Cultural property radiography

Last updated
An early unit for producing medical x-radiographs. The set up does not drastically differ for taking X-rays of cultural objects. Radiography, x-ray therapeutics and radium therapy (1915) (14777545043).jpg
An early unit for producing medical x-radiographs. The set up does not drastically differ for taking X-rays of cultural objects.

The radiography of cultural property is the use of radiography to understand intrinsic details about objects. Most commonly this involves X-rays of paintings to reveal underdrawing, pentimenti alterations in the course of painting or by later restorers, and sometimes previous paintings on the support. Many pigments such as lead white show well in radiographs.

Contents

X-ray spectromicroscopy has also been used to analyse the reactions of pigments in paintings. For example, in analysing colour degradation in the paintings of van Gogh. [1]

These processes can reveal various details about objects that are not visible to the naked eye. This information, which includes structural elements, aids conservators as they assess object condition and consider treatment plans.

For three dimensional objects, the computed tomography (CT) has become a common tool, which when combined with analysis can, for example, "digitally unroll" or unfold and make possible the reading of fragile scrolls, books, or sealed correspondence. [2]

Use and precautions

Infrared and ultraviolet light are also useful tools to understand the intrinsic details of certain objects. However, X-rays tend to be more useful for denser objects. [3] The benefit of radiography is that it is not intrusive. Radiography does expose the object to radiation, but these levels are low. In fact, they are much lower than the radiation levels required for medical X-rays. While technicians and staff conducting the X-ray must use protective gear, the object is not damaged during the process. [4] [5] Furthermore, the use of radiography is widely accepted by conservators, art historians, and archaeologists. [6] Several institutions around the world conduct radiography of objects in their collections including the Victoria & Albert Museum in London, England and the Smithsonian, which operates the Museum Conservation Institute.

Radiography of paintings

The Ghent Altarpiece at the Altaussee Mine, where it was stored by the Nazis after it was taken from St Bavo's Cathedral, Ghent. It was later recovered by the Monuments Men. Lt. Daniel J. Kern and Karl Sieber examining the Ghent Altarpiece in the Altaussee mine, 1945.jpg
The Ghent Altarpiece at the Altaussee Mine, where it was stored by the Nazis after it was taken from St Bavo's Cathedral, Ghent. It was later recovered by the Monuments Men.

Conservators and art historians have used radiography to uncover technical information about paintings. Compositions of materials, previous alterations, and painting techniques have been revealed in X-rays. [7] This data has also been used to date works and identify forgeries. [8] Diagnostic and therapeutic x-ray systems are generally used to produce X-rays of paintings. [9] Infrared reflectography has also been used to see underdrawings and previous markings on painted canvases. [10]

Paints are produced with a variety of elements. Depending on how much these pigments absorb X-rays affects how clear or opaque they will appear in the radiograph, this is known as X-ray fluorescence. [11] [12] Lead white, for example, will absorb more rays and appear much more opaque on an x-radiograph than carbon black, which will allow most of the x-rays to pass through resulting in a clearer result on the radiograph. [13] [14] To produce a radiograph of a painting, the radiographic film is placed on the painted surface and the X-ray tube is placed behind the canvas. [15] [16]

Implementation

The Syndics of the Drapers' Guild by Rembrandt is in the collection of the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam. Netherlands-4183 - The Syndics, Rembrandt.jpg
The Syndics of the Drapers' Guild by Rembrandt is in the collection of the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam.

An X-ray of the Ghent Altarpiece, painted by Jan van Eyck, in Saint Bavo Cathedral in Ghent, Belgium revealed the structure and details of the large altarpiece’s painting scheme. The complete radiography of the altarpiece was conducted between 2010 and 2011 as part of a project largely funded by the Getty Institute. The X-rays and other technical information that was gathered were used to prepare conservation treatments. [17]

The Sampling Officials of the Amsterdam Drapers’ Guild, also known as the Syndics of the Drapers' Guild or more simply as the Syndics, was painted by Rembrandt in 1662. An X-ray of the painting revealed that Rembrandt fine-tuned the composition several times, alternating the glances between the figures and slightly changing their positions before he settled on that is known today. [18]

X-ray analysis revealed alterations to the paint of a sixteenth century portrait that had been identified as a Bronzino portrait of Eleanor of Toledo at the Carnegie Museum of Art in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. After a conservation treatment, which removed the added paint, the subject of the portrait was found to be Isabella de' Medici. The painting was also attributed to Alessandro Allori. [19] [20]

An X-ray of the Syndics reveals Rembrandt's earlier compositions for the group portrait. De Staalmeesters x-ray.jpg
An X-ray of the Syndics reveals Rembrandt's earlier compositions for the group portrait.

Jean-François Millet’s The Wood Sawyers at Victoria & Albert Museum was X-rayed, revealing that Millet had reused a canvas to complete this oil painting. The artist not only painted over a previous work, but he had also added strips of canvas to enlarge the painting area. [21]

According to X-rays taken of Twilight by Jean Baptiste Camille Corot, also at the Victoria & Albert Museum, the artist painted over a previous picture that had not even dried yet. Pigments from the lower painting appear through cracks in the surface layer. [22]

The Old Guitarist by Pablo Picasso at the Art Institute of Chicago had been previously examined with visible and ultraviolet light, which had hinted at the possibility of an earlier composition. X-rays of the painting revealed that Picasso had originally painted two female figures behind the guitarist. The X-rays also penetrated far enough to reveal how Picasso had prepared the wooden panel for painting. [23]

Radiography of sculpture and other three dimensional objects

Detail of Tiffany glass. Bella apartment window by Louis Comfort Tiffany, c. 1880, Metropolitan Museum of Art.JPG
Detail of Tiffany glass.

X-rays can provide a better picture of plaster casts and other works that rely on internal supports. However, size and mobility can often affect whether or not radiography is an option for sculptural works. X-rays can also identify cracks and previous repairs to glass and ceramic materials, which is important for assessing the condition. [24] This information can also reveal details about the manufacturing process, which may be instrumental in providing establishing place of manufacture, and possibly also reveal inherent vices that are not visible to the naked eye. [25] Jewelry and other objects with inlaid pieces have been X-rayed to reveal more about their structure. [26]

Implementation

Radiograph of the African Songye Power Figure at the Indianapolis Museum of Art. Detailed Radiographic Image of an African Songye Power Figure in the collection of the Indianapolis Museum of Art (2005.21).jpg
Radiograph of the African Songye Power Figure at the Indianapolis Museum of Art.

The plaster cast of Michelangelo’s David at the Victoria & Albert Museum was X-rayed revealing that the supports in David’s legs were positioned similarly to that of bones in a human leg. The size of this particular piece required a portable machine to complete the X-rays. [27]

The Museum of Applied Arts in Vienna, the Research Centre Seibersdorf  [ de ], and the New York Historical Society have used X-rays to learn more about the manufacture of art nouveau style glass. In particular, they are investigating differences between Tiffany glass of New York and Austria’s Loetz glass to learn more about differences in the manufacturing process. [28]

In the X-rays of a wooden power figure at the Indianapolis Museum of Art, conservators discovered that there were hollowed out sections through the center of the sculpture that connected three filled cavities. Information about the network inside of these sculptures has aided curators as they research the function of these pieces. The findings have led to the use of radiography to compare power figures in other collections. [29]

Radiography of Textiles

X-rays can reveal information about layers of textiles and stitching patterns. For quilts, for instance, different textile types and other materials are used. [30] These materials are often hidden in the finished quilt. Therefore, x-radiography can provide conservators with useful information. For other textiles X-rays can also provide conservators with information about dyes since metallic mordant has historically been used in the dye making process. Details about stitching patterns can also appear on X-rays. [31] The Victoria & Albert Museum has used X-rays as a tool for several textile conservation projects.

An x-ray of foot inside a shoe. American X-ray journal (1899) (14756518452).jpg
An x-ray of foot inside a shoe.

Implementation

X-rays of the King George III Golden Jubilee Quilt from 1810 revealed concealed stitching patterns and fabric dyes. [32]

Conservators learned more about the complex stitching of the Sundial Coverlet, which dates to 1797, through X-rays. [33]

X-rays were used to understand some of the stains and stitching patterns on an Egyptian tunic, dating to AD 600-799, in the Victoria & Albert collection. [34]

Hidden design and structure details were visible on X-rays of pairs of shoes in the V&A’s collection. [35]

Radiography in Archaeology

A mummy on display at the Louvre. X-rays provide a non-obtrusive way to research mummies. Mummy at Louvre.jpg
A mummy on display at the Louvre. X-rays provide a non-obtrusive way to research mummies.
Images of the Archimedes Palimpsest were taken under various lighting conditions to uncover gaps and alterations to the text. ArPalimTyp2.jpg
Images of the Archimedes Palimpsest were taken under various lighting conditions to uncover gaps and alterations to the text.

Archaeological materials have also benefited from X-rays. X-rays of soil segments have revealed artifacts that have eroded away, leaving them nearly undetectable to the naked eye. [36] Worn and damaged surfaces, which appear unmarked, have yielded inscriptions or other markings on X-rays. [37] Heavily corroded metal objects have also used X-rays to learn more about their original state. [38] Industrial and medical CT scans have also been used by archaeologists to study a variety of artifacts. [39] [40] [41] Underwater archaeologists have utilized X-rays to see what is beneath layers of concretions.

Implementation

Radiography has been used with human dry bones to diagnose pathologies, demonstrate trauma and assist age estimation through dentition eruption status. [42]

X-rays have been employed to analyze what is under the wrappings of mummies. [43] In addition to providing images of the bones within, X-rays have revealed the location of jewelry and other objects that were buried with the body without disturbing the wrappings.

The Herculaneum papyri that survived the Vesuvius disaster were excavated and researchers have used X-rays to read their contents. Previous methods involved slowly unrolling the papyrus, which damaged much of the scrolls, some beyond repair. [44]

X-ray technology was used to quickly identify individual coins uncovered in a single container. Researchers did not have to wait for slower, traditional conservation methods to separate and decipher the coins. [45]

X-rays were among the imaging techniques used to uncover lost text on the Archimedes Palimpsest, which is in the collection of the Walters Museum in Baltimore, Maryland. The museum spearheaded an extensive research project on the palimpsest that employed various imaging techniques including ultraviolet, infrared, and x-radiography. [46]

The heavily corroded Antikythera mechanism, which was uncovered from a shipwreck at the beginning of the 20th century, has been X-rayed several times in an effort to understand how it works.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation and restoration of cultural property</span> Process of protecting cultural property

The conservation and restoration of cultural property focuses on protection and care of cultural property, including artworks, architecture, archaeology, and museum collections. Conservation activities include preventive conservation, examination, documentation, research, treatment, and education. This field is closely allied with conservation science, curators and registrars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Victoria and Albert Museum</span> Art museum in London, England

The Victoria and Albert Museum in London is the world's largest museum of applied arts, decorative arts and design, housing a permanent collection of over 2.27 million objects. It was founded in 1852 and named after Queen Victoria and Prince Albert.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Orpiment</span> Orange-yellow arsenic sulfide mineral

Orpiment is a deep-colored, orange-yellow arsenic sulfide mineral with formula As
2
S
3
. It is found in volcanic fumaroles, low-temperature hydrothermal veins, and hot springs and is formed both by sublimation and as a byproduct of the decay of another arsenic sulfide mineral, realgar. Orpiment takes its name from the Latin auripigmentum because of its deep-yellow color. Orpiment is widely used in ancient artistic creations, medicine, and other fields. Orpiment is toxic and hard to conserve, and is no longer commonly used in contemporary times.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservator-restorer</span> Professional responsible for the preservation of artistic and cultural artifacts

A conservator-restorer is a professional responsible for the preservation of artistic and cultural artifacts, also known as cultural heritage. Conservators possess the expertise to preserve cultural heritage in a way that retains the integrity of the object, building or site, including its historical significance, context and aesthetic or visual aspects. This kind of preservation is done by analyzing and assessing the condition of cultural property, understanding processes and evidence of deterioration, planning collections care or site management strategies that prevent damage, carrying out conservation treatments, and conducting research. A conservator's job is to ensure that the objects in a museum's collection are kept in the best possible condition, as well as to serve the museum's mission to bring art before the public.

Conservation and restoration of movable cultural property is a term used to denote the conservation of movable cultural property items in libraries, archives, museums and private collections. Conservation encompasses all the actions taken toward the long-term preservation of cultural heritage. Activities include examination, documentation, treatment, and preventive care, which is supported by research and education. Object conservation is specifically the actions taken to preserve and restore cultural objects. The objects span a wide range of materials from a variety of cultures, time periods, and functions. Object conservation can be applied to both art objects and artifacts. Conservation practice aims to prevent damage from occurring, a process known as 'preventive conservation'. The purpose of preventive conservation is to maintain, and where possible enhance, the condition of an object, as well as managing deterioration risks, such as handling and environmental conditions. Historically, object conservation was focused on the category of fine arts but now many different types of objects are conserved. Each type of object material, typically denoted by organic or inorganic then the specific medium, requires a specialized professional conservator and often requires collaborative work between museum staff, scientists, and conservators.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation and restoration of iron and steel objects</span>

Iron, steel, and ferrous metals constitute a large portion of collections in museums. The conservation and restoration of iron and steel objects is an activity dedicated to the preservation and protection of objects of historical and personal value made from iron or steel. When applied to cultural heritage this activity is generally undertaken by a conservator-restorer. Historically, objects made from iron or steel were created for religious, artistic, technical, military and domestic uses. Though it is generally not possible to completely halt deterioration of any object, the act of conservation and restoration strives to prevent and slow the deterioration of the object as well as protecting the object for future use. One of the first steps in caring for iron is to examine them and determine their state, determine if they are corroding, and consider options for treatment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paintings conservator</span>

A paintings conservator is an individual responsible for protecting cultural heritage in the form of painted works of art. These individuals are most often under the employ of museums, conservation centers, or other cultural institutions. They oversee the physical care of collections, and are trained in chemistry and practical application of techniques for repairing and restoring paintings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Objects conservator</span>

An Objects conservator is a professional, working in a museum setting or private practice, that specializes in the conservation of three-dimensional works. They undergo specialized education, training, and experience that allows them to formulate and implement preventive strategies and invasive treatment protocols to preserve cultural property for the future. Objects conservators typically specialize in one type of material or class of cultural property, including metals, archaeological artifacts, ethnographic artifacts, glass, and ceramic art. Objects conservation presents many challenges due to their three-dimensional form and composite nature.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation scientist</span>

A conservation scientist is a museum professional who works in the field of conservation science and whose focus is on the research of cultural heritage through scientific inquiry. Conservation scientists conduct applied scientific research and techniques to determine the material, chemical, and technical aspects of cultural heritage. The technical information conservation scientists gather is then used by conservator and curators to decide the most suitable conservation treatments for the examined object and/or adds to our knowledge about the object by providing answers about the material composition, fabrication, authenticity, and previous restoration treatments.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation and restoration of musical instruments</span>

The conservation and restoration of musical instruments is performed by conservator-restorers who are professionals, properly trained to preserve or protect historical and current musical instruments from past or future damage or deterioration. Because musical instruments can be made entirely of, or simply contain, a wide variety of materials such as plastics, woods, metals, silks, and skin, to name a few, a conservator should be well-trained in how to properly examine the many types of construction materials used in order to provide the highest level or preventive and restorative conservation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation and restoration of painting frames</span>

The conservation and restoration of painting frames is the process through which picture frames are preserved. Frame conservation and restoration includes general cleaning of the frame, as well as in depth processes such as replacing damaged ornamentation, gilding, and toning.

Conservation and restoration at the Smithsonian Institution deals with the care of the 138 million artifacts located in the collections of Smithsonian Institution. Work is conducted by one research center, the Museum Conservation Institute (MCI), and by conservators at the Smithsonian's museums, galleries, zoo. Smithsonian conservators provide myriad services to their units, including exhibit preparation of the museum collection and loan objects, advising on object care, training for future generations of conservationists, engaging in routine preventive care on a daily basis, conducting research projects related to the collections, and examining objects for evidence of manufacturing techniques and previous restorations All conservation labs collectively further the mission of the Smithsonian Institution, "the increase and diffusion of knowledge." Founded in 1846 the Smithsonian is the world's largest museum and research complex, consisting of 19 museums and galleries, the National Zoological Park, and nine research facilities.

The conservation and restoration of lacquerware prevents and mitigates deterioration or damage to objects made with lacquer. The two main types of lacquer are Asian, made with sap from the Urushi tree, and European, made with a variety of shellac and natural resins. Lacquer can be damaged by age, light, water, temperature, or damaged substrate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation and restoration of paintings</span>

The conservation and restoration of paintings is carried out by professional painting conservators. Paintings cover a wide range of various mediums, materials, and their supports. Painting types include fine art to decorative and functional objects spanning from acrylics, frescoes, and oil paint on various surfaces, egg tempera on panels and canvas, lacquer painting, water color and more. Knowing the materials of any given painting and its support allows for the proper restoration and conservation practices. All components of a painting will react to its environment differently, and impact the artwork as a whole. These material components along with collections care will determine the longevity of a painting. The first steps to conservation and restoration is preventive conservation followed by active restoration with the artist's intent in mind.

The conservation and restoration of ancient Greek pottery is a sub-section of the broader topic of conservation and restoration of ceramic objects. Ancient Greek pottery is one of the most commonly found types of artifacts from the ancient Greek world. The information learned from vase paintings forms the foundation of modern knowledge of ancient Greek art and culture. Most ancient Greek pottery is terracotta, a type of earthenware ceramic, dating from the 11th century BCE through the 1st century CE. The objects are usually excavated from archaeological sites in broken pieces, or shards, and then reassembled. Some have been discovered intact in tombs. Professional conservator-restorers, often in collaboration with curators and conservation scientists, undertake the conservation-restoration of ancient Greek pottery.

The conservation-restoration of panel paintings involves preventive and treatment measures taken by paintings conservators to slow deterioration, preserve, and repair damage. Panel paintings consist of a wood support, a ground, and an image layer. They are typically constructed of two or more panels joined together by crossbeam braces which can separate due to age and material instability caused by fluctuations in relative humidity and temperature. These factors compromise structural integrity and can lead to warping and paint flaking. Because wood is particularly susceptible to pest damage, an IPM plan and regulation of the conditions in storage and display are essential. Past treatments that have fallen out of favor because they can cause permanent damage include transfer of the painting onto a new support, planing, and heavy cradling. Today's conservators often have to remediate damage from previous restoration efforts. Modern conservation-restoration techniques favor minimal intervention that accommodates wood's natural tendency to react to environmental changes. Treatments may include applying flexible battens to minimize deformation or simply leaving distortions alone, instead focusing on preventive care to preserve the artwork in its original state.

Cultural property imaging is a necessary part of long term preservation of cultural heritage. While the physical conditions of objects will change over time, imaging serves as a way to document and represent heritage in a moment in time of the life of the item. Different methods of imaging produce results that are applicable in various circumstances. Not every method is appropriate for every object, and not every object needs to be imaged by multiple methods. In addition to preservation and conservation related concerns, imaging can also serve to enhance research and study of cultural heritage.

The conservation and restoration of Pompeian frescoes describes the activities, methods, and techniques that have historically been and are currently being used to care for the preserved remains of the frescoes from the archeological site of Pompeii, Italy. The ancient city of Pompeii is famously known for its demise in A.D. 79 after the fatal eruption of Mount Vesuvius wiped out the population and buried the city beneath layers of compact lava material. In 1738, King Charles III or Charles of Bourbon, began explorations in Portici, Resina, Castellammare di Stabia, a Civita, where it was believed that the ancient cities of Pompeii, Stabiae, and Herculaneum were buried beneath. The first phase of the excavations at Pompeii started in 1748, which led to the first conservation and restoration efforts of the frescoes since their burial, and in 1764, open-air excavations began at Pompeii. Pompeii has a long history of excavation and restoration that began without a strong foundation or strategy. After centuries of cronyism, recurring financial shortages, and on-again-off-again restoration, the city's frescoes and structures were left in poor condition. In 1997, Pompeii was added to the UNESCO List of World Heritage Sites.

Conservation-restoration of Thomas Eakins <i>The Gross Clinic</i>

The conservation-restoration of Thomas Eakins' The Gross Clinic refers to the on-going conservation-restoration treatments of American painter Thomas Eakins' 1875 painting The Gross Clinic throughout the 20th and 21st centuries. These treatments are a testament to the changing methodologies undertaken in the field of paintings conservation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservation and restoration of quilts</span>

The conservation and restoration of quilts refers to the processes involved in maintaining the integrity of quilts and/or restoring them to an acceptable standard so that they may be preserved for future generations. Quilts have been produced for centuries, as utilitarian blankets, decorations, family heirlooms, and now treasured museum collections objects. Quilts are three-layered textile pieces with a decorated top, a back, and a filler in the middle. The composite nature of these objects creates an interesting challenge for their conservation, as the separate layers can be made of different textile materials, multiple colors, and therefore, varying degrees of wear, tear, and damage.

References

  1. Monico L, Van der Snickt G, Janssens K, De Nolf W, Miliani C, Verbeeck J, Tian H, Tan H, Dik J, Radepont M, Cotte M (2011). "Degradation Process of Lead Chromate in Paintings by Vincent van Gogh Studied by Means of Synchrotron X-ray Spectromicroscopy and Related Methods. 1. Artificially Aged Model Samples". Analytical Chemistry. 83 (4): 1214–1223. doi:10.1021/ac102424h. PMID   21314201.Monico L, Van der Snickt G, Janssens K, De Nolf W, Miliani C, Dik J, Radepont M, Hendriks E, Geldof M, Cotte M (2011). "Degradation Process of Lead Chromate in Paintings by Vincent van Gogh Studied by Means of Synchrotron X-ray Spectromicroscopy and Related Methods. 2. Original Paint Layer Samples" (PDF). Analytical Chemistry. 83 (4): 1224–1231. doi:10.1021/ac1025122. PMID   21314202. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2017-03-31. Retrieved 2020-11-21.
  2. Dambrogio, Jana; Ghassaei, Amanda; Staraza Smith, Daniel; Jackson, Holly; Demaine, Martin L. (2 March 2021). "Unlocking history through automated virtual unfolding of sealed documents imaged by X-ray microtomography". Nature Communications. 12 (1): 1184. doi: 10.1038/s41467-021-21326-w . PMC   7925573 . PMID   33654094. S2CID   232102719.
  3. Art Conservation at the University of Delaware (2014). X-radiography. Retrieved from artcons.udel.edu
  4. Pigments through the Ages: X-rays. (n.d.) Retrieved from webexhibits.org
  5. Schreiner, B., Frühmann, B., Jembrih-Simbürger, D. & Linke, R. (2004). X-rays in art and archaeology: An overview. International Centre for Diffraction Data. Retrieved from icdd.com
  6. Schreiner, B., Frühmann, B., Jembrih-Simbürger, D. & Linke, R. (2004). X-rays in art and archaeology: An overview. International Centre for Diffraction Data. Retrieved from icdd.com
  7. The British Museum (n.d.). X-ray diffraction analysis. Retrieved from britishmuseum.org
  8. Victoria & Albert Museum (n.d.). X-radiography of paintings. Retrieved from Victoria & Albert Museum
  9. The Art Institute of Chicago (n.d.). X-Radiography. Retrieved from artic.edu
  10. Art Conservation at the University of Delaware (2014). Infrared Reflectography. Retrieved from artcons.udel.edu
  11. Pigments through the Ages: X-rays. (n.d.) Retrieved from webexhibits.org
  12. Art Conservation at the University of Delaware (2014). X-ray fluorescence. Retrieved from artcons.udel.edu
  13. Pigments through the Ages: X-rays. (n.d.) Retrieved from webexhibits.org
  14. The National Gallery (n.d.). X-rays. Retrieved from nationalgallery.org.uk
  15. Art Conservation at the University of Delaware (2014). X-radiography. Retrieved from artcons.udel.edu
  16. Pigments through the Ages: X-rays. (n.d.) Retrieved from webexhibits.org/
  17. Closer to Van Eyck: Rediscovering the Ghent Altarpiece (2011). Retrieved from closertovaneyck.kikirpa.be
  18. "Late Rembrandt - The Syndics, 1662". KPN Late Rembrandt. Retrieved 2015-12-04.
  19. Rouvalis, C. (2014). The tedious intrigue of art conservation: How Carnegie Museum of Art conservators expose fakes, restore past glory, and play doctor to every art form imaginable. Carnegie Magazine, Spring 2014. Retrieved from carnegiemuseums.org
  20. Cascone, S. (2014 July 1). Carnegie conservators reveal true face of Medici portrait. Retrieved from Artnet News.
  21. Victoria & Albert Museum (n.d.). X-radiography of paintings. Retrieved from vam.ac.uk
  22. Victoria & Albert Museum (n.d.). X-radiography of paintings. Retrieved from vam.ac.uk
  23. The Art Institute of Chicago (n.d.). X-Radiography. Retrieved from artic.edu
  24. Pigments through the Ages: X-rays. (n.d.) Retrieved from webexhibits.org
  25. Schreiner, B., Frühmann, B., Jembrih-Simbürger, D. & Linke, R. (2004). X-rays in art and archaeology: An overview. International Centre for Diffraction Data. Retrieved from icdd.com
  26. The British Museum (n.d.). X-ray diffraction analysis. Retrieved from britishmuseum.org
  27. Puisto, J. (2014). David revealed! Victoria & Albert Conservation Blog. Retrieved from vam.ac.uk
  28. Schreiner, B., Frühmann, B., Jembrih-Simbürger, D. & Linke, R. (2004). X-rays in art and archaeology: An overview Retrieved from the International Centre for Diffraction Data
  29. "The Songye X-ray Project". IMA Magazine. Indianapolis Museum of Art. Spring 2010.
  30. Hackett, J. (2011). X-radiography as a tool to examine the making and remaking of historic quilts. Victoria & Albert Online Journal 3(Spring 2011). Retrieved from vam.ac.uk
  31. Hackett, J. (2011). X-radiography as a tool to examine the making and remaking of historic quilts. Victoria & Albert Online Journal 3(Spring 2011). Retrieved from vam.ac.uk
  32. Hackett, J. (2011). X-radiography as a tool to examine the making and remaking of historic quilts. Victoria & Albert Online Journal 3(Spring 2011). Retrieved from vam.ac.uk
  33. Hackett, J. (2011). X-radiography as a tool to examine the making and remaking of historic quilts. Victoria & Albert Online Journal 3(Spring 2011). Retrieved from vam.ac.uk
  34. Haldane, E., Gillies, S., O’Connor, S., Batt, C. & Stern, B. (2009). Victoria & Albert Conservation Journal 57(Spring 2009). Retrieved from vam.ac.uk
  35. Glenn, S. (2013). Seeing the unseen. Victoria & Albert Conservation Blog. Retrieved from vam.ac.uk
  36. Re, A., Corsi, J., Demmelbauer, M., Martini, M., Mila, G. & Ricci, C. (2015). X-ray tomography of a soil block: useful tool for the restoration of archaeological finds. Heritage Science 2015 3(4). Retrieved from heritagesciencejournal.com
  37. Palmer, J. (2011). X-ray technique peers beneath archaeology’s surface. Retrieved from BBC news.
  38. Schreiner, B., Frühmann, B., Jembrih-Simbürger, D. & Linke, R. (2004). X-rays in art and archaeology: An overview. International Centre for Diffraction Data. Retrieved from icdd.com
  39. Kennedy, M. (2012). X-rays reveal secrets of Roman coins. The Guardian. Retrieved from theguardian.com
  40. Gleeson, M. (2015). Animal mummy X-rays. Retrieved from The Penn Artifact Lab.
  41. Re, A., Corsi, J., Demmelbauer, M., Martini, M., Mila, G. & Ricci, C. (2015). X-ray tomography of a soil block: useful tool for the restoration of archaeological finds. Heritage Science 2015 3(4). Retrieved from heritagesciencejournal.com
  42. Elliott, J. (2022). "Radiographic Technique for Archaeological Human Dry Bones: a scoping review". Internet Archaeology (59). doi: 10.11141/ia.59.1 .
  43. Gleeson, M. (2015). Animal mummy X-rays. Retrieved from The Penn Artifact Lab.
  44. Vergano, D. (2015). X-rays reveal snippets from papyrus scrolls that survived Mount Vesuvius. Retrieved from The National Geographic
  45. Kennedy, M. (2012). X-rays reveal secrets of Roman coins. Retrieved from The Guardian.
  46. The Archimedes Palimpsest: A-ray fluorescence imaging (n.d.). Retrieved from archimedespalimpsest.org