Rothschild loans to the Holy See

Pope Gregory XVI oversaw the loan deal between the Rothschild family and the Holy See in 1832.

Rothschild loans to the Holy See refers to a series of major financial loans arranged between the Rothschild family and the Holy See of the Catholic Church. The first loan, which occurred in 1832, took place in the aftermath of the Napoleonic Wars during the pontificate of Pope Gregory XVI (involving James Mayer de Rothschild and Carl Mayer von Rothschild). This loan agreed on was for a sum of £400,000 (equivalent to £4.7 billion in 2023). A second loan occurred during the pontificate of Pope Pius IX in the early 1850s with the same members of the Rothschild family, after the collapse of Giuseppe Mazzini's short-lived revolutionary Roman Republic and the restoration of the Papal States.

1832 loan under Pope Gregory XVI

Background

In the aftermath of the Napoleonic Wars, there was a return to the politics of throne and altar in Europe. Around this time, the Rothschild family of Jewish bankers from Frankfurt had arisen to a position of prominence as bankers. Scions of this family established themselves in several European power centers, including in Catholic countries, such as in Vienna in the Austrian Empire of Klemens von Metternich (for whom the Age of Metternich is named), and in Naples ruled by the Bourbon-Two Sicilies monarchy. One of the states to which sovereignty was restored by the Congress of Vienna was the Papal States, temporal domain of the Holy See. However, in the years following restoration, the finances of the Holy See declined. ^[1]

James Mayer de Rothschild negotiated the specific terms of the loan deal with Alessandro Torlonia.

In 1831, Cardinal Bartolomeo Cappellari was elected Pope Gregory XVI. The Rothschilds were considered reliable in conservative circles in Europe, because they had worked with the Austrian government to stabilize finances after the Napoleonic Wars. They also shored up the Bourbons in the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies, which bordered the Papal States, by helping finance their suppression of two attempted revolutions. ^[2] That year there were rumours that Rome would reach out to the Rothschild family for a loan; the brothers James and Carl were initially wary, but both Austria (Metternich and Count Appony) and France (Casimir Pierre Périer and Horace François Bastien Sébastiani de La Porta) pressed the issue for Rome. ^[3] Initially, there was some resistance during the negotiations, particularly from the Roman government and Monsignor Antonio Garibaldi at Paris. However, Alessandro Torlonia (acting for the Holy See) held direct negotiations with James Mayer de Rothschild and thrashed out an agreement, signed on 30 November 1831. Thus in 1832 the Rothschilds’ agreement to provide a loan to the Holy See for £400,000 (equivalent to £4.7 billion in 2023) came into force. ^[2]

James Mayer de Rothschild, head of the French Banque Rothschild, became the official Papal banker. ^[2] His Naples-based brother, Carl Mayer von Rothschild, geographically closer to Rome, went to meet with Pope Gregory XVI in January 1832. Here Carl Mayer was presented with the ribbon and star of the Sacred Military Constantinian Order of Saint George. It was customary for Catholics to show reverence for him whom they regarded as the Vicar of Christ, to kiss the Pope's feet when meeting him. As a Jew, Carl Mayer von Rothschild was permitted to simply kiss the ring on his hand instead. ^[2] This outraged Catholic critics of the deal at the time. It even garnered a reference centuries later, by Philippe de Rothschild, a direct descendant of James and Carl, in his autobiography Milady Vine (1984).

This loan agreed on was for a sum of £400,000 (equivalent to £3.7 billion in 2019). A second loan occurred during the Pontificate of Pope Pius IX ("Pio Nono") in the early 1850s with the same members of the Rothschild family after the collapse of Giuseppe Mazzini's short-lived revolutionary Roman Republic and the restoration of the Papal States.

Reactions

Reports of the transaction led to stinging criticisms of Pope Gregory XVI in the Christian (in particular, Catholic) world, almost all of which circulated around the Jewishness of the Rothschilds. The French romantic poet Alfred de Vigny said "a Jew now reigns over the Pope and Christianity. He pays monarchs and buys nations." ^[2] Ludwig Börne, a Jewish convert to Lutheranism and member of the Young Germany movement stated, "A wealthy Jew kisses his hand, while a poor Christian kisses the Pope's feet. The Rothschilds are assuredly nobler than their ancestor Judas Iscariot. He sold Christ for 30 small pieces of silver: the Rothschilds would buy Him, if He were for sale." ^[2] Another prominent example, is the mention of the loan in a sonnet of Giuseppe Gioachino Belli, Er motivio de li guai. While Belli found the Rothschilds highly objectionable, for him the Pope was even worse as a weak man who had "sold both Rome and the State" and was thus no longer worthy of wearing the Papal robes. ^[4]

Cardinal Tosti

Cardinal Antonio Tosti attempted to convert the debt with six Parisian banks who were rivals to the Rothschilds.

Pope Gregory XVI appointed Cardinal Antonio Tosti as the new Papal Treasurer (also known as the Apostolic Camera) at Rome in July 1834. Considering stock market conditions and a recent Rothschild offer to Egypt to refinance its debt, Tosti attempted to refinance the debt in more favorable terms; Rothschild opposed such an early refinance, fearing losses to his own bank and disrepute to Vatican bond issuances. ^[5]

As part of a plan to gain better conditions, Tosti reached out to a number of banking firms in Paris active on the Paris Bourse, who stood in a position of competition with the Rothschilds, due to their self-interested business opposition to a Rothschild monopoly of the financial sector. ^[6] Although the Hungarian-Jewish writer Ignatius Balla in his 1913 book The Romance of the Rothschilds later attributed Cardinal Tosti's motivation to "no doubt sectarian reasons," ^[7] the six rival banks were themselves mostly Protestant or Swiss, but also some Jewish. They included; Banque J. Hagerman, Banque André & Cottier, Banque Fould-Oppenheim & Cie, Banque J. A. Blanc, Colin et Compagnie, Banque Gabriel Odier & Compagnie and Banque Wells & Compagnie. ^{[6] [8]}

The leading element among these interests who were rivals to the Rothschilds on the Paris Bourse, Jonas-Philip Hagerman, a Swedish Lutheran who previously had a bank at Genoa, had already achieved a similar feat of helping attain for the Kingdom of Sardinia a French government loan, which gifted the deal to the six banks, side-stepping the Rothschilds. ^[8] The Rothschilds who until then had considered themselves unassailable, had retaliated by procuring a fall on Parisian government bonds which brought the Sardinian bonds lower than contracted for. Although this counter-attack damaged the Rothschilds rivals, when Cardinal Tosti floated the idea of Roman bonds, the Banque André & Cottier and others were keen to advance on it and sent the Livorno merchant Vincent Nolte to confirm their interest. ^[9]

All of this had been done in a discreet manner, without the Rothschilds being informed. But when agents of the Rothschild banking family of Naples had learned that an agent of the "six banks" of Paris, had been in Rome, their suspicions were heightened. ^[10] After learning about the situation, Carl Mayer von Rothschild set out to Rome to find out the truth about the matter from Cardinal Tosti. ^[11] While there he produced a copy of the original 5% contract, signed by Rothschild and Torlonia (before Tosti had been involved with Papal finance) which contained an until now secret condition; ^[11] the Holy See may not approach any other firm for a new loan without first informing the Rothschilds and giving them preference if it offered equal conditions to its competition. ^[12] The six Parisian firms at first considered trying to offer such conditions that, if the Rothschilds tried to match it then it would damage their own interests; however, in the end, the two sides reconciled and went in on the new loan terms together. ^[13]

Catholic–Jewish relations

Prince Metternich worked closely with the Rothschilds and liaised with Pope Gregory XVI on issues such as the Ancona Jews on their behalf.

Whether the loan had any significant effect on the relationship between Catholicism and Judaism is debated. Despite his approval of the loan across religious lines, Pope Gregory XVI was opposed to what he called religious indifferentism and upheld Catholic orthodoxy in such matters in encyclicals such as Mirari vos . ^[14] Through Austrian Chancellor Klemens von Metternich working as an intermediary, ^[15] the Rothschilds asked the Pope for a number of concessions towards Jews living in the Papal dominions, ^[16] such as the Ancona Jews.

See also

• Paris Bourse crash of 1882
• Chemins de Fer du Nord
• Cardinal Giacomo Antonelli
• André Langrand-Dumonceau
• Edward Charles Blount

References

1. Gerald Posner (2015). "[2] The Last Pope King". God's Bankers: A History of Money and Power at the Vatican. Simon and Schuster. p. 12. ISBN   978-1416576570 . Retrieved 3 August 2019. The economy stagnated, and over decades tax revenues steadily declined. By the time Gregory XVI, the son of a lawyer, became pope in 1831, the situation was so dire [...]
2. Posner 2015 , p. 12.
3. Felisini 2017 , p. 88.
4. Feinstein 2003 , p. 151.
5. Felisini 2017 , pp. 109–110: "Encouraged by the positive movement of stock market quotations for the Roman bonds, as well as by a comparison with conditions offered by the Rothschilds to other countries (i.e. Egypt, ruled by Muhammad Ali) [...] Rothschild stated his firm opposition, fearing the losses that this operation would bring to the Maison, but perhaps also concerned about disaffection on the part of investors. The idea of a conversion such a short time after the issue might have made subscribers fearful, driving them away from the Roman bonds"
6. Reeves 1887 , p.  266.
7. Balla 1913 , p.  224.
8. Nolte 1854 , p.  391.
9. Nolte 1854 , p.  392.
10. Nolte 1854 , p.  393.
11. Balla 1913 , p.  228.
12. Balla 1913 , p.  229.
13. Balla 1913 , p.  230.
14. Felisini 2017 , p. 94.
15. Kertzer 2003 , p. 79.
16. Gerald Posner (2015). God's Bankers: A History of Money and Power at the Vatican. Simon and Schuster. p. 15. ISBN   9781416576594 . Retrieved 7 August 2019. the Rothschilds tried leveraging their influence to beseech the Holy See to improve conditions for the fifteen thousands Jews in the Papal States [57]. They asked that the Pope cancel extra taxes levied solely on Jews, the prohibition on taking property from the ghetto, and the ban on working on professions, and that he abolish onerous evidentiary standards that put them at tremendous disadvantage in court cases

Bibliography

• Balla, Igantius (1913). The Romance of the Rothschilds. E. Nash. ISBN   978-1331118770.
• Berry, Jason (2012). Render Unto Rome: The Secret Life of Money in the Catholic Church. Broadway Books. ISBN   978-0385531344.
• Corti, Egon Caesar (1928). The Rise of the House of Rothschild. Insel-Verlag. ISBN   978-1482385991.
• Cowles, Virginia (1973). The Rothschilds: A Family of Fortune. Knopf. ISBN   978-0394487731.
• Feinstein, Wiley (2003). The Civilization of the Holocaust in Italy: Poets, Artists, Saints, Anti-semites. Fairleigh Dickinson Univ Press. ISBN   978-0838639887.
• Felisini, Daniela (1990). Le finanze pontificie e i Rothschild. 1830-1870. Facoltà di Economia dei Trasporti e del Commercio Internazionale, Istituto Universitario Navale. ISBN   978-8871043265.
• Felisini, Daniela (2017). Alessandro Torlonia: The Pope's Banker. Springer. ISBN   978-3319419985.
• Ferguson, Niall (1998). The House of Rothschild: Money's prophets, 1798-1848. Viking. ISBN   978-0670857685.
• Johnstone, Robert Matteson (1901). The Roman Theocracy and the Republic, 1846-1849. Macmillan.
• Kertzer, David I (2003). Unholy War: The Vatican's Role in the Rise of Modern Anti-semitism. Pan Macmillan. ISBN   978-0330390491.
• Lottman, Herbert R. (1995). Return of the Rothschilds: The Great Banking Dynasty Through Two Turbulent Centuries. I. B. Tauris. ISBN   978-1850439141.
• Nolte, Vincent (1854). Fifty Years in Both Hemispheres: Or, Reminiscences of the Life of a Former Merchant. Redfield.
• Pollard, John F. (2008). Money and the Rise of the Modern Papacy: Financing the Vatican, 1850-1950. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0521092111.
• Posner, Gerald (2015). God's Bankers: A History of Money and Power at the Vatican. Simon and Schuster. ISBN   978-1416576570.
• Reeves, John (1887). The Rothschilds: The Financial Rulers of Nations. A. C. McClueg & Co. ISBN   978-1428621732.
• de Rothschild, Philippe (1984). Milady Vine: The Autobiography of Philippe de Rothschild. Cape. ISBN   978-0224022088.