Fife Scottish

This article is about the business formed in 1985 after the restructuring of its parent company. For its predecessor which also traded as "Fife Scottish" after 1978, see W. Alexander & Sons (Fife) Ltd.

Fife Scottish Omnibuses Ltd.

Preserved Fife Scottish Northern Counties bodied Leyland Olympian in Aberhill in February 2015
Parent	Scottish Bus Group
Founded	1978;46 years ago (1978)
Defunct	July 1991;32 years ago (1991-07)
Headquarters	Kirkcaldy, Fife, Scotland
Service area	Fife Tayside
Service type	Bus and coach
Depots	7 (February 1991)
Fleet	300 (February 1991)

Fife Scottish Omnibuses Ltd was a former bus operating subsidiary of the Scottish Bus Group, formed in June 1985 from Walter Alexander & Sons (Fife) Ltd in preparation for bus deregulation and the subsequent privatisation of the Scottish Bus Group. The company today trades as part of Stagecoach East Scotland.

History

Fife Scottish's origins can be traced back to 1909, where after numerous buyouts and mergers, the company became part of W. Alexander & Sons. ^[1] In 1961, Walter Alexander & Sons was split into three separate companies, with the Fife operations becoming Alexanders (Fife), ^[2] the colour red being used as the main fleet colour. Alexanders (Fife) was included with the purchase of W. Alexander & Sons by Scottish Motor Traction, which following the passage of the Transport Act 1968, would merge with other bus operators to form the Scottish Bus Group (SBG) on 1 January 1969. ^[3]

Fife Scottish was first created by the SBG in 1978 as part of the rebranding of the Alexanders (Fife) operation. The company would retain the red and cream livery as well as the Alexanders (Fife) legal address, however it would adopt a group standard logo consisting of three-quarters of a blue saltire between the words 'Fife' and 'Scottish'. ^[4] From its head office in Kirkcaldy, Fife Scottish operated throughout the ancient kingdom and beyond to Dundee and Edinburgh as the largest bus operator in the region, being responsible for urban, rural and interurban services in towns such as St Andrews, Dunfermline, Cowdenbeath, Glenrothes and Leven. Fife Scottish also provided coaches for Scottish Citylink services, which were operated mainly from Fife to other destinations across Scotland.

In preparation for the deregulation of the bus industry on 26 October 1986, which would ultimately see the breakup of the Scottish Bus Group, Fife Scottish Omnibuses Ltd. was created amid the reorganisation of all SBG subsidiaries. ^[5] Fife Scottish was the only SBG subsidiary to survive the reorganisation without losing any of its operating areas to the four new companies formed by the SBG, although it did not again any operating area from any pre-existing subsidiaries. ^[6] The SBG corporate fleet name style was retained, albeit printed in an unusually large size and placed on buses painted with larger areas of cream.

Although Fife Scottish did not expand into the nearby cities of Edinburgh and Dundee following deregulation, the company still endured competition within its operating area. Rennie's of Dunfermline were the first challengers to Fife Scottish, however the largest and most sustained competition came from local coach operator Moffat & Williamson, who built up a substantial network of services throughout much of Fife that mirrored Fife Scottish's network. A "bus war" would break out in Fife between Fife Scottish, Rennie's and Moffatt & Wilson, however Rennies would soon withdraw from Dunfermline while Moffat & Williamson would scale back its operations, though still retaining pockets of strong competition in the industrialised towns in the south of Fife.^{[ citation needed ]}

Stagecoach sale controversy

Despite enduring heavy competition, Fife Scottish remained the most profitable of the SBG subsidiaries throughout the SBG's gradual breakup. When the company was put on the market in February 1991 as the penultimate SBG subsidiary to be sold, ^{[7] [8]} Fife Scottish was seen by potential buyers^{[ who? ]} as the 'jewel in the crown' of the formerly state-owned bus group.^{[ citation needed ]} Competitive bids were placed to buy the company, with Fife Scottish's employees led by managing director Derek Stuart offering to perform either a management buyout or an employee share ownership plan as 'Henjac 171', while fast-growing Perth independent Stagecoach Holdings, who had already purchased former SBG subsidiary Bluebird Northern, also placed a bid to buy the company outright. Stagecoach was initially announced as the preferred bidder for Fife Scottish, however the sale would be delayed after the Henjac team submitted a £9 million (equivalent to £20,555,000in 2021) bid rivalling Stagecoach's, forcing Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Scotland James Douglas-Hamilton to launch a review of the sale. ^[9]

For six weeks between late May and July 1991, the Henjac employee team and Stagecoach Holdings would compete with one another, placing revised bids. Following an initial judicial review, Secretary of State for Scotland Ian Lang announced that he would back Stagecoach's bid for the company, ^[10] causing outcry amid claims the Henjac bid was higher than Stagecoach's. ^{[11] [12]} The Henjac team would go to the Court of Session in Edinburgh in an attempt to make Ian Lang reconsider his views on Staegcoach's bid, and although an appeal for an interim interdict was rejected, the sale to Stagecoach would be blocked when the Scottish Transport Group agreed not to sell Fife Scottish to Stagecoach Holdings until the hearing into the sale was concluded. ^{[13] [14]} Despite three of four of Fife Scottish's senior managers withdrawing from the Henjac team in July 1991 as a result of a disagreement over a proposed share structure, ^[15] a bid to throw out Henjac's case was rejected by the Court of Session. ^[16] However, it was subsequently ruled by Lord Coulsfield that no grounds had been established by Henjac to justify a judicial review of Ian Lang's decision, ^[17] and ultimately, Fife Scottish would be purchased by Stagecoach Holdings for £9.1 million (equivalent to £20,784,000in 2021). ^[18]

Following the sale, Stagecoach would engage in increasingly severe competition with Moffat & Williamson following the purchase of Fife Scottish, which was criticised for being predatory and uncompetitive, ^[19] and a loss-making Moffat & Williamson would be forced to withdraw the majority of its competing services despite Stagecoach being reprimanded by the Office of Fair Trading. ^[20] This would result in Stagecoach Fife Scottish becoming the sole operator in much of the kingdom.

References

1. Brochie, Allan W. (1990). Fife's trams and buses. N.B. Traction Group. ISBN   0-905069-27-7.
2. "Scottish Omnibuses Reorganization". The Commercial Motor . Temple Press. 12 May 1961. p. 37. Retrieved 2 March 2024.
3. Taylor, Ashley (7 November 1969). "State control - but local management". Commercial Motor. Temple Press. pp. 114–129. Retrieved 2 March 2024.
4. Burt, Walter (15 July 2012). Fife Buses: From Alexanders (Fife) to Stagecoach. Stroud: Amberley Publishing. ISBN   978-1-4456-0992-8 . Retrieved 2 March 2024.
5. "All change for SBG companies". Commercial Motor. Temple Press. 3 November 1984. p. 21. Retrieved 2 March 2024.
6. "Scots add four". Commercial Motor. Temple Press. 20 October 1984. p. 28. Retrieved 2 March 2024. The existing Northern, Eastern, Highland and Western companies will lose territory, and the Fife company will remain unaltered.
7. "Fife Scottish goes up for grabs". Commercial Motor. Temple Press. 14 February 1991. p. 22. Retrieved 2 March 2024.
8. "Fife Scottish for sale". Bus & Coach Buyer. No. 91. Spalding. 8 February 1991. p. 1. Retrieved 3 April 2024.
9. "Stagecoach bid stalled". Perthshire Advertiser . Perth. 31 May 1991. p. 22. Retrieved 2 March 2024– via Newspapers.com.
10. "Stagecoach bid for Fife Scottish is now backed by Government". Coachmart. No. 643. Peterborough: Emap. 13 June 1991. p. 8.
11. Dow, Ian (11 June 1991). "It's war on the buses". Daily Record . Glasgow. p. 2. Retrieved 2 March 2024– via Newspapers.com.
12. "Stagecoach take over Fife bus company". Perthshire Advertiser. Perth. 14 June 1991. p. 11. Retrieved 2 March 2024– via Newspapers.com.
13. "Bus workers halt firm's sale". Daily Record. Glasgow. 17 June 1991. p. 5. Retrieved 2 March 2024– via Newspapers.com.
14. "Fife team fights on as Stagecoach bids". Commercial Motor. Temple Press. 20 June 1991. p. 23. Retrieved 2 March 2024.
15. "Scottish consortium heads for Highland". Commercial Motor. Temple Press. 11 July 1991. p. 13. Retrieved 2 March 2024.
16. "Judge lets busmen fight on". Daily Record. Glasgow. 11 July 1991. p. 14. Retrieved 2 March 2024– via Newspapers.com.
17. "End of road for Fife bus bid". Perthshire Advertiser. Perth. 16 July 1991. p. 4. Retrieved 2 March 2024– via Newspapers.com.
18. "Stagecoach wins Fife Scottish". Coachmart. No. 648. Kingston upon Hull. 18 July 1991. p. 6.
19. "SBG sell-off was bad for public - MP". Coach & Bus Week . No. 24. Peterborough: Emap. 1 August 1992. p. 3.
20. Cooper, Glenda (24 December 1995). "Stagecoach set record of shameful record of shame" . The Independent. London. Retrieved 2 March 2024.