Accident | |
---|---|
Date | 7 August 2020 |
Summary | Runway overrun in poor weather conditions due to pilot error |
Site | Kozhikode International Airport, Calicut, Kerala, India 11°07′59″N75°58′13″E / 11.13306°N 75.97028°E |
Aircraft | |
Aircraft type | Boeing 737-8HG(SFP) |
Operator | Air India Express |
IATA flight No. | IX1344 |
ICAO flight No. | AXB1344 |
Call sign | EXPRESS INDIA 1344 |
Registration | VT-AXH |
Flight origin | Dubai International Airport, Dubai, United Arab Emirates |
Destination | Kozhikode International Airport, Calicut, Kerala, India |
Occupants | 190 [1] |
Passengers | 184 |
Crew | 6 |
Fatalities | 21 [2] |
Injuries | 167 [3] |
Survivors | 169 |
Air India Express Flight 1344 was a scheduled international flight on 7 August 2020 from Dubai, United Arab Emirates, to Kozhikode, India, landing at Calicut International Airport. The flight was part of the Vande Bharat Mission to repatriate Indian nationals stranded due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The flight crew aborted two landing attempts because of heavy rain and tailwind. On the third landing attempt, the aircraft touched down on runway 10, but skidded off the end of the tabletop runway and slid down a 9–10.5 m (30–35 ft) slope, killing 19 passengers and both pilots. The four cabin crew members and 165 passengers survived, of whom all but two were injured. [4] This was the second fatal accident involving Air India Express, after the 2010 Mangalore crash.
Calicut International Airport in Karipur, Malappuram, is considered one of the most dangerous airports in India, according to India's Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA). [5] It has a tabletop runway, that is a runway located on the top of a plateau or hill with one or both ends adjacent to a steep precipice which drops into a gorge. The DGCA designated Calicut Airport as a "critical airfield", which means that only the captain (and not the first officer) can perform takeoffs and landings there. [6] The Airports Authority of India says that the airport is licensed for use in all weather conditions under instrument flight rules, but that the pilots operating flights to and from Calicut Airport (both day and night) should have sufficient flying hours at night to handle the dangerous conditions. [7]
Captain Mohan Ranganathan, a member of a safety advisory committee of the Ministry of Civil Aviation, said in 2011 that Calicut Airport is "unsafe". He recommended that Calicut Airport not be used for landing during wet weather. He observed that the airport had a tabletop runway with a steep down-slope from one-third of the runway 10 and inadequate "buffer zones", referring to the runway end safety areas (RESA) at both ends of the runway. Instead of the recommended 240 m (790 ft) safety area, it had only 90 m (300 ft). The width of runway 10 is only half of the minimum width that existing regulations require, with very little buffer zone on either side, whereas the recommended width is 150 m (490 ft). Calicut Airport also lacked an engineered materials arrestor system (EMAS), which could have prevented the accident. He also reported that there were heavy rubber deposits on the runway. [8] Calicut Airport's management ignored several warnings about the dangerous conditions at Calicut Airport, especially during wet conditions. [9] [10] [11] Many international airlines stopped landing wide-body aircraft at Calicut because of the dangerous conditions. [12] [13] Ranganathan said "The warnings were ignored... in my opinion, it is not an accident but a murder. Their own audits have had flagged safety issues". [11]
Conditions at Calicut Airport were investigated in 2019, following a tailstrike during the landing of Air India Express aircraft. The investigation revealed several safety hazards, including multiple cracks in the runways, pools of stagnant water, and excessive rubber deposits. In July 2019, the DGCA issued a show-cause notice to the director of Calicut Airport because of these hazards. [14] [15] [16]
The accident involved a Boeing 737-800 with a short-field performance package, registered as VT-AXH, manufacturer's serial number 36323 and line number 2108. [17] The aircraft, that first flew on 15 November 2006, was operated by Air India Express and had a tail livery with India Gate on the left and Gateway of India on the right. [18] The crew consisted of Captain Deepak Sathe (59), first officer Akhilesh Kumar (32); and four flight attendants. [19] [20] [21] Sathe had landed successfully at Calicut airport at least 27 times, including more than ten times in 2020. [12] He had 10,000 hours of flying experience on the Boeing 737, including 6,662 as commander. [22]
The aircraft departed stand E6 and took off from runway 30R at Dubai International Airport on 7 August 2020, at 14:14 GST (7 August 2020, 10:14 UTC) and was scheduled to arrive at Calicut International Airport at 19:40 IST (7 August 2020, 14:10 UTC), covering a distance of 2,673 kilometres (1,661 mi). [23] It was a repatriation flight for people who had been stranded abroad due to the COVID-19 pandemic, under the Vande Bharat Mission. [24]
The aircraft reached the airport on schedule. The approach was for runway 28, but two landings were aborted due to tailwind and the aircraft circled, waiting for clearance before making a landing on runway 10. [lower-alpha 1] [27] [28] At around 19:37 IST (14:07 UTC), they were given clearance to land on runway 10. [13] Due to the monsoon and floods in Kerala at the time, inclement weather conditions reduced visibility at the time of landing to 2,000 m (6,600 ft). Runway 28 was operational and in the first landing attempt, the pilot could not see the runway thus requested for runway 10. On the second attempt on 2,860 m (9,380 ft) runway 10, the aircraft touched down near taxiway ''C'', which is approximately 1,000 m (3,300 ft) beyond the runway threshold. [29] [30] The aircraft failed to stop before the end of the tabletop runway and plunged 9–10.5 m (30–35 ft) into a gorge, splitting the fuselage into two sections upon impact. [27] [31] The accident site was around 3 km (9,800 ft) from the airport terminal. [32] No post-crash fire was reported. [33] It was suggested that the crew shut off the engines on landing, which may have saved lives by preventing a fire. [34] According to a CISF officer, the aircraft did not slide into the gorge. It took off from the cliff and then collapsed. [32]
The accident was the second fatal accident of Air India Express and was similar to Air India Express Flight 812 which also overran the runway 10 years earlier at Mangalore International Airport, killing 158 people on board. [35] [36] [37]
A total of 184 passengers, four cabin crew and two cockpit crew were on board, all Indian. [38] [39] [40] Seventeen people died on the spot from the crash, including both pilots. [33] Later the death toll rose to twenty-one people on 24 August. [41] [42] [2] and more than 100 people were injured. [43] [44] [45] The chief minister of Maharashtra, Uddhav Thackeray, announced a state funeral for late Wing commander Captain Deepak Vasant Sathe in Mumbai. [46]
Type of victims | Total on board | Survivors | Fatalities |
---|---|---|---|
Passengers | 184 | 165 | 19 |
Pilots | 2 | 0 | 2 |
Cabin crew | 4 | 4 | 0 |
Total | 190 | 169 | 21 |
The Government of India and Kerala each announced an interim compensation of ₹ 10 lakh (equivalent to ₹12 lakhorUS$15,000 in 2023) for the families of the deceased above the age of 12 years, ₹ 5 lakh (equivalent to ₹5.9 lakhorUS$7,400 in 2023) for below the age of 12 years, ₹2 lakh (equivalent to ₹2.4 lakhorUS$2,900 in 2023) for seriously injured, and ₹50,000 (equivalent to ₹59,000orUS$740 in 2023) for those who sustained minor injuries. [47] It was also announced that the medical expenses of the injured would be borne by the state government. [48] [49]
Air India Express completed the disbursement of interim compensation to all passengers and next of kin of the deceased passengers soon after the accident. [50] Interim compensation of ₹10 lakh (equivalent to ₹12 lakhorUS$15,000 in 2023) was paid to the next of kin of 15 deceased passengers who were above the age of 12, ₹5 lakh (equivalent to ₹5.9 lakhorUS$7,400 in 2023) to the next of kin of 4 deceased passengers who were below the age of 12, ₹2 lakh (equivalent to ₹2.4 lakhorUS$2,900 in 2023) each to 92 passengers and 2 crew members who were critically injured, and ₹50,000 (equivalent to ₹59,000orUS$740 in 2023) each to 73 passengers who suffered minor injuries. [50]
Following the incident, local people from the surrounding Karipur village rushed to the crash site to rescue trapped victims from the aircraft, [51] followed by 40 Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) personnel who were guarding the perimeter of the airport, a quick reaction team and the Chief Airport Security Officer. Family members of the CISF personnel living nearby also joined. [52] Police and firefighters were also deployed for the initial rescue operations. [53] All passengers were evacuated in about three hours and taken to various hospitals in Kozhikode and Malappuram districts. [43] [45] [40] Emergency response team, GO Team [lower-alpha 2] and special assistance team of Air India (officially known as 'Angels of Air India') [1] from Kochi, Mumbai and Delhi were sent to the accident site. [55] [56] Three CISF officers were awarded Director General commendation disc for their rescue efforts after the mishap. [57] [58] The accident is predicted to cost the insurers and their reinsurers ₹ 375 crore (equivalent to ₹441 croreorUS$55 million in 2023), which includes aircraft or hull and liability for third party and passengers. It is around 90 per cent of the insured value and Air India will recover this amount since the aircraft has been totally damaged. The insurer is an Indian insurance consortium led by New India Assurance. Claim settlement survey has already started. [59] [60] [61] The airline had engaged a US-based firm, Kenyon International, to recover the baggage along with Angels of Air India. [62]
Two passengers on the flight who survived tested positive for COVID-19, after arriving at a hospital after the accident. To check the spread among other passengers and rescue personnel, CISF and Kerala Health Department asked their personnel and other passengers who were on the flight to undertake testing and quarantine. [63] [48] [64] One week later, 24 officers involved in the rescue operation tested positive. Kondotty municipality, the place where the airport is located, was subsequently declared as a containment zone. [65] [66]
The International Federation of Air Line Pilots' Associations (IFALPA) tightly monitored the actions after the accident and responded "Our thoughts are with the families of the pilots, crew members, and passengers who lost their lives aboard the aircraft. We send support and wishes to all the survivors, many of them injured and in hospital in critical condition." They got in touch with the Indian association, Air Line Pilots’ Association-India (ALPA-India) and the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) for technical expertise and assistance in investigation. [67] [12]
Following the accident, many pilot associations in the country soared up against the director of the DGCA, Arun Kumar, and wanted him to be replaced with someone more technically sound in aviation, after he referred to the late pilots as "fellows" and also said, "...and the landing it seems was not appropriate...", "The landing was not smooth". The pilot associations said that these comments from the director were amateurish and made them "the laughing stock of the aviation world". [68]
According to Yeshwant Shenoy, a lawyer fighting for safer airports in India, the DGCA should have put restrictions on conditions when airlines could land or take off. He blamed the DGCA for being incompetent and negligent after the 2010 crash in Mangalore, and called it a state-run syndicate. [69] He filed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) in the Kerala High Court after the crash, to shut down operations of Calicut airport as it is not compliant with air regulations. Shenoy demanded an open inquiry by a Court of Inquiry instead of a closed one by AAIB. He also demanded that the investigation should be conducted by the Central Bureau of Investigation, as local police weren't experienced in these. [70]
Shortly after the crash, operations of wide-body aircraft at Kozhikode were put on hold. As a result, Air India and Saudia removed their widebody services to Calicut. [71]
The Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) and Flight Safety Departments investigated the accident. [45] [72] [73] The cockpit voice recorder and flight data recorder were recovered the next day and sent to Delhi for analysis. [74] Boeing was to send its investigation team to examine the debris of the aircraft for defects and assist the probe. [75] [57]
Initial findings suggested that at the time of landing, the tailwind was around 9 knots (17 km/h). The aircraft was at 176 knots (326 km/h) at an altitude of approximately 450 feet (140 m) above the surface of runway 10, which is not considered ideal for short finals during poor weather conditions. [76] The throttle was found to be in a fully forward position (takeoff or go-around position) and the spoilers were retracted from the position of the speed brake lever, which indicates that the pilots might have tried for a go-around. [77] [78] The tailwind, rubber deposits and wet runway affecting the braking performance of the aircraft are thought to be contributory factors to the accident. [8] Civil Aviation Minister, Hardeep Puri, in a press conference at Kozhikode on 8 August, said that there had been sufficient fuel onboard for the aircraft to have flown to a diversion airport. [76] The possibility of pilot error as a cause of the accident was suggested by DGCA's Arun Kumar. [79] [13] [80] [81]
Several concerns were raised on the inquiry on this incident, by Captain Mohan Ranganathan, Yeshwant Shenoy and others, that it might get covered up and the truth would never surface. [8] [11] [69] Royal Aeronautical Society fellow and aviation safety expert Amit Singh alleged that evidence in the crash site was being tampered, as few unidentified people were spotted near the wreckage, thus asked for an open investigation. [82] He also pointed out that investigations were flawed and instead of punishing real culprits, actions were taken against the pilots. [83]
The AAIB team in Kozhikode probed the incident with the assistance of Airports Authority of India officials, air traffic control, ground staff, CISF, the fire team and the rescue team. It found evidence of waterlogging of the runway at the time of landing. It also checked whether ATC was aware of waterlogging and whether the pilots adhered to rules. The preliminary investigation report was expected to be ready in a week after the accident, [57] however this did not happen. [84] The United States National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) also sent a member to assist the AAIB. [85]
A five-member committee was set up by AAIB on 13 August, to investigate the incident, with the final report to be submitted on 13 January 2021. The committee headed by Captain S.S. Chahar, former designated examiner on Boeing 737 Next Generation, was to also provide recommendations to avoid such accidents in future. [86] [87] [88] The civil aviation ministry cited delays due to the COVID-19 pandemic and granted a two-month extension to the AAIB to submit its draft final probe report on the crash. [89] [90]
On 11 September 2021 the final report was released by the Indian Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) stated that the probable cause was:
The pilot flying did not adhere to the Standard Operating Procedures (SOP) of the company, despite this, he continued the unstabilized approach and landed over the touchdown zone, halfway down the runway, despite the pilot monitoring called for a Go-around which would have permitted a necessary Go-around but the pilot monitoring failed to take the control of the airplane and making a Go-around by himself. [91]
According to the investigative team a contributory factor was a role of some systemic factors that are failed to be noticed in this accident. Similar incidents/accidents will be continue to appened mostly of this appened in AIXL, This has reinforced these systemic failures in the aviation sector. This usually happened due to this prevailing safety culture that create rise of this errors, mistakes and violations of routine duties performed by people operating within the system. Consequently, the contributory factors which were found below include both the immediate causes and the deeper or systemic causes. [91]
Vande Bharat Flight IX 1344: Hope to Survival is a 2021 Discovery+ original documentary based on the crash. The 45-minute documentary creates graphical simulations of the accident. [71] [92]
Cochin International Airport is an international airport serving the city of Kochi, Kerala, in southwestern India. It is located at Nedumbassery, about 25 km (16 mi) northeast of the city center. The airport is the first of its kind to be developed under a public-private partnership (PPP) model in India. This project was funded by nearly 10,000 non-resident Indians from 32 countries. It is the busiest and largest airport in the state of Kerala and the fourth biggest airport in South India. As of 2019, the airport caters to 61.8% of the total air passenger traffic in Kerala. It is the third busiest airport in India in terms of international traffic, and the eighth busiest overall.
Bagdogra Airport is a customs airport serving the city of Siliguri in West Bengal, India. It is located in Bagdogra, 12 km (7.5 mi) south-west from the city centre. It is operated as a civil enclave at Bagdogra Air Force Station of the Indian Air Force. It is the gateway to the hill stations of Darjeeling, Gangtok, Kurseong, Kalimpong, Mirik and other parts of North Bengal region. Siliguri, being a major transport and economic hub, the airport sees thousands of travellers and tourists annually. The Government of India conferred limited international airport status to the airport in 2002 with limited international operations to Bangkok–Suvarnabhumi and Paro. This is the second busiest airport in West Bengal.
Air India Express is an Indian low-cost airline and a wholly owned subsidiary of Indian flag carrier airline Air India. Currently it is headquartered in Gurgaon, Haryana.
Kozhikode International Airport also known as Calicut International Airport is an international airport serving the city of Malappuram and Kozhikode in the state of Kerala, India. It is located at Karipur near Kondotty in the Malappuram district of the South Malabar region. It serves the Malabar region, consisting of Malappuram, Wayanad and Palakkad. It is situated 28 km (17 mi) away from Kozhikode and 25 km (16 mi) away from Malappuram. It serves two of the seven metropolitan areas in the state—Kozhikode metropolitan area and Malappuram metropolitan area. The airport opened on 13 April 1988. The airport serves as an operating base for Air India Express and operates Hajj Pilgrimage services to Medina and Jeddah from Kerala. It is tied with Hyderabad in terms of international traffic. It received international airport status on 2 February 2006. It is one of the few airports in the country with a tabletop runway.
Fort Lauderdale Executive Airport is a general aviation airport located within the city limits of Fort Lauderdale, in Broward County, Florida, United States, five miles (8.0 km) north of downtown Fort Lauderdale. It is a division of the Transportation and Mobility Department of the City of Fort Lauderdale.
Mangalore International Airport is an international airport serving the coastal city of Mangalore, India. It is one of only two international airports in Karnataka, the other being Kempegowda International Airport, Bangalore. Mangalore International Airport is the second busiest airport in Karnataka. In addition to domestic destinations, flights depart daily for major cities in the Middle East. The airport was named Bajpe Aerodrome, when it opened on 25 December 1951 by former Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru who arrived on a Douglas DC-3 aircraft.
Lengpui Airport is a domestic airport serving Aizawl, the capital of Mizoram, India. It is located at Lengpui in the Mamit district of the state. The airport is connected by flights to Delhi, Kolkata, Guwahati, Imphal and Silchar and is located at a distance of 32 km from Aizawl. Lengpui Airport is the first airport in the country to be built by the State Government.
TAM Airlines Flight 3054 (JJ3054/TAM3054) was a regularly scheduled domestic passenger flight operated by TAM Airlines from Porto Alegre to São Paulo, Brazil. On the evening of July 17, 2007, the Airbus A320-233 serving the flight overran runway 35L at São Paulo during moderate rain and crashed into a nearby TAM Express warehouse adjacent to a Shell gas station. The plane exploded on impact, killing all 187 passengers and crew on board, as well as 12 people on the ground. An additional 27 people in the warehouse were injured. This crash surpassed Gol Transportes Aéreos Flight 1907 as the deadliest aviation accident in Brazilian territory and in South American history and was the deadliest involving the Airbus A320 series until the bombing of Metrojet Flight 9268 in 2015 which killed 224.
Sudan Airways Flight 109 was a scheduled international Amman–Damascus–Khartoum passenger flight, operated with an Airbus A310 by the flag carrier of Sudan, Sudan Airways. On 10 June 2008, at approximately 17:26 UTC, the Airbus A310 crashed on landing at Khartoum International Airport, killing 30 of the 214 occupants on board.
Turkish Airlines Flight 634 was a scheduled domestic passenger flight from Turkish Airlines' hub at Istanbul Atatürk Airport to Diyarbakır Airport in southeastern Turkey. On 8 January 2003 at 20:19 EET, the aircraft operating the flight, a British Aerospace Avro RJ100, struck the ground on final approach approximately 900 metres (3,000 ft) short of the runway threshold during inclement weather conditions. In the following collision with a slope, a post-crash fire broke out, killing 75 of the 80 occupants, including the entire crew. This is the deadliest aviation accident to involve the BAe 146.
FedEx Express Flight 80 was a scheduled cargo flight from Guangzhou Baiyun International Airport in the People's Republic of China, to Narita International Airport in Narita, Chiba Prefecture, Japan. On March 23, 2009, the McDonnell Douglas MD-11F (N526FE) operating the flight crashed at 6:48 am JST, while attempting a landing on Runway 34L in gusty wind conditions. The aircraft became destabilized at flare and touchdown resulting in an unrecovered "bounced" landing with structural failure of the landing gear and airframe, and came to rest off the runway, inverted, and burning fiercely. The captain and first officer, the jet's only occupants, were both killed.
Merpati Nusantara Airlines Flight 836 was a scheduled domestic flight between Sorong and Manokwari, Indonesia. On 13 April 2010, the flight, operated by Boeing 737-300 PK-MDE, overran the runway on landing. The aircraft broke into three pieces. All people on board survived, although 44 suffered injuries.
Air India Express Flight 812 was a scheduled international flight from Dubai International Airport, Dubai to Mangalore International Airport, Mangalore. On 22 May 2010, the Boeing 737-800 passenger jet operating the flight crashed on landing at Mangalore. The captain had continued an unstabilised approach, despite three calls from the first officer to initiate a "go-around", resulting in the aircraft overshooting the runway, falling down a hillside, and bursting into flames. Of the 166 passengers and crew on board, 158 were killed ; only eight survived. This was the first fatal accident involving Air India Express and, as of 2024, the deadliest.
A tabletop runway is a runway that is located on the top of a plateau or hill with one or both ends adjacent to a steep precipice which drops into a deep gorge. This type of runway creates an optical illusion of being at the same level as the plains below, which requires a very precise visual approach by the pilot when instrument landing is not used or not available.
Kannur International Airport is an international airport serving the city of Kannur and the North Malabar region of Kerala, Kodagu district of Karnataka and Mahé district of Puducherry in India. It is located 28 km (17 mi) east of Kannur, and 24 km (15 mi) east of Thalassery, near the municipality of Mattannur in Thalassery taluka of Kannur district. It is owned and operated by Kannur International Airport Limited (KIAL), a public–private consortium. The airport opened for commercial operations on 9 December 2018.
Baramati Airport is located in Baramati, Pune district of Maharashtra state in India. This airstrip was constructed by MIDC in 1996, at a distance of 12 km from Baramati city/ Baramati railway station. It is currently being used for general aviation and pilot training.
The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) is a division of the Ministry of Civil Aviation, Government of India which investigates aircraft accidents and incidents in India.
Pakistan International Airlines Flight 8303 was a scheduled domestic flight from Allama Iqbal International Airport in Lahore to Jinnah International Airport in Karachi, Pakistan. On 22 May 2020, the Airbus A320 crashed into Model Colony, a densely populated residential area of Karachi only a few kilometres from the runway, while on a second approach after a failed landing attempt with landing gear not extended. The aircraft was badly damaged in the first belly landing, with both engines flaming out during the go-around. Of the 91 passengers and 8 crew on board the aircraft, 97 were killed, and two passengers survived with injuries. Eight people on the ground were also injured in the accident, one of whom later succumbed to her injuries.
{{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link){{cite book}}
: |work=
ignored (help)