Supreme Court of Ghana

Last updated

Supreme Court of Ghana
Supreme Court of Ghana.jpg
Aerial view of the Supreme Court Buildings
Supreme Court of Ghana
5°32′43.8072″N0°12′17.3736″W / 5.545502000°N 0.204826000°W / 5.545502000; -0.204826000
Established1876;148 years ago (1876)
Location Accra, Ghana
Coordinates 5°32′43.8072″N0°12′17.3736″W / 5.545502000°N 0.204826000°W / 5.545502000; -0.204826000
Composition methodPresidential nomination, in consultation with the Council of State and with Parliamentary confirmation and approval
Authorised bySupreme Court Ordinance, 1876 and Constitution of Ghana, 1992
Judge term lengthMandatory retirement at age 70
Number of positionsA minimum of 9
Website The Judicial Service of Ghana
Chief Justice of Ghana
Currently Gertrude Torkornoo
Since12 June 2023

The Supreme Court of Ghana is the highest judicial body in Ghana. [1] Ghana's 1992 constitution guarantees the independence and separation of the Judiciary from the Legislative and the Executive arms of government. [2]

Contents

The Supreme Court of Ghana has the final say on legal matters and can overturn lower court decisions. The Court consists of nine justices and hears cases on a wide range of issues, including criminal law, civil law, and administrative law. [3]

History

The Supreme Court was established by the Supreme Court Ordinance (1876) as the highest tribunal in the Gold Coast (now Ghana) during the colonial era. [4]

Until 1960, there was a right of appeal to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London, England.

On July 2, 2013, the Supreme Court sentenced the editor of the Daily Search light newspaper, Ken Kuranchie, to 10 days in prison for calling the 9 Justices hypocritical and selective. [5] After the parliament of Ghana passed a bill allowing the cultivation of weed in the country in 2022, the Supreme Court in May 2023 struck out the cannabis cultivation bill by a 5-4 majority. [6] [7]

Role and Jurisdiction

The Supreme Court of Ghana plays a critical role in the country's legal framework. Its jurisdiction extends to a wide range of matters, including:

Current status

Aerial view of the Supreme Court building. Supreme Court of Ghana.jpg
Aerial view of the Supreme Court building.
Front view of the Supreme Court building. Ghana Supreme Court Accra.jpg
Front view of the Supreme Court building.

The 1992 constitution stipulates that the Supreme Court is made up of the Chief Justice of Ghana and not less than nine other Justices of the Supreme Court. [9] Is the final court of appeal and has jurisdiction over matters relating to the enforcement or the interpretation of constitutional law. The Chief Justice is appointed by the President of Ghana acting in consultation with the Council of State and with the approval of the country's Parliament. [10] The other Supreme Court Justices are appointed by the President acting on the advice of the Judicial Council and in consultation with the Council of State. This must also be with the approval of Parliament. [11] The 1992 Constitution abolished all the public tribunals established under the PNDC and created the Regional Tribunal whose chairman was equated with the High Court judges. [12] There is no limit on the number of judges appointed to the Supreme Court. There have been calls for there to be a cap on the number but various judges advised against it due to the demands on the court by the 1992 constitution. [13] The Court of Appeal, which includes the chief justice and not fewer than five other judges, has jurisdiction to hear and to determine appeals from any judgment, decree, or High Court of Justice order. [14] The High Court of Justice, which consists of the chief justice and not fewer than twelve other justices, has jurisdiction in all matters, civil and criminal, other than those involving treason.

The current Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Ghana is Gertrude Torkornoo.

Justices of the Supreme Court

The following is a list of the judges of the Supreme Court. [15] [16] In July 2018, President Nana Akufo-Addo appointed four new judges to the Supreme Court. They were Samuel K. Marful-Sau and Agnes M.A Dordzie, both Justices of the Appeal Court, Nii Ashie Kotey, a former Dean of the Faculty of Law at the University of Ghana and Nene A. O. Amegatcher, a lawyer in private practice who also a former president of the Ghana Bar Association. [17] One of the longest-serving judges of the Court, William Atuguba retired in the same month. He had been on the Supreme Court after being nominated by Jerry Rawlings in November 1995 [18] [19] until July 2018. [20] The last female Chief Justice was Sophia Akuffo. She was the last Supreme Court Judge appointed by Jerry Rawlings to retire. She retired on 20 December 2019 and was replaced by Kwasi Anin-Yeboah on 7 January 2020. In December 2019, President Akufo-Addo appointed three new judges to the Supreme Court. They were Mariama Owusu, Avril Lovelace-Johnson, and Gertrude Tokornoo. [21] They were to replace Vida Akoto-Bamfo, Sophia Adinyira, and Sophia Akuffo who had either retired or were due to retire. [22]

List of Justices of the Supreme Court of Ghana [23]
JudgeDate AppointedLength of serviceAppointed by
Gertrude Torkornoo
(Chief Justice)
17 December 2019 [21] 4 years, 11 months Nana Akufo-Addo
Paul Baffoe-Bonnie 11 June 2008 [24] 16 years, 5 monthsJohn Kufuor
Gabriel Pwamang 29 June 2015 [25] 9 years, 4 months John Mahama
Avril Lovelace-Johnson 17 December 2019 [21] 4 years, 11 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
Issifu Omoro Tanko Amadu 22 May 2020 [26] [27] 4 years, 5 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
Henrietta Mensa-Bonsu 26 May 2020 [28] 4 years, 5 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
Yonny Kulendi 26 May 2020 [28] 4 years, 5 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
Barbara Ackah-Yensu 28 December 2022 [29] 1 year, 10 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
Samuel Adibu Asiedu 28 December 2022 [29] 1 year, 10 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
George Kingsley Koomson 5 April 20231 year, 7 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
Ernest Gaewu 5 April 20231 year, 7 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
Henry Anthony Kwofie 3 January 202410 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
Yaw Darko Asare 3 January 202410 monthsNana Akufo-Addo
Richard Adjei-Frimpong 3 January 202410 monthsNana Akufo-Addo

List of chief justices of the Supreme Court

Since its inception in 1876, the Supreme Court has had 27 chief justices. [30]

List of chief justices of the Gold Coast and Ghana
Chief JusticeTime framePeriod
Sir David Patrick Chalmers 1876–1878Gold Coast
P. A. Smith 1878–1879Gold Coast
Sir James Marshall 1880–1882Gold Coast
N. Lessingham Bailey 1882–1886Gold Coast
H. W. Macleod 1886–1889Gold Coast
Joseph Turner Hutchinson [31] 1889 - 1894Gold Coast
Francis Smith (acting)1894 - 1895Gold Coast
Sir William Brandford Griffith 1895–1911Gold Coast
Philip Crampton Smyly 1911–1928Gold Coast
Sir George Campbell Deane 1929–1935Gold Coast
Sir Philip Bertie Petrides 1936–1943Gold Coast
Sir Walter Harrangin 1943–1947Gold Coast
Sir Mark Wilson 1948–1956Gold Coast
Sir Kobina Arku Korsah 1956–1963Gold Coast (1956 – 6 Mar 1957)
Dominion of Ghana1st Republic of Ghana (6 Mar 1957 – 1963)
J. Sarkodee-Addo 1964–19661st Republic
Edward Akufo-Addo 1966–1970military rule [32] (1966–1969)
2nd Republic (1969–1970)
Edmund Alexander Lanquaye Bannerman 1970 -19722nd Republic [33]
Samuel Azu Crabbe 1973–1977military rule [34]
Fred Kwasi Apaloo 1977–1986military rule (1977–1979)
3rd Republic [12] (24 Sep 1979-31 Dec 1981)
[35] military rule [12] (31 Dec 1981–1986)
E. N. P. Sowah 1986–1990military rule
Nicholas Yaw Boafo Adade (acting)1990–1991military rule
Philip Edward Archer 1991–1995military rule (1991–1993)
4th Republic (1993–1995)
Isaac Kobina Abban 1995 – 21 April 20014th Republic
Edward Kwame Wiredu 2001–20034th Republic
George Kingsley Acquah 4 July 2003 – 25 March 20074th Republic
Georgina Theodora Wood [36] 15 June 2007 – 8 June 20174th Republic
Sophia Akuffo 19 June 2017 – 20 December 20194th Republic
Kwasi Anin-Yeboah 7 January 2020 [37] – 24 May 20234th Republic
Gertrude Torkornoo 6 June 2023 –4th Republic

Martyrs of the Rule of Law

On 30 June 1982, during the curfew hours, three High Court Judges and a retired Army Officer, namely: Mr. Justice Frederick Poku Sarkodee, Mrs. Justice Cecilia Koranteng-Addow, Mr. Justice Kwadwo Agyei Agyepong and Major (Rtd) Sam Acquah were abducted from their homes and brutally murdered at the Bundase Military Range in the Accra Plains. [38] [39] The unfortunate victims' bodies were then doused in gasoline and set ablaze. [38] The bodies were saved from total destruction by divine intervention in the form of a light rain that put out the fire. [38]

These distinguished judges paid the ultimate price for their unwavering commitment to the rule of law and the fair administration of justice. [38]

The Ghanaian judicial system honours them each year on Martyrs Day, the day commemorating their passing. [39] This memorial is meant to serve as a source of inspiration for us as a nation as we rededicate ourselves individually and collectively to the beloved goals and principles on whose altar they made the ultimate sacrifice: Lest We Forget. [38]

Selected Landmark Decisions of the Supreme Court of Ghana

YearNameCitationAlso known asSubject Matter
1961 Re Akoto and 7 Others [1961] GLR 523 Constitutionalism
1963The State v. Otchere and Others[1963] 2 GLR 463The Kulungugu Treason trial
1970 Sallah v. Attorney-General [1970] SCGLR 55The Sallah Case Constitutional law, Natural justice
1980 Tuffour v. Attorney-General [1980] GLR 637Constitutional law, Standing (law)
1992New Patriotic Party v. Attorney-General[1992] SCGLR 3531st December CaseConstitutional law, Judicial review
1993–1994New Patriotic Party v GBC[1993–94] 2 GLR 3 [40] 54
2013Akufo-addo and Others Vrs Mahama and Another[2013] GHASC 1372012 Election petition

Critical assessment

Corruption

Controversies

Former President John Dramani Mahama in September 2022 criticized the Registrar of the Supreme Court for not setting a date to hear an application seeking an interlocutory injunction. This application aims to halt the Electoral Commission's limited voter registration until a final decision is made on a lawsuit challenging the choice of venues for the exercise. [41] [42]

Halt of Speaker Ruling 2024

On October 17, 2024, the Speaker of the Ghana Parliament, Alban Sumana Kingsford Bagbin, declared four parliamentary seats vacant after the incumbents defected to contest the 2024 parliamentary elections under different political parties. [43] [44] This decision sparked tensions, leading to a rowdy parliamentary session on October 22, 2024, where some lawmakers walked out of the chamber. Following consultations with parliamentary leadership, Bagbin exercised his discretionary powers to suspend the house indefinitely under Standing Order 59(1), citing the ongoing crisis. [45]

On October 18, 2024, the Supreme Court temporarily halted the enforcement of Bagbin’s ruling, allowing the affected MPs to retain their seats for the time being. [40] [46]

On November 12, 2024, the Supreme Court ruled against the decision of the speaker to declare four seats vacant, on the verdict that it was unconstitutional. [47]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Politics of Ghana</span>

Politics of Ghana takes place in a framework of a presidential representative democratic republic, whereby the president of Ghana is both head of state and head of government, and of a two party system. The seat of government is at Golden Jubilee House. Executive power is exercised by the government. Legislative power is vested in both the government and Parliament. The judiciary is independent of the executive and the legislature.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edward Akufo-Addo</span> 2nd president of Ghana (1970-72)

Edward Akufo-Addo was a Ghanaian politician and lawyer. He was a member of the "Big Six" leaders of the United Gold Coast Convention (UGCC) and one of the founding fathers of Ghana who engaged in the fight for Ghana's independence. He became the Chief Justice (1966–70), and later ceremonial President (1970–72), of the Republic of Ghana. He is the father of the current (executive) President of Ghana, Nana Addo Akufo-Addo.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sophia Akuffo</span> Ghanaian judge (born 1949)

Sophia Abena Boafoa Akuffo was the chief justice of Ghana from 19 June 2017 until 20 December 2019. She had been a judge in the Supreme Court of Ghana since 1995.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nana Akufo-Addo</span> President of Ghana since 2017

Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo is a Ghanaian politician who has served as the president of Ghana since 2017. He previously served as Attorney General from 2001 to 2003 and as Minister for Foreign Affairs from 2003 to 2007 under the administration of then-president John Kufuor.

Georgina Theodora Wood is a Ghanaian former judge and a former police prosecution officer. She was the first woman Chief Justice of Ghana. She retired in 2017 after five decades of service to the state. She is a member of the Council of State.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chief Justice of Ghana</span> Highest-ranking judge of the Supreme Court of Ghana

The chief justice of Ghana is the highest-ranking judge of the Supreme Court of Ghana. The chief justice is also the head of the Judiciary of Ghana and is responsible for its administration and supervision. In order of state precedence, the chief justice is the fourth highest official in Ghana.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electoral Commission of Ghana</span> Official body responsible for public elections in Ghana

The Electoral Commission of Ghana (EC) is the official body in Ghana responsible for all public elections. Made up of seven members and there are seven (7) functional departments at the Head Office. Each department is headed by a Director who is assisted by Unit Heads. The departments are:- Electoral services; Human Resource; Finance; Training; Administration; Research, Monitoring & Evaluation; Information Technology. its independence is guaranteed by the 1992 Ghana constitution. The current commission was established by the Electoral Commission Act (Act 451) of 1993. Kwadwo Afari-Gyan was the first substantive chairman of the commission in the Fourth Republic of Ghana, from 1993 to 2015. He was succeeded by Charlotte Osei as the first female chairman of the commission from 2015 to June 2018. Jean Adukwei Mensah succeeded Charlotte Osei in July 2018. On December 5, 2018, the Electoral commission chaired by Jean Adukwei Mensah reverted to the old logo showing the Coat of arms of Ghana and a ballot box showing the hand casting its votes, after the controversy over the new logo.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Council of State (Ghana)</span>

The Council of State in Ghana is a small body of prominent citizens, analogous to the Council of Elders in the traditional political system, which advises the president on national issues.

William Anaam Atuguba is a retired justice of the Supreme Court of Ghana.

Kwasi Anin-Yeboah is a Ghanaian judge and a former Chief Justice of Ghana. In December 2019, President Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo nominated Justice Anin-Yeboah as the Chief Justice of Ghana.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2020 Ghanaian general election</span>

General elections were held in Ghana on 7 December 2020. Incumbent President Nana Akufo-Addo of the New Patriotic Party (NPP) was re-elected in the first round after securing a majority of the votes. Former President John Dramani Mahama announced that he would contest the results. At the Supreme Court, a petition challenging the result was filed on 30 December, and unanimously dismissed on 4 March 2021 for lack of merit.

JusticeGertrude Araba Esaaba Sackey Torkornoo is the current Chief Justice of the republic of Ghana. She was nominated to the Supreme Court in November 2019 and received parliamentary approval in December 2019. She was sworn in on 17 December 2019. She was nominated to the office of Chief Justice in April 2023 to replace Justice Kwasi Anin-Yeboah who retired as Chief Justice on May 24, 2023. She was sworn into office as the 15th Chief Justice of Ghana on 12 June 2023.

Julius Ansah was a Ghanaian judge who served as a Justice of the Supreme Court of Ghana from 2004 to 2020.

Clemence Jackson Honyenuga is a Ghanaian former judge, who served in the Supreme Court of Ghana from 22 May 2020 until 4 September 2022.

Barbara Frances Ackah-Yensu is a Ghanaian judge and an active Justice of the Supreme Court of Ghana. She has been on the bench in Ghana since 2003 and was appointed to the Supreme Court in 2022.

Samuel Kwame Adibu Asiedu is a Ghanaian judge. He is an active Justice of the Supreme Court of Ghana. He has been on the bench in Ghana since 1996 and became a Supreme Court judge in 2022.

Anthony Henry Kwofie is a Ghanaian judge, an active justice of the Supreme Court of Ghana and president of the Association of Magistrates and Justices of Ghana.

Yaw Darko Asare is a Ghanaian jurist and an active justice of the Supreme Court of Ghana.

The case of Tuffour v Attorney General is a landmark decision of the Supreme Court of Ghana. The case centers on the controversial dismissal of then, Chief Justice Fred Apaloo by the Parliament of the Third Republic and the subsequent legal challenge that sought to contest this dismissal.

References

  1. "Ghanaian criminal court system". Association of Commonwealth Criminal Lawyers. Archived from the original on 12 January 2013. Retrieved 28 January 2011.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
  2. 1992 Constitution Article 125(1). "Justice emanates from the people and shall be administered in the name of the Republic by the Judiciary which shall be independent and subject only to this Constitution."
  3. "Supreme Court of Ghana, Biography". www.ghanaweb.com. Retrieved 28 September 2023.
  4. Hofstedt, Matthew (July 2014). "Afterword: A brief history of Supreme Court messengers". Journal of Supreme Court History. 39 (2): 259–263. doi:10.1111/j.1540-5818.2014.12045.x. ISSN   1059-4329. S2CID   143325855.
  5. Online, Peace FM. "Supreme Court Jails Atubiga And Ken Kuranchie". Peacefmonline.com - Ghana news. Retrieved 12 July 2023.
  6. "Ghana: Supreme Court strikes out cannabis cultivation bill". www.mmjdaily.com. 29 May 2023. Retrieved 12 July 2023.
  7. "Supreme Court erred in its decision to cancel 'wee law' - NPP MP". GhanaWeb. 11 July 2023. Retrieved 12 July 2023.
  8. "Ghana Supreme Court upholds John Mahama's win". BBC News. 29 August 2013. Retrieved 28 September 2023.
  9. "1992 Constitution:Article 128(1)". Ghana Review International. Archived from the original on 1 April 2007. Retrieved 26 March 2007. The Supreme Court shall consist of the Chief Justice and not less than nine other Justices of the Supreme Court.
  10. Ghana Constitution:Article 144 clause 1 "The Chief Justice shall be appointed by the President acting in consultation with the Council of State and with the approval of Parliament."
  11. 1992 Constitution:Article 144 clause 2 "The other Supreme Court Justices shall be appointed by the President acting on the advice of the Judicial Council, in consultation with the Council of State and with the approval of Parliament."
  12. 1 2 3 "Historical Development of the Courts After Independence". Official Website. Judicial Service of Ghana. p. 3. Archived from the original on 6 October 2007. Retrieved 26 March 2007.
  13. Justice Agbenorsi (8 December 2022). "Don't cap Supreme Court judges - Chief Justice, Sophia Akuffo proposes". Graphic Online. Accra: Graphic Communications Group Limited. Retrieved 30 May 2023.
  14. "Supreme Court Republic of Ghana". mobile.ghanaweb.com. Retrieved 13 September 2023.
  15. "List of Judges of the Superior Court of Judicature". Official Website. Judicial Service of Ghana. Archived from the original on 18 October 2012. Retrieved 10 January 2013.
  16. "The Judiciary – Justice of the Supreme aCourt". Ghana local government website. Min. of Local Govt., Rural Dev. & Environment & Maks Publications & Media Services. Archived from the original on 10 October 2007. Retrieved 19 April 2007.
  17. "Akufo-Addo appoints 4 new Supreme Court Justices". GhanaWeb.com. GhanaWeb. 3 July 2018. Archived from the original on 28 August 2018. Retrieved 27 August 2018.
  18. "Atuguba was an NPP parliamentary candidate in 1992 - Gabby reveals". Ghanaweb.com. Ghanaweb. 7 September 2013. Archived from the original on 5 August 2017. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
  19. "Supreme Court adjourns ruling in Minority leader's case". Ghanaweb. 14 May 1998. Archived from the original on 28 August 2018. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
  20. "Justice William Atuguba retires after 44 years as a judge". GhanaWeb.com. GhanaWeb. 3 July 2018. Archived from the original on 28 August 2018. Retrieved 27 August 2018.
  21. 1 2 3 "Akufo-Addo swears in 46 judges". ghanaweb.com. GhanaWeb. 17 December 2019. Retrieved 12 January 2020.
  22. "Nana Addo nominates three new judges to Supreme Court". Ghanaweb.com. GhanaWeb. 12 November 2019. Retrieved 16 November 2019.
  23. "Supreme Court Judges". www.judicial.gov.gh. Retrieved 30 May 2023.
  24. "Four new Supreme Court Judges Sworn In". General News of Wednesday, 11 June 2008. Ghana Home Page. Archived from the original on 14 June 2008. Retrieved 12 June 2008.
  25. "Mahama swears in two Supreme Court Judges". Ghanaweb.com. Ghanaweb. 29 June 2017. Archived from the original on 2 January 2016. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
  26. "Amadu Tanko sworn in as first Muslim Supreme Court Justice". www.ghanaweb.com. GhanaWeb. 22 May 2020. Retrieved 26 May 2020.
  27. Dapatem, Donald Ato (23 May 2020). "President swears in 2 Justices of Supreme Court". Graphic Online. Accra. Retrieved 14 March 2021.
  28. 1 2 "I'll serve Ghana – New SC judge Mensah Bonsu". www.ghanaweb.com. GhanaWeb. 26 May 2020. Retrieved 26 May 2020.
  29. 1 2 "BusinessGhana". www.businessghana.com. Retrieved 2 January 2023.
  30. "List of Chief Justices". Official Website. Judicial Service of Ghana. Archived from the original on 22 June 2008. Retrieved 1 September 2016.
  31. Peile, John (2014). Biographical Register of Christ's College, 1505–1905. Vol. 2. 1666–1905. Cambridge University Press. p. 611. ISBN   978-1-107-42606-1.
  32. "Historical Development of the Courts after Independence". Official Website. Judicial Service of Ghana. p. 1. Archived from the original on 6 October 2007. Retrieved 26 March 2007.
  33. "Historical Development of the Courts after Independence". Official Website. Judicial Service of Ghana. p. 2. Archived from the original on 6 October 2007. Retrieved 26 March 2007.
  34. "History – Summary". Official Website. Judicial Service of Ghana. Archived from the original on 13 February 2007. Retrieved 26 March 2007.
  35. The Supreme Court was left intact under this military regime. See note 5.
  36. "Kpegah urges new Chief Justice to unite judges". General News of Friday, 15 June 2007. Ghana Home Page. Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 16 June 2007.
  37. "Parliament okays Justice Anin Yeboah as Chief Justice". ghanaweb.com. GhanaWeb. 24 December 2019. Retrieved 10 January 2020.
  38. 1 2 3 4 5 "Martyrs of the Rule of Law Historical Marker". www.hmdb.org. Retrieved 28 July 2023.
  39. 1 2 Tigo, Joshua (30 June 2020). "Today in History: Personalities behind three statues in front of Ghana's Sup". Adomonline.com. Retrieved 28 July 2023.
  40. 1 2 GhanaWeb (21 October 2024). "Parliament served with Supreme Court ruling freezing Bagbin's declaration of 4 seats vacant".
  41. "Mahama criticises Supreme Court over failure to set hearing date - Graphic Online".
  42. Annang, Evans (5 September 2023). "Mahama's criticism of the judiciary is setting a dangerous precedent – Gary Nimako". Pulse Ghana. Retrieved 14 September 2023.
  43. "Ghana parliament sitting: Ghana Speaker Bagbin adjourn Parliament indefinitely sake of Supreme Court ruling over fight between NPP, NDC MPs". BBC News Pidgin. 22 October 2024. Retrieved 22 October 2024.
  44. "Eye on Africa - Explaining a dramatic week in Ghanaian politics". France 24. 23 October 2024. Retrieved 29 October 2024.
  45. "Speaker's declaration on 4 MPs: Supreme Court ruling binding on Parliament - Legal experts tell NDC Caucus - Graphic Online".
  46. "Read why Supreme Court halted Bagbin's ruling". 18 October 2024. Retrieved 22 October 2024.
  47. "Supreme Court rules: Speaker's declaration of four seats vacant is unconstitutional - MyJoyOnline". www.myjoyonline.com. 12 November 2024. Retrieved 12 November 2024.