2008 Massachusetts Question 1

Last updated

Question 1
State Income Tax Repeal
Results
Choice
Votes %
Check-71-128-204-brightblue.svg Yes914,42030.63%
Light brown x.svg No2,070,69969.37%
Valid votes2,985,119100.00%
Invalid or blank votes00.00%
Total votes2,985,119100.00%

MA Question 1 2008 Counties.svg
MA Question 1 2008 Municipalities.svg
MA Question 1 2008.svg

The State Income Tax Repeal, also known as Massachusetts Question 1, was one of the 2008 ballot measures that appeared on the November 4, 2008 ballot in the U.S. state of Massachusetts. [1] Voters were asked whether or not they approved of the proposed measure which, if it had passed, would have ended the 5.3% income tax in Massachusetts on wages, interest, dividends and capital gains. Ultimately, Massachusetts voters defeated Question 1 by a wide margin, with approximately 70% opposed versus 30% in favor.

Contents

Specific provisions

This proposed law would have had the following features:

Supporters of the income tax repeal

The official proponent of the measure was the Committee for Small Government. Michael Cloud and Carla Howell led the committee. [2]

Initiative supporter Michael Cloud believed that the measure would lower the budget from about $28 billion to $17 billion, which is approximately the size of the 1995 state budget. [3]

Polling showed that 46 percent of those asked supported the measure before hearing any of its details, and 40 percent still supported it after hearing about the measure in depth. [4] [5]

Arguments that were presented in support of Question 1

Funding

According to campaign finance reports, as of November 1, 2008 the Committee for Small Government had raised approximately $385,000 since creation and had $14,131.72 cash left. They also had about $80,000 in outstanding liabilities. [6]

As of August 15, 2008, Ms Howell and Mr Cloud had paid themselves almost $200,000 from committee donations for "consulting fees" over the previous 6 years for services rendered to their own campaigns while soliciting donors for additional contributions because the campaign was out of funds. [7] [8] [9]

Earlier attempt to repeal income tax

The Committee for Small Government advanced a similar initiative, called the Massachusetts End the Income Tax initiative, in 2002. That measure did not pass and received 885,683 votes, or 45.3 percent. [10]

Individual Support

The Republican senatorial candidate, Jeff Beatty, said that he supported Question 1 while challenging incumbent-John Kerry.

Editorial Support

Stephen Moore of the Wall Street Journal stated: "The forces of the tax-and-spend status quo will descend on this initiative like British troops after the original Boston tea party, but somebody has to make an effort to stop the relentless growth of government."

Steve Forbes of Forbes magazine stated: "This is an attack on political establishments there and throughout the U.S. that routinely put their own interests above those of their constituents: lavish government pensions with payouts that would bankrupt private companies; resistance to genuine reform in Medicaid spending, which has become the biggest item on virtually every state's budget; ever more pork-barrel spending; and ever more obsequiousness to rapacious special interests. Bay State voters – go for Proposition 1."

Opposition

Funding

According to campaign finance reports, as of October 15, 2008 the Coalition for Our Communities, the organization opposing this tax cut, had raised over $5 million—99.8% from teachers' and other government sector unions.

Individual opponents

Michael Widmer, president of the Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation, [11]

Gov. Deval Patrick [12]

The Selectman in the town of Wayland voted unanimously to oppose the initiative.

State Rep. Tom Conroy, D-Wayland [13]

Senator John Kerry (D-MA) publicly opposed it while running for reelection for senate.

Republican State Senator and future U.S. senator Scott Brown voted against Question 1 despite voting against raising the state's flat tax to 5.95% while in the state senate in 2003.

Organizations against the measure

Coalition for Our Communities, an organization created by the Massachusetts AFL-CIO that reportedly had $1.34 million with which to mount an effort to defeat the measure. The Coalition's funds are derived mainly from unions, including $750,000 from the National Education Association. [14] [15] The group also received $250,000 from American Federation of Teachers Solidarity Fund. Both the NEA and the AFTSF are based in Washington, D.C. [16]

Editorial opposition

The Boston Globe officially asked voters to vote "no" on Question 1. [17]

Arguments that were presented against Question 1

Funding

According to campaign finance reports, as of November 1, 2008 The Coalition for Our Communities had raised approximately $6,625,000 since creation and had $117,270.95 cash left. They also received about an additional $650,000 in in-kind donations from unions such as donated staff, supplies, postage etc. [19]

History of petition drive and blocking allegations

The proponents submitted about 100,000 signatures to the Massachusetts Secretary of State for the first phase of signature collection. 76,084 of those signatures were determined to be valid, with a requirement that 66,593 must be valid for the initiative to proceed to the next step. [20] The next step was for the Massachusetts State Legislature to take up the measure. They declined to pass it by the first Wednesday in May 2008, meaning that the proponents had to collect an additional 11,099 valid signatures by June 18, 2008. On July 3, it was announced that 15,913 additional certified signatures had been filed, making the measure extremely likely to appear on the ballot. [21] [22]

The Massachusetts Teachers Association, whose mailing address is the same as the "Committee for our Communities", admitted in December 2007 that it had made phone calls to people who had signed the petition to place the income tax repeal on the ballot, inquiring about whether their signatures were valid. The calls were made from a group identifying itself as the "Committee for our Communities". [23]

Results

State Income Tax Repeal Initiative [24] [25]
ChoiceVotes %
Light brown x.svg No2,070,69969.37
Yes914,42030.63
Valid votes2,985,11996.20
Invalid or blank votes117,8763.80
Total votes3,102,995100.00
Registered voters/turnout4,220,48873.52

See also

Related Research Articles

Carla Howell is an American politician, small government advocate and activist. She was the Libertarian Party of Massachusetts candidate for Massachusetts State Auditor in 1998, U.S. Senate in 2000, and Governor in 2002. She then served in multiple leadership positions in the U.S. Libertarian Party. She has also organized tax-cut initiative ballot measures in Massachusetts and worked for the Libertarian National Committee.

The Oregon tax revolt is a political movement in Oregon which advocates for lower taxes. This movement is part of a larger anti-tax movement in the western United States which began with the enactment of Proposition 13 in California. The tax revolt, carried out in large part by a series of citizens' initiatives and referendums, has reshaped the debate about taxes and public services in Oregon.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tim Eyman</span> Anti-tax activist, businessman (born 1965)

Timothy Donald Eyman is an American anti-tax activist and businessman.

Rex Andrew Sinquefield is an American businessman, investor, and philanthropist who has been called an "index-fund pioneer" for creating the first passively managed index fund open to the general public. Sinquefield was also a co-founder of Dimensional Fund Advisors. He is active in Missouri politics.

The Committee for Sensible Marijuana Policy is a Boston, Massachusetts based organization that was devoted to passing Question 2, a cannabis decriminalization initiative also known as the Massachusetts Sensible Marijuana Policy Initiative that was passed in Massachusetts in 2008 and officially became law on January 2, 2009. Whitney A. Taylor is the treasurer and chairwoman of the organization.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2008 Massachusetts Question 2</span>

The Sensible Marijuana Policy Initiative, also known as Massachusetts Ballot Question 2, was an initiated state statute that replaced prior criminal penalties with new civil penalties on adults possessing an ounce or less of marijuana. The initiative appeared on the November 4, 2008, ballot in Massachusetts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Massachusetts Greyhound Protection Act</span> Referendum banning commercial dog racing

The Greyhound Protection Act is a Massachusetts statute that gradually eliminated commercial dog racing by 2010. It was enacted as Question 3 on the November 4, 2008 ballot in Massachusetts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2008 Oregon Ballot Measure 59</span>

Oregon Ballot Measure 59 was an initiated state statute ballot measure sponsored by Bill Sizemore that appeared on the November 4, 2008 general election ballot in Oregon, United States. If it had passed, Oregon would have join Alabama, Iowa, and Louisiana as the only states to allow federal income taxes to be fully deducted on state income tax returns.

The South Dakota Open and Clean Government Act, or Initiated Measure 10, was a South Dakota initiative that would ban taxpayer-funded lobbying, stop the exchange of campaign donations for state contracts, and open a website with information on state contracts. The Open and Clean Government Act was proposed as a citizen-initiated state statute and appeared on the November 4, 2008 ballot.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2010 California Proposition 23</span> Referendum on environmental regulations

Proposition 23 was a California ballot proposition that was on the November 2, 2010 California statewide ballot. It was defeated by California voters during the statewide election by a 23% margin. If passed, it would have suspended AB 32, a law enacted in 2006, legally referred to its long name, the Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006. Sponsors of the initiative referred to their measure as the California Jobs Initiative while opponents called it the Dirty Energy Prop.

A Massachusetts general election was held on November 5, 2002 in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.

A Massachusetts general election was held on November 8, 1994 in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2010 Massachusetts Question 1</span> Referendum repealing a sales tax on alcohol

The No Sales Tax for Alcohol Question, also known as Question 1, was on the November 2, 2010 ballot in Massachusetts. The measure asked voters whether to repeal a sales tax on alcohol sales. The ballot measure for the 2010 ballot was added after the Massachusetts State Legislature increased the sales tax in the state from 5% to 6.25% and eliminated an exemption for alcohol sold in liquor stores.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2010 Massachusetts Question 2</span>

The Massachusetts Comprehensive Permits and Regional Planning Initiative, also known as Question 2, appeared on the November 2, 2010 ballot in the state of Massachusetts as an initiative. Question 2 was rejected by the Massachusetts voters by 1,254,759 "No" votes to 900,405 "Yes" votes. The measure had been sponsored by Better Not Bigger, a local advocacy group in the state.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Massachusetts Sales Tax Relief Act</span>

Massachusetts Question 3, filed under the name, the 3 percent Sales Tax Relief Act, appears on the November 2, 2010 ballot in the state of Massachusetts as an initiative. The measure, if enacted by voters, would reduce the state sales tax rate from 6.25 to 3 percent. The measure is being sponsored by the Alliance to Roll Back Taxes headed by Carla Howell. The measure would be enacted into a law 30 days after the election if approved by voters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">November 2012 California elections</span>

The California state elections was held on Election Day, November 6, 2012. On the ballot were eleven propositions, various parties' nominees for the United States presidency, the Class I Senator to the United States Senate, all of California's seats to the House of Representatives, all of the seats of the State Assembly, and all odd-numbered seats of the State Senate.

Direct democracy refers to decision making or direct vote a proposal, law, or political issue by the electorate, rather than being voted on by representatives in a state or local legislature or council.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2014 Massachusetts Question 1</span> Referendum

The Massachusetts Automatic Gas Tax Increase Repeal Initiative, Question 1 was on the November 4, 2014 statewide ballot. Approved by voters, the measure repeals a 2013 law that would automatically adjust gas taxes according to inflation, allowing for automatic annual increases in the state's gas tax.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">American Anti-Corruption Act</span> American model legislation

The American Anti-Corruption Act (AACA), sometimes shortened to Anti-Corruption Act, is a piece of model legislation designed to limit the influence of money in American politics by overhauling lobbying, transparency, and campaign finance laws. It was crafted in 2011 "by former Federal Election Commission chairman Trevor Potter in consultation with dozens of strategists, democracy reform leaders and constitutional attorneys from across the political spectrum," and is supported by reform organizations such as Represent.Us, which advocate for the passage of local, state, and federal laws modeled after the AACA. It is designed to limit or outlaw practices perceived to be major contributors to political corruption.

Three ballot measures were certified for the November 6, 2018, general election in the state of Massachusetts.

References

  1. Berkshire Eagle: "Income tax repeal gets 1st ballot slot," July 11, 2008
  2. WSJ Online: "Boston Tax Party," Aug. 5, 2008
  3. Boston Globe: "4 ballot petitions clear 1st obstacle," Nov. 24, 2007
  4. The Colombian: "Washington View: Another tea party brewing in Massachusetts," Aug 12, 2008 [ permanent dead link ]
  5. American Spectator: "Taxachusetts, RIP," Aug 12, 2008 Archived 2008-08-14 at the Wayback Machine
  6. committee for small government - campaign finance report Archived 2008-10-05 at the Wayback Machine
  7. Boston Herald "Carla Howells tax fight pays off for Her and activist pal"
  8. committee for small government - campaign finance report - 2008 ballot question 1 Archived 2008-10-05 at the Wayback Machine
  9. The committee for small government - campaign finance report- 2002 ballot question 1 Archived 2009-12-17 at the Wayback Machine
  10. Committee for Small Government
  11. Ballot Question Would Eliminate Income Tax In Mass., MyFox Boston, Dec. 2, 2007 Archived 2008-09-24 at the Wayback Machine
  12. WBZtv.com "Ballot Question Rattles Nerves On Beacon Hill," Aug 11, 2008 Archived 2008-08-21 at the Wayback Machine
  13. WickedLocal.com: "Selectmen oppose elimination of state income tax," Sep 3, 2008
  14. Forbes.com: "Backers of tax question have just $24,753 in bank," Sep 10, 2008 [ dead link ]
  15. Amherst Bulletin: "Efforts under way to defeat income tax ballot measure," Sep 5, 2008 Archived 2008-11-20 at the Wayback Machine
  16. Worcester Telegram & Gazette: "DC donations flood Mass. ballot question campaigns," Sep 21, 2008
  17. Boston.com: "This Question is Not the Answer," Sep 28, 2008
  18. "Home".
  19. Coalition for our Communities - campaign finance report Archived 2008-10-05 at the Wayback Machine
  20. The 2nd American Revolution
  21. Politicker: "Ballot initiative to abolish income tax will appear on November ballot", July 3, 2008
  22. CapitalNews9.com: "Group wants to abolish state income tax," May 19, 2008
  23. WickedLocal.com: "Union group made calls to tax cut petition signers, challenge seems unlikely" Archived 2008-06-14 at the Wayback Machine
  24. "2008 Return of Votes Complete" (PDF). Massachusetts Secretary of the Commonwealth. 2008-12-17. Retrieved 2008-11-05.
  25. "Enrollment Breakdown as of 15 October 2008" (PDF). Massachusetts Secretary of the Commonwealth. 2008-10-30. Retrieved 2008-11-05.

Further reading

Note: The original version of this article was taken from Ballotpedia's article about the Massachusetts State Income Tax Repeal Initiative