Judiciary of the Czech Republic

Last updated

The Judiciary of the Czech Republic is set out in the Constitution, which defines courts as independent institutions within the constitutional framework of checks and balances. [1]

Contents

The whole of chapter four of the Constitution of the Czech Republic is dedicated to defining the role of judicial power in the Czech Republic. It states the main function of courts of law is the protection of rights in a manner defined by legislation, and gives them sole responsibility for determining guilt and administering penalties for criminal offences. [2] Courts are defined as independent, [3] although their administration is in the hands of the Ministry of Justice.

Czech courts are presided over by professional judges, who are named for life by the President and normally may not be recalled or transferred against their will. [4]

The Czech Republic has a four-tier system of courts and two-instance proceedings. [5]

Most of the higher courts are seated in Brno; this is to counterbalance the concentration of power in the capital (pragocentrismus).

Courts

General courts in the Czech Republic MapOfCzechJustice.PNG
General courts in the Czech Republic
Allegory of Justice on the facade of the District Court in Olomouc Justice statue.jpg
Allegory of Justice on the facade of the District Court in Olomouc
The "Ruling in the Name of the Republic" (Rozsudek jmenem republiky
) of the Regional Court in Prague in a civil matter Rozsudek 36 C 8 2008-141.pdf
The "Ruling in the Name of the Republic" (Rozsudek jménem republiky) of the Regional Court in Prague in a civil matter
Seat of the Constitutional Court in Brno Brno, Jostova str.jpg
Seat of the Constitutional Court in Brno
Courtroom at district court Soudni sin.jpg
Courtroom at district court

While the broad strokes are set out in the Constitution and the Charter of Fundamental Rights and Basic Freedoms, [6] the organization of the judiciary is detailed in the Act No. 6/2002 Coll. on Courts and Judges. [cs 1]

The four tiers of Czech courts are: [5] [7] [8]

  1. 2 supreme courts (nejvyšší soudy) – one for ordinary and one for administrative matters
  2. 2 high courts (vrchní soud) – one in Prague and one in Olomouc
  3. 8 regional courts (krajské soudy)
  4. 86 district courts (okresní soudy)

There are three different jurisdictions: [7]

The latter two are specialised jurisdictions – if a matter is not assigned to them specifically (by legislation), it will be dealt with the courts of general jurisdiction. [7]

The Constitutional Court

The Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic (Ústavní soud České republiky) stands outside the general courts structure. [5] Its status and powers are enshrined directly in the Constitution of the Czech Republic. [9] It is the judicial body responsible for constitutionality and the protection of fundamental human rights and freedoms that arise from constitutional order [10] of the Czech Republic and to guarantee the constitutional character of the exercise of state power.

This it achieves mainly through its power to annul statutes (or parts of them) if they are in conflict with the constitutional order (most important of them, the Constitution and the Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms). This is because laws that are part of the constitutional order are legislative acts of the highest force, their enactment also requires a special majority in the parliament. Any other legislation is subordinate. This process is called the judicial review. Related to this is the power of the court to decide about the conformity with the constitutional order of an international treaty prior to its ratification. [11]

The seat of the court is in Brno. [12]

Ordinary courts

Both criminal and civil case can start at either a district court or a regional court; in other words, district and regional courts act as courts of the first instance. For example, in criminal proceedings, the district courts would generally hear cases in first instance. However, when the penalty for the crime in question exceeds 5 years, the case will be tried by a regional court as a court of the first instance. [5]

Boundaries of the district court jurisdictions are, confusingly, non-conterminous with those of the administrative districts. [13]

Of the two high courts, one is seated in Prague with jurisdiction over Bohemia, the other in Olomouc with jurisdiction over Moravia and Silesia. Naturally, these will handle an appeal of a case heard in the first instance by a regional court.

The Supreme Court of the Czech Republic (Nejvyšší soud České republiky), seated in Brno, is the highest judicial authority both in civil (including commercial) and criminal matters, except for issues that fall within the competence of the Constitutional Court or the Supreme Administrative Court. [14] As a court of third instance it works on the principles of cassation (review) and appeal. [15]

Administrative courts

Czech administrative judiciary (správní soudnictví) has two layers. The lower one consists of specialised administrative chambers within regional courts, which act as courts of first instance. The court of second and last instance is the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic (Nejvyšší správní soud České republiky), seated in Brno, which, as the name suggests, is dedicated exclusively to administrative justice. [16]

Matters falling within the competence of administrative courts include cases relating to elections, registration of political parties and movements and actions for competence issues between government agencies.

Officials

The most important characters in all proceedings are professional judges (soudce) and advocates (advokát), in criminal trials also state prosecutors (státní zástupce), and sometimes lay judges ( přísedící ). Note that other legal professions exist, not directly involved in court proceedings – notaries (notář) and bailiffs (soudní exekutor). [7]

Judge

The judge (soudce) is indeed the central figure of the Czech judiciary, as only his position is defined by the Constitution itself. There is no such thing as jury in Czech courts and the judge himself (or a panel of judges) decides both the verdict and the sentence.

The Czech Republic has a system of career judiciary. The Constitution stipulates that judges are appointed for life by the President of the Republic, and cannot normally be recalled. [17] Submitted by the Minister of Justice, the appointments are subject to co-signing by the Prime Minister. The Constitution requires a judge to be a graduate of a law school, a person with full integrity (no criminal record) and states the position is incompatible with political functions. [18] Further regulations specifies he must be at least 30 and go through a three years of specialised training within the courts. [7]

Since the judiciary is to be kept from influences of the executive and the legislator, all disciplinary matters of judges (as well as state prosecutors) are to be dealt with by the judiciary itself, in particular by the disciplinary chambers of the Supreme Administrative Court. [19]

It does not help the reputation of judges, that around 1,000 of them have been members of the pre-1989 Communist Party, according to a list published by the Ministry of Justice. [20] [21] In the socialist legal system, law and judges were tools of the state, dedicated to punishment of its enemies.

Public prosecutor

The only body capable of bringing a criminal court action is the state prosecutor. The State Prosecutors' Bureau (státní zastupitelství) is part of the Ministry of Justice.

Advocate

All legally educated persons providing legal representation in court (and giving advice and other services) are called advokát. To be allowed to legally practise law in the Czech Republic, an advocate must first obtain a master's degree from a faculty of law, a prospective advocate must complete 3 years of professional training crowned by passing the bar examination. He must then become a member of the Czech Bar Association (Česká advokátní komora). Members of equivalent bodies in other EU member states are also allowed. [22]

Lay judge

Lay judges sit with a professional judge in the first instance of a non-specialized trial. They are appointed by local councils; [7] by municipal councils (zastupitelstvo obce) in district courts, and by regional councils (zastupitelstvo kraje) in regional courts. The whole institution is a bit of a leftover of the communist idea of popularization of justice. [15]

Law

The Czech Republic has a legal system of the continental type, rooted in Germanic legal culture. The main source of law is written legislature. Its main areas are systematically codified, mainly in Civil Code and Criminal Code. The form of court proceeding is prescribed in the Codes of Criminal, Civil and Administrative Procedure. The legal force of different Czech legal sources is hierarchical. [7]

Procedure

Court proceedings are oral and public, with exceptions stated by law (juvenile justice etc.). The procedure is based on inquisitorial system with features of the adversarial system. There is no jury.

For criminal procedure, the chief regulation is Act No. 141/1961 Coll., the Code of Criminal Procedure. [cs 2] In the chapter on preparatory procedure it sets out the role of the bodies involved in criminal proceedings (orgány činné v trestním řízení, namely the police, the public prosecutor and the court) while preparing the prosecution, such as interviewing the witnesses and gathering evidence. The chapter on court proceedings sets out procedures for criminal charge, trial, and appeal process. Although in force since 1961, the code has been amended many times since 1989, adding radically new features, such as plea bargaining (in 2012). In Act No. 218/2003 Coll., on Juvenile Criminal Procedure, [cs 3] separate procedure has been introduced for minors.

The civil procedure is governed by a number of statutes, most importantly Act. No. 99/1963 Coll., the Code of Civil Procedure. [cs 4]

Administrative justice, deals with claims of natural and legal persons, who seek protection from illegal decisions or action of public authorities. While in many respects similar to civil procedure, the administrative court procedure is different in that the defendant here is not an entity of private law, but a public body. Not being a legal person, such a public body could not be sued otherwise. Administrative matters are usually adjudicated by regional courts, and follow the procedure set out in Act. No. 150/2002, the Code of Administrative Procedure. [23] [cs 5]

Pardon and amnesty

Czech president is endowed by the Constitution with extrajudicial power of interfering in criminal proceedings, before, during and after the trial. He can "pardon and mitigate penalties imposed by the court, order not to initiate criminal proceedings and suspend them if they are already initiated, and expunge sentences" (as if they never happened). [24] When he does so en masse, this is called amnesty. This prerogative had been used several times by Václav Havel in order to stress the discontinuity with pre-1989 socialist regime.

In 2013 Václav Klaus gave amnesty to about a third of prisoners disillusioning the public and attracting criticism from many, including senior judges. In the heart of the controversy appeared stopping of serious fraud cases, when the court proceedings had dragged on for more than eight years. Defending the step, Klaus mentioned the critique by the EU for lengthy court proceedings. His critics, on the other hand, argued that he needlessly interrupted delivering of justice in difficult, high-profile cases of serious financial crime, rouge privatisation and corruption. [25] [26] [27] The Senate took a court action against the president, alleging high treason at the Constitutional Court. [28] However, the Constitutional Court rejected the treason charges on the grounds that Klaus could not be charged with constitutional violations - given the fact that the charges came on the eve of the end of Klaus's term. [29]

Analysis and criticism

Access to justice

The report of European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights [30] criticizes the Czech Republic mainly for costs and length of legal proceedings, which is a long-term and endemic problem. It says: "In the Czech Republic, for example, where a considerable length of proceedings is suggested to be de-motivating for victims of discrimination, the average duration of civil proceedings can take several years in one region, yet only a few months in another." It is also said to be the most frequent problem across the EU. [31] Other issues mentioned are that legal aid is not quite sufficient (a new law is being prepared) as well as an imperfect Antidiscrimination Act, which, among other things, stipulates reverse burden of proof in antidiscrimination cases. [32]

Amnesty International's reports on the state of human rights repeatedly bring up the discrimination against Roma, especially in education. [33]

See also

Related Research Articles

Politics of the Czech Republic Political system of the Czech Republic

The Czech Republic is a unitary parliamentary constitutional republic, in which the President is the head of state and the Prime Minister is the head of government.
Executive power is exercised by the Government of the Czech Republic which reports to the Chamber of Deputies. The Legislature is exercised by the Parliament. Czech Parliament is bicameral, the upper house of the Parliament is the Senate, the lower house of the Parliament is the Chamber of Deputies. The Senate consists of 81 members who are elected for six years. The Chamber of Deputies consists of 200 members who are elected for four years. The Judiciary system is topped by the trio of Constitutional Court, Supreme Court and Supreme Administrative Court.
The highest legal document is the Constitution of the Czech Republic, complemented by constitutional laws and the Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms. The current constitution went in effect on 1st January 1993, after the Dissolution of Czechoslovakia. The Czech Republic has a multi-party system. Between 1993 and 2013, the two largest political parties were the left-wing Czech Social Democratic Party (ČSSD) and right-wing Civic Democratic Party (ODS). This changed in early 2014, with the rise of a new major political party ANO 2011, which has since lead two cabinets.
The Economist Intelligence Unit rated Czech Republic a "flawed democracy" in 2019.

Judicial Yuan

The Judicial Yuan is the judicial branch of the government of the Republic of China on Taiwan. It runs a Constitutional Court and oversees all systems of courts in Taiwan, including ordinary courts like the supreme court, high courts, district courts as well as special courts like administrative courts and disciplinary courts. By Taiwanese law, the Judicial Yuan holds the following powers:

Federal Supreme Court of Switzerland Supreme court of Switzerland

The Federal Supreme Court of Switzerland is the supreme court of the Swiss Confederation and at the head of the Swiss judiciary.

Legal system of Macau

Macau law is broadly based on Portuguese law, and therefore part of the civil law tradition of continental European legal systems. Portuguese law is itself highly influenced by German law. However, many other influences are present, including Chinese law, Italian law, and some narrow aspects of common law.

Judiciary of Russia

The Judiciary of Russia interprets and applies the law of Russia. It is defined under the Constitution and law with a hierarchical structure with the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court at the apex. The district courts are the primary criminal trial courts, and the regional courts are the primary appellate courts. The judiciary is governed by the All-Russian Congress of Judges and its Council of Judges, and its management is aided by the Judicial Department of the Supreme Court, the Judicial Qualification Collegia, the Ministry of Justice, and the various courts' chairpersons. And although there are many officers of the court, including jurors, the Prosecutor General remains the most powerful component of the Russian judicial system.

Judicial system of Turkey

The judicial system of Turkey is defined by Articles 138 to 160 of the Constitution of Turkey.

Law of Brazil

The law of Brazil is based on statutes and, partly and more recently, a mechanism called súmulas vinculantes. It derives mainly from the civil law systems of European countries, particularly Portugal, the Napoleonic Code and the Germanic law.

Supreme court Highest court in a jurisdiction

The supreme court is the highest court within the hierarchy of courts in many legal jurisdictions. Other descriptions for such courts include court of last resort, apex court, and highcourt of appeal. Broadly speaking, the decisions of a supreme court are not subject to further review by any other court. Supreme courts typically function primarily as appellate courts, hearing appeals from decisions of lower trial courts, or from intermediate-level appellate courts.

Judiciary of Portugal

The Judiciary of Portugal is a system of courts that together constitute one of the four organs of Sovereignty as defined by the Portuguese Constitution. The courts are independent from the other three Portuguese organs of Sovereignty.

Supreme Court of Spain Highest court in Spain

The Supreme Court is the highest court in the Kingdom of Spain. Originally established pursuant to Title V of the Constitution of 1812 and currently regulated by Title VI of the Constitution of 1978, it has original jurisdiction over cases against high-ranking officials of the Kingdom and over cases regarding illegalization of political parties. It also has ultimate appellate jurisdiction over all cases. The Court has the power of judicial review, except for the judicial revision on constitutional matters, reserved to the Constitutional Court.

The legal system of Azerbaijan is based on civil law. As the country was a republic of the Soviet Union until 1991, its legal history has also been influenced heavily by socialist law. However, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, Azerbaijan became independent by enactment of the constitutional act of national independence on October 18, 1991. Azerbaijan started reformation of the legal system by the establishing of democratic reforms. This was followed by the adoption of the first Constitution in 1995 which is the foundation of the legislative system of the modern country. The Constitution creates the system of presidential republic with a separation of powers among the Legislative, Executive and Judicial branches of the government in order to prevent abuse of power.

Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic

The Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic is a specialized type of court which primarily works to protect the people in the Czech Republic against violations of the Constitution by either the legislature, government or by any other subject that violates people's constitutional rights and freedoms. In this respect, it is similar in functionality to the Supreme Court of the United States, but is distinct from the Supreme Court of the Czech Republic. Of all the various levels of the Czech Judiciary it is the one created with the greatest specificity in the constitution.

Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic

The Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic is the court of highest authority on issues of procedural and administrative propriety. It also has jurisdiction over many political matters, such as the formation and closure of political parties, jurisdictional boundaries between government entities, and the eligibility of persons to stand for public office. It also adjudicates in disciplinary proceedings against judges and state prosecutors. It is the court of second instance in actions against the decisions of authorities.

Supreme Court of the Czech Republic

The Supreme Court of the Czech Republic is the court of highest appeal for almost all legal cases heard in the Czech Republic. As set forth in the Constitution of the Czech Republic, however, cases of constitutionality, administrative law and political jurisdiction are heard by other courts.

Judiciary of Spain

The Judiciary of Spain consists of Courts and Tribunals, composed of judges and magistrates (Justices), who have the power to administer justice in the name of the King of Spain.

Law of the Czech Republic

Czech law, often referred to as the legal order of the Czech Republic, is the system of legal rules in force in the Czech Republic, and in the international community it is a member of. Czech legal system belongs to the Germanic branch of continental legal culture. Major areas of public and private law are divided into branches, among them civil, criminal, administrative, procedural and labour law, and systematically codified.

Judiciary of Croatia

The judiciary of Croatia is a branch of the Government of Croatia that interprets and applies the laws of Croatia, to ensure equal justice under law, and to provide a mechanism for dispute resolution. The legal system of Croatia is a civil law system, historically influenced by Austrian, Hungarian and Yugoslav law, but during the accession of Croatia to the European Union, the legal system was almost completely harmonised with European Union law. The Constitution of Croatia provides for an independent judiciary, led by a Supreme Court and a Constitutional Court. The Ministry of Justice handles the administration of courts and judiciary, including paying salaries and constructing new courthouses. It also administers the prison system.

The law of Cyprus is a legal system which applies within the Republic of Cyprus. Although Cypriot law is extensively codified, it is still heavily based on English common law in the sense that the fundamental principle of precedent applies.

Supreme Court of the Dominican Republic

The Supreme Court of the Dominican Republic is the highest court existing in the Republic and is, therefore, the head of the judiciary in the country.

The Judiciary of Azerbaijan exercises judicial power separately from the legislative power of parliament and executive power of the president.

References

  1. Czech Republic. Ministry of Foreign Affairs. "The System of Independent Courts." Hello Czech Republic (Czech Republic - The Official Website) Archived 2012-01-03 at the Wayback Machine . Ministerstvo zahraničních věcí ČR, 01 Jan. 2010. Web. 07 Dec. 2012.
  2. Constitution, Art. 90
  3. Constitution, Art. 81
  4. Constitution, Art. 82
  5. 1 2 3 4 European Union. European Commission. "The System of Courts in the Czech Republic". European Judicial Atlas in Civil Matters. European Commission, 28 Feb. 2007. Web. 7 Dec. 2012.
  6. Charter..., Chapter Five: The Right to Judicial and Other Legal Protection
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Bobek, Michal (September 2009). "UPDATE: An Introduction to the Czech Legal System and Legal Resources Online". GlobaLex (Hauser Global Law School Program). New York University School of Law . Retrieved 7 December 2012.
  8. The four levels are specifically named in the Constitution, Art. 91
  9. Constitution, Art. 89–89
  10. or constitutional laws, different renderings of Czech ústavní pořádek České republiky
  11. Czech Republic. Constitutional Court. "Competences." Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic. Ústavní soud ČR, n.d. Web. 07 Dec. 2012.
  12. Czech Republic. Constitutional Court. "Home Page." Archived 2014-11-29 at the Wayback Machine Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic. Ústavní soud ČR, n.d. Web. 07 Dec. 2012.
  13. District courts were originally conterminous with the districts of the Czech Republic (okresy). But the municipalities for each district court were explicitly named in the Law on Courts and Judges of 2002, and in 2007 the borders of the districts of the Czech Republic were slightly adjusted and many municipalities are now within different districts of the Czech Republic, making district court boundaries non-conterminous with these new districts of the Czech Republic.
  14. Constitution, Article 92
  15. 1 2 Czech Republic. Supreme Court. "General Information." Archived 2016-03-04 at the Wayback Machine The Supreme Court of the Czech Republic. Nejvyšší soud ČR, 2010. Web. 07 Dec. 2012.
  16. Czech Republic. Supreme Administrative Court. "Introduction." Supreme Administrative Court. Nejvyšší správní soud ČR, 14 Aug. 2012. Web. 07 Dec. 2012
  17. Constitution, Art. 63
  18. Constitution, Article 93
  19. Czech Republic. Supreme Administrative Court. "Disciplinary Chambers." Supreme Administrative Court. Nejvyšší správní soud ČR, 14 Aug. 2012. Web. 07 Dec. 2012
  20. Richter, Jan (10 Jan 2011). "Justice Ministry releases list of ex-communists among Czech judges and prosecutors". Radio Prague. Retrieved 7 January 2013.
  21. Contiguglia, Cat (8 Dec 2010). "Judges' communist past public". The Prague Post. Retrieved 7 January 2013.
  22. "Welcome at the Czech Bar Association". Czech Bar Association, n.d. Web. 28 Dec. 2012.
  23. Official translation available, translated as the Code of Administrative Justice
  24. Constitution, Art. 62
  25. "Czech president's mass prison amnesty draws protests". BBC News. 3 January 2013. Retrieved 10 January 2013.
  26. ČTK (1 January 2013). "Klausova amnestie je teprve čtvrtá od roku 1990". České noviny. Retrieved 10 January 2013.
  27. Ochvat, Radim (1 January 2013). "Prezident vyhlásil amnestii". www.hrad.cz, official website of the President of the Czech Republic. Czech Republic. President. Retrieved 10 January 2013.
  28. Bilefsky, Dan (4 March 2013). "Czech Senate Accuses Outgoing President of High Treason". The New York Times. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
  29. Lopatka, Jan. "Czech court throws out treason charges against ex-president Klaus". reuters.com. Reuters. Retrieved 27 September 2017.
  30. Access to justice in Europe: an overview of challenges and opportunities. European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. ISBN   978-92-9192-676-3 doi: 10.2811/171
  31. "Access to justice in Europe: an overview of challenges and opportunities". European Union Agency for Fundamental Right. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
  32. "Country thematic studies on access to justice: Czech Republic" (PDF). European Union Agency for Fundamental Right. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
  33. Czech Republic. Amnesty International Annual Report 2011. 31 Dec. 2012

Further reading

Statutes (in English)
Statutes (in Czech)