Stephen Dorrell

The Right Honourable Stephen Dorrell
Dorrell in 2012
Secretary of State for Health
In office 5 July 1995 –2 May 1997

During the February 1974 general election, Dorrell acted as a personal assistant to Conservative minister Peter Walker. Aged only 22, he contested the safe Labour seat of Kingston upon Hull East at the October 1974 general election, but was heavily defeated by the sitting MP (and later Deputy Prime Minister), John Prescott, who was returned with a majority of 25,793 votes.

At the 1979 general election, the Conservatives were returned to office under the leadership of Margaret Thatcher. Dorrell, then 27, was elected to the House of Commons for the marginal seat of Loughborough, ousting the veteran Labour MP John Cronin by 5,199 votes. He remained an MP until standing down from Parliament at the 2015 General Election.

On his election he was the Baby of the House of Commons , an informal title for the youngest member. He was succeeded as the Baby of the House on 9 April 1981 when Bobby Sands was elected at the April 1981 Fermanagh and South Tyrone by-election; however, Sands died on 5 May 1981 whilst on hunger strike in Long Kesh Prison. Dorrell again became the Baby of the House until 20 August 1981, when Sands' successor Owen Carron was elected at the August 1981 Fermanagh and South Tyrone by-election. He nonetheless remained the youngest MP to take his seat in the House of Commons (Sinn Féin members do not take their seats) until the 1983 election, when Charles Kennedy succeeded him.

Following his election to parliament in 1979 he was a member of the Transport Select committee. After the 1983 general election he was appointed as the Parliamentary Private Secretary to his old boss Peter Walker, who had now become the Secretary of State for Energy.

In government

Dorrell was promoted to government after the 1987 General Election by the Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher as an Assistant Government Whip, and in 1988 became a Lord Commissioner to the Treasury 'full whip'. He was appointed as the Parliamentary Under Secretary of State at the Department of Health in 1990 under the premiership of John Major. After the 1992 General Election he became the Financial Secretary to the Treasury.

Dorrell was promoted to the Major Cabinet as the Secretary of State for National Heritage in 1994, and on appointment became a Member of the Privy Council. He headhunted Jennie Page for the job of Millennium Dome Chief Executive according to The Observer . ^[2] He was transferred to become the Secretary of State for Health in 1995, and remained in position until the end of the Conservative administration at the 1997 general election.

After government

When constituency boundaries were revised for the 1997 election, he moved with his key rural voters into the new Charnwood constituency. He won the seat comfortably with a majority of 5,900, although Loughborough was lost to Andy Reed of Labour. ^[3]

He launched a bid for the leadership of the Conservative Party in 1997, but withdrew before the first ballot when it became clear his support amongst Conservative MPs was negligible. Instead he threw his support behind Kenneth Clarke's bid. Under William Hague he became shadow Secretary of State for Education and Employment, but left the shadow cabinet in 1998, and was a backbencher for the remainder of his parliamentary career.

Chairman of Health Select Committee and views on NHS reforms

In June 2010, Dorrell was elected Chairman of the Health Select Committee. In June 2011, following concerns over the unpopularity of Andrew Lansley's NHS reforms, Dorrell was tipped as a possible successor but stated that he wanted to continue as the committee chairman for the full parliament. ^[4] An alternate view was that David Cameron would not want any more "Tory retreads" from previous governments. ^[4] Dorrell acknowledged that resources would become tighter but changes driven by new medicines and new expectations were inevitable and integration of health care and social care would be both better and more efficient. ^[4]

Interviewed in 2012, Dorrell stated that the 4% per year for four years efficiency targets, agreed before the 2010 election and described as "a huge challenge", were taking too long to achieve. ^[5] Whilst the bill had good points, e.g. involving clinicians and local authorities, more independence for public health etc. savings required a change in the way care is delivered not just changes in management structure. ^[5] The reforms were acting as a "disruption and distraction". ^[5] They were a secondary issue compared with the need to make efficiency savings of £20bn, he added. ^[6]

Dorrell resigned in June 2014 and was succeeded by Sarah Wollaston. ^[7]

Expenses investigation over "secret flat rent deal" with care home owners

In November 2012 Dorrell was reported to the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (IPSA) after arranging to sell his London flat to “friends” who owned a chain of nursing homes, subsequently renting it back at £1,400 a month, funded by the taxpayer. His impartiality as chairman was questioned as the Health Select Committee was investigating social care, and some of the chain's nursing homes had been criticised by the Care Quality Commission. Committee members were not aware of the financial connection. David Cameron refused to get involved, saying it was a matter for IPSA. IPSA said that the rules banned MPs from renting from family members, not from friends. ^[8]

Standing down from Parliament

In November 2014, he surprised local party members and staff by announcing his future retirement from the House to take a job with consultancy KPMG in "a senior role supporting their health and public service practice...". The role, he said, was "incompatible with seeking re-election to the House of Commons". Fellow Leicestershire Conservative MP Andrew Bridgen also expressed surprise, but said that the prestige of Parliament had fallen since the expenses scandal, and a number of experienced MPs were leaving. Neighbouring Loughborough MP Nicky Morgan described him as "a really important political figure in Leicestershire since 1979. He has been a great support to me". She denied claims she would stand in Dorrell's Charnwood seat (rather than Loughborough) at the 2015 general election, saying that these were "rumour-mongering" by members of the Labour Party. (In May 2015 she held the Loughborough seat with an increased majority.)

The Labour candidate for Charnwood, Sean Kelly Walsh, paid tribute to Dorrell's long service and constituency work, as well as his roles as Secretary of State for Health and chairman of the Health Affairs Select Committee. ^[9]

Resignation call over conflict of interest

In December 2014, Dorrell was criticised for alleged conflict of interest when it became clear that he would be working both as an MP and KPMG consultant for six months until the election, and that KPMG were considering bidding for a £1 billion NHS contract. Pointing out that Dorrell had previously admitted the two roles were incompatible, Dr Clive Peedell, co-leader of the National Health Action Party, called for him to resign from one of the posts. Dorrell responded saying no issues were raised as he was not seeking re-election. ^[10]

In January 2015, a group of six pensioners, who called at Dorrell's offices in Thurmaston to hand in a 2,286 signature petition calling on him to resign, were told they were trespassing and the police would be called. Hanif Asmal, Chairman of Charnwood Conservative Association claimed police were called as the group didn't have an appointment. ^[11]

According to The Daily Telegraph , Dorrell's extra-parliamentary work took up 1,736 hours, or 33.4 hours per week, in 2014. ^[12] The Telegraph also stated he voted in 63% of opportunities in Parliament, ranking him 517 out of 650 MPs. ^[13]

Criticisms of business practice

Dorrell was criticised for his actions when, in 2009, his family-owned firm went into a prepack administration, a "controversial" but legal procedure which the Government's Insolvency Service said was "mocking rules". ^[14] David Blake, Director of the Cass Business School in London, believes the method is used to dump pension fund liabilities. ^[15] The controversy may have deterred David Cameron from inviting Dorrell to join the Front Bench. ^[14] His stake was in clothing company, Faithful, a family business established in the 19th century which made blue collar workwear in Worcester. ^[16] Finance Director Steve Hall reported the company had been quite profitable until 2004 when it was split between Dorrell and his brother. ^[16]

By 2005, after loss-making acquisitions, the company pensions deficit was almost £3 million. The pension scheme was changed to money purchase, and the factory site was pledged to support it. ^[16] However, when the site was sold, some of the money was used to buy another business, and the firm was bought by stock market-listed Wensum. ^[16] None of the money was paid into the pension scheme. ^[16] According to Dorrell, the scheme then required 10% of annual turnover, making (debt or equity) restructuring (by financiers) impossible. ^[16] An independent trustee was appointed, the pension fund received nothing and Wensum continued as a company. ^[16] In May 2009, Wensum was put into a prepack administration which allowed a new company, GG125, to acquire Wensum's assets for £7.9 million, whilst leaving its debts unpaid. ^[17]

GG125 was then renamed Wensum Group Limited. ^[17] The deal was completed in a day, Dorrell receiving a director salary (increased to £200,000 in September 2009) plus 15% share ownership in the new company. ^{[16] [18]} As company contributions had ceased, the workers were put into the Pension Protection Fund (PPF), which caps (often reducing) personal payouts and tends to erode with inflation. ^[16] Hall expected 30–40% pension loss to him as such. ^[15] Dorrell and his wife had already withdrawn their pensions. ^[16] Dorrell claimed he had lost £550,000 because of the failure and that the alternative to the prepack would have offered less. ^[14]

The prepack was criticised as "completely immoral", and inappropriate for listed companies, by a South African creditor, LA group. It had sold a clothing manufacturer to Wensum in May 2009 for Wensum shares which became worthless and ceased after the prepack. ^[17] Another Wensum shareholder compared the deal to a "spider eviscerating a fly it has caught, taking all the good bits, then dropping the useless carcass, which is the creditors, the shareholders and of course the taxpayer". ^[14]

After Parliament

He was reckoned by the Health Service Journal to be the 24th most influential person in the English NHS in 2015 after he became Chair of the NHS Confederation. ^[19]

In 2016 he became Chair of the European Movement UK, succeeding Richard Corbett, in order to lead its campaign to stop Brexit. He stood down in 2021.

In 2018, Dorrell became a committee member of the Tories Against Brexit campaign, which is run by Citizens4Britain.org. He also became the chair of healthcare consultancy LaingBuisson, ^[20] where he is now a Non Executive Director ^[21] in addition to being a Director of NHS change consultancy Four Eyes Insight, ^[22] global policy institute Public Policy Projects ^[23] and its holding company Dorson Transform, ^[24] and affiliate Dorson Inform ^[25]

He became a supporter of Change UK in 2019. ^[26] He stood for the party in the 2019 European Parliament elections in the constituency of the West Midlands. ^[27]

Dorrell stood unsuccessfully in the 2019 general election as the Liberal Democrat candidate for Buckingham to succeed former Speaker of the House of Commons John Bercow, having joined the Lib Dems in August from Change UK. ^[28] He was beaten by the Conservative Greg Smith, who had a majority of over 20,000. ^[29]

Personal life

Dorrell is married to Penelope Taylor ^[30] and has three sons and a daughter.

He is a Trustee of Uppingham School and a Governor of Loughborough Endowed Schools. ^[31] He was Chairman of Trustees at Uppingham from 2008 to 2017. ^[32]

References

1. "Stephen Dorrell MP -official constituency website". Archived from the original on 21 October 2012. Retrieved 2 May 2012.
2. Vanessa Thorpe (5 February 2000). "How Dome dreams were dashed". The Observer . Archived from the original on 24 August 2013. Retrieved 31 July 2008.
3. "Andy Reed MP Loughborough, Labour/Co-operative". London: BBC Democracy Live. Retrieved 21 March 2010.
4. John Hess (9 June 2011). "Stephen Dorrell rules out return as Health Secretary". BBC News . Archived from the original on 20 March 2012. Retrieved 1 May 2012.
5. "Stephen Dorrell: NHS faces huge challenge". BBC News . 24 January 2012. Archived from the original on 9 April 2012. Retrieved 1 May 2012.
6. Clare Horton (2 March 2012). "NHS reform debate has lost touch with reality, says Stephen Dorrell". The Guardian . Archived from the original on 8 March 2016. Retrieved 2 May 2012.
7. "Dr Sarah Wollaston elected as health committee chairwoman". BBC News . 18 June 2014. Archived from the original on 1 July 2014. Retrieved 14 July 2014.
8. Christopher Hope (21 November 2012). "MPs' expenses: Stephen Dorrell MP reported to sleaze watchdog over secret flat rent deal". The Daily Telegraph . Archived from the original on 25 October 2014. Retrieved 24 October 2014.
9. danjmartin (25 November 2014). "Conservative Charnwood MP Stephen Dorrell quitting Parliament to join KPMG". Leicester Mercury. Archived from the original on 19 February 2015. Retrieved 26 November 2014.
10. "Stephen Dorrell MP faces calls to resign over conflict of interest". The Daily Telegraph . 1 December 2014. Archived from the original on 3 December 2014. Retrieved 4 December 2014.
11. PA_Warzynski (11 January 2015). "Police called to MP Stephen Dorrell's office to deal with petitioning pensioners". Leicester Mercury. Archived from the original on 15 January 2015. Retrieved 17 January 2015.
12. Lyndsey Telford and Luke Heighton (22 February 2015). "The MPs who topped up their salaries with £1,600-an-hour second jobs". The Daily Telegraph . Archived from the original on 23 February 2015. Retrieved 23 February 2015.
13. Michael Wilkinson. "Election 2015: How active was my MP?". The Daily Telegraph . Archived from the original on 25 April 2015. Retrieved 28 April 2015.
14. Graham Ruddick (21 July 2009). "MP Stephen Dorrell faces backlash over Wensum 'pre-pack'". The Daily Telegraph . Archived from the original on 28 August 2011. Retrieved 1 May 2012.
15. Fran Abrams (9 March 2010). "How firms 'avoid' pension costs". BBC News . Retrieved 1 May 2012.
16. Fran Abrams (14 March 2010). "Pensions crisis". BBC File on 4. Retrieved 1 May 2012.
17. Graham Ruddick (19 September 2009). "Stephen Dorrell criticised over 'immoral' deal". The Daily Telegraph . Archived from the original on 21 April 2012. Retrieved 1 May 2012.
18. Graham Ruddick (27 September 2009). "MP gets pay rise as creditors struggle with £4m debt". The Daily Telegraph . Archived from the original on 12 November 2012. Retrieved 1 May 2012.
19. "HSJ100 2015". Health Service Journal. 23 November 2015. Archived from the original on 24 December 2015. Retrieved 23 December 2015.
20. "LaingBuisson names chairman and CEO". PMLive. 4 July 2016. Archived from the original on 7 July 2016. Retrieved 6 May 2017.
21. "LaingBuisson comprises a highly experienced and diverse team".
22. "Meet Our Team | Four Eyes Insight | Clinical Efficiencies Solution".
23. "Rt Hon Stephen Dorrell".
24. "The Network | dorsontransform". Archived from the original on 15 April 2021. Retrieved 26 March 2021.
25. "DORSON INFORM Ltd people - Find and update company information - GOV.UK".
26. Dorrell, Stephen (14 April 2019). "As nationalists grip the Tories, I now support Change UK". The Observer . Archived from the original on 14 April 2019. Retrieved 14 April 2019.
27. Walker, Jonathan (23 April 2019). "Ex-Tory minister Stephen Dorrell stands for anti-Brexit party". birminghammail. Archived from the original on 23 April 2019. Retrieved 25 April 2019.
28. Bucks Lib Dems 🔶 (2 November 2019). "Stephen Dorrell to contest Buckingham for @LibDems! He held a number of senior posts incl Secretary of State for Health. He left the Conservatives earlier this year & has since joined @LibDems. We're campaigning to WIN Buckingham. Meet Stephen today!".
29. "BBC election result". BBC News. Archived from the original on 13 April 2019. Retrieved 13 December 2019.
30. "Stephen Dorrell MP". Westminster Parliamentary Record. Archived from the original on 27 May 2012. Retrieved 2 May 2012.
31. "Changes to the Register of Members' Interests Stephen Dorrell". TheyWorkForYou. Archived from the original on 30 December 2011. Retrieved 2 May 2012.
32. The Richard Harman Foundation Award, olduppinghamian.co.uk, accessed 19 December 2020

External links

• Profile at Parliament of the United Kingdom
• Contributions in Parliament at Hansard
• Contributions in Parliament at Hansard 1803–2005
• Voting record at Public Whip
• Record in Parliament at TheyWorkForYou
• Profile: Stephen Dorrell MP, BBC News , 18 October 2002

Parliament of the United Kingdom
Preceded by John Cronin	Member of Parliament for Loughborough 1979–1997	Succeeded by Andy Reed
New constituency	Member of Parliament for Charnwood 1997–2015	Succeeded by Edward Argar
Preceded by David Alton	Baby of the House 1979–1981	Succeeded by Bobby Sands
Preceded by Bobby Sands	Baby of the House 1981	Succeeded by Owen Carron
Political offices
Preceded by Francis Maude	Financial Secretary to the Treasury 1992–1994	Succeeded by George Young
Preceded by Peter Brooke	Secretary of State for National Heritage 1994–1995	Succeeded by Virginia Bottomley
Preceded by Virginia Bottomley	Secretary of State for Health 1995–1997	Succeeded by Frank Dobson
Preceded by Harriet Harman	Shadow Secretary of State for Health 1997	Succeeded by John Maples
Preceded by Gillian Shephard	Shadow Secretary of State for Education and Employment 1997–1998	Succeeded by David Willetts