1989 Italian Grand Prix

Last updated
1989 Italian Grand Prix
Race 12 of 16 in the 1989 Formula One World Championship
Monza 1976-1993.png
Race details
Date10 September 1989
Official name LX Coca-Cola Gran Premio d'Italia
Location Autodromo Nazionale di Monza
Milan, Italy
Course Permanent racing facility
Course length 5.80 km (3.6039 miles)
Distance 53 laps, 307.400 km (191.009 miles)
Weather Hot, dry, sunny
Pole position
Driver McLaren-Honda
Time 1:23.720
Fastest lap
Driver Flag of France.svg Alain Prost McLaren-Honda
Time 1:28.107 on lap 43
Podium
First McLaren-Honda
Second Ferrari
Third Williams-Renault
Lap leaders
  • 1989 Italian Grand Prix

The 1989 Italian Grand Prix was a Formula One motor race held at Monza on 10 September 1989. It was the twelfth race of the 1989 Formula One season.

Contents

Alain Prost took his fourth and final win of the season after McLaren teammate and pole-sitter Ayrton Senna suffered an engine failure with nine laps to go, thus extending the Frenchman's lead over the Brazilian in the Drivers' Championship to 20 points. Having earlier announced that he was moving to Ferrari for 1990, Prost dropped his winners' trophy from the podium into the crowd, to the severe disapproval of his team manager Ron Dennis. [1] [2] Gerhard Berger, the man Prost would be replacing at Ferrari, recorded his first finish of the season with second, followed by the two Williams of Thierry Boutsen and Riccardo Patrese. The final points went to Jean Alesi in the Tyrrell and Martin Brundle in the Brabham.

Pre-race

Before the Italian Grand Prix, Alain Prost announced that he had signed with Ferrari for the upcoming 1990 season. To the Tifosi who had previously seen Prost as the villain, he was now the hero of the crowd. It mattered not that he was still driving for McLaren, he was a confirmed Ferrari driver now and was treated as such (in previous years he had been jostled, jeered, and even pelted with tomatoes by some of the Tifosi for daring to beat the Ferraris).[ citation needed ]

Prost's announcement allowed Frank Williams to re-sign Riccardo Patrese for 1990 (Prost had offers from both Ferrari and Williams). Lotus also announced at the Grand Prix that they would be using the Lamborghini V12 engine in 1990. They also confirmed that their 1990 drivers would be Derek Warwick and the team’s test driver Martin Donnelly. For his part, Piquet claimed after the press conference that his reason for leaving Lotus was his belief that although it had potential, the under-developed and underpowered Lamborghini V12 wouldn't be competitive and at that stage of his career he didn't want to spend another season developing an engine like he had done with the BMW turbo back in 1982. [3] History would prove him correct with Lotus only scoring 3 points in 1990. Piquet on the other hand would link with Benetton and their exclusive Ford HB V8 engines for 1990 and would ultimately finish 3rd in the championship with 2 wins and 43 points.

Qualifying

Pre-qualifying report

For the first time in six Grands Prix, Onyx were not fastest in pre-qualifying. That credit went to Larrousse-Lola, as their cars were first and second on Friday morning, with Philippe Alliot ahead of Michele Alboreto. Third was Nicola Larini in the Osella, with Bertrand Gachot's Onyx fourth. Gachot's team-mate and once a hero of the Tifosi as a Ferrari driver in 1985 and 1986 Stefan Johansson, missed out in fifth.

Sixth was the AGS of Gabriele Tarquini, with Roberto Moreno's Coloni seventh. Eighth was Larini's Osella team-mate Piercarlo Ghinzani, his eleventh pre-qualifying failure this season. As at the previous meeting, the Zakspeeds were ninth and tenth, Bernd Schneider again ahead of Aguri Suzuki. Argentine Oscar Larrauri had returned to EuroBrun for whom he raced in 1988, replacing Swiss driver Gregor Foitek, but with no improvement down in eleventh. Twelfth was the other AGS of Yannick Dalmas, ahead only of the second Coloni of Enrico Bertaggia. [4]

Pre-qualifying classification

PosNoDriverConstructorTimeGap
130 Flag of France.svg Philippe Alliot Lola-Lamborghini 1:26.623
229 Flag of Italy.svg Michele Alboreto Lola-Lamborghini 1:27.829+1.206
317 Flag of Italy.svg Nicola Larini Osella-Ford 1:27.980+1.357
437 Flag of Belgium (civil).svg Bertrand Gachot Onyx-Ford 1:28.344+1.721
536 Flag of Sweden.svg Stefan Johansson Onyx-Ford 1:28.588+1.965
640 Flag of Italy.svg Gabriele Tarquini AGS-Ford 1:28.813+2.190
731 Flag of Brazil (1968-1992).svg Roberto Moreno Coloni-Ford 1:28.864+2.241
818 Flag of Italy.svg Piercarlo Ghinzani Osella-Ford 1:28.884+2.261
934 Flag of Germany.svg Bernd Schneider Zakspeed-Yamaha 1:29.472+2.849
1035 Flag of Japan (1870-1999).svg Aguri Suzuki Zakspeed-Yamaha 1:30.085+3.462
1133 Flag of Argentina.svg Oscar Larrauri EuroBrun-Judd 1:30.089+3.466
1241 Flag of France.svg Yannick Dalmas AGS-Ford 1:30.882+4.259
1332 Flag of Italy.svg Enrico Bertaggia Coloni-Ford 1:31.606+4.983

Qualifying report

Predictably, the McLaren-Honda of Ayrton Senna was the fastest in qualifying for his 38th career pole position. Second was a surprise as Ferrari's Gerhard Berger joined Senna on the front row, whilst his teammate Nigel Mansell was third. Prost was only 4th, some 1.79 seconds slower than his Brazilian teammate, publicly complaining all weekend of a down on power engine compared to Senna's.

Prost's claims that Honda were favouring Senna were refuted by both Honda and McLaren boss Ron Dennis. However Prost's assertion was supported by former Honda drivers Mansell and 1982 World Champion Keke Rosberg who also told the press that when it became known they would not be driving Honda powered cars any more that their engines did not work as well or have as much power as was previous. BBC commentator Murray Walker also reported during the race itself that Prost was over 7 mph (11 km/h) slower than Senna through the speed trap in the race morning warm-up session despite the two cars running similar wing settings.

Senna's time of 1:23.720 in his V10 McLaren-Honda was 2.254 seconds faster than he had been a year earlier in the turbocharged McLaren MP4/4. His time was only 0.26 seconds shy of the fastest ever lap of the Monza circuit set by Nelson Piquet in a Williams-Honda in qualifying for the 1987 race when the turbo engines were developing some 300 bhp (224 kW; 304 PS) more than the naturally aspirated engines of 1989.

Eddie Cheever, who had finished 3rd in the 1988 race, failed to qualify his Arrows-Ford. It was the second time in 1989 that the American had failed to qualify for a race. His teammate Derek Warwick qualified 16th. The Brabham-Judd of Stefano Modena was excluded from the meeting when his car was found to be underweight. This promoted the Minardi of Luis Pérez-Sala onto the grid.

Qualifying classification

PosNoDriverConstructorQ1Q2Gap
11 Flag of Brazil (1968-1992).svg Ayrton Senna McLaren-Honda 1:25.0211:23.720
228 Flag of Austria.svg Gerhard Berger Ferrari 1:24.7341:24.998+1.014
327 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Nigel Mansell Ferrari 1:24.7391:24.979+1.019
42 Flag of France.svg Alain Prost McLaren-Honda 1:25.8721:25.510+1.790
56 Flag of Italy.svg Riccardo Patrese Williams-Renault 1:26.1951:25.545+1.825
65 Flag of Belgium (civil).svg Thierry Boutsen Williams-Renault 1:26.1551:26.392+2.435
730 Flag of France.svg Philippe Alliot Lola-Lamborghini 1:27.1181:26.985+3.265
819 Flag of Italy.svg Alessandro Nannini Benetton-Ford 1:27.1621:27.052+3.332
920 Flag of Italy.svg Emanuele Pirro Benetton-Ford 1:28.3671:27.397+3.677
104 Flag of France.svg Jean Alesi Tyrrell-Ford 1:27.399+3.679
1111 Flag of Brazil (1968-1992).svg Nelson Piquet Lotus-Judd 1:28.1351:27.508+3.788
127 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Martin Brundle Brabham-Judd 1:27.6271:27.637+3.907
1329 Flag of Italy.svg Michele Alboreto Lola-Lamborghini 1:28.5861:27.803+4.083
143 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Jonathan Palmer Tyrrell-Ford 1:29.1871:27.822+4.102
1523 Flag of Italy.svg Pierluigi Martini Minardi-Ford 1:28.3971:27.923+4.203
169 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Derek Warwick Arrows-Ford 1:28.0921:29.031+4.372
1722 Flag of Italy.svg Andrea de Cesaris Dallara-Ford 1:28.1291:28.180+4.472
1816 Flag of Italy.svg Ivan Capelli March-Judd 1:31.9691:28.430+4.710
1912 Flag of Japan (1870-1999).svg Satoru Nakajima Lotus-Judd 1:28.7691:28.441+4.721
2021 Flag of Italy.svg Alex Caffi Dallara-Ford 1:28.5961:28.708+4.876
2126 Flag of France.svg Olivier Grouillard Ligier-Ford 1:28.6691:29.537+4.949
2237 Flag of Belgium (civil).svg Bertrand Gachot Onyx-Ford 1:28.6841:29.058+4.964
2325 Flag of France.svg René Arnoux Ligier-Ford 1:28.6851:28.843+4.965
2417 Flag of Italy.svg Nicola Larini Osella-Ford 1:29.2651:28.773+5.053
2515 Flag of Brazil (1968-1992).svg Maurício Gugelmin March-Judd 1:29.1921:28.923+5.203
2624 Flag of Spain.svg Luis Pérez-Sala Minardi-Ford 1:29.5921:29.293+5.573
2710 Flag of the United States.svg Eddie Cheever Arrows-Ford 1:29.8841:29.554+5.834
2838 Flag of Germany.svg Christian Danner Rial-Ford 1:32.0741:31.830+8.110
2939 Flag of France.svg Pierre-Henri Raphanel Rial-Ford 1:36.295+12.575
EX8 Flag of Italy.svg Stefano Modena Brabham-Judd

Race

Race report

As the grid was in the process of forming up before the start, the McLaren team transferred the settings from Senna's car to Prost's in the hope of curing its handling problem (Prost had actually been more than 2 seconds slower in the race morning warm up than Senna). Prost would later say that while handling and grip were significantly improved, the down on power engine remained and despite the same wing settings he still could not match his teammate for straight line speed. [5]

Senna led from the start and built up a small lead over Berger, while Mansell (whose 'development' V12 engine was not revving right) and especially Prost struggled to stay in touch. Indeed, in the early stages of the race Prost, who was getting used to his cars new set up, was having a hard time holding off the V10 Williams-Renault of Thierry Boutsen, though the BBC's James Hunt explained that Prost was using a harder set of "B" compound tyres in the hope of not having to pit during the race.

Emanuele Pirro was the races first retirement, the transmission in his Benetton-Ford not lasting a single lap. Only just longer was the Lola-Lamborghini of Philippe Alliot. The V12 powered Lolas of Alliot and Michele Alboreto had easily been the fastest in pre-qualifying, and Alliot went on to qualify a fine 7th (ahead of the Benetton's) before spinning into the sand trap at Ascari on just his second lap.

Alessandro Nannini's Benetton lost its brakes on lap 33 putting him into retirement, while Nigel Mansell suffered gearbox failure on lap 41. Through all of this, Senna was still comfortably in the lead with Prost having fought his way past Berger into second following Mansell's retirement. Prost passed Berger in front of the pits and the main grandstand and this saw the unusual sight of the Tifosi cheering when a McLaren passed a Ferrari. It must be remembered though that Prost was a confirmed Ferrari driver for 1990 while Berger, the hero of the 1988 race, was leaving the Scuderia to take Prost's seat at McLaren. The Williams' pair of Boutsen and Patrese, having found the limits of the older FW12 model, were circulating in 4th and 5th places but at no stage threatened the leaders.

On lap 44 the roar of the crowd told the story as the V10 Honda in Senna's McLaren comprehensively blew up going into the Parabolica, dumping its oil onto the rear tyres and sending Senna into a gentle spin and retirement, handing Prost the lead which he held to win his first Italian Grand Prix since 1985. Berger finished second for not only his first points of the season but indeed his first race finish while Boutsen came home third. Despite Prost's engine complaints, he still managed to set the fastest lap of the race on lap 43.

Prost's win restored his 20-point championship lead over Senna with only four races remaining in the season. However, due to the "Best 11" scoring system, Prost had now scored major points in 11 races while Senna could still score from all four remaining races. This meant that unless Prost won races, he would be able to score only a small number of points for the remainder of the season while Senna could conceivably score a maximum of 36 points (and win the championship) if he won the last four rounds.

McLaren-Honda won the Constructors' Championship with four races left.

Race classification

PosNoDriverConstructorLapsTime/RetiredGridPoints
12 Flag of France.svg Alain Prost McLaren-Honda 531:19:27.55049
228 Flag of Austria.svg Gerhard Berger Ferrari 53+ 7.32626
35 Flag of Belgium (civil).svg Thierry Boutsen Williams-Renault 53+ 14.97564
46 Flag of Italy.svg Riccardo Patrese Williams-Renault 53+ 38.72253
54 Flag of France.svg Jean Alesi Tyrrell-Ford 52+ 1 Lap102
67 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Martin Brundle Brabham-Judd 52+ 1 Lap121
723 Flag of Italy.svg Pierluigi Martini Minardi-Ford 52+ 1 Lap15 
824 Flag of Spain.svg Luis Pérez-Sala Minardi-Ford 51+ 2 Laps26 
925 Flag of France.svg René Arnoux Ligier-Ford 51+ 2 Laps23 
1012 Flag of Japan (1870-1999).svg Satoru Nakajima Lotus-Judd 51Suspension19 
1121 Flag of Italy.svg Alex Caffi Dallara-Ford 47Engine20 
Ret22 Flag of Italy.svg Andrea de Cesaris Dallara-Ford 45Engine17 
Ret1 Flag of Brazil (1968-1992).svg Ayrton Senna McLaren-Honda 44Engine1 
Ret27 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Nigel Mansell Ferrari 41Gearbox3 
Ret37 Flag of Belgium (civil).svg Bertrand Gachot Onyx-Ford 38Radiator22 
Ret19 Flag of Italy.svg Alessandro Nannini Benetton-Ford 33Brakes8 
Ret16 Flag of Italy.svg Ivan Capelli March-Judd 30Engine18 
Ret26 Flag of France.svg Olivier Grouillard Ligier-Ford 30Exhaust21 
Ret11 Flag of Brazil (1968-1992).svg Nelson Piquet Lotus-Judd 23Spun Off11 
Ret3 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Jonathan Palmer Tyrrell-Ford 18Engine14 
Ret9 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Derek Warwick Arrows-Ford 18Fuel System16 
Ret17 Flag of Italy.svg Nicola Larini Osella-Ford 16Gearbox24 
Ret29 Flag of Italy.svg Michele Alboreto Lola-Lamborghini 14Electrical13 
Ret15 Flag of Brazil (1968-1992).svg Maurício Gugelmin March-Judd 14Throttle25 
Ret30 Flag of France.svg Philippe Alliot Lola-Lamborghini 1Spun Off7 
Ret20 Flag of Italy.svg Emanuele Pirro Benetton-Ford 0Transmission9 
DSQ8 Flag of Italy.svg Stefano Modena Brabham-Judd   
DNQ10 Flag of the United States.svg Eddie Cheever Arrows-Ford   
DNQ38 Flag of Germany.svg Christian Danner Rial-Ford   
DNQ39 Flag of France.svg Pierre-Henri Raphanel Rial-Ford   
DNPQ36 Flag of Sweden.svg Stefan Johansson Onyx-Ford   
DNPQ40 Flag of Italy.svg Gabriele Tarquini AGS-Ford   
DNPQ31 Flag of Brazil (1968-1992).svg Roberto Moreno Coloni-Ford   
DNPQ18 Flag of Italy.svg Piercarlo Ghinzani Osella-Ford   
DNPQ34 Flag of Germany.svg Bernd Schneider Zakspeed-Yamaha   
DNPQ35 Flag of Japan (1870-1999).svg Aguri Suzuki Zakspeed-Yamaha   
DNPQ33 Flag of Argentina.svg Oscar Larrauri EuroBrun-Judd   
DNPQ41 Flag of France.svg Yannick Dalmas AGS-Ford   
DNPQ32 Flag of Italy.svg Enrico Bertaggia Coloni-Ford     
Source: [6]

Championship standings after the race

References

  1. "Six of the best - Unusual podium ceremonies".
  2. Cooper, Adam (2000). "Memories are Made of This". Atlas F1. Retrieved 29 December 2011.
  3. Nigel Roebuck, John Townsend (1990). Grand Prix - 1989 Formula One World Championship (1st ed.). Glen Waverly, Victoria, Australia: Garry Sparke & Associates. pp. 120–125. ISBN   0 908081 99 5.
  4. Walker, Murray (1989). Murray Walker's Grand Prix Year. First Formula Publishing. pp. 101–108. ISBN   1-870066-22-7.
  5. Roebuck, Nigel; Henry, Alan (1989). Naismith, Barry (ed.). "Round 12:Italy The Unhappy Victor". Grand Prix. 5. Glen Waverly, Victoria: Garry Sparke & Associates: 122. ISBN   0-908081-99-5.
  6. "1989 Italian Grand Prix". formula1.com. Archived from the original on 18 January 2015. Retrieved 23 December 2015.
  7. 1 2 "Italy 1989 - Championship • STATS F1". www.statsf1.com. Retrieved 18 March 2019.
Previous race:
1989 Belgian Grand Prix
FIA Formula One World Championship
1989 season
Next race:
1989 Portuguese Grand Prix
Previous race:
1988 Italian Grand Prix
Italian Grand Prix Next race:
1990 Italian Grand Prix