Stochastic terrorism

Last updated

Stochastic terrorism is a form of political violence instigated by hostile public rhetoric directed at a group or an individual. Unlike incitement to terrorism, stochastic terrorism is accomplished with indirect, vague or coded language, which grants the instigator plausible deniability for any associated violence. [1] A key element of stochastic terrorism is the use of media for propagation, where the person carrying out the violence may not have direct connection to any other users of violent rhetoric. [2] [3] [4]

Contents

Defining features

Although stochastic terrorism is considered an academic term without a formal legal definition, [1] it is differentiated from other forms of terrorism due to its public, indirect, and seemingly random nature.

  1. Speech: A public figure or group disseminates violent, inflammatory rhetoric via mass-media, directed at people or groups of people, sometimes suggesting or legitimizing the use of violence. [1] This speech tends to be protected due to the use of ambiguous coded language, dog whistles, jokes, hints, and other subtext in statements that fall short of a criminal threshold for causation. [5] [6] [1] [7] The 'it was just a joke' defense has been linked to early days of Nazism. [8] Other themes identified include black and white good vs. evil narratives [9] as well as painting an enemy as a mortal threat, which have been compared to the radicalization techniques used by terrorist groups. [10] [11] These attacks are often repeated and amplified inside a media echo chamber. [12] [13]
  2. Speaker(s): Typically the speaker is an influential political or media figure, who is referred to as the "stochastic terrorist" for his or her alleged indirect culpability for the attack. [14] [13] [1] [7] The instigator(s) or "stochastic terrorist(s)" may or may not knowingly use this technique to attack and intimidate enemies, nonetheless, the effect remains the same. The public figure can plausibly disclaim any subsequent attack, as their words were not an explicit call for violence, and because of the lack of a direct organizational link between the instigator and perpetrator of the attack. [15] [1] The public figure cannot be prosecuted for his or her statements so long as they do not meet the legal definition of incitement. This is the key distinction between stochastic terrorism and other forms of terrorism. In the U.S., the 1969 Supreme Court case Brandenburg v. Ohio held that violent, inflammatory speech cannot be criminalized unless it is intended to, and likely to, result in imminent lawless action. [5] However, Kurt Braddock warns that speech can be quite dangerous even if legal. [14]
  3. Inspiration: An individual or group, without any ties to known terrorist groups, hears the speech and becomes motivated to commit violence against the target of the speech, believing it will further a political or ideological goal. [5] [16] Annalee Newitz points to social media and other types propaganda that demonizes groups as a common modern source of inspiration. [8]
  4. Attack: An attacker commits an act of terrorism that could include physical violence, threats, or other acts meant to harm, instill fear, intimidate. [14] The victims may receive or fear physical attacks, (online) harassment, and death threats. [17] This can have a chilling effect, as many victims do not have the resources for adequate security. [18]
  5. Probability: While difficult to predict each individual act of violence due to the disconnected chain of causality, the speech makes threats and terror attacks more likely. These attacks observed as a collection have a statistically valid relationship, even if individual attacks are too random (stochastic) to predict precisely. [19]

Origin and popularization of the term

In 2002, the term was first used by Gordon Woo to describe a process to quantify risk of a terrorist attack. [1] [20] [21] [22]

Credit for defining the term has also been given to the blogger, G2geek, on the Daily Kos platform in 2011, when defining it as "the use of mass communications to stir up random lone wolves to carry out violent or terrorist acts that are statistically predictable but individually unpredictable", with plausible deniability for those creating media messaging. [1] [23] [24] The article covered the 2011 Tucson shooting. [14]

As of 2016, "stochastic terrorism" was an "obscure" academic term according to professor David S. Cohen. [25] During an August 9, 2016 campaign rally, then-candidate Donald Trump remarked "If [Hillary Clinton] gets to pick her judges, nothing you can do, folks. Although the Second Amendment people, maybe there is. I don't know." These comments were widely condemned as instigating violence, and described by Cohen as "stochastic terrorism", further popularizing the term. [26] [25] [14] Trump has continued to be criticized as inspiring violence. [27] [28] [29] [30]

Counter measures

Counterterrorism techniques such as attitudinal inoculation can help explain to a broad audience how radicalization and manipulation works, helping to blunt the impact of messages that increase violent tendencies. [14] [11] Seth Jones argues that labeling domestic terrorist groups, similar to labeling of international groups, would be helpful, although he acknowledges that most right-wing violence is perpetrated by lone wolves. [31] Rachel Kleinfeld advocates for increasing the penalties of violent actions or threats against elected officials, election workers, and other essential personnel for the functioning of a democracy to a specially-protected class similar to how hate crimes are classified. [32]

While U.S. jurisprudence narrowly defines the crime of incitement, conduct that incites ethnic or racial hatred is illegal in many other jurisdictions. In Germany, for instance, Volksverhetzung is speech that "denigrates an individual or a group based on their ethnicity or religion," or "tries to rouse hatred or promotes violence against such a group or an individual" and is punishable by up to five years in prison. [33]

Alleged incidents

The 2009 murder of George Tiller has been described as an example of stochastic terrorism, as many conservative news opinion shows and talk radio shows repeatedly demonized him for his administration of post-viability abortions. [26] [34] [25]

The 2011 Tucson shooting where US Rep Gabby Giffords was shot has also been cited as a prominent example. [35] [36] [37]

Al Qaeda and ISIS used this tactic, which has been cited as the mechanism that inspired attacks including Boston Marathon bombing and Fort Hood. [2]

The 2016 murder of Jo Cox MP by white supremacist Thomas Mair ahead of the Brexit referendum has been described as stochastic terrorism. [38] It has been noted that the views held by Mair –including anti-immigrant and anti-refugee sentiment –are part of mainstream British political discourse. By describing the murder in the context of Nazism, the presiding judge separated the sentiments from modern political discourse rather than drawing attention to contemporary extremist groups and figures whose rhetoric were likely to have influenced Mair. [39]

In their 2017 book Age of Lone Wolf Terrorism, criminologist Mark S. Hamm and sociologist Ramón Spaaij describe ISIS, [1] Anwar al-Awlaki, and Alex Jones as guilty of stochastic terrorism. [24] : 157  In the 2010 Oakland freeway shootout, Byron Williams was said to be en route to offices of the American Civil Liberties Union and the Tides Foundation, planning to commit mass murder, "indirectly enabled by the conspiracy theories" of Glenn Beck and Alex Jones. [24] They also cite the 2012 shooting at the Family Research Council. [24]

The 2017 congressional baseball shooting has been described as an act of stochastic terrorism. [40] [35]

The 2018 mail bombings were also attributed by Barbara MacQuade, [2] Medhi Hasan [41] and Jonathon Keats [36] as stochastic terrorism indirectly inspired by the rhetoric of Donald Trump.

The Gretchen Whitmer kidnapping plot in 2020 has been described by Molly Amman and Reid Meloy as an example of stochastic terrorism. [5] [1] [11] [42]

In the wake of escalating attacks on the LGBT community in the early 2020s, including bomb threats on children's hospitals and the Colorado Springs nightclub shooting, right-wing activists such as Matt Walsh and Chaya Raichik of Libs of TikTok have been accused of stochastic terrorism by commentators Kristofer Goldsmith, [43] Helen Santoro [44] and Juliette Kayyem. [45] [46]

The 6 January attack on the Capitol has also been described as stochastic terrorism. [2] [42] [47] [40] [8]

The May 2022 Buffalo shooting [16] [48] [49] and the August 2022 Cincinnati FBI field office attack have been cited as examples of stochastic terrorism. [50] [51] [52] [53] [54]

The perpetrator of the October 2022 attack on Paul Pelosi stated he was looking for Nancy Pelosi and hoping to intimidate other Democratic lawmakers, actions that have been described by some commentators and academics as stochastic terrorism. [55] [56] [40] [57]

In June 2024, two racially motivated stabbing incidents happened in Oulu, Finland. [58] Green Sisu described the attacks as stochastic terrorism and being predated by years of hostile rhetoric from far-right politicians in Finland, most notably from the Finns Party. [59] [60]

Following the July 2024 Southport stabbing, inflammatory remarks and sharing of disinformation by public figures were linked to subsequent rioting. The Reform UK leader Nigel Farage was accused by former counter-terrorism Police chief Neil Basu of inciting violence and creating conspiracy theories. [61] [62] [63] Islamophobic and racially-motivated disorder, including a stabbing, [64] were linked to the English Defence League and British Movement, following social media posts by right-wing extremists. [65] [66] [ improper synthesis? ]

Starting in September 2024, false claims and rumors spread that in Springfield, Ohio, Haitian immigrants were stealing pets and eating them. These claims were amplified by prominent figures in the American right, most notably Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump and his running mate JD Vance. [67] [68] In the following days, the city of Springfield received dozens of bomb threats [69] leading multiple commentators and a sitting senator, Brian Schatz, as well as Elie Mystal and school administrators in Springfield to suggest Trump and JD Vance were engaging in stochastic terrorism. [70] [71] [72]

See also

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Amman, Molly; Meloy, J. Reid (2021). "Stochastic Terrorism: A Linguistic and Psychological Analysis" (PDF). Perspectives on Terrorism. 15 (5): 2–13. ISSN   2334-3745. JSTOR   27073433 . Retrieved October 5, 2023.
  2. 1 2 3 4 McQuade, Barbara (2024). "Chapter 7". Attack from within: how disinformation is sabotaging America. New York: Seven Stories Press. ISBN   978-1-64421-363-6.
  3. ↑ Angrove, James (2024). "Stochastic terrorism: critical reflections on an emerging concept". Critical Studies on Terrorism. 17 (1): 21–43. doi: 10.1080/17539153.2024.2305742 .
  4. ↑ "What is Stochastic Terrorism?". George A. Smathers Libraries of the University of Florida .
  5. 1 2 3 4 Amman, Molly; Meloy, Reid (October 2021). "Incitement to Violence and Stochastic Terrorism: Legal, Academic, and Practical Parameters for Researchers and Investigators". Terrorism and Political Violence . 15 (5). Terrorism Research Initiative: 2–13. doi:10.1080/09546553.2022.2143352. ISSN   0954-6553. S2CID   254907232 – via JSTOR.
  6. ↑ Follman, Mark (December 17, 2020). "National security experts warn Trump 'is promoting terrorism' against Americans". Mother Jones . Retrieved August 11, 2023.
  7. 1 2 Yousef, Odette (September 17, 2024). "The U.S. has had a long history of political violence, but experts see a new trend". NPR.
  8. 1 2 3 Newitz, Annalee (June 4, 2024). "Chapter 3". Stories Are Weapons: Psychological Warfare and the American Mind. W. W. Norton & Company.
  9. ↑ Snodgrass, Erin (November 8, 2022). "Stochastic terrorism appears to be on the rise globally. Extremism experts explain how this form of violence has gone mainstream". Business Insider. Retrieved September 26, 2023.
  10. ↑ Ioanes, Ellen (November 5, 2022). "An atmosphere of violence: Stochastic terror in American politics". Vox . Retrieved September 28, 2023.
  11. 1 2 3 Nelson, Bryn (November 5, 2022). "Opinion: How Stochastic Terrorism Uses Disgust to Incite Violence". Scientific American . Retrieved October 3, 2023.
  12. ↑ DeVega, Chauncey (June 30, 2021). "Tucker Carlson prepares white nationalists for war: Don't ignore the power of his rhetoric". Salon.com . Retrieved October 3, 2023.
  13. 1 2 Bensinger, Ken; Frenkel, Sheera (October 5, 2022). "After Mar-a-Lago Search, Talk of 'Civil War' Is Flaring Online". The New York Times . ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved September 28, 2023.
  14. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Keats, Jonathon (January 21, 2019). "How Stochastic Terrorism Lets Bullies Operate in Plain Sight". Wired. ISSN   1059-1028 . Retrieved August 11, 2023.
  15. ↑ Forno, Richard (November 7, 2022). "Political violence in America isn't going away anytime soon". University of Maryland, Baltimore County . Retrieved October 3, 2023.
  16. 1 2 Hutterer, Michaela (June 2, 2023). "From Sparks To Fire" (PDF). Max Planck Institute for the Study of Crime, Security and Law . Retrieved October 3, 2023.
  17. ↑ Mathis-Lilley, Ben (June 23, 2022). "The Poll Workers Targeted by Trump". Slate (Interview). Interviewed by Mary Harris. Retrieved October 3, 2023.
  18. ↑ Kleinfeld, Rachel (October 2021). "The Rise of Political Violence in the United States". Journal of Democracy . 32 (4): 160–76. doi: 10.1353/jod.2021.0059 . S2CID   239879073 . Retrieved October 3, 2023.
  19. ↑ "What Is 'Stochastic Terrorism,' And Why Is It Trending?". Dictionary.com. August 8, 2019. Retrieved August 19, 2023.
  20. ↑ Munn, Luke (June 2019). "Alt-Right pipeline: Individual Journeys to extremism online". First Monday . 26 (6). doi: 10.5210/fm.v24i6.10108 . Retrieved April 22, 2024.
  21. ↑ Woo, Gordon (April 1, 2002). "Quantitative Terrorism Risk Assessment". The Journal of Risk Finance. 4 (1): 7–14. doi:10.1108/eb022949. ISSN   1526-5943 . Retrieved October 5, 2023.
  22. ↑ Woo, Gordon (December 2003). "Insuring Against Al-Quaeda" (PDF). Cambridge: National Bureau of Economic Research. Retrieved March 26, 2024.
  23. ↑ G2geek (January 11, 2011). "Stochastic Terrorism: Triggering the shooters". Daily Kos. Retrieved September 2, 2023.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  24. 1 2 3 4 Hamm, Mark S.; Spaaij, Ramón; Cottee, Simon (2017). The Age of Lone Wolf Terrorism. Studies in transgression. New York City: Columbia University Press. ISBN   978-0-231-54377-4.
  25. 1 2 3 Cohen, David S. (August 9, 2016). "Trump's Assassination Dog Whistle Was Even Scarier Than You Think". Rolling Stone . Retrieved August 11, 2023.
  26. 1 2 Crockett, Emily (August 10, 2016). "Trump's 2nd Amendment comment wasn't a joke. It was 'stochastic terrorism.'". Vox.com . Retrieved October 4, 2023.
  27. ↑ Hasan, Mehdi (August 4, 2019). "After El Paso, We Can No Longer Ignore Trump's Role in Inspiring Mass Shootings". The Intercept. Retrieved June 19, 2024.
  28. ↑ Murai, Ruth (March 30, 2024). "Donald Trump just stooped to his lowest low yet". Mother Jones. Retrieved June 19, 2024.
  29. ↑ Timmons, Heather (October 26, 2018). "Stochastic terror and the cycle of hate that pushes unstable Americans to violence". Quartz. Retrieved June 19, 2024.
  30. ↑ Kayyem, Juliette (December 6, 2023). "The Proud Boys Love a Winner". The Atlantic. ISSN   2151-9463 . Retrieved June 19, 2024.
  31. ↑ Jones, Seth G. (2018). The Rise of Far-Right Extremism in the United States (Report). Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) . Retrieved October 3, 2023.
  32. ↑ Kleinfeld, Rachel (March 31, 2022). "The Rise in Political Violence in the United States and Damage to Our Democracy". Carnegie Endowment for International Peace . Retrieved October 3, 2023.
  33. ↑ Sauerbrey, Anna (August 23, 2017). "How Germany Deals With Neo-Nazis". The New York Times . Retrieved September 16, 2024.
  34. ↑ Rawwas, Mohammed (April 1, 2019). "Opinion: On Christchurch & stochastic terrorism". The Northern Iowan . Retrieved August 11, 2023.
  35. 1 2 Forno, Richard (July 16, 2024). "Social media and political violence – how to break the cycle". The Conversation. Retrieved August 12, 2024.
  36. 1 2 Keats, Jonathon (January 21, 2019). "How Stochastic Terrorism Lets Bullies Operate in Plain Sight". Wired. ISSN   1059-1028 . Retrieved August 12, 2024.
  37. ↑ Barbaro, Michael; Chaturvedi, Asthaa; Reid, Will; Wood, Chris; Lin, M. J. Davis; Lozano, Marion (November 2, 2022). "The Man Who Tried to Kidnap Nancy Pelosi". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved August 12, 2024.
  38. ↑ Angove, James (January 2, 2024). "Stochastic terrorism: critical reflections on an emerging concept". Critical Studies on Terrorism . 17 (1): 21–43. doi: 10.1080/17539153.2024.2305742 . ISSN   1753-9153.
  39. ↑ Ali, Nadya (December 2020). "Seeing and unseeing Prevent's racialized borders". Security Dialogue . 51 (6): 579–596. doi:10.1177/0967010620903238. ISSN   0967-0106.
  40. 1 2 3 Chait, Jonathan (October 28, 2022). "This Is Not the Political Violence That Should Scare Us". Intelligencer. Retrieved August 12, 2024.
  41. ↑ Hasan, Mehdi (August 4, 2019). "After El Paso, We Can No Longer Ignore Trump's Role in Inspiring Mass Shootings". The Intercept . Retrieved August 12, 2024.
  42. 1 2 Tannehill, Brynn (December 12, 2022). "Preparing for the Worst". The New Republic. ISSN   0028-6583 . Retrieved August 7, 2024.
  43. ↑ Halon, Yael (December 12, 2022). "MSNBC guest accuses Musk and Libs of TikTok of promoting 'stochastic terrorism' on Twitter". Fox News . Retrieved August 11, 2023.
  44. ↑ Santoro, Helen (December 12, 2022). "How Anti-LGBTQ+ Rhetoric Fuels Violence". Scientific American . Retrieved August 11, 2023.
  45. ↑ Wilson, Jason (November 22, 2022). "Colorado Springs: Far-Right Influencers Made LGBTQ People Into Targets". Southern Poverty Law Center . Retrieved August 11, 2023.
  46. ↑ Wiggins, Christopher (November 20, 2022). "Club Q Shooting Comes Amid Increased Attacks on LGBTQ+ Venues". The Advocate . Retrieved August 7, 2024.
  47. ↑ Follman, Mark (2021). "How Trump unleashed a domestic terrorism movement—and how to defeat it". Mother Jones . Retrieved August 12, 2024.
  48. ↑ Lavin, Talia (May 15, 2022). "The Buffalo Shooter Isn't a 'Lone Wolf.' He's a Mainstream Republican". Rolling Stone . Retrieved October 5, 2023.
  49. ↑ Dinki, Tom (June 24, 2022). "Extremism in WNY: How to combat extremism here and elsewhere". WBFO . Retrieved October 3, 2023.
  50. ↑ Follman, Mark (September 2022). "How Trump spread incitement of violence throughout the GOP". Mother Jones . Retrieved September 26, 2023.
  51. ↑ Hurley, Bevan (August 17, 2022). "How Trump-loving Ohio FBI shooter became the right's new Ashli Babbitt". Independent.co.uk . Retrieved September 26, 2023.
  52. ↑ Zavarise, Isabella (August 14, 2022). "Extremism researcher says death of gunman who tried to breach Ohio FBI office is 'a really good example' of how far-right conspiracies can get followers killed". Business Insider . Retrieved September 26, 2023.
  53. ↑ Timmons, Heather (October 29, 2022). "Hate speech, online extremism fed Pelosi attack, terror experts believe". Reuters. Retrieved September 26, 2023.
  54. ↑ Froomkin, Dan (August 12, 2022). "The phrase you're looking for is 'stochastic terrorism'". Press Watch . Retrieved September 26, 2023.
  55. ↑ Fisher, Max (November 3, 2022). "Troubled Loner? Political Terrorist? Both? It's Often Hard to Say". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved August 7, 2024.
  56. ↑ Forno, Richard (November 3, 2022). "Political violence in America isn't going away anytime soon". The Conversation. Retrieved August 7, 2024.
  57. ↑ "'Where's Nancy?': Suspect in hammer attack on Pelosi's husband facing attempted murder charge". ABC News. Reuters. October 30, 2022. Retrieved August 12, 2024.
  58. ↑ "Second stabbing at Oulu shopping centre in a week, police suspect racist motive". YLE. June 19, 2024. Retrieved April 18, 2024.
  59. ↑ Suopanki, Kaisu (June 20, 2024). "Suomen hallitus mahdollistaa äärioikeistolaista väkivaltaa, sanoo professori" [Finnish government enables far-right violence, says professor]. Keskisuomalainen (in Finnish). Retrieved April 20, 2024.
  60. ↑ Poikola, Antti (June 20, 2024). "Green Sisu urges government to act against the far-right violence". Keskisuomalainen . Retrieved April 20, 2024.
  61. ↑ Dodd, Vikram; Quinn, Ben; Mason, Rowena (July 31, 2024). "Former counter-terror chief accuses Farage of inciting Southport violence". The Guardian . ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved July 31, 2024.
  62. ↑ Albert Tait (August 6, 2024). "Call the migrant hotel riots terrorism, former counter-terror chief says". The Telegraph. Telegraph Media Group. Retrieved August 6, 2024.
  63. ↑ Kate Nicholson (August 1, 2024). "Nigel Farage Doubles Down On His 'Perfectly Reasonable' Response To Southport Attack After Backlash". HuffPost. Archived from the original on August 1, 2024. Retrieved August 5, 2024.
  64. ↑ Nadine White (August 5, 2024). "Street beatings, stabbing and mosques under siege: the horrifying racist attacks carried out by far-right mobs". Independent. Retrieved August 5, 2024.
  65. ↑ "'Southport was just the spark': UK hit by unrest as far-right exploits knife attack tragedy". France 24. August 1, 2024. Archived from the original on August 1, 2024. Retrieved August 5, 2024.
  66. ↑ Esther Bintliff; Eve Sampson (August 3, 2024). "Who Are the Far-Right Groups Behind the U.K. Riots?". The New York Times. Retrieved August 5, 2024.
  67. ↑ Zadrozny, Brandy (September 13, 2024). "Before Trump, neo-Nazis pushed false claims about Haitians as part of hate campaign". NBC News . Archived from the original on September 13, 2024. Retrieved September 13, 2024.
  68. ↑ Gomez, Henry J.; Zadrozny, Brandy; Smith, Allan; Tsirkin, Julie (September 13, 2024). "How a fringe online claim about immigrants eating pets made its way to the debate stage". NBC News . Retrieved September 13, 2024.
  69. ↑ Chavez, Julio-Cesar (September 12, 2024). "Bomb threat in city at heart of Trump immigrant rumors sparks evacuation". Reuters . Retrieved September 12, 2024.
  70. ↑ "CNN NewsNight with Abby Phillip". CNN. September 16, 2024.
  71. ↑ Coghill, Arianna (September 12, 2024). "Bomb Threat Prompts Evacuation of Springfield, Ohio, City Hall". Mother Jones . Retrieved September 17, 2024.
  72. ↑ Senter, Irie (September 22, 2024). "'Why they gotta threaten the kids?': Under the national spotlight, Springfield schools cower". Politico . Retrieved November 14, 2024.

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.