1979 Indianapolis mayoral election

Last updated

Indianapolis mayoral election, 1979
Flag of Indianapolis.svg
  1975 November 6, 1979 1983  
Turnout33.6% [1]
  WmHudnutIII (1).png 3x4.svg
Nominee William H. Hudnut III Paul Cantwell
Party Republican Democratic
Popular vote124,51543,955
Percentage73.9%26.1%

Mayor before election

William H. Hudnut III
Republican

Elected mayor

William H. Hudnut III
Republican

The Indianapolis mayoral election of 1979 took place on November 6, 1979, and saw the reelection of Republican William H. Hudnut III.

Contents

Hudnut defeated Democratic former city-county councilman Paul Cantwell in what was reported to have been the greatest margin of defeat for a Democratic candidate in an Indianapolis mayoral election in 150 years. [2] Cantwell had resigned his seat on the Indianapolis City-County Council in order to focus on his campaign. [2]

Campaigning

Ahead of the election season, Hudnut had demonstrated a strong advantage in polls. [3] Top prospective Democratic candidates declined to run. [3] Even before party primaries, many Democratic Party officials believed that Hadnut was not able to be unseated in the 1979 election. [4]

Laws prevented Cantwell from seeking re-election in the coinciding election for the Indianapolis City–County Council while running for mayor. [5] He opted to resign early from the city council in order to focus on his campaign. [2] In the coinciding council election, his former seat was won by Republican nominee Stanley P. Strader, [5] with Republicans winning a 22–7 council majority in the election. [6]

Cantwell struggled to raise funds, ultimately raising only $38,000. [3] Hudnut, meanwhile, spent $278,000 during his campaign. [3] This allowed Hadnut to outspend Cantwell by a 10 to 1 margin. [4] Cantwell also lacked organizational support from the Democratic Party. [4] He also found that Democratic donors were much more keen on contributing to Indiana Democratic campaigns for the upcoming 1980 elections than contributing to his campaign: including Jimmy Carter's presidential re-election campaign and Ted Kennedy's primary election campaign against Carter; Birch Bayh's likely Senate re-election campaign; John A. Hillenbrand II and Wayne Townsend's gubernatorial primary campaigns. [6]

Hadnut enjoyed much stronger name recognition than Cantwell. [4] Hadnut received diverse support for his re-election, not only with near-unanimous backing from local Republicans, but also receiving strong support within the local Black community (as well as from local Black leaders) and support from liberal groups and organized labor. The Central Indiana Building Trades Council (a labor organization) endorsed his candidacy. [6]

At the time of the election, Cantwell's son Danny Cantwell was awaiting trial for murder. He would be acquitted in November 1980. Paul Cantwell argued that the charges were political, and were retribution for his investigations of police corruption. [2]

Cantwell's campaign received some praise for speaking to genuine flaws of Hadnut's mayoral administration, [4] such as issues in the Solid Waste Division of the Department of Public Works. Cantwell also alleged that Hadnut's mayoralty had seen an "eroding tax base", a troubling growth of the local bureaucracy and an overall lack of inefficiency in the local government. [7] However, without an advertising budget behind Cantwell's message these concerns went unheard by many voters. [4]

Results

Indianapolis mayoral election, 1979 [1]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican William H. Hudnut III (incumbent) 124,515 73.9
Democratic Paul Cantwell 43,95526.1
Turnout 168,470
Majority80,560
Republican hold

References

  1. 1 2 Bodenhamer, David J. (1994). The Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. Indiana University Press. p. 1356 and 1357. ISBN   0-253-31222-1.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Mundy, Alicia (July 28, 2006). "Father introduced Cantwell to excitement, pitfalls of politics". The Seattle Times. Retrieved September 13, 2019.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Owen, James; York, Wilbern. Governing Metropolitan Indianapolis: The Politics of Unigov. University of California Press. p. 175.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Rohn, David (November 7, 1979). "'I Have No Regrets' Cantwell Takes Defeat With A Joke And A Beer" . The Indianapolis News. p. 6. Retrieved August 12, 2025 via Newspapers.com.
  5. 1 2 Booher, William J. (November 7, 1979). "Defeated Mayoral Candidate; Voting Machines Hardly Cool Before Cantwell Concedes Race" . The Indianapolis Star. p. 10. Retrieved August 12, 2025 via Newspapers.com.
  6. 1 2 3 LaFollette, Gerry (November 7, 1979). "'Spirit' Sums Up Hadnut Victory". The Indianapolis News. pp. 1 and 6.:
  7. LaFollette, Gerry (November 5, 1979). "Way To Mayor's Office Long For Cantwell, Hadnut" . The Indianapolis News. p. 11. Retrieved August 12, 2025 via Newspapers.com.
Preceded by
1975
Indianapolis mayoral election
1979
Succeeded by
1983