British Rail 10100

Last updated

British Railways 10100
Derby works fell diesel geograph-2390424-by-Ben-Brooksbank.jpg
The Fell Diesel at Derby Works in June 1957
Type and origin
Power typeDiesel-mechanical
Builder LMS, Derby Works
Build date1951
Specifications
Configuration:
   Whyte 4-8-4
   UIC 2′D2′
Gauge 4 ft 8+12 in (1,435 mm) standard gauge
Leading dia. 39 in (0.991 m)
Driver dia.51 in (1.295 m)
Minimum curve 5 chains (101  m)
Wheelbase 41 ft 4 in (12.60 m)
Length50 ft 0 in (15.24 m)
Width9 ft 0 in (2.74 m)
Height13 ft 0 in (3.96 m)
Loco weight120 long tons (122 t; 134 short tons)
Fuel capacity720 imp gal (3,300 L; 860 US gal)
Coolant cap.60 imp gal (270 L; 72 US gal)
Water cap.500 imp gal (2,300 L; 600 US gal)
Prime mover Paxman 12RPH, x 4
Cylinder size 7 in × 7+34 in (178 mm × 197 mm)
Transmission Vulcan Sinclair SCRD fluid; Fell central gearbox
Train heating Steam generator
Train brakes Vacuum
Performance figures
Maximum speed84 mph (135 km/h)
Power output2,000  bhp (1,500  kW) at 1,500 rpm
Tractive effort 25,000 lbf (111 kN)
Brakeforce38 long tons-force (380 kN)
Career
Operators British Railways
Power class6P5F, later Type 4
Numbers10100
NicknamesFell Diesel Locomotive
Withdrawn15 October 1958
ScrappedDerby Works, July 1960

British Railways 10100 was an unusual experimental diesel locomotive known informally as The Fell Diesel Locomotive (after Lt. Col. L. F. R. Fell, who was one of the designers). It was the joint production of Davey Paxman & Co, Shell Refining & Marketing Co and Lt-Col L. F. R. Fell, built for them by the London, Midland and Scottish Railway at Derby. Sir Harry Ricardo was also involved. By the time it emerged in 1950, nationalisation had taken place and it carried British Railways livery. The locomotive had six diesel engines, four of them used for traction. There were two auxiliary engines, both of which were 150 hp (110 kW) AEC 6-cylinder units, and these drove the pressure-chargers for the main engines and the purpose of this arrangement was to enable the main engines to deliver very high torque at low crankshaft speed.

Contents

Design

The design for 10100, a collaboration between Fell Developments Ltd and H. G. Ivatt of the LMS, aimed to address several of the weaknesses perceived of diesel powered rail traction. Weight was reduced by using several small engines, meaning that both the engines and their supporting structure could be lighter. [1] This was also expected to save time in maintenance as an individual diesel engine could be exchanged more easily and with lighter equipment.

Transmission

Using differential gearing to transmit the power, it was built as a 4-8-4 with the coupling rods connecting the centre four pairs of driving wheels. The coupling rods between the innermost axles were later removed, but as the four axles were driven by a single gearbox, it remained a 4-8-4. At 2,000 hp (1,500 kW) it was the most powerful of BR's non-steam locomotives at the time. From 1951 it worked the expresses from Manchester to London, proving some 25% more powerful than 5XP 4-6-0s. [2] While the mechanical transmission made it much lighter than the diesel-electric locomotives, its complicated mechanism made it difficult to maintain (a working model of the transmission is on display at the National Railway Museum, York).

The locomotive had four main Paxman 12RPH 12-cylinder engines, each producing 500 brake horsepower at 1,500 rpm. Each engine was connected to the gearbox via a hydraulic coupling, which could be filled with oil to transmit power or drained to disconnect that engine from the transmission. The engine outputs were combined in pairs by two sets of differential gearing, and the output shafts from these two gearsets were then combined by a third differential gearset to drive the main output shaft. [3] Each differential input shaft was provided with a mechanism to prevent backwards rotation when the couplings were drained. Since this could cause the drive mechanism to lock up if the locomotive were to be pushed backward a vacuum-operated clutch was included in the geartrain. [4]

The effect of this arrangement was that the gear ratio between an engine and the output shaft depended on how many engines were driving the transmission. Gear ratio selection was accomplished not by "changing gear" in the conventional sense, but by filling or draining the hydraulic couplings to connect or disconnect the engines from the transmission. With only one hydraulic coupling filled with oil and the other three engines disconnected and their respective input shafts to the transmission locked by the one-way clutches, the single engine drove the output shaft through an effective gear ratio of 4:1. With two engines driving, the effective gear ratio was 2:1; with three engines, 1.33:1; and with all four engines, unity. In other words, the effective gear ratio of the transmission was the inverse of the number of engines driving it.

Unlike the transmission of a car, there was no overall torque-multiplication effect from selecting a lower gear. The 4:1 mechanical advantage afforded to the single engine driving in first gear was cancelled out by the fact that there was only one engine operating, so the maximum output torque from the transmission was the same as was available in top gear with all four engines operating. The same argument applies to second and third gears. The transmission of this locomotive, therefore, unlike almost all other locomotive transmissions, did not provide any means of matching the torque characteristics of the engine(s) to the requirements of the locomotive; it did not provide for an increased torque output at low speeds for starting and hill climbing. [3] It served only to match the output speed of the engine(s) to the requirements of the locomotive.

The requirement for high starting torque was met in the Fell not by the transmission characteristics but by altering the torque characteristics of the engines themselves. [3] Normally a diesel engine aspires charge at a mass flow rate proportional to its rotational speed; the faster it rotates, the more charge it can aspire, and this leads to a power output curve which rises more or less linearly with rotational speed until various limiting factors become significant.

The Fell Diesel south of Belper on a Manchester-London express Duffield (near) Fell diesel geograph-2390450-by-Ben-Brooksbank.jpg
The Fell Diesel south of Belper on a Manchester-London express

In the Fell locomotive, however, the four main drive engines received their charge from Roots blowers driven by two further auxiliary engines which were governed such that when the traction power demand was more than minimal, they operated at essentially a constant speed. Since a Roots blower is a positive-displacement device, this meant that the mass flow rate at which charge was delivered to the main engines depended not on the speed of the main engines but on that of the auxiliary engines, so the power output of the main engines was essentially defined by the speed of the auxiliary engines.

Since the speed of the auxiliary engines was held constant, the main engines had a power curve which was constant with rotational speed; since power is the product of torque and rotational speed, the main engines were endowed with a torque curve inversely proportional to speed, producing maximum torque at a low speed and reducing as the speed increased. Thus the necessary increased low-speed torque output for starting and hill climbing was provided. [4]

Withdrawal

In July 1952, 10100's gearbox was severely damaged after a loose bolt fell through the geartrain, and the locomotive was out of service for over a year. British Railways subsequently lost interest in the project, and an improved version of the locomotive under development was abandoned.

10100 remained in service until 16 October 1958, when its steam heating boiler caught fire at Manchester Central. It was returned to Derby Works, where it was slowly stripped of parts before being scrapped in July 1960. [5]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Automatic transmission</span> Type of motor vehicle transmission that automatically changes gear ratio as the vehicle moves

An automatic transmission is a multi-speed transmission used in motor vehicles that does not require any input from the driver to change forward gears under normal driving conditions. Vehicles with internal combustion engines, unlike electric vehicles, require the engine to operate in a narrow range of rates of rotation, requiring a gearbox, operated manually or automatically, to drive the wheels over a wide range of speeds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diesel locomotive</span> Locomotive powered by a diesel engine

A diesel locomotive is a type of railway locomotive in which the power source is a diesel engine. Several types of diesel locomotives have been developed, differing mainly in the means by which mechanical power is conveyed to the driving wheels. The most common are diesel-electric locomotives and diesel-hydraulic.

In railway engineering, the term tractive effort describes the pulling or pushing capability of a locomotive. The published tractive force value for any vehicle may be theoretical—that is, calculated from known or implied mechanical properties—or obtained via testing under controlled conditions. The discussion herein covers the term's usage in mechanical applications in which the final stage of the power transmission system is one or more wheels in frictional contact with a railroad track.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dynamic braking</span> Dynamic braking is the use of the traction motors as generators when slowing a vehicle.

Dynamic braking is the use of an electric traction motor as a generator when slowing a vehicle such as an electric or diesel-electric locomotive. It is termed "rheostatic" if the generated electrical power is dissipated as heat in brake grid resistors, and "regenerative" if the power is returned to the supply line. Dynamic braking reduces wear on friction-based braking components, and regeneration lowers net energy consumption. Dynamic braking may also be used on railcars with multiple units, light rail vehicles, electric trams, trolleybuses, and electric and hybrid electric automobiles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Torque converter</span> Fluid coupling that transfers rotating power from a prime mover to a rotating driven load

A torque converter is a device, usually implemented as a type of fluid coupling, that transfers rotating power from a prime mover, like an internal combustion engine, to a rotating driven load. In a vehicle with an automatic transmission, the torque converter connects the prime mover to the automatic gear train, which then drives the load. It is thus usually located between the engine's flexplate and the transmission. The equivalent device in a manual transmission is the mechanical clutch.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Overdrive (mechanics)</span> Gearing that lowers engine revolutions

Overdrive is the operation of an automobile cruising at sustained speed with reduced engine speed (rpm), leading to better fuel consumption, lower noise, and lower wear. The term is ambiguous. The most fundamental meaning is that of an overall gear ratio between engine and wheels, such that the car is over-geared, and cannot reach its potential top speed, i.e. the car could travel faster if it were in a lower gear, with the engine turning at higher RPM.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transmission (mechanical device)</span> Drivetrain transmitting propulsion power

A transmission is a mechanical device which uses a gear set—two or more gears working together—to change the speed or direction of rotation in a machine. Many transmissions have multiple gear ratios, but there are also transmissions that use a single fixed-gear ratio.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Continuously variable transmission</span> Automotive transmission technology

A continuously variable transmission (CVT) is an automated transmission that can change through a continuous range of gear ratios. This contrasts with other transmissions that provide a limited number of gear ratios in fixed steps. The flexibility of a CVT with suitable control may allow the engine to operate at a constant angular velocity while the vehicle moves at varying speeds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Manual transmission</span> Motor vehicle manual gearbox; stick shift

A manual transmission (MT), also known as manual gearbox, standard transmission, or stick shift, is a multi-speed motor vehicle transmission system, where gear changes require the driver to manually select the gears by operating a gear stick and clutch.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Drive shaft</span> Mechanical component for transmitting torque and rotation

A drive shaft, driveshaft, driving shaft, tailshaft, propeller shaft, or Cardan shaft is a component for transmitting mechanical power, torque, and rotation, usually used to connect other components of a drivetrain that cannot be connected directly because of distance or the need to allow for relative movement between them.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fluid coupling</span> Device used to transmit rotating mechanical power

A fluid coupling or hydraulic coupling is a hydrodynamic or 'hydrokinetic' device used to transmit rotating mechanical power. It has been used in automobile transmissions as an alternative to a mechanical clutch. It also has widespread application in marine and industrial machine drives, where variable speed operation and controlled start-up without shock loading of the power transmission system is essential.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Friction drive</span> Mechanical power transmission by friction between components

A friction drive or friction engine is a type of transmission that utilises two wheels in the transmission to transfer power from the engine to the driving wheels. The system is inherently a continuously variable transmission; by adjusting the positions of the two disks, the output ratio changes continuously. Although it was once employed in early automobiles, today the system is most commonly used on scooters, particularly go-peds, as a substitute for a chain and gear system. It is mechanically identical to a ball-and-disk integrator, but is designed to handle higher torque levels.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Magnetic coupling</span>

A magnetic coupling is a component which transfers torque from one shaft to another using a magnetic field, rather than a physical mechanical connection. They are also known as magnetic drive couplings, magnetic shaft couplings, or magnetic disc couplings.

Hybrid vehicle drivetrains transmit power to the driving wheels for hybrid vehicles. A hybrid vehicle has multiple forms of motive power.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Differential steering</span> The steering method used by tanks and similar tracked vehicles

Differential steering is the means of steering a land vehicle by applying more drive torque to one side of the vehicle than the other. Differential steering is the primary means of steering tracked vehicles, such as tanks and bulldozers, is also used in certain wheeled vehicles commonly known as skid-steer, and even implemented in some automobiles, where it is called torque vectoring, to augment steering by changing wheel direction relative to the vehicle. Differential steering is distinct from torque steer, which is usually considered a negative side effect of drive-train design choices.

Turbo transmissions are hydrodynamic, multi-stage drive assemblies designed for rail vehicles using internal combustion engines. The first turbo-transmission was developed in 1932 by Voith in Heidenheim, Germany. Since then, improvements to turbo-transmissions have paralleled similar advances in diesel motors and today this combination plays a leading role worldwide, second only to the use of electrical drives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cross-drive steering transmission</span>

A cross-drive steering transmission is a transmission, used in tracked vehicles to allow precise and energy-efficient steering.

The Paxman Hi-Dyne engine was a form of experimental diesel engine developed for rail transport use by the British engine makers Paxman of Colchester. They used variable supercharging to give a constant power output across their speed range.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Drivetrain</span> Group of components that deliver power to the driving wheels

A drivetrain or Transmission System, is the group of components that deliver mechanical power from the prime mover to the driven components. In automotive engineering, the drivetrain is the components of a motor vehicle that deliver power to the drive wheels. This excludes the engine or motor that generates the power. In marine applications, the drive shaft will drive a propeller, thruster, or waterjet rather than a drive axle, while the actual engine might be similar to an automotive engine. Other machinery, equipment and vehicles may also use a drivetrain to deliver power from the engine(s) to the driven components.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Internal combustion locomotive</span> Railway locomotive that produces its pulling power through an internal combustion engine

An internal combustion locomotive is a type of railway locomotive that produces its pulling power using an internal combustion engine. These locomotives are fuelled by burning fossil fuels, most commonly oil or gasoline, to produce rotational power which is transmitted to the locomotive's driving wheels by various direct or indirect transmission mechanisms. The fuel is carried on the locomotive.

References

  1. Carr, Richard. "The Fell Locomotive - No 10100". Richard Carr's Paxman History Pages. Retrieved 2 December 2008.
  2. Bentley, C. (1997) British Railways Operating History: Volume 1, The Peak District, Carnarvon: XPress Publishing
  3. 1 2 3 Ransome-Wallis, P., ed. (2001) [1959]. Encyclopedia of World Railway Locomotives. Dover Transportation. Courier Corporation. pp. 80–81. ISBN   0486412474.
  4. 1 2 Technical details of the locomotive
  5. Derby Through the Diesel Years 1947 - 1972

Further reading