Foam depopulation

Last updated
Aftermath of foam depopulation being used on a flock of turkeys with a few still alive, as often occurs. Avian influenza roee shpernik 09.jpg
Aftermath of foam depopulation being used on a flock of turkeys with a few still alive, as often occurs.

Foam depopulation or foaming is a means of mass killing farm animals by spraying foam over a large area to obstruct breathing and ultimately cause suffocation. [1] It is usually used to attempt to stop disease spread. [2] Foaming has also been used to kill farm animals after backlogs in slaughtering occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic. [3] Foam depopulation has been used on poultry and pigs and has seen initial research for use on cattle. [4] It has faced criticism from some groups. Some veterinarians have called it inhumane, [5] along with many animal rights and animal welfare organizations who cite the pain caused by suffocation or the harm experienced by the stray survivors. [6] [7]

Contents

History

Foam depopulation was developed in 2006 in response to a 2004 outbreak of H5N1. [8] It received conditional approval the same year in the US by the USDA-APHIS. [9]

In the 2015 H5N2 outbreak in the US, foaming was the primary method used to kill poultry en masse with it employed at 66% of locations. [10] However, since 2019, foaming has increasingly been replaced in the US with ventilation shutdown, a controversial method which relies on suffocation and heatstroke after shutting off airways into a building. [11]

In 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic caused supply chain disruption and meat packing closures. This led to a backlog in slaughtering—leading to many locations using foaming or ventilation shutdown to mass kill farm animals outside of the typical slaughtering process. [3]

Criticism

Foam depopulation has been called inhumane by organizations such as the ASPCA, [12] Animal Justice, [13] and Mercy For Animals, [14] among others. Some veterinarians have also questioned the ethics of the method. [5] Concerns include the pain felt during suffocation and the stress or other effects on stray survivors seeing those who have died around them. [6] [7]

Other groups, such as the Center for Biological Diversity, have raised issues about the usage of PFAS from farms using firefighting foam to accomplish foam depopulation. [15]

Additionally, some researchers have raised environmental concerns about water-based foam's resource usage. Amounts vary, but using 30,000 liters of water to produce foam is typical. Water is usually the majority of the foam with foam concentrate making up 1% of it. [16]

Global usage

While first developed in the United States, foaming has seen use elsewhere. [17] For instance, usage is common in Israel [18] and Australia. [19] [20]

Some countries' governing bodies have also given support more directly to foam depopulation. For instance, the Japanese Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries has purchased equipment for foaming that can be issued out. [21] The United States National Veterinary Stockpile maintains foam depopulation units as well. [22]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Avian influenza</span> Influenza caused by viruses adapted to birds

Avian influenza, also known as avian flu, is a bird flu caused by the influenza A virus, which can infect people. It is similar to other types of animal flu in that it is caused by a virus strain that has adapted to a specific host. The type with the greatest risk is highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Influenza A virus subtype H5N1</span> Subtype of influenza A virus

Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 (A/H5N1) is a subtype of the influenza A virus which can cause illness in humans and many other species. A bird-adapted strain of H5N1, called HPAI A(H5N1) for highly pathogenic avian influenza virus of type A of subtype H5N1, is the highly pathogenic causative agent of H5N1 flu, commonly known as avian influenza. It is enzootic in many bird populations, especially in Southeast Asia. One strain of HPAI A(H5N1) is spreading globally after first appearing in Asia. It is epizootic and panzootic, killing tens of millions of birds and spurring the culling of hundreds of millions of others to stem its spread. Many references to "bird flu" and H5N1 in the popular media refer to this strain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chick culling</span> Process of killing newly hatched chicks for which the industry has no use

Chick culling or unwanted chick killing is the process of separating and killing unwanted chicks for which the intensive animal farming industry has no use. It occurs in all industrialised egg production, whether free range, organic, or battery cage. However, some certified pasture-raised egg farms are taking steps to eliminate the practice entirely. Worldwide, around 7 billion male chicks are culled each year in the egg industry. Because male chickens do not lay eggs and only those in breeding programmes are required to fertilise eggs, they are considered redundant to the egg-laying industry and are usually killed shortly after being sexed, which occurs just days after they are conceived or after they hatch. Some methods of culling that do not involve anaesthetics include: cervical dislocation, asphyxiation by carbon dioxide, and maceration using a high-speed grinder. Maceration is the primary method in the United States. Maceration is often a preferred method over carbon dioxide asphyxiation in western countries as it is often considered as "more humane" due to the deaths occurring immediately or within a second.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Culling</span> Process of segregating organisms in biology

Culling is the process of segregating organisms from a group according to desired or undesired characteristics. In animal breeding, it is removing or segregating animals from a breeding stock based on a specific trait. This is done to exaggerate desirable characteristics, or to remove undesirable characteristics by altering the genetic makeup of the population. For livestock and wildlife, culling often refers to killing removed animals based on their characteristics, such as their sex or species membership, or as a means of preventing infectious disease transmission.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transmission and infection of H5N1</span> Spread of an influenza virus

Transmission and infection of H5N1 from infected avian sources to humans has been a concern since the first documented case of human infection in 1997, due to the global spread of H5N1 that constitutes a pandemic threat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Influenza A virus subtype H5N2</span> Virus subtype

H5 N2 is a subtype of the species Influenzavirus A. The subtype infects a wide variety of birds, including chickens, ducks, turkeys, falcons, and ostriches. Affected birds usually do not appear ill, and the disease is often mild as avian influenza viral subtypes go. Some variants of the subtype are much more pathogenic than others, and outbreaks of "high-path" H5N2 result in the culling of thousands of birds in poultry farms from time to time. It appears that people who work with birds can be infected by the virus, but suffer hardly any noticeable health effects. Even people exposed to the highly pathogenic H5N2 variety that killed ostrich chicks in South Africa only seem to have developed conjunctivitis, or a perhaps a mild respiratory illness. There is no evidence of human-to-human spread of H5N2. On November 12, 2005 it was reported that a falcon was found to have H5N2.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Influenza A virus subtype H7N7</span> Virus subtype

Influenza A virus subtype H7N7 (A/H7N7) is a subtype of Influenza A virus, a genus of Orthomyxovirus, the viruses responsible for influenza. Highly pathogenic strains (HPAI) and low pathogenic strains (LPAI) exist. H7N7 can infect humans, birds, pigs, seals, and horses in the wild; and has infected mice in laboratory studies. This unusual zoonotic potential represents a pandemic threat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Influenza A virus subtype H5N8</span> Subtype of Influenza A virus, also known as Avian or Bird Flu

H5N8 is a subtype of the influenza A virus and is highly lethal to wild birds and poultry. H5N8 is typically not associated with humans. However, seven people in Russia were found to be infected in 2021, becoming the first documented human cases.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Global spread of H5N1 in 2006</span>

The global spread of H5N1 in birds is considered a significant pandemic threat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2007 Bernard Matthews H5N1 outbreak</span> Avian influenza outbreak in United Kingdom in 2007

The 2007 Bernard Matthews H5N1 outbreak was an occurrence of avian influenza in England caused by the H5N1 subtype of Influenza virus A that began on 30 January 2007. The infection affected poultry at one of Bernard Matthews' farms in Holton in Suffolk. It was the third instance of H5N1-subtype detected in the United Kingdom and a range of precautions were instituted to prevent spread of the disease including a large cull of turkeys, the imposition of segregation zones, and a disinfection programme for the plant.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Poultry farming</span> Part of animal husbandry

Poultry farming is the form of animal husbandry which raises domesticated birds such as chickens, ducks, turkeys and geese to produce meat or eggs for food. Poultry – mostly chickens – are farmed in great numbers. More than 60 billion chickens are killed for consumption annually. Chickens raised for eggs are known as layers, while chickens raised for meat are called broilers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Global spread of H5N1 in 2007</span>

The global spread of H5N1 in birds is considered a significant pandemic threat.

Rembrandt Enterprises (REI) is an American company headquartered in Spirit Lake, Iowa. The company was founded in 2000 and is named after its egg operation in Rembrandt, Iowa. The company runs one of the world's largest egg producing and processing facilities. As of July 2023, the ownership of the company is unclear. There is conflicting information on whether the company was sold to an unnamed buyer. The company has faced criticism for their treatment of hens generally along with the usage of ventilation shutdown and treatment of workers following the appearance of avian influenza in March 2022.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2015 United States H5N2 outbreak</span> 2015 outbreak of avian influenza subtype H5N2

In 2015, an outbreak of avian influenza subtype H5N2 was identified in a series of chicken and turkey farming operations in the Midwestern United States. By May 30, more than 43 million birds in 15 states had been destroyed as a result of the outbreak, including nearly 30 million in Iowa alone, the nation's largest egg producer. In the Midwestern U.S., the average price of eggs had increased 120% between April 22 and May 30. The effects however were seen nationwide, with prices in California up 71% in the same timeframe.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2017 Central Luzon H5N6 outbreak</span> Bird flu outbreak in the Philippines

From April to September 2017 in the Philippines, an outbreak of H5N6 avian influenza or bird flu affected poultry in at least three towns in Central Luzon; San Luis in Pampanga and Jaen and San Isidro in Nueva Ecija.

Farm Forward is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit whose mission is to promote conscientious eating, reduce farmed animal suffering, and advance sustainable agriculture. Farm Forward aims to eliminate the most harmful practices in intensive animal agriculture, increase the market share of humane and sustainable animal agriculture, and raise awareness about the cultural significance of animal agriculture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2020–2023 H5N8 outbreak</span> Outbreak of Avian influenza in poultry farms and wild birds

In the early 2020s, an ongoing outbreak of avian influenza subtype H5N8 has been occurring at poultry farms and among wild bird populations in several countries and continents, leading to the subsequent cullings of millions of birds to prevent a pandemic similar to that of the H5N1 outbreak in 2008. The first case of human transmission of avian flu, also known as bird flu, was reported by Russian authorities in February 2021, as several poultry farm workers tested positive for the virus.

Iowa Select Farms is a pork production operation headquartered in Iowa Falls, the largest in Iowa, and the fourth largest in the United States. It grew in the 1970s, was officially founded in 1992 and as of 2023 produced more than 5 million pigs on 800 CAFOs in 50 Iowa counties. Throughout the 1990s there was rural backlash against the expansion of factory farming with its negative environmental impact of pig farming, but Iowa´s hog industry, led by Hansen, has successfully lobbied state politicians to roll back regulations pertaining to CAFOs.

Ventilation shutdown (VSD) is a means to kill livestock by suffocation and heat stroke in which airways to the building in which the livestock are kept are cut off. It is used for mass killing — usually to prevent the spread of diseases such as avian influenza. Animal rights organizations have called the practice unethical. The addition of carbon dioxide or additional heat to the enclosure is known as ventilation shutdown plus (VSD+).

Since 2020, global cases of avian influenza subtype H5N1 have been rising, with cases reported from every continent as of February 2023 except for Australia and Antarctica. In late 2023, H5N1 was discovered in the Antarctic for the first time, raising fears of imminent spread throughout the region, potentially leading to a "catastrophic breeding failure" among animals that had not previously been exposed to avian influenza viruses. The virus involved in the outbreak is classified in H5 clade 2.3.4.4b.

References

  1. "New weapon in war on bird flu: tiny bubbles". NBC News. 2007-06-10. Retrieved 2024-01-21.
  2. Bolotnikova, Marina (2022-03-08). "'They're cooking them alive': calls to ban 'cruel' killing methods on US farms". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 2024-01-21.
  3. 1 2 Kevany, Sophie (2020-04-29). "Millions of farm animals culled as US food supply chain chokes up". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 2024-01-20.
  4. Capria, Vittoria M; Arruda, Andréia G; Cheng, Ting-Yu; Campler, Magnus R; Youngblood, Brad L; Moeller, Steven J; Bowman, Andrew S; Kieffer, Justin D (2023-01-01). "Water-based medium-expansion foam depopulation of adult cattle". Translational Animal Science. 7 (1): txad065. doi:10.1093/tas/txad065. ISSN   2573-2102. PMC   10321402 . PMID   37415594.
  5. 1 2 Donn, Jeff (2007-08-26). "Industry looking for 'humane' way to slay thousands". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 2024-01-21.
  6. 1 2 Bolotnikova, Marina (2023-11-17). "Bird flu is surging again on poultry farms. The US is normalizing the cruelest mass killing method to stop it". Vox. Retrieved 2024-01-20.
  7. 1 2 "Bird flu's grisly question: how to kill millions of poultry". AP News. 2022-04-07. Retrieved 2024-01-31.
  8. Gurung, Shailesh; Hoffman, John; Stringfellow, Kendre; Abi-Ghanem, Daad; Zhao, Dan; Caldwell, David; Lee, Jason; Styles, Darrel; Berghman, Luc; Byrd, James; Farnell, Yuhua; Archer, Gregory; Farnell, Morgan (2018-01-11). "Depopulation of Caged Layer Hens with a Compressed Air Foam System". Animals. 8 (1): 11. doi: 10.3390/ani8010011 . ISSN   2076-2615. PMC   5789306 . PMID   29324639.
  9. Benson, E.R.; Alphin, R.L.; Dawson, M.D.; Malone, G.W. (May 2009). "Use of water-based foam to depopulate ducks and other species". Poultry Science. 88 (5): 904–910. doi:10.3382/ps.2008-00268. PMID   19359675.
  10. Final Report for the 2014–2015 Outbreak of Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza (HPAI) in the United States (PDF) (Report). August 11, 2016.
  11. Reyes-Illg, Gwendolen; Martin, Jessica E.; Mani, Indu; Reynolds, James; Kipperman, Barry (2022-12-29). "The Rise of Heatstroke as a Method of Depopulating Pigs and Poultry: Implications for the US Veterinary Profession". Animals. 13 (1): 140. doi: 10.3390/ani13010140 . ISSN   2076-2615. PMC   9817707 . PMID   36611748.
  12. "Our Fight Against Inhumane "Depopulation" Methods | ASPCA". www.aspca.org. August 6, 2020. Retrieved 2024-02-10.
  13. Labchuk, Camille (2022-07-05). ""Live Birds Buried Under Dead Ones": Whistleblower Speaks Out About Avian Flu Cull". Animal Justice. Retrieved 2024-02-10.
  14. Bugga, Hannah (2020-08-05). "Mercy For Animals Urges Congress Not to Fund Cruel Mass Killing". Mercy For Animals. Retrieved 2024-02-10.
  15. Kevany, Sophie (2020-06-30). "Ban burning and burying of animals in US Covid-19 farm culls, NGOs urge". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 2024-02-14.
  16. Benson, E. R.; Alphin, R. L.; Rankin, M. K.; Caputo, M. P.; Hougentogler, D. P.; Johnson, A. L. (Dec 2012). "Mass Emergency Water-Based Foam Depopulation of Poultry". Avian Diseases. 56 (4s1): 891–896. doi:10.1637/10160-040912-Reg.1. ISSN   0005-2086. PMID   23402109. S2CID   22903879.
  17. "Mas Depop & Euthanasia – Avian Euthanasia" (PDF). Foreign Animal Disease Preparedness & Response Plan (FAD PReP)/National Animal Health Emergency Management System (NAHEMS). 2015.
  18. Avidov, R.; Sudharsan Varma, V.; Saadi, I.; Hanan, A.; Yoselevich, I.; Lublin, A.; Chen, Y.; Laor, Y. (Jan 2021). "Physical and chemical indicators of transformations of poultry carcass parts and broiler litter during short term thermophilic composting". Waste Management. 119: 202–214. Bibcode:2021WaMan.119..202A. doi:10.1016/j.wasman.2020.09.040. ISSN   0956-053X. PMID   33070090. S2CID   224784653.
  19. Angus, Crossan (November 2014). Development and Extension of Industry Best Practice for On-Farm Euthanasia of Spent Layer Hens (PDF) (Report). ISBN   978-1-921010-53-8.
  20. Operational manual: Destruction of animals (PDF) (Report). Animal Health Australia. 2015. ISBN   978-1-876-71438-3.
  21. John, Weaver (October 2016). PVS Evaluation Report (PDF) (Report). World Organisation for Animal Health.
  22. 2024 USDA EXPLANATORY NOTES – ANIMAL AND PLANT HEALTH INSPECTION SERVICE (PDF) (Report). 2024.