Air pollution in Hong Kong

Last updated

On two cloud-free days, the haze situation can differ dramatically depending on the season and therefore on the direction of the wind. Hong kong haze comparison.jpg
On two cloud-free days, the haze situation can differ dramatically depending on the season and therefore on the direction of the wind.
Renovation and building rehabilitation programs are neglected sources of air pollution in Hong Kong.

Air pollution in Hong Kong is considered a serious problem. In 2004, visibility was less than eight kilometers for 30 per cent of the year. Cases of asthma and bronchial infections have soared due to reduced air quality. However, in recent years,[ when? ] the hours of reduced visibility in Hong Kong have decreased by significant amounts compared to the previous ten years. [1] [ obsolete source ]

Contents

Effects

Declining regional air quality means visibility has also decreased dramatically. In 2004, low visibility occurred 18 per cent of the time, the highest on record, according to the Hong Kong Observatory. [2]

Health implications

The mortality rate from vehicular pollution can be twice as high near heavily travelled roads, based on a study conducted in the Netherlands at residences 50 metres from a main road and 100 metres from a freeway. [3] Since millions of people in Hong Kong live and work in close proximity to busy roads, this presents a major health risk to city residents. The Hong Kong Medical Association estimates that air pollution can exacerbate asthma, impair lung function and raise the risk of cardio-respiratory death by 2 to 3 per cent for every increase of 10 micrograms per cubic metre of pollutants. [3] Studies by local public health experts have found that these roadside pollution levels are responsible for 90,000 hospital admissions and 2,800 premature deaths every year. In 2009 the Australian government highlighted that air pollution in Hong Kong could exacerbate some medical conditions. [4] [5]

Former Chief Executive Donald Tsang declared that the high life-expectancy of Hong Kong demonstrates that concerns over air quality were not justified.

The life expectancy in Hong Kong is among the highest in the world ... you can come to only one conclusion: we have the most environmental-friendly place for people, for executives, for Hong Kong people to live. [6]

Professor Anthony Hedley, chair of community medicine at Hong Kong University, said: "Tsang is badly advised on current public health issues." Hedley added that air pollution levels in Hong Kong were extremely high, and could affect the lungs, blood vessels and heart. [6] James Tien, former Chairman of the Liberal Party of Hong Kong, retorted, "Can [Tsang] really be confident that, if pollution continues to worsen, will he be able to promise the same life expectancy for our children and for our grandchildren?" [7]

Economic impact

Even as early as 2000, the total negative impact to the Hong Kong Economy, including cardiorespiratory disease was in excess of HK$11.1 billion. [8] About 1,600 deaths a year might be avoided if air quality improves. [9]

Made aware of fresh statistical and anecdotal evidence that pollution is driving away business and hurting Hong Kong's global competitiveness, James Tien called air pollution "a health issue, a lifestyle issue, a tourism issue, a business issue, and increasingly a political issue." [7]

Merrill Lynch downgraded several Hong Kong property companies because of air quality concerns, and there have been warnings from the head of the Stock Exchange that pollution was scaring investors away. [7] It said that the air quality in Hong Kong is now regularly so poor that its "long-term competitiveness is in some doubt", and advised clients to switch into developers in Singapore instead. [9]

Pollution is dramatically harming not only the health of citizens of Hong Kong but also its economy, particularly relating to the ability to attract skilled foreign labour. [10]

The chairman of the Danish Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong said each year at least two or three people decline offers to work in the Hong Kong offices of member companies because of pollution: "It's going to cost us in the future if we don't clean up here".

"Five years ago, air quality wasn't a concern when people considered whether to relocate to Hong Kong", said Jardine Engineering Corp. Chief Executive James Graham. "In the past, one of the advantages was clean air. We can no longer say that". A London-based human resources consultant recommends that companies pay a 10 per cent hardship allowance to lure expatriates, partly because of air quality. [11]

Causes

Suspended particulates generated from power tool used in road work. DustWorker.jpg
Suspended particulates generated from power tool used in road work.

There are more than twenty thousand home improvement projects every year in Hong Kong, affecting more than a million residents [12] (population of HK is around 7.5 million in 2023). [13]

As per the Clean Air Network, 53% of Hong Kong's pollution comes from local sources – power stations, idling engines of cars, trucks and buses and marine emissions. [14] [ obsolete source ] Hong Kong has only 5% of the land of the Pearl River Delta, but it creates 20% of its pollution, far more than its neighbouring cities of Shenzhen and Guangzhou. [15] [16] [ obsolete source ]

A large portion of this pollution comes from coal-fired power stations in Hong Kong and vehicular traffic. A significant contribution wafts down from the tens of thousands of factories in China's neighboring manufacturing heartland of the Pearl River Delta. [14] [ obsolete source ] The two major electricity companies of Hong Kong, namely China Light and Power and HK Electric Holdings emit more than 75,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide into Hong Kong's air daily. At 275 vehicles per kilometer, Hong Kong also has among the highest density of vehicles in the world. [17]

Air-quality monitoring

Air Pollution Index - EPD

The Environmental Protection Department (EPD) in Hong Kong was established to solve problems and provide for a long lasting acceptable level of air quality. [18]

In June 1995, instead of adopting internationally accepted benchmark index for pollution[ vague ], it set up the Air Pollution Index as an indicator to pollution levels, both "General" and "Roadside".

Air Quality Objectives (AQOs) for seven widespread air pollutants were established in 1987 under the Air Pollution Control Ordinance (APCO), [18] and have not been reviewed since it was set up. [3] It is not clear how the levels are determined. [3]

In October 2005, Task Force on Air Pollution criticised the Government for deluding itself with a pollution index that is a "meaningless" indicator of health risks. [3] Professor Wong Tze-wai, at the Chinese University of Hong Kong commented that the current air pollution index "gives a false sense of security". [3] Gary Wong, a professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong's Department of Paediatrics and School of Public Health, said that under the current index, "some harmful pollution components aren't even recorded." In addition, he pointed out that there is no strategic plan or a timetable to tackle the problem, unlike in other countries [3]

Street-level air quality regularly falls short of the government's Air Quality Objectives (AQOs), and even further short of the World Health Organization (WHO) Air Quality Guidelines, revised in October.

Academics called for Hong Kong Government to immediately update its air quality objectives set almost twenty years ago. [6] For example, on 19 and 20 November 2006, roadside levels of respirable suspended particulates (RSPs – equivalent to PM10) exceeded the WHO guidelines by at least 300 per cent. Prof Anthony Hedley of the University of Hong Kong said in September 2007 that if Hong Kong's Air Pollution Index was based on WHO recommended levels, our readings would be "absolutely sky high" for most of the year. [19] Secretary for Environment, Transport and Works Sarah Liao Sau-tung said the WHO targets were too stringent. [6]

Air quality monitoring by the department are carried out by 11 general stations and three roadside stations. On 8 March 2012, the department started reporting data on fine suspended particulates in the air on an hourly basis, that are a leading component of smog. It began regular monitoring of PM2.5 levels, which measure particles 2.5 micrometres (μm) in diameter or less, at three stations since 2005, but the data were never publicized. [20]

Real Air Pollution Index - Greenpeace

In September 2008, Greenpeace East Asia's Hong Kong office launched its "Real Air Pollution Index" [21] as part of a campaign to get the government to update the Air Pollution Index to match WHO guidelines. The Real Air Pollution Index reports hourly pollution levels from 15 monitoring stations across the region and compares them to WHO standards.

Actions implemented

Switch to cleaner motor fuels

All HK taxis and PLBs now run on LPG.

Sign on taxi showing its new LPG status Hong Kong Taxi - 19-12-2006 - LPG Taxi.jpg
Sign on taxi showing its new LPG status

Incentives for scrapping pre-Euro IV vehicles

In 2014, an ex gratia payment scheme was introduced to encourage vehicle-owners to scrap about 82,000 pre-Euro VI vehicles. [22] This included a Citybus AEC Routemaster, which attracted controversy for its resulting loss of transport heritage. [23]

Green Groups / Non-Government Organisations

CarbonCare InnoLab

Christian Family Service Centre

Civic Exchange

Clean Air Network -CAN

Clear the Air

Conservation International Hong Kong

Designing Hong Kong

Environmental Association

Friends of the Earth (HK) (since 1983)

Green Council

Green Lantau Association (since 1989)

Green Peace (since 1997)

Green Peng Chau Association

Green Power (since 1988)

Green Sense

Greeners Action

Hong Kong Dolphinwatch Ltd.

Hong Kong Society of Herpetology Foundation

Kadoorie Farm & Botanic Garden

Ocean Park Conservation Foundation Hong Kong

Produce Green Foundation

Sustainable Ecological Ethical Development Foundation

The Conservancy Association (since 1968)

The Green Earth

The Hong Kong Bird Watching Society

The Nature Conservancy

World Green Organisation

World Wide Fund For Nature Hong Kong (since 1981) [24] [25]

Historical actions discussed

July 2006 Action Blue Sky Campaign

The Action Blue Sky Campaign was an environmental campaign organised by the Environmental Protection Department, and launched by Chief Executive Donald Tsang in July 2006. Its campaign slogan in Chinese was "全城投入　為藍天打氣" ("Let all of the city join in to fight for a blue sky"), [26] while its campaign slogan in English is "Clean Air for a Cool Hong Kong!" [27] The campaign hoped to win support from the public as well as the business community, including those businesses investing in the Pearl River Delta Region.

November 2007 vehicle idling ban

In November 2007, the government launched a public consultation on the proposal which would impose a fixed penalty of HK$320 on drivers who would violate a ban on idling, with taxi and minibus drivers likely to bear the brunt of the ban. The government said its action is due to the failure of motorists to heed many past campaigns switch off engines while waiting. Taxi and minibus drivers were opposed to the proposal. [28]

It is illegal for any driver to leave their engine running if they get out of their vehicle. [29] The courts have been awarding fines of HK$700. [30] It is also illegal for taxis to loiter and minibuses to stop longer than necessary to pick up or put down passengers. It is also illegal to park anywhere except in a designated parking place. This means that the vast majority of drivers who idle their engines are already in violation of at least one existing traffic safety law.

However, traffic wardens are under strict policy guidelines not to give out any tickets unless there has already developed a "serious" obstruction of the roadway or there have been multiple complaints made by the public; this is the "Selective Traffic Enforcement Policy" (STEP). [31]

Traffic safety policing of idling vehicles, therefore, falls to private organisations like "mini spotters" who act as volunteer traffic wardens, making statements to police that can be prosecuted without traffic wardens having to issue tickets directly to the transport trade.

2008–09 Budget measures

In the 2008–09 Budget, Financial Secretary John Tsang proposed a 100 per cent profit tax deduction for capital expenditure on environmentally friendly machinery and equipment in the first year of purchase, to encourage the business community to go green. He also suggested shortening the depreciation period of this equipment from the usual 25 years to 5 years. Neither proposal was actually passed.

New goals for 2014

In January 2014, Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah announced that the HK government would update its air quality objectives, put in place in 1990, bringing them closer to WHO guidelines. According to the proposals, which will be set through legislation but have yet to be approved, seven types of emissions will be monitored. Respirable and fine particulates will also be monitored, but less stringently due to their more pronounced health impact. Targets set for three of the seven environmental pollutants are to be based on the WHO's loosest interim targets. Sulphur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide and lead would be subject to monitoring. Monitoring of particulates smaller than 2.5 μm (PM2.5) would be introduced under the proposals, but will be loosest of the three WHO interim targets. Yau asserted some local pollution had roots in mainland China, but did not mention any ongoing dialogue to address the issue with mainland authorities. Yau also did not address roadside pollution in Hong Kong. [32] In total, 22 measures in all were suggested to contribute towards meeting the new objectives. Such measures would include phasing out heavily polluting vehicles, promoting hybrid or electric vehicles, and increasing the use of natural gas, but no actions have yet to be taken. Environmental impact assessments of projects such as the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau bridge were conducted and approved under the old air-quality guidelines. [32] Mike Kilburn from Civic Exchange and Professor Hedley of the University of Hong Kong expressed their disappointment, saying that it too little, and too long overdue. Kilburn said: " It is a move that we have been waiting years for years but we are extremely disappointed as the objectives are not strict enough to make any positive impact on air quality." [33] Other environmental activists shared little hope in government efforts to reduce pollution and lamented the half-hearted implementation of measures, and the elusiveness of timetable for meeting the most stringent objectives. [32]

See also

Sources and pollutants

More

Related Research Articles

Dr. Sarah Mary Liao Sau-tung, GBS, MBE, JP, FRSC was former Secretary for the Environment, Transport and Works of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region and a member of the Executive Council of Hong Kong since 2002. She was appointed on 1 August 2002 and served until 2007. She is also a Senior Adviser to the Vice-Chancellor of the University of Hong Kong on Environmental and Sustainability Matters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air quality index</span> Measure of air pollution

An air quality index (AQI) is an indicator developed by government agencies to communicate to the public how polluted the air currently is or how polluted it is forecast to become. As air pollution levels rise, so does the AQI, along with the associated public health risk. Children, the elderly and individuals with respiratory or cardiovascular problems are typically the first groups affected by poor air quality. When the AQI is high, governmental bodies generally encourage people to reduce physical activity outdoors, or even avoid going out altogether. When wildfires result in a high AQI, the use of a mask outdoors and an air purifier indoors are also encouraged.

Sir Percy Cradock was a British diplomat, civil servant and sinologist who served as British Ambassador to the People's Republic of China from 1978 to 1983, playing a significant role in the Sino-British negotiations which led up to the signing of the Sino-British Joint Declaration in 1984.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marine Department (Hong Kong)</span>

The Marine Department of the Hong Kong Government is responsible for maintaining safety and environmental protection of the harbour, ships registered/foreign ships in Hong Kong and monitor shipping traffic in Hong Kong waters, search and rescue operations for large waters of the South China Sea.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">North Lantau New Town</span> Place in Hong Kong, Peoples Republic of China

North Lantau New Town is the newest of the nine new towns in Hong Kong, a special administrative region of China, located on the northern coast of the Lantau Island in the New Territories. It covers Tung Chung, Tai Ho Wan, Siu Ho Wan, other parts of northeast Lantau Island, and the reclaimed land along the coast between them. It is the only new town in the Islands District and the youngest new town in Hong Kong. As the commercial, residential and community facilities in the New Town are concentrated in Tung Chung, it has been renamed Tung Chung New Town in recent official government documents.

Lights Out Hong Kong is a campaign in Hong Kong to protest against the city's light pollution. Organisers of the campaign urged people in Hong Kong to switch off their lights for 3 minutes at 8pm on 8th August 2006 as a statement of protest. Campaign organisers hope that the campaign will raise awareness for the issue of air pollution in Hong Kong and urge the government to take action against it. The campaign has gained support from a number of green groups and corporations, and the music duo At17 has volunteered to promote it.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air Pollution Index</span> Air quality measurement in Malaysia

The Air Pollution Index is a simple and generalized way to describe the air quality, which is used in Malaysia. It is calculated from several sets of air pollution data and was formerly used in mainland China and Hong Kong. In mainland China the API was replaced by an updated air quality index in early 2012 and on 30 December 2013 Hong Kong moved to a health based index.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Action Blue Sky Campaign</span> Environmental campaign

The Action Blue Sky Campaign is an environmental campaign in Hong Kong, organised by the Environmental Protection Department, to clean up the city's air pollution. It was officially launched by Chief Executive Donald Tsang on July 25, 2006. According to a press release of the Hong Kong government, its campaign slogan in Chinese is "全城投入　為藍天打氣", while its campaign slogan in English is "Clean Air for a Cool Hong Kong!" The campaign hopes to win support from the public as well as the business community, including those businesses investing in the Pearl River Delta Region.

Clear The Air is a voluntary organisation aiming at reducing air pollution in Hong Kong. It was founded on 10 December 1997 as a Society under the Societies Ordinance. It is self-sustained and is supported by individual membership fees and member donations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Donald Luddington</span> British colonial government official

Sir Donald Collin Cumyn Luddington, was a British colonial government official and civil servant who served firstly in the Hong Kong Government and became District Commissioner, New Territories and the Secretary for Home Affairs successively, during which he had also served as an official member of the Legislative Council. He was later promoted to Oceania and was High Commissioner for the Western Pacific and Governor of the Solomon Islands during the period from 1973 to 1976. He returned to Hong Kong in 1977 to replace Sir Ronald Holmes as chairman of the Public Service Commission. He was the second person, after Sir Jack Cater, to hold the post of Commissioner of ICAC from 1978 until his retirement in 1980.

Clean Air Network is an independent non-governmental organisation exclusively focused on the issue of air pollution in Hong Kong. CAN aims to educate the public about the health impacts of air pollution and to mobilise public support for cleaner air in Hong Kong. According to Civic Exchange's environmental program director Mike Kilburn, CAN was created with the purpose of encouraging the public to speak out and support government measures that could improve the quality of air in Hong Kong.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tai Hom Village</span> Village in Kowloon, Hong Kong

Tai Hom Village was the largest squatter village in Kowloon, Hong Kong. Its demolition was completed in 2001, with a few structures of historical value being preserved. The name is still used to designate its former site in Wong Tai Sin District, which is awaiting redevelopment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air pollution in Canada</span> Overview of the air pollution in Canada

Air pollution is the release of pollutants into the air that are detrimental to human health and the Earth. In Canada, air pollution is regulated by standards set by the Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment (CCME), an inter-governmental body of federal, provincial and territorial Ministers responsible for the environment. Air pollution from the United States and to lesser extent Canada; caused by metal smelting, coal-burning for utilities, and vehicle emissions has resulted in acid rain, has severely impacted Canadian waterways, forest growth, and agricultural productivity.

<i>Princess and the Seven Kung Fu Masters</i> 2013 Hong Kong film

Princess and the Seven Kung Fu Masters is a 2013 Hong Kong martial arts comedy film directed by Wong Jing.

<i>The Bounty</i> (2012 film) 2012 Hong Kong film

The Bounty is a 2012 action comedy film featuring the directorial debut of Fung Chi Keung and starring Chapman To, Fiona Sit and Alex Man. In November, the film received the Hong Kong Film Development Fund's "Film Development Foundation Film Production Finance Project" to provide HK$2,605,711 of finance. This is the 13th film financed by The Hong Kong Film Development Fund.

Dai pai dong is a type of traditional food stall in Hong Kong. It was popular in Hong Kong during the 1960s and 1970s. The literal meaning of dai pai dong in English is “big license stall”. The characteristics of dai pai dong are a lack of air-conditioners, unclean environment, and various kinds of food. Starting from 1980s, the government stopped issuing new licenses and began buying them back. Due to its hygienic problem and the deaths of the license holders,most dai pai dong closed down and were replaced by different kinds of restaurants. Urban development has also had an impact on dai pai dong. There are only 25 dai pai dong left in Hong Kong according to the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department, which manages the licenses. Because of the desire to preserver the local food culture, it has been suggested that licenses should be issued again for new and existing dai pai dong owners.

The Hong Kong 2030: Planning Vision and Strategy is a study group tasked with preparing a strategic land use planning framework for Hong Kong up to year 2030. The HK2030 Study aimed to provide strategic framework for future land use in New Territories to address long-term housing demands in the New Development Areas (NDAs) of Kwu Tung North (KTN) and Fanling North (FLN). In 2008 “The North East New Development Areas Planning and Engineering Study” began; it continued until 2013.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tuen Mun Community Network</span> Political party in Hong Kong

Tuen Mun Community Network was a local political group based in Tuen Mun founded in 2015. In a historic pro-democracy landslide in 2019 District Council election, the group won a total of four seats in the Tuen Mun District Council.

Public housing estates in Hong Kong are the most common kind of public housing in Hong Kong. Typically, estate units are leased to low-income people. There are three organizations that provide housing units. They are Hong Kong Housing Authority (HKHA), Hong Kong Housing Society (HKHS), and Hong Kong Settlers Housing Corporation Limited.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Environment and Ecology Bureau</span> Hong Kong policy bureau

Environment and Ecology Bureau is one of the fifteen policy bureau of the Government of Hong Kong. The agency was established on 1 July 2022. The current Secretary for Environment and Ecology is Tse Chin-wan.

References

  1. ↑ "The Health Effects of Air Pollution in Hong Kong 🇭🇰". My Health Portal. Archived from the original on 30 June 2014. Retrieved 14 November 2013.
  2. ↑ Loh, Christine (5 March 2007). "Hong Kong: how to breathe easier". Hong Kong: how to breathe easier - China Dialogue. China Dialogue. Retrieved 7 November 2019.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Albert Wong, Our air is killing us Archived 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine , The Standard, 29 October 2005
  4. ↑ Barrett, Rosanne (26 March 2009). "Australia Defends Inclusion of Air Pollution in New Travel Warning". South China Morning Post. Retrieved 25 December 2016.
  5. ↑ Barrett, Rosanne (25 March 2009). "City's Air Is Bad For You".
  6. 1 2 3 4 Tsang hit for `naive' comments Archived 17 October 2007 at the Wayback Machine , Mimi Lau, The Standard, 28 November 2006 (quoted during the Business for Clear Air conference)
  7. 1 2 3 Jonathan Cheng, Lot of hot air on pollution, claims Tien Archived 17 October 2007 at the Wayback Machine , The Standard, 4 December 2006
  8. ↑ Ip Chin Chung, Dan (Autumn 2006). "Putrid Air Puts Heath at Risk: How to cope with it" (PDF). Improving Hong Kong. 3: 4. Archived from the original (PDF) on 10 July 2007. Retrieved 11 November 2007.
  9. 1 2 Our future up in the air Archived 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine , William Pesek, The Standard , 8 December 2006
  10. ↑ Hong Kong Wheezes as China's Industrial Economy Belches Smog, Bloomberg, 13 October 2005
  11. ↑ "Hong Kong Pollution Sends Expats to Singapore". The Stalwart. 23 May 2006.
  12. ↑ "訂修噪音條例今起諮詢 管制住宅裝修使用撞擊式破碎機需呈報預繳". 香港01 (in Chinese). 18 December 2023. Retrieved 10 January 2024.
  13. ↑ "Press Releases Detail". censtatd.gov.hk. Retrieved 10 January 2024.
  14. 1 2 "Hong Kong smothered in worst air pollution two years". Reuters. 2 August 2012. Retrieved 22 January 2018.
  15. ↑ "Hong Kong pollution: How the haze affects every breath you take". Expat Living. 2 April 2014. Retrieved 22 January 2018.
  16. ↑ "Lost in the haze: China's air pollution crisis". www.greenpeace.org. Green Peace Asia. Retrieved 22 January 2018.
  17. ↑ "Haze in Hong Kong hits Unhealthy levels". Sure Boh Singapore. 18 January 2018. Retrieved 22 January 2018.
  18. 1 2 6.4 Air Quality Objectives - Environment Hong Kong 2006, Environmental Protection Department, Accessed 2007-05-22
  19. ↑ Pollution index based on index set 20 years ago, p5, South China Morning Post, 30 September 2007
  20. ↑ Foo, Kenneth "Action stations as air monitoring fine-tuned" Archived 26 June 2015 at the Wayback Machine The Standard . 9 March 2012. Retrieved 9 March 2012
  21. ↑ "Real Air Pollution Index - Greenpeace East Asia". Greenpeace.org. 17 March 2003. Retrieved 2 October 2011.
  22. ↑ Fung, Freda (3 April 2014). "The road to cleaner vehicles in Hong Kong and in mainland China". South China Morning Post. Retrieved 2 November 2015.
  23. ↑ Leung, Christy (25 September 2015). "Citybus condemns classic Routemaster bus to scrap heap so it can claim Hong Kong clean fuel payout". South China Morning Post. Retrieved 2 November 2015.
  24. ↑ "Non-Government Organisations / Green Groups".
  25. ↑ "Major Green Groups in Hong Kong". epd.gov.hk. Retrieved 11 August 2023.
  26. ↑ 曾蔭權冀政府大樓再減1.5％用電 (in Chinese). Hong Kong SAR Information Services Department. 25 July 2006. Archived from the original on 11 March 2007. Retrieved 13 May 2007.
  27. ↑ "CE launches Action Blue Sky Campaign". Hong Kong SAR Information Services Department. 25 July 2006. Archived from the original on 2 December 2006. Retrieved 13 May 2007.
  28. ↑ Winnie Chong, "'Idle' talk sparks heated debate" Archived 10 November 2007 at the Wayback Machine , The Standard, 3 November 2007
  29. ↑ "Cap 374G Reg 44". Hong Long e-Legislation. Retrieved 17 March 2017.
  30. ↑ "Mini Spotters – Hong Kong". Minispot.org. Archived from the original on 27 July 2011. Retrieved 2 February 2011.
  31. ↑ Traffic Safety is the Goal- Cleaner Air is the Result
  32. 1 2 3 Ng, Joyce (18 January 2012). "Clean-air targets don't measure up, critics say", South China Morning Post
  33. ↑ Foo, Kenneth (18 January 2012). "Clearing the air" Archived 11 May 2013 at the Wayback Machine . The Standard.

Further reading

News articles

In Chinese

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.