Calf hutch

Last updated
Calf hutch on a farm in England Calf igloos and calves in England.jpg
Calf hutch on a farm in England

A calf hutch is an enclosure used in the dairy industry to keep pre-weaned calves separated individually and outside year-round. [1] They are typically made of plastic and have an opening to a small fenced-in area or tether calves to it. [2] [3] They are commonly used around the world. [4] They have faced criticism from some researchers for negatively impacting calves and from various animal rights and animal welfare groups who call it cruel and call to end their use.

Contents

History

Early research on individual pens in the 1950s Individual portable calf pens fig 2.png
Early research on individual pens in the 1950s

In 1943, the predecessor of a calf hutch (a portable pen) was invented in the US for the stated purpose of trying to limit disease spread. In 1947, it was modified to add a roof, making it into a calf hutch itself. [1] [5] They became popular in North America in the 1970s. In 1977, they were introduced into Japan. [1]

Effects on calves

Calf hutches are known to limit calves' abilities for social and play behavior. Compared to pair housing, calves raised in hutches or other individual housing show worse social and cognitive abilities along with more vocalizations in stressful settings. [6] [7]

Studies are mixed on whether calf hutches offer lower disease risk compared to group housing. [8] Some researchers have also argued that the cleaning and ventilation of housing is a more important factor for disease than the way the calves are housed. [9]

Criticism

Various animal rights and animal welfare groups have criticized the use of calf hutches. Animal Justice has called for it to be banned in Canada. [10] [11] Animal Equality has called them a form of "extreme confinement". [12] World Animal Protection has called them a source of significant stress for calves. [13]

In 2017, the RSPCA defended their use on disease reduction grounds but suggested minimizing their use because of social harms to calves. They also acknowledged newer research suggesting that small group housing does not pose disease risks and suggested it may influence their position in the future. [14]

Global presence

Usage of calf hutches varies around the world but is common in many countries. Some countries with low usage of calf hutches still use high rates of individual housing through other methods.

In the UK, 38% of dairy farms used some form of individual housing with 16% using calf hutches specifically as of 2022. [15] In Ireland, 41% of dairy farms used some form of individual housing as of 2023. [16] A 2021 survey in China found 56% of large farms and 33% of medium-sized farms used individual separation, but around 3/4ths of calves were housed indoors. [17] In Canada, 63% of pre-weaned calves were in individual housing with 21% in hutches as of 2018. [18] As of 2014, Southern Brazil saw 70% housed individually, but primarily indoors, so only 7% of total housing were calf hutches. [19] In the US, 80% of dairy farms used individual housing, 42.1% of which were calf hutches or outdoor pens as of 2011. [20] [21]

Some countries place a degree of limitation on their use. The EU allows use for calves under 8 weeks old but not over. They also require direct visual and tactile contact between calves, but it is common for this to be ignored. [22] The UK places those requirements and also requires hutches to be large enough for calves to stand up and turn around. [14]

See also

References

  1. 1 2 3 Hoshiba, Shinji (June 30, 1986). "Environmental characteristics of calf hutches" (PDF). Journal of the Faculty of Agriculture. 63.
  2. Ugwu, Nnenna; Love, Emma; Murrell, Jo; Whay, Helen R; Knowles, Toby; Hockenhull, Jo (Jan 2021). "Development of an ethogram for hutch-housed dairy calves and determination of factors influencing their behaviour". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 234 105165. doi:10.1016/j.applanim.2020.105165. hdl:1983/c925b498-85c8-4a99-a55d-397af74f6601. The predominant hutch type is the commercial plastic outdoor calf-hutch (made of fiberglass or polythene)
  3. Stull, Carolyn; Reynolds, Jim (Mar 2008). "Calf Welfare". Veterinary Clinics of North America: Food Animal Practice. 24 (1): 191–203. doi:10.1016/j.cvfa.2007.12.001. PMID   18299038. Calves may choose between the outside or inside environment, and are either tethered to the hutch or have a perimeter fence
  4. Haberman, Jade (August 12, 2015). Biological Effects of Hutch Covers in Reducing Heat and Cold Stress in Individually Housed Dairy Calves (Master of Science thesis). Texas A&M University.
  5. Davis, L.R.; Autrey, K.M.; Herlich, H.; Hawkins, G.E. (May 1954). "Outdoor Individual Portable Pens Compared with Conventional Housing for Raising Dairy Calves". Journal of Dairy Science. 37 (5): 562–570. doi:10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(54)91299-0.
  6. Knauer, W. A.; Godden, S. M.; Rendahl, A. K.; Endres, M. I.; Crooker, B. A. (2021-03-01). "The effect of individual versus pair housing of dairy heifer calves during the preweaning period on measures of health, performance, and behavior up to 16 weeks of age". Journal of Dairy Science. 104 (3): 3495–3507. doi:10.3168/jds.2020-18928. ISSN   0022-0302. PMID   33358809.
  7. Jensen, Margit Bak; Vestergaard, Klaus S.; Krohn, Christian C. (1998-03-01). "Play behaviour in dairy calves kept in pens: the effect of social contact and space allowance". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 56 (2): 97–108. doi:10.1016/S0168-1591(97)00106-8. ISSN   0168-1591.
  8. Abdelfattah, Essam M.; Aly, Sharif S.; Lehenbauer, Terry W.; Karle, Betsy M. (June 2024). "Effects of simplified group housing on behavior, welfare, growth performance, and health of preweaned dairy calves on a California dairy". Journal of Dairy Science. 107 (6): 3927–3940. doi:10.3168/jds.2023-23820. PMID   38246538.
  9. Lidfors, Lena; Alvegard, Therese; Verbeek, Else (2024). "Effects on Health, Growth and Redirected Suckling Behaviour in Pair-Housed Dairy Calves in Outdoor Hutches" (PDF). Journal of Veterinary Medicine and Research. 11.
  10. Devine, Alanna (2025-05-07). "Ontario Dairy Farm Cruelty: Calves Found Alone & Suffering". Animal Justice. Retrieved 2025-07-28.
  11. Guttman, Suzanne (2025-05-09). "Dairy Hurts Moms: This Mother's Day, Choose Kindness". Animal Justice. Retrieved 2025-07-28.
  12. "The truth about the dairy industry". Animal Equality. 2017-12-06. Retrieved 2025-08-03.
  13. Kavanagh, Lynn (2023-05-19). "Updates to Canada's Code of Practice for Dairy Cows". World Animal Protection. Retrieved 2025-08-03.
  14. 1 2 "RSPCA Farm Animals Department Position Statement Individual hutches for calves". RSPCA.
  15. Mahendran, S. A.; Wathes, D. C.; Booth, R. E.; Blackie, N. (2022-01-01). "A survey of calf management practices and farmer perceptions of calf housing in UK dairy herds". Journal of Dairy Science. 105 (1): 409–423. doi:10.3168/jds.2021-20638. ISSN   0022-0302. PMID   34763915.
  16. Sinnott, Alison M.; Bokkers, Eddie A. M.; Murphy, John Paul; Kennedy, Emer (2023-03-10). "A Survey of Calf Housing Facilities Pre-Weaning, Management Practices and Farmer Perceptions of Calf Welfare on Irish Dairy Farms". Animals. 13 (6): 1019. doi: 10.3390/ani13061019 . ISSN   2076-2615. PMC   10044077 . PMID   36978560.
  17. Zhao, Wanying; Choi, Christopher Y.; Li, Guoming; Li, Hao; Shi, Zhengxiang (September 2021). "Pre-weaned dairy calf management practices, morbidity and mortality of bovine respiratory disease and diarrhea in China". Livestock Science. 251 104608. doi:10.1016/j.livsci.2021.104608.
  18. Winder, Charlotte B.; Bauman, Cathy A.; Duffield, Todd F.; Barkema, Herman W.; Keefe, Greg P.; Dubuc, Jocelyn; Uehlinger, Fabienne; Kelton, David F. (2018-11-01). "Canadian National Dairy Study: Heifer calf management". Journal of Dairy Science. 101 (11): 10565–10579. doi:10.3168/jds.2018-14680. ISSN   0022-0302. PMID   30172400.
  19. Hötzel, Maria J.; Longo, Cibele; Balcão, Lucas F.; Cardoso, Clarissa S.; Costa, João H. C. (2014-12-15). "A Survey of Management Practices That Influence Performance and Welfare of Dairy Calves Reared in Southern Brazil". PLOS ONE. 9 (12): e114995. Bibcode:2014PLoSO...9k4995H. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0114995 . ISSN   1932-6203. PMC   4266638 . PMID   25506692.
  20. Machado, Vinicius S; Ballou, Michael A (2022-01-01). "Overview of common practices in calf raising facilities". Translational Animal Science. 6 (1): txab234. doi:10.1093/tas/txab234. ISSN   2573-2102. PMC   8824608 . PMID   35146377.
  21. Dairy Heifer Raiser, 2011 An overview of operations that specialize in raising dairy heifers (PDF) (Report). October 2012.
  22. Mahendran, Sophie (2023-10-14). "Impacts of Individual and Pair Housing on Calves". Animal Science Cases ascs20230002. doi:10.1079/animalsciencecases.2023.0002. ISSN   3006-6387.