2018 Welsh Labour leadership election

2018 Welsh Labour leadership election

←  2009 9 November – 6 December 2018 February–March 2024  →

Candidate Mark Drakeford Vaughan Gething Eluned Morgan First Round 46.9% 30.8% 22.3% Second Round 53.9% 41.4%

Leader before election Carwyn Jones Elected Leader Mark Drakeford

The 2018 Welsh Labour Party leadership election took place between 9 November and 6 December 2018 to elect a successor to Carwyn Jones as leader of the Welsh Labour Party.

Carwyn Jones, who had led Welsh Labour since 2009, announced his intention to resign at the Welsh Labour conference in Llandudno in April 2018. He stated that he would stand down in autumn 2018, and that he would continue to lead the party until then. ^[1]

Procedure

On 21 April 2018, at the Welsh Labour conference, Carwyn Jones announced that he would retire as First Minister in the autumn. ^[2] The conference considered whether to change the voting system for electing a party leader and decided to set up a democracy review, which would report back after Jones had retired. However, two days later, pressure began to build for a special conference to address the issue more quickly and to consider changing the voting system from an electoral college to one member one vote. Four trade unions—GMB, Unison, Usdaw and the CWU—protested about this, supporting the continuation of an electoral college, and their position was endorsed by Vaughan Gething. ^[3] In May and June 2018, Drakeford and Morgan pushed for the holding of such a party conference. It was reported that the supporters of Drakeford believed the existing system favoured Gething. ^[4] At the end of May, Carwyn Jones himself asked Lord Murphy to carry out an expedited democracy review and to consult on changes in advance of a special conference. ^[5] At the end of June, Drakeford came out in support of one member, one vote. ^[6] In mid June, Eluned Morgan announced that she would be standing as leader. ^[7] In July, Unite broke ranks with the other big unions by coming out in support of a change to one member, one vote. ^[8]

The special conference took place on 15 September and decided that the system to be used for the forthcoming election would be by one member, one vote, with the votes of individual party members and members of the affiliated organisations carrying the same weight. ^[9]

Ballot papers were sent out to members on 9 November by email, or by post for those who did not have an email address. The voters had until 3 December to return their ballots. A preferential voting system was used.

The result of the election was announced on 6 December, with Carwyn Jones scheduled to formally resign as First Minister of Wales the following week. His resignation would trigger a vote of all Assembly Members to elect his successor as First Minister.

Welsh Liberal Democrat AM Kirsty Williams had joined Welsh Labour in government following the 2016 assembly election as Cabinet Secretary for Education. She said that she would stay on in post if the same terms were available as those agreed with Carwyn Jones when she joined the government. ^[10]

Former Plaid Cymru AM Dafydd Elis-Thomas left his party in October 2016 to support the Labour-led government, and joined the government as Minister for Culture, Tourism and Sport in November 2017. This gave the government side a majority of 31 out of the 60 Assembly Members.

All three candidates in the election indicated they would wish for Williams and Elis-Thomas to remain in the government.

Timetable

• 27 September – Nominations opened
• 3 October – Nominations closed
• 9 November – Ballot papers were despatched
• 6 December – Winner announced ^[11]
• 11 December – Formal resignation of First Minister
• 12 December – Vote in the Senedd to elect a new First Minister

Nominations

In order to become a candidate, individuals required 20% of current Labour AMs to nominate them. This equated to six AMs, including themselves. ^[12]

Finance Secretary Mark Drakeford was the first candidate to declare he was standing, shortly after Jones announced he would be stepping down. He immediately secured the support of seven other AMs, ensuring he would be on the ballot. ^[13] A further nine AMs later announced they were nominating Drakeford, giving him the support of a majority of the Labour Group. He also had the backing of Momentum, a group supporting the national leader Jeremy Corbyn, and had been described as both a "Corbynist" and a pragmatist. ^{[13] [14]} Drakeford started the election campaigning as the favourite, although the academic Roger Awan-Scully suggested he might not remain the frontrunner. ^{[13] [15]}

Health Secretary Vaughan Gething announced his candidacy on 25 May, with the support of four members of the Assembly, putting himself one nomination short of becoming a candidate. ^[16] He later achieved the required number of endorsements when Ann Jones announced she would nominate him on 10 August. ^[17]

Minister for Welsh Language & Lifelong Learning Eluned Morgan announced her intention to run on 11 June 2018, declaring herself to be a 'centre-left candidate'. ^[18] She didn't receive any further nominations until Huw Irranca-Davies and Alun Davies, who had wanted to stand for the leadership but received no public support from other AMs, withdrew and nominated her. Two other AMs also nominated her, putting her one nomination short of the six required. ^[19] After Gething received sufficient nominations, he asked that no further AMs nominate him, but instead nominate a female candidate. ^[20] He suggested that Drakeford himself could nominate Morgan to ensure diversity in the election. ^[21] National party leader Jeremy Corbyn called for diversity in the choices offered to Welsh Labour members. ^[22] On 24 September, at the Labour Conference in Liverpool, Carwyn Jones said that if necessary he would nominate Morgan to ensure that there was a woman on the ballot paper, making it clear that he would remain neutral regarding the merit of the candidates. ^[23]

In addition to nominations from AMs, candidates could receive supporting nominations from Welsh MPs, affiliated trade unions and Constituency Labour Parties (CLPs), to be listed alongside the candidates' names on the ballot paper.

Campaign

Drakeford started the election as the favourite, though academic Roger Awan-Scully cautioned against the assumption that he would go on to win. ^{[13] [15]} Drakeford said he would act as a "bridge" to a new generation, and that he would stand aside midway through the next term of the Assembly. ^[24] His early policy proposals included a pilot of universal baby boxes like those used in Finland and Scotland. ^[25]

In addition to a formal campaign launch in the Ely area of Cardiff at the community centre where he once worked, Drakeford held a second launch at Northop College to announce his plans for North Wales. ^[26] He also launched a set of economic policy proposals at the North Wales launch, and later held further policy launch events: a social policy launch in Blackwood and an environmental policy launch in Carmarthen. ^{[27] [28]}

In a speech delivered in his former department at Cardiff University, Drakeford set out the political philosophy he called '21st Century Socialism', in which he suggested the Labour Party in Wales should use its traditional socialist principles to find solutions for the challenges facing modern Wales, such as the housing crisis, climate change and Brexit. ^[29]

Gething put focus on inter-generational poverty, and committed to improving productivity. ^[24] He also pledged to create a National Care Service to deliver elderly care free at point of use, funded by tax increases or a new care levy. ^[30]

Gething faced controversy for creating a group separate to his leadership campaign called Together for Labour, which was accused of being a vehicle to keep data after the end of the leadership campaign. ^[31] He was also criticised for accepting large campaign donations from a company which had been convicted for environmental infringements, another which is a major property developer in his constituency, and another which is owned by a controversial former local Councillor. ^{[32] [33]}

Morgan said she would appoint a minister for north Wales, as well as increasing support for the self-employed. ^[34] She also proposed a universal basic income for Wales, starting by pitching for a pilot to be held in a Welsh community. ^[35]

Morgan also faced questions about her election expenses, as she did not publicly register any donations to her campaign. ^[36]

Both Gething and Morgan said they would support a public vote on the final Brexit deal if elected leader, while Drakeford supported the national Labour Party position of only calling for another referendum as a last resort. ^{[37] [38]}

Candidate endorsements

Candidate		Political roles	Nominations from AMs	Endorsements
Mark Drakeford [39]		AM for Cardiff West since 2011 Cabinet Secretary for Finance since 2016	17 / 29 58.6% Nominations Mick Antoniw [40] Hannah Blythyn [41] Jayne Bryant [42] Rebecca Evans [43] John Griffiths [40] Lesley Griffiths [44] Mike Hedges [40] Jane Hutt [40] Jeremy Miles [45] Julie Morgan [40] Julie James [40] Rhianon Passmore [40] Jenny Rathbone [40] Ken Skates [42] Jack Sargeant Lee Waters [41]	Endorsements MPs/MEP Kevin Brennan, MP for Cardiff West [46] Ann Clwyd, MP for Cynon Valley [47] Wayne David, MP for Caerphilly [48] Nia Griffith, MP for Llanelli [48] Albert Owen, MP for Ynys Môn [49] Ian Lucas, MP for Wrexham [50] Anna McMorrin, MP for Cardiff North [51] Chris Ruane, MP for Vale of Clwyd [52] Mark Tami, MP for Alyn and Deeside [52] Paul Flynn, MP for Newport West [53] Geraint Davies, MP for Swansea West [54] Derek Vaughan MEP for Wales Trade unions CWU [55] UNISON [56] Unite [57] National Union of Mineworkers [58] BFAWU [59] ASLEF [60] Usdaw [61] TSSA CLPs Aberconwy Arfon Brecon & Radnorshire Caerphilly Cardiff North Cardiff West Carmarthen East and Dinefwr Ceredigion Clwyd South Clwyd West Cynon Valley Delyn Dwyfor Meirionnydd Gower Islwyn Llanelli Montgomeryshire Neath Pontypridd Rhondda Swansea East Swansea West Vale of Glamorgan Ynys Môn Affiliated Groups Socialist Health Association Wales Socialist Education Association Council leaders Andrew Morgan, leader of Rhondda Cynon Taf Council Rob Stewart, leader of Swansea Council Former AMs & MPs Nick Ainger, former MP for Carmarthen West & South Pembrokeshire Rosemary Butler, former AM for Newport West Richard Edwards, former AM for Preseli Pembrokeshire [62] Sue Essex, former AM for Cardiff North [ citation needed ] Brian Gibbons, former AM for Aberavon [63] Christine Gwyther, former AM for Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire [64] Edwina Hart, former AM for Gower [63] Gwyn R Price, former AM for Islwyn [ citation needed ] Alun Pugh, former AM for Clwyd West Catherine Thomas, former AM for Llanelli [65] Gwenda Thomas, former AM for Neath Individuals Meena Upadhyaya, geneticist [53] Unaffiliated groups Momentum [13]
Vaughan Gething [14]		AM for Cardiff South and Penarth since 2011 Cabinet Secretary for Health & Social Services since 2016	6 / 29 20.7% Nominations Hefin David [16] Vikki Howells [16] Ann Jones [66] Lynne Neagle [16] Joyce Watson [16]	Endorsements MPs Stephen Doughty MP for Cardiff South and Penarth Owen Smith, MP for Pontypridd [67] Stephen Kinnock, MP for Aberavon Council leaders Huw Thomas, leader of Cardiff City Council [68] Anthony Hunt, leader of Torfaen County Borough Council [68] Trade unions GMB [69] Community Affiliated groups Welsh Young Labour [70] BAME Labour CLPs Torfaen Cardiff South & Penarth
Eluned Morgan [71]		AM for Mid and West Wales since 2016 Minister for Welsh Language and Lifelong Learning since 2017	6 / 29 20.7% Nominations Dawn Bowden [21] [lower-alpha 1] Alun Davies [21] Huw Irranca-Davies [21] [lower-alpha 2] Carwyn Jones [lower-alpha 3] David Rees [21]	Endorsements MPs Tonia Antoniazzi, MP for Gower [72] Gerald Jones, MP for Merthyr Tydfil and Rhymney [73] Council leaders Debbie Wilcox, leader of Newport City Council[ citation needed ] Former AMs & MPs Lord Elystan-Morgan CLPs Blaenau Gwent Preseli Pembrokeshire

1. Nominated Eluned Morgan but voting for Vaughan Gething.
2. Nominated Eluned Morgan but voting for Vaughan Gething.
3. Nominated Eluned Morgan, will not declare who he is voting for.

Withdrawn

Huw Irranca-Davies and Alun Davies withdrew on 18 September 2018 to endorse Eluned Morgan. ^[21]

Declined

• Ken Skates, Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Transport in the Welsh Government; Assembly Member for Clwyd South since 2011. ^{[74] [42]}
• Jeremy Miles, Counsel General for Wales in the Welsh Government; Assembly Member for Neath since 2016. ^{[75] [45]}

Results and turnout

The results were announced at the Principality Stadium in Cardiff on 6 December 2018.

Turnout among members was 53.1% (~13,275 votes cast) and among affiliates it was 5.6% (~8,400 votes cast). ^[76]

See also

• 2018 Welsh Labour Party deputy leadership election

References

1. "Carwyn Jones to quit as first minister after the 'darkest of times'". BBC News. Retrieved 21 April 2018.
2. "Carwyn Jones to quit as first minister after the 'darkest of times'". BBC News. BBC. 21 April 2018.
3. "Unions say one member one vote is wrong for Welsh Labour". ITV News. 27 April 2018. Retrieved 5 August 2018.
4. Shipton, Martin (4 May 2018). "Key meeting will shape Welsh Labour leadership battle".
5. Shipton, Martin (1 June 2018). "Special conference to decide how Carwyn Jones' successor should be chosen".
6. "Drakeford backs one member one vote". 29 June 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
7. Mosalski, Ruth (12 June 2018). "Eluned Morgan announces she will stand in the contest to succeed Carwyn Jones".
8. "Biggest union backs one member one vote to choose Welsh Labour leader". ITV News. 17 July 2018. Retrieved 5 August 2018.
9. "Boost for Mark Drakeford as Welsh Labour changes voting system". ITV News. Retrieved 24 September 2018.
10. "Williams 'would stay in cabinet'". 27 May 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
11. "Race to take over from Carwyn Jones begins". ITV News. Retrieved 27 September 2018.
12. Blake, Aled (4 November 2017). "Welsh Labour agrees new leadership election rules".
13. "Mark Drakeford tipped for Labour's next leader in Wales" . Financial Times . Archived from the original on 29 May 2018.
14. "Gething 'optimistic' on leadership bid". 25 May 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
15. "Stop assuming Mark Drakeford will be the next Welsh first minister". newstatesman.com.
16. "Labour AMs back Vaughan Gething for Welsh Labour leadership in open letter".
17. "Adrian Masters on Twitter". Twitter. Retrieved 24 September 2018.
18. "Wales - BBC News". BBC News.
19. "Leadership rivals pull out to back Morgan". BBC News. 18 September 2018. Retrieved 24 September 2018.
20. "Back a woman, Labour candidate tells AMs". BBC News. 31 August 2018. Retrieved 1 September 2018.
21. "Labour leadership rivals pull out to back Eluned Morgan". 18 September 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
22. "Corbyn urges diverse Welsh leader contest". BBC News. 20 September 2018. Retrieved 22 September 2018.
23. "Jones offers Morgan backing for leader". BBC News. 24 September 2018. Retrieved 24 September 2018.
24. Davies, Daniel (18 July 2018). "Welsh Labour leader needs 'courage to be different'". BBC News. Retrieved 5 August 2018.
25. "Baby bundle plan for newborns backed". 10 September 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
26. "AM promises to install a Minister for North Wales if he elected as new Welsh Labour leader". The Leader. Retrieved 28 October 2018.
27. "Wannabe first minister outlines 'bread and butter policies'". South Wales Argus. Retrieved 28 October 2018.
28. Cooper, Jason (29 October 2018). "AM lays out vision for 'A Greener Wales'".
29. "Welsh Labour leader hopeful pledges to tackle inequality and protect the environment from fracking". Morning Star. 2 November 2018.
30. "Free care for elderly pledged by Gething". 17 September 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
31. Shipton, Martin (29 August 2018). "Data row over Welsh Labour leadership contender Gething's new group".
32. "Vaughan Gething campaign accepted donation from company fined for illegally dumping waste on Gwent Levels". 28 October 2018.
33. "Register of interests for Vaughan Gething AM". senedd.assembly.wales. 6 July 2016.
34. "Labour leadership hopeful pledges to appoint north Wales minister". ITV News. 31 July 2018. Retrieved 5 August 2018.
35. "Labour hopeful backs universal income". 15 October 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
36. "Register of interests for Eluned Morgan AM". senedd.assembly.wales. 29 June 2016.
37. "'Deal or no deal' Brexit vote call". 6 August 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
38. Williams, James (29 August 2018). "'Too early' to back second EU referendum" – via www.bbc.co.uk.
39. "Mark Drakeford first to declare bid to replace Carwyn Jones".
40. "Drakeford in Welsh Labour leadership bid". 24 April 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
41. "Welsh Labour leadership: Most AMs back Mark Drakeford". BBC News. 17 September 2018. Retrieved 17 September 2018.
42. "Welsh Labour leadership: Ken Skates rules himself out". BBC News. 4 July 2018. Retrieved 5 July 2018.
43. Mark for Leader/ Mark ein Harweinydd [@mark4leader] (3 July 2018). "Thank you to @RebeccaEvansAM for becoming the ninth AM to support Mark's leadership bid. Diolch yn fair i @RebeccaEvansAM am fod y nawfed AS i gefnogi Mark i fod yn harweinydd Llafur Cymru.‌ https://t.co/jaoWZl3cKU" (Tweet). Retrieved 5 August 2018– via Twitter.
44. "Two Welsh cabinet ministers back Mark Drakeford to be Wales' next First Minister". Wales Online. 4 July 2018. Retrieved 5 August 2018.
45. "Labour's Jeremy Miles backs Mark Drakeford leader bid". BBC News. 4 August 2018. Retrieved 5 August 2018.
46. "Kevin Brennan MP on Twitter".
47. Clwyd, Ann (19 October 2018). "I am so pleased that Cynon Valley CLP has supported Mark Drakeford this evening!".
48. "Mark Drakeford AM on Twitter".
49. "Albert Owen MP endorses Mark Drakeford for Welsh Labour Leader - Albert Owen MP". albertowenmp.org.
50. MP, Ian Lucas [@IanCLucas] (26 October 2018). "I will support Mark Drakeford AM for the Labour leadership in Wales.https://twitter.com/nathanleedavies/status/1055847664787566593" (Tweet) – via Twitter.
51. "Anna McMorrin MP 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🇪🇺 on Twitter".
52. "Mark for Leader/ Mark ein Harweinydd on Twitter".
53. "Supporters". Archived from the original on 26 October 2018. Retrieved 25 October 2018.
54. @MarkDrakeford (8 November 2018). "Thank you for your support @GeraintDaviesMP. Diolch yn fawr. 👍 #C21Socialism" (Tweet) – via Twitter.
55. "South Wales Branch on Twitter".
56. "UNISON supports Mark Drakeford for leader of Welsh Labour - Press release - News - UNISON Cymru/Wales". 12 October 2018.
57. "Unite the Union supports Mark Drakeford for Welsh Labour Leadership". unitetheunion.org.
58. "Mark for Leader/ Mark ein Harweinydd on Twitter".
59. "Mark for Leader/ Mark ein Harweinydd on Twitter".
60. "ASLEF backs Mark Drakeford". aslef.org.uk. Archived from the original on 20 October 2018. Retrieved 19 October 2018.
61. "Usdaw nominates Mark Drakeford for leader of the Welsh Labour Party". usdaw.org.uk.
62. Gwyther, Christine (26 October 2018). "Fantastic to see this support for Mark Drakeford from former Preseli Pembrokeshire AM Richard Edwards. #MD4L #C21Socialismpic.twitter.com/NHnIbkbJNx".
63. "Welsh Labour leadership: ex-health ministers back Drakeford". ITV News. 5 July 2018. Retrieved 5 August 2018.
64. "Christine Gwyther on Twitter".
65. "Catherine Thomas on Twitter".
66. "Adrian Masters on Twitter".
67. "Gething backed to be new first minister". 8 September 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
68. Mosalski, Ruth (6 July 2018). "Cardiff leader backs Vaughan Gething to be the first black head of a UK nation".
69. "GMB supports Vaughan Gething AM to be the next Welsh Labour Leader". 5 October 2018.
70. ^[ dead link ]
71. "Eluned Morgan joins Welsh Labour leadership race". 12 June 2018 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
72. MP, Tonia Antoniazzi (23 October 2018). "Today I put in my MP nomination for @WelshLabour leader @Eluned_Morgan #Eluned4FM I am so happy to support Eluned after such a battle to get a woman in the ballot paper. Credit to Carwyn for stepping up and giving our members the best selection of candidatespic.twitter.com/vJmOngIM7E".
73. MP 🇬🇧 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿, Gerald Jones (12 October 2018). "Delighted to be supporting @Eluned_Morgan @Em4Fm to be the next leader of @WelshLabour and First Minister. A great candidate with passion and ideas for taking our party forward across #Wales. #PobLwcpic.twitter.com/rXiAnjtlNn".
74. Mosalski, Ruth (21 April 2018). "Who could be Wales' next First Minister? The likely contenders to lead Welsh Labour". Walesonline . Retrieved 22 April 2018.
75. Morris, Steven (22 April 2018). "Welsh finance minister considering bid to succeed Carwyn Jones". theguardian.com . Retrieved 22 April 2018.
76. Davies, Daniel (6 December 2018). "So about half the 25,000 party members voted. But of the ~150,000 union and affiliates, only 5.6%".