Historical Right

Historical Right Destra storica
Leaders	Massimo d'Azeglio Camillo Benso di Cavour Bettino Ricasoli Giovanni Lanza Marco Minghetti Antonio Starabba di Rudinì Sidney Sonnino
Founded	1849
Dissolved	1913
Preceded by	Moderate Party
Merged into	Liberal Union
Ideology	Liberal conservatism [1] [2] [3] Conservative liberalism [4] [5] Conservatism [6] [7] Classical liberalism [8] [9] Monarchism [10]
Political position	Centre [11] to centre-right [11]
Politics of Italy Political parties Elections

The Right group (Italian : Destra), later called Historical Right (Italian : Destra storica) by historians to distinguish it from the right-wing groups of the 20th century, was an Italian conservative parliamentary group during the second half of the 19th century. ^[12] After 1876, the Historical Right constituted the Constitutional opposition toward the left governments. ^[13] It originated in the convergence of the most liberal faction of the moderate right and the moderate wing of the democratic left. ^[14] The party included men from heterogeneous cultural, class, and ideological backgrounds, ranging from British-American individualist liberalism to Neo-Hegelian liberalism as well as liberal-conservatives, from strict secularists to more religiously-oriented reformists. ^{[14] [1] [15]} Few prime ministers after 1852 were party men; instead they accepted support where they could find it, and even the governments of the Historical Right during the 1860s included leftists in some capacity. ^[11]

The Right represented the interests of the Northern bourgeoisie and the Southern aristocracy. Its members were mostly large landowners, industrialists and people related to the military. On economic issues, the Right supported free trade and laissez-faire policies while on social issues it favoured a strong central government, obligatory conscription and during the Cavour era the secular Law of Guarantees, causing Pope Pius IX's Non Expedit policy of abstention. ^[16] In foreign relations, their goal was the unification of Italy, primarily aiming for an alliance with the British Empire and the French Empire, but sometimes also with the German Empire against Austria-Hungary. ^[17] In the last decades of its history, the Right was often referred to as Constitutional Opposition.

History

Origins

Massimo D'Azeglio

The origins of the Historical Right are in the right-wing faction of the Sardinian Parliament, established in 1849. The Right was at the time led by Massimo d'Azeglio, who was also a representative of the moderate movement that tried to unify Italy as a federation of states. ^[18] As the Right dominated the Parliament, D'Azeglio was appointed as Prime Minister of Sardinia by King Victor Emmanuel II. However, there were tensions inside the group caused by D'Azeglio's assertiveness towards the Catholic Church and the King. ^{[19] [20]} The tensions caused the group to split into two separate factions:

• The Conservatives, led by D'Azeglio, Luigi Cibrario, General La Marmora and Carlo Bon Compagni, who supported compromises with the Church and a slow Italian unification.
• The Liberals, led by Cavour, Luigi Carlo Farini and Giovanni Galvagno, who supported the expropriation of the Church's goods, a lesser role of the King in government and French intervention to achieve Italian unification.

In May 1852, Cavour and his supporters left the Right group and moved toward the moderate Left led by Urbano Rattazzi. ^[19] The duo Rattazzi–Cavour made an alliance (pejoratively called "a marriage"), ^[21] forming a centrist group called the Connubio. ^[22] D'Azeglio was forced to resign in November 1852 and Cavour was appointed by the King as the new prime minister, ending the Sardinian phase of the Right.

Unification and governments

The Count of Cavour

In 1861, Italy was united as a Kingdom under the House of Savoy. Cavour, who was Prime Minister of Sardinia since November 1852 with brief interruptions, became the first Prime Minister of Italy. During the first year after unification, Cavour became more conservative as many radicals and republicans refused to recognize the new government, but instead recognize the Southern Army led by Giuseppe Garibaldi. Fearing a democratic revolution, Cavour became near to the new Right group in the Italian Parliament and led it until his premature death in June 1861. The Cavourian policies were partially continued by his successors aligned with the Right group like Luigi Farini, Bettino Ricasoli and Marco Minghetti. Starting in 1861, the Right's government pursued a policy of a balanced budget, ^[23] maintained with austerity and high taxation. The taxes, especially the tax on grains, were unpopular among the rural and middle classes. As a result, the Right progressively lost its support. With that, the Right was split, with the original Northern liberals supporting the taxation and the newly arrived Southern conservatives who opposed the modernization and taxation. ^[24]

In the 1870s, in a time of rising tensions inside the Right governments, the group split into different factions for specific goals and territorial composition: ^[25]

• The Emilian clique led by Marco Minghetti representing Emilian parochialism, in addition to supporting protectionism, moderate liberalism, ^{[26] [27]} and alignment with Germany. ^[28]
• The Piedmontese clique led by Giovanni Lanza ^[29] and Gustavo Ponza di San Martino representing Piedmontese parochialism, supporting liberalism and a moderate Francophilic foreign policy. ^[30]
• The Tuscan clique led by Ubaldino Peruzzi ^[31] representing Tuscan parochialism, favourable to liberalism and modernization. Hostile to Minghetti, but vague toward the Left. ^[32]
• The Lombardian clique led by Cesare Correnti ^[33] representing the Lombardian parochialism along with centrists and secularists and those favourable to cooperation with the Left. ^[32]

On 25 March 1876, Prime Minister Marco Minghetti was forced to resign after the so-called Parliamentary Revolution. The Left, together with dissident members from the Right, put the government into a minority because of the tax on grains' question, which damaged the rural economy. ^[14] Ironically, many Right politicians who sided now with Left were from the North. Since this moment, the Right fell into opposition and Agostino Depretis, leader of the Left, was appointed as the new prime minister.

Constitutional opposition

Further information: Liberal Constitutional Party (Italy) and Liberal Union (Italy)

Marco Minghetti

After the fall of Minghetti, the Right progressively saw splits and disbanded. On 8 October 1882, some weeks before the general elections, Depretis proclaimed that anyone who was willing to become a progressive would be accepted into his government. Surprisingly, Minghetti agreed with this, causing various individuals in the Right to join the Left. ^[34] After this event, the rest of the anti-compromise Right was called the Liberal Constitutional Party or "Constitutional opposition" ^[35] led by former Finance Minister Quintino Sella and Interior Minister Antonio Starabba, Marquess of Rudinì. The Constitutionals were not a structured and organized party, but simply a coalition of both Northern and Southern conservatives like Sidney Sonnino, Luigi Luzzatti and Pasquale Villari who rejected perceived opportunism and Depretis' protectionist policies.

After ten years in opposition, the Constitutionals gained the majority thanks to an agreement with dissident Left Giovanni Nicotera and radical Felice Cavallotti and Rudinì was charged to form a new government in substitution of Francesco Crispi. During his short government, overthrown after one year, Rudinì worked to reduce to public expenditure, limit the rising imperialist sentiment and keep Italy aligned with the Triple Alliance. ^[36] Rudinì was recalled in office after the political fall of Crispi, following the defeat in the First Italo-Ethiopian War. During this second term, Rudinì worked to repress the Sicilian Fasci, a powerful rising socialist protest in Sicily, but also several nationalist groups. After two years, Rudinì was ousted from office after his unpopular ceding of Kassala to the United Kingdom. Constitutional politicians like Luzzatti and Sonnino later formed their own governments, but they were short, and were weakened by the newborn Italian Socialist Party and the first organized political parties. The awareness of that forced the Constitutionals to join in the Liberal Union in 1913, a political alliance between various liberal politicians, many of whom were previously opposed to each other. ^[37]

Electoral results

Chamber of Deputies
Election year	Votes	%	Seats	+/–	Leader
1861	110,400 (1st)	46.1	342 / 443	–	Camillo Benso di Cavour
1865	114,208 (1st)	41.2	183 / 443	159	Alfonso La Marmora
1867	84,685 (2nd)	39.2	151 / 493	32	Bettino Ricasoli
1870	110,525 (1st)	37.2	233 / 508	82	Giovanni Lanza
1874	156,784 (1st)	53.6	276 / 508	43	Marco Minghetti
1876	97,726 (2nd)	28.2	94 / 508	182	Marco Minghetti
1880	135,797 (2nd)	37.9	171 / 508	77	Marco Minghetti
1882	353,693 (2nd)	28.9	147 / 508	24	Marco Minghetti
1886	399,295 (2nd)	27.9	145 / 508	2	Silvio Spaventa
1890	138,854 (2nd)	9.4	48 / 508	97	Antonio Starabba di Rudinì
1892	309,873 (2nd)	18.3	93 / 508	45	Antonio Starabba di Rudinì
1895	263,315 (2nd)	21.6	104 / 508	11	Antonio Starabba di Rudinì
1897	242,090 (2nd)	19.4	99 / 508	5	Antonio Starabba di Rudinì
1900	271,698 (2nd)	21.4	116 / 508	17	Antonio Starabba di Rudinì
1904	212,584 (3rd)	13.9	76 / 508	20	Tommaso Tittoni
1909	108,029 (4th)	5.9	44 / 508	32	Sidney Sonnino

References

1. Mario Belardinelli (1976). ELIA (ed.). Un esperimento liberal-conservatore: i governi di Rudinì (1896-1898).
2. Umberto Gentiloni Silveri (2000). Stadium (ed.). Conservatori senza partito. Un tentativo fallito nell'Italia giolittiana.
3. Di Mauro, Luca. "La Destra storica". Oilproject.
4. Sarti, Roland (2009). Italy: A Reference Guide from the Renaissance to the Present. p. 537. ISBN   9780816074747.
5. Dyson, Kenneth (2014). States, Debt, and Power: 'Saints' and 'Sinners' in European History and Integration. p. 223. ISBN   9780191023477.
6. Gramsci, Antonio (1966). Gramsci Institute (ed.). Studi storici. p. 703.
7. Campanelli, Giuseppe; Carducci, Michele; Tondi Della Mura, Vincenzo; Loiodice, Isabella (2 December 2016). Giappichelli (ed.). Lineamenti di diritto costituzionale della regione Puglia. p. 188. ISBN   9788834847916.
8. Baglioni, Guido (1973). L'Ideologia della borghesia industriale nell'Italia liberale. Einaudi. p. 191.
9. Treccani, ed. (2010). "Destra storica italiana". Dizionario di Storia.
10. Gentile, Emilio (1982). Laterza (ed.). Il mito dello Stato nuovo: Dal radicalismo nazionale al fascismo. ISBN   9788858121498.
11. Donovan, Mark; Newell, James L. (2008). "Centrism in Italian politics". Modern Italy. 13 (4): 381–397. doi:10.1080/13532940802367554. S2CID   144016171.
12. Herb, Guntram H.; Kaplan, David H. (22 May 2008). Nations and Nationalism: A Global Historical Overview [4 volumes]. ABC-CLIO. ISBN   9781851099085.
13. Pirett (October 1999). Una voce per l'Opposizione Costituzionale di Sua Maestà: Alle origini del "Giornale d'Italia" (in Italian). Contemporanea. pp. 699–712.
14. "Destra storica italiana". Treccani (in Italian). 2010.
15. Emilio Gentile (2003). "1. Il governo del generale Pelloux". In Laterza (ed.). Le origini dell'Italia contemporanea: L'età giolittiana. ISBN   9788858118290.
16. Montanelli, Indro (1977). Rizzoli (ed.). Storia d'Italia: Gli anni della destra (1861-1876). Vol. 32.
17. Sarti, Roland (2009). "The Politics of the Liberal State (1861-1901)". In Infobase Publishing (ed.). Italy: A Reference Guide from the Renaissance to the Present. ISBN   9780816074747.
18. "Partito Moderato". Encilopedia Treccani.
19. Romeo, Vita di Cavour, Bari, 2004, p. 213.
20. Hearder, Cavour, Bari, 2000, p. 74.
21. Cavour (1865). "Discorsi parlamentari del conte Camillo di Cavour". Chamber of Deputies of Italy. p. 355. Retrieved 25 May 2014.
22. "La politica del "connubio"; Cavour primo ministro - MuseoTorino".
23. XII/elenco "Camera dei deputati".
24. Indro Montanelli (1977). Storia d'Italia: Gli anni della destra, (1861-1876) (in Italian). Vol. 32. Rizzoli.
25. Merlini, Stefano; Tarli Barbieri, Giovanni (11 January 2017). Giappichelli (ed.). Il governo parlamentare in Italia. p. 34. ISBN   9788892105478.
26. Gherardi, Raffaella (2010). Treccani (ed.). "Marco Minghetti". Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani. Vol. 74.
27. Ragazzoni, David (2019). "Silvio Spaventa and Marco Minghetti on party government". Journal of Modern Italian Studies. 24 (2): 293–323. doi:10.1080/1354571X.2019.1573023. S2CID   151209326.
28. Luzzatti, Luigi (2006). Cosimo, Inc (ed.). God in Freedom: Studies in the Relations Between Church and State. p. 420. ISBN   9781596054486.
29. Montaldo, Silvano (2004). Treccani (ed.). "Giovanni Lanza". Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani. Vol. 63.
30. Tavallini, Enrico (1887). L. Roux & Co. (ed.). La vita e i tempi di Giovanni Lanza. Vol. 2.
31. Manfredi, Marco (2015). Treccani (ed.). "Ubaldino Peruzzi". Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani. Vol. 82.
32. Leoni, Francesco (2001). Guida (ed.). Storia dei partiti politici italiani. p. 117. ISBN   9788871884950.
33. Ambrosoli, Luigi (1983). Treccani (ed.). "Cesare Correnti". Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani. Vol. 3.
34. Fulvio Cammarano (2011). Storia dell'Italia liberale. Laterza. ISBN   9788842095996.
35. La Stampa historical archive.
36. "Antonio Starrabba marchese di Rudinì". Treccani.
37. Francesco Leoni (2001). Storia dei partiti politici italiani (in Italian). Guida Editori. p. 386. ISBN   9788871884950.