List of classical music concerts with an unruly audience response

Last updated

Riots at the Royal Opera House, 1763 Artaxerxes riots.jpg
Riots at the Royal Opera House, 1763

There have been many notable instances of unruly behaviour at classical music concerts, often at the premiere of a new work or production. Audience members displayed unruly behavior for a variety of reasons.

Contents

18th century

ComposerTitleDateLocationDetails
Thomas Arne Artaxerxes February 24, 1763 London At the revival of Thomas Arne's opera Artaxerxes , a mob protesting the abolition of half-price admissions stormed the theatre in the middle of the performance. [1]

19th century

ComposerTitleDateLocationDetails
William Reeve Family Quarrels December 18, 1802LondonPart of the Jewish audience catcalled because of perceived anti-Jewish slights. The melody of one of the songs in this opera greatly resembled the sacred Jewish Kaddish prayer. [2]
Gioachino Rossini The Barber of Seville February 20, 1816 Milan Many audience members were supporters of the elder composer Giovanni Paisiello who had written a Barber of Seville of his own. They shouted, heckled, hissed, and jeered at Rossini's new version of the piece. [3]
Daniel Auber La muette de Portici August 25, 1830 Brussels Audience members at a performance in Brussels left before the end of the opera to join planned riots that were already taking place across the city, marking the beginning of the Belgian Revolution. [4]
Hector Berlioz Benvenuto Cellini September 10, 1838 Paris The audience hissed at most of the music after the first few numbers. [5]
Richard Wagner Tannhäuser March 14, 1861ParisThe audience was unruly for several reasons. Whistling and cat-calls occurred the night before, during the premiere of the "Paris version," in response to the music, like the shepherd's piping in Act I. Wagner also did not pay the claque's fee in order to prevent disruptions. The interruptions increased during the second performance, when the Jockey-Club de Paris organized a disruption in response to the opera's ballet being placed in the first act instead of the second, which was customary. The jockey members usually arrived in time for the second act in order to see the ballet, and did not take kindly to Wagner's dissent. [6]
Arrigo Boito Mefistofele March 5, 1868MilanThe audience came predisposed to drown out Boito's claqueurs and succeeded in making the music inaudible with their hisses and boos. [7] [8] [9]

20th century

ComposerTitleDateLocationDetails
Giacomo Puccini Madama Butterfly February 17, 1904MilanOne of the biggest flops in Italian opera history, the performance was met with jeers and boos throughout. Originally, the opera was split into only two acts, with no intermission during the overlong second act. Puccini, aiming for verismo, planted people with bird-whistles throughout the audience to accompany the Act 2 intermezzo. The already restless audience responded by making loud animal noises of their own. Puccini withdrew the opera the very next day and made several changes before re-debuting the opera three months later in Brescia to a much more favorable response. [10]
Richard Strauss Elektra March 12, 1910LondonDue to Strauss's already poor reputation, when he was brought on stage, he was met with screaming and fits of discontent. [11]
Francesco Balilla Pratella Musica FuturistaMarch 9, 1913 Rome At the second performance of the work, the audience booed and threw refuse at the orchestra, and some fighting occurred. [12] [13]
Alban Berg Altenberg Lieder March 31, 1913 Vienna As part of a front in Vienna's ongoing style wars, the audience booed and catcalled, and some punches were thrown. Berg's piece was highly expressionistic, which prompted the uproar after growing tension in the crowd. [14] The event came to be known as the Skandalkonzert. [15]
Igor Stravinsky The Rite of Spring May 29, 1913ParisDueling factions tried to drown each other out during the ballet's premiere, launching generations of exaggerations of what actually happened in the hall that night. [16] [17] [18]
Sergei Prokofiev Piano Concerto No. 2 September 5, 1913 St. Petersburg The work was met with hisses and catcalls. [19]
Luigi Russolo The Awakening of a City, The Meeting of Automobiles and AeroplanesApril 21, 1914MilanA concert organized by the Futurists to provide the first public demonstration of their experimental "noise-making" instruments called intonarumori resulted in an expected fracas, [20] with Futurists led by Filippo Tommaso Marinetti fighting members of the audience in the stalls. [21]
Erik Satie Parade May 18, 1917ParisOne faction of the audience booed, hissed, and was generally unruly, but they were eventually silenced by an enthusiastic ovation. [22] [23]
Anton Webern Five Movements for String Quartet, Op. 5 August 8, 1922 Salzburg Webern attended, interrupting his summer with Schoenberg, who remained in Traunkirchen. Webern praised the Amar Quartet's performance to Berg, but what unfolded left him "out of sorts" and disturbed his plans to continue composing that summer. The Moldenhauers described the "Salzburg affair" as "a riot ... subdued only by police intervention". Wilhelm Grosz constantly laughed, crying "'furchtbar!' [terrible]" during the fourth movement. Adolf Loos and Rudolf Ganz defended Webern. A London Daily Telegraph reporter wrote, "I never saw an angrier man" of Webern's taking the stage amid the fray, "as if he were going to kill". The Quartet was able to play the music in full to an invitation-only audience the next day. Arthur Bliss, Arthur Honegger, Francis Poulenc, and Jean Wiéner reassured Webern. [24]
Edgard Varèse Hyperprism March 4, 1923 New York The audience laughed throughout and hissed at the conclusion, which prompted Varèse to repeat the work in hopes of a more serious response. [25]
Rued Langgaard Symphony No. 6 September 26, 1923 Copenhagen Frejlif Olsen, editor of the Ekstra Bladet, reported what happened the day after: "The audience abandoned themselves to one surprise after the other; along the rows of seats tittering, hissing, the gnashing of teeth and suppressed 'goodgriefs' could be heard [...] some groaned, others spat, an elderly lady collapsed and had to be carried out, and when the piece had finally come to an end, a violent booing and hissing could be heard throughout the concert hall, offended shrieks and outbursts of laughter drowned out a half-hearted applause. Rud Langgaard failed to understand what was going on - he thought he was being called forward, he stood up there on stage and waved and bowed with a bouquet of flowers in one hand." [26] [27]
George Antheil Sonata SauvageOctober 4, 1923ParisVery raucous physical altercations and verbal fights broke out within three minutes of Antheil playing, with many distinguished guests in attendance. Artist Man Ray reportedly punched a man in the nose, Marcel Duchamp began hurling obscenities at a fellow audience member, and Erik Satie was heard shouting, "What precision! What precision!" [28]
Henry Cowell Antinomy October 15, 1923 Leipzig The audience threw program notes at Cowell and clambered onto the stage, leading to a large physical altercation and the arrest of over 20 audience members. [29]
Henry Cowell Five Encores to Dynamic Motion October 31, 1923ViennaAn audience member began screaming at Cowell, "Stop! Stop!" and would not be quiet when shushed by audience members, leading to an attempt to drown one other out with continuous catcalling. [30]
Erik Satie Mercure June 15, 1924ParisThe police were called to the premiere due to unruly behavior that sprang from the Parisian cultural infighting of the time. [31]
George Antheil Ballet Mécanique June 19, 1926ParisThe premiere performance received a large ovation despite some unruly behavior in the audience, including an outburst by Ezra Pound, but there were some fistfights in the street after the concert. [32]
Alban Berg Wozzeck November 11, 1926PragueMusicologist Brian S. Locke called the "Wozzeck Affair" the "most important event at the Czechs' National Theater in the interwar period". There Otakar Ostrčil gave Wozzeck its second premiere (after Erich Kleiber's in Berlin). The third evening's (Tuesday) performance was interrupted by a planned demonstration in the second act before the chorus of the sleeping soldiers. This eventually culminated in its cancellation amid dueling whistling and applause. Police ordered the audience, among them Berg, his wife Helene, and Alma Mahler, to exit. Tuesday evening performances were attended by wealthy or upper-middle-class subscribers. The political dimension of Berg's opera in this milieu and, moreover, in the context of burgeoning Czech fascism and anti-German sentiment has often been emphasized. Indeed, critics warred along political lines in the press. Authorities forbade more performances. [33]
Béla Bartók The Miraculous Mandarin November 27, 1926 Cologne The plot caused a commotion in the audience, which began leaving during the performance. [34]
Anton Webern String Trio, Op. 20 September 13, 1928 Siena At the beginning of the second movement, the Kolisch ensemble's 1928 ISCM festival performance in the Palazzo Chigi-Saracini was interrupted by unrest, including a call for Benito Mussolini's intervention and fist fights. [35]
Kurt Weill Rise and Fall of the City of Mahagonny March 9, 1930LeipzigOrganized bands of right-wing agitators planted themselves in the audience and created a large commotion, directed towards the opera's supposed anti-German sentiment. It was subsequently banned by the Nazis in 1933. [36] [37]
Igor Stravinsky Danses concertantes February 27, 1945ParisA group of students from Olivier Messiaen's class, including Serge Nigg and Pierre Boulez, protested noisily with police whistles against the neoclassical style of the compositions. [38]
Igor StravinskyFour Norwegian MoodsMarch 15, 1945ParisSame as above.
Pierre Boulez Polyphonie X October 6, 1951 Donaueschingen Musicologist Antoine Goléa, who attended the concert, recalled: "Those who experienced this Donaueschingen première will remember the scandal as long as they live. Shouts, caterwauling, and other animal noises were unleashed from one half of the hall in response to applause, foot-stamping and enthusiastic bravos from the other". [39] Boulez was unable to attend, but, after hearing a tape of the concert, decided to withdraw the piece. [39]
John Cage 4'33" 1952New YorkDuring the premiere of this piece, the audience grew agitated due to the complete silence. It consisted of three movements, and during the third movement audience members began to walk out of the performance. [40]
Edgard Varèse Déserts December 2, 1954ParisThe audience booed and jeered the piece. [41]
Richard Wagner Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg 1956 Bayreuth Festival Bayreuth A new interpretation of Die Meistersinger by Wagner's grandson Wieland Wagner removed elements associated with German nationalism and introduced a minimalist, modernist staging. Particularly controversial was the removal of scenery depicting Nuremberg – both the setting of the play and a city central to Nazi propaganda. The production was booed by the audience throughout the summer of 1956, beginning a tradition of booing at future Bayreuth Festivals. [42]
Luigi Nono Intolleranza 1960 April 13, 1961 Venice The opera's premiere was disrupted by shouts from a neo-fascist faction in the audience. [43] [44]
John Cage Atlas EclipticalisFebruary 6, 1964New YorkPart of an avant-garde season of music featuring the New York Philharmonic conducted by Leonard Bernstein, most performances had received lukewarm responses. This one, with Cage as performer, was met with boos and hisses. Allegedly, the orchestra failed to take the music seriously, and in so doing, effectively sabotaged it. The event was recorded, and released as part of a Bernstein retrospective set. [45] [46]
Hans Werner Henze Das Floß der Medusa December 9, 1968 Hamburg Students hung a Che Guevara banner, the Red, and Black flags, and after the chorus responded in protest, the police began making arrests, prompting Henze to cancel the concert. [47]
Steve Reich Four Organs January 18, 1973New YorkAt a Carnegie Hall performance of the work, the conservative audience tried yelling and sarcastically applauding to hasten the end of the piece, which received both boos and cheers during the ovation. [48] One of the performers, Michael Tilson Thomas, recalls: "One woman walked down the aisle and repeatedly banged her head on the front of the stage, wailing 'Stop, stop, I confess.'" [49] [50]
Richard Wagner Tristan und Isolde 1981 Tel Aviv, Israel Disturbances broke out within the Mann Auditorium in Tel Aviv as Conductor Zubin Mehta led the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra with music by Richard Wagner. By tradition, Wager's work had been banned by the Israeli orchestra since 1939 because of his anti-Semitic beliefs and the Nazi glorification of his music. Arguments broke out during and after the concert, with security guards wrestling protesters. Three musicians left their desks by prearrangement with the conductor. [51]
John Adams Grand Pianola Music 1982New YorkPremiere of the piece at the Horizons Festival, held at Lincoln Center, New York. Audience was booing and cheering. [52]
Harrison Birtwistle Panic 1995LondonBBC received thousands of complaints after its broadcast to millions during the Last Night of the Proms [53]

21st century

ComposerTitleDateLocationDetails
Giuseppe Verdi Aida December 10, 2006MilanWhen tenor Roberto Alagna's opening aria "Celeste Aida" was booed by the loggionisti in the opera house's less expensive seats, he walked off stage while the music was still playing. Understudy Antonello Palombi, in a black dress shirt and slacks, came on a few seconds later to replace him. Alagna did not return to the production. [54]
Steve Reich Piano Phase February 29, 2016CologneDuring a performance of the piece by Iranian harpsichordist Mahan Esfahani in the Kölner Philharmonie, parts of the crowd clapped, whistled, and walked out. Esfahani, as he introduced the piece in English, had been ordered by a heckler to speak in German. Loud arguments between numerous members of the crowd persisted for several minutes; Esfahani stopped his performance and started playing a concerto by C. P. E. Bach instead. He attributed the 'pandemonium' to the choice of a modern composition, while the German media inferred a xenophobic motive. [55]
Giacomo Puccini Tosca January 4, 2023BarcelonaThe controversy primarily stemmed from the unconventional staging of the opera at the Gran Teatre del Liceu. The production featured Mario Cavaradossi as an alter ego of Italian film director Pier Paolo Pasolini, who was murdered in 1975, trying to draw parallels between them as artists seen inconvenient to religious and political powers. Controversial scenes included many references to sexual violence and an invented scene of homosexual prostitution between Pasolini and his alleged killer while the song "Love in Portofino" played in the background. All this was met with substantial booing from the audience. [56] [57]

See also

References

  1. ↑ The Gentleman's Magazine , February 1763, vol. XXXIII, p. 97 – via HathiTrust
  2. ↑ Chancellor, V. E. (2002). "Anti-Racialism or Censorship? The 1802 Jewish Riots at Covent Garden Opera and the Career of Thomas John Dibdin". The Opera Quarterly . 18 (1): 18–25. doi:10.1093/oq/18.1.18. S2CID   191511631.
  3. ↑ Osborne, Richard (2007). Rossini: His Life and Works. Oxford University Press. pp. 38–41. ISBN   978-0-19-518129-6.
  4. ↑ Slatin, Sonia (1979). "Opera and revolution: La Muette de Portici and the Belgian revolution of 1830 revisited". Journal of Musicological Research. 3 (1–2): 45–62 [53–54]. doi:10.1080/01411897908574506.
  5. ↑ Wasselin, Christian, "Benvenuto Cellini" on the Hector Berlioz website for a more detailed inside story of the opera
  6. ↑ Wagner, Tannhäuser & the Jockey Club Claque
  7. ↑ Halperson, Maurice. "The Romance of Music, 56", Musical America , September 8, 1917.
  8. ↑ Nicolaisen, Jay (1978). "The First Mefistofele". 19th-Century Music . 1 (3): 221–232 [221–222]. doi:10.2307/746412. JSTOR   746412.
  9. ↑ Kennedy, Michael; Kennedy, Joyce; Rutherford-Johnson, Tim, eds. (2013). "Boito, Arrigo". The Oxford Dictionary of Music. Oxford University Press. p. 99. ISBN   978-0-19-957854-2.
  10. ↑ Arruga, Lorenzo (1976). La Scala. New York: Prager. ISBN   978-0-275-53680-0.
  11. ↑ Ashley, Tim (2003-03-21). "Elektra complex". The Guardian.
  12. ↑ Payton, Rodney J. (1976). "The Music of Futurism: Concerts and Polemics". The Musical Quarterly . 62 (1): 25–45. doi:10.1093/mq/LXII.1.25. JSTOR   741598.
  13. ↑ Music of the Twentieth-century Avant-garde: A Biocritical Sourcebook. Greenwood Publishing Group. 2002. p. 415. ISBN   9780313296895.
  14. ↑ Service, Tom (2014-12-02). "10 of the best: Musical riots". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 2024-05-08.
  15. ↑ Barker, Andrew (1997). "Battles of the Mind: Berg and the Cultural Politics of 'Vienna 1900'", The Cambridge Companion to Berg , p. 24. Pople, Anthony, ed. ISBN   0-521-56489-1.
  16. ↑ Bullard, Truman (1971). The first performance of Igor Stravinsky's Sacre du printemps. Ann Arbor, Michigan: Ann Arbor University (microfilm copy). OCLC   937514.
  17. ↑ Pieter C. van den Toorn, Stravinsky and The Rite of Spring, Chapter 1: Point of Order
  18. ↑ 100 Years After The Riot, The 'Rite' Remains : Deceptive Cadence : NPR
  19. ↑ Steinberg, Michael. "Program notes Archived 2016-06-05 at the Wayback Machine ", San Francisco Symphony.
  20. ↑ Nice, James. "Music Futurista: The Art of Noises". www.ltmrecordings.com. Retrieved 3 September 2016.
  21. ↑ Thorn, Benjamin (2002). "Luigi Russolo (1885-1947)". In Larry Sitsky (ed.). Music of the Twentieth-century Avant-garde: A Biocritical Sourcebook. Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 415. ISBN   978-0-313-29689-5.
  22. ↑ Peterkin, Norman (1919). "Erik Satie's 'Parade'". The Musical Times . 60 (918): 426–427 [426]. doi:10.2307/3701903. JSTOR   3701903.
  23. ↑ "Springtime in Paris: Erik Satie". Music.minnesota.publicradio.org. 2000-03-01. Retrieved 2014-01-14.
  24. ↑ Moldenhauer, Hans and Rosaleen Moldenhauer (1978). Anton von Webern: A Chronicle of His Life and Work. London: Victor Gollancz Ltd. ISBN   978-0-394-47237-9. pp. 248–249, 663.
  25. ↑ "Taxi Toots Sound Sweet After Music By Composers Guild: Many Hisses Greet Conclusion of 'Hyperprism'; Dissenters Told to Leave and Piece Is Played Over Again", New-York Tribune , March 5, 1923.
  26. ↑ Viinholt Nielsen, Bendt (November 2016). "Langgaard SYMPHONY No 6". issuu.com. Wise Music Classical. pp. 6–8. Retrieved 2 May 2025.
  27. ↑ Giannini, Juri, ed. (2 April 2021). Rued Langgaard. Perspektiven[Rued Langgaard. Perspectives]. Musikkontext (in German). Vol. 15. Vienna, Austria: Hollitzer Wissenschaftsverlag. p. 171. ISBN   978-3-99012-598-4.
  28. ↑ Rischitelli, p. 40[ full citation needed ]
  29. ↑ Rischitelli (2005), p. 26.[ full citation needed ]
  30. ↑ Sachs, p. 117[ full citation needed ]
  31. ↑ Orledge, Robert (1998). "Erik Satie's Ballet Mercure (1924): From Mount Etna to Montmartre". Journal of the Royal Musical Association . 123 (2): 229–249. doi:10.1093/jrma/123.2.229. JSTOR   766416.
  32. ↑ Key, Susan, Larry Rothe, and Thomas M. Tilson. American Mavericks . San Francisco, California: San Francisco Symphony, 2001.
  33. ↑ Locke, Brian S. (2008). "The "Wozzeck Affair": Modernism and the Crisis of Audience in Prague". The Journal of Musicological Research. 27: 63–98. doi:10.1080/01411890701804788.
  34. ↑ Vinton, John (January 1964). "The Case of the Miraculous Mandarin". The Musical Quarterly . 50 (1): 13. doi:10.1093/mq/L.1.1.
  35. ↑ Moldenhauer, Hans and Rosaleen Moldenhauer (1978). Anton von Webern: A Chronicle of His Life and Work. London: Victor Gollancz Ltd. ISBN   978-0-394-47237-9. pp. 323–324.
  36. ↑ Scott, Bruce (10 December 2010). "Decadence and Decay: Kurt Weill's Mahagonny". NPR .
  37. ↑ Drew, David (January 1963). "The History of Mahahonny". The Musical Times . 184 (1439): 18–24. doi:10.2307/951087. JSTOR   951087.
  38. ↑ Sprout, Leslie A. (Winter 2009). "The 1945 Stravinsky Debates: Nigg, Messiaen, and the Early Cold War in France". The Journal of Musicology . 26 (1): 86. doi:10.1525/jm.2009.26.1.85.
  39. 1 2 Jameux, Dominique (1991). Pierre Boulez . Translated by Susan Bradshaw. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. pp. 47–48. ISBN   0-674-66740-9.
  40. ↑ "Five classical music controversies". www.bbc.com. 14 April 2015. Retrieved 2024-05-08.
  41. ↑ Mattis, Olivia (1992). "Varèse's Multimedia Conception of Déserts". The Musical Quarterly. 76 (4): 557–583 [557]. doi:10.1093/mq/76.4.557.
  42. ↑ "Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg". Wagner Operas. Retrieved 29 August 2023.
  43. ↑ Boyden, Matthew, and Nick Kimberly. The Rough Guide to Opera , Rough Guides, 2002, p. 550.
  44. ↑ "Luigi Nono". Encyclopædia Britannica Online. 2014. Retrieved 28 March 2014.
  45. ↑ John Cage, Antonin Becvar, and Leonard Bernstein Walk into a Bar, greg.org
  46. ↑ Cage: Atlas Eclipticalis (audio) on YouTube, New York Philharmonic, Leonard Bernstein; Bernstein's introduction to Cage starts at 9:00 minutes.
  47. ↑ Ernst Schnabel, "Zum Untergang einer Uraufführung" and "Postscriptum nach dreiunddreissig Tagen", in Hans Werner Henze and Ernst Schnabel, Das Floss der Medusa: Text zum Oratorium, 47–61 & 65–79 (Munich: Piper-Verlag, 1969);
    Andrew Porter, "Henze: The Raft of the Frigate 'Medusa' – Oratorio" [record review of DGG 139428-9], Gramophone 47, no. 563 (April 1970): 1625;
    Anon. "Affären/Henze: Sie bleibt", Der Spiegel 22, no. 51 (16 December 1968): 152. (in German)
  48. ↑ Schonberg, Harold. "Music: A Concert Fuss: Piece by Reich Draws a Vocal Reaction" The New York Times , January 20, 1973.
  49. ↑ Essay, Michael Tilson Thomas, 1997
  50. ↑ "Steve Reich: the composer with his finger on the pulse" by David Shariatmadari, The Guardian , 26 October 2016
  51. ↑ Moshe Brilliant (1981-10-17). "Playing of Wagner in Israel Provokes Disturbance". New York Times. Retrieved 2025-06-17.
  52. ↑ Frank J. Oteri (2001-01-01). "John Adams: In The Center Of American Music". NewMusicBox. Retrieved 2020-01-26.
  53. ↑ Fisher, Neil (3 May 2014). "Birtwistle at 80: the man who brought Panic to the Proms". The Times . Retrieved 7 March 2019.
  54. ↑ Wakin, Daniel J. (December 13, 2006). "After La Scala Boos, a Tenor Boos Back". The New York Times . Retrieved January 31, 2018.
  55. ↑ Lizzie Dearden (2016-03-03). "Iranian musician forced to stop Cologne concert after audience members jeer and shout 'speak German'". The Independent. Retrieved 2018-10-28.
  56. ↑ "Pasolini, Character From Tosca at the Liceu (Column) | Opera Online - The opera lovers web site". www.opera-online.com. Retrieved 2024-01-16.
  57. ↑ Parera, Xavier (2023-01-16). "BARCELONA / Una polémica y fallida 'Tosca' abre el año en el Liceu". Scherzo (in Spanish). Retrieved 2024-01-16.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.