Dynatoaetus

Last updated

Contents

Dynatoaetus
Temporal range: PliocenePleistocene,
5.333–0.05  Ma
Dynatoaetus.png
Known skeletal elements of Dynatoaetus gaffae in grey
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Aves
Order: Accipitriformes
Family: Accipitridae
Genus: Dynatoaetus
Mather et al., 2023
Type species
Dynatoaetus gaffae
Mather et al., 2023
Species
  • D. gaffaeMather et al., 2023
  • D. pachyosteusMather et al., 2023

Dynatoaetus is an extinct genus of large bird of prey from the Pleistocene of Australia. It is among the largest known raptors of the region, second only to the Haast's eagle of New Zealand, with estimates suggesting a weight of up to 12 kg (26 lb). Although most closely related to modern vultures, it shows clear adaptations towards an active predatory lifestyle in the form of robust, powerful talons. This may either hint at it retaining these ancestral features from the closely related serpent eagles or show that it convergently evolved these features as it took on a similar lifestyle. Due to their size and robust bones, it is thought that Dynatoaetus would have been capable of taking large prey items like kangaroos, giant wombats and flightless birds. There are two species within the genus, the type species Dynatoaetus gaffae and the somewhat smaller Dynatoaetus pachyosteus, both of which inhabited the same part of Australia at the same time.

History and naming

The first fossil remains now identified as belonging to Dynatoaetus were discovered in 1956 and 1969 in Mairs Cave, located in the Flinders Ranges, South Australia. This material included a variety of body parts, including toes, the upper arm and a sternum. The bones, which were found around 55 m (180 ft) into the cave, were covered in a thin calcite layer showing that the bones had not been buried and instead preserved simply lying on the floor of the cave. In later years fossils of large raptors were recovered from several more fossil sites across Australia, including Cooper Creek within the Lake Eyre Basin and the Victoria Fossil Cave (both in South Australia), and the Wellington Caves in New South Wales. However it was not until the discovery of 28 additional remains from Mairs Cave, including skull bones and vertebrae, that the various remains were found to have belonged to a single species. The discovery of these remains was made by a group of recreational speleologists and palaeontologists, which entered the cave with the express purpose of finding more fossils of the bird. Many of the bones of Mairs Cave were found to have belonged to a single individual bird, which served as the holotype when the fossils were described as a distinct genus and species by Ellen K. Mather et al. in 2023. [1] Later that same year a second species was described from the Victoria Fossil Cave on the basis of a variety of bones including a humerus, various other limb bones, a quadrate and a partial pelvis. This species, which was noted for being notably smaller than D. gaffae, was named D. pachyosteus. [2]

The genus name Dynatoaetus derives from the Ancient Greek "dynatós", a word meaning mighty or powerful, and "āetós" for eagle. [1]

Species

The type species of Dynatoaetus and the larger of the two. Fossils of this species are known from multiple regions of South Australia, including the Lake Eyre Basin, as well as New South Wales. The species name was chosen to honor Priscilla Gaff, who was the first to discuss the fossil material of this animal in a 2002 thesis. [3] [4]
Dynatoaetus pachyosteus was described the same year as Dynatoaetus gaffae and was noted for being smaller than the type species. Remains of it are currently only known from the Victoria Fossil Cave in South Australia, where fossils of Dynatoaetus gaffae have also been found. The species name is a combination of the Greek "pachys" meaning "thick" or "large" and "osteon", meaning bone. This name reflects the robust bones of this bird.

Description

The hindlimbs of Dynatoaetus were robust and much like those of modern eagles, with the femur in particular being described as extremely large and robust. The tarsometatarsus follows the same condition, being robust and large. The metatarsals however are relatively short. Although they too match the other bones in robustness, they are not much different in length from what is observed in female wedge-tailed eagles. The ungual phalanges of Dynatoaetus gaffae, the claws of the toes, are again much larger than those of modern wedge-tailed eagles. [1] The wings are also described as being short and robust. [2]

The fossil remains indicate that this eagle was the largest bird of prey to have inhabited Australia, over twice the weight of the extant wedge-tailed eagle. It was, however, not as large as a female Haast's eagle (Hieraaetus moorei) from the same time of New Zealand or Gigantohierax suarezi , a buteonine from Cuba. Unlike these two birds of prey, which both likely obtained their massive sizes due to insular gigantism and a lack of notable competitors, Dynatoaetus was a continental species like the Woodward's Eagle (Amplibuteo woodwardi) from North America. It is therefore believed that its size was at least in part due to its evolutionary history, given that aegypiine vultures are known to regularly obtain large sizes. For instance, Gyps melitensis from the Pleistocene of Malta as well as the Chinese vultures Aegypius jinniushanensis and Torgos sp. were all in a similar size range as Dynatoaetus gaffae. However, due to their much more derived ecology and the influence this had on their morphology, the precise size difference is difficult to determine. [1] Dynatoaetus gaffae may have reached a wingspan of up to 3 m (9.8 ft) [4] while Dynatoaetus pachyosteus was likely comparable in wingspan to the wedge-tailed eagle. [2]

Weight estimates were included in the description of the smaller species, Dynatoaetus pachyosteus, with varying results. Estimates based on humerus length yield a mere 2.9 kg (6.4 lb), but this is deemed to be an underestimate considering the robust nature of the elements. The least circumference of the humerus meanwhile suggests a more expected weight of 9 kg (20 lb), while the least circumference of the femur might even support a weight of up to 13 kg (29 lb). However, like with humerus length the weight of the femur is likely to be incorrect, as this element often yields overestimates. Dynatoaetus gaffae expectedly yielded higher weight estimates than its relatives, with the least circumference of the tibiotarsus indicating a weight of up to 12 kg (26 lb), while the least circumference of the femur, which again likely represents an overestimate, resulted in a weight of up to 19 kg (42 lb). Mather and colleagues point out that the large differences among the results is caused by the used algorithms, which are built around a wide variety of vastly different birds. They further highlight that these algorithms generally favour length, not taking into account how weight would be influenced by how robustly built certain birds, like Dynatoaetus, were. They conclude that Dynatoaetus gaffae most likely reached a weight of around 12 kg (26 lb), whereas Dynatoaetus pachyosteus would be at least several kilos lighter. [2]

Phylogeny

Phylogenetic analysis on the fossil remains of Dynatoaetus used both molecular and morphological data in order to determine its relationship with other birds of prey, resulting in three most parsimonious trees. Nine anatomical characters connect Dynatoaetus to vultures of the subfamily Aegypiinae, however not all of these are unique to the group and may also be found in other birds of prey like some Gypaetinae and Perninae. In the strict consensus tree, it was recovered as the sister taxon to the aegypiine vultures and more basal than Cryptogyps . Together, Dynatoaetus and derived aegypiines clade with the serpent eagles of the subfamily Circaetinae, a group that includes the Philippine eagle. The Bayesian analysis shows similar results, with Dynatoaetus likewise being found in a position basal to modern aegypiines. The key difference is that in this analysis Cryptogyps was not found to be part of this clade and instead a much more basal bird of prey. [1] The phylogenetic analysis conducted following the discovery of Dynatoaetus pachyosteus recover results much the same as the strict consensus of the earlier study. In this study the strict consensus placed both species in a polytomy with the Aegypiinae (including Cryptogyps), while the Bayesian analysis only differed in having the two species actually form a monophyletic clade. [2]

Generally, the unique mix of characters seen in Dynatoaetus is thought to be in large part the result of combining phylogenetic traits inherited from its ancestry with morphological traits developed to support its lifestyle, rendering it difficult to determine its precise relationship but confirming its highly distinct nature. Regardless, the relationship between aegypiines and serpent eagles was recovered in all analysis conducted for this species. [1] It could be possible that Dynatoaetus simply diverged from other aegypiine vultures prior to their diversification or that it convergently evolved anatomy similar to serpent eagles due to its predator habits. [2]

Accipitridae

Elaninae (elanine kites)

Gypaetinae (gypaetine vultures)

Perninae (honey buzzards and kin)

Circaetinae (serpent eagles)

Dynatoaetus gaffae

Dynatoaetus pachyosteus

Cryptogyps lacertosus

Aegypiinae (aegypiine vultures)

Harpiinae (forest eagles)

Aquilinae (booted eagles)

Accipitrinae (true hawks)

Buteoninae (buzzards and kin)

Haliaeetinae (sea eagles and kites)

Palaeobiology

Dynatoaetus may have occupied a similar niche to that of modern wedge-tailed eagles, hunting large prey while also scavenging Wedge-tailed eagle Diamantina Developmental Road Boulia Shire Queensland P1060459.jpg
Dynatoaetus may have occupied a similar niche to that of modern wedge-tailed eagles, hunting large prey while also scavenging

Although fossil material of Dynatoaetus is currently limited to the centre and south-east of Australia, specifically South Australia and New South Wales, this may not reflect the raptor's actual range and could instead be simply the result of preservation and collection bias as well as the fact that large predators are inherently rarer than other animals. Mather et al. thus suggest that this bird of prey may have been much more widespread during the Pleistocene. Regardless of its hypothetical range, Dynatoaetus appears to have inhabited a variety of habitats, from the dry inland of Australia to the more temperate coastal regions. [1]

While Dynatoaetus was much larger than the extant wedge-tailed eagle, the foot span of the two was rather similar due to the former's proportionally short toes. They were however notably more robust, which is thought to be an adaptation towards tackling larger prey items due to the increased strength of the talons. The short but robust toes would have allowed this bird to attack and maintain a grip on large prey even as it struggled. [1] This is supported by the deep and robust pelvis, which allowed for the attachment of powerful musculature. [2] Similar adaptations can be seen in a variety of other large predatory birds, including both the African crowned eagle and the South American harpy eagle, both of which are known to hunt both primates and small ungulates like antelopes and peccaries respectively. A geographically closer example would be Haast's eagle from the Pleistocene and Holocene of New Zealand, which hunted the giant moas of its home. Pleistocene Australia would have been abundant in potential prey, which could have included kangaroos, short-faced kangaroos, juvenile and weak giant wombats, megapodes and flightless birds such as Genyornis . Unlike the large, insular Haasts eagle however, Dynatoaetus had to compete for resources with other large carnivores like the monitor lizard Megalania, the terrestrial crocodile Quinkana and marsupial predators such as Thylacoleo , which would have impacted its behaviour and niche. [1] There is also the matter of both species coexisting with one another, suggesting that they must have differed in some of their habits. This may be explained through different habitat or prey differences. [2]

The wings of Dynatoaetus, which were short and robust, indicate that it adopted a flapping flying style which has also been likened to that of Haast's eagle. [2]

Like other modern eagles, Dynatoaetus was likely not above scavenging as well, even if it lacked the specific adaptations that characterise more derived vultures. This would have put the raptor in competition with the smaller Cryptogyps. Given its size and similar interactions observed in modern scavenging birds, it is believed that Dynatoaetus would have been able to dominate carcasses when coming into contact with its smaller relative. Dynatoaetus would have also been in competition with eagles of the genus Aquila , as remains of wedge-tailed eagles are known from some of the same localities as the larger raptor. It is hypothesised that Pleistocene wedge-tailed eagles may have been more limited in their ecology due to the pressure put on them by Dynatoaetus as hunters and Cryptogyps as scavengers. [2] [1] As a large vulture-like raptor capable of killing its own prey as well as scavenging, Dynatoaetus was also comparable to the lappet-faced vulture of Africa, which is known to kill mammals up to the size of a juvenile impala. [5]

Dynatoaetus likely went extinct approximately 50,000 years ago during the late Pleistocene, coinciding with the extinction of much of Australia's endemic megafauna and the disappearance of the scavenging Cryptogyps. It is possible that these extinctions also lead to the rise of the wedge-tailed eagle to the position as apex raptor in Australia, now able to occupy a more generalist niche. [1]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eagle</span> Large carnivore bird

Eagle is the common name for the golden eagle, bald eagle, and other birds of prey in the family Accipitridae. Eagles belong to several groups of genera, some of which are closely related. True eagles comprise the genus Aquila. Most of the 68 species of eagles are from Eurasia and Africa. Outside this area, just 14 species can be found—two in North America, nine in Central and South America, and three in Australia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Haast's eagle</span> Extinct species of bird

Haast's eagle is an extinct species of eagle that lived in the South Island of New Zealand, commonly accepted to be the pouākai of Māori mythology. It is the largest eagle known to have existed, with an estimated weight of 15 kilograms, compared to the next-largest and extant harpy eagle, at up to 9 kg (20 lb). Its massive size is explained as an evolutionary response to the size of its prey—the flightless moa—the largest of which could weigh 230 kg (510 lb). Haast's eagle became extinct around 1445, following the arrival of the Māori, who hunted moa to extinction, introduced the Polynesian rat, and destroyed large tracts of forest by fire.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Accipitridae</span> Family of birds of prey

The Accipitridae is one of the three families within the order Accipitriformes, and is a family of small to large birds of prey with strongly hooked bills and variable morphology based on diet. They feed on a range of prey items from insects to medium-sized mammals, with a number feeding on carrion and a few feeding on fruit. The Accipitridae have a cosmopolitan distribution, being found on all the world's continents and a number of oceanic island groups. Some species are migratory. The family contains 255 species which are divided into 70 genera.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wedge-tailed eagle</span> Bird of prey within the genus Aquila

The wedge-tailed eagle is the largest bird of prey in the continent of Australia. It is also found in southern New Guinea to the north and is distributed as far south as the state of Tasmania. Adults of the species have long, broad wings, fully feathered legs, an unmistakable wedge-shaped tail, an elongated upper mandible, a strong beak and powerful feet. The wedge-tailed eagle is one of 12 species of large, predominantly dark-coloured booted eagles in the genus Aquila found worldwide. Genetic research has clearly indicated that the wedge-tailed eagle is fairly closely related to other, generally large members of the Aquila genus. A large brown-to-black bird of prey, it has a maximum reported wingspan of 2.84 m and a length of up to 1.06 m.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">White-tailed eagle</span> Species of bird

The white-tailed eagle, sometimes known as the 'sea eagle', is a large bird of prey, widely distributed across temperate Eurasia. Like all eagles, it is a member of the family Accipitridae which includes other diurnal raptors such as hawks, kites, and harriers. One of up to eleven members in the genus Haliaeetus, which are commonly called sea eagles, it is also referred to as the white-tailed sea-eagle. Sometimes, it is known as the ern or erne, gray sea eagle and Eurasian sea eagle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harpy eagle</span> Species of eagle

The harpy eagle is a large neotropical species of eagle. It is also called the American harpy eagle to distinguish it from the Papuan eagle, which is sometimes known as the New Guinea harpy eagle or Papuan harpy eagle. It is the largest and most powerful bird of prey found throughout its range, and among the largest extant species of eagles in the world. It usually inhabits tropical lowland rainforests in the upper (emergent) canopy layer. Destruction of its natural habitat has caused it to vanish from many parts of its former range, and it is nearly extirpated from much of Central America. In Brazil, the harpy eagle is also known as royal-hawk. The genus Harpia, together with Harpyopsis, Macheiramphus and Morphnus, form the subfamily Harpiinae.

Aiolornis incredibilis is an extinct species of teratorn bird from the western United States. Only fragmentary remains have been found, which are dated between the Early Pliocene (Zanclean) and Late Pleistocene. First described as Teratornis incredibilis by Howard in 1952 based on a cuneiform bone, the species has been moved to the new genus Aiolornis by Campbell, Scott and Springer in 1999. The generic name is derived from the ancient Greek words aiolus and ornis. Aiolus refers to the Greek god of the wind, and ornis means "bird". The specific name incredibilis means ‘incredible’. A. incredibilis is lesser-known than its close relative, Teratornis merriami, even though A. incredibilis was significantly larger. It presumably became extinct at the same time as the other megafauna in North America.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Teratornithidae</span> Extinct family of birds

Teratornithidae is an extinct family of very large birds of prey that lived in North and South America from the Late Oligocene to Late Pleistocene. They include some of the largest known flying birds.

<i>Teratornis</i> Extinct genus of birds

Teratornis was a genus of huge North American birds of prey—the best-known of the teratorns—of which, two species are known to have existed: Teratornis merriami and Teratornis woodburnensis. A large number of fossil and subfossil bones, representing more than 100 individuals, have been found in locations in California, Oregon, southern Nevada, Arizona, and Florida, though most are from the Californian La Brea Tar Pits. All remains except one Early Pleistocene partial skeleton from the Leisey Shell Pit near Charlotte Harbor, Florida date from the Late Pleistocene, with the youngest remains dating from the Pleistocene–Holocene boundary.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Little eagle</span> One of the closest living relatives of the Haasts eagle, along with the booted eagle

The little eagle is a very small eagle endemic to Australia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Woodward's eagle</span> Extinct species of bird

Woodward's eagle is an extinct species of black hawk that lived in North America and the Caribbean during the Late Pleistocene. Remains have been found in the La Brea Tar Pits in the United States and in Cuba. Despite the common name, the species is technically a gigantic variety of hawk as it is a member of the still extant black hawk genus, Buteogallus, within the Buteoninae subfamily that are chiefly referred to as hawks, and not the Aquilinae subfamily most eagles belong to.

Titanohierax gloveralleni, also known as the Bahama eagle, is a large species of extinct hawk from the Late Quaternary of the Caribbean. Remains of the animal have been found on multiple islands in The Bahamas. The animal is known from a handful of bones found across multiple islands, including a tarsometatarsus, partial metacarpal, and nearly complete right ulna. The animal was described based on the former two by Alexander Wetmore in 1937, with all other currently referred material being assigned by Storrs Olson and colleagues in 1982.

Buteogallus daggetti, occasionally called "Daggett's eagle" or the "walking eagle", is an extinct species of long-legged hawk which lived in southwest North America during the Pleistocene. Initially believed to be some sort of carrion-eating eagle, it was for some time placed in the distinct genus Wetmoregyps, named for Alexander Wetmore. It probably resembled a larger version of the modern-day savanna hawk, with its long legs possibly used like the secretarybird of Africa to hunt for small reptiles from a safe distance. It died out about 13,000 years ago.

<i>Leptoptilos robustus</i> Extinct species of stork

Leptoptilos robustus is an extinct species of large-bodied stork belonging to the genus Leptoptilos that lived on the island of Flores in Indonesia during the Pleistocene epoch. It stood at about 1.8 metres (5.9 ft) tall and weighed up to an estimated 16 kilograms (35 lb). The majority of the discoveries are concentrated in Liang Bua cave located slightly north of Ruteng in the East Nusa Tenggara province.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aquilinae</span> Subfamily of birds

The Aquilinae are a subfamily of eagles of the family Accipitridae. The general common name used for members of this subfamily is "booted eagle", although this is also the common name of a member of the subfamily. At one point, this subfamily was considered inclusive with the Buteoninae based probably on some shared morphological characteristics. However, research on the DNA of the booted eagles has shown that they are a monophyletic group that probably have had millions of years of separation from other extant forms of accipitrid.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Crowned eagle</span> Species of bird

The crowned eagle, also known as the African crowned eagle or the crowned hawk-eagle, is a large bird of prey found in sub-Saharan Africa; in Southern Africa, it is restricted to more easterly areas. Its preferred habitats are principally riparian woodlands and various forests. The crowned eagle is the only extant member of the genus Stephanoaetus. A second species, the Malagasy crowned eagle, went extinct after early humans settled on Madagascar.

Gigantohierax is a genus of eagle from the Quaternary of present-day Cuba. Little is known about the two known species of the genus other than their very large size.

Giganhinga is a genus of giant darter that lived during the Late Miocene to Early Pleistocene in what is now Uruguay and Argentina. The largest species of anhinga known to science, estimates suggest it may have weighed around 17.7 kg (39 lb) and was likely flightless. Its weight likely helped it dive for prey and the anatomy of the pelvis indicates that it was a good and maneuverable swimmer. Only a single species is currently recognized, G. kiyuensis.

Cryptogyps is an extinct genus of Old World vulture from the Pleistocene of Australia. It was relatively small for a vulture but still larger than the extant wedge-tailed eagle. Originally described as an eagle in 1905, in 2022 it was reidentified as a vulture, the first known example from the continent. Phylogenetic analysis suggests it either being a sister species to the extant, widespread Eurasian vulture genus Gyps or as a more basal member of the subfamily. The identification of Cryptogyps as a vulture solves a longstanding mystery about the lack of specialized lineages of large scavenging birds in Australia despite being present on every other continent aside from Antarctica. It is likely that Cryptogyps went extinct towards the end of the Pleistocene due to the disappearance of the megafauna it depended on for carrion. The genus contains a single species, C. lacertosus.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Mather, E.K.; Lee, M.S.Y.; Camens, A.B.; Worthy, T.H. (2023). "A giant raptor (Aves: Accipitridae) from the Pleistocene of southern Australia". Journal of Ornithology. doi: 10.1007/s10336-023-02055-x . S2CID   257575533.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Mather, Ellen K.; Lee, Michael S. Y.; Fusco, Diana A.; Hellstrom, John; Worthy, Trevor H. (19 November 2023). "Pleistocene raptors from cave deposits of South Australia, with a description of a new species of Dynatoaetus (Accipitridae: Aves): morphology, systematics and palaeoecological implications". Alcheringa: An Australasian Journal of Palaeontology: 1–32. doi: 10.1080/03115518.2023.2268780 . ISSN   0311-5518.
  3. Gaff, P. (2002). The fossil history of the family Accipitridae in Australia (PDF) (MSc thesis). Monash University. doi:10.26180/19574641.v1. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2 June 2020.
  4. 1 2 Cominos, Christian (16 March 2023). "Giant eagle Dynatoaetus gaffae was Australia's biggest raptor, researchers say". Australia: ABC News . Retrieved 17 March 2023.
  5. Ferguson-Lees, James; Christie, David A. (2001), Raptors of the World, Houghton-Mifflin Company, ISBN   978-0-618-12762-7