Nigel Godrich | |
---|---|
Background information | |
Birth name | Nigel Timothy Godrich |
Born | Westminster, London, England | 28 February 1971
Genres | Alternative rock, experimental rock, electronic |
Occupation(s) | Recording engineer, record producer, musician, DJ |
Instrument(s) | Keyboards, guitar, bass |
Years active | 1990–present |
Member of | Ultraísta |
Formerly of | Atoms for Peace |
Nigel Timothy Godrich (born 28 February 1971) is an English record producer, recording engineer and musician. He has worked with acts including Radiohead, Travis, Beck, Air, Paul McCartney, U2, R.E.M., Pavement, Roger Waters, Arcade Fire and Idles.
Early in his career, Godrich worked as the house engineer at RAK Studios, London, under the producer John Leckie. He met Radiohead while working on their second album, The Bends (1995), at RAK. Radiohead hired him to produce OK Computer (1997), which was a major success and brought him attention from major artists. He has produced all of their albums since, along with several projects with the Radiohead members Thom Yorke and Jonny Greenwood. Godrich won the Grammy Award for Best Engineered Non-Classical Album for the 2003 Radiohead album Hail to the Thief.
Godrich is a member of the bands Atoms for Peace (with Yorke) and Ultraísta. In 2006, he launched the music webseries From the Basement . In 2010, Godrich and Beck composed the score for Scott Pilgrim vs. the World , Godrich's first film work.
Nigel Godrich was born in Westminster, London, the son of Victor Godrich, a BBC sound supervisor, and Brenda Godrich.[ citation needed ] He was fascinated by recording at an early age. [1] As a child, after he asked for a machine to make records, his father bought him a cassette machine; Godrich used it to make recordings of his television, train sets and running water. [1]
Godrich was educated at William Ellis School in North West London, where he shared classes with his friend and the future Zero 7 member Henry Binns.[ citation needed ] Godrich began playing guitar, inspired by Jimi Hendrix and Frank Zappa.[ citation needed ] He first visited a recording studio at the age of 16, when his band recorded a demo at Elephant Studios, Wapping, and spent time asking the engineer questions. [2] He studied at the School of Audio Engineering (SAE), London. [3]
After graduating from SAE, Godrich became a junior staff member at the Audio One studio complex, working as a tea boy. [3] He did not enjoy his time there. [4] According to Godrich, "With a beeper in my pocket, I'd wait next to the kettle, ready to deliver my hot beverages. I wasn't even allowed in the studios, but I [would] hang there thinking, 'OK, it's only the first rung, but at least I'm on the ladder.'" [3]
After the closure of Audio One, [4] in 1990 Godrich worked at RAK Studios, London, first as a messenger and later as a studio assistant. He would stay late at night, inviting musician friends to play there while he practised recording them. [3] At RAK, he became a tape operator for the producer John Leckie, with whom he worked on albums by Ride and Denim. [4]
After four years, Godrich left RAK to go freelance and set up his own studio, Shabang, where he planned to create dance music. [4] Six months later, he was hired to engineer and mix The Sound Of... McAlmont & Butler (1995), the debut album by McAlmont & Butler. Godrich said it was a "brilliant experience" and credited Bernard Butler with teaching him how to produce records. [4] Godrich produced the self-titled debut album by Silver Sun , released in May 1997. [4]
Godrich first worked with the rock band Radiohead when John Leckie hired him at RAK to engineer their EP My Iron Lung (1994) and their second album, The Bends (1995). [3] The band nicknamed him "Nihilist", approving of his efforts to take their sound in new directions. [3] When Leckie left the studio to attend a social engagement, Radiohead and Godrich stayed to record B-sides. One song, "Black Star", was instead included on The Bends. [3] In 1995, Godrich produced Radiohead's charity single "Lucky", plus the B-sides "Bishop's Robes" and "Talk Show Host", released on the 1996 single "Street Spirit (Fade Out)". [3]
I can only ever have one band like Radiohead who I've worked with for this many years. That's a very deep and profound relationship. The Beatles could only have ever had one George Martin; they couldn't have switched producers halfway through their career. All that work, trust, and knowledge of each other would have been thrown out of the window and they’d have to start again.
—Godrich in 2016 [5]
Radiohead invited Godrich to co-produce their third album, OK Computer (1997). [3] It won Best Alternative Album at the 40th Grammy Awards [6] and sold more than 4.5 million copies worldwide. [7] Working in improvised studios without supervision, Godrich and the band learned as they went, and credited the success to the open process. In 2013, Godrich told the Guardian : "OK Computer was such a big thing for me because I was given power for the first time. Some of these incredibly intelligent and insightful people said 'do what you want' to me so I worked my arse off for them and together we did something that represents where we all were at the time. And it stuck for some reason. People got it, so that changed my life." [8]
Godrich has produced every Radiohead studio album since. He won the Grammy Award for Best Engineered Non-Classical Album for their sixth album, Hail to the Thief (2003). [9] For their seventh album, In Rainbows (2007), Radiohead initially hired a new producer, Spike Stent. According to the guitarist Ed O'Brien, Radiohead wanted to get out of the "comfort zone" by working with a new producer, [10] and the bassist, Colin Greenwood, said Godrich was busy working with Charlotte Gainsbourg and Beck. [11] Radiohead re-enlisted Godrich after their sessions with Stent proved fruitless. [12]
Godrich's father died during the recording of Radiohead's ninth album, A Moon Shaped Pool (2016). Godrich wrote: "Making this album was a very intense experience for me. I lost my dad in the process. Hence a large piece of my soul lives here in a good way." [13] Godrich provided sound design for Kid A Mnesia Exhibition (2021), an interactive experience created for the anniversary of Kid A and Amnesiac. [14]
In 2006, CBC described Godrich's collaboration with Radiohead as "the most adventurous band-producer partnership in modern rock". [3] He has been dubbed the band's "sixth member", an allusion to Beatles producer George Martin being called the "fifth Beatle". [3] Godrich also plays Chieftain Mews, a long-running character who appears in Radiohead's promotional material. [15]
Godrich has produced most of the solo work by the Radiohead singer, Thom Yorke, including his albums The Eraser (2006), Tomorrow's Modern Boxes (2014) [16] and Anima (2019). [17] Yorke credits Godrich with helping edit his work, identifying which parts need improvement and which have potential. He gave the example of the Eraser song "Black Swan", which originally was "a six-minute load of crap, except for this one juicy bit, and [Godrich] goes past and goes, 'That bit. Fuck the rest.' Usually it's something like that." [18]
Godrich said: "When we were in a room when it's with Radiohead ... I'm trying to manage a relationship between [Yorke] and the band and it's me butting heads with him and trying to work on behalf of the band. As soon as he and I were alone, we found that the dynamic was completely different, we were pulling in the same direction and it was incredibly productive." [19]
In 2009, to perform songs from The Eraser, Godrich and Yorke formed Atoms for Peace, with Godrich on guitar, keyboards and synthesisers. The band also includes the bassist Flea of the Red Hot Chili Peppers, the drummer Joey Waronker of Beck and R.E.M., and the percussionist Mauro Refosco of Forro in the Dark. [20] Their debut album, Amok , produced by Godrich, was released in 2013, [21] [22] followed by a tour of Europe, the US and Japan. [23] Godrich engineered Junun , a 2015 album by the Radiohead guitarist Jonny Greenwood, the Israeli composer Shye Ben Tzur and the Indian ensemble the Rajasthan Express, recorded at Mehrangarh Fort in Rajasthan, India. [24]
Godrich produced A Light for Attracting Attention (2022), the debut album by the Smile, a band comprising Yorke, Greenwood and the drummer Tom Skinner. [25] The Guardian critic Alexis Petridis said the Smile "sound like a simultaneously more skeletal and knottier version of Radiohead", exploring more progressive rock influences with unusual time signatures, complex riffs and "hard-driving" motorik psychedelia. [26] Godrich mixed Jarak Qaribak , a 2023 album by Greenwood and the Israeli rock musician Dudu Tasaa. [27]
Following his success with OK Computer, Godrich mixed most of Natalie Imbruglia's hit album Left of the Middle (1997) [3] and R.E.M.'s Up (1998). [3] Godrich produced three albums by the American singer-songwriter Beck: Mutations (1998), Sea Change (2002) and The Information (2006). The first two, particularly Sea Change, were noted for their atmospheric folk/pop sound, a departure from the spontaneous, sample-heavy style Beck was known for.[ citation needed ]
Godrich produced several albums by Travis, including their commercial breakthrough, The Man Who (1999), and its followup, The Invisible Band (2001). [3] According to the Travis songwriter, Fran Healy, Godrich was frustrated after the gruelling sessions for Radiohead's albums Kid A and Amnesiac, and so "took it out on us because he couldn't take it out on Radiohead". [28] The mood settled after an argument. [28] Healy felt it was good for Godrich to work with "melodic" bands such as Travis as well as more experimental acts such as Radiohead. [28] Godrich co-produced the Travis albums The Boy With No Name (2007) with Brian Eno and Mike Hedges.[ citation needed ]
Godrich produced Pavement's final album, Terror Twilight (1999), with Radiohead's Jonny Greenwood contributing harmonica on two tracks. [29] Godrich, a fan of the band, hoped to help them find a bigger audience with a less "sloppy" record. [30] Songwriter Stephen Malkmus later described the album as "overproduced" and described conflicts with Godrich. [31] In response, Godrich tweeted: "I literally slept on a friend's floor in NYC to be able to make that album." [31] In 2020, Godrich said that he loved the album and had enjoyed making it. [31]
In 2001, Godrich remixed U2's "Walk On" for its single release, and mixed and contributed production to Air's albums Talkie Walkie (2004) and Pocket Symphony (2007).[ citation needed ] In 2002, Godrich was hired to produce the second album by the Strokes, Room on Fire (2003). He was fired when their work, according to the band, proved "soulless". [32] Godrich said of the failed collaboration: "The problem there was that me and [singer Julian Casablancas] are just too similar, we're both control freaks. He wanted to do it his way, I wanted to do it my way, and obviously that's the point of me being there. And I'm saying 'Well, why am I here if you're not prepared to try and do it the way I want to do it?' We got on great, it was just one of those laughable things where it just doesn't work. I wanted them to change, and they didn't." [33]
Godrich produced the 20th-anniversary version of "Do They Know It's Christmas?", released in December 2004, which featured Yorke and Greenwood. [34] Paul McCartney hired Godrich to produce his album Chaos and Creation in the Backyard (2005) after being recommended by Beatles producer George Martin. Godrich fired McCartney's touring band and demanded that McCartney abandon songs Godrich found clichéd, over-sentimental, or subpar. [3] [35] The album was nominated for several Grammy Awards, including Album of the Year, and Godrich was nominated for Producer of the Year. [3]
In 2010, Godrich and Beck composed the score for Scott Pilgrim vs. the World , Godrich's first film work. [36] In October 2012, Godrich, along with Joey Waronker and singer Laura Bettinson, released an album as Ultraísta. In 2015, he produced the live album Roger Waters: The Wall , [37] and made a cameo as a Stormtrooper in Star Wars: The Force Awakens . [38] He mixed the Red Hot Chili Peppers' eleventh studio album, The Getaway (2016). [39] Godrich produced the fifth solo album by Roger Waters, Is This the Life We Really Want? , released in June 2017. [40] Godrich, a fan of Waters' work with Pink Floyd, was critical of Waters' previous solo work and felt his role as producer was to "encourage him, to push him a little bit". [41] During the COVID-19 pandemic, Godrich worked with the Arcade Fire in isolation in El Paso, Texas, producing their album We (2022). [42]
In September 2006, it was announced that Godrich, along with producer Dilly Gent, producer James Chads and John Woollcombe, were shooting the music series From the Basement , filmed from London's Maida Vale Studios. [43] The series focused on intimate, live performances by musicians without a host or an audience. Godrich said, "I'm really interested to capture some really iconic, bigger names– really the whole point is to get people who are having their moment, to try and get a definitive record of what they're doing." [44]
Godrich conceived From the Basement as a means of authentically documenting music being made. Drawing further inspiration from British television music series The Old Grey Whistle Test , Godrich came upon the idea of a television programme. Despite early reports, From the Basement did not initially appear on British television, because of not taking on corporate sponsors. [44]
When the pilot was in production, From the Basement was to be an online programme only. However, this was not feasible as it did not generate enough money to produce the episodes to the quality level desired. Instead, the producers went to international TV networks to receive money up front to produce the series. [45] The series did eventually air on television; the first UK broadcast was on Sky Arts on 1 December 2007, featuring four songs performed by Thom Yorke on 8 December 2007. [46] [47] The United States premiere was on Rave HD on 22 February 2008, followed by a run on Independent Film Channel, as part of the network's "Automat" block of television programmes in the autumn of 2008. [48] On 3 November 2008, the series was released on DVD. [49] A new series of From the Basement began on YouTube in May 2022, featuring acts including Idles, Warpaint and Caribou. [50]
Godrich credited the producers Phil Thornalley, John Leckie and Steve Lillywhite for teaching him his craft, saying they were "people I watched directly and emulated". [1] He named his "heroes" as the Beatles producer George Martin, for "inventing the job", and Trevor Horn, for being "the thing that really made me sit up and listen". [33] He said Joni Mitchell was his favourite artist, citing her "unique combination of musical and lyrical talent". [1]
Godrich said that although he enjoys listening to "clinical" and "shiny" music, he works best creating "organic" sounds: "Making a dark brown soup was more my skill, [rather] than making a big fairy cake." [33] He does not approach acts he produces; instead, he waits for them to contact him, as he does not assume he could improve the work of acts he already admires. [1]
Godrich said he believes people place too much emphasis on studio equipment and "trickery", which is less important than musical sensibility and communication. He said: "I get very annoyed with people asking me what my favourite microphone is. It doesn't matter ... One of the reasons why music has become generally worse, and I'm sorry to say that, is that people think about technology more than the actual music they're making." [1] He feels that "the recording process is best when fast, because it's then the smallest obstacle to the actual music". [1]
Year | Title | Artist | Credits |
---|---|---|---|
1990 | Scandalo | Gianna Nannini | Assistant engineer |
1990 | Tune In | The Silent Blue | Engineer, producer |
1991 | Superstition | Siouxsie and the Banshees | Assistant engineer |
1992 | Vivienne McKone | Vivienne McKone | Assistant engineer |
1993 | Buffalo Skinners | Big Country | Assistant engineer |
1994 | Carnival of Light | Ride | Engineer |
1994 | Heitor | Heitor | Engineer |
1994 | My Iron Lung EP | Radiohead | Producer, engineer |
1995 | The Bends | Radiohead | Engineer, producer ("Black Star") |
1995 | Feeling Mission | Harvest Ministers | Engineer |
1995 | Totally | Tee | Engineer |
1995 | Booth and the Bad Angel | Tim Booth & Angelo Badalamenti | Engineer |
1996 | English and French | Hopper | Engineer |
1996 | Sun..! | Sun..! | Engineer |
1996 | Sound of..McAlmont & Butler | McAlmont & Butler | Engineer, Assistant engineer, Mixing |
1997 | OK Computer | Radiohead | Balance engineer, recording technician (Producer) |
1997 | Silver Sun | Silver Sun | Producer, mixing |
1997 | Plagiarism | Sparks | Engineer |
1997 | Left of the Middle | Natalie Imbruglia | mixing |
1998 | Mutations | Beck | Producer, mixing |
1998 | Sisters in Pain | Jamaica | Engineer |
1998 | Try Whistling This | Neil Finn | Remixer, mixing |
1998 | Up | R.E.M. | Mixing |
1999 | Can You Still Feel? | Jason Falkner | Engineer |
1999 | The Man Who | Travis | Producer, mixing |
1999 | Terror Twilight | Pavement | Producer |
2000 | Kid A | Radiohead | Producer, engineer, mixing |
2001 | "Walk On" | U2 | Remixer |
2001 | Amnesiac | Radiohead | Producer, engineer |
2001 | The Invisible Band | Travis | Producer, mixing |
2001 | Regeneration | The Divine Comedy | Producer |
2002 | Rouge on Pockmarked Cheeks | Brazzaville | Producer, mixing, String ensemble, Fender Rhodes |
2002 | Sea Change | Beck | Producer, engineer, mixing, synthesizer, percussion, keyboards |
2003 | City Reading | Air & Alessandro Baricco | Mixing |
2003 | Hail to the Thief | Radiohead | Editing, mixing, Operation, Recording, producer |
2004 | Absent Friends | The Divine Comedy | Mixing |
2004 | Heroes to Zeros | The Beta Band | Mixing |
2004 | Talkie Walkie | Air | Producer, engineer, mixing |
2004 | When It Falls | Zero 7 | Guitar, Sounds |
2004 | "Do They Know It's Christmas?" | Band Aid 20 | Producer |
2005 | Chaos and Creation in the Backyard | Paul McCartney | Producer, piano and Epiphone acoustic guitar loops |
2005 | Guero | Beck | Mixing |
2005 | The Roads Don't Love You | Gemma Hayes | Mixing |
2006 | The Eraser | Thom Yorke | Producer, mixing, musician, arranger |
2006 | 5:55 | Charlotte Gainsbourg | Producer, mixing |
2006 | The Garden | Zero 7 | Acoustic guitar, engineer |
2006 | The Information | Beck | Producer, engineer, mixing, keyboards, Programming, Effects, Scratching, Tambourine, percussion, background vocals, Speak & Spell, whistle, Tote A Tune, Kalimba, drums, Game Boy |
2006 | Dad's Weird Dream | Silver Sun | Remixing |
2007 | Pocket Symphony | Air | Producer |
2007 | The Boy With No Name | Travis | Producer |
2007 | In Rainbows | Radiohead | Producer, engineer, mixing |
2008 | Odd Couple | Gnarls Barkley | Engineer, mixing |
2010 | Turn Ons | The Hotrats | Producer, engineer, mixing, Additional instruments and noises |
2011 | The King of Limbs | Radiohead | Producer, engineer, mixing |
2011 | Supercollider / The Butcher | Radiohead | Producer, engineer, mixing |
2011 | The Daily Mail / Staircase | Radiohead | Producer, engineer, mixing |
2012 | A Different Ship | Here We Go Magic | Producer |
2012 | Ultraísta | Ultraísta | Composer, engineer, mixing, producer |
2013 | AMOK | Atoms For Peace | Producer, Programmer |
2014 | Warpaint | Warpaint | Mixing |
2014 | Tomorrow's Modern Boxes | Thom Yorke | Composer, producer |
2015 | Junun | Shye Ben Tzur, Jonny Greenwood, the Rajasthan Express | Recording, engineer, mixing |
2016 | A Moon Shaped Pool | Radiohead | Producer |
2016 | The Getaway | Red Hot Chili Peppers | Mixing |
2017 | Is This the Life We Really Want? | Roger Waters | Producer, keyboards, guitar, sound collages, arrangements |
2019 | Anima | Thom Yorke | Composer, producer |
2020 | Sister | Ultraísta | Composer, engineer, mixing, producer |
2022 | We | Arcade Fire | Producer |
2022 | A Light for Attracting Attention | The Smile | Composer, producer |
2024 | Tangk | Idles | Producer |
Year | Song | Artist | Album |
---|---|---|---|
1997 | "She" | The Sundays | Static & Silence |
2004 | "Speed Dial No 2" | Zero 7 | When It Falls |
2006 | "Movie Theme" | Beck | The Information |
2006 | "Soldier Jane" | Beck | The Information |
2006 | "The Horrible Fanfare/Landslide/Exoskeleton" | Beck | The Information |
2006 | "Motorcade" | Beck | The Information |
2010 | List of composed songs
| Nigel Godrich | Scott Pilgrim vs. the World (Original Motion Picture Score) |
Radiohead are an English rock band formed in Abingdon, Oxfordshire, in 1985. They comprise Thom Yorke ; brothers Jonny Greenwood and Colin Greenwood (bass); Ed O'Brien ; and Philip Selway. They have worked with the producer Nigel Godrich and the cover artist Stanley Donwood since 1994. Radiohead's experimental approach is credited with advancing the sound of alternative rock.
The Bends is the second studio album by the English rock band Radiohead, released on 13 March 1995 by Parlophone. It was produced by John Leckie, with extra production by Radiohead, Nigel Godrich and Jim Warren. The Bends combines guitar songs and ballads, with more restrained arrangements and cryptic lyrics than Radiohead's debut album, Pablo Honey (1993).
Thomas Edward Yorke is an English musician who is the main vocalist and songwriter of the rock band Radiohead. He plays guitar, bass, keyboards and other instruments, and is noted for his falsetto. Rolling Stone described Yorke as one of the greatest and most influential singers of his generation.
My Iron Lung is the third EP by the English rock band Radiohead, released on 26 September 1994 by Parlophone Records in the UK and by Capitol Records in the US. It was produced by Radiohead, John Leckie and Nigel Godrich. It marked Radiohead's first collaborations with Godrich and the artist Stanley Donwood, who have worked on every Radiohead release since.
"Everything in Its Right Place" is a song by the English rock band Radiohead, released as the opening track of their fourth studio album, Kid A (2000). It features synthesiser, digitally manipulated vocals and unusual time signatures. The lyrics were inspired by the stress felt by the singer, Thom Yorke, while promoting Radiohead's album OK Computer (1997).
The Eraser is the debut solo album by the English musician Thom Yorke, released on 10 July 2006 through XL Recordings. It was produced by Nigel Godrich, the longtime producer for Yorke's band Radiohead.
In Rainbows is the seventh studio album by the English rock band Radiohead. It was self-released on 10 October 2007 as a pay-what-you-want download, followed by a retail release internationally through XL Recordings on 3 December 2007 and in North America through TBD Records on 1 January 2008. It was Radiohead's first release after their recording contract with EMI ended with their album Hail to the Thief (2003).
From the Basement is a web television series created by Nigel Godrich and producer Dilly Gent. It features live music performances by artists in a studio environment without a host or audience.
"Reckoner" is a song by the English rock band Radiohead, released on their seventh album, In Rainbows (2007). It was produced by Nigel Godrich and developed while Radiohead were working on another song, "Feeling Pulled Apart by Horses".
"Jigsaw Falling into Place" is a song by the English rock band Radiohead, produced by Nigel Godrich. It was the first single from Radiohead's seventh studio album, In Rainbows (2007), on 14 January 2008. The music video, directed by Garth Jennings and Adam Buxton, features Radiohead performing in their studio with cameras attached to bicycle helmets.
"FeelingPulledApartByHorses" and "TheHollowEarth" are songs by Thom Yorke, produced by Nigel Godrich. They were released as a limited double A-side vinyl in September 2009, and as a download on 6 October 2009.
Atoms for Peace were an English-American rock supergroup comprising the Radiohead songwriter Thom Yorke, the Red Hot Chili Peppers bassist Flea, the Radiohead producer Nigel Godrich, the drummer Joey Waronker of Beck and R.E.M., and the percussionist Mauro Refosco of Forro in the Dark.
"Lucky" is a song by the English rock band Radiohead, first released on The Help Album, a 1995 charity compilation organised by the charity War Child. "Lucky" was recorded in five hours with the producer Nigel Godrich. Radiohead included it on their third studio album, OK Computer (1997), and released it as a single in France in December 1997.
The King of Limbs is the eighth studio album by the English rock band Radiohead. It was self-released on 18 February 2011 as a download, followed by a physical release on 28 March through XL Recordings internationally and TBD Records in North America.
The King of Limbs: Live from the Basement is a 2011 live video album by the English rock band Radiohead, performing their eighth album, The King of Limbs (2011). It was Radiohead's second performance for the series From the Basement, following In Rainbows – From the Basement (2008). Radiohead's producer, Nigel Godrich, described it as an effort to record a different version of TheKing of Limbs and show it in a "different light".
Tomorrow's Modern Boxes is the second studio album by the English musician Thom Yorke, released on 26 September 2014. It was produced by Nigel Godrich, with artwork by Stanley Donwood, both of whom have long collaborated with Yorke and his band Radiohead. The album blends Yorke's vocals and piano playing with electronic beats and textures.
"Daydreaming" is a song by the English rock band Radiohead, produced by Nigel Godrich. The song is a piano ballad with strings arranged by the Radiohead guitarist Jonny Greenwood. It was released as a download on 6 May 2016 as the second and final single from Radiohead's ninth studio album, A Moon Shaped Pool, accompanied by a music video directed by Paul Thomas Anderson.
"Man of War" is a song by the English rock band Radiohead, released on 22 June 2017 on the compilation OK Computer OKNOTOK 1997 2017.
The Smile are an English rock band comprising Thom Yorke, Jonny Greenwood and Tom Skinner (drums). Critics likened them to Yorke and Greenwood's band Radiohead, with more jazz, krautrock and progressive rock influences and a looser, wilder sound.
A Light for Attracting Attention is the debut studio album by the English rock band the Smile. It was released digitally through XL Recordings on 13 May 2022, with a retail release on 17 June.
It wasn't about being too safe with him, he just wasn't around because he was working with Charlotte Gainsbourg and Beck. It wasn't like he was twiddling his thumbs and we were like, 'Ah well, we won't give him a ring.'