Colwich rail crash

Last updated

Colwich rail crash
Colwich rail crash.jpg
Details
Date19 September 1986
18:28
Location Colwich Junction, Staffordshire, England
CountryEngland
Line West Coast Main Line
Incident typeCollision
CauseDriver's error
Statistics
Trains2
Passengers~873
Deaths1
Injured75
List of UK rail accidents by year

The Colwich rail crash occurred on the evening of Friday 19 September 1986 at Colwich Junction, Staffordshire, England. [1] It was significant in that it was a high speed collision between two packed express trains. One driver was killed, but no passengers died because of the great strength of the rolling stock involved, which included examples of Mk1, Mk2 and Mk3 coaches.

Contents

Background

Colwich Junction lies between Rugeley and Stafford and is where the four-track West Coast Main Line from London splits into two routes. Approaching from the south, two tracks go to Manchester via Stoke-on-Trent and two tracks go to Stafford and Crewe. In the middle of the layout, two of the lines cross each other at a diamond crossing.

In August 1986, the signalling was altered so that drivers of northbound trains taking the Stoke line would see flashing yellow signals on approach. The rulebook meaning of this was:

"A flashing yellow aspect means facing points at a junction ahead are set for a diverging route and the speed of the train must be reduced". [2]

This sequence of signalling was designed for use at higher-speed turnouts as a replacement for approach release , where the junction signal is held at red until the train is near to it.

Over the next few years, flashing yellows were also installed at locations where trains cross over between different tracks travelling in the same direction, e.g. from a "fast" line to a "slow" line. While not "junctions" in the traditional sense, the signalling sequence was identical to that given at a "diverging" route.

The accident

Diverging route signalling - the driver must slow down and be prepared to stop at the red signal. Four-aspect flashing yellow signalling.gif
Diverging route signalling - the driver must slow down and be prepared to stop at the red signal.

On 19 September 1986, the signalman at Colwich saw that the 17:00 express train from London Euston to Manchester Piccadilly was approaching the junction at roughly the same time as the 17:20 express from Liverpool to Euston. He decided to give precedence to the latter and so the Manchester train might need to wait its turn over the junction.

The Manchester train needed to cross from the Down Fast to the Down Slow line before turning off towards Stoke. The signals presented to its driver were as follows:

Signal no.AspectMeaning
CH105Flashing double yellowAdvance indication of diverging route ahead
CH103Flashing single yellowIndication of diverging route ahead
CH18Single yellow with junction indicatorNext signal at Danger. Next set of points have been set for a diverging route.
CH23RedDanger – stop

After passing over the crossover he saw that CH23 was still red. Having interpreted the flashing yellows to mean that the route was set all the way over the junction to Stoke, he was expecting this signal to clear as he approached it (as under the approach release system). But as he got nearer he realised it had not.

The driver made an emergency brake application but the train did not stop before reaching the diamond crossing. At that moment he saw the Liverpool train approaching at high speed and shouted a warning to a trainee driver who was also in the cab. They both jumped from the locomotive almost immediately before the Liverpool train collided with it.

The locomotive of the Liverpool train was 86211 City of Milton Keynes. It hit the other locomotive 86429 The Times side-on, which finished up in the wreckage with its body twisted and split open. The passenger coaches were scattered in all directions and some had their ends badly damaged. Eric Goode, the driver of no. 86211, was killed. [3] It was also reported that Nicaragua's ambassador to Britain, Francisco d'Escoto, was one of the injured passengers. [4]

Investigation

The destroyed cab of 86211, the driver of which was killed in the accident Destroyed 86211 cab.jpg
The destroyed cab of 86211, the driver of which was killed in the accident

After the accident, the driver went to the signal box and told the signalman "You had double flashing yellows and the route was set for Stoke". [5] [6] With "traditional" junction layouts in mind, flashing yellows would have meant that the route was set for him right through the junction, with at worst, the red signal on the far side. It was not; at Colwich the signalling system was designed for the 'diverging route' to be only the crossover from the Down Fast to the Down Slow, and the driver was not expecting to see a red signal before taking the Stoke line. In this respect railway nomenclature had unwittingly set a trap; he had after all seen a 'Junction Indicator' illuminated and thus assumed that his train had been routed across the junction. [7]

The public inquiry centred on whether the driver had had adequate training on the recently introduced flashing yellow signals and the implications at multiple junctions. [8] The driver admitting to signing for, but not actually reading, the Notice that referred to the installation of flashing yellows at Colwich the previous month.

A contributory factor was the lack of flank protection given the layout at Colwich Junction. The accident would not have happened if the points had been set to route the train away from the diamond crossing, rather than head-on into the Liverpool train's path, as would have been normal practice in an older manual installation. This feature was not included in the junction design because it would have prevented a parallel movement from being signalled on the down fast line, [9] even though in this particular case the train had approached on the down fast line anyway.

This lesson was not learnt; lack of flank protection would again prove a significant factor in a head-on collision, at the Ladbroke Grove rail crash in 1999. [10]

Recommendations

The Inspector's report recommended changing the signalling system so that a flashing yellow sequence could only occur when the route was set across the whole junction, as the driver was expecting. A second recommendation was to inhibit wheel slide protection (WSP) during an emergency brake application – practical tests suggested the train could then have stopped before fouling the junction. The latter recommendation was not implemented.

Memorial

Local resident Alf Taylor created a memorial to Eric Goode at the site of the accident, which he looked after until his death in 1997. On 17 September 2006, the Sunday before the 20th anniversary of the accident, the garden was re-dedicated. [11]

In 2010 a new road in Crewe, where Eric Goode was based was named after him. The road is on the site of the railway bingo club he frequented. [12]

See also

Notes

    Related Research Articles

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">West Coast Main Line</span> Railway route in Britain

    The West Coast Main Line (WCML) is one of the most important railway corridors in the United Kingdom, connecting the major cities of London and Glasgow with branches to Birmingham, Liverpool, Manchester and Edinburgh. It is one of the busiest mixed-traffic railway routes in Europe, carrying a mixture of intercity rail, regional rail, commuter rail and rail freight traffic. The core route of the WCML runs from London to Glasgow for 399 miles (642 km) and was opened from 1837 to 1869. With additional lines deviating to Northampton, Birmingham, Manchester, Liverpool and Edinburgh, this totals a route mileage of 700 miles (1,127 km). The Glasgow–Edinburgh via Carstairs line connects the WCML to Edinburgh. However, the main London–Edinburgh route is the East Coast Main Line. Several sections of the WCML form part of the suburban railway systems in London, Coventry, Birmingham, Liverpool, Manchester and Glasgow, with many more smaller commuter stations, as well as providing links to more rural towns.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway</span> Pre-1923 grouping British Railway company

    The Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway (L&YR) was a major British railway company before the 1923 Grouping. It was incorporated in 1847 from an amalgamation of several existing railways. It was the third-largest railway system based in northern England.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">North Staffordshire Railway</span> Former British railway company

    The North Staffordshire Railway (NSR) was a British railway company formed in 1845 to promote a number of lines in the Staffordshire Potteries and surrounding areas in Staffordshire, Cheshire, Derbyshire and Shropshire.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Clapham Junction rail crash</span> 1988 rail crash in London

    The Clapham Junction railway crash occurred on the morning of 12 December 1988, when a crowded British Rail passenger train crashed into the rear of another train that had stopped at a signal just south of Clapham Junction railway station in London, England, and subsequently sideswiped an empty train travelling in the opposite direction. A total of 35 people died in the collision, while 484 were injured.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Breckland line</span> Railway line in England

    The Breckland line is a secondary railway line in the east of England that links Cambridge in the west to Norwich in the east. The line runs through three counties: Cambridgeshire, Suffolk and Norfolk. It takes its name from the Breckland region of Norfolk and passes through Thetford Forest.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Stafford railway station</span> Railway station in Staffordshire, England

    Stafford railway station is a major interchange railway station in Stafford, Staffordshire, England, and is the second busiest railway station in Staffordshire, after Stoke-on-Trent. The station serves the county town, as well as surrounding villages. The station lies on the junction of the Trent Valley line, the Birmingham Loop/Rugby–Birmingham–Stafford line, and the West Coast Main Line.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Harrow and Wealdstone rail crash</span> 1952 train wreck in Wealdstone, England

    The Harrow and Wealdstone rail crash was a three-train collision at Harrow and Wealdstone station in Wealdstone, Middlesex during the morning rush hour of 8 October 1952. The crash resulted in 112 deaths and 340 injuries, 88 of these being detained in hospital. It remains the worst peacetime rail crash in British history and the second deadliest overall after the Quintinshill rail disaster of 1915.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">UK railway signalling</span> Rail traffic control systems used in the United Kingdom

    The railway signalling system used across the majority of the United Kingdom rail network uses lineside signals to control the movement and speed of trains.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Cheadle Hulme railway station</span> Railway station in Cheadle Hulme, Greater Manchester

    Cheadle Hulme railway station is a station in Cheadle Hulme, Greater Manchester, England. It is operated by Northern Trains.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Penistone rail accidents</span> List of rail accidents in Penistone South Yorkshire, England

    Over the latter years of the 19th and early years of the 20th centuries, Penistone in Yorkshire gained a name as an accident black-spot on Britain's railway network; indeed, it could be said to hold the title of the worst accident black-spot in the country. The main line through the town was the Woodhead route of the Manchester, Sheffield and Lincolnshire Railway between Sheffield Victoria and Manchester, London Road. The line was heavily graded with a summit some 400 yards inside the eastern portal of the Woodhead tunnel.

    Norton Bridge is a village in Staffordshire, England. Until May 2004 it was served by Norton Bridge railway station.

    The Bourne End rail crash occurred on 30 September 1945 when a sleeper train from Perth to London Euston derailed, killing 43. The cause was driver error, possibly compounded by ambiguous signalling regulations.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Stafford–Manchester line</span>

    The Stafford–Manchester line is a major railway line branching from the West Coast Main Line serving Stafford, Stone, Stoke-on-Trent, Kidsgrove, Congleton, Macclesfield, Cheadle Hulme, Stockport and Manchester.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Spa Road Junction rail crash</span>

    The Spa Road Junction rail crash was an accident on the British railway system which occurred during the peak evening rush hour of 8 January 1999 at Spa Road Junction in Bermondsey, in South East London.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Trent Valley line</span>

    The Trent Valley line is a railway line between Rugby and Stafford in England, forming part of the West Coast Main Line. It is named after the River Trent which it follows. The line is 51 miles (82 km) long between Rugby and Stafford, and was built to provide a direct route from London to North West England and Scotland, and avoid the slower route between Rugby and Stafford via Birmingham, which is congested, and 7.75 miles (12.47 km) longer.

    Weaver Junction is a railway junction connecting the West Coast Main Line (WCML) with the Weaver Junction–Liverpool line, opening on 1 April 1869. Trains bound for Liverpool from London diverge from the WCML at this junction. Weaver Junction is the oldest flying junction in Britain, and also the world.

    Colwich Junction is a rail junction near the village of Little Haywood, in the county of Staffordshire, England. It is the junction between two routes of the West Coast Main Line: the Trent Valley line and the Stone to Colwich cutoff line. The junction was the site of the 1986 Colwich rail crash.

    The Warrington rail crash occurred at Walton Junction just south of the town of Warrington in Lancashire on 29 June 1867. The collision involved a passenger train running into the back of a coal train. Eight people were killed and 33 injured. The accident resulted in changes being made to the management of points and signals.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Colwich–Stone line</span>

    The Stone to Colwich Line is a 11.7 miles (18.8 km) long railway line in Staffordshire which serves as a cut-off for West Coast Main Line services to Manchester Piccadilly. This route goes direct from Rugeley Trent Valley to Stoke-on-Trent, not going via Stafford.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Coppenhall Junction railway accident</span> 1962 disaster in the United Kingdom

    On the evening of 26 December 1962, cold weather and snow in and around Crewe had caused points to become frozen and trains were being detained at signals. About midway between Winsford and Crewe, the 13:30 Glasgow Central to London Euston Mid-Day Scot, hauled by an English Electric type 4 diesel, D215, with 13 coaches and 500 passengers, was stopped at a signal but the driver found the telephone to Coppenhall Junction, the next signal box ahead, out of order. Seeing the next signal ahead he decided to proceed down towards it and use the telephone there, but too fast. In the darkness he failed to notice the 16:45 express from Liverpool Lime Street to Birmingham New Street, hauled by an electric locomotive with eight coaches with 300 passengers, standing on the line ahead and collided with it at about 20 mph (32 km/h).

    References

    1. "Engineer dies in rail crash". The Vincennes Sun-Commercial. Vincennes, Indiana. Associated Press. 21 September 1986. p. 10 via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
    2. "Online Rulebook - Module: Signals, handsignals, indicators and signs Handbook - Section 2.5 (Flashing Yellow Aspects)" (PDF). RSSB. Archived from the original (PDF) on 5 December 2016. Retrieved 7 June 2016.
    3. Hoyland, Paul (24 September 1986). "Cause of fatal rail collision is known says BR". The Guardian. London. p. 2 via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
    4. "Nicaragua's ambassador hurt in crash". Clarion-Ledger. Jackson, Mississippi. Associated Press. 21 September 1986. p. 12 via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
    5. Ministry of Transport & Olver 1988, p. 9.
    6. "I prayed to stop train crash - rail man". Evening Standard. London. 23 October 1986. p. 5 via Newspapers.com. The inquiry heard that the driver of the Manchester train told another railwayman minutes after the crash 'I had the flashing yellows.' Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
    7. Ministry of Transport & Olver 1988, pp. 9–10.
    8. Hall, Stanley (1987). Danger Signals: an investigation into modern railway accidents. Ian Allan. ISBN   0-7110-1704-2.
    9. Vaughan, Adrian (2003). Tracks to Disaster. Hersham: Ian Allan. pp. 48–49. ISBN   0-7110-2985-7.
    10. Hall, Stanley (2003). Beyond Hidden Dangers: Railway Safety into the 21st Century. Ian Allan. ISBN   0-7110-2915-6.
    11. "Village remembers horrific train crash". ICStafford. Trinity Mirror Midlands Limited. 12 September 2006. Archived from the original on 29 September 2011.
    12. "Crewe train crash victim remembered with street naming". Crewe Chronicle. 20 May 2023.

    52°47′18″N1°59′16″W / 52.78833°N 1.98778°W / 52.78833; -1.98778