Jochi

Last updated

Jochi
Juchi Khan (cropped).JPG
A statue of Jochi in modern-day Mongolia
Khan of the Ulus of Jochi
Predecessornone
Successor Orda
Batu
Bornc. 1182
Diedc. 1225
Issue Orda Khan
Batu Khan
Berke Khan
others
Dynasty Borjigin
Mother Börte
Military career
Battles / wars

Jochi (Mongolian : ᠵᠦᠴᠢ; c. 1182 – c. 1225), also known as Jüchi, [1] was a prince of the early Mongol Empire. His life was marked by controversy over the circumstances of his birth and culminated in his estrangement from his family. He was nevertheless a prominent military commander and the progenitor of the family who ruled over the khanate of the Golden Horde.

Contents

Jochi was the son of Börte, the first wife of the Mongol leader Temüjin. For many months before Jochi's birth, Börte had been a captive of the Merkit tribe, one of whom forcibly married and raped her. Although there was thus considerable doubt over Jochi's parentage, Temüjin considered him his son and treated him accordingly. Many Mongols, most prominently Börte's next son Chagatai, disagreed; these tensions eventually led to both Chagatai and Jochi being excluded from the line of succession to the Mongol throne.

After Temüjin founded the Mongol Empire in 1206 and took the name Genghis Khan, he entrusted Jochi with nine thousand warriors and a large territory in the west of the Mongol heartland; Jochi commanded and participated in numerous campaigns to secure and extend Mongol power in the region. He was also a prominent commander during the invasion of the Khwarazmian Empire (1219–1221), during which he subdued cities and tribes to the north. During the 1221 Siege of Gurganj, tensions arose between him, his brothers, and Genghis, which never healed. Jochi was still estranged from his family when he died of ill health c. 1225. His son Batu was appointed to rule his territories in his stead.

Birth and paternity

Jochi's mother, Börte, was born into the Onggirat tribe, who lived along the Greater Khingan mountain range south of the Ergüne river, in modern-day Inner Mongolia. [2] At the age of ten, she was betrothed to a Mongol boy named Temüjin, son of the Mongol chieftain Yesugei. [a] Seven years later (c. 1178), after he had survived a violent adolescence, they married. [4] They had their first child, a daughter named Qojin, in 1179 or 1180. [5] By forming alliances with notable steppe leaders, such as his friend Jamukha and his father's former ally Toghrul, and with the help of his charisma, Temüjin began to attract followers and gain power. [6] Word of his rise spread and soon drew the attention of the Merkit tribe to the northwest, from whom Yesugei had abducted Temüjin's mother Hö'elün, sparking a blood feud; they resolved to take revenge on Yesugei's heir. [7]

Because of their consequences, the subsequent events were considered controversial: most contemporary authors omitted any mention of the events, while the two that did include them (the Secret History of the Mongols , a mid-13th-century epic poem, and the 14th-century Persian historian Rashid al-Din's Jami al-tawarikh ) are contradictory. [8] The following narrative, containing elements from both, is considered most plausible. In 1180 or 1181, [9] a large force of Merkits raided Temüjin's camp; while most of his family managed to escape, Börte was captured. [10] She was forcibly married to Chilger-Bökö, the younger brother of Hö'elün's original husband. Meanwhile, Temüjin had convinced his allies to assemble substantial forces to help him rescue Börte. [11] Under Jamukha's command, the combined army campaigned against the Merkits and defeated them, recovering Börte and taking large amounts of plunder. [12]

However, there was a problem—Börte was heavily pregnant and c. 1182 gave birth to Jochi in Jamukha's camp. As Chilger-Bökö had undoubtedly raped her, and as she had been among the Merkits for nearly nine months, Jochi's paternity was uncertain; [13] this was reflected in his name, meaning "guest" in Mongolian. [14] While Temüjin always regarded Jochi as his son by blood and treated him accordingly, many Mongols, such as his younger brother Chagatai, viewed him as a bastard sired by Chilger-Bökö. [15]

Adulthood

Marriages and family

A depiction of Batu Khan, Jochi's second son and eventual successor. Batu Khan on the Throne by Rashid al-Din.jpg
A depiction of Batu Khan, Jochi's second son and eventual successor.

Jochi does not reappear in historical sources until 1203. [16] By this time, he was old enough for marriage. Temüjin intended to betroth him to a daughter of his ally Toghrul, but because of Jochi's uncertain birth and Temüjin's comparatively low status, this proposal was taken as insulting by Toghrul's people and eventually led to war between the two leaders. [17] After Toghrul's defeat in 1204, Jochi was given one of his nieces, Begtütmish, as a wife. [18] He also married other women: Börte's niece Öki; her relative Sorghan; and several less powerful women, namely Qutlugh Khatun, Sultan Khatun, Nubqus, Shīr, Qarajin, and Kul. In addition, Jochi took concubines. It is unknown who Jochi's senior wife was, but it was likely either Öki or Sorghan. [19]

Jochi's most important sons were Orda Khan and Batu Khan; they were the children of Sorghan and Öki respectively. Neither these women nor Begtütmish was the mother of Jochi's other notable son, Berke. The names of eleven other sons are known, but none had significant careers, reflecting the junior status of their mothers. [20] Descendants of younger sons nevertheless used their Jochid lineage to legitimise their right to rule: these included Khiḍr Khan of Shiban's line, and Tokhtamysh who descended from Jochi's youngest son Tuqa-Timur. [21]

Early commands

In 1206, having united the tribes of Mongolia, Temüjin held a large assembly called a kurultai where he was acclaimed as "Genghis Khan". [22] He began to reorder his new nation, dividing it between members of his ruling dynasty. As the eldest son, Jochi received the largest share—nine thousand subject warriors, all with their own families and herds; Chagatai received eight thousand, and their younger brothers Ögedei and Tolui received five thousand each. [23] As expected for a firstborn, Jochi received the territories furthest away from the homeland for his ulus (domain): they were located in western Mongolia along the River Irtysh. [24]

Map of the course of the River Irtysh; Jochi's territories were initially located around its headwaters in the west of the Mongol heartland, but later came to include most of this map. Irtysh river basin map.png
Map of the course of the River Irtysh; Jochi's territories were initially located around its headwaters in the west of the Mongol heartland, but later came to include most of this map.

This allocation was made with the expectation that Jochi would expand, and so in 1207–08 he campaigned against and subjugated the Hoi-yin Irgen  [ ja ], a collection of tribes on the edge of the Siberian taiga between the Angara and Irtysh rivers. [25] Jochi secured a marriage alliance with the Oirats, whose leader Qutuqa Beki guided the Mongols to the Yenisei Kyrgyz and other Hoi-yin Irgen. These tribes soon submitted, and Jochi took control of the region's trade in grain and furs, as well as its gold mines. [26] He subsequently reinforced Subutai's army before it defeated the renegade Merkits at the battle of the Irtysh River in late 1208 or early 1209. [27] Jochi would campaign intermittently against the Merkits and their Qangli allies for the next decade, finally destroying the last remnants of the people in 1217 or 1218 alongside Subutai. [28] The historian Christopher Atwood has argued that this narrative minimised Jochi's role, that in reality he, not Subutai, was the primary commander in all campaigns against the Merkit and Qangli, and that his right to rule the former Qangli lands was justified by the success of the campaigns. [29]

Alongside his brothers Chagatai and Ögedei, Jochi commanded the right wing in the 1211 invasion of the Chinese Jin dynasty. The Mongols marched southwards from Genghis's campaign headquarters in modern Inner Mongolia in November 1211: first they attacked the cities in the area between Hohhot and Datong, and then they followed the Taihang Mountains into Shanxi, where they pillaged and plundered in autumn 1213. [30] He may have also taken part in the Irghiz River skirmish, an inconclusive engagement fought against the army of Muhammad II of Khwarazm. [31] The Secret History records two conversations between Jochi and his father about his campaigns: once when Genghis declined Jochi's request to spare the life of a renowned Merkit archer, and once when Jochi's triumphant return from the subjugation of the Oirats garnered high praise from his father. [32]

Khwarazmian war and succession

In 1218, Genghis was provoked into launching a campaign against the Central Asian Khwarazmian Empire after a Mongol trade caravan was killed by the governor of the border town of Otrar and subsequent diplomatic overtures failed. [33] According to the Secret History, Yesui, one of Genghis's secondary wives, requested that he decide the succession before setting out. Though Genghis appears not to have cared about Jochi's possible illegitimacy, Chagatai vehemently objected to his brother becoming the next khan, shouting "How can we let ourselves be ruled by this Merkit bastard?" After a short brawl between the brothers was broken up, the Secret History continues, the suggestion of Ögedei as a compromise candidate was endorsed by both brothers and their father. [34] Because of other sources which present a less febrile gathering which took place after the war's conclusion, some historians speculate that the Secret History's account was "a later interpolation" and that Jochi only lost his place as heir after making mistakes during the Khwarazmian campaign. [35]

The Khwarazmian Empire c. 1220. Jochi campaigned along the northern border from east to west; when he reached the Aral Sea, he took his army south to besiege Gurganj (marked as Urgench). Khwarezmian Empire 1190 - 1220 (AD).svg
The Khwarazmian Empire c. 1220. Jochi campaigned along the northern border from east to west; when he reached the Aral Sea, he took his army south to besiege Gurganj (marked as Urgench).

The Mongol armies, estimated to number 150,000 or 200,000 men in total, descended upon Otrar in late 1219. Leaving Chagatai and Ögedei to besiege the town, Genghis took their younger brother Tolui and traversed the Kyzyl Kum desert to attack the city of Bukhara. [36] Meanwhile, Jochi was dispatched to march down the Syr Darya river in the direction of the Khwarazmian capital Gurganj and subdue all the cities en route, which Genghis intended to become part of Jochi's territories. The towns of Sighnaq and Asanas offered particularly stiff resistance and their inhabitants were thus slaughtered, while Jand and Yanikant were occupied without much trouble. [37] In late 1220, he travelled southwest along the shores of the Aral Sea to Gurganj, while his brothers Chagatai and Ögedei, having captured Otrar, converged on his position. [38]

There are contradictory accounts of the siege of Gurganj and Jochi's part in it. What is certain is that the siege was lengthy, lasting between four and seven months, and that it was exceptionally fierce: the defiant Khwarazmian defenders forced the Mongol army to engage in bitter house-by-house urban warfare, with much of the city destroyed either by burning naphtha or flooding from collapsed dams. [39] After the city's eventual fall in 1221, its inhabitants were either killed or enslaved. [40]

The usual narrative of the siege recounts that Jochi and Chagatai quarrelled on how best to conduct its progress, as Jochi presumed that the rich city would become part of his domain and wished to damage it as little as possible. Chagatai on the other hand held no such qualms. When Genghis heard about this infighting, he ordered that Ögedei be promoted to command his brothers. [41] Atwood however argues that this narrative was a later invention designed to buttress Ögedei's rule as khan of the empire and that Jochi in reality retained primacy throughout the siege. [42]

Death and legacy

The "Jochi Mausoleum" in Kazakhstan has traditionally been identified as Jochi's burial place, but this is likely untrue. Dzhuchi khan mausoleum (cropped).jpg
The "Jochi Mausoleum" in Kazakhstan has traditionally been identified as Jochi's burial place, but this is likely untrue.

Regardless of the narrative discrepancies, Jochi lost the favour of his father following the siege. [43] Genghis likely considered it a military failure on account of its length and destruction; Jochi also erred by not sending his father his rightful share of the loot. [44] After its conclusion, Chagatai and Ögedei departed southwards to join their father in his pursuit of the renegade Khwarazmian prince Jalal al-Din, while Jochi moved north, ostensibly to bring the Qangli to heel in his new territories, which included the steppes west of the river Chu. Some sources allege that he preferred to spend his time hunting, an activity he was very greatly fond of. It is unclear if he ever met his father again. [45]

Although Jochi sent huge numbers of wild asses and 20,000 white horses to Genghis as a gift c. 1224, relations were steadily worsening because of Jochi's preoccupation with his territories. [46] On his return home, Genghis ordered Jochi to join him, but the latter claimed he was too ill to do so. When a traveller claimed that he was not ill and merely hunting, Genghis resolved to bring him to heel. Before he could do so, in either 1225 or 1227, [b] news came that Jochi had died of his illness. [49] One account, likely fabricated, states that Jochi had been so offended by the destruction at Gurganj that he had made a secret alliance with the Khwarazmians, and that having found out, Genghis ordered that Jochi be poisoned. [50]

Batu was confirmed as ruler of his father's territories by Genghis—his elder brother Orda assumed a junior position, while their younger brothers each took a strip of land to rule. [51] Jochi's descendants would grow more independent, eventually ruling over the state known as the Golden Horde. [52] Although a large mausoleum in Ulytau Region in Kazakhstan has traditionally been identified as the resting place of Jochi's remains, radiocarbon dating indicates that it was built much later and that it is not the site of the grave. [53]

Related Research Articles

Börte Üjin, better known as Börte, was the first wife of Temüjin, who became Genghis Khan, the founder of the Mongol Empire. Börte became the head of the first Court of Genghis Khan, and Grand Empress of his Empire. She was betrothed to Genghis at a young age, married at seventeen, and then kidnapped by a rival tribe. Her husband's rescue of her is considered one of the key events that started him on his path to becoming a conqueror. She gave birth to four sons and five daughters, who, along with their own descendants, were the primary bloodline in the expansion of the Mongol Empire.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ögedei Khan</span> Second Great Khan of the Mongol Empire

Ögedei Khan was the second ruler of the Mongol Empire. The third son of Genghis Khan, he continued the expansion of the empire that his father had begun.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tolui</span> Regent of the Mongol Empire (c. 1191 – 1232)

Tolui was the youngest son of Genghis Khan and Börte. A prominent general during the early Mongol conquests, Tolui was a leading candidate to succeed his father after his death in 1227 and ultimately served as regent of the Mongol Empire until the accession of his brother Ögedei two years later. Tolui's wife was Sorghaghtani Beki; their sons included Möngke and Kublai, the fourth and fifth khans of the empire, and Hulagu, the founder of the Ilkhanate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chagatai Khan</span> Second son of Genghis Khan and Börte (1183–1242)

Chagatai Khan was a son of Genghis Khan and a prominent figure in the early Mongol Empire. The second son of Genghis's wife Börte, Chagatai was renowned for his masterful knowledge of Mongol custom and law, which he scrupulously obeyed, and his harsh temperament. Because Genghis felt that he was too inflexible in character, most notably never accepting the legitimacy of his elder brother Jochi, he excluded Chagatai from succession to the Mongol throne. He was nevertheless a key figure in ensuring the stability of the empire after Genghis's death and during the reign of his younger brother Ögedei Khan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Merkit</span> 12th-century tribal confederation of the Mongolian Plateau

The Merkit was one of the five major tribal confederations of Turkic origin in the 12th century Mongolian Plateau.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hö'elün</span> Mother of Genghis Khan (fl. 1162–1210)

Hö'elün was a noblewoman of the Mongol Empire and the mother of Temüjin, better known as Genghis Khan. She played a major role in his rise to power, as described in the Secret History of the Mongols.

Oghul Qaimish was the wife of Güyük Khan, the third ruler of the Mongol Empire, and was herself the nominal regent of the empire between Güyük's death in 1248 and the accession of Möngke Khan in 1251.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Genghis Khan</span> Founder of the Mongol Empire (c. 1162 – 1227)

Genghis Khan, also known as Chinggis Khan, was the founder and first khan of the Mongol Empire. After spending most of his life uniting the Mongol tribes, he launched a series of military campaigns, conquering large parts of China and Central Asia.

Shigi Qutuqu was a high-ranking official during the early decades of the Mongol Empire. The adopted son of the empire's founder Temüjin and his wife Börte, Shigi Qutuqu played an important role in the codification of Mongol law, serving with distinction as an administrator in North China. He may also have been a major source for the Secret History of the Mongols, which portrays him very favourably.

Between 1219 and 1221, the Mongol forces under Genghis Khan invaded the lands of the Khwarazmian Empire in Central Asia. The campaign, which followed the annexation of the Qara Khitai Khanate, saw widespread devastation and atrocities. The invasion marked the completion of the Mongol conquest of Central Asia, and began the Mongol conquest of Persia.

Mongol campaigns in Central Asia occurred after the unification of the Mongol and Turkic tribes on the Mongolian plateau in 1206. Smaller military operations of the Mongol Empire in Central Asia included the destruction of surviving Merkit and Naimans and the conquest of Qara Khitai. These were followed by a major campaign against Khwarazm. Expansion into Central Asia began in 1209 as Genghis Khan sent an expedition to pursue rivals who had fled to the region and threatened his new empire. The Uyghur kingdom Qocho and leaders of the Karluks submitted voluntarily to the Mongol Empire and married into the imperial family. By 1218 the Mongols controlled all of Xinjiang and by 1221 all the territories of the former Khwarazmian Empire. In 1236, the Mongols defeated the eastern portions of Cumania and swept into Eastern Europe.

Boroqul was one of the foremost generals of Temüjin during his rise to power. Raised as a foundling by Temüjin's mother Hoelun, he won great renown by saving the life of Temüjin's son and future heir Ögedei after the Battle of Khalakhaljid Sands in 1203.

Al-Altan, also known as Altalun and Altaluqan, was the youngest child and favourite daughter of Genghis Khan, founder of the Mongol Empire, and Börte, his primary wife. As part of Genghis's policy of marrying his daughters to powerful rulers in exchange for their submission to him, she married Barchuk, the ruler of the wealthy Uighur people to the southwest, in around 1211.

Checheyigen was the second daughter of Genghis Khan, the founder of the Mongol Empire, and his first wife Börte. As part of Genghis's policy of marrying his daughters to powerful rulers in exchange for their submission, she married a prince of the Oirat tribe, who lived near Lake Baikal, in 1207. There, she assumed a high-ranking administrative role among her husband's people, organising people and flocks like other high-ranking nomadic women. Over the following decades, Checheyigen arranged a series of advantageous marriages for her seven children and, after she backed the successful side in the Toluid Revolution of the early 1250s, her Oirat family became one of the most powerful in the empire. However, her descendants failed to take full advantage of their position, and eventually lost most of their influence.

The rise of Genghis Khan involves the events from his birth as Temüjin in 1162 until 1206, when he was bestowed the title of "Genghis Khan", which means something along the lines of "Universal Ruler" or "Oceanic Ruler" by the Quriltai, which was an assembly of Mongol chieftains.

Genghis Khan had many wives and concubines. Wives and concubines were frequently acquired from conquered territory, and, in the case of Genghis Khan, sometimes whole empires, and the women enrolled as either his wives or concubines were often princesses or queens that were either taken captive or gifted to him.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Otrar Catastrophe</span> Siege and capture of Otrar by Mongol Empire

The Otrar Catastrophe was a siege that took place between December 1219 and February 1220 during the Mongol conquest of the Khwarazmian Empire at Otrar, a large trading city on the Syr Darya river. Inalchuq, the city's governor, had seized the goods of a Mongol trade caravan the previous year; after more provocations from Inalchuq's liege and ruler of the Khwarazmian Empire, Shah Muhammad II, Genghis Khan launched a full-scale invasion of the empire.

The Shengwu qinzheng lu is a Chinese translation of a Mongolian chronicle describing the lives of Genghis Khan and his son Ögedei Khan. Much of the chronicle was derived from the Altan Debter, a now-lost state history of the Mongol Empire. Both the Persian Jami' al-tawarikh, written by Rashid al-Din at the start of the 14th century, and the Chinese Yuán Shǐ, drew upon the Altan Debter. By combining the three extant works, historians are able to adequately reconstruct the Altan Debter's original content.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Baljuna Covenant</span> 1203 oath sworn by Genghis Khan

The Baljuna Covenant was an oath sworn in mid-1203 AD by Temüjin—the khan of the Mongol tribe and the future Genghis Khan—and a small group of companions, subsequently known as the Baljunatu. Temüjin had risen in power in the service of the Kereit khan Toghrul during the late 12th century. In early 1203, Toghrul was convinced by his son Senggum that Temüjin's proposal of a marriage alliance between his and their families was an attempt to usurp their power. After escaping two successive Kereit ambushes, Temüjin was cornered and comprehensively defeated at the Battle of Qalaqaljid Sands.

The Battle of the Irtysh River or Battle Along the Buqdarma was a battle between the Mongol Empire and remnants of the Merkit and Naimans, fought at the junction of the Bukhtarma with the Irtysh in late 1208 or very early 1209. The Merkit had a longstanding rivalry with the Borjigin, the family of Genghis Khan, and together with the Naimans opposed Genghis Khan's rise to power. The Battle of Chakirmaut in 1204 shattered the forces of the Merkit-Naimans alliance and the survivors fled into southern Western Siberia. When Jochi, the son of Genghis, led an expedition into Siberia to subjugate what the Mongols called the "Forest Peoples", he encountered the remnant armies of the Merkits and Naimans at the Irtysh and soundly defeated them, shattering the alliance. The Merkit commander Toqto'a was slain and the Naiman leader Kuchlug fled.

References

Notes

  1. ↑ At this point in time, the word "Mongols" only referred to the members of one tribe in northeast Mongolia; because this tribe played a central role in the formation of the Mongol Empire, their name was later used for all the tribes. [3]
  2. ↑ Sources for 1225: [47]
    Sources for 1227: [48]

Citations

  1. ↑ Atwood 2004, p. 278.
  2. ↑ Atwood 2004, p. 456.
  3. ↑ Atwood 2004, pp. 389–391.
  4. ↑ Broadbridge 2018, pp. 49–50, 57; Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 20–21, 31; May 2018, pp. 23–28.
  5. ↑ Broadbridge 2018, p. 58.
  6. ↑ Favereau 2021, p. 34; May 2018, pp. 28–30; Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 31–34.
  7. ↑ Ratchnevsky 1991, p. 34; Broadbridge 2018, pp. 46–47; Atwood 2004, p. 347.
  8. ↑ Broadbridge 2018, pp. 58–64; Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 34–37; May 2018, pp. 30–31.
  9. ↑ Broadbridge 2018, p. 63.
  10. ↑ Ratchnevsky 1991, p. 34; May 2022a, p. 55.
  11. ↑ May 2018, p. 30; May 2022a, pp. 55–56; Broadbridge 2018, p. 59; Atwood 2004, p. 278.
  12. ↑ Favereau 2021, p. 34; Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 35–36; May 2018, p. 30.
  13. ↑ Biran 2012, p. 35; May 2022a, p. 56; Atwood 2004, p. 278.
  14. ↑ Dunnell 2023, p. 25; Atwood 2004, p. 278.
  15. ↑ Favereau 2021, p. 65; Biran 2012, p. 35; Atwood 2004, p. 278.
  16. ↑ May 2017, p. 162.
  17. ↑ Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 67–69; May 2022a, pp. 59–61; Broadbridge 2018, pp. 78–79.
  18. ↑ May 2017, p. 162; May 2022a, p. 61.
  19. ↑ Broadbridge 2018, pp. 230–231.
  20. ↑ Broadbridge 2018, pp. 229–232; Atwood 2004, p. 202.
  21. ↑ May 2018, pp. 302–304.
  22. ↑ Atwood 2004, pp. 98–99.
  23. ↑ Dunnell 2023, pp. 30–31.
  24. ↑ Biran 2012, p. 69; Favereau 2021, pp. 65–66; Favereau & Pochekaev 2023, p. 248.
  25. ↑ May 2022b, p. 138; Favereau & Pochekaev 2023, p. 248.
  26. ↑ Atwood 2004, p. 502; May 2018, pp. 44–45; May 2022b, p. 139.
  27. ↑ May 2018, p. 45; Favereau 2021, pp. 43–44.
  28. ↑ Atwood 2004, p. 278; Favereau 2021, pp. 46–47; Favereau & Pochekaev 2023, p. 248.
  29. ↑ Atwood 2017, pp. 44–45, 50.
  30. ↑ Favereau 2021, p. 48; Dunnell 2023, p. 35; Atwood 2004, p. 278; Atwood 2017, p. 36.
  31. ↑ Dunnell 2023, p. 38; May 2018, pp. 58–59.
  32. ↑ Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 116–118.
  33. ↑ Biran 2012, pp. 54–55.
  34. ↑ Atwood 2004, pp. 278, 416; Broadbridge 2018, p. 130; May 2018, p. 69; Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 125–126.
  35. ↑ Broadbridge 2018, p. 131; Dunnell 2023, p. 41; Favereau 2021, p. 63.
  36. ↑ Boyle 2007, p. 307; Dunnell 2023, p. 42; Biran 2012, p. 56.
  37. ↑ Barthold 1992, p. 414–416; Chambers 1979, p. 10; Favereau 2021, p. 61.
  38. ↑ Dunnell 2023, p. 44; Barthold 1992, p. 433.
  39. ↑ Atwood 2017, p. 51; Barthold 1992, pp. 434–437.
  40. ↑ Ratchnevsky 1991, p. 131; Atwood 2017, p. 51.
  41. ↑ Atwood 2017, pp. 52–53; Dunnell 2023, p. 44; Barthold 1992, p. 435; Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 136–137.
  42. ↑ Atwood 2017, pp. 53–54.
  43. ↑ Atwood 2017, p. 54.
  44. ↑ Favereau 2021, pp. 61–63; Favereau & Pochekaev 2023, p. 248.
  45. ↑ Dunnell 2023, p. 44, 47; Atwood 2004, p. 278.
  46. ↑ Barthold 1992, p. 455; Atwood 2004, p. 278.
  47. ↑ Atwood 2004, p. 278; Broadbridge 2018, p. 169.
  48. ↑ Dunnell 2023, p. 47; Favereau & Pochekaev 2023, pp. 248–249.
  49. ↑ Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 136–137; Favereau 2021, p. 76; Dafeng & Jianyi 1998, p. 290.
  50. ↑ Ratchnevsky 1991, p. 137; Biran 2012, p. 69; Barthold 1992, p. 458.
  51. ↑ Atwood 2004, p. 202; Favereau & Pochekaev 2023, p. 249.
  52. ↑ Atwood 2004, pp. 201–202.
  53. ↑ Panyushkina et al. 2022.

Bibliography

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.