Odonterpeton

Last updated

Odonterpeton
Temporal range: Moscovian (Westphalian D)
Odonterpeton skull diagram.png
Skull diagram in dorsal view (left) and ventral view (right)
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Order: Microsauria
Clade: Recumbirostra (?)
Family: Odonterpetidae
Genus: Odonterpeton
Moodie, 1909
Species:
O. triangulare
Binomial name
Odonterpeton triangulare
Moodie, 1909

Odonterpeton is an extinct genus of "microsaur" from the Late Carboniferous of Ohio, containing the lone species Odonterpeton triangulare. [1] [2] It is known from a single partial skeleton preserving the skull, forelimbs, and the front part of the torso. The specimen was found in the abandoned Diamond Coal Mine of Linton, Ohio, a fossiliferous coal deposit dated to the late Moscovian stage (Westphalian D), about 310 million years ago. [2]

Contents

Description

Odonterpeton is one of the smallest known microsaurs, with a skull length of only 6.6 millimeters (0.26 inches). [1] The skull is rounded and semi-triangular when seen from above, hence the species name. The snout is short, with moderately large orbits (eye sockets) which are shifted forwards and widely-spaced, facing sideways. The nasal bones (at the top of the snout) are notably small, while the parietal bones (at the back of the skull) are very large. [1] [2] Some older sources reported that Odonterpeton had a large singular postparietal bone at the rear apex of the skull. [1] Later investigations consider this to have been a misidentification of cracks in the parietals, as preserved in the fossil. [3] [2] Restudy of the fossil has also led to the identification of a tabular bone adjacent to each parietal and above the squamosal. [2]

There are around five small teeth in each premaxilla and more than 14 (possibly up to 19) [1] in the maxilla. This is a high tooth count relative to most microsaurs. [2] A high number of teeth are also present in the slender dentary bone of the lower jaw. The teeth mid-way down the maxilla are particularly large, lending their name to the genus ("Odontos" being Greek for "tooth"). [1] The skull texture is mostly smooth, but a series of prominent pits are apparent on several bones, particularly the maxilla, frontal, and jugal. [2] Similar pits are found on the skull of brachystelechids and Brachydectes . They may serve as canals for cranial nerves and blood vessels, or attachment sites for large scales. [2]

The pterygoid bone of the palate (roof of the mouth) has small tooth-like denticles closely packed along the rear edge of a projection which extends outwards and forwards. This may be homologous to a structure found in amniotes: the transverse flange, a tooth-bearing horizontal ridge occupying a sharply angled rim at the back of the pterygoid. The rest of the palate of Odonterpeton is covered in a broad field of less evenly distributed denticles. Odonterpeton has a massive subtemporal fenestra, a hole behind each pterygoid which acts as a window for muscles stretching from the skull to the jaw. The braincase is well-integrated, with many constituent bones fused together. The parasphenoid (lower plate of the braincase) is relatively wide and triangular, tapering forwards to a stout cultriform process. [2]

At least 18 narrow vertebrae are preserved behind the skull, each with a constricted form and a ventral midline keel. The forelimbs are tiny but well-ossified, with individual bones easily distinguishable. [1] The pectoral girdle is also present, with a well-ossified clavicle and possible fragments of an interclavicle. Odonterpeton is similar to an amphiuma regarding the proportions of its forelimbs to the skull. [1] The humerus, ulna, and radius are all very slender, and an olecranon process may be present at the elbow. The hand is diminutive, with only three fingers. The phalangeal formula (number of joints per finger) is 2-4-3. It is uncertain whether hindlimbs were present, though a disarticulated bone on the main slab may represent a femur. [2]

Classification

Like many microsaurs, Odonterpeton was initially considered a small reptile, though most modern sources consider "microsaurs" to be a grade or clade of small reptiliomorph amphibians which branched off the tetrapod family tree prior to amniotes. [1] [2] Microsaur taxonomy was summarized in The Order Microsauria, a 1978 book by Robert Carroll and Pamela Gaskill. This overview proposed a two-fold division of microsaur taxonomy into Tuditanomorpha and Microbrachomorpha. Odonterpeton was assigned as a microbrachomorph based on its simple teeth, three-fingered hands, and skull roof bones which are strongly unequal in size. Other "microbrachomorphs" included aquatic forms like Microbrachis , Hyloplesion , and possibly "Brachystelechus" (Batropetes). [1] Within Microbrachomorpha, Odonterpeton was given its own family, Odonterpetontidae. [1]

The fundamental division proposed by Carroll and Gaskill (1978) has long been superseded by the results of phylogenetic analyses, though microsaur systematics are still unstable and little consensus exists. Many studies continued to support close affinities between Odonterpeton, Microbrachis, and Hyloplesion, either as a clade [4] [5] [3] or a grade. [6] [3] One analysis, modified from previous studies with an expanded set of taxa, has suggested that Odonterpeton is completely unrelated to other "microbrachomorphs", and instead related to Sparodus . [3]

Odonterpeton triangulare was revisited and redescribed in 2022. The redescription found it to be the sister species of Joermungandr bolti , from the Mazon Creek lagerstätte of Illinois. The family Odonterpetontidae had its name emended to Odonterpetidae, and Joermungandr was identified as a second member of the family. [2] Apart from its roughly contemporaneous time and place, Odonterpeton shares many traits with Joermungandr. These include a rounded skull, short snout, tiny forelimbs, large parietals, a pineal foramen which is shifted forward far enough to contact the frontals, and thin, distinctively textured scales. Unlike Joermungandr, Odonterpeton retains a higher tooth count, a tabular bone next to the parietal, and better-ossified limb and shoulder bones. [2]

According to the 2022 redescription, odonterpetids belong within the clade Recumbirostra, which encompasses many other long-bodied "microsaurs" with burrowing or semiaquatic adaptations. Odonterpetids are particularly closely related to the Early Permian hapsidopareiids, represented by Llistrofus . Below is a cladogram showing the results of the analysis: [2]

Recumbirostra 

Ostodolepididae

Gymnarthridae

Pariotichus

Proxilodon

Huskerpeton

Llistrofus

Odonterpetidae

Joermungandr

Odonterpeton

Aletrimyti

Dvellecanus

Rhynchonkos

Chthonosauria

Molgophidae

Brachystelechidae

Paleobiology

With its small size, small limbs, and presumed long body, Odonterpeton has been compared to fully aquatic salamanders such as Amphiuma. Supporting bones for external gills were tentatively identified in the neck region in 1978. [1] However, these bones were later reinterpreted as cervical ribs. [2] The skull of Odonterpeton has large eye sockets (suggesting good vision and an active lifestyle) and voluminous subtemporal fenestrae (suggesting a strong bite), though the unspecialized teeth indicate that most of its diet was likely soft invertebrates. [1]

Paleoecology

Life restoration of Odonterpeton depicted in an aquatic habitat Odonterpeton.jpg
Life restoration of Odonterpeton depicted in an aquatic habitat

Odonterpeton was one of many vertebrates preserved in the Diamond Coal Mine of Linton, Ohio. Fossils are concentrated in a thick cannel coal bed contemporaneous with the Lower Freeport Coal of the Allegheny Group. The most common fossils are fish, particularly coelacanths ( Rhabdoderma ), small haplolepid 'palaeoniscoids' ( Microhaplolepis , Parahaplolepis ), and xenacanthid shark teeth ( Orthacanthus ). Lungfish teeth ( Conchopoma , Sagenodus ) and xenacanthid spines are less common but still far from rare. Legitimate rhizodont, megalichthyid, and acanthodian fossils are unknown from the deposit. [7]

Among tetrapods, Odonterpeton is joined by at least 11 other species of lepospondyls. The most common lepospondyls, and indeed the most common tetrapods as a whole, are Sauropleura pectinata and Ptyonius marshii (both newt-like urocordylid nectrideans), followed by Ophiderpeton amphiuminum (a legless aistopod) and Diceratosaurus brevirostris (an early diplocaulid nectridean). Cocytinus gyrinoides, Molgophis (both lysorophians) and Phlegethontia linearis (an aistopod) also occur in sizable numbers. [7]

Linton preserves at least 6 temnospondyl species, including common freshwater dvinosaurians ( Isodectes obtusus [8] , Erpetosaurus radiatus ) and rare terrestrial dissorophoids (Platyrhinops lyelli, [9] Stegops newberryi ) and edopoids ( Macrerpeton huxleyi ). [7] The colosteid Colosteus scutellatus is another common amphibian. Other amphibians are rare, such as the large baphetid Megalocephalus lineolatus , the embolomere Leptophractus obsoletus , and the small lizard-like gephyrostegid Eusauropleura digitata . [7] Linton even preserves a few fully terrestrial amniote fossils, such as Anthracodromeus longipes (a eureptile) and Carbonodraco lundi (a fanged parareptile). [10]

During the Pennsylvanian, Linton was a tropical fluviodeltaic environment, with a large meandering river flowing northwest towards a sandy delta. The fossil-bearing cannel coal deposit is encased in a thick but geographically narrow sequence of river sandstone. Due to a fault just north of Linton, the river valley passing through the area would have been deeper and more isolated relative to the shallow rivers common in the muddy floodplains of the surrounding region. The river meanders were prone to sudden cutoffs, creating abandoned channels and broad oxbow lakes. Peat was likely deposited as organic residue accumulating in a deep, stagnant channel with deoxygenated bottom waters hostile to decomposing organisms. Freshwater and riparian animals would have continued to inhabit shallower water until the channel was fully filled in by collapsed levee debris and encroaching land plants. [11] [12] [13] Linton's vertebrate faunas may have been tolerant of mild salinity levels, which may explain the absence of fully freshwater specialist amphibians like microbrachids, micromelerpetontids, and branchiosaurids. [14]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Labyrinthodontia</span> Paraphyletic group of tetrapodomorphs

"Labyrinthodontia" is an informal grouping of extinct predatory amphibians which were major components of ecosystems in the late Paleozoic and early Mesozoic eras. Traditionally considered a subclass of the class Amphibia, modern classification systems recognize that labyrinthodonts are not a formal natural group (clade) exclusive of other tetrapods. Instead, they consistute an evolutionary grade, ancestral to living tetrapods such as lissamphibians and amniotes. "Labyrinthodont"-grade vertebrates evolved from lobe-finned fishes in the Devonian, though a formal boundary between fish and amphibian is difficult to define at this point in time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adelospondyli</span> Extinct order of amphibians

Adelospondyli is an order of elongated, presumably aquatic, Carboniferous amphibians. They have a robust skull roofed with solid bone, and orbits located towards the front of the skull. The limbs were almost certainly absent, although some historical sources reported them to be present. Despite the likely absence of limbs, adelospondyls retained a large part of the bony shoulder girdle. Adelospondyls have been assigned to a variety of groups in the past. They have traditionally been seen as members of the subclass Lepospondyli, related to other unusual early tetrapods such as "microsaurs", "nectrideans", and aïstopods. Analyses such as Ruta & Coates (2007) have offered an alternate classification scheme, arguing that adelospondyls were actually far removed from other lepospondyls, instead being stem-tetrapod stegocephalians closely related to the family Colosteidae.

<i>Westlothiana</i> Extinct genus of tetrapods

Westlothiana is a genus of reptile-like tetrapod that lived about 338 million years ago during the latest part of the Viséan age of the Carboniferous. Members of the genus bore a superficial resemblance to modern-day lizards. The genus is known from a single species, Westlothiana lizziae. The type specimen was discovered in the East Kirkton Limestone at the East Kirkton Quarry, West Lothian, Scotland in 1984. This specimen was nicknamed "Lizzie the lizard" by fossil hunter Stan Wood, and this name was quickly adopted by other paleontologists and the press. When the specimen was formally named in 1990, it was given the specific name "lizziae" in homage to this nickname. However, despite its similar body shape, Westlothiana is not considered a true lizard. Westlothiana's anatomy contained a mixture of both "labyrinthodont" and reptilian features, and was originally regarded as the oldest known reptile or amniote. However, updated studies have shown that this identification is not entirely accurate. Instead of being one of the first amniotes, Westlothiana was rather a close relative of Amniota. As a result, most paleontologists since the original description place the genus within the group Reptiliomorpha, among other amniote relatives such as diadectomorphs and seymouriamorphs. Later analyses usually place the genus as the earliest diverging member of Lepospondyli, a collection of unusual tetrapods which may be close to amniotes or lissamphibians, or potentially both at the same time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Microsauria</span> Extinct order of tetrapods

Microsauria is an extinct, possibly polyphyletic order of tetrapods from the late Carboniferous and early Permian periods. It is the most diverse and species-rich group of lepospondyls. Recently, Microsauria has been considered paraphyletic, as several other non-microsaur lepospondyl groups such as Lysorophia seem to be nested in it. Microsauria is now commonly used as a collective term for the grade of lepospondyls that were originally classified as members of Microsauria.

<i>Anthracosaurus</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Anthracosaurus is an extinct genus of embolomere, a possible distant relative of reptiles that lived during the Late Carboniferous in what is now Scotland, England, and Ohio. It was a large, aquatic eel-like predator. It has a robust skull about 40 centimetres (1.3 ft) in length with large teeth in the jaws and on the roof of the mouth. Anthracosaurus probably inhabited swamps, rivers and lakes. Its name is Greek for "coal lizard".

<i>Limnoscelis</i> Genus of diadectomorphs

Limnoscelis was a genus of large diadectomorph tetrapods from the Late Carboniferous of western North America. It includes two species: the type species Limnoscelis paludis from New Mexico, and Limnoscelis dynatis from Colorado, both of which are thought to have lived concurrently. No specimens of Limnoscelis are known from outside of North America. Limnoscelis was carnivorous, and likely semiaquatic, though it may have spent a significant portion of its life on land. Limnoscelis had a combination of derived amphibian and primitive reptilian features, and its placement relative to Amniota has significant implications regarding the origins of the first amniotes.

<i>Solenodonsaurus</i> Extinct genus of reptiles

Solenodonsaurus is an extinct genus of reptiliomorphs that lived in what is now Czech Republic, during the Westphalian stage.

<i>Megalocephalus</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Megalocephalus is an extinct genus of baphetid amphibian from the late Carboniferous of the British Isles and the United States (Ohio). It contains two species, M. pachycephalus and M. lineolatus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Allegheny Group</span> Pennsylvanian-age geological unit

The Allegheny Group, often termed the Allegheny Formation, is a Pennsylvanian-age geological unit in the Appalachian Plateau. It is a major coal-bearing unit in the eastern United States, extending through western and central Pennsylvania, western Maryland and West Virginia, and southeastern Ohio. Fossils of fishes such as Bandringa are known from the Kittaning Formation, which is part of the Allegheny Group.

<i>Neopteroplax</i> Extinct genus of tetrapodomorphs

Neopteroplax is an extinct genus of eogyrinid embolomere closely related to European genera such as Eogyrinus and Pteroplax. Members of this genus were among the largest embolomeres in North America. Neopteroplax is primarily known from a large skull found in Ohio, although fragmentary embolomere fossils from Texas and New Mexico have also been tentatively referred to the genus. Despite its similarities to specific European embolomeres, it can be distinguished from them due to a small number of skull and jaw features, most notably a lower surangular at the upper rear portion of the lower jaw.

<i>Acherontiscus</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Acherontiscus is an extinct genus of stegocephalians that lived in the Early Carboniferous of Scotland. The type and only species is Acherontiscus caledoniae, named by paleontologist Robert Carroll in 1969. Members of this genus have an unusual combination of features which makes their placement within amphibian-grade tetrapods uncertain. They possess multi-bone vertebrae similar to those of embolomeres, but also a skull similar to lepospondyls. The only known specimen of Acherontiscus possessed an elongated body similar to that of a snake or eel. No limbs were preserved, and evidence for their presence in close relatives of Acherontiscus is dubious at best. Phylogenetic analyses created by Marcello Ruta and other paleontologists in the 2000s indicate that Acherontiscus is part of Adelospondyli, closely related to other snake-like animals such as Adelogyrinus and Dolichopareias. Adelospondyls are traditionally placed within the group Lepospondyli due to their fused vertebrae. Some analyses published since 2007 have argued that adelospondyls such as Acherontiscus may not actually be lepospondyls, instead being close relatives or members of the family Colosteidae. This would indicate that they evolved prior to the split between the tetrapod lineage that leads to reptiles (Reptiliomorpha) and the one that leads to modern amphibians (Batrachomorpha). Members of this genus were probably aquatic animals that were able to swim using snake-like movements.

<i>Boii</i> (genus) Extinct genus of amphibians

Boii is an extinct genus of microsaur within the family Tuditanidae. It was found in Carboniferous coal from mines near the community of Kounov in the Czech Republic. The only remains of the genus consist of a crushed skull, shoulder girdle bones, and scales, which were similar to microsaurian elements originally referred to Asaphestera. Boii can be characterized by its heavily sculptured skull, thin ventral plate of the clavicles, and a larger number of fangs on the roof of the mouth. For many years the type and only known species, Boii crassidens, was considered to be a species of Sparodus, until 1966 when Robert Carroll assigned it to its own genus.

<i>Batropetes</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Batropetes is an extinct genus of brachystelechid recumbirostran "microsaur". Batropetes lived during the Sakmarian stage of the Early Permian. Fossils attributable to the type species B. fritschi have been collected from the town of Freital in Saxony, Germany, near the city of Dresden. Additional material has been found from the Saar-Nahe Basin in southwestern Germany and has been assigned to three additional species: B. niederkirchensis, B. palatinus, and B. appelensis.

<i>Euryodus</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Euryodus is an extinct genus of microsaur within the family Gymnarthridae. Euryodus is a Lepospondyl from the clade Microsauria that lived during the Lower Permian. The name comes from Greek, meaning ‘broad-tooth’. It has been found in the southern half of North America, from its original discovery in Texas up to Utah.

Llistrofus is an extinct genus of early Permian microsaur within the family Hapsidopareiidae that is known from Oklahoma.

<i>Hyloplesion</i> Extinct genus of tetrapods

Hyloplesion is an extinct genus of microbrachomorph microsaur. It is the type and only genus within the family Hyloplesiontidae. Fossils have been found from the Czech Republic near the towns of Plzeň, Nýřany, and Třemošná, and date back to the Middle Pennsylvanian. The type species is H. longicostatum, named in 1883. Two species belonging to different genera, Seeleya pusilla and Orthocosta microscopica, have been synonymized with H. longicostatum and are thought to represent very immature individuals.

<i>Adamanterpeton</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Adamanterpeton is a genus of Edopoid Temnospondyl within the family Cochleosauridae. The type species A. ohioensis was named in 1998 and is currently the only known species within this genus. Adamanterpeton is rare in the Linton vertebrate assemblage, with other amphibians like Sauropleura, Ophiderpeton, and Colosteus being more common. Unlike other Linton vertebrates, Adamanterpeton may have been adapted to a terrestrial lifestyle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Recumbirostra</span> Extinct clade of tetrapods

Recumbirostra is a clade of tetrapods which lived during the Carboniferous and Permian periods. They are thought to have had a fossorial (burrowing) lifestyle and the group includes both short-bodied and long-bodied snake-like forms. At least one species, the long-bodied molgophid Nagini mazonense, lost its forelimbs entirely. Recumbirostra includes the families Pantylidae, Gymnarthridae, Ostodolepidae, Rhynchonkidae and Brachystelechidae, with additional families such as Microbrachidae and Molgophidae being included by some authors. Brachystelechidae and Molgophidae have also been grouped together in the suggested clade Chthonosauria.

Huskerpeton is an extinct genus of recumbirostran from the Early Permian period. They belong to the order Microsauria, which was established in 1863 by Dawson, and was quickly expanded to include many different small taxa. They lived in what is now Nebraska and Kansas. The holotype of Huskerpeton was uncovered at the Eskridge formation in Nebraska, which is part of how it got its name.

<i>Andersonerpeton</i> Extinct genus of tetrapodomorphs

Andersonerpeton is an extinct genus of aïstopod from the Bashkirian of Nova Scotia, Canada. It is known from a single jaw, which shares an unusual combination of features from both other aistopods and from stem-tetrapod tetrapodomorph fish. As a result, Andersonerpeton is significant for supporting a new classification scheme which states that aistopods evolved much earlier than previously expected. The genus contains a single species, A. longidentatum, which was previously believed to have been a species of the microsaur Hylerpeton.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Carroll, R. L.; Gaskill, P. (1978). "The Order Microsauria". Memoirs of the American Philosophical Society. 126: 1–211. ISBN   9780871691262.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Mann, Arjan; Pardo, Jason D; Sues, Hans-Dieter (19 July 2022). "Osteology and phylogenetic position of the diminutive 'microsaur' Odonterpeton triangulare from the Pennsylvanian of Linton, Ohio, and major features of recumbirostran phylogeny". Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society. 197 (3): 641–655. doi: 10.1093/zoolinnean/zlac043 . ISSN   0024-4082.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Marjanović, David; Laurin, Michel (2019-01-04). "Phylogeny of Paleozoic limbed vertebrates reassessed through revision and expansion of the largest published relevant data matrix". PeerJ. 6: e5565. doi: 10.7717/peerj.5565 . ISSN   2167-8359. PMC   6322490 . PMID   30631641.
  4. Ruta, Marcello; Jeffery, Jonathan E.; Coates, Michael I. (2003-12-07). "A supertree of early tetrapods". Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences. 270 (1532): 2507–2516. doi:10.1098/rspb.2003.2524. ISSN   0962-8452. PMC   1691537 . PMID   14667343.
  5. Ruta, Marcello; Coates, Michael I. (2007). "Dates, nodes and character conflict: Addressing the Lissamphibian origin problem". Journal of Systematic Palaeontology. 5 (1): 69–122. doi:10.1017/S1477201906002008. ISSN   1477-2019. S2CID   86479890.
  6. Anderson, Jason S. (2001-03-01). "The Phylogenetic Trunk: Maximal Inclusion of Taxa with Missing Data in an Analysis of the Lepospondyli (Vertebrata, Tetrapoda)". Systematic Biology. 50 (2): 170–193. doi: 10.1080/10635150119889 . ISSN   1076-836X. PMID   12116927.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Hook, Robert W.; Baird, Donald (1986-06-19). "The Diamond Coal Mine of Linton, Ohio, and its Pennsylvanian-age vertebrates". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 6 (2): 174–190. Bibcode:1986JVPal...6..174H. doi:10.1080/02724634.1986.10011609. ISSN   0272-4634.
  8. Sequeira, S. E. K. (1998). "The cranial morphology and taxonomy of the saurerpetontid Isodectes obtusus comb. Nov. (Amphibia: Temnospondyli) from the Lower Permian of Texas". Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society. 122 (1–2): 237–259. doi: 10.1111/j.1096-3642.1998.tb02531.x .
  9. Clack, J. A.; Milner, A. R. (2009). "Morphology and systematics of the Pennsylvanian amphibian Platyrhinops lyelli (Amphibia: Temnospondyli)". Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh. 100 (3): 275–295. doi:10.1017/S1755691010009023. ISSN   1755-6910. S2CID   128827583.
  10. Mann, Arjan; McDaniel, Emily J.; McColville, Emily R.; Maddin, Hillary C. (2019). "Carbonodraco lundi gen et sp. nov., the oldest parareptile, from Linton, Ohio, and new insights into the early radiation of reptiles". Royal Society Open Science. 6 (11): 191191. Bibcode:2019RSOS....691191M. doi:10.1098/rsos.191191. ISSN   2054-5703. PMC   6894558 . PMID   31827854.
  11. Hook, R.W.; Ferm, J.C. (1985-10-17). "A depositional model for the Linton tetrapod assemblage (Westphalian D, Upper Carboniferous) and its palaeoenvironmental significance". Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. B, Biological Sciences. 311 (1148): 101–109. Bibcode:1985RSPTB.311..101H. doi:10.1098/rstb.1985.0142. ISSN   0080-4622.
  12. Hook, Robert W.; Hower, James C. (1988). "Petrography and Taphonomic Significance of the Vertebrate-Bearing Cannel Coal of Linton, Ohio (Westphalian D, Upper Carboniferous)". Journal of Sedimentary Research. 58 (1): 72–80. doi:10.1306/212F8D19-2B24-11D7-8648000102C1865D. ISSN   1527-1404.
  13. Hook, Robert W.; Ferm, John C. (1988). "Paleoenvironmental controls on vertebrate-bearing abandoned channels in the Upper Carboniferous". Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 63 (1–3): 159–181. Bibcode:1988PPP....63..159H. doi:10.1016/0031-0182(88)90095-8.
  14. Milner, A. R. (1987). "The Westphalian tetrapod fauna; some aspects of its geography and ecology". Journal of the Geological Society. 144 (3): 495–506. Bibcode:1987JGSoc.144..495M. doi:10.1144/gsjgs.144.3.0495. ISSN   0016-7649. S2CID   131149516.