S&M2

S&M2
Live album by Metallica and the San Francisco Symphony
Released	August 28, 2020 (2020-08-28)
Recorded	September 6 & 8, 2019
Venue	Chase Center (San Francisco)
Genre	Symphonic metal [1]
Length	143:25
Label	Blackened
Producer	Greg Fidelman James Hetfield Lars Ulrich
Metallica chronology
Hardwired... to Self-Destruct (2016) S&M2 (2020) 72 Seasons (2023)
Singles from S&M2
"All Within My Hands" Released: July 15, 2020 [2] "Nothing Else Matters" Released: July 15, 2020 "Moth into Flame" Released: August 5, 2020 "For Whom the Bell Tolls" Released: August 20, 2020

S&M2 (stylized as S&M²; an abbreviation of Symphony and Metallica 2) is a live album by American thrash metal band Metallica and the San Francisco Symphony. It is a follow-up to S&M , a live collaborative album released in 1999. The album was recorded during a live performance in San Francisco at the Chase Center in 2019. ^[3] The performance was also filmed and released theatrically on October 9, 2019. ^[4]

Background and recording

Further information: S&M (album)

On April 21 and 22, 1999, Metallica, in collaboration with the San Francisco Symphony and Michael Kamen, recorded and filmed a concert at the Berkeley Community Theater. ^{[5] [6]} The performance was released as a film and a live album in November 1999. ^[7]

In March 2019, Metallica announced the S&M2 concert. The concert, which was similarly performed in collaboration with the San Francisco Symphony, was planned in celebration of the 20th anniversary of S&M. ^[8] The concert was recorded and filmed at the Chase Center in San Francisco on September 6 and 8, 2019, ^[9] with Edwin Outwater and Michael Tilson Thomas ^{[nb 1]} conducting the symphony orchestra. ^[10] The concert also marked the grand opening of the Chase Center. ^[11] Filming was directed by Wayne Isham, who also directed S&M. ^[12]

Release

The film was released in theaters on October 9, 2019. It earned over $1.2 million at the North American box office, and totaled $5.5 million internationally, making it the highest-grossing rock cinema event ever. ^[12] As a result, the film was shown theatrically for a second time on October 30, 2019. ^[13]

The live album was released on August 28, 2020. ^[14] The Blu-ray release included a new revised version of the film seen in theaters edited by the band, with remixed and remastered audio plus behind the scenes footage. ^[15]

Critical reception

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	78/100 [16]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[17]
Clash	7/10 [18]
Classic Rock	9/10 [19]
Consequence of Sound	B+ [20]
Kerrang!	[21]
Metal Hammer	[22]
Mojo	[23]
Pitchfork	5.2/10 [24]
Slant Magazine	[25]

At Metacritic, the album received an average score of 78 based on eight reviews, indicating "generally favorable reviews". ^[16]

Critics generally praised the album as a worthy successor of S&M. Paul Brannigan of Kerrang! gave the performance a perfect rating, writing that the album "stands as a tribute both to Metallica’s growing confidence as players and composers, and an absolute vindication of their decision to revisit one of their most inspired creative outings." ^[21]

In a mixed review, Andy Cush of Pitchfork felt that the album had the same issues that S&M did. Cush wrote that the songs are not suited to an orchestral accompaniment, writing "Metallica’s best songs, intricate and ambitious though they may be, are not actually well suited for the additional orchestrating they get here, precisely because they are plenty symphonic already." ^[24] Cush was also critical of the song selection for S&M2, noting that "Of the 20 pieces of music here, more than half appeared in a similar form more than two decades ago on the first S&M." ^[24]

Commercial performance

S&M2 debuted at No. 4 on Billboard with 56,000 equivalent album units, with 53,000 units of that coming from album sales. ^[26]

Track listing

Disc 1

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Original album	Length
1.	"The Ecstasy of Gold" (instrumental)	Ennio Morricone	The Good, the Bad and the Ugly	2:41
2.	"The Call of Ktulu" (instrumental)	James Hetfield Lars Ulrich Cliff Burton Dave Mustaine	Ride the Lightning	9:14
3.	"For Whom the Bell Tolls"	Hetfield Ulrich Burton	Ride the Lightning	4:37
4.	"The Day That Never Comes"	Hetfield Ulrich Kirk Hammett Robert Trujillo	Death Magnetic	8:27
5.	"The Memory Remains"	Hetfield Ulrich	Reload	5:42
6.	"Confusion"	Hetfield Ulrich	Hardwired... to Self-Destruct	6:41
7.	"Moth into Flame"	Hetfield Ulrich	Hardwired... to Self-Destruct	6:18
8.	"The Outlaw Torn"	Hetfield Ulrich	Load	10:03
9.	"No Leaf Clover"	Hetfield Ulrich	S&M	5:30
10.	"Halo on Fire"	Hetfield Ulrich	Hardwired...to Self-Destruct	8:17
Total length:				67:30

Disc 2

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Original album	Length
1.	"Intro to Scythian Suite"			5:17
2.	"Scythian Suite, Opus 20 II: The Enemy God and the Dance of the Dark Spirits" (instrumental)	Sergei Prokofiev		3:39
3.	"Intro to the Iron Foundry"			1:03
4.	"The Iron Foundry, Opus 19" (instrumental)	Alexander Mosolov		4:16
5.	"The Unforgiven III"	Hetfield Ulrich Hammett Trujillo	Death Magnetic	8:19
6.	"All Within My Hands (Acoustic)"	Hetfield Ulrich Hammett Bob Rock	St. Anger	6:13
7.	"(Anesthesia) - Pulling Teeth" (instrumental)	Burton	Kill 'Em All	7:27
8.	"Wherever I May Roam"	Hetfield Ulrich	Metallica	6:32
9.	"One"	Hetfield Ulrich	...And Justice for All	9:23
10.	"Master of Puppets"	Hetfield Ulrich Burton Hammett	Master of Puppets	8:29
11.	"Nothing Else Matters"	Hetfield Ulrich	Metallica	6:39
12.	"Enter Sandman"	Hetfield Ulrich Hammett	Metallica	8:45
Total length:				Disc two: 76:42 Total: 143:25

Blu-ray

No.	Title	Length
1.	"Intro (Wherever I May Roam / All Within My Hands)" (medley)
2.	"The Ecstasy of Gold" (instrumental)
3.	"The Call of Ktulu" (instrumental)
4.	"For Whom the Bell Tolls"
5.	"The Day That Never Comes"
6.	"The Memory Remains"
7.	"Confusion"
8.	"Moth into Flame"
9.	"The Outlaw Torn"
10.	"No Leaf Clover"
11.	"Halo on Fire"
12.	"Intro to Scythian Suite"
13.	"Scythian Suite, Opus 20 II: The Enemy God and The Dance of the Dark Spirits" (instrumental)
14.	"Intro to the Iron Foundry"
15.	"The Iron Foundry, Opus 19" (instrumental)
16.	"The Unforgiven III"
17.	"All Within My Hands (Acoustic)"
18.	"(Anesthesia) – Pulling Teeth" (instrumental)
19.	"Wherever I May Roam"
20.	"One"
21.	"Master of Puppets"
22.	"Nothing Else Matters"
23.	"Enter Sandman"
24.	"Credits"
25.	"Behind the Scenes: Making of the Show"
26.	"All Within My Hands Promo"

Personnel

Metallica

• James Hetfield – lead vocals, rhythm guitar, guitar solo on "Nothing Else Matters", "Master of Puppets" and "The Outlaw Torn", acoustic (rhythm) guitar on "All Within My Hands", production
• Lars Ulrich – drums, production
• Kirk Hammett – lead guitar, backing vocals, acoustic (lead) guitar on "All Within My Hands", Coral electric sitar on "Wherever I May Roam" ^[27]
• Robert Trujillo – bass guitar, backing vocals

San Francisco Symphony

• Edwin Outwater – conductor
• Michael Tilson Thomas – conductor on "Scythian Suite, Opus 20 II: The Enemy God and the Dance of the Dark Spirits", "The Iron Foundry, Opus 19", "The Unforgiven III" and "Enter Sandman", keyboards on "Enter Sandman"
• Scott Pingel – bass solo for "(Anesthesia) – Pulling Teeth"
• Nadya Tichman (concertmaster), Jeremy Constant, Mariko Smiley, Melissa Kleinbart, Sarn Oliver, Naomi Kazama Hull, Victor Romasevich, Yun Chu, Yukiko Kurakata, Katie Kadarauch – first violins
• Jessie Fellows, Polina Sedukh, David Chernyavsky, Raushan Akhmedyarova, Chen Zhao, Adam Smyla, Sarah Knutson, Yuna Lee – second violins
• Yun Jie Liu, John Schoening, Christina King, Gina Cooper, David Gaudry, Matthew Young, David Kim, Nanci Severance – violas
• Amos Yang, Margaret Tait, Jill Rachuy Brindel, Stephen Tramontozzi, Shu-Yi Pai, Richard Andaya, Miriam Perkoff, Adelle-Akiko Kearns – cellos
• Scott Pingel, Daniel G. Smith, S. Mark Wright, Charles Chandler, Chris Gilbert, William Ritchen – basses
• Robin McKee, Linda Lukas, Catherine Payne – flutes
• James Button, Pamela Smith, Russ deLuna – oboes
• Luis Baez, David Neuman, Jerome Simas – clarinets
• Stephen Paulson, Rob Weir, Steven Braunstein – bassons
• Robert Ward, Jonathan Ring, Bruce Roberts, Daniel Hawkins, Chris Cooper, Joshua Paulus, Jeff Garza – horns
• Aaron Schuman, Joseph Brown, Robert Giambruno, John Freeman – trumpets
• Timothy Higgins, Nick Platoff, John Engelkes, Jeff Budin – trombones
• Jeffrey Anderson – tuba
• Edward Stephan – timpani
• Jacob Nissly, James Lee Wyatt III, Tom Hemphill, Robert Klieger – percussion
• Douglas Rioth – harp
• Marc Shapiro – keyboard
• Margo Kieser, John Campbell, Matt Gray – librarians

Additional musicians

• Avi Vinocur – backing vocals on "All Within My Hands"

Technical personnel

• Greg Fidelman – production, mixing
• Edwin Outwater – musical direction
• Michael Tilson Thomas – additional conceptualization
• Bruce Coughlin, Michael Kamen – arrangement
• Scott Pingel – arrangement on "(Anesthesia) – Pulling Teeth"
• Emily Grisham, Adriana Grace, David Horne, Larry Spivack, Frederick Alden Terry – copyists
• Ann Shuttlesworth, Patrick DiCenso – transcribers
• John Harris, Jay Vicari, Brian Flanzbaum – recording engineering
• Bran Vibberts, Bob Wartinbee, Charlie Campbell, Mike Fortunato, Jimmy Goldsmith, Dave Schwerkolt – recording crew
• Sara Lyn Killion, Dan Monti, Jim Monti, Jason Gossman, Kent Matcke, Billy Joe Bowers – engineering, editing
• Bob Ludwig – mastering
• Anton Corbijn – band photography
• Stan Musilek – cover/instrument photography
• Brett Murray – additional audience photography
• David Turner – album package design, art direction
• Alex Tenta – album package layout, additional art direction

Charts

Weekly charts Weekly chart performance of S&M2 Chart (2020) Peak position Australian Albums (ARIA) [28] 1 Austrian Albums (Ö3 Austria) [29] 1 Belgian Albums (Ultratop Flanders) [30] 1 Belgian Albums (Ultratop Wallonia) [31] 2 Canadian Albums (Billboard) [32] 4 Czech Albums (ČNS IFPI) [33] 4 Danish Albums (Hitlisten) [34] 3 Dutch Albums (Album Top 100) [35] 1 Finnish Albums (Suomen virallinen lista) [36] 3 French Albums (SNEP) [37] 4 German Albums (Offizielle Top 100) [38] 1 Hungarian Albums (MAHASZ) [39] 2 Irish Albums (OCC) [40] 2 Italian Albums (FIMI) [41] 13 New Zealand Albums (RMNZ) [42] 7 Norwegian Albums (VG-lista) [43] 6 Polish Albums (ZPAV) [44] 3 Portuguese Albums (AFP) [45] 1 Scottish Albums (OCC) [46] 1 Spanish Albums (PROMUSICAE) [47] 3 Swiss Albums (Schweizer Hitparade) [48] 2 UK Albums (OCC) [49] 2 UK Rock & Metal Albums (OCC) [50] 1 US Billboard 200 [51] 4 US Top Classical Albums (Billboard) [52] 1 US Top Hard Rock Albums (Billboard) [53] 1 US Top Rock Albums (Billboard) [54] 1

Year-end charts 2020 year-end chart performance for S&M2 Chart (2020) Position Austrian Albums (Ö3 Austria) [55] 71 Belgian Albums (Ultratop Flanders) [56] 123 Belgian Albums (Ultratop Wallonia) [57] 55 French Albums (SNEP) [58] 183 German Albums (Offizielle Top 100) [59] 7 Polish Albums (ZPAV) [60] 30 Spanish Albums (PROMUSICAE) [61] 81 Swiss Albums (Schweizer Hitparade) [62] 42 US Top Classical Albums (Billboard) [63] 1 US Top Rock Albums (Billboard) [64] 58 2021 year-end chart performance for S&M2 Chart (2021) Position US Top Classical Albums (Billboard) [65] 10

Certifications

Certifications and sales for S&M2

Region	Certification	Certified units/sales
Germany (BVMI) [66]	Gold	100,000‡
Poland (ZPAV) [67]	Gold	10,000‡
‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone.

Notes

1. Edwin Outwater served as the primary conductor. Thomas only conducted during the performance of "Scythian Suite, Opus 20 II: The Enemy God and the Dance of the Dark Spirits", "The Iron Foundry, Opus 19" and "The Unforgiven III", and conducted "Enter Sandman" before moving to keyboards and leaving Outwater conducting ^[1]

References

1. Ruskin, Zack (October 2, 2019). "Symphonic Metal at the Movies: What to Expect When Metallica's 'S&M2' Hits Screens". Variety . Retrieved September 3, 2020.
2. Munro, Scott (July 15, 2020). "Watch Metallica's acoustic performance of All Within My Hands from S&M2". Louder Sound . Retrieved April 12, 2022.
3. Moore, Sam (July 15, 2020). "Metallica announce 'S&M2' live album and concert film release". NME. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
4. Grow, Kory (October 9, 2019). "Metallica on What They Have in Common With Classical Music: 'It's All an Attitude'". Rolling Stone . Retrieved September 3, 2020.
5. Young, Alex (October 29, 2011). "Dusting 'Em Off: Metallica - S&M". Consequence of Sound. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
6. Dangelo, Joe (November 18, 2003). "Composer Who Worked With Metallica, Aerosmith Dead At 55". MTV News. Archived from the original on October 16, 2015. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
7. "Metallica's Lars Ulrich Says S&M2 Will Be "An Opportunity For New Discoveries"". Kerrang!. September 5, 2019. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
8. Reed, Ryan (March 19, 2019). "Metallica Plot Concert With San Francisco Symphony". Rolling Stone. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
9. Kreps, Daniel (August 5, 2020). "See Metallica Rock Out in Symphony for 'Moth Into Flame' From 'S&M2'". Rolling Stone. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
10. Harrington, Jim (August 24, 2020). "'S&M2' conductor Edwin Outwater recalls magical Metallica shows". The Mercury News. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
11. Vaziri, Aidin (August 23, 2019). "Metallica's Lars Ulrich on jamming with San Francisco Symphony, why the band has never been happier". San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved September 4, 2020.
12. Hadusek, Jon (October 16, 2019). "Metallica's S&M2 film breaks $5 million at the box office, gets additional worldwide screening". Consequence of Sound . Retrieved September 3, 2020.
13. Jones, Damian (October 16, 2019). "Metallica's 'S&M2' live concert film is returning to cinemas". NME . Retrieved September 3, 2020.
14. Dowd, Rachael (September 2, 2020). "Metallica and Katy Perry are battling for the top debut album spot". Alternative Press . Retrieved September 3, 2020.
15. "S&M2 Blu-Ray". Metallica.com. Retrieved November 28, 2022.
16. "S&M2 [Live] by Metallica". Metacritic. Retrieved January 3, 2022.
17. Erlewine, Stephen Thomas. Review of S&M2 at AllMusic. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
18. Walker-Smart, Sam (August 25, 2020). "Metallica & San Francisco Symphony - S&M2". Clash. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
19. Everley, Dave (September 2020). "Metallica S&M2". Classic Rock. No. 279. p. 84.
20. Hadusek, Jon (August 28, 2020). "Metallica's S&M2 cleans up nicely for home release: Review + Stream". Consequence of Sound. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
21. Brannigan, Paul (August 27, 2020). "Album Review: Metallica – S&M2". Kerrang!. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
22. Daly, Joe (August 24, 2020). "Metallica's S&M2: metal's biggest band changes the game once more on epic live album". Metal Hammer . Retrieved May 31, 2021.
23. McNair, James. "Metallica S&M 2". Mojo. No. 323. p. 86.
24. Cush, Andy (September 1, 2020). "Metallica / San Francisco Symphony: S&M2". Pitchfork. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
25. Theobald, Brian (September 2, 2020). "Review: Metallica's S&M2 Is at Once Rousing and Redundant". Slant Magazine. Retrieved September 3, 2020.
26. "Metallica & San Francisco Symphony's 'S&M2' Starts Atop Rock, Classical Charts". Rutherford, Keven. Billboard. September 9, 2020.
27. Grow, Kory (August 25, 2019). "Metallica's Kirk Hammett and Lars Ulrich Break Down 'S&M2' Set List". Rolling Stone. Retrieved July 29, 2022.
28. "Australiancharts.com – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2". Hung Medien. Retrieved September 5, 2020.
29. "Austriancharts.at – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2" (in German). Hung Medien. Retrieved September 13, 2020.
30. "Ultratop.be – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2" (in Dutch). Hung Medien. Retrieved September 5, 2020.
31. "Ultratop.be – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2" (in French). Hung Medien. Retrieved September 5, 2020.
32. "Metallica Chart History (Canadian Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved September 9, 2020.
33. "Czech Albums – Top 100". ČNS IFPI. Retrieved September 7, 2020.
34. "Hitlisten.NU – Album Top-40 Uge 35, 2020". Hitlisten . Retrieved September 4, 2020.
35. "Dutchcharts.nl – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2" (in Dutch). Hung Medien. Retrieved September 4, 2020.
36. "Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra: S&M2" (in Finnish). Musiikkituottajat – IFPI Finland. Retrieved September 8, 2020.
37. "Top Albums (Week 36, 2020)" (in French). Syndicat National de l'Édition Phonographique. Retrieved September 8, 2020.
38. "Offiziellecharts.de – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2" (in German). GfK Entertainment Charts. Retrieved September 4, 2020.
39. "Album Top 40 slágerlista – 2020. 36. hét" (in Hungarian). MAHASZ. Retrieved September 11, 2020.
40. "Official Irish Albums Chart Top 50". Official Charts Company. Retrieved September 4, 2020.
41. "Italiancharts.com – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2". Hung Medien. Retrieved September 5, 2020.
42. "Charts.nz – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2". Hung Medien. Retrieved September 9, 2020.
43. "VG-lista – Topp 40 Album uke 36, 2020". VG-lista . Retrieved October 15, 2020.
44. "Oficjalna lista sprzedaży :: OLiS - Official Retail Sales Chart". OLiS. Polish Society of the Phonographic Industry. Retrieved September 10, 2020.
45. "Portuguesecharts.com – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2". Hung Medien. Retrieved September 18, 2020.
46. "Official Scottish Albums Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company. Retrieved September 4, 2020.
47. "Top 100 Álbumes – Semana 36: del 28.8.2020 al 3.9.2020" (in Spanish). Productores de Música de España. Retrieved September 8, 2020.
48. "Swisscharts.com – Metallica with Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra – S&M2". Hung Medien. Retrieved September 9, 2020.
49. "Official Albums Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company. Retrieved September 4, 2020.
50. "Official Rock & Metal Albums Chart Top 40". Official Charts Company. Retrieved September 13, 2020.
51. "Metallica Chart History (Billboard 200)". Billboard. Retrieved September 9, 2020.
52. "Metallica Chart History (Top Classical Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved December 28, 2020.
53. "Metallica Chart History (Top Hard Rock Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved December 28, 2020.
54. "Metallica Chart History (Top Rock Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved December 28, 2020.
55. "Ö3 Austria Top40 Longplay 2020". Ö3 Austria Top 40. November 8, 2019. Archived from the original on December 28, 2020. Retrieved December 31, 2020.
56. "Jaaroverzichten 2020". Ultratop. Retrieved December 18, 2020.
57. "Rapports Annuels 2020". Ultratop. Retrieved December 18, 2020.
58. "Top de l'année Top Albums 2020" (in French). SNEP. Retrieved April 21, 2021.
59. "Top 100 Album-Jahrescharts 2020" (in German). GfK Entertainment . Retrieved December 18, 2020.
60. "Najpopularniejsze single radiowe i najlepiej sprzedające się płyty 2020 roku" (in Polish). Polish Society of the Phonographic Industry . Retrieved January 28, 2021.
61. "Top 100 Álbumes 2020" (in Spanish). Productores de Música de España. Retrieved April 24, 2021.
62. "Schweizer Jahreshitparade 2020". hitparade.ch. Retrieved December 28, 2020.
63. "Classical Albums – Year-End 2020". Billboard. January 2, 2013. Retrieved December 28, 2020.
64. "Top Rock Albums – Year-End 2020". Billboard. January 2, 2013. Retrieved December 28, 2020.
65. "Classical Albums – Year-End 2021". Billboard. January 2, 2013. Retrieved January 19, 2022.
66. "Gold-/Platin-Datenbank (Metallica; 'S&M2')" (in German). Bundesverband Musikindustrie . Retrieved April 3, 2023.
67. "Wyróżnienia – Złote płyty CD - Archiwum - Przyznane w 2020 roku" (in Polish). Polish Society of the Phonographic Industry . Retrieved November 18, 2020.