Speaking truth to power

Last updated

Mahatma Gandhi spoke truth to power using non-violent tactics Mahatma-Gandhi, studio, 1931.jpg
Mahatma Gandhi spoke truth to power using non-violent tactics

Speaking truth to power is a non-violent political tactic, employed by dissidents against the received wisdom or propaganda of governments they regard as oppressive, authoritarian or an ideocracy. The phrase originated with a pamphlet, Speak Truth to Power: a Quaker Search for an Alternative to Violence , published by the American Friends Service Committee in 1955. Speak Truth To Power is also the title of a global human rights initiative under the auspices of Robert F. Kennedy Human Rights. Practitioners who have campaigned for a more just and truthful world have included Apollonius of Tyana, Vaclav Havel, [1] Nelson Mandela, Archbishop Desmond Tutu, Mahatma Gandhi, Bacha Khan, and the Dalai Lama. [2]

Contents

History of the concept

In classical Greece, "speaking truth to power" was known as parrhesia . The tactic is similar to satyagraha (literally, "truth-force") which Mahatma Gandhi used in the Indian independence movement to bring an end to the British colonial regime in India. [3]

Historian Clayborne Carson attributes the popularizing of the phrase in America to civil rights organizer and peace activist Bayard Rustin, and said that he adapted it in the early 1940s from a saying of Muhammad. [4] [5] Rustin adapted and condensed this concept as part of co-writing the pamphlet Speak Truth to Power: a Quaker Search for an Alternative to Violence which was published in 1955 [6] . [7]

In 1970, Albert O. Hirschman wrote that subordinates have three options: Exit, Voice, and Loyalty. [8] [9] However, according to Michel Foucault, only the courageous may pursue the truth-to-power course, as they risk losing their friends (as Winston Churchill did in the 1930s [10] ), their liberty, even their lives (as Liu Xiaobo did [11] ). [12]

Noam Chomsky is dismissive of "speaking truth to power". He asserts: "power knows the truth already, and is busy concealing it". It is the oppressed who need to hear the truth, not the oppressors. [13] Chomsky's belief that we must speak 'truth to the powerless' inspired a six-part docuseries on Canadian foreign policy of the same name, released in 2022, in which he also took part. [14]

Examples

Alexander Solzhenitsyn [15] and Andrei Sakharov [16] are among those who suffered for speaking out against the USSR. In 1936, Japanese finance minister Takahashi Korekiyo was assassinated after suggesting that Japan could not afford its planned military buildup. [17] Dietrich Bonhoeffer in Nazi Germany, and Martin Luther King Jr. in the US, were people who lost their lives for speaking truth to power. [18]

Ex-GCHQ employee Katharine Gun was charged under the UK Official Secrets Act 1989 with leaking a request by the United States for compromising intelligence on United Nations delegates prior to the Iraq invasion of 2003. Together with Daniel Ellsberg, Coleen Rowley and Sibel Edmonds, she set up the Truth-telling Coalition to encourage more of their former colleagues to 'tell truth to power'. [19] [20]

In education

The reverend Nick Mercer, an assistant chaplain at Sherborne School, believes that human rights and morality should be taught in all schools. Mercer, who gave evidence on mistreatment of detainees in Iraq, once served as a military lawyer. [21]

According to Vaclav Havel, politics should not be ignored because it attracts bad people. It follows that politics requires people of exceptional purity, higher sensitivity, taste, tact and responsibility. "Those who say that politics is disreputable help make it so... Those who claim that politics is a dirty business are lying to us." [22]

Michel Foucault spoke and wrote about power [23] and oppression [24] by examining how "technologies of power and knowledge have, since antiquity, intertwined and developed in concrete and historical frameworks". [25]

Paulo Freire in his seminal work Pedagogy of the Oppressed explains how "oppression has been justified and how it is reproduced through a mutual process between the "oppressor" and the "oppressed" (oppressors–oppressed distinction). Freire admits that the powerless in society can be frightened of freedom. He writes, "Freedom is acquired by conquest, not by gift. It must be pursued constantly and responsibly. Freedom is not an ideal located outside of man; nor is it an idea which becomes myth. It is rather the indispensable condition for the quest for human completion". According to Freire, freedom will be the result of praxis—informed action—when a balance between theory and practice is achieved". [26]

Books

Anita Hill's book Speaking Truth to Power (1998), is a candid autobiography in which Hill reflects on her experience of testifying at the 1991 Clarence Thomas Supreme Court nomination hearings, gives details on her earlier professional relationship with Clarence Thomas, and explains her motivation for going public with her sexual harassment accusations against Thomas. [27]

Kerry Kennedy's book Speak Truth To Power: Human Rights Defenders Who Are Changing Our World (1st edition 2000), with photographs by Eddie Adams, features interviews with dedicated human rights campaigners including: José Ramos-Horta from East Timor, Dianna Ortiz of Guatemala, Baltasar Garzón of Spain and Desmond Tutu of South Africa. [28]

Films

The story of Sophie Scholl and the White Rose non-violent, intellectual resistance group in the Third Reich has been filmed four times, including Die Weiße Rose (1982), [29] and Sophie Scholl: The Final Days (2005). [30]

Richard Attenborough's film Gandhi (1982) was a worldwide success, despite one Hollywood mogul's opinion that the central character was a "little brown man in a sheet whom nobody wants to see." [31]

More recent films exemplifying speaking truth to power include the biopic Snowden (2016), about the whistleblower Edward Snowden, and Official Secrets (2019), about the story of Katharine Gun.

Television

The phrase "truth to power" is often used in the HBO series The Wire . [32] For example, for a reality check, politician Tommy Carcetti frequently asks his trusted advisor Norman Wilson to speak "truth to power" [33] (e.g., in season 5, episode 1). [34]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Discourse</span> Field of theory which examines elements of conversation

Discourse is a generalization of the notion of a conversation to any form of communication. Discourse is a major topic in social theory, with work spanning fields such as sociology, anthropology, continental philosophy, and discourse analysis. Following pioneering work by Michel Foucault, these fields view discourse as a system of thought, knowledge, or communication that constructs our experience of the world. Since control of discourse amounts to control of how the world is perceived, social theory often studies discourse as a window into power. Within theoretical linguistics, discourse is understood more narrowly as linguistic information exchange and was one of the major motivations for the framework of dynamic semantics, in which expressions' denotations are equated with their ability to update a discourse context.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michel Foucault</span> French philosopher (1926–1984)

Paul-Michel Foucault was a French philosopher, historian of ideas, writer, political activist, and literary critic. Foucault's theories primarily address the relationships between power and knowledge, and how they are used as a form of social control through societal institutions. Though often cited as a structuralist and postmodernist, Foucault rejected these labels. His thought has influenced academics, especially those working in communication studies, anthropology, psychology, sociology, criminology, cultural studies, literary theory, feminism, Marxism and critical theory.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Václav Havel</span> First president of the Czech Republic (1936–2011)

Václav Havel was a Czech statesman, author, poet, playwright and dissident. Havel served as the last president of Czechoslovakia from 1989 until 1992, prior to the dissolution of Czechoslovakia on 31 December, before he became the first president of the Czech Republic from 1993 to 2003. He was the first democratically elected president of either country after the fall of communism. As a writer of Czech literature, he is known for his plays, essays and memoirs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Honesty</span> Moral quality of truthfulness

Honesty or truthfulness is a facet of moral character that connotes positive and virtuous attributes such as integrity, truthfulness, straightforwardness, along with the absence of lying, cheating, theft, etc. Honesty also involves being trustworthy, loyal, fair, and sincere.

Critique is a method of disciplined, systematic study of a written or oral discourse. Although critique is commonly understood as fault finding and negative judgment, it can also involve merit recognition, and in the philosophical tradition it also means a methodical practice of doubt. The contemporary sense of critique has been largely influenced by the Enlightenment critique of prejudice and authority, which championed the emancipation and autonomy from religious and political authorities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paulo Freire</span> Brazilian educator (1921–1997)

Paulo Reglus Neves Freire was a Brazilian educator and philosopher who was a leading advocate of critical pedagogy. His influential work Pedagogy of the Oppressed is generally considered one of the foundational texts of the critical pedagogy movement, and was the third most cited book in the social sciences as of 2016 according to Google Scholar.

In philosophy, episteme is knowledge or understanding. The term epistemology is derived from episteme.

Critical pedagogy is a philosophy of education and social movement that developed and applied concepts from critical theory and related traditions to the field of education and the study of culture.

Biopower is a term which relates to the practice of modern nation states and their regulation of their subjects through "an explosion of numerous and diverse techniques for achieving the subjugations of bodies and the control of populations". It was coined by French social theorist Michel Foucault. Foucault first used the term in his lecture courses at the Collège de France, and the term first appeared in print in The Will to Knowledge, Foucault's first volume of The History of Sexuality. In Foucault's work, it has been used to refer to practices of public health, regulation of heredity, and risk regulation, among many other regulatory mechanisms often linked less directly with literal physical health. It is closely related to a term he uses much less frequently, but which subsequent thinkers have taken up independently, biopolitics, which aligns more closely with the examination of the strategies and mechanisms through which human life processes are managed under regimes of authority over knowledge, power, and the processes of subjectivation.

In social justice theory, internalized oppression is a recognized understanding in which an oppressed group accepts the methods and incorporates the oppressive message of the oppressing group against their own best interest. Rosenwasser (2002) defines it as believing, adopting, accepting, and incorporating the negative beliefs provided by the oppressor as the truth.

In rhetoric, parrhesia is candid speech, speaking freely. It implies not only freedom of speech, but the obligation to speak the truth for the common good, even at personal risk.

Critical literacy is the ability to find embedded discrimination in media. This is done by analyzing the messages promoting prejudiced power relationships found naturally in media and written material that go unnoticed otherwise by reading beyond the author's words and examining the manner in which the author has conveyed their ideas about society's norms to determine whether these ideas contain racial or gender inequality.

<i>Pedagogy of the Oppressed</i> Book by Paulo Freire

Pedagogy of the Oppressed is a book by Brazilian educator Paulo Freire, written in Portuguese between 1967 and 1968, but published first in Spanish in 1968. An English translation was published in 1970, with the Portuguese original being published in 1972 in Portugal, and then again in Brazil in 1974. The book is considered one of the foundational texts of critical pedagogy, and proposes a pedagogy with a new relationship between teacher, student, and society.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Human Rights Foundation</span> Human rights non-government organisation

The Human Rights Foundation (HRF) is a non-profit organization that focuses on promoting and protecting human rights globally, with an emphasis on closed societies. HRF organizes the Oslo Freedom Forum. The Human Rights Foundation was founded in 2005 by Thor Halvorssen Mendoza, a Venezuelan film producer and human rights advocate. The current chairman is Russian chess grandmaster Garry Kasparov, and Javier El-Hage is the current chief legal officer. The foundation's head office is in the Empire State Building in New York City.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Liu Xiaobo</span> Chinese human rights activist (1955–2017)

Liu Xiaobo was a Chinese literary critic, human rights activist, philosopher and Nobel Peace Prize laureate who called for political reforms and was involved in campaigns to end communist one-party rule in China. He was arrested numerous times, and was described as China's most prominent dissident and the country's most famous political prisoner. On 26 June 2017, he was granted medical parole after being diagnosed with liver cancer; he died a few weeks later on 13 July 2017.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Truth prevails</span> National motto of the Czech Republic

"Truth prevails" is the national motto of the Czech Republic. The motto appears on the standard of the president of the Czech Republic, which the Czech Constitution designates a national symbol. Before the dissolution of Czechoslovakia in 1993, the motto was the motto of Czechoslovakia and appeared on the standard of the president of Czechoslovakia as well.

The Power of the Powerless is an expansive political essay written in October 1978 by the Czech dramatist, political dissident, and later statesman, Václav Havel.

Rudolf Battěk was a Czech sociologist, politician, and political dissident during Czechoslovakia Communist era.

<i>Parrhesia</i> (journal) Academic journal

Parrhesia: A Journal of Critical Philosophy is an international open-access journal of Critical Philosophy affiliated with Melbourne School of Continental Philosophy. It is edited by four MSCP members: Alex Murray, Matthew Sharpe, Jon Roffe and Ashley Woodward. It was launched in 2006 and has included articles by Alain Badiou and Jacques Rancière.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Moral intellectualism</span> View in meta-ethics

Moral intellectualism or ethical intellectualism is a view in meta-ethics according to which genuine moral knowledge must take the form of arriving at discursive moral judgements about what one should do. One way of understanding this is that doing what is right is a reflection of what any being knows is right. However, it can also be interpreted as the understanding that a rationally consistent worldview and theoretical way of life, as exemplified by Socrates, is superior to the life devoted to a moral life.

References

  1. Havel, Václav; et al. (1985). Keane, John, ed. The Power of the Powerless: Citizens against the state in central-eastern Europe. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe. ISBN   0-87332-761-6.
  2. Nan Richardson (ed), Kerry Kennedy and Eddie Adams, 'Speak Truth to Power', Umbrage, 2003, introduction.
  3. Galbraith, John Kenneth (1983). The Anatomy of Power. Hamish Hamilton. p. 89.
  4. "The most excellent jihad is when one speaks a true word in the presence of a tyrannical ruler", from the Mishkat al-Masabih.
  5. William E. Phipps, Muhammad and Jesus: A Comparison of the Prophets and Their Teachings, page 157
  6. Speak truth to power A Quaker search for an alternative to violence. American Friends Service Committee. 1955. Retrieved 25 April 2024.
  7. According to Fea (2017), 'Rustin and his co-authors expunged Rustin’s name from the pamphlet because of his arrest on charges of committing a homosexual act in 1953.'The History of the Phrase “Speak Truth to Power”
  8. Corkindale, Gill (21 July 2011). "The Price of (Not) Speaking Truth to Power". Harvard Business Review .
  9. Hirschman, Albert O. (1970). Exit, Voice, and Loyalty.
  10. Baldoni, John (28 June 2017). "Churchill and Orwell; speaking truth to power". Forbes Magazine .
  11. Dorn, James A. (18 July 2017). "What Liu Xiaobo's grisly prison death tells us about free speech in China". Newsweek .
  12. Foucault, Michel (1983). Fearless Speech. pp. 15–16.
  13. Eagleton, Terry (3 April 2006). "The Truth Speakers". New Statesman.
  14. "Truth to the Powerless: An Investigation into Canada's Foreign Policy". www.truthtothepowerless.com.
  15. Anon, 'Speaking Truth to Power', The Economist, 7 August 2008
  16. Serge Schmemann, 'The moral clarity of Andrei Sakharov', Hoover Institution, 7 October 2015
  17. S.C.M.Paine, The Japanese Empire, Cambridge University Press, 2017, p101
  18. James Deotis Roberts, Bonhoeffer and King: Speaking Truth To Power, Westminster John Knox Press, 2005
  19. Martin Bright, 'What happened to the Woman who revealed dirty tricks on the UN Iraq War vote?', The Guardian , 2 March 2013.
  20. Katharine Gun, 'The Truth Must Out', The Guardian , 18 September 2004
  21. Richard Garner, 'Iraq abuse whistleblower Nick Mercer; 'Schools must teach speaking truth to power'.', Independent, 25 December 2014
  22. Timothy Garton Ash, History of the Present, Penguin, 2000, p 162-3
  23. Gutting, Gary; Oksala, Johanna (2019), "Michel Foucault", in Zalta, Edward N. (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2019 ed.), Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University, retrieved 12 January 2021
  24. Deacon, Roger (25 July 2016). "An analytics of power relations: Foucault on the history of discipline". History of the Human Sciences. 15: 89–117. doi:10.1177/0952695102015001074. S2CID   145100804.
  25. Power/knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972-1977
  26. Freire, Paulo. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. New York: Continuum, 2007.
  27. "Speaking Truth to Power". goodreads.com. Retrieved 16 June 2019.
  28. "Speak Truth to Power: Human Rights Defenders Who Are Changing Our World". goodreads.com. Retrieved 16 June 2019.
  29. Maslin, Janet (6 May 1983). "Film review: Die Weiße Rose". The New York Times.
  30. Holden, Stephen (17 February 2006). "The quiet resolve of a German anti-Nazi martyr". The New York Times .
  31. Chilton, Martin (11 April 2016). "Film review: Gandhi". Daily Telegraph .
  32. Zurawik, David (19 November 2006). "He Must Speak Truth To Power". Baltimore Sun.
  33. Zurawik, David (19 November 2006). "He Must Speak Truth To Power". Baltimore Sun.
  34. Sweeney, Sheamus (August 2013). 'From here to the rest of the world': Crime, class, and labour in David Simon's Baltimore (PDF) (PhD thesis). Dublin City University.