of Chinese widow Kang Tongbi during the reign of the Qianlong Emperor. She takes in a poor Buddhist monk, Bao Ssu, and his son whom she finds scavenging, but the monk is wrongly implicated in a series of queue cuttings and dies in prison. Later, Kang meets a Hui Muslim scholar named Ibrahim ibn Hasam and together they discover it is possible to remember their past lives. They marry and move to Lanzhou in western China, where they undertake work to try to reconcile Islamic and Confucian beliefs. Kang creates and collects works of proto-feminist poetry and becomes a known writer. There is a Muslim rebellion in the region due to the Qing intolerance of new Islamic sects coming from the west, but the revolt is crushed with massive force.

Book Seven: The Age of Great Progress

In the 19th century, war rages between the Ottoman Empire and the Indian state of Travancore. The Indians have overthrown the Mughals and the Safavids and have now developed steam engines, ironclad warships, and military balloons. Using these new weapons, they sail to Kostantiniyye and easily defeat the Ottomans. A Muslim Armenian doctor named Ismail ibn Mani al-Dir, who had served the Ottoman Sultan, is captured and sent to Travancore, where he happily joins the hospital of Travancore and begins work in anatomy and physiology. Ismail eventually meets their ruler, the Kerala of Travancore, who aims to drive out the Muslim invaders and unify India into a democratic confederation.

Later, during the Xianfeng Emperor's reign, in the Chinese colony known as Gold Mountain, the Great Flood of 1862 forces the evacuation of Chinese and Japanese settlers alike. The Japanese had originally fled to the new world to escape Chinese oppression in their homeland, but find themselves once again under the Chinese yoke. A displaced Japanese slave, Kiyoaki, and a pregnant Chinese refugee, Peng-ti, manage to flee to the great coastal city of Fangzhang. [6] There Kiyoaki joins a secret Japanese freedom movement that is being aided by Travancore, with Ismail acting as a liaison.

Map of the world of The Years of Rice and Salt in the year 1333 AH (1915 AD), showing the four major blocs and alliances on the eve of the "Long War".
Dar al-Islam (multiple nations in alliance during the war)
Travancori League
China & her Colonies
Hodenosaunee League
.mw-parser-output .legend{page-break-inside:avoid;break-inside:avoid-column}.mw-parser-output .legend-color{display:inline-block;min-width:1.25em;height:1.25em;line-height:1.25;margin:1px 0;text-align:center;border:1px solid black;background-color:transparent;color:black}.mw-parser-output .legend-text{} The Years of Rice and Salt (Pre-War Map).png
Map of the world of The Years of Rice and Salt in the year 1333 AH (1915 AD), showing the four major blocs and alliances on the eve of the "Long War".
  Dar al-Islam (multiple nations in alliance during the war)
  Travancori League
  China & her Colonies
  Hodenosaunee League

...the complaints about alternative histories being "too much like" our history are always balanced, sometimes in the same commentator, by complaints that it is "too different to be possible," and I have concluded that really one can't win: alternatives to our world history are in some deep sense unthinkable. The alternative history then becomes an exercise in pushing at that limit and always asking "why" to one's responses concerning "plausibility" or the like.

—Kim Stanley Robinson [2]

The Years of Rice and Salt belongs to the alternate history subgenre of speculative fiction. The novel starts at the point of divergence with Timur turning his army away from Europe where the Black Death killed 99 percent of Europe's population, instead of a third. Robinson explores world history from that point in AD 1405 (807 AH) to about AD 2045 (1467 AH) with Mughal Emperor Akbar being the last character with a real-world counterpart. [13]

Robinson's take on alternate history is that because it "is set in the same lawful universe as ours, its science must be the same [and] because its people have the same basic human needs, their societies resemble ours." [10] Therefore, despite the difference in who specifically is there, "the great majority of humanity [is] doing their work, and that work would tend to forge along at a certain pace as people tried to solve the problems of making themselves more comfortable in this world." [2]

While most alternate histories use the Great Man theory of history, focusing on leaders, wars, and big events, Robinson writes more about social history, similar to the Annales School of historical theory and Marxist historiography, focusing on the lives of ordinary people living in their time and place. [2] This is reflected in the title of the novel, The Years of Rice and Salt, which refers to the everyday chores of raising a family, often performed by women, despite the politics and wars of men. [11]

Reviewers noted this allows for the "history [to be] experienced by readers on a human scale" [18] and "an implicit but thorough rebuke to the kind of war-gaming determinism that most alternate histories embody." [9] The novel has characters that explore subjects like philosophy, theology, history, and scientific theory. [19] [20]

Publication and reception

Robinson takes advantage of the romance inherent in the idea of reincarnation; it's a lovely, seductive concept, and it adds much mystical texture to the narrative. But that does not mean the author is any less tough-minded here than in his other books. Indeed, The Years of Salt and Rice, for all of its fantastic elements, is essentially a character-driven — which is to say, literary — series of novelettes.

—Chauncy Mabe, Books Editor, South Florida Sun-Sentinel [8]

Released in March 2002, the book was published in North America by Bantam Books and in the United Kingdom by HarperCollins. The paperback was released in 2003 along with a Spanish translation. In the subsequent years, other translated versions were published, in French, Polish, Chinese, and Hungarian.

The novel was well received by critics who variously called it "thoughtful", [4] [7] [12] [21] "realistic", [3] [4] and "rich". [4] [9] [16] In Publishers Weekly , the reviewers called it a "highly realistic and credible alternate history", [3] and in the School Library Journal , Christine Menefee called it "an addictive, surprising, and suspenseful novel". [18] The Library Journal "highly recommended" it, saying that its "superb storytelling and imaginative historic speculation make [it] a priority choice for all SF and general fiction collections". [22] The critic at Kirkus Reviews found it "overlong, but blessed with moments of wry and gentle beauty". [23] Likewise, Roz Kaveney stated that "if there is a weakness in Robinson's work, it is perhaps this; his characters are so intelligent that they never shut up". [21] For The Globe and Mail , Sol Chrom lauded the epic scope, calling it a "magnificent achievement", [17] and for The Belfast News Letter , the reviewer called the novel "extraordinary, ambitious, poetic and powerful". [24] Science fiction critic Paul Kincaid concluded that it is "a huge, complex and highly enjoyable book". [25]

Awards

It won the 2003 Locus Award for Best Science Fiction Novel and was nominated for the Hugo Award, the Arthur C. Clarke Award, and the British Science Fiction Award.

See also

Other alternate-history novels where the Black Death was much deadlier in Europe, which was subsequently colonized in whole or part by Muslims:

Notes

  1. "The Lucky Strike" was first published in Universe #14 ( ISBN   0-385-19134-0) and was nominated for a Hugo and a Nebula Award
  2. "A Sensitive Dependence on Initial Conditions" was first published in Author's Choice #20 ( OCLC   23764754)
  3. Both "The Lucky Strike" and "A Sensitive Dependence on Initial Conditions" were published together in the 2009 booklet The Lucky Strike by PM Press ( ISBN   9781604860856) as part of their Outspoken Authors series.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alternate history</span> Genre of speculative fiction, where one or more historical events occur differently

Alternate history is a subgenre of speculative fiction in which one or more historical events have occurred but are resolved differently than in actual history. As conjecture based upon historical fact, alternate history stories propose What if? scenarios about crucial events in human history, and present outcomes very different from the historical record. Some alternate histories are considered a subgenre of literary fiction, science fiction, or historical fiction.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edgar Rice Burroughs</span> American writer (1875–1950)

Edgar Rice Burroughs was an American writer, best known for his prolific output in the adventure, science fiction, and fantasy genres. Best known for creating the characters Tarzan and John Carter, he also wrote the Pellucidar series, the Amtor series, and the Caspak trilogy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kim Stanley Robinson</span> American science fiction writer (born 1952)

Kim Stanley Robinson is an American writer of science fiction. He has published 22 novels and numerous short stories and is best known for his Mars trilogy. His work has been translated into 24 languages. Many of his novels and stories have ecological, cultural, and political themes and feature scientists as heroes. Robinson has won numerous awards, including the Hugo Award for Best Novel, the Nebula Award for Best Novel and the World Fantasy Award. The Atlantic has called Robinson's work "the gold standard of realistic, and highly literary, science-fiction writing." According to an article in The New Yorker, Robinson is "generally acknowledged as one of the greatest living science-fiction writers."

<i>Icehenge</i>

Icehenge is a science fiction novel by American author Kim Stanley Robinson, published in 1984.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mars in fiction</span> Depictions of the planet

Mars, the fourth planet from the Sun, has appeared as a setting in works of fiction since at least the mid-1600s. Trends in the planet's portrayal have largely been influenced by advances in planetary science. It became the most popular celestial object in fiction in the late 1800s, when it became clear that there was no life on the Moon. The predominant genre depicting Mars at the time was utopian fiction. Around the same time, the mistaken belief that there are canals on Mars emerged and made its way into fiction, popularized by Percival Lowell's speculations of an ancient civilization having constructed them. The War of the Worlds, H. G. Wells's novel about an alien invasion of Earth by sinister Martians, was published in 1897 and went on to have a major influence on the science fiction genre.

Counterfactual history is a form of historiography that attempts to answer the What if? questions that arise from counterfactual conditions. As a method of intellectual enquiry, counterfactual history explores history and historical incidents by extrapolating a timeline in which key historical events either did not occur or had an outcome different from the actual historical outcome. Counterfactual history seeks by "conjecturing on what did not happen, or what might have happened, in order to understand what did happen." It has produced a literary genre which is variously called alternate history, speculative history, allohistory, and hypothetical history.

<i>Mars</i> trilogy Series of science fiction novels by Kim Stanley Robinson

The Mars trilogy is a series of science fiction novels by Kim Stanley Robinson that chronicles the settlement and terraforming of the planet Mars through the personal and detailed viewpoints of a wide variety of characters spanning almost two centuries. Ultimately more utopian than dystopian, the story focuses on egalitarian, sociological, and scientific advances made on Mars, while Earth suffers from overpopulation and ecological disaster.

The exploration of politics in science fiction is arguably older than the identification of the genre. One of the earliest works of modern science fiction, H. G. Wells’ The Time Machine, is an extrapolation of the class structure of the United Kingdom of his time, an extreme form of social Darwinism; during tens of thousands of years, human beings have evolved into two different species based on their social class.

<i>China Mountain Zhang</i> 1992 novel by Maureen F. McHugh

China Mountain Zhang is a 1992 science fiction novel by American writer Maureen F. McHugh. The novel is made up of several stories loosely intertwined.

Pamela Sargent is an American feminist, science fiction author, and editor. She has an MA in classical philosophy and has won a Nebula Award.

As an adjective, Martian means of or pertaining to the planet Mars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mundane science fiction</span> Science fiction subgenre limited to near-future tech

Mundane science fiction (MSF) is a niche literary movement within science fiction that developed in the early 2000s, with principles codified by the "Mundane Manifesto" in 2004, signed by author Geoff Ryman and "The Clarion West 2004 Class". The movement proposes "mundane science fiction" as its own subgenre of science fiction, typically characterized by its setting on Earth or within the Solar System; a lack of interstellar travel, intergalactic travel or human contact with extraterrestrials; and a believable use of technology and science as it exists at the time the story is written or a plausible extension of existing technology. There is debate over the boundaries of MSF and over which works can be considered canonical. Rudy Rucker has noted MSF's similarities to hard science fiction and Ritch Calvin has pointed out MSF's similarities to cyberpunk. Some commentators have identified science fiction films and television series which embody the MSF ethos of near-future realism.

<i>Sixty Days and Counting</i> Novel by Kim Stanley Robinson

Sixty Days and Counting (2007) is the third book in the hard science fiction Science in the Capital trilogy by Kim Stanley Robinson. It directly follows the events of Fifty Degrees Below, beginning just after the election of character Phil Chase to the White House. It follows the previous novel's deep freeze of the area surrounding Washington D.C. and details the remediation of the climate in the United States and around the world.

<i>The Gate of Worlds</i> 1967 alternate history novel by Robert Silverberg

The Gate of Worlds is an alternate history novel by American writer Robert Silverberg. It was first published by Holt, Rinehart & Winston in the United States in 1967. The first UK hardcover edition was published by Gollancz in 1978.

This is a bibliography of American science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson.

Phillip E. Wegner is a professor in the Department of English and the Marston-Milbauer Eminent Scholar in English at the University of Florida.

<i>The Crystal Empire</i> (novel)

The Crystal Empire is a 1986 novel by American science fiction and alternate history writer L. Neil Smith. It is set in an alternate universe that shares with Kim Stanley Robinson's The Years of Rice and Salt, Robert Silverberg's The Gate of Worlds and Harry Turtledove's In High Places a point of divergence where the Black Death kills much more of Europe's population than it did in reality, opening the way for a Muslim conquest of Europe. The plague also decimates the Mongol Empire, allowing a Mughal power to arise in the Far East in its place.

<i>Through Darkest Europe</i> 2018 alternate history novel

Through Darkest Europe is an alternate history novel by Harry Turtledove. The book is set in an alternate present in which Islamic countries form a prosperous, democratic and progressive First World, while underdeveloped Christian countries suffer from religious fanaticism.

<i>The Ministry for the Future</i> Science fiction novel by Kim Stanley Robinson

The Ministry for the Future is a climate fiction ("cli-fi") novel by American science fiction writer Kim Stanley Robinson published in 2020. Set in the near future, the novel follows a subsidiary body, established under the Paris Agreement, whose mission is to act as an advocate for the world's future generations of citizens as if their rights are as valid as the present generation's. While they pursue various ambitious projects, the effects of climate change are determined to be the most consequential. The plot primarily follows Mary Murphy, the head of the titular Ministry for the Future, and Frank May, an American aid worker traumatized by experiencing a deadly heat wave in India. Many chapters are devoted to other characters' accounts of future events, as well as their ideas about ecology, economics, and other subjects.

References

  1. Bisson, Terry (2009). "A Real Joy to be Had: Outspoken Interview with Kim Stanley Robinson". The Lucky Strike. Outspoken Authors. Oakland, California: PM Press. pp. 77–107. ISBN   9781604860856.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Szeman, Imre; Maria Whiteman (July 2004). "Future Politics: An Interview with Kim Stanley Robinson". Science Fiction Studies . 31 (2): 177–188.
  3. 1 2 3 Zaleski, Jeff; Peter Canon (January 7, 2002). "The Years of Rice and Salt". Publishers Weekly . 249 (1): 51.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Evans, Clay (February 24, 2002). "New worlds - Two giant new 'alternative histories' vividly explore Islam ascendant". Daily Camera . Boulder, Colorado. p. DD6.
  5. Evans, Clay (June 13, 2004). "Real, but not real fun: - Robinson's new global-warming trilogy gets off to a slow star". Daily Camera . Boulder, Colorado. p. E5.
  6. "The years of rice and salt | KimStanleyRobinson.info".
  7. 1 2 3 Hopper, Jim (March 10, 2002). "Grand opportunity to go reelin' in the 'Years'". The San Diego Union-Tribune . San Diego, California. p. BOOKS-7.
  8. 1 2 Mabe, Chauncy (March 31, 2002). "Trio's Lives Intertwine — Again and Again". South Florida Sun-Sentinel . Fort Lauderdale, Florida. p. 10D.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 Feeley, Gregory (April 7, 2002). "Past Forward". The Washington Post . Washington, D.C.
  10. 1 2 3 Jonas, Gerald (April 28, 2002). "Science Fiction". The New York Times Book Review . New York. p. 20.
  11. 1 2 Barbour, Douglas (March 17, 2002). "Islam and Buddhism clash in believable alternate history". Edmonton Journal . Edmonton, Alberta. p. D11.
  12. 1 2 3 Wilson, Andrew (June 15, 2002). "Worlds of wonder". The Scotsman . Edinburgh, Scotland. p. 10.
  13. 1 2 Robinson, Kim Stanley (April 14, 2002). "Profile: Kim Stanley Robinson's Book "The Years Of Rice And Salt"". Weekend Edition Sunday (Interview). Interviewed by Neda Ulaby. National Public Radio.
  14. Powers, John (June 2002). "The West Coast of Utopia: Kim Stanley Robinson and the science fiction of hope". The American Prospect : 45.
  15. Pierleoni, Allen (July 14, 2004). "Warming Up —- Kim Stanley Robinson's latest is the first in a sci-fi trilogy about a catastrophic ice age". The Sacramento Bee . Sacramento, California. p. E1.
  16. 1 2 Cleaver, Fred (March 24, 2002). "Intrigue envelops Russian poet, student Marvelous language fills "The Translator'". The Denver Post . Denver, Colorado. p. EE-02.
  17. 1 2 Chrom, Sol (June 15, 2002). "World without West". The Globe and Mail . Toronto, Ontario. p. D30.
  18. 1 2 Menefee, Christine (August 2002). "The Years of Rice and Salt". School Library Journal . 48 (8): 222.
  19. Fisher, George (October 2002). "The Years of Rice and Salt". New Internationalist (350): 31.
  20. Shaw, Elizabeth (July 14, 2002). "Salt' insight into alternate history". The Flint Journal . Flint, Michigan. p. F03.
  21. 1 2 Kaveney, Roz (March 5, 2002). "Tuesday Book: After the Black Death, 700 Years of New Life". The Independent . London, England. p. 5.
  22. Cassada, Jackie (February 15, 2002). "The Years of Rice and Salt". Library Journal . 127 (3): 180.
  23. "The Years of Rice and Salt". Kirkus Reviews . 70 (1): 23. January 2002.
  24. Abernethy, Daphne (March 11, 2002). "Book review: History as it might have been". The News Letter . Belfast, Northern Ireland.
  25. Kincaid, Paul (March 25, 2002). "Big Death". New Scientist . 173 (2335): 50.

Further reading