Zeitenwende speech

Last updated

Olaf Scholz, pictured about two months before delivering the Zeitenwende speech 2021-12-07 Unterzeichnung des Koalitionsvertrages der 20. Wahlperiode des Bundestages by Sandro Halank-062.jpg
Olaf Scholz, pictured about two months before delivering the Zeitenwende speech

The Zeitenwende speech was an address delivered to the Bundestag by Olaf Scholz, the Chancellor of Germany, on 27 February 2022. His speech was a reaction to the Russian invasion of Ukraine on 24 February. Scholz described the attack as a "historic turning point" (German : Zeitenwende, literally: "times-turn," referring to the change from one age or era to another) and announced that in response his government would use a €100 billion off-budget fund to significantly increase military spending, reversing Germany's previously cautious defence policy.

Contents

Scholz's speech was well-received by most German and international politicians, and was endorsed by the leader of the opposition Friedrich Merz. [1] The speech represented a major turning point for Germany’s policies in the areas of energy, relations with Russia, and security. [2]

Background

In the early months of 2022, Russia built up a military presence of around 150,000 troops near the Ukrainian border while demanding a commitment from the Western military alliance NATO that Ukraine would not be admitted to its membership. Western governments rejected this demand and reacted by increasing their military aid to Ukraine. Germany, whose government was led by the recently elected chancellor Olaf Scholz, was criticised for taking a cautious approach to the crisis. The criticism focused on Scholz's refusal to specify whether certification of Nord Stream 2, a gas pipeline financed by the Russian energy corporation Gazprom, would be suspended in the event of a Russian attack on Ukraine. On 15 February, Scholz met the Russian President Vladimir Putin for talks in Moscow. Scholz's visit was interpreted by some commentators as a sign of German weakness towards Russia. [3] On 22 February, Scholz announced that his government would prevent the pipeline's certification after Putin ordered troops into eastern Ukraine. [4]

On 24 February 2022, Russia launched an invasion of Ukraine from its built-up positions in southern Russia and Belarus. The invasion was described by Putin as a "special military operation" to aid the Donetsk People's Republic and the Luhansk People's Republic, two separatist territories in Ukraine's Donbas region that had requested Russia's help. Western leaders harshly condemned the attack. [5]

As a country poor in natural resources and economy greatly relying on export, Germany was particularly affected. [6]

Speech on 27 February

On 27 February, Scholz addressed the Bundestag, Germany's lower house of parliament, to outline his government's reaction to Russia's invasion of Ukraine. He announced a fundamental restructuring of the country's cautious defence policy: Scholz vowed to set up an extraordinary fund of €100 billion to be invested in the modernisation of the German armed forces, the Bundeswehr. [7] He also promised that defence spending would exceed 2% of gross domestic product (GDP), a requirement of NATO membership that Scholz's Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) had traditionally opposed. [7] Scholz justified his departure from established defence policy with the threat posed by Russia to peace in Europe. He described the new political situation on the continent as a "historic turning point" German : Zeitenwende, literally: times-turn), [8] saying:

Wir erleben eine Zeitenwende. Und das bedeutet: Die Welt danach ist nicht mehr dieselbe wie die Welt davor. Im Kern geht es um die Frage, ob Macht das Recht brechen darf, ob wir es Putin gestatten, die Uhren zurückzudrehen in die Zeit der Großmächte des 19. Jahrhunderts, oder ob wir die Kraft aufbringen, Kriegstreibern wie Putin Grenzen zu setzen. Das setzt eigene Stärke voraus. [9]

We are living through a watershed era. And that means that the world afterwards will no longer be the same as the world before. The issue at the heart of this is whether power is allowed to prevail over the law. Whether we permit Putin to turn back the clock to the nineteenth century and the age of the great powers. Or whether we have it in us to keep warmongers like Putin in check. That requires strength of our own. [10]

Policy changes and actions

Following Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s Zeitenwende (“turning point”) speech in February 2022, Germany implemented significant shifts in defence and foreign policy:

In addition to increases in German budgetary allotments for defence spending to achieve the 2% of GDP target mentioned in Scholz' speech, by September 2022, Germany had sent "30 Gepard anti-aircraft tanks, 10 Panzerhaubitze 2000 howitzers and three MARS multiple rocket launchers, as well as various lighter weapons," to support Ukraine. However, the government continued to delay the provision of heavy weapons, resisting opposition pressure to provide German-made Leopard battle tanks and Marder infantry fighting vehicles. [15] On 5 January 2023, Scholz partially reversed this policy: he issued a joint press release with Joe Biden, the President of the United States, announcing that their countries would supply Ukraine with Marders and Bradley Fighting Vehicles respectively. Scholz also committed to sending a Patriot air defence system as a reaction to Russia's continued attacks on Ukraine's critical infrastructure. [16]

During the early weeks of 2023, the German government faced mounting domestic and international pressure to authorize the export of Leopard 2 battle tanks to Ukraine. On 25 January, Germany announced it would approve export requests from allied states and would send 14 Leopard 2A6 tanks from its own Bundeswehr inventory to Ukraine. [17]

Subsequently, on 27 March 2023, the German Defence Ministry confirmed that 18 Leopard 2A6 tanks had arrived in Ukraine, exceeding the original commitment to fulfill a full Ukrainian tank battalion when combined with contributions from Portugal and Sweden. [18]

In December 2024, Germany expanded its support by supplying Ukraine with 15 older Leopard 1A5 tanks, alongside deliveries of air defence systems—comprising IRIS-T and Patriot launchers—demonstrating a growing German commitment to bolstering Ukraine’s defensive capabilities. [19]

Reception

Slide from a presentation at the 2022 SPD party conference entitled 'Putin's war - a historical turning point?' Putins Krieg - eine Zeitenwende.jpg
Slide from a presentation at the 2022 SPD party conference entitled 'Putin's war – a historical turning point?'

The speech was received positively by most German and international politicians. The Bundestag passed a motion of condemnation against the Russian government with the support of all parties except The Left and Alternative for Germany (AfD). Friedrich Merz, the leader of the opposition Christian Democratic Union of Germany (CDU), vowed to support Scholz's defence agenda, [20] while he characterised the previous attitude of the chancellor's party as pro-Russian. Robert Habeck, the Minister for Economic Affairs, endorsed the new policy and admitted to mistakes in Germany's previous assessment of Russia. [7] Jens Stoltenberg, Secretary General of NATO, praised Germany's new commitment to collective security, describing Scholz's promises as "a significant investment in security and freedom for our nations". [20] According to a poll, 78% of Germans supported the proposed policies. [21]

Even though the party shared Scholz's condemnation of Russia, the Left Party criticised the proposed increase in military spending. The party's chairwoman Amira Mohamed Ali accused the chancellor of engaging in an arms race that would prove detrimental to international security. Alice Weidel of AfD contradicted Scholz and asserted that NATO had committed an "historic mistake" in "aggrieving Russia" by entertaining the possibility of Ukrainian membership. [20] As Scholz resisted the transfer of heavy weaponry to Ukraine, parts of the governing coalition began challenging the chancellor in parliament. [15]

Writing for The Guardian , Patrick Wintour described Scholz's proposals as a "180-degree course correction" and wrote that Germany had become "not just an economic but also a geopolitical powerhouse" overnight. [21] Sergey Lagodinsky, a Member of the European Parliament, argued that, in addition to its increased military spending, Germany needed to learn how to wield military intervention as a tool of foreign policy. He considered the country's close energy ties with Russia "one of the biggest strategic mistakes of the past 20 years". [21] In August 2022, The Economist credited the Zeitenwende speech with facilitating the modification of long-held positions in politics and society. The newspaper reckoned that Germany now had the potential to become a "country comfortable with asserting itself using its armed forces". It also linked Scholz's new defence agenda to a new energy policy that could see Germany become less dependent on Russian gas, a scenario it described as "one of Vladimir Putin's biggest [potential] regrets". [22]

The term Zeitenwende became a political catchphrase in the aftermath of the speech [23] and was chosen the German word of the year 2022. [24]

Around the anniversary of the speech, some have criticized a perceived gap between Scholz's words and subsequent actions. Minister-President of Bavaria Markus Söder criticized Scholz by stating "everyone is talking about Zeitenwende, but so far we’ve only seen Zeitlupe [slow motion]". [25] Matthew Karnitschnig of Politico commented that "it's become clear that the best way to describe Scholz's much-ballyhooed slogan is with a blunt Americanism: bullshit". [26] Confronted with similar criticisms by CNN's Fareed Zakaria, Scholz emphasized Germany's aid to Ukraine and the successful decoupling from Russian energy dependence, while stating it "is absolutely clear we will go to two percent of GDP [in military spending]" and that starting necessary military production takes time. [27]

Effects

As of early 2025, the overall picture is mixed. [6]

In the area of energy, Germany's hydrocarbon dependency on Russia had ended, with little chance of returning to the status quo ante bellum. However, the resulting high energy prices had contributed to the economic stagnation. [28] Although Germany had managed to avoid broad deindustrialization, energy-intensive industry, especially plants directly dependent on natural gas for as a source of heat or feedstock, had partially fled the country. [29]

Germany had become the biggest European provider of support for Ukraine, but is unlikely to succeed in building up its army to the targeted 203,000 personnel strength. As the off-budget €100 billion Sondervermögen Bundeswehr fund money runs out, a creation of a new, and larger size, fund becomes inevitable, with the alternative being a significant expansion of the defense budget. [28]

Although Chancellor Scholz's 2022 Zeitenwende speech was accompanied by a €100 billion special fund to modernize the Bundeswehr, implementation has faced significant obstacles. By 2025, critics noted that despite initial procurement efforts—such as F-35A fighters, upgraded Puma IFVs, and naval frigates—the Bundeswehr remained under-equipped and strategically limited. [30]

See also

Citations

  1. Helferich, John (2023). "The (false) promise of Germany's Zeitenwende". European View. 22 (1): 85–95. doi: 10.1177/17816858231157556 . ISSN   1781-6858.
  2. Deni et al. 2025, p. ix.
  3. Vock 2022.
  4. Riley & Horowitz 2022.
  5. Al Jazeera 2022.
  6. 1 2 Deni et al. 2025, p. xiii.
  7. 1 2 3 Becker 2022.
  8. Harding 2022.
  9. Federal Government of Germany 2022a.
  10. Federal Government of Germany 2022b.
  11. "Chancellor Olaf Scholz has responded to Russia's invasion of Ukraine with historic measures". Time. 27 February 2022. Retrieved 19 August 2025. "Scholz has announced a €100 billion plan to improve the German military … for the first time since World War II, send weapons to a conflict zone."
  12. "Assessing the Zeitenwende". Strategic Studies Institute (US Army War College). 27 February 2025. Retrieved 19 August 2025. "Germany reached the NATO spending target of 2 percent of gross domestic product"
  13. "German government approves strategy aimed at bolstering defence industry". Reuters. 4 December 2024. Retrieved 19 August 2025. "The strategy includes financial framework enhancements, retention of skilled labour, reduction of bureaucratic obstacles, potential government stakes in defence companies …"
  14. "Germany abandons 'Wandel durch Handel' after Ukraine war". European Politics Journal. 10 March 2022. Retrieved 19 August 2025. "Due to the war … German politicians have abandoned the policy of Wandel durch Handel."
  15. 1 2 von der Burchard 2022.
  16. Richter 2023.
  17. Connolly, Kate (25 January 2023). "Germany announces it will supply Leopard 2 tanks to Ukraine". The Guardian. Retrieved 24 August 2025. "Germany will supply Ukraine with 14 Leopard 2A6 tanks and will allow partner countries to re-export additional battle tanks"
  18. Oltermann, Philip (28 March 2023). "German Leopard 2 tanks now in Ukraine, Berlin confirms". The Guardian. Retrieved 24 August 2025. "Germany's much-awaited shipment of 18 Leopard 2 battle tanks has arrived in Ukraine … Germany had promised 14 vehicles but increased that to 18."
  19. "Germany provides Ukraine with 15 Leopard 1 tanks, IRIS-T and Patriot systems". The Kyiv Independent. 23 December 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2025. "Berlin supplied Ukraine with 15 Leopard 1A5 tanks, … one short-range and one medium-range IRIS-T air defence system … two Patriot air defence launchers."
  20. 1 2 3 Deutsche Presse-Agentur 2022.
  21. 1 2 3 Wintour 2022.
  22. The Economist 2022.
  23. Alexander 2022.
  24. Der Spiegel 2022.
  25. ""Alle reden von Zeitenwende, aber bisher ist es nur eine Zeitlupe"". Der Spiegel. 22 February 2023. Retrieved 13 March 2023. Alle reden von Zeitenwende, aber bisher ist es nur eine Zeitlupe
  26. Karnitschnig, Matthew (27 February 2023). "The truth about Germany's defense policy shift". Politico. Retrieved 13 March 2023.
  27. Zakaria asks German chancellor what happens next in Putin's war with Ukraine. CNN. Event occurs at 5:47–. Retrieved 13 March 2023 via YouTube.
  28. 1 2 Deni et al. 2025, p. xiv.
  29. Deni et al. 2025, p. 59.
  30. "€100 Billion Later: Fixing the Bundeswehr Wasn't on Budget". Großwald | Structured Intelligence on European Defense. 17 December 2024. Retrieved 18 May 2025.

Bibliography