Detachment of wall paintings

Last updated

The detachment of wall paintings involves the removal of a wall painting from the structure of which it formed part. While detachment was once a common practice, the preservation of art in situ is now preferred, and detachment is now largely restricted to cases where the only alternative is total loss. [1] According to the International Council on Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS): [2]

Contents

Detachment and transfer are dangerous, drastic and irreversible operations that severely affect the physical composition, material structure and aesthetic characteristics of wall paintings. These operations are, therefore, only justifiable in extreme cases when all options of in situ treatment are not viable. Should such situations occur, decisions involving detachment and transfer should always be taken by a team of professionals, rather than by the individual who is carrying out the conservation work. Detached paintings should be replaced in their original location whenever possible. Special measures should be taken for the protection and maintenance of detached paintings, and for the prevention of their theft and dispersion. The application of a covering layer concealing an existing decoration, carried out with the intention of preventing damage or destruction by exposure to an inhospitable environment, should be executed with materials compatible with the wall painting, and in a way that will permit future uncovering.

History

Vitruvius records how in Sparta, in 59 BC, "paintings have been taken out of certain walls by cutting through the bricks, enclosed in wooden frames, and brought to the Comitium". [3] A century later, apprised of paintings of Atalanta and Helen without drapery and "enflamed with lust", Caligula attempted to carry them off, but was prevented by the makeup of the plaster. [4] Maiuri cites examples of wall paintings in wooden frames excavated at Pompeii, a precursor to what was to follow in the 18th and 19th centuries. [5] [6] The practice of detachment, in abeyance or undocumented for a millennium, was revived in Renaissance Italy, with several instances recorded by Vasari. [7]

Some of the earliest wall paintings date to 16,000 BCE in the Lascaux Caves in France. Wall paintings historically differ from wall murals due to wall paintings being put on structurally significant walls, as murals are in dedicated wall niches. [8] Some early accounts of wall painting detachment come from the expeditions of Napoleon Bonaparte. Prior to the Napoleonic Expeditions in the early 1700s chemists and architects from around Europe began working with both the strappo and stacco methods of detachment. [9] It was the method of stacco Napoleon's team of artists and architects used in order to remove Daniele da Volterra's Deposition. [9] Although detachment is possible it is favorably viewed as a last resort when other methods of preservation have failed. Typically the largest threat to wall paintings is moisture behind the work; if this is corrected, detachment is typically no longer necessary. [8] In more recent years the artist Banksy has become world renown for their street art. This rise in popularity of the artist has resulted in the removal of their paintings to be sold. One example can be seen in the removal of Girl with Red Balloon from Shoreditch, east London in 2013–2014. The painting was removed over a period of two weeks, using a diamond-bladed chainsaw to cut through 22 cm of brick. The detached work went on to sell for £350,000 in an auction. [10]

Motivation

In their study, Mora, Mora, and Philippot cite four reasons for the "over-use" of detachment: the 19th-century division of the arts that privileged a "painting" divorced from its architectural and historical context; insensitivity to the aesthetic consequences, often partially concealed by restorers; the curiosity of art historians looking for sinopie ; or perceived savings relating to the initial cost of treatment. [11] Commercial gain and exploitation as consumer goods by collectors, dealers and restorers provides another possible incentive. [12] This process enables nowadays' companies to offer their customers an authentic fresco, created in their laboratory according to the ancient technique and transferred onto a canvas to be shipped to the place of installation. [13]

Techniques

Mural by Banksy on the West Bank barrier (2005); a wall painting's meaning is intimately related to its immediate physical setting. Mauer-betlehem.jpg
Mural by Banksy on the West Bank barrier (2005); a wall painting's meaning is intimately related to its immediate physical setting.

There are three main methods, typically referred to by their Italian terms, namely stacco a massello, involving detachment and removal of painting, render, and some or all of the mural support; stacco or detachment of the painting with render alone; and strappo, lit. "tearing", lifting of only the paint layer, attached to a facing with adhesive. [17] In each case the resulting material must be applied to a new support. [18]

Schwartzbaum et al. liken the removal of a fresco to the transfer of a panel painting, in that it is generally considered undesirable except as a last resort. "Strappo" involves the removal of only the uppermost pigment-bearing layer; "stacco" is the removal of the fresco and its plaster preparation; "stacco a massello" is the removal of the painting, preparation, and mural support. It is generally desirable to remove as much of the preparation as possible in order to preserve the original character of the wall, yet "Stacco a massello is often prohibitively expensive." [19]

According to the Benozzo Gozzoli Museum, Castelfiorentino, Italy, the "Strappo" technique is the least invasive method of wall painting removal because unlike stacco a massello or stacco, it "involves removal of only the topmost layer of plaster, which has absorbed the pigment" as described in the video, The Strappo Technique produced by the Museo Benozzo Gozzoli. [20]

Ths video details removal by the strappo method, in which the overlaying painted surface is first coated with a thin layer of cotton cloth and animal glue. Following is a secondary and sturdier layer of cloth extending beyond the perimeter of the work and the outline of the fresco is incised. The entire surface of the painting and protective cloth are then detached from the subsurface by means of pouncing with a rubber mallet, and the fresco and cloth layer are both carefully removed from its support from the bottom up. A new backing layer is then applied to the exposed reverse of the fresco, called velatini, followed by two additional layers of mortar (one rough and another smooth). The two layers of cloth are known as the "sacrficial" or "sacrificial leg", because they serve only to facilitate future detachments and are hence, reversible. [20] The detached painting is then secured to a rigid support and the protective covering removed with a solution of "hot water spray and decolored ethyl alcohol" – exposing the original painted surface to the gaze of the viewer. [20]

Case study

Salvaging the Frescos at the Church of San Lorenzo, Fruli Region, Italy:

The following narrative describes extreme circumstances under which removal of wall paintings is mandated. Due to a series of strong earthquakes in the Fruili Region of Italy in 1976, the structure of the Church of San Lorenzo was compromised, posing a severe threat to the integrity of its wall paintings. Under these rare circumstances, detachment was considered as a last resort. Destruction was documented as follows:

"After the May 6th earthquake, the roof and upper portions of the nave of the Church of San Lorenzo collapsed. Plaster fell from the remaining walls, revealing traces of a previously unknown eleventh century fresco cycle, unique in the Friuli…Furthermore, the edge of the cliff on which the church was situated had moved to within inches of the left nave wall as a result of earthquake-related landslides. The probability of complete loss of the left wall with further landslides required the immediate removal of its frescoes. However, since the thin, well-adhered preparations of the frescoes precluded "stacco" or "strappo", the only alternative was a "stacco a massello", the removal of the painting, preparation, and masonary support as a complete unit." [19]

Criticisms

Minimum intervention and reversibility are core conservation ethics that favor preservation in situ. [21] [22] Detachment breaks the intrinsic link between wall paintings and architecture; causes irreversible physical damage to the texture, topography, and tone of the painting; leaves a void in the stripped interior; with the introduction of new materials, typically leads to a cycle of retreatment; and has resulted in "many transfers in terrible condition that serve as examples of serious, albeit unintentional, maltreatment". [23]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fresco</span> Mural painting upon freshly laid lime plaster

Fresco is a technique of mural painting executed upon freshly laid ("wet") lime plaster. Water is used as the vehicle for the dry-powder pigment to merge with the plaster, and with the setting of the plaster, the painting becomes an integral part of the wall. The word fresco is derived from the Italian adjective fresco meaning "fresh", and may thus be contrasted with fresco-secco or secco mural painting techniques, which are applied to dried plaster, to supplement painting in fresco. The fresco technique has been employed since antiquity and is closely associated with Italian Renaissance painting.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mural</span> Piece of artwork painted or applied directly on a large permanent surface

A mural is any piece of graphic artwork that is painted or applied directly to a wall, ceiling or other permanent substrate. Mural techniques include fresco, mosaic, graffiti and marouflage.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gambier Parry process</span>

The Gambier Parry process is a development of the classical technique of fresco for painting murals, named for Thomas Gambier Parry.

<i>Madonna Della Strada</i> Painting of Mary at the Church of the Gesù in Rome, Italy

Madonna Della Strada or Santa Maria Della Strada is a painting of Mary, mother of Jesus at the Church of the Gesù in Rome, mother church of the Society of Jesus (Jesuits) religious order of the Catholic Church; it is a variation on the basilissa (imperial) type of icon.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sgraffito</span> Art technique involving scratching

Sgraffito is a technique either of wall decor, produced by applying layers of plaster tinted in contrasting colours to a moistened surface, or in pottery, by applying to an unfired ceramic body two successive layers of contrasting slip or glaze, and then in either case scratching so as to reveal parts of the underlying layer. The Italian past participle sgraffiato is also used, especially of pottery.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fresco-secco</span>

Fresco-secco is a wall painting technique where pigments mixed with an organic binder and/or lime are applied onto dry plaster. The paints used can e.g. be casein paint, tempera, oil paint, silicate mineral paint. If the pigments are mixed with lime water or lime milk and applied to a dry plaster the technique is called lime secco painting. The secco technique contrasts with the fresco technique, where the painting is executed on a layer of wet plaster.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Memorial Hall (University of Kentucky)</span> Landmark building on the University of Kentucky campus

Memorial Hall located at 610 South Limestone Street is a prominent building on the campus of the University of Kentucky. It is approximately 17,012 square feet and 130 feet tall. The building's construction was funded by donations and individual contributions over a ten-year period through a subscription to the university, beginning in 1919. Completed in 1929 as a memorial to those who died in World War I, it is used for lectures and performances, and also serves as a site for graduation ceremonies of some colleges within the university. From 1969 to 1970 major renovations of the interior of the building took place. The additions include new flooring, seating, powder rooms, lighting, and air conditioning. It is located on central campus at the end of Funkhouser Drive.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sinopia</span> Dark reddish-brown natural earth pigment

Sinopia is a dark reddish-brown natural earth pigment, whose reddish colour comes from hematite, a dehydrated form of iron oxide. It was widely used in Classical Antiquity and the Middle Ages for painting, and during the Renaissance it was often used on the rough initial layer of plaster for the underdrawing for a fresco. The word came to be used both for the pigment and for the preparatory drawing itself, which may be revealed when a fresco is stripped from its wall for transfer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sittanavasal Cave</span> Historic site in Pudukottai, India

Sittanavasal Cave is a 2nd-century Tamil Śramaṇa complex of caves in Sittanavasal village in Pudukottai district of Tamil Nadu, India. Its name is a distorted form of Sit-tan-na-va-yil, a Tamil word which means "the abode of great saints".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Takamatsuzuka Tomb</span>

The Takamatsuzuka Tomb is an ancient circular tomb in Asuka village, Nara Prefecture, Japan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Villa of the Mysteries</span> Building in Pompeii, Italy

The Villa of the Mysteries is a well-preserved suburban ancient Roman villa on the outskirts of Pompeii, southern Italy. It is famous for the series of exquisite frescos in Room 5, which are usually interpreted as showing the initiation of a bride into a Greco-Roman mystery cult. These are now among the best known of the relatively rare survivals of Ancient Roman painting from the 1st century BC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation issues of Pompeii and Herculaneum</span> Aspect of archaeology in Pompeii and Herculaneum

Pompeii and Herculaneum were once thriving towns, 2,000 years ago, in the Bay of Naples. Both cities have rich histories influenced by Greeks, Oscans, Etruscans, Samnites and finally the Romans. They are most renowned for their destruction: both were buried in the AD 79 eruption of Mount Vesuvius. For over 1,500 years, these cities were left in remarkable states of preservation underneath volcanic ash, mud and rubble. The eruption obliterated the towns but in doing so, was the cause of their longevity and survival over the centuries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Restoration of the Sistine Chapel frescoes</span> 20th-century art conservation project

The conservation-restoration of the frescoes of the Sistine Chapel was one of the most significant conservation-restorations of the 20th century.

Buon fresco is a fresco painting technique in which alkaline-resistant pigments, ground in water, are applied to wet plaster.

<i>Last Supper</i> (Castagno) Fresco by Andrea del Castagno in the Rectory of Santa Apollonia

The Last Supper (1445–1450) is a fresco by the Italian Renaissance artist Andrea del Castagno, located in the refectory of the convent of Sant'Apollonia, now the Museo di Cenacolo di Sant'Apollonia, and accessed through a door on Via Ventisette Aprile at the corner with Santa Reparata, in Florence, region of Tuscany. The painting depicts Jesus and the Apostles during the Last Supper, with Judas, unlike all the other apostles, sitting separately on the near side of the table, as is common in depictions of the Last Supper in Christian art.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Children's Chapel, St James' Church, Sydney</span> Church building in New South Wales, Australia

The Chapel of Saint Mary and the Angels is a chapel in one of the bays of the crypt of St James' Church, Sydney, created as a place for younger children to receive an adapted form of the Eucharist on Sundays. In the 21st century, the chapel is used for the children's Eucharist on the first Sunday of the month. The walls and ceiling of the chapel are painted with scenes inspired by the Christmas carol "As I Sat Under A Sycamore Tree" with the setting transferred to Sydney Harbour.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation and restoration of frescos</span> Art preservation techniques

The conservation and restoration of frescoes is the process of caring for and maintaining frescos, and includes documentation, examination, research, and treatment to insure their long-term viability, when desired.

Conservation-restoration of Leonardo da Vincis <i>The Last Supper</i>

The conservation-restoration of Leonardo da Vinci's The Last Supper is an ongoing project that has spanned many centuries. Completed in the late 15th century by the Renaissance artist Leonardo da Vinci, the mural is located in the refectory of the Convent of Santa Maria delle Grazie, Milan, Italy. The Last Supper was commissioned by Ludovico Sforza, Duke of Milan in 1495, as part of a series of renovations to the convent with the intention that the location would become the Sforza family mausoleum. Work began on The Last Supper in 1495 and lasted until 1498. The scene is understood to depict the Bible verse John 13:22, showing the reactions of the Twelve Disciples, at the Last Supper, in the moments following Jesus’s announcement that one among them will betray him.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation and restoration of paintings</span>

The conservation and restoration of paintings is carried out by professional painting conservators. Paintings cover a wide range of various mediums, materials, and their supports. Painting types include fine art to decorative and functional objects spanning from acrylics, frescoes, and oil paint on various surfaces, egg tempera on panels and canvas, lacquer painting, water color and more. Knowing the materials of any given painting and its support allows for the proper restoration and conservation practices. All components of a painting will react to its environment differently, and impact the artwork as a whole. These material components along with collections care will determine the longevity of a painting. The first steps to conservation and restoration is preventive conservation followed by active restoration with the artist's intent in mind.

The conservation and restoration of Pompeian frescoes describes the activities, methods, and techniques that have historically been and are currently being used to care for the preserved remains of the frescoes from the archeological site of Pompeii, Italy. The ancient city of Pompeii is famously known for its demise in A.D. 79 after the fatal eruption of Mount Vesuvius wiped out the population and buried the city beneath layers of compact lava material. In 1738, King Charles III or Charles of Bourbon, began explorations in Portici, Resina, Castellammare di Stabia, a Civita, where it was believed that the ancient cities of Pompeii, Stabiae, and Herculaneum were buried beneath. The first phase of the excavations at Pompeii started in 1748, which led to the first conservation and restoration efforts of the frescoes since their burial, and in 1764, open-air excavations began at Pompeii. Pompeii has a long history of excavation and restoration that began without a strong foundation or strategy. After centuries of cronyism, recurring financial shortages, and on-again-off-again restoration, the city's frescoes and structures were left in poor condition. In 1997, Pompeii was added to the UNESCO List of World Heritage Sites.

References

  1. ↑ Weyer, Angela; Roig Picazo, Pilar; Pop, Daniel; Cassar, JoAnn; Özköse, Aysun; Vallet, Jean-Marc; Srša, Ivan, eds. (2015). EwaGlos. European Illustrated Glossary Of Conservation Terms For Wall Paintings And Architectural Surfaces. English Definitions with translations into Bulgarian, Croatian, French, German, Hungarian, Italian, Polish, Romanian, Spanish and Turkish. Petersberg: Michael Imhof. p. 344. doi:10.5165/hawk-hhg/233. ISBN   978-3-7319-0260-7.
  2. ↑ "Principles for the Preservation and Conservation-Restoration of Wall Paintings (Article 6: Emergency Measures)" (PDF). ICOMOS. 2003. Retrieved 13 February 2012.
  3. ↑ "Vitruvius, De Architectura II.8.9". Perseus Project . Retrieved 13 February 2012.
  4. ↑ "Pliny the Elder, Natural History XXXV.6.17-18". Perseus Project . Retrieved 13 February 2012.
  5. ↑ Maiuri, Amedeo (1940). "Picturae Ligneis Formis Inclusae: Note sulla Tecnica della Pittura Campana". Atti della Accademia dei Lincei. Accademia dei Lincei. 18 (7–10): 138–60.
  6. ↑ Moorman, Eric (1991). "Destruction and restoration of Campanian mural paintings in the 18th and 19th centuries". In Cather, Sharon (ed.). The Conservation of Wall Paintings (PDF). Getty Conservation Institute. pp. 87–102. ISBN   0-89236-162-X. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2012-05-27.
  7. ↑ Mora, Paolo; Mora, Laura; Philippot, Paul (1984). Conservation of Wall Paintings. Butterworths. p. 260f. ISBN   0-408-10812-6.
  8. 1 2 Rosenthal, Anne. "Art Conservation and Restoration". Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved April 7, 2022.
  9. 1 2 Hoeniger, Cathleen. "The Art Requisitions by the French under Napoléon and the Detachment of Frescoes in Rome, with an Emphasis on Raphael". Open Edition Journels. Retrieved April 7, 2022.
  10. ↑ Smallman, Etan (21 February 2014). "How do you remove a Banksy mural?". The Independent.
  11. ↑ Mora, Paolo; Mora, Laura; Philippot, Paul (1984). Conservation of Wall Paintings. Butterworths. pp. 245f. ISBN   0-408-10812-6.
  12. ↑ Brajer, Isabelle (1999). "Aspects of reversibility in transferred paintings". In Oddy, Andrew; Carroll, Sara (eds.). Reversibility - Does it Exist?. British Museum Press. pp. 64f. ISBN   0-86159-135-6.
  13. ↑ How is a fresco detached from a wall? - Fresco Blog by Italian Fresco Blog.
  14. ↑ Jones, Sam (5 August 2005). "Spray can prankster tackles Israel's security barrier". The Guardian . Retrieved 6 July 2012.
  15. ↑ Mora, Paolo; Mora, Laura; Philippot, Paul (1984). Conservation of Wall Paintings. Butterworths. pp. 2ff. ISBN   0-408-10812-6.
  16. ↑ Sven Sandström (1963). Levels of Unreality: Studies in structure and construction in Italian mural painting during the Renaissance. Uppsala. pp. passim.
  17. ↑ Mora, Paolo; Mora, Laura; Philippot, Paul (1984). Conservation of Wall Paintings. Butterworths. pp. 246–260. ISBN   0-408-10812-6.
  18. ↑ Mora, Paolo; Mora, Laura; Philippot, Paul (1984). Conservation of Wall Paintings. Butterworths. pp. 262–281. ISBN   0-408-10812-6.
  19. 1 2 Schwartzbaum, Paul (1997). "Earthquake Damage to Works of Art in the Fruili Region of Italy". Journal of the American Institute for Conservation. 17: 9–16.
  20. 1 2 3 The Strappo Technique , retrieved 2022-04-06
  21. ↑ Brajer, Isabelle (2002). The Transfer of Wallpaintings; based on Danish experience. Archetype Publications. ISBN   978-1-873132-43-2.
  22. ↑ Michaelides, Demetrios, ed. (2003). "Philosophies favouring in situ conservation". Mosaics make a Site: The conservation in situ of mosaics on archaeological sites. ICCM. pp. 17–29. ISBN   92-9077-179-8.
  23. ↑ Brajer, Isabelle (1999). "Aspects of reversibility in transferred paintings". In Oddy, Andrew; Carroll, Sara (eds.). Reversibility - Does it Exist?. British Museum Press. pp. 63–71 (p. 65 for quote). ISBN   0-86159-135-6.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.