Glenbrook rail accident

Glenbrook rail accident
Details
Date	2 December 1999 8:22 am
Location	Glenbrook, New South Wales
Country	Australia
Line	Blue Mountains railway line
Operator	Great Southern Rail, CityRail
Incident type	Collision
Cause	Signal failure and driver-signalman miscommunication
Statistics
Trains	2
Deaths	7
Injured	51

The Glenbrook rail accident occurred on 2 December 1999 at 8:22 am on a curve east of Glenbrook railway station on the CityRail network between Glenbrook and Lapstone, in the Blue Mountains of New South Wales, Australia. Seven passengers were killed and 51 passengers were taken to hospital with injuries ^[1] when a CityRail electric interurban train collided with the rear wagon of the long-haul Perth-to-Sydney Indian Pacific.

Overview

The Indian Pacific train was authorised to pass a red signal at Glenbrook and stopped at the next signal, also red. The driver alighted to use the lineside signal telephone to call the signaller for authority to pass the signal at danger; as a component of the phone was missing, he incorrectly believed it to be defective. A delay of approximately seven minutes resulted despite the locomotive having a radio (at that time it was not a procedure for the National Rail Corporation to use a radio to contact signal boxes).

The interurban train restarted with authority after stopping at the red signal at Glenbrook and collided shortly after with the rear of the Indian Pacific train waiting at the second failed signal. Several factors were involved, from equipment breakdown to poor phrasing of the safe working rules: the most important was that the interurban picked up too much speed and the driver was not able to see the rear of the Indian Pacific around a sharp curve in a deep cutting in time to avoid a collision. This is essentially equivalent to a blind corner.

Visibility

The track was curved to the left, the train was using the left-hand track, the driver was sitting on the left side of the train, and the track was in a narrow rock cutting. These four factors contributed to less than average visibility.

Inquiry

A Commission of Inquiry headed by Justice Peter McInerney investigated the accident. ^[1]

Causes

The Commission found that the accident occurred after a power failure disabled two consecutive automatic signals: due to their fail-safe design, both exhibited danger (red).

Both trains obtained permission from the signalman at Penrith to pass the first signal at danger. The driver of the Indian Pacific obeyed the rule requiring him to proceed with "extreme caution", but the driver of the interurban train failed to do so and caught up with the Indian Pacific.

The Commission found fault with a number of procedures, their application by railway employees, and the training those employees had received. Among other factors, it found that:

• the signalman was unable to monitor the position of the Indian Pacific, so was unaware it had not cleared the second signal;
• safety-critical communication was too informal;
• the train controller in Sydney told the driver of the interurban train by radio, "it's only an auto... just trip past", thereby potentially misleading the driver into believing that the signal section was clear; the signalman in Penrith was not aware of this exchange;
• the driver of the interurban train failed to proceed with "extreme caution", as required by the rule, and so was unable to stop in time to avoid the collision. ^[1]
• training for passing signals at danger was deficient, as was the rule, safeworking unit 245.

Effects

The seven people who died were in the front compartment of the first carriage of the interurban train. The rear carriage of the Indian Pacific was a car transport wagon that did not convey passengers, and, in absorbing the brunt of the collision, was arguably the reason there were not any fatalities on board the Indian Pacific. ^[2] The impact of the collision was such that the front six metres of the interurban car were compressed into just one metre, while also causing the first six carriages of the Indian Pacific to separate from the rest of the train. ^{[2] [3]} When the driver of the CityRail train saw the stationary Indian Pacific, he ran from the driver's compartment (the dead-man's brake was automatically activated) to the lower deck of the double-decker carriage warning the passengers to brace themselves. He was badly injured, but survived because of this. As he ran through, a man from the front compartment ran to the upper deck to warn the passengers and thereby also survived the crash. ^[4]

A third train, bound for Lithgow, only narrowly avoided colliding with the wreckage when signallers managed to warn the driver to stop just 60 seconds before it reached the crash site. ^[5]

The interurban train

The train was a standard four-car V set, labelled V21. The first carriage, DIM8067, received critical damage to its front and lower compartments, but it was repaired. To avoid any reference and insensitivity to the victims, it was re-numbered DIM8020 and remained in service until it was withdrawn in 2005 following many problems. ^[6]

See also

• Roseville collision, 1950. Tripped past red signal according to rules, similar to Glenbrook.
• Railway accidents in New South Wales

References

1. The Honourable Peter Aloysius McInerney (April 2001). "Special Commission of Inquiry into the Glenbrook Rail Accident" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 21 August 2006.
2. "Death toll now officially 7 in Glenbrook train crash". Danger ahead! Historic rail accidents. 3 December 1999. Retrieved 8 January 2017.
3. "Biggest blow to traveller familiar with misfortune". The Sydney Morning Herald. 3 December 1999.
4. "Driver's frantic yell: 'Get Down!". The Sydney Morning Herald. 3 December 1999.
5. Adcock, Bronwyn (14 February 2000). "Glenbrook train crash inquiry hears of narrow escape". Australian Broadcasting Corporation . Retrieved 8 January 2017.
6. Sydney Trains Vlog 802: The Story of V Set Car DIM8020, 16 January 2015, archived from the original on 12 December 2021, retrieved 8 January 2017

33°46′31″S150°37′18″E / 33.775328°S 150.62159°E / -33.775328; 150.62159