Tullimonstrum

Last updated

Tullimonstrum
Temporal range: Pennsylvanian (Moscovian to Kasimovian), 311–306  Ma
Ꞓ
O
S
D
C
P
T
J
K
Pg
N
↓
Tullimonstrum gregarium 4334.JPG
Specimen of Tullimonstrum gregarium showing stalked structures
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Subkingdom: Eumetazoa
Clade: ParaHoxozoa
Clade: Bilateria
Genus:† Tullimonstrum
Richardson, 1966
Type species
Tullimonstrum gregarium
Richardson, 1966
Synonyms

Nemavermes mackeeiSchram, 1973 [1]

Tullimonstrum, colloquially known as the Tully monster or sometimes Tully's monster, is an extinct genus of soft-bodied bilaterian animal that lived in shallow tropical coastal waters of muddy estuaries during the Pennsylvanian geological period, about 300 million years ago. A single species, T. gregarium, is known. Examples of Tullimonstrum have been found only in the Essex biota, a smaller section of the Mazon Creek fossil beds of Illinois, United States. Its classification has been the subject of controversy, and interpretations of the fossil have likened it to molluscs, arthropods, conodonts, worms, tunicates, and vertebrates. This creature had a mostly cigar-shaped body, with a triangular tail fin, two long stalked eyes, and a proboscis tipped with a mouth-like appendage. Based on the fossils, it seems this creature was a nektonic carnivore that hunted in the ocean’s water column. When Tullimonstrum was alive, Illinois was a mixture of ecosystems like muddy estuaries, marine environments, and rivers and lakes. Fossils of other organisms like crustacean Belotelson , the cnidarian Essexella , and the elasmobranch fish Bandringa have been found alongside Tullimonstrum.

Contents

Description

Reconstruction of Tullimonstrum according to Johnson et al. (1969) Tullimonstrum Johnson 1969.png
Reconstruction of Tullimonstrum according to Johnson et al. (1969)

Tullimonstrum probably reached lengths of up to 35 centimetres (14 in); the smallest individuals are about 8 cm (3.1 in) long. [2]

Tullimonstrum had a pair of vertical, ventral fins (though the fidelity of preservation of fossils of its soft body makes this difficult to determine) situated at the tail end of its body, and typically featured a long proboscis with up to eight small sharp teeth on each "jaw", with which it may have actively probed for small creatures and edible detritus in the muddy bottom. It was part of the ecological community represented in the unusually rich group of soft-bodied organisms found among the assemblage called the Mazon Creek fossils from their site in Grundy County, Illinois. [3]

The absence of a hard part in the fossil implies that the animal did not possess organs composed of bone, chitin or calcium carbonate. [2] There is evidence of serially repeated internal structures. [2] Its head is poorly differentiated. [2] A transverse bar-shaped structure, which was either dorsal or ventral, terminates in two round organs [2] [3] which are associated with dark material which have been identified as melanosomes (containing the pigment melanin). [4] Their form and structure is suggestive of a camera-type eye. [2] [4] Tullimonstrum possessed structures which have been interpreted as gills, and a possible notochord or rudimentary spinal cord. [5] [6]

History of discovery

T. gregarium fossil (part and counterpart) Tullimonstrum gregarium 343.JPG
T. gregarium fossil (part and counterpart)

Amateur collector Francis Tully  [ ia ] found the first of these fossils in 1955 in a fossil bed known as the Mazon Creek formation. He took the strange creature to the Field Museum of Natural History, but paleontologists were stumped as to which phylum Tullimonstrum belonged in. [7] The species Tullimonstrum gregarium ("Tully's common monster"), as these fossils later were named, takes its genus name from Tully, [2] whereas the species name, gregarium, means "common", and reflects its abundance. [8] The term monstrum ("monster") relates to the creature's outlandish appearance and strange body plan.

The fossil remains "a puzzle", and interpretations liken it to a worm, a mollusc, an arthropod, a conodont, [9] or a vertebrate. [4] [5] Since it appears to lack characteristics of the well-known modern phyla, some speculate that it was representative of a stem group to one of the many phyla of worms that are poorly represented today. [2] Similarities with Cambrian fossil organisms were noted. Chen et al. suggested similarities to Nectocaris pteryx. [10] Others pointed to a general resemblance between Tullimonstrum and Opabinia regalis , [11] although Cave et al. note that they were too morphologically dissimilar to be related. [12]

Classification

The classification of Tullimonstrum has been an ongoing debate since the creature was first described, [4] [5] with many scientists presenting evidence of a vertebrate affinity, and others of an invertebrate affinity. [5] [13] [14] [15] [4]

Arguments in favor of vertebrate affinities

McCoy et al. (2016)

Reconstruction of Tullimonstrum as vertebrate, according to McCoy et al. (2016) Tullimonstrum McCoy et al 2016.png
Reconstruction of Tullimonstrum as vertebrate, according to McCoy et al. (2016)

In 2016 two studies were released simultaneously showing that Tullimonstrum may have been a basal vertebrate, thus a member of the phylum Chordata. [4] [5] McCoy et al. undertook a morphological study of several specimens; their analysis indicated that Tullimonstrum may be closely related to modern lampreys. [5] This affinity was attributed based on pronounced cartilaginous vertebral structures known as arcualia, a dorsal fin and asymmetric caudal fin, keratinous teeth, a single nostril, and tectal cartilages like in lampreys. While McCoy et al. raised the possibility that Tullimonstrum belong to the ancestral group of lamprey, [5] [16] it also has many features not found in Cyclostomes (lampreys and hagfishes). [17]

Clements et al. (2016)

A second study, by Clements et al. (2016), came to the conclusion that Tullimonstrum was a stem-vertebrate based on its eye anatomy. Close examination revealed that the animal had a camera-like eye, with preserved lenses and the presence of cylindrical and spheroid melanosomes arranged in distinct layers. These ocular pigments and their unique structure was interpreted to be a retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE), offering strong support that the bar organs were indeed eyes. [4] The dark pigments in the eye were chemically tested and found to be fossilized melanin, as opposed to ommochromes or pterins (which are ocular pigments used by many invertebrate groups). While the authors admitted that the ocular pigments of many invertebrate groups have been poorly investigated, at the time of publication the presence of RPE and two distinct melanosome morphology is a uniquely vertebrate trait. [4]

McCoy et al. (2020); Wiemann et al. (2022)

In 2020, McCoy, Wiemann and colleagues used Raman spectroscopy to identify the molecular bonds present in the organic material preserved with Tullimonstrum. Based on samples from multiple points in the body, they identified the organic material as representing the decay products of chordate tissues as opposed to the polysaccharide-based chitin (as is seen in arthropods), offering independent and rather unambiguous evidence for the interpretation that Tullimonstrum is a chordate or vertebrate. [18] In 2022, Wiemann and colleagues replicated these spectral signals in collaboration with independent laboratories using Fourier-Transform Infrared spectroscopy. [19] Comparable tissue signatures have been detected in preserved carbonaceous remains of a diversity of other animals. [13] [14]

Arguments in favour of non-vertebrate affinities

Sallan et al. (2017)

In 2017 Sallan et al. rejected the identification of the Tully monster as a vertebrate. Firstly, they noted that even the presence of the two melanosome types is variable among vertebrates; hagfish lack them altogether, and extant sharks as well as extinct forms found in the Mazon Creek area, such as Bandringa , only have spheroid melanosomes. Additionally, the supposed notochord extends in front of the level of the eyes, which is not the case in any other vertebrate, although is seen in lancelets. Even if the structure was a notochord, the presence of notochords is not limited to vertebrates either. [15] [20]

Further criticism was drawn towards the identification of the blocks of the body variously as gill pouches and muscle blocks (myomeres), despite the lack of differentiation in the structure of these blocks. In vertebrates, myomeres are also thinner, and extend along the whole length of the body rather than stopping short of the head. Meanwhile, the gill pouches of lampreys are paired extensions rather than segmented structures, and are usually embedded in a complex gill skeleton, neither of which is the case in Tullimonstrum. [15] [20]

Other identifications of soft-tissue structures were considered as being equally problematic. The supposed brain has no associated nervous tissue and is not connected to the eyes, and the purported liver was located under the gills as opposed to being further back as in other vertebrates. The "mouth" at the front of the proboscis was described as possessing gnathostome-like distinct tooth rows, despite lampreys having "tooth fields" on the interior of the mouth. This would necessitate the convergent re-evolution of grasping jaws. [15]

An additional difficulty is that the thin and jointed proboscis is inconsistent with the feeding methods typically used for open-water vertebrates: Either ram or suction feeding. The gill pouches would have obstructed the flow of water even further. [15]

Sallan et al. note that stalked eyes, tail fins, and brains are also present in anomalocaridids, and that Opabinia also has a similar proboscis. Previously arthropod affinities were rejected under the presumption that other Mazon Creek arthropods are preserved in three-dimensions, with carbonization of the exoskeleton, but the arthropods are not actually preserved in that manner. [15] They also suggested that molluscs convergently evolved complex camera-like eyes containing melanosomes, [15] but proponents of the vertebrate interpretation argue that no molluscs are known that have or had melanosomes in two distinct forms. [4] Further similarities (such as the lobed brain, muscle bands, tail fin, proboscis, and "teeth") could support possible molluscan affinities. [15]

Rogers et al. (2019)

Regardless, Rogers et al. (2019) demonstrated that certain squid ( Loligo vulgaris ) and cuttlefish ( Sepia officinalis ) species do in fact have two different melanosome forms which can decay to look like an RPE-like layer, similar to that observed in vertebrates and Tullimonstrum fossils. [21] On a plot of trace metal signatures in the eyes of Mazon Creek fossils, Tullimonstrum is clearly distinct from both vertebrates (which have a higher concentration of zinc) and the eyespots of the putative cephalopod Pohlsepia (however, no evidence of melanosomes were found in Pohlsepia , and some studies deny its affinity as cephalopod [22] [23] ) - although it should be noted however that these signals are influenced by the fossilisation process. The authors doubt that Tullimonstrum was a cephalopod (in the absence of other supporting traits), they argue that eye structure and chemistry alone cannot disprove invertebrate affinities. [21]

Even if the eye of Tullimonstrum is homologous with vertebrates, it is not necessarily a member of Vertebrata. Many vertebrate-like traits are also observed in tunicates (the larvae of which have pigmented eyes and tail fins), lancelets and acorn worms (both of which have gill openings and axial support structures), and the extinct vetulicolians. [15]

Mikami et al. (2023)

Reconstruction of Tullimonstrum as invertebrate according to Mikami et al. (2023) Tullimonstrum Mikami et al 2023.png
Reconstruction of Tullimonstrum as invertebrate according to Mikami et al. (2023)

In 2023, Mikami et al. (2023) scanned 153 specimens of Tullimonstrum by 3D scanner, as well as other taxa from Mazon Creek. They concluded that some of the characters used by McCoy et al. (2016) to justify a vertebrate identity (tri-lobed brain, tectal cartilages, fin rays) are not comparable to those of vertebrates. The authors also determined that Tullimonstrum has segmentation extending to the preoptic region, which is clearly different from vertebrates. Alternative classifications were discussed in detail, but Tullimonstrum could be a non-vertebrate chordate (due to its segmentation resembling the myomeres of Esconichthys apopyris , an enigmatic jawed vertebrate from Mazon Creek) or a protostome. [24]

Paleoecology

Tullimonstrum was probably a free-swimming carnivore that dwelt in open marine water, and was occasionally washed to the near-shore setting in which it was preserved. [2] This means it swam freely in the water and not clamped to a hard surface or benthic environment. [2]

Taphonomy

The formation of the Mazon Creek fossils is unusual. When the creatures died, they were rapidly buried in silty outwash. The bacteria that began to decompose the plant and animal remains in the mud produced carbon dioxide in the sediments around the remains. The carbonate combined with iron from the groundwater around the remains, forming encrusting nodules of siderite. The organism was entombed, retarding decay and allowing an impression or carbonaceous remains [18] [13] of the organism to be preserved. The first insights into the mechanisms of carbonaceous preservation in the Mazon Creek are provided as part of a large fossil data set, [13] however, the details are still subject of ongoing research. [25]

The combination of rapid burial and rapid formation of siderite resulted in excellent preservation of the many animals and plants that were entombed in the mud. As a result, the Mazon Creek fossils are one of the world's major Lagerstätten , or concentrated fossil assemblages. [2] The rapid burial and compression often caused Tullimonstrum carcasses to fold and bend like other Mazon Creek animals. [4]

The proboscis is rarely preserved in its entirety; it is complete in around 3% of specimens. However, some part of the organ is preserved in about 50% of cases. [2]

Many unique fossils have been found alongside Tullimonstrum like the sea anemone Essexella , the malacostracan Belotelson , the eurypterid Adelophthalmus mazonensis, horseshoe crabs, the elasmobranch fish Bandringa , and the coleoid cephalopod Jeletzkya. [26] [27]

Paleontologist's prank

A 1966–1968 prank promulgated by paleontologist Bryan Patterson suggested that modern representatives could possibly be found in remote lakes of Kenya, known under the local name "Ekurut Loedonkakini". These "dancing worms of Turkana" could supposedly kill a man with a bite, produced some sort of milk, and were known even to school-age children.

Patterson had several letters sent from Kenya under various aliases to Eugene Richardson, the Field Museum's curator of fossil invertebrates. Patterson had previously been the museum's curator of vertebrate paleontology and retained an accomplice there who was aware of the prank (and prevented it from going too far). A planned expedition was cancelled after the hoax was disclosed in a good-natured Christmas letter. [28] [29]

Richardson later recounted the story and published the original letters, poems, and doctored photos in a book under the pseudonym E. Scumas Rory. [30]

In 1989, Tullimonstrum gregarium was officially designated the state fossil of Illinois. [31] Artwork of it is featured on U-Haul rental vehicles from the state. [32] [33]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chordate</span> Phylum of animals having a dorsal nerve cord

A chordate is a deuterostomic bilaterial animal belonging to the phylum Chordata. All chordates possess, at some point during their larval or adult stages, five distinctive physical characteristics (synapomorphies) that distinguish them from other taxa. These five synapomorphies are a notochord, a hollow dorsal nerve cord, an endostyle or thyroid, pharyngeal slits, and a post-anal tail.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Invertebrate</span> Animals without a vertebral column

Invertebrates is an umbrella term describing animals that neither develop nor retain a vertebral column, which evolved from the notochord. It is a paraphyletic grouping including all animals excluding the chordate subphylum Vertebrata, i.e. vertebrates. Well-known phyla of invertebrates include arthropods, mollusks, annelids, echinoderms, flatworms, cnidarians, and sponges.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nemertea</span> Phylum of invertebrates, ribbon worms

Nemertea is a phylum of animals also known as ribbon worms or proboscis worms, consisting of about 1300 known species. Most ribbon worms are very slim, usually only a few millimeters wide, although a few have relatively short but wide bodies. Many have patterns of yellow, orange, red and green coloration. The foregut, stomach and intestine run a little below the midline of the body, the anus is at the tip of the tail, and the mouth is under the front. A little above the gut is the rhynchocoel, a cavity which mostly runs above the midline and ends a little short of the rear of the body. All species have a proboscis which lies in the rhynchocoel when inactive but everts to emerge just above the mouth to capture the animal's prey with venom. A highly extensible muscle in the back of the rhynchocoel pulls the proboscis in when an attack ends. A few species with stubby bodies filter feed and have suckers at the front and back ends, with which they attach to a host.

<i>Opabinia</i> Extinct stem-arthropod species found in Cambrian fossil deposits

Opabinia regalis is an extinct, stem group arthropod found in the Middle Cambrian Burgess Shale Lagerstätte of British Columbia. Opabinia was a soft-bodied animal, measuring up to 7 cm in body length, and its segmented trunk had flaps along the sides and a fan-shaped tail. The head shows unusual features: five eyes, a mouth under the head and facing backwards, and a clawed proboscis that probably passed food to the mouth. Opabinia probably lived on the seafloor, using the proboscis to seek out small, soft food. Fewer than twenty good specimens have been described; 3 specimens of Opabinia are known from the Greater Phyllopod bed, where they constitute less than 0.1% of the community.

<i>Nectocaris</i> Extinct animal genus

Nectocaris is a genus of squid-like animal of controversial affinities known from the Cambrian period. The initial fossils were described from the Burgess Shale of Canada. Other similar remains possibly referrable to the genus are known from the Emu Bay Shale of Australia and Chengjiang Biota of China.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Craniate</span> Clade of chordates, member of the Craniata

A craniate is a member of the Craniata, a proposed clade of chordate animals with a skull of hard bone or cartilage. Living representatives are the Myxini (hagfishes), Hyperoartia, and the much more numerous Gnathostomata. Formerly distinct from vertebrates by excluding hagfish, molecular and anatomical research in the 21st century has led to the reinclusion of hagfish as vertebrates, making living craniates synonymous with living vertebrates.

Pikaia gracilens is an extinct, primitive chordate animal known from the Middle Cambrian Burgess Shale of British Columbia. Described in 1911 by Charles Doolittle Walcott as an annelid, and in 1979 by Harry B. Whittington and Simon Conway Morris as a chordate, it became "the most famous early chordate fossil", or "famously known as the earliest described Cambrian chordate". It is estimated to have lived during the latter period of the Cambrian explosion. Since its initial discovery, more than a hundred specimens have been recovered.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Melanosome</span> Organelle found in animal cells used for the synthesis, storage and transport of melanin

A melanosome is an organelle found in animal cells and is the site for synthesis, storage and transport of melanin, the most common light-absorbing pigment found in the animal kingdom. Melanosomes are responsible for color and photoprotection in animal cells and tissues.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cephalization</span> Evolutionary trend of a head region developing

Cephalization is an evolutionary trend in animals that, over many generations, the special sense organs and nerve ganglia become concentrated towards the rostral end of the body where the mouth is located, often producing an enlarged head. This is associated with the animal's movement direction and bilateral symmetry, and cephalization of the nervous system led to the formation of a functional centralized brain in three groups of bilaterian animals, namely the arthropods, cephalopod molluscs, and vertebrates (craniates).

The Mazon Creek fossil beds are a conservation lagerstätte found near Morris, in Grundy County, Illinois. The fossils are preserved in ironstone concretions, formed approximately 309 million years ago in the mid-Pennsylvanian epoch of the Carboniferous period. These concretions frequently preserve both hard and soft tissues of animal and plant materials, as well as many soft-bodied organisms that do not normally fossilize. The quality, quantity and diversity of fossils in the area, known since the mid-nineteenth century, make the Mazon Creek lagerstätte important to paleontologists attempting to reconstruct the paleoecology of the sites. The locality was declared a National Historic Landmark in 1997.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marine life</span> Organisms that live in salt water

Marine life, sea life, or ocean life is the plants, animals, and other organisms that live in the salt water of seas or oceans, or the brackish water of coastal estuaries. At a fundamental level, marine life affects the nature of the planet. Marine organisms, mostly microorganisms, produce oxygen and sequester carbon. Marine life, in part, shape and protect shorelines, and some marine organisms even help create new land.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">UW–Madison Geology Museum</span> Natural history museum at the University of Wisconsin-Madison

The UW–Madison Geology Museum (UWGM) is a geology and paleontology museum housed in Weeks Hall, in the southwest part of the University of Wisconsin–Madison campus. The museum's main undertakings are exhibits, outreach to the public, and research. It has the second highest attendance of any museum at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, exceeded only by the Chazen Museum of Art. The museum charges no admission.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bear Gulch Limestone</span>

The Bear Gulch Limestone is a limestone-rich geological lens in central Montana, renowned for the quality of its late Mississippian-aged fossils. It is exposed over a number of outcrops northeast of the Big Snowy Mountains, and is often considered a component of the more widespread Heath Formation. The Bear Gulch Limestone reconstructs a diverse, though isolated, marine ecosystem which developed near the end of the Serpukhovian age. It is a lagerstätte, a particular type of rock unit with exceptional fossil preservation of both articulated skeletons and soft tissues. Bear Gulch fossils include a variety of fish, invertebrates, and algae occupying a number of different habitats within a preserved shallow bay.

Pohlsepia mazonensis is a species of fossil organism with unknown affinity. Although it was originally identified as an extinct cephalopod, later studies denied that interpretation. The species is known from a single exceptionally preserved fossil discovered in the late Carboniferous (Pennsylvanian) Francis Creek Shale of the Carbondale Formation, north-east Illinois, United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marine invertebrates</span> Marine animals without a vertebral column

Marine invertebrates are the invertebrates that live in marine habitats. Invertebrate is a blanket term that includes all animals apart from the vertebrate members of the chordate phylum. Invertebrates lack a vertebral column, and some have evolved a shell or a hard exoskeleton. As on land and in the air, marine invertebrates have a large variety of body plans, and have been categorised into over 30 phyla. They make up most of the macroscopic life in the oceans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paleontology in Illinois</span> Paleontological research in the U.S. state of Illinois

Paleontology in Illinois refers to paleontological research occurring within or conducted by people from the U.S. state of Illinois. Scientists have found that Illinois was covered by a sea during the Paleozoic Era. Over time this sea was inhabited by animals including brachiopods, clams, corals, crinoids, sea snails, sponges, and trilobites.

<i>Priscomyzon</i> Extinct lamprey from late Devonian South Africa

Priscomyzon riniensis is an extinct lamprey that lived some 360 million years ago during the Famennian in a marine or estuarine environment in South Africa. This small agnathan is anatomically similar to the Mazon Creek lampreys, but is some 35 million years older. Its key developments included the first known large oral disc, circumoral teeth and a branchial basket.

This list of fossil fishes described in 2016 is a list of new taxa of jawless vertebrates, placoderms, acanthodians, fossil cartilaginous fishes, bony fishes and other fishes of every kind that have been described during the year 2016, as well as other significant discoveries and events related to paleontology of fishes that occurred in the year 2016. The list only includes taxa at the level of genus or species.

<i>Mayomyzon</i> Extinct species of lamprey

Mayomyzon pieckoensis is an extinct species of lamprey that lived during the Late Carboniferous period, about 300 million years ago. It is the only known species of the genus Mayomyzon, which belongs to the family Mayomyzontidae. It is known from the Mazon Creek fossil beds located in present-day Illinois.

<i>Tyrannophontes</i> Extinct genus of mantis shrimp

Tyrannophontes is an extinct genus of mantis shrimp that lived during the late Carboniferous period in what is now the Mazon Creek fossil beds of Illinois. It is the only genus in the family Tyrannophontidae. The type species, T. theridion, was described in 1969 by Frederick Schram. A second, much larger species, T. gigantion, was also named by Schram in 2007. Two other species were formerly assigned to the genus, but have since been reclassified.

References

  1. ↑ McCoy, Victoria E.; Wittry, Jack; Sadabadi, Hamed; Mayer, Paul (December 1, 2023). "A reappraisal of Nemavermes mackeei from the Mazon Creek fossil site expands Carboniferous cyclostome diversity". Journal of Paleontology. 97 (5): 1116–1132. Bibcode:2023JPal...97.1116M. doi: 10.1017/jpa.2023.72 . ISSN   0022-3360.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Johnson, Ralph Gordon & Richardson, Jr., Eugene Stanley (March 24, 1969). "Pennsylvanian Invertebrates of the Mazon Creek Area, Illinois: The Morphology and Affinities of Tullimonstrum". Fieldiana Geology . 12 (8): 119–149. OCLC   86328.
  3. 1 2 Richardson, Jr., Eugene Stanley (January 7, 1966). "Wormlike Fossil from the Pennsylvanian of Illinois". Science . 151 (3706): 75–76. Bibcode:1966Sci...151...75R. doi:10.1126/science.151.3706.75-a. PMID   17842092. S2CID   40136008.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Clements, Thomas; et al. (April 28, 2016). "The eyes of Tullimonstrum reveal a vertebrate affinity". Nature . 532 (7600): 500–503. Bibcode:2016Natur.532..500C. doi:10.1038/nature17647. hdl: 2381/37646 . PMID   27074512. S2CID   205248673.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 McCoy, Victoria E.; et al. (April 28, 2016). "The 'Tully monster' is a vertebrate". Nature . 532 (7600): 496–499. Bibcode:2016Natur.532..496M. doi:10.1038/nature16992. PMID   26982721. S2CID   205247805.
  6. ↑ Dunham, Will (March 16, 2016). "Tully Monster Mystery Solved, Scientists Say". Scientific American. Reuters. Retrieved March 18, 2016.
  7. ↑ Greshko, Michael (March 16, 2016). "Scientists Finally Know What Kind of Monster a Tully Monster Was". National Geographic. Archived from the original on March 19, 2016. Retrieved March 17, 2016.
  8. ↑ Mikulic, Donald G. & Kluessendorf, Joanne (1997). "Illinois' State Fossil—Tullimonstrum gregarium" (PDF). Geobit. 5. OCLC   38563956. Archived from the original (PDF) on February 22, 2014.
  9. ↑ Briggs, Helen (March 16, 2016). "Fishy origin of bizarre fossil 'monster'". BBC News .
  10. ↑ Chen, Jun-yuan; et al. (October 2005). "An Early Cambrian problematic fossil: Vetustovermis and its possible affinities". Proceedings of the Royal Society B . 272 (1576): 2003–2007. doi:10.1098/rspb.2005.3159. OCLC   112007302. PMC   1559895 . PMID   16191609.
  11. ↑ Switek, Brian (January 27, 2011). "Tully's Mystery Monster". Wired . Laelaps. Retrieved February 5, 2014.
  12. ↑ Delle Cave, Laura; et al. (1998). "Advances, diversions, possible relapses and additional problems in understanding the early evolution of the Articulata". Italian Journal of Zoology . 65 (1): 19–38. doi: 10.1080/11250009809386724 .
  13. 1 2 3 4 Wiemann, Jasmina; Crawford, Jason M.; Briggs, Derek E. G. (July 8, 2020). "Phylogenetic and physiological signals in metazoan fossil biomolecules". Science Advances . 6 (28): eaba6883. Bibcode:2020SciA....6.6883W. doi:10.1126/sciadv.aba6883. ISSN   2375-2548. PMC   7439315 . PMID   32832604.
  14. 1 2 Tang, Qing; Pang, Ke; Li, Guangjin; Chen, Lei; Yuan, Xunlai; Xiao, Shuhai (September 1, 2021). "One-billion-year-old epibionts highlight symbiotic ecological interactions in early eukaryote evolution". Gondwana Research. 97: 22–33. Bibcode:2021GondR..97...22T. doi: 10.1016/j.gr.2021.05.008 . ISSN   1342-937X.
  15. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Sallan, L.; et al. (February 20, 2017). "The 'Tully Monster' is not a vertebrate: characters, convergence and taphonomy in Palaeozoic problematic animals". Palaeontology . 60 (2): 149–157. Bibcode:2017Palgy..60..149S. doi: 10.1111/pala.12282 . S2CID   90132820.
  16. ↑ St. Fleur, Nicholas (March 16, 2016). "Solving the Tully Monster's Cold Case". The New York Times . Retrieved March 16, 2016.
  17. ↑ Miyashita, Tetsuto; Diogo, Rui (2016). "Evolution of Serial Patterns in the Vertebrate Pharyngeal Apparatus and Paired Appendages via Assimilation of Dissimilar Units". Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution. 4. doi: 10.3389/fevo.2016.00071 . ISSN   2296-701X.
  18. 1 2 McCoy, Victoria E.; et al. (April 28, 2020). "Chemical signatures of soft tissues distinguish between vertebrates and invertebrates from the Carboniferous Mazon Creek Lagerstätte of Illinois". Geobiology . 18 (5): 560–565. Bibcode:2020Gbio...18..560M. doi:10.1111/gbi.12397. PMID   32347003. S2CID   216646333.
  19. ↑ Wiemann, Jasmina; Briggs, Derek E. G. (2022). "Raman spectroscopy is a powerful tool in molecular paleobiology: An analytical response to Alleon et al". BioEssays . 44 (2): 2100070. doi:10.1002/bies.202100070. ISSN   1521-1878. PMID   34993976. S2CID   245824320.
  20. 1 2 Baillie, Katherine Unger (February 20, 2017). "'Tully Monster' Mystery Is Far From Solved, Penn-led Group Argues". The University of Pennsylvania . Retrieved February 20, 2017.
  21. 1 2 Rogers, Christopher S.; Astrop, Timothy I.; Webb, Samuel M.; Ito, Shosuke; Wakamatsu, Kazumasa; McNamara, Maria E. (October 23, 2019). "Synchrotron X-ray absorption spectroscopy of melanosomes in vertebrates and cephalopods: implications for the affinity of Tullimonstrum". Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 286 (1913): 20191649. doi:10.1098/rspb.2019.1649. ISSN   0962-8452. PMC   6834042 . PMID   31640518.
  22. ↑ Klug, Christian; Landman, Neil H.; Fuchs, Dirk; Mapes, Royal H.; Pohle, Alexander; Guériau, Pierre; Reguer, Solenn; Hoffmann, René (July 31, 2019). "Anatomy and evolution of the first Coleoidea in the Carboniferous". Communications Biology. 2 (1): 280. doi:10.1038/s42003-019-0523-2. ISSN   2399-3642. PMC   6668408 . PMID   31372519.
  23. ↑ Whalen, Christopher D.; Landman, Neil H. (March 8, 2022). "Fossil coleoid cephalopod from the Mississippian Bear Gulch Lagerstätte sheds light on early vampyropod evolution". Nature Communications. 13 (1): 1107. Bibcode:2022NatCo..13.1107W. doi:10.1038/s41467-022-28333-5. ISSN   2041-1723. PMC   8904582 . PMID   35260548.
  24. ↑ Mikami, Tomoyuki; Ikeda, Takafumi; Muramiya, Yusuke; Hirasawa, Tatsuya; Iwasaki, Wataru (2023). Cherns, Lesley (ed.). "Three-dimensional anatomy of the Tully monster casts doubt on its presumed vertebrate affinities". Palaeontology. 66 (2): e12646. Bibcode:2023Palgy..6612646M. doi:10.1111/pala.12646. ISSN   0031-0239. S2CID   258198566.
  25. ↑ Baird, Gordon (1986). "Taphonomy of Middle Pennsylvanian Mazon Creek area fossil localities, northeast Illinois: Significance of exceptional fossil preservation in syngenetic concretions". PALAIOS . 1 (3): 271–285. Bibcode:1986Palai...1..271B. doi:10.2307/3514690. JSTOR   3514690.
  26. ↑ P. A. Allison (1987). "A new cephalopod with soft parts from the Upper Carboniferous Francis Creek Shale of Illinois, USA". Lethaia . 20 (78): 117–121. Bibcode:1987Letha..20..117A. doi:10.1111/j.1502-3931.1987.tb02028.x.
  27. ↑ Selden, Paul; Nudds, John (2012). "Mazon Creek". Evolution of Fossil Ecosystems (second ed.). Manson Publishing Ltd. pp. 94–96. ISBN   978-1-84076-623-3 – via Google Books.
  28. ↑ Chure, Dan (April 1, 2012). "Tullimonstrum gregarium and the dancing worm of Turkana". Land of the Dead. Retrieved June 8, 2021.
  29. ↑ Kloss, Gerald (June 18, 1968). "The Great Dancing Worm Hoax". The Milwaukee Journal . Retrieved March 31, 2012.
  30. ↑ Rory, E. Scumas (1969). The Dancing Worm of Turkana. Vanishing Press. OCLC   191964063.
  31. ↑ "State Symbol: Illinois State Fossil — Tully Monster (Tullimonstrum gregarium)". Illinois State Museum . Retrieved March 31, 2012.
  32. ↑ Shelton, Jim (March 16, 2016). "Solving the mystery of the Tully Monster". YaleNews. Retrieved February 22, 2023.
  33. ↑ Geggel, Laura (April 13, 2016). "Photos: Ancient Tully Monster's Identity Revealed". livescience.com. Retrieved February 22, 2023.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.