Metropolitan Council (Minnesota)

Last updated

Metropolitan Council
Metro Council logo.png
Agency overview
Formed1967 (1967)
Type Regional government and Metropolitan planning organization
Jurisdiction Twin Cities
Agency executive
  • Charlie Zelle, Chair
Website www.metrocouncil.org
Map
Metropolitan Council (cropped).svg
Counties of the Metropolitan Council

The Metropolitan Council, commonly abbreviated Met Council or Metro Council, is the regional governmental agency and metropolitan planning organization in Minnesota serving the Twin Cities seven-county metropolitan area, accounting for over 55 percent of the state's population.

Contents

The Met Council is granted regional authority powers in state statutes by the Minnesota Legislature. These powers are unique in that unlike the Regional Development Commissions they can supersede decisions and actions of local governments. The legislature created the Metro Council to maintain public services, oversee growth of the state's largest metro area and to act as the regional planning organization. Like the Metro in Portland, Oregon, it also administers an urban growth boundary.

The Council's role in the Twin Cities metro area is defined by the necessary regional services it provides and manages. These include public transportation, sewage treatment, regional planning, urban planning for municipalities, forecasting population growth, ensuring adequate affordable housing, maintaining a regional park and trails system, and "provides a framework for regional systems including aviation, transportation, parks and open space, water quality and water management." [1]

The Council has survived multiple reform attempts after being accused of mismanagement and lack of accountability, notably over the construction of the Southwest LRT, though state lawmakers continue to develop plans to remake the Council.

Governance and structure

The counties of the Metropolitan Council are the seven most densely-populated in the state Population density of Minnesota counties (2020).png
The counties of the Metropolitan Council are the seven most densely-populated in the state

The Met Council has 17 members, 16 of whom represent a geographic district in the seven-county area with one chair who serves at large. All members are appointed by the Governor of Minnesota and are reappointed with each new governor in office. [2] The Minnesota Senate may confirm or reject each appointment.

The seven counties in the Council's Twin Cities Metropolitan Area are Anoka, Carver, Dakota, Hennepin, Ramsey, Scott, and Washington counties.

Geographic districts vary in characteristics but were historically drawn by population percentage and the presence of major natural resources. Districts near the downtown core are much smaller while the edge districts encompass large amounts of rural land. For example, District 3 contains almost all of Lake Minnetonka and its tributaries and watershed.

The Met Council employs about 4,300 people, and their wage data are publicly accessible.

Duties

General duties

The Council delivers regional services to communities and the public through these divisions and operating areas:

Tax sharing

The council's most distinctive authority is its ability to tax and share the tax revenue between municipalities through the Minnesota Fiscal Disparities Program. [5] This program, first implemented in 1975, made the Twin Cities region the first region to attempt tax-base sharing in the country. [6] The funds are then largely redistributed back to the localities with lower than average market value of property per capita. [6]

History

In 1967 the Minnesota Legislature created the Metropolitan Council in response to growing issues of septic tank wastewater contamination. [2] At the time, the region consisted of "172 cities, 97 townships, and 76 school districts". [2] The region also faced issues with a deteriorating privately-owned bus system. [2] [7]

Additional acts of the legislature passed in 1974, 1976, and 1994 expanded the role and powers of the Met Council, merging it with transit and waste control commissions to become a unified regional authority. [2] The Met Council also gained the authority to approve or disapprove of municipal development plans and to manage the region's affordable housing programs. [2]

Current efforts are ongoing to transfer responsibility of the METRO Blue Line extension, a light‑rail project connecting Minneapolis to the suburbs of Robbinsdale, Crystal, and Brooklyn Park from the Met Council to Minnesota's Department of Transportation. [8] The council has controversially overseen the almost $3 billion project while it has been delayed an additional four years and as costs rose $450 million to $550 million. [8]

Chairs

ChairTermAppointed by
James L. Hetland Jr. 1967 – 1971 Harold LeVander
Albert Hofstede 1971 – 1973 Wendell Anderson
John E. Boland 1973 – 1979Wendell Anderson
Charles R. Weaver Sr. 1979 – 1982 Al Quie
Gerald J. Isaacs 1983 – 1984 Rudy Perpich
Sandra S. Gardebring 1984 – 1986Rudy Perpich
Steve Keefe 1986 – 1991Rudy Perpich
Mary E. Anderson 1991 – 1992 Arne Carlson
Dottie Rietow 1992 – 1995Arne Carlson
Curtis W. Johnson 1995 – 1999Arne Carlson
Ted Mondale 1999 – 2003 Jesse Ventura
Peter Bell 2003 – 2011 Tim Pawlenty
Susan Haigh 2011 – 2015 Mark Dayton
Adam Duininck 2015 – 2017Mark Dayton
Alene Tchourumoff2017 – 2019Mark Dayton
Nora Slawik2019 – 2020 Tim Walz
Charlie Zelle2020 Tim Walz

Controversy

The Met Council has long raised the ire of suburban residents in the region. [2] For instance, one source of controversy has been the council's power to invalidate the land use plans of municipalities which conflict with its own. [9]

In 2004, the city of Lake Elmo refused to allow higher‑density development despite the Met Council's comprehensive development guide. [10] The city challenged the Council's statutory authority to compel the city to modify its comprehensive plan in order to reach minimum density levels. [11] However, the Minnesota Supreme Court found the city's argument unpersuasive "when viewed against the plain and unambiguous language of the statutes at issue." [11]

Shortly after the 2010 Minnesota elections, Minnesota Legislative Auditor James Nobles recommended on January 21, 2011, that "the Legislature should restructure the governance of the Metropolitan Council" (page 41). [12] The Legislative Auditor continued stating that "Maintaining an appointed Met Council would continue the Council's accountability problems ... Because Council members are appointed by the governor, however, they are not directly accountable to the public for (their) decisions." This lack of credibility and accountability was reported on by newspapers such as the St. Paul Pioneer Press , [13] the Star Tribune , [14] and online editorials like Politics In Minnesota. [15]

An anti-Metropolitan Council bumper sticker in Saint Paul AntiMetCouncil.jpg
An anti-Metropolitan Council bumper sticker in Saint Paul

Marty Seifert, a Republican candidate for governor in the 2014 election, also called for the abolition of the Council, citing it as an unelected authority with taxation powers without representation. [16] However, most of the responsibilities of the Metropolitan Council would still need to be maintained, including a Metropolitan Planning Organization that allows the region to receive federal transportation funding.

Criticisms of the council reached a high point in 2018 when the Met Council survived two attempted reforms at both the state and the federal level. [17]

In late 2023, the Met Council came under fire again with a state legislative committee, the Metropolitan Governance Task Force, tasked with examining reformation, be it through elections or other means. [18] In February 2024, the task force came up with six reformation paths, but the state legislature will need to take further action as warranted. [19]

In May 2024, after years of mounting delays, cost overruns and mismanagement of the Southwest LRT, the Minnesota State Legislature passed a law giving the Minnesota Department of Transportation greater oversight of future transit projects. Transportation-focused State Senator Scott Dibble (politician) sponsored the change, calling the Met Council "incompetent and incapable." [20]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority</span> Public transport agency in Los Angeles County, California, United States

The Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority (LACMTA), branded as Metro, is the county agency that plans, operates, and coordinates funding for most of the public transportation system in Los Angeles County, California, the most populated county in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metro Blue Line (Minnesota)</span> Light rail line in Hennepin County, Minnesota

The Metro Blue Line is a 12-mile (19.3 km) light rail line in Hennepin County, Minnesota, that is part of the Metro network. It travels from downtown Minneapolis to Minneapolis–Saint Paul International Airport and the southern suburb of Bloomington. Formerly the Hiawatha Line prior to May 2013, the line was originally named after the Milwaukee Road's Hiawatha passenger train and Hiawatha Avenue, reusing infrastructure from the former and running parallel to the latter for a portion of the route. The line opened June 26, 2004, and was the first light rail service in Minnesota. An extension, Bottineau LRT, is planned to open in 2028.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Northstar Line</span> Commuter rail route in Minnesota, United States

The Northstar Line is a commuter rail route in the US state of Minnesota. Northstar runs 40 miles (64 km) from Big Lake to downtown Minneapolis at Target Field using existing track and right-of-way owned by the BNSF Railway. Passenger service began on November 16, 2009. The rail line serves part of the Northstar Corridor between Minneapolis and St. Cloud. Planning for the line began in 1997 when the Northstar Corridor Development Authority (NCDA) was formed. The corridor is also served by Interstate 94 and U.S. Highway 10. In 2023, the system had a ridership of 142,200, or about 500 per weekday as of the third quarter of 2024.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metro Transit (Minnesota)</span> Public transit operator in the Twin Cities region of Minnesota

Metro Transit is the primary public transportation operator in the Minneapolis–Saint Paul area of the U.S. state of Minnesota and the largest operator in the state. In 2023, the system had a ridership of 44,977,200, or about 145,300 per weekday as of the third quarter of 2024.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metro Green Line (Minnesota)</span> Light rail transit line in Minnesota, US

The Metro Green Line is an 11-mile (18 km) light rail line that connects the central business districts of Minneapolis and Saint Paul in Minnesota as well as the University of Minnesota. An extension is under construction that will extend the line to the southwest connecting St. Louis Park, Hopkins, Minnetonka and Eden Prairie. The line follows the path of former Metro Transit bus route 16 along University Avenue and Washington Avenue. It is the second light-rail line in the region, after the Blue Line, which opened in 2004 and connects Minneapolis with the southern suburb of Bloomington.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metro (Oregon regional government)</span> Regional government agency

Metro is the regional government for the Oregon portion of the Portland metropolitan area, covering portions of Clackamas, Multnomah, and Washington Counties. It is the only directly elected regional government and metropolitan planning organization in the United States. Metro is responsible for overseeing the Portland region's solid waste system, general planning of land use and transportation, maintaining certain regional parks and natural areas, and operating the Oregon Zoo, Oregon Convention Center, Portland's Centers for the Arts, and the Portland Expo Center. It also distributes money from two voter-approved tax measures: one for homeless services and one for affordable housing.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Southwest LRT</span> Under-construction light rail transit line in Minneapolis

The Southwest LRT is an under–construction 14.5-mile (23.3 km) light rail transit corridor in Hennepin County, Minnesota, with service between Minneapolis and Eden Prairie. The estimated one-way travel time from Southwest Station in Eden Prairie to Target Field Station in Minneapolis is 32 minutes. The Southwest LRT will extend through St. Louis Park, Hopkins and Minnetonka along the route. Major locations on the line will include Bde Maka Ska, Cedar Lake, the Walker Art Center, the Minneapolis Sculpture Garden and Target Field in downtown Minneapolis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transportation in Minnesota</span>

Transportation in the U.S. State of Minnesota consists of a complex network of roadways, railways, waterways and airports. The transportation system is generally overseen by the Minnesota Department of Transportation, a cabinet-level agency of the state government. Additionally, regional governments such as the Metropolitan Council have authority over regional planning for the transportation system and local governments such as cities and counties oversee the local transportation network.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Minnesota Valley Transit Authority</span> Public transportation agency in Minnesota, US

The Minnesota Valley Transit Authority, also known by the acronym MVTA, is a public transportation agency that serves seven communities in the southern portion of the Minneapolis–Saint Paul metropolitan area. The agency provides fixed-route and demand-responsive transit within the service area of the communities and to select destinations in the region.

The Metro Purple Line, formerly known as the Rush Line Corridor, is a proposed bus rapid transit service that would run from Union Depot in downtown Saint Paul to the northeastern suburbs of Saint Paul. Along the corridor's 21 proposed stations there are 106,000 jobs within a 10-minute walk. The project is currently in an environmental analysis phase with further development, engineering, and construction expected to take at least six more years. Service would run 7-days a week with 10-minute headways in peak periods and 15-minute service at most other times. The corridor was named the Rush Line because it was originally planned to end in Rush City, Minnesota. After using the color purple since 2017, the route was officially named the Purple Line and became part of the Metro network on July 14, 2021.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Denver Regional Council of Governments</span>

The Denver Regional Council of Governments is a nonprofit membership organization of local governments in the Denver region of the US state of Colorado. DRCOG is the designated metropolitan planning organization (MPO) and the Transportation Planning Region (TPR) for the region, as well as the Area Agency on Aging (AAA).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metro Red Line (Minnesota)</span> Bus route in Minnesota, United States

The Metro Red Line is a bus rapid transit line between the Twin Cities suburbs of Bloomington, Minnesota and Apple Valley, Minnesota. The Red Line travels primarily on Minnesota State Highway 77 and Cedar Avenue from the Apple Valley station in Apple Valley, north through Eagan, Minnesota, to the Mall of America station in Bloomington where it connects to the Metro Blue Line. The line has bus rapid transit elements including bus-only lanes, specially branded vehicles, transit signal priority, and dedicated stations.

The Bottineau LRT is a proposed light rail line extension in the Minneapolis – Saint Paul Metro area, projected to run northwest from Target Field station in downtown Minneapolis to the communities of North Minneapolis, Robbinsdale, Crystal, and Brooklyn Park.

The Riverview Corridor is a transit corridor connecting Downtown Saint Paul and the Mall of America in Bloomington via the Minneapolis-Saint Paul International Airport. The corridor serves an area from the Saint Paul Union Depot to the Mall via a route along West 7th Street, which runs southwest from Downtown Saint Paul. The corridor creates a triangle connecting opposite ends of the Blue Line and Green Line.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metro Orange Line (Minnesota)</span> Minnesota bus line

The Metro Orange Line is a bus rapid transit line in the Twin Cities, Minnesota operated by Metro Transit. The line operates primarily along Interstate 35W from downtown Minneapolis through Richfield and Bloomington before terminating in Burnsville, Minnesota. The Orange Line provides access to 198,000 jobs with roughly a quarter of them outside downtown Minneapolis. The route serves a mix of stations located in the center of the highway, stations near highway exits, and on-street stations. The line has features typical of bus rapid transit systems with off-board fare payment, articulated buses with extra doors, stations with improved passenger amenities, and transit-only bus lanes on portions of the route.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dan Patch Corridor</span> Commuter rail line in Minnesota

The Dan Patch Corridor is a proposed commuter rail line that would serve a region which runs from Minneapolis to Northfield, Minnesota. The corridor consists of the tracks on the former Minneapolis St. Paul Rochester and Dubuque Electric Traction Company lines, which came to be known as the Dan Patch lines. It was proposed as a passenger rail line in 2000 after being identified as a "Tier One" corridor in the Minnesota Department of Transportation's 2000 Commuter Rail System Plan before being given a study ban during the 2002 Minnesota legislative session. It sat in relative silence until 2008, when bills were introduced in the Minnesota State Legislature to potentially revive discussion. On May 21, 2023, the Minnesota House of Representatives and Minnesota Senate passed an omnibus transit bill that removed the study ban for the Dan Patch line.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metro Gold Line (Minnesota)</span> Future bus rapid transit line in Minnesota

The METRO Gold Line is an under construction bus rapid transit line in Minnesota. The line will travel from its western terminus in downtown Saint Paul, Minnesota to Woodbury, Minnesota. The 10-mile line runs largely along I-94 in bus-only lanes with stops at designated stations. The Gold Line will be the first bus rapid transit project in Minnesota that operates primarily in bus lanes. The project was initially called the Gateway Corridor before being named a color to match the rest of the Metro system operated by Metro Transit.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metro (Minnesota)</span> Rapid transit network in the Minneapolis metropolitan area of the United States

Metro is a transit network in Minnesota serving the cities of Minneapolis and Saint Paul. It also provides service to some suburban areas. As of 2022, the system consists of two light rail lines and five bus rapid transit (BRT) lines all of which are operated by the local public transit company: Metro Transit. The five lines connect Downtown Minneapolis and St Paul with Bloomington, Minneapolis-St Paul International Airport, Roseville, Richfield, Burnsville and Brooklyn Center.

A public transportation benefit area, abbreviated as PTBA, is a type of public-benefit corporation for public transit operators in the U.S. state of Washington. It was authorized in 1975 along with a funding mechanism that uses sales taxes levied within a district. As of 2016, there are 31 PTBAs that cover most of Washington's counties and large cities, with the exception of Seattle.

Regional Development Commissions are regional governments in the U.S. state of Minnesota, made up of a board of local elected officials from counties, cities, schools boards, public interest groups and transit systems that provide cooperation and coordination on broad regional issues. The Regional Development Commissions, commonly abbreviated as RDC, were established by state law in 1969 to provide a variety of governmental assistance to local governments. They are a type of regional planning organization that have responsibility to provide technical assistance to a broad multi-county area of the state, and their functions are similar to the metropolitan planning organization in urbanized areas. As their intent was to support local governments, they frequently provide a coordinating role and generally do not exercise any type of binding authority over local matters.

References

  1. "/ – Metropolitan Council". Metrocouncil.org. April 28, 2017. Retrieved October 29, 2017.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Brendan Ballou, Note, A Future for the Met Council, 12 U. St. Thomas L.J. 131, 131, 135 (2015).
  3. Met Council (February 2006). "Transit centers help attract new riders, boost system efficiency". Archived from the original on November 20, 2008. Retrieved September 21, 2007.
  4. Steven Hauser. "Testing Inter-System Usability of Opt Out Transit Systems and Transportation" . Retrieved September 21, 2007.
  5. See Gerald E. Frug, Beyond Regional Government, 115 Harv. L. Rev. 1763, 1777 (2002) ("Regional revenue sharing, however, is the Minneapolis-St. Paul area's most distinctive metropolitan feature.").
  6. 1 2 Myron Orfield & Nicholas Wallace, The Minnesota Fiscal Disparities Act of 1971: The Twin Cities' Struggle and Blueprint for Regional Cooperation, 33 WM. Mitchell L. Rev. 591, 591–92 (2007).
  7. Susan Haigh, The Metropolitan Council, 40 WM. Mitchell L. Rev. 160, 164 (2013) (stating that the issues consisted of leaking private septic systems in the suburbs, a disintegrating bus system, the loss of environmental assets to development, and tax disparities between municipalities).
  8. 1 2 Janet Moore, Bill Would Transfer Southwest Light‑Rail Project from Met Council to MnDOT, Star Tribune (February 9, 2022, 9:00 PM), https://www.startribune.com/bill-would-transfer-southwest-light-rail-project-from-met-council-to-mndot/600144936/ .
  9. Ballou, supra, at 137.
  10. See Lake Elmo v. Metro. Council, 685 N.W.2d 1, 1 (Minn. 2004) ("The City of Lake Elmo argues that the Council does not have the statutory authority to adopt Resolution 2003‑10 and, therefore, the resolution is not binding upon it.").
  11. 1 2 See Lake Elmo v. Metro. Council, 685 N.W.2d 1, 4–5 (Minn. 2004) ("Because no statutory provision explicitly grants the Council authority to order a city to reach "minimum density levels," Lake Elmo argues that the Council's practice of combining population forecasts with related system plans to dictate housing densities is impermissible and infringes on Lake Elmo's zoning authority in a manner unintended by the legislature.").
  12. http://www.auditor.leg.state.mn.us/ped/pedrep/transit.pdf [ bare URL PDF ]
  13. Hoppin, Jason (January 21, 2011). "Changes to Met Council's makeup urged in legislative auditor's report – Twin Cities". Twincities.com. Retrieved October 29, 2017.
  14. "Ride transit? Go to parks? Use water? Her job affects you". StarTribune.com. April 28, 2015. Retrieved October 29, 2017.
  15. Shaw, Charley (January 21, 2011). "The Paper Trail: Legislative Auditor recommends Met Council reform – Minnesota Lawyer". Politicsinminnesota.com. Retrieved October 29, 2017.
  16. "Seifert to campaign all across Minnesota in governor race". November 26, 2013.
  17. Peter Callaghan, A Bill to Reform the Met Council Will Probably Be Vetoed, MinnPost (May 29, 2019), https://www.minnpost.com/politics-policy/2018/05/bill-reform-met-council-will-probably-be-vetoed-doesnt-mean-lot-people-still/?hilite=met+council (detailing a state bill that would have turned the Met Council into an amalgamation of city and county officials plus an amendment to a federal appropriations bill that would have ended the Met Council's ability to receive federal transportation and planning funds).
  18. Magan, Christopher (December 8, 2023). "Lawmakers urged to let voters pick Met Council members". The Star Tribune . Retrieved July 3, 2024.
  19. Adler, Erin (February 1, 2024). "Group tasked with reforming Met Council offers lawmakers six options". The Star Tribune . Retrieved July 3, 2024.
  20. Moore, Janet (May 29, 2024). "Lawmakers frustrated by delays, cost overruns enlist MnDOT on light-rail project". The Star Tribune . Retrieved July 3, 2024.