Data breach

Last updated

A data breach, also known as data leakage, is "the unauthorized exposure, disclosure, or loss of personal information". [1]

Contents

Attackers have a variety of motives, from financial gain to political activism, political repression, and espionage. There are several technical root causes of data breaches, including accidental or intentional disclosure of information by insiders, loss or theft of unencrypted devices, hacking into a system by exploiting software vulnerabilities, and social engineering attacks such as phishing where insiders are tricked into disclosing information. Although prevention efforts by the company holding the data can reduce the risk of data breach, it cannot bring it to zero.

The first reported breach was in 2002 and the number occurring each year has grown since then. A large number of data breaches are never detected. If a breach is made known to the company holding the data, post-breach efforts commonly include containing the breach, investigating its scope and cause, and notifications to people whose records were compromised, as required by law in many jurisdictions. Law enforcement agencies may investigate breaches, although the hackers responsible are rarely caught.

Many criminals sell data obtained in breaches on the dark web. Thus, people whose personal data was compromised are at elevated risk of identity theft for years afterwards and a significant number will become victims of this crime. Data breach notification laws in many jurisdictions, including all states of the United States and European Union member states, require the notification of people whose data has been breached. Lawsuits against the company that was breached are common, although few victims receive money from them. There is little empirical evidence of economic harm to firms from breaches except the direct cost, although there is some evidence suggesting a temporary, short-term decline in stock price.

Definition

A data breach is a violation of "organizational, regulatory, legislative or contractual" law or policy [2] that causes "the unauthorized exposure, disclosure, or loss of personal information". [1] Legal and contractual definitions vary. [3] [2] Some researchers include other types of information, for example intellectual property or classified information. [4] However, companies mostly disclose breaches because it is required by law, [5] and only personal information is covered by data breach notification laws. [6] [7]

Prevalence

The first reported data breach occurred on 5 April 2002 [8] when 250,000 social security numbers collected by the State of California were stolen from a data center. [9] Before the widespread adoption of data breach notification laws around 2005, the prevalence of data breaches is difficult to determine. Even afterwards, statistics per year cannot be relied on because data breaches may be reported years after they occurred, [10] or not reported at all. [11] Nevertheless, the statistics show a continued increase in the number and severity of data breaches that continues as of 2022. [12] In 2016, researcher Sasha Romanosky estimated that data breaches (excluding phishing) outnumbered other security breaches by a factor of four. [13]

Perpetrators

According to a 2020 estimate, 55 percent of data breaches were caused by organized crime, 10 percent by system administrators, 10 percent by end users such as customers or employees, and 10 percent by states or state-affiliated actors. [14] Opportunistic criminals may cause data breaches—often using malware or social engineering attacks, but they will typically move on if the security is above average. More organized criminals have more resources and are more focused in their targeting of particular data. [15] Both of them sell the information they obtain for financial gain. [16] Another source of data breaches are politically motivated hackers, for example Anonymous, that target particular objectives. [17] State-sponsored hackers target either citizens of their country or foreign entities, for such purposes as political repression and espionage. Often they use undisclosed zero-day vulnerabilities for which the hackers are paid large sums of money. [18] The Pegasus spyware—a no-click malware developed by the Israeli company NSO Group that can be installed on most cellphones and spies on the users' activity—has drawn attention both for use against criminals such as drug kingpin El Chapo as well as political dissidents, facilitating the murder of Jamal Khashoggi. [19]

Causes

Technical causes

Despite developers' goal of delivering a product that works entirely as intended, virtually all software and hardware contains bugs. [20] If a bug creates a security risk, it is called a vulnerability. [21] [22] [23] Patches are often released to fix identified vulnerabilities, but those that remain unknown (zero days) as well as those that have not been patched are still liable for exploitation. [24] Both software written by the target of the breach and third party software used by them are vulnerable to attack. [22] The software vendor is rarely legally liable for the cost of breaches, thus creating an incentive to make cheaper but less secure software. [25]

Vulnerabilities vary in their ability to be exploited by malicious actors. The most valuable allow the attacker to inject and run their own code (called malware), without the user being aware of it. [21] Some malware is downloaded by users via clicking on a malicious link, but it is also possible for malicious web applications to download malware just from visiting the website (drive-by download). Keyloggers, a type of malware that records a user's keystrokes, are often used in data breaches. [26] The majority of data breaches could have been averted by storing all sensitive information in an encrypted format. That way, physical possession of the storage device or access to encrypted information is useless unless the attacker has the encryption key. [27] Hashing is also a good solution for keeping passwords safe from brute-force attacks, but only if the algorithm is sufficiently secure. [28]

Many data breaches occur on the hardware operated by a partner of the organization targeted—including the 2013 Target data breach and 2014 JPMorgan Chase data breach. [29] Outsourcing work to a third party leads to a risk of data breach if that company has lower security standards; in particular, small companies often lack the resources to take as many security precautions. [30] [29] As a result, outsourcing agreements often include security guarantees and provisions for what happens in the event of a data breach. [30]

Human causes

Human causes of breach are often based on trust of another actor that turns out to be malicious. Social engineering attacks rely on tricking an insider into doing something that compromises the system's security, such as revealing a password or clicking a link to download malware. [31] Data breaches may also be deliberately caused by insiders. [32] One type of social engineering, phishing, [31] obtains a user's credentials by sending them a malicious message impersonating a legitimate entity, such as a bank, and getting the user to enter their credentials onto a malicious website controlled by the cybercriminal. Two-factor authentication can prevent the malicious actor from using the credentials. [33] Training employees to recognize social engineering is another common strategy. [34]

Another source of breaches is accidental disclosure of information, for example publishing information that should be kept private. [35] [36] With the increase in remote work and bring your own device policies, large amounts of corporate data is stored on personal devices of employees. Via carelessness or disregard of company security policies, these devices can be lost or stolen. [37] Technical solutions can prevent many causes of human error, such as encrypting all sensitive data, preventing employees from using insecure passwords, installing antivirus software to prevent malware, and implementing a robust patching system to ensure that all devices are kept up to date. [38]

Breach lifecycle

Prevention

Although attention to security can reduce the risk of data breach, it cannot bring it to zero. Security is not the only priority of organizations, and an attempt to achieve perfect security would make the technology unusable. [39] Many companies hire a chief information security officer (CISO) to oversee the company's information security strategy. [40] To obtain information about potential threats, security professionals will network with each other and share information with other organizations facing similar threats. [41] Defense measures can include an updated incident response strategy, contracts with digital forensics firms that could investigate a breach, [42] cyber insurance, [43] [7] and monitoring the dark web for stolen credentials of employees. [44] In 2024, the United States National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) issued a special publication, "Data Confidentiality: Identifying and Protecting Assets Against Data Breaches". [45] The NIST Cybersecurity Framework also contains information about data protection. [46] Other organizations have released different standards for data protection. [47]

The architecture of a company's systems plays a key role in deterring attackers. Daswani and Elbayadi recommend having only one means of authentication, [48] avoiding redundant systems, and making the most secure setting default. [49] Defense in depth and distributed privilege (requiring multiple authentications to execute an operation) also can make a system more difficult to hack. [50] Giving employees and software the least amount of access necessary to fulfill their functions (principle of least privilege) limits the likelihood and damage of breaches. [48] [51] Several data breaches were enabled by reliance on security by obscurity; the victims had put access credentials in publicly accessible files. [52] Nevertheless, prioritizing ease of use is also important because otherwise users might circumvent the security systems. [53] Rigorous software testing, including penetration testing, can reduce software vulnerabilities, and must be performed prior to each release even if the company is using a continuous integration/continuous deployment model where new versions are constantly being rolled out. [54]

The principle of least persistence [55] —avoiding the collection of data that is not necessary and destruction of data that is no longer necessary—can mitigate the harm from breaches. [56] [57] [58] The challenge is that destroying data can be more complex with modern database systems. [59]

Response

A large number of data breaches are never detected. [60] Of those that are, most breaches are detected by third parties; [61] [62] others are detected by employees or automated systems. [63] Responding to breaches is often the responsibility of a dedicated computer security incident response team, often including technical experts, public relations, and legal counsel. [64] [65] Many companies do not have sufficient expertise in-house, and subcontract some of these roles; [66] often, these outside resources are provided by the cyber insurance policy. [67] After a data breach becomes known to the company, the next steps typically include confirming it occurred, notifying the response team, and attempting to contain the damage. [68]

To stop exfiltration of data, common strategies include shutting down affected servers, taking them offline, patching the vulnerability, and rebuilding. [69] Once the exact way that the data was compromised is identified, there is typically only one or two technical vulnerabilities that need to be addressed in order to contain the breach and prevent it from reoccurring. [70] A penetration test can then verify that the fix is working as expected. [71] If malware is involved, the organization must investigate and close all infiltration and exfiltration vectors, as well as locate and remove all malware from its systems. [72] If data was posted on the dark web, companies may attempt to have it taken down. [73] Containing the breach can compromise investigation, and some tactics (such as shutting down servers) can violate the company's contractual obligations. [74]

Gathering data about the breach can facilitate later litigation or criminal prosecution, [75] but only if the data is gathered according to legal standards and the chain of custody is maintained. [76] Database forensics can narrow down the records involved, limiting the scope of the incident. [77] Extensive investigation may be undertaken, which can be even more expensive than litigation. [62] In the United States, breaches may be investigated by government agencies such as the Office for Civil Rights, the United States Department of Health and Human Services, and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). [78] Law enforcement agencies may investigate breaches [79] although the hackers responsible are rarely caught. [80]

Notifications are typically sent out as required by law. [81] Many companies offer free credit monitoring to people affected by a data breach, although only around 5 percent of those eligible take advantage of the service. [82] Issuing new credit cards to consumers, although expensive, is an effective strategy to reduce the risk of credit card fraud. [82] Companies try to restore trust in their business operations and take steps to prevent a breach from reoccurring. [83]

Consequences

For consumers

After a data breach, criminals make money by selling data, such as usernames, passwords, social media or customer loyalty account information, debit and credit card numbers, [16] and personal health information (see medical data breach). [84] Criminals often sell this data on the dark web—parts of the internet where it is difficult to trace users and illicit activity is widespread—using platforms like .onion or I2P. [85] Originating in the 2000s, the dark web, followed by untraceable cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin in the 2010s, made it possible for criminals to sell data obtained in breaches with minimal risk of getting caught, facilitating an increase in hacking. [86] [87] One popular darknet marketplace, Silk Road, was shut down in 2013 and its operators arrested, but several other marketplaces emerged in its place. [88] Telegram is also a popular forum for illegal sales of data. [89]

This information may be used for a variety of purposes, such as spamming, obtaining products with a victim's loyalty or payment information, identity theft, prescription drug fraud, or insurance fraud. [90] The threat of data breach or revealing information obtained in a data breach can be used for extortion. [16]

Consumers may suffer various forms of tangible or intangible harm from the theft of their personal data, or not notice any harm. [91] A significant portion of those affected by a data breach become victims of identity theft. [82] A person's identifying information often circulates on the dark web for years, causing an increased risk of identity theft regardless of remediation efforts. [80] [92] Even if a customer does not end up footing the bill for credit card fraud or identity theft, they have to spend time resolving the situation. [93] [94] Intangible harms include doxxing (publicly revealing someone's personal information), for example medication usage or personal photos. [95]

For organizations

There is little empirical evidence of economic harm from breaches except the direct cost, although there is some evidence suggesting a temporary, short-term decline in stock price. [96] Other impacts on the company can range from lost business, reduced employee productivity due to systems being offline or personnel redirected to working on the breach, [97] resignation or firing of senior executives, [78] reputational damage, [78] [98] and increasing the future cost of auditing or security. [78] Consumer losses from a breach are usually a negative externality for the business. [99] Some experts have argued that the evidence suggests there is not enough direct costs or reputational damage from data breaches to sufficiently incentivize their prevention. [100] [101]

Estimating the cost of data breaches is difficult, both because not all breaches are reported and also because calculating the impact of breaches in financial terms is not straightforward. There are multiple ways of calculating the cost to businesses, especially when it comes to personnel time dedicated to dealing with the breach. [102] Author Kevvie Fowler estimates that more than half the direct cost incurred by companies is in the form of litigation expenses and services provided to affected individuals, with the remaining cost split between notification and detection, including forensics and investigation. He argues that these costs are reduced if the organization has invested in security prior to the breach or has previous experience with breaches. The more data records involved, the more expensive a breach typically will be. [103] In 2016, researcher Sasha Romanosky estimated that while the mean breach cost around the targeted firm $5 million, this figure was inflated by a few highly expensive breaches, and the typical data breach was much less costly, around $200,000. Romanosky estimated the total annual cost to corporations in the United States to be around $10 billion. [104]

Laws

Notification

The law regarding data breaches is often found in legislation to protect privacy more generally, and is dominated by provisions mandating notification when breaches occur. [105] Laws differ greatly in how breaches are defined, [3] what type of information is protected, the deadline for notification, [6] and who has standing to sue if the law is violated. [106] Notification laws increase transparency and provide a reputational incentive for companies to reduce breaches. [107] The cost of notifying the breach can be high if many people were affected and is incurred regardless of the company's responsibility, so it can function like a strict liability fine. [108]

As of 2024, Thomas on Data Breach listed 62 United Nations member states that are covered by data breach notification laws. Some other countries require breach notification in more general data protection laws. [109] Shortly after the first reported data breach in April 2002, California passed a law requiring notification when an individual's personal information was breached. [9] In the United States, notification laws proliferated after the February 2005 ChoicePoint data breach, widely publicized in part because of the large number of people affected (more than 140,000) and also because of outrage that the company initially informed only affected people in California. [110] [111] In 2018, the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) took effect. The GDPR requires notification within 72 hours, with very high fines possible for large companies not in compliance. This regulation also stimulated the tightening of data privacy laws elsewhere. [112] [113] As of 2022, the only United States federal law requiring notification for data breaches is limited to medical data regulated under HIPAA, but all 50 states (since Alabama passed a law in 2018) have their own general data breach notification laws. [113]

Security safeguards

Measures to protect data from a breach are typically absent from the law or vague. [105] Filling this gap is standards required by cyber insurance, which is held by most large companies and functions as de facto regulation. [114] [115] Of the laws that do exist, there are two main approaches—one that prescribes specific standards to follow, and the reasonableness approach. [116] The former is rarely used due to a lack of flexibility and reluctance of legislators to arbitrate technical issues; with the latter approach, the law is vague but specific standards can emerge from case law. [117] Companies often prefer the standards approach for providing greater legal certainty, but they might check all the boxes without providing a secure product. [118] An additional flaw is that the laws are poorly enforced, with penalties often much less than the cost of a breach, and many companies do not follow them. [119]

Litigation

Many class-action lawsuits, derivative suits, and other litigation have been brought after data breaches. [120] They are often settled regardless of the merits of the case due to the high cost of litigation. [121] [122] Even if a settlement is paid, few affected consumers receive any money as it usually is only cents to a few dollars per victim. [78] [122] Legal scholars Daniel J. Solove and Woodrow Hartzog argue that "Litigation has increased the costs of data breaches but has accomplished little else." [123] Plaintiffs often struggle to prove that they suffered harm from a data breach. [123] The contribution of a company's actions to a data breach varies, [119] [124] and likewise the liability for the damage resulting for data breaches is a contested matter. It is disputed what standard should be applied, whether it is strict liability, negligence, or something else. [124]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Software</span> Instructions a computer can execute

Software consists of computer programs that instruct the execution of a computer. Software also includes design documents and specifications.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Computer security</span> Protection of computer systems from information disclosure, theft or damage

Computer security is the protection of computer software, systems and networks from threats that can lead to unauthorized information disclosure, theft or damage to hardware, software, or data, as well as from the disruption or misdirection of the services they provide.

An exploit is a method or piece of code that takes advantage of vulnerabilities in software, applications, networks, operating systems, or hardware, typically for malicious purposes. The term "exploit" derives from the English verb "to exploit," meaning "to use something to one’s own advantage." Exploits are designed to identify flaws, bypass security measures, gain unauthorized access to systems, take control of systems, install malware, or steal sensitive data. While an exploit by itself may not be a malware, it serves as a vehicle for delivering malicious software by breaching security controls.

Malware is any software intentionally designed to cause disruption to a computer, server, client, or computer network, leak private information, gain unauthorized access to information or systems, deprive access to information, or which unknowingly interferes with the user's computer security and privacy. Researchers tend to classify malware into one or more sub-types.

Network security consists of the policies, processes and practices adopted to prevent, detect and monitor unauthorized access, misuse, modification, or denial of a computer network and network-accessible resources. Network security involves the authorization of access to data in a network, which is controlled by the network administrator. Users choose or are assigned an ID and password or other authenticating information that allows them access to information and programs within their authority. Network security covers a variety of computer networks, both public and private, that are used in everyday jobs: conducting transactions and communications among businesses, government agencies and individuals. Networks can be private, such as within a company, and others which might be open to public access. Network security is involved in organizations, enterprises, and other types of institutions. It does as its title explains: it secures the network, as well as protecting and overseeing operations being done. The most common and simple way of protecting a network resource is by assigning it a unique name and a corresponding password.

A black hat is a computer hacker who violates laws or ethical standards for nefarious purposes, such as cybercrime, cyberwarfare, or malice. These acts can range from piracy to identity theft. A Black hat is often referred to as a "cracker".

Vulnerabilities are flaws in a computer system that weaken the overall security of the system.

Data security means protecting digital data, such as those in a database, from destructive forces and from the unwanted actions of unauthorized users, such as a cyberattack or a data breach.

Crimeware is a class of malware designed specifically to automate cybercrime.

Security controls or security measures are safeguards or countermeasures to avoid, detect, counteract, or minimize security risks to physical property, information, computer systems, or other assets. In the field of information security, such controls protect the confidentiality, integrity and availability of information.

Security breach notification laws or data breach notification laws are laws that require individuals or entities affected by a data breach, unauthorized access to data, to notify their customers and other parties about the breach, as well as take specific steps to remedy the situation based on state legislature. Data breach notification laws have two main goals. The first goal is to allow individuals a chance to mitigate risks against data breaches. The second goal is to promote company incentive to strengthen data security.Together, these goals work to minimize consumer harm from data breaches, including impersonation, fraud, and identity theft.

A zero-day is a vulnerability in software or hardware that is typically unknown to the vendor and for which no patch or other fix is available. The vendor has zero days to prepare a patch as the vulnerability has already been described or exploited.

Cloud computing security or, more simply, cloud security, refers to a broad set of policies, technologies, applications, and controls utilized to protect virtualized IP, data, applications, services, and the associated infrastructure of cloud computing. It is a sub-domain of computer security, network security, and, more broadly, information security.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Malvertising</span> Use of online advertisement or advertising to spread malware

Malvertising is the use of online advertising to spread malware. It typically involves injecting malicious or malware-laden advertisements into legitimate online advertising networks and webpages. Because advertising content can be inserted into high-profile and reputable websites, malvertising provides malefactors an opportunity to push their attacks to web users who might not otherwise see the ads, due to firewalls, more safety precautions, or the like. Malvertising is "attractive to attackers because they 'can be easily spread across a large number of legitimate websites without directly compromising those websites'."

In computer security, a threat is a potential negative action or event enabled by a vulnerability that results in an unwanted impact to a computer system or application.

Browser security is the application of Internet security to web browsers in order to protect networked data and computer systems from breaches of privacy or malware. Security exploits of browsers often use JavaScript, sometimes with cross-site scripting (XSS) with a secondary payload using Adobe Flash. Security exploits can also take advantage of vulnerabilities that are commonly exploited in all browsers.

A cyberattack occurs when there is an unauthorized action against computer infrastructure that compromises the confidentiality, integrity, or availability of its content.

Endpoint security or endpoint protection is an approach to the protection of computer networks that are remotely bridged to client devices. The connection of endpoint devices such as laptops, tablets, mobile phones, and other wireless devices to corporate networks creates attack paths for security threats. Endpoint security attempts to ensure that such devices follow compliance to standards.

Cyber threat hunting is a proactive cyber defence activity. It is "the process of proactively and iteratively searching through networks to detect and isolate advanced threats that evade existing security solutions." This is in contrast to traditional threat management measures, such as firewalls, intrusion detection systems (IDS), malware sandbox and SIEM systems, which typically involve an investigation of evidence-based data after there has been a warning of a potential threat. Threat analyst Lesley Carhart stated that there is no consensus amongst practitioners what threat hunting actually entails.

Data center security is the set of policies, precautions and practices adopted at a data center to avoid unauthorized access and manipulation of its resources. The data center houses the enterprise applications and data, hence why providing a proper security system is critical. Denial of service (DoS), theft of confidential information, data alteration, and data loss are some of the common security problems afflicting data center environments.

References

  1. 1 2 Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 5.
  2. 1 2 Fowler 2016, p. 2.
  3. 1 2 Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 41.
  4. ↑ Shukla et al. 2022, pp. 47–48.
  5. ↑ National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 18.
  6. 1 2 Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 42.
  7. 1 2 Fowler 2016, p. 45.
  8. ↑ Joerling 2010, p. 468 fn 7.
  9. 1 2 Lesemann 2010, p. 206.
  10. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 18.
  11. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 29.
  12. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, pp. 17–18.
  13. ↑ National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 9.
  14. ↑ Crawley 2021, p. 46.
  15. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 7–8.
  16. 1 2 3 Fowler 2016, p. 13.
  17. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 9–10.
  18. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 10–11.
  19. ↑ Kaster & Ensign 2023, p. 355.
  20. ↑ Ablon & Bogart 2017, p. 1.
  21. 1 2 Ablon & Bogart 2017, p. 2.
  22. 1 2 Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, p. 25.
  23. ↑ Seaman 2020, pp. 47–48.
  24. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 26–27.
  25. ↑ Sloan & Warner 2019, pp. 104–105.
  26. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, p. 19–22.
  27. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, p. 15.
  28. ↑ Ntantogian, Malliaros & Xenakis 2019.
  29. 1 2 Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 22–23.
  30. 1 2 Fowler 2016, pp. 19–20.
  31. 1 2 Sloan & Warner 2019, p. 94.
  32. ↑ Makridis 2021, p. 3.
  33. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 16–19.
  34. ↑ Sloan & Warner 2019, pp. 106–107.
  35. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, p. 28.
  36. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 19.
  37. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 18–19.
  38. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 31–32.
  39. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, pp. 69–70.
  40. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 7, 9–10.
  41. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 200–201.
  42. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 203–204.
  43. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, p. 205.
  44. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 206–207.
  45. ↑ Fisher et al. 2024, Title page.
  46. ↑ Fisher et al. 2024, p. 2.
  47. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 210.
  48. 1 2 Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, p. 217.
  49. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 215–216.
  50. ↑ Tjoa et al. 2024, p. 14.
  51. ↑ Lenhard 2022, p. 53.
  52. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, p. 218.
  53. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 218–219.
  54. ↑ Daswani & Elbayadi 2021, pp. 314–315.
  55. ↑ Tjoa et al. 2024, p. 68.
  56. ↑ Lenhard 2022, p. 60.
  57. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 184.
  58. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 146.
  59. ↑ Tjoa et al. 2024, p. 69.
  60. ↑ Crawley 2021, p. 39.
  61. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 64.
  62. 1 2 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 25.
  63. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 4.
  64. ↑ Crawley 2021, p. 97.
  65. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 5, 32.
  66. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 86.
  67. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 94.
  68. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 4–5.
  69. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 120–122.
  70. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 115.
  71. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 116.
  72. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 117–118.
  73. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 119.
  74. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 124.
  75. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 81–82.
  76. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 83.
  77. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 128.
  78. 1 2 3 4 5 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 22.
  79. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 44.
  80. 1 2 Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 58.
  81. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 5, 44.
  82. 1 2 3 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 13.
  83. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 5–6.
  84. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 14.
  85. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 12–13.
  86. ↑ Davidoff 2019, "Modern dark data brokers".
  87. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 21.
  88. ↑ Howell, Christian Jordan; Maimon, David (2 December 2022). "Darknet markets generate millions in revenue selling stolen personal data, supply chain study finds". The Conversation . Retrieved 22 April 2024.
  89. ↑ Garkava, Taisiia; Moneva, Asier; Leukfeldt, E. Rutger (2024). "Stolen data markets on Telegram: A crime script analysis and situational crime prevention measures". Trends in Organized Crime. doi:10.1007/s12117-024-09532-6.
  90. ↑ Fowler 2016, pp. 13–14.
  91. ↑ National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 27.
  92. ↑ National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, pp. 30–31.
  93. ↑ National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 29.
  94. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 56.
  95. ↑ National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, pp. 27–29.
  96. ↑ Makridis 2021, p. 1.
  97. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 22.
  98. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 41.
  99. ↑ Sloan & Warner 2019, p. 104.
  100. ↑ Makridis 2021, pp. 1, 7.
  101. ↑ Sloan & Warner 2019, p. 64.
  102. ↑ National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, pp. 8–10.
  103. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 21.
  104. ↑ National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 10.
  105. 1 2 Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 10.
  106. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 43.
  107. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 44.
  108. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 45.
  109. ↑ Thomas 2023, pp. xxvii, xxix, xxxii–xxxiii, xxxiv.
  110. ↑ Lesemann 2010, pp. 206–207.
  111. ↑ Joerling 2010, pp. 468–469.
  112. ↑ Seaman 2020, pp. 6–7.
  113. 1 2 Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 40.
  114. ↑ National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 24.
  115. ↑ Talesh 2018, p. 237.
  116. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 48.
  117. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, pp. 48–49.
  118. ↑ Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 52.
  119. 1 2 Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 53.
  120. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 5.
  121. ↑ Fowler 2016, p. 222.
  122. 1 2 Solove & Hartzog 2022, pp. 55, 59.
  123. 1 2 Solove & Hartzog 2022, p. 55.
  124. 1 2 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2016, p. 23.

Sources

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.