Cleveland Cripple Survey

Last updated

The Cleveland Cripple Survey or Survey of Cripples in Cleveland was a survey done in Cleveland, Ohio first published in 1918 report by the Welfare Federation of Cleveland entitled: "Education and Occupations of cripples Juvenile and Adults: A Survey of All Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, 1916". The two reporters/authors for this Survey and report were Lucy Wright and Amy M. Hamburger. This survey is often credited as being one of the first accurate disability censuses, that measured the social and economic conditions of individuals considered.[ citation needed ]

Contents

Purpose and context

Many reports regarding this survey state that the purpose of the survey was to reveal the needs, constraints, and general conditions of the disability community within Cleveland. It was also revealed that the basis of the survey, which began its works in 1915, was formulated around various questions, one of which was: "What, then does the cripple want?". [1] From this question the two authors undertook this project with aspiration to not only discover the true nature and size of the problems disabled individuals within the community faced but also to create feasible community based plan that would: "promote the welfare of cripples". [2]

Within the survey, a "cripple" is defined "as a person whose muscular movements are so far restricted by congenital defect, results of disease or accidents as to affect his capacity for self-support.". [3] Individuals classified as blind or with cardiac problem were excluded from this definition.[ citation needed ]

The Cleveland area was chosen as the sample for this survey due to the fact that it provided a booming industrial community that was majorly affected by two historical events. The first event was the early implementations of Workmen's Compensation and Employer's Liability Act. Disabled workers during this time period often faced discrimination by employers that often feared that hiring disabled laborers would increase their insurance rates and increase their own liability for providing workers compensation benefits. [4] The next historical event was the early spread of Poliomyelitis or the Polio Virus, which in densely populated cities such as Cleveland was rapidly infecting numerous laborers children, thus creating adding to the number of disabled individuals. Wounded Veterans returning from World War I also added to these newly classified disabled individuals. Because of this rapid increase of disabled individuals the survey uncovered over 60 percent of individuals they deemed disabled by their definition were in fact not documented as so by their local ordinances.[ citation needed ]

Research methods

Common to the Progressive Era, Social Survey was used as the method to collect information. Work for the survey began on October 17, 1915, and was completed August 19, 1916 [5] . Data for this survey was obtained by canvassing eight districts of the city with house-to house-visits, scheduled questions, and survey cards. The initial process began for the survey was done by amateur volunteer workers, students, and some experienced social workers that canvassed the eight districts with "lists of cripples" provided to them by hospitals, dispensaries and social agencies (24). [6] A total of 150,000 families from all economic backgrounds were canvassed within the survey. Out of that number 4,186 were given survey cards that were compiled within a 12-month span. The estimated total cost for the survey was reported at $12,500.[ citation needed ]

Results

The survey uncovered a variety of findings from the series of questions that families were asked to answer on a survey card. These suggested that disabled individuals had discovered ways to stay economically successful despite societal constraints and lack of government assistance. In addition, the survey established a greater need for disabled child assistance programs and institutions. More dependent disabled children as well[ citation needed ]

The population and age demographics revealed that nearly half of the individuals that were classified as "crippled", became disabled before the age of 15. 43 percent became classified during active working years (ages 15–60) while only 6 percent became classified after age 60. [7] Out of the 936 cases that identified as becoming disabled at childhood, 382 were attributed to the Polio Virus (Infantile Paralysis). These results confirmed the severity of virus's epidemic and suggested that preventive measure should be taken to limit the illness from spreading further. [8]

Overall the survey suggested that within Cleveland in 1916 out of every 100 individuals, six of them were classified as "crippled" according to their definition. Out of these individuals 65 percent were completely unaware that they could potentially utilize free public food dispensaries or social agencies.[ citation needed ]

Recommendations

The Welfare Federation of Cleveland recommendations based on this survey included the implantation of long-term rehabilitation and vocational programs, promotion of economic employment inclusion, and preventive efforts to reduce the number of individuals becoming disabled from accidents and diseases. [9] They also recommended special federal institution be made for the severely disabled that "cannot place themselves". While though whom they classified as capable of work be provided more employment opportunities based on their skill sets. [10] Additional the committee also encouraged the census to change qualification for all physically disabled individuals regardless of their defined economic class.[ citation needed ]

Influence on policy

The survey results may have influenced many types of disability social policies throughout the 1920s and 1930s. A news article from the Washington Post, dated September 3, 1930, reported that the study had been presented in a White House Conference on Child Health and Project. The same year as the "Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adults: A Survey of All Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, 1916," the Smith Sears Veterans Rehabilitation Act became law, helping integrate disabled veterans back into the work force. This act was the first piece of legislation that promoted any kind of disability rehabilitation and closely coincides with the recommendations from the survey's committee. The survey may also have contributed to discrimination within immigration procedures, reporting that districts with high percentages of immigrants typically had more disabled individuals present. The committee added in their recommendation that "preventive measures" should be taken to prevent "American" people from becoming classified as disabled. [11]

Criticism

The Ugly Laws: Disability Politics by Susan M. Schweiks (2009) heavily criticizes many aspects of "The Cleveland survey" including its rhetoric, rehabilitation approach, as well as the publications discourse that arguable speaks for its subjects. Schweiks suggests that in the report's section "successful individuals", subjects are not only spoken for by the surveyors but also given identities such as "beggar", "street operator", or even just a survey number. [12]

Halle Lewis also heavily criticized the survey's contents in her dissertation Cripples are not the Dependent One is Led to think. According to her, the survey itself "made disabled Clevelanders a separate class of people", and subsequently creating a new disabled identity. [13] Although she does in fact credit the survey for the advancement of some disabled individuals during that time period that were provided with better educational, medical, and vocational programs because of the survey's result, she also suggests that becoming identified as "crippled" gave them an identity associated with inferiority and therefore robbed them of an individual identity [14]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Disability</span> Impairments, activity limitations, and participation restrictions

Disability is the experience of any condition that makes it more difficult for a person to do certain activities or have equitable access within a given society. Disabilities may be cognitive, developmental, intellectual, mental, physical, sensory, or a combination of multiple factors. Disabilities can be present from birth or can be acquired during a person's lifetime. Historically, disabilities have only been recognized based on a narrow set of criteria—however, disabilities are not binary and can be present in unique characteristics depending on the individual. A disability may be readily visible, or invisible in nature.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Welfare</span> Means-oriented social benefit

Welfare, or commonly social welfare, is a type of government support intended to ensure that members of a society can meet basic human needs such as food and shelter. Social security may either be synonymous with welfare, or refer specifically to social insurance programs which provide support only to those who have previously contributed, as opposed to social assistance programs which provide support on the basis of need alone. The International Labour Organization defines social security as covering support for those in old age, support for the maintenance of children, medical treatment, parental and sick leave, unemployment and disability benefits, and support for sufferers of occupational injury.

People with disabilities in the United States are a significant minority group, making up a fifth of the overall population and over half of Americans older than eighty. There is a complex history underlying the U.S. and its relationship with its disabled population, with great progress being made in the last century to improve the livelihood of disabled citizens through legislation providing protections and benefits. Most notably, the Americans with Disabilities Act is a comprehensive anti-discrimination policy that works to protect Americans with disabilities in public settings and the workplace.

The United States Children's Bureau is a federal agency founded in 1912, organized under the United States Department of Health and Human Services' Administration for Children and Families. Today, the bureau's operations involve improving child abuse prevention, foster care, and adoption. Historically, its work was much broader, as shown by the 1912 act which created and funded it:

The said bureau shall investigate and report to [the Department of Commerce and Labor] upon all matters pertaining to the welfare of children and child life among all classes of our people, and shall especially investigate the questions of infant mortality, the birth-rate, orphanage, juvenile courts, desertion, dangerous occupations, accidents and diseases of children, employment, legislation affecting children in the several states and territories.

Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 is American legislation that guarantees certain rights to people with disabilities. It was one of the first U.S. federal civil rights laws offering protection for people with disabilities. It set precedents for subsequent legislation for people with disabilities, including the Americans with Disabilities Act in 1990.

From 1867 to 1974, various cities of the United States had unsightly beggar ordinances, retroactively named ugly laws. These laws targeted poor people and disabled people. For instance, in San Francisco a law of 1867 deemed it illegal for "any person, who is diseased, maimed, mutilated or deformed in any way, so as to be an unsightly or disgusting object, to expose himself or herself to public view." Exceptions to public exposure were acceptable only if the people were subjects of demonstration, to illustrate the separation of disabled from nondisabled and their need for reformation.

Research published from 2000 to 2020 illustrates increased prevalence rates of sexual violence against people with intellectual disabilities, compared to the general population.:61 The World Health Organization (WHO) funded a study which concluded that 15% of the adult population worldwide in 2012 had a disability, putting them at increased risk of physical, sexual, and intimate partner violence. Of that 15%, 6.1% had intellectual disability with 5.5% experiencing sexual violence. In another 2012 report, the WHO found that worldwide, children with intellectual disabilities experienced a 4.6 times greater risk of sexual violence than those without disability.

Disability abuse is when a person with a disability is abused physically, financially, sexually and/or psychologically due to the person having a disability. This type of abuse has also been considered a hate crime. The abuse is not limited to those who are visibly disabled or physically deformed, but also includes those with learning, intellectual and developmental disabilities or mental illnesses.

Hattie Larlham is an American nonprofit organization that creates opportunities for more than 1,600 children and adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities in the state of Ohio. Services provided encompass medical, work training and employment, recreational, educational, and residential, catering to both children and adults.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Douglas Crawford McMurtrie</span>

Douglas Crawford McMurtrie was an American typeface designer, graphic designer, historian, author and bibliographer of printing.

Ableism is discrimination and social prejudice against people with physical or mental disabilities. Ableism characterizes people as they are defined by their disabilities and it also classifies disabled people as people who are inferior to non-disabled people. On this basis, people are assigned or denied certain perceived abilities, skills, or character orientations.

The world's poor are significantly more likely to have or incur a disability within their lifetime compared to more financially privileged populations. The rate of disability within impoverished nations is notably higher than that found in more developed countries. Since the early 2010s there has been growing research in support of an association between disability and poverty and of a cycle by which poverty and disability are mutually reinforcing. Physical, cognitive, mental, emotional, sensory, or developmental impairments independently or in tandem with one another may increase one's likelihood of becoming impoverished, while living in poverty may increase one's potential of having or acquiring disability in some capacity.

Disability in China is common, and according to the United Nations, approximately 83 million people in China are estimated to have a disability.

Age-related mobility disability is a self-reported inability to walk due to impairments, limited mobility, dexterity or stamina. It has been found mostly in older adults with decreased strength in lower extremities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Disability in Yemen</span>

Disability in Yemen has been increasing over time, especially because of increased conflict in the area. Disabled people in Yemen face many challenges due to poverty, lack of accessible infrastructure, gender segregation and more. The government of Yemen has passed laws to help protect the rights of disabled people in their country, but not all laws are equally enforced.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Disability in Singapore</span>

Singapore does not have a formal definition of disability. Singapore signed on to the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in 2013 and coordinates the Enabling Masterplan with both government and non governmental organisations.

Tuvalu has been slow to deal with problems that people with a disability face in the country. Since 1978, the government of Tuvalu has been slow to create policy and laws for people with disabilities. In addition, few studies have been done to assess the scope of the issue on the islands. The first comprehensive study of people with disabilities in Tuvalu was done in February 2017.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Disability in Zambia</span>

People with disability in Zambia face many unique challenges. The country has been passing laws and policies to help people with disabilities in Zambia, however, social stigma and other factors sometimes interfere in people being able to access services and assistance. In addition, the HIV epidemic in Zambia also has a significant impact on the lives of people with disabilities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bell Greve</span>

Bell Greve was an American social worker, based in Cleveland, Ohio.

References

  1. Welfare Federation of Cleveland. Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adult: A Survey of All the Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, in 1916. New York: The RedCross Institute for Crippled and Disabled Men, 1918, p. 13
  2. Welfare Federation of Cleveland."Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adult: A Survey of All the Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, in 1916." New York: The RedCross Institute for Crippled and Disabled Men, 1918, p. 9
  3. Welfare Federation of Cleveland. Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adult: A Survey of All the Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, in 1916. New York: The RedCross Institute for Crippled and Disabled Men, 1918, p. 12
  4. Welfare Federation of Cleveland. Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adult: A Survey of All the Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio,"in 1916. New York: The RedCross Institute for Crippled and Disabled Men, 1918, p. 15.
  5. Welfare Federation of Cleveland. Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adult: A Survey of All the Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, in 1916. New York: The RedCross Institute for Crippled and Disabled Men, 1918, p. 167.
  6. Stern, Walter G. ""A Report on The Cleveland and Elyria Cripple Surveys."" The Journey of Bone & Joint Surgery, January 1, 1919: 23-32.
  7. Welfare Federation of Cleveland. Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adult: A Survey of All the Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, in 1916. New York: The RedCross Institute for Crippled and Disabled Men, 1918, p. 33.
  8. Welfare Federation of Cleveland. "Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adult: A Survey of All the Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, in 1916." New York: The RedCross Institute for Crippled and Disabled Men, 1918, p. 39.
  9. Welfare Federation of Cleveland. Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adult: A Survey of All the Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, in 1916. New York: The RedCross Institute for Crippled and Disabled Men, 1918, p. 194.
  10. Stern, Walter G. ""A Report on The Cleveland and Elyria Cripple Surveys."" The Journey of Bone & Joint Surgery, January 1, 1919, p. 30.
  11. Welfare Federation of Cleveland. "Education and Occupations of Cripples Juvenile and Adult: A Survey of All the Cripples of Cleveland, Ohio, in 1916." New York: The RedCross Institute for Crippled and Disabled Men, 1918, p. 198.
  12. Schweik, Susan M. "The Ugly Laws: Disability in Public." NYU Press, 2009. Print, p. 244-246.
  13. Lewis, Halle Gayle. "Cripples are Not the Dependents One is Led to Think": Work and Disability in Industrializing Cleveland, 1861--1916." Ph.D dissertation, SUNY Binghamton, 2004, p. 200
  14. Lewis, Halle Gayle. "Cripples are Not the Dependents One is Led to Think": Work and Disability in Industrializing Cleveland, 1861--1916." Ph.D dissertation, SUNY Binghamton, 2004, p. 200-201