Administrative police (France)

Last updated

Administrative police in France are French police tasked with preventing disturbances to the ordre public. [1] [2] and ensuring the public peace and preventing crime. Ordre public or public peace in a society includes public tranquility, safety and well-being. Two types of ordre public exist:

Contents

A norm of ordre public is an imperative that the parties cannot set aside, generally in the name of protecting the weaker party.

Administrative policing can fall under either local or national jurisdiction, but does not include searching for, or arresting, the perpetrator(s) of a particular offense. [4] For example the French Border Police and the traffic police [5] have certain powers to detain and ask for identification, but are not involved in criminal investigations. [4]

The goals of administrative police are distinct from those of the judicial police who, under Article 14 of the Code of Criminal Procedure can investigate and arrest people for prosecution and punishment. [4]

The separation of administrative and judicial policing functions dates from the 1795 Code of Offences and Penalties, and is still in force today. This functional distinction does not necessarily imply an organizational separation: a single organization may perform both types of policing: an example is the National Gendarmerie.[ citation needed ]

Overview

Administrative policing is an activity intended to assure the ordre public but does not include searching for, or arresting, the perpetrator of a given breach of the law.

This teleological definition focuses on the goal of administrative policing, and takes into account the following functional and organic definitions:

Concept of ordre public

Administrative policing is defined by its goal of public peace (ordre public) which according to Article L.2212-2 of the code général des collectivités territoriales  [ fr ] assures "good order, safety, security, and public health". Safety speaks to a limit to disorder, security to limiting the risk of accidents, and public health to limiting the risk of illness. It can be likened to the American theory of the police power.

Good order is a more imprecise concept which has allowed the scope of the administrative police to expand and take into account morality and the protection of individuals against themselves. Article L.2212-2 of the code général des collectivités territoriales mandates the municipal police, [6] but administrative policing is also exercised by those whose ordre public authority stems from the Minister of the Interior. Article 12 of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen of 1789 is a foundational text for that authority,

Initially, administrative judges only took immorality into account if it might provoke a significant disorder. Today they do take morality into account, notably in the case of cinema, if this is justified by local circumstances. (Conseil d'Etat, 18 December 1959, Société des films Lutetia [7] )

Morality has also been monitored in terms of respect for preserving human dignity, since the Morsang-sur-Orge decision  [ fr ]; (Conseil d'État, 27 October 1995), which concerned dwarf tossing.

The Conseil d'État can also take into account esthetic issues (2 August 1924), Leroux, 18 February 1972, Chambre syndicale des entreprises artisanales du bâtiment de la Haute-Garonne: the Conseil d'État overturned an order of the mayor of Toulouse that for esthetic reasons very precisely regulated the dimensions and shape of funerary monuments in the cemetery). But this decision is outdated, and currently put back in question by the law of 19 December 2008 [8] which gave the mayor police power over the monuments under the supervision of the administrative judge.

The legality of administrative police actions to protect individuals against themselves (22 January 1982), Auto défense [9] and 9 July 2001, Préfet du Loiret), and protect a person mise en examen or charged with a crime. (TC 19 October 1998, veuve Laroche) [10] ) or protected the location of a possible crime (TC 12 December 2005, Prefect of Champagne-Ardenne).

Administrative and judicial police

The judicial police are charged with noting an infraction and finding or arresting its authors. Its function is thus repressive, as opposed to the preventive nature of administrative policing.

The distinction is essential where jurisdiction is uncertain and may lie with first an administrative judge, then a judicial judge, as it for responsibility, which is more easily triggered by administrative policing activities.

Characteristics of administrative policing

Administrative policing manifests unilateral prescriptions. These administrative decisions may take the form of regulations (decrees, arrêtés, ...) or individual rulings (individual authorization, visa or use licence, permit, ID check, body searches, ...). Police powers cannot be delegated to an individual.

Administrative police power can be general or special. In the latter case it applies only to certain categories of person (foreigners), of places (railway stations, airports), or of activities (hunting, fishing, cinema).

The administration has a duty to exercise its police power, but refusing to do so is only illegal if this refusal results in a failure to meet its legal obligations to maintain the ordre public. In the same way, a refusal to take police action need not be explained. Police actions never create rights and therefore may always be withdrawn, since the administration only acts on its responsibility in cases of faute lourde.

Mixed operations

The distinction between administrative policing and judicial policingis nonetheless sometimes delicate. Indeed, it is often exercised by the same individuals (police, gendarmes) and an administrative police operation may transform into a judicial police operation. For example, police officers who carry out body searches ("frisking") at the entrance to a stadium do so as an exercise of their administrative police powers (prevention of violence), but if in so doing they find narcotics, any subsequent arrest would be a judicial police operation (acting on an infraction). Inversely, a judicial police operation may transform into an administrative police operation. For example towing and impounding a vehicle (a judiciary police operation) but once the vehicle was impounded, an administrative police operation.

Jurisprudence concerning the distinction between types of policing system

In 1951, with the consorts Baud judgement, [11] [12] the Conseil d'État clarified the criterion of the "finality" of the operation. This criterion was taken back up in that same year by the Tribunal des conflits in the Dame Noualek judgement. [13] and by the Court of cassation in the Giry decision [14]

Holders of police power

Police power is shared among several holders.

National level

The Prime minister as holder of the general regulatory power (Article 21 of the Constitution of 4 October 1958) exercises police power at the national level . [15]

The special authorities of the police are different: the Minister of Culture is charged with policing cinema; thele Minister of the Interior with policing foreigners.

Zone level

The préfet de zone de défense et de sécurité disposes of both general and special powers. [16]

Departmental level

The president of the Conseil départemental has been a police authority since the loi du 2 mars 1982  [ fr ], [17] in the area of traffic circulation on departmental roads outside of municipalities.

Le police prefect is the police authority at the departmental level for traffic on highways (routes nationales) outside of municipalities but especially for the many special police forces (hunting, fishing, environment, sanitation, and through control of municipal police).

The power of the prefect also extends to continental waters. [18]

Commune level

The mayor exercises police power on the level of the commune.

In communes with more than 20,000 inhabitants, however, as well as of certain smaller communes, police personnel fall under the state's French Civil Service even though it executes the arrêtés of the mayor's policing. The prefect assures respect for the public peace.

In Paris, the mayor only has very limited powers in matters of policing: fairs and markets, and cleanliness of the public roadways. [19] The other police powers belong to the prefect of police.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prefectures in France</span> Governmental subdivision in France

In France, a prefecture may be:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Court of Cassation (France)</span> Highest judicial court in France

The Court of Cassation is the supreme court for civil and criminal cases in France. It is one of the country's four apex courts, along with the Council of State, the Constitutional Council and the Jurisdictional Disputes Tribunal.

The order of precedence for public ceremonies in France is established by Décret n°89-655 du 13 septembre 1989 relatif aux cérémonies publiques, préséances, honneurs civils et militaires. The original order has been modified since 1989, for example inserting the Defender of Rights after that office's 2011 creation. As of 9 January 2024 the order is as follows:

  1. The President of the Republic
  2. The Prime Minister
  3. The President of the Senate
  4. The President of the National Assembly
  5. Former Presidents of the Republic, in order of term
    1. Nicolas Sarkozy
    2. François Hollande
  6. The Government, in the order decided by the President of the Republic
  7. Former Prime Ministers, in order of term
    1. Laurent Fabius
    2. Édith Cresson
    3. Édouard Balladur
    4. Alain Juppé
    5. Lionel Jospin
    6. Jean-Pierre Raffarin
    7. Dominique de Villepin
    8. François Fillon
    9. Jean-Marc Ayrault
    10. Manuel Valls
    11. Bernard Cazeneuve
    12. Édouard Philippe
    13. Jean Castex
    14. Élisabeth Borne
    15. Gabriel Attal
  8. The President of the Constitutional Council
  9. The Vice President of the Conseil d'État
  10. The President of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council
  11. The Defender of Rights
  12. Members of the National Assembly
  13. Senators
  14. European parliament members
  15. The judicial authority represented by the first President of the Court of Cassation and the public prosecutor of that court
  16. The first President of the Revenue Court and the public prosecutor of that court
  17. The Great Chancellor of the Légion d'honneur, chancellor of the National Order of Merit and the members of the councils of these orders
  18. The Chancellor of the Order of the Libération, and the members of the council of this order
  19. The Chief of the Defence Staff
<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conseil d'État</span> French administrative justice institution and legal counsel to the government

In France, the Conseil d'État is a governmental body that acts both as legal adviser to the executive branch and as the supreme court for administrative justice, which is one of the two branches of the French judiciary system. Established in 1799 by Napoleon as a successor to the King's Council, it is located in the Palais-Royal in Paris and is primarily made up of top-level legal officers. The Vice President of the Council of State ranks as the ninth most important civil servant in France.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prefect (France)</span> States representative in a French department or region

A prefect in France is the state's representative in a department or region. Subprefects are responsible for the subdivisions of departments, known as arrondissements. The office of a prefect is known as a prefecture and that of a subprefect as a subprefecture. Regional prefects are ex officio the departmental prefects of the regional prefecture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Police (France)</span> Civil police force of France

The National Police, formerly known as the Sûreté nationale, is one of two national police forces of France, the other being the National Gendarmerie. The National Police is the country's main civil law enforcement agency, with primary jurisdiction in cities and large towns. By contrast, the National Gendarmerie has primary jurisdiction in smaller towns, as well as in rural and border areas. The National Police comes under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of the Interior and has about 145,200 employees. Young French citizens can fulfill their mandatory service in the police force.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Law enforcement in France</span>

Law enforcement in France is centralized at the national level. Recently, legislation has allowed local governments to hire their own police officers which are called the police municipale.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paris Police Prefecture</span> French institution

The Paris Police Prefecture, officially the Police Prefecture, is the unit of the French Ministry of the Interior that provides police, emergency services, and various administrative services to the population of the city of Paris and the surrounding three suburban départements of Hauts-de-Seine, Seine-Saint-Denis, and Val-de-Marne. It is headed by the Paris Prefect of Police, officially called the Prefect of Police.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Judiciary of France</span> Overview of Frances court system

France's independent court system enjoys special statutory protection from the executive branch. Procedures for the appointment, promotion, and removal of judges vary depending on whether it is for the ordinary or the administrative stream. Judicial appointments in the judicial stream must be approved by a special panel, the High Council of the Judiciary. Once appointed, career judges serve for life and cannot be removed without specific disciplinary proceedings conducted before the council with due process.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Law of France</span>

French law has a dual jurisdictional system comprising private law, also known as judicial law, and public law.

The Conseil du Roi, also known as the Royal Council, is a general term for the administrative and governmental apparatus around the King of France during the Ancien Régime designed to prepare his decisions and to advise him. It should not be confused with the role and title of a "Conseil du Roi", a type of public prosecutor in the French legal system at the same period.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Politics of France</span>

The politics of France take place within the framework of a semi-presidential system determined by the French Constitution of the French Fifth Republic. The nation declares itself to be an "indivisible, secular, democratic, and social Republic". The constitution provides for a separation of powers and proclaims France's "attachment to the Rights of Man and the principles of National Sovereignty as defined by the Declaration of 1789".

The Bouches-du-Rhône Police Prefecture, headed by the Bouches-du-Rhône Police Prefect, is a Prefecture of Police part of the National Police, which is a police force in the department of Bouches-du-Rhône. It was created on 16 October 2012.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Administration of Paris</span>

As the capital of France, Paris is the seat of France's national government. For the executive, the two chief officers each have their own official residences, which also serve as their offices. The President of France resides at the Élysée Palace in the 8th arrondissement. The Prime Minister's seat is at the Hôtel Matignon in the 7th arrondissement. Government ministries are located in various parts of Paris. Many are located in the 7th arrondissement, near the Matignon.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ministère public (France)</span>

In French law, the ministère public or le parquet is the authority charged with defending the interests of society and of the application of law. It is primarily made up of magistrates, but is sometimes represented by other persons such as police officials. Its magistrates can be referred to as "standing" magistrates, as opposed to magistrats du siège. Its closest equivalent in some English-speaking countries is the director of public prosecutions and the attorney general in others.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Court of appeal (France)</span> French court

In France, a cour d’appel of the ordre judiciaire (judiciary) is a juridiction de droit commun du second degré, an appellate court of general jurisdiction. It reviews the judgments of a tribunal judiciaire. When one of the parties is not satisfied with the trial court’s judgment, the party can file an appeal. While decisions of a court of first instance are termed "jugements" in French, a court of appeals hands down an arrêt, which may either affirm or reverse the judgment of the court below. An arrêt (judgment) of the court of appeals may be further appealed en cassation. If the appeal is admissible at the cour de cassation, that court does not re-judge the facts of the matter a third time, but may investigate and verify whether the rules of law were properly applied by the lower courts.

A professional order is an organization which, in a given territory, comprises all the members of the same profession, a profession which can generally be exercised in a liberal manner and which ensures a form of regulation of the profession in question.

This glossary of French criminal law is a list of explanations or translations of contemporary and historical concepts of criminal law in France.

Jurisdictional dualism in France is the separation of the French court system into two separate divisions, or "ordres", as they are called in French: the ordinary courts, and the administrative courts. The ordinary courts, also known as the judiciary order, handle criminal and civil cases, while the administrative courts handle disputes between individuals and the government. This dual system allows for a clear separation of powers and specialized handling of cases related to the actions of the government. The administrative courts are headed by the Council of State, and the ordinary courts by the Court of Cassation for judiciary law.

In French law, judges cannot create legal norms, because of the principle known as "la prohibition des arrêts de règlement" of Article 5 of the French civil code: "Judges are forbidden from pronouncing in a generally dispositive and regulatory fashion on the matters submitted to them." They can only put into evidence and interpret existing norms. This general principle underlies the state of existing law, which is merely uncovered by the judge.

References

  1. Chambers 1896, p. 286.
  2. Donnelly 2013, p. 37.
  3. Forde, M. “The ‘Ordre Public’ Exception and Adjudicative Jurisdiction Conventions.” The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, vol. 29, no. 2/3, 1980, pp. 259–73. JSTOR. Accessed 14 Jan. 2023.
  4. 1 2 3 Bell 2008, p. 129.
  5. Police administrative: Police de circulation: immatriculation des véhicules. In: Revue Judiciaire de l'Ouest, 1986-2. p. 253. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3406/juro.1986.1402, [www.persee.fr/doc/juro_0243-9069_1986_num_10_2_1402 via Persée]
  6. III. LA SÉCURITÉ A. UNE COMPÉTENCE LARGEMENT PARTAGÉE, Senate of France
  7. See the decision at Société des films Lutetia on Légifrance
  8. LOI n° 2008-1350 du 19 décembre 2008 relative à la législation funéraire. 19 December 2008. Retrieved 12 April 2020.
  9. Conseil d'Etat, 3 / 5 SSR, 22 January 1982, 20758 20966 21002 21030 21185 21194 21221, unpublished in the Lebon collection . Retrieved 12 April 2020.
  10. During the affaire Grégory, M. Laroche was released from detention, and killed. The State had not sufficiently protected persons who had a presumption of innocence.
  11. CE, 11 May 1951, the consorts Baud decision
  12. Conseil d’Etat, Section, 11 mai 1951, Consorts Baud, requête numéro 2542, rec. p. 265 Revue générale du droit, 'Conseil d’Etat, Section, 11 mai 1951, Consorts Baud, requête numéro 2542, rec. p. 265, ': Revue générale du droit on line, 1951, numéro 17175 (www.revuegeneraledudroit.eu/?p=17175)
  13. TC 7 June 1951, arrêt Dame Noualek
  14. Cassation civ. 23 November 1956
  15. Décision of the Conseil d'État, 8 August 1919, Labonne, which at the time concerned the president of the Republic.
  16. Rémi Capart. Les pouvoirs de police administrative du préfet de zone de défense et de sécurité, thèse Montpellier, 2015[Administrative police powers of the préfet of a defense and security zone]. Montpellier.
  17. Loi n° 82-213 du 2 mars 1982 relative aux droits et libertés des communes, des départements et des régions, LégiFrance
  18. (CAA Nantes, 5 December 2006, Fédération française motonautique).
  19. See the decision of the Conseil d'État of 11 February 1998, City of Paris vs Association des artistes-peintres de la place du Tertre.

Works cited

Further reading