Anti-Korean sentiment in Japan

Last updated

A demonstration by Zaitokukai against Koreans in Japan took place in Tokyo, 2013. A woman carries a placard written "Kill all Koreans". Demonstration by zaitokukai in Tokyo 2.jpg
A demonstration by Zaitokukai against Koreans in Japan took place in Tokyo, 2013. A woman carries a placard written "Kill all Koreans".

Anti-Korean sentiment in Japan refers to opposition, hostility, hatred, distrust, fear, and other negative attitudes towards Korean people or culture in Japan. Relations between Japan and Korea date back nearly two millennia and have included cultural exchange, trade, and periods of conflict, with wars and political disputes described as contributing to later negative sentiment. [1] Much of the current anti-Korean sentiment stems from conservative politicians and far-right groups.

Contents

Ancient era

Relations between ancient Japan and Korea date back to at least the 4th century, according to historical records of ancient China, Japan, and Korea. The Book of Sui records that Silla and Baekje greatly valued relations with the Kofun-period Wa of Japan and made diplomatic efforts to maintain these relations. [2] The Samguk sagi (Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms) reported that Baekje and Silla sent princes to the Yamato court as hostages in exchange for military assistance in their campaigns; King Asin of Baekje sent his son (Jeonji) in 397, [3] and King Silseong of Silla sent his son Misaheun in 402. [4] The chronicles also report that Hogong, from Japan, helped found Silla. [5] According to the Nihon Shoki , Silla was invaded by an army from Wa (Japan) in the third century. [6] The Gwanggaeto Stele records that the king of Goguryeo assisted Silla when it was invaded and punished Baekje for its alliance with Wa, noting additional Wa expeditions in the early 5th century. [7]

During the Mongol conquests of the 13th and 14th centuries, the Goryeo dynasty of Korea became a vassal state. Under Mongolian influence, Korean envoys were sent to Japan to declare submission to the Mongols, but were rejected. [8] [9] In response, the emperor Kublai Khan launched two separate invasions in 1274 and 1281. Although both attempts to conquer Japan failed, anti-Korean sentiment had risen due to the major involvement of Korean troops participating in the invasion.[ citation needed ]

During the Joseon period, Japanese pirates known as wokou repeatedly raided Korean coastal settlements. In 1592, Toyotomi Hideyoshi ordered an invasion of Korea, starting the Imjin Wars, in which Japanese samurai occupied most of the Korean peninsula before withdrawing in 1598. During the withdrawal, the Japanese took a number of Korean craftsmen.[ citation needed ]

19th-20th century

During the Meiji Restoration, Japan implemented Western-style reforms and increased its military influence in Qing China, whose prior defeats by Western powers and associated treaties had limited its capacity to oppose Japanese initiatives. As Korea was a tributary state of China at the time, Japan used military force and diplomatic pressure to secure the 1876 Treaty of Gangwha, in which Korea granted extraterritorial rights to Japanese citizens in the country, opened the ports Busan, Incheon, and Wonsan to foreign trade, and established independence from China in conducting foreign relations. Over the following decades, the Empire of Japan restricted other foreign influence in Korea and formally annexed the country in 1910. [10] Japan maintained control of Korea until the end of World War II in 1945. Discussions of later anti‑Korean sentiment in Japan and anti‑Japanese sentiment in Korea relate these attitudes to the period of colonial rule, policies of assimilation and coercion, and disputes over historical interpretation and responsibility.[ citation needed ]

Koreans in Japan about to be stabbed by Japanese vigilantes with bamboo spears immediately after the 1923 Great Kanto earthquake (see Kanto Massacre) 1923 Kanto Massacre.jpg
Koreans in Japan about to be stabbed by Japanese vigilantes with bamboo spears immediately after the 1923 Great Kantō earthquake (see Kantō Massacre)

During the 1923 Great Kantō earthquake, widespread damage occurred in areas of the Kantō region where many Korean residents lived, and rumors spread in local Japanese communities that Koreans were poisoning wells and committing arson. This led to the killing of more than 6,000 Koreans in the area, as well as several hundred Chinese and Japanese mistaken for Koreans. [11] [12] Japanese would use the shibboleth of ba bi bu be bo (ばびぶべぼ) to distinguish ethnic Koreans from Japanese, as it was assumed that Koreans would be unable to pronounce the line correctly, and instead pronounce them as [pa,pi,pu,pe,po] . [13] [14] Other shibboleths used were "jū-go-en, go-jū-ssen" (15円 50銭; 15 yen, 50 sen) [15] and "gagigugego" (がぎぐげご), where Japanese people pronounce initial g as [ɡ] and medial g as [ŋ], whereas Koreans pronounce the two sounds as [k] and [ɡ] respectively. [16] [17]

Post-WWII history

After the end of World War II, Japanese politicians accused the Korean (and Taiwanese) minority in Japan of "insolence," bullying the Japanese, running the black market, counterfeiting currency, spreading disease, and other criminal activities. These politicians painted the minorities as a "menace" and a "source of social disorder." The accusations led to violent mob actions against Koreans in Japan. [18]

Right wing demonstration criticizing South Korea over the Liancourt Rocks dispute in February 2022 Right wing criticizing South Korea February 2022.jpg
Right wing demonstration criticizing South Korea over the Liancourt Rocks dispute in February 2022

In April 2014, several anti-Korean stickers were found posted at 13 locations along the Shikoku Pilgrimage route; the stickers were denounced by a spokesman from the Shikoku 88 Temple Pilgrimage Association. [19]

In 2021, a Japanese man set fire to an empty house in a Korean village in Utoro district, Uji. The fire spread to other properties and damaged them. He attributed his actions to his hatred of the Korean people, which was in part sparked by online rhetoric. He was sentenced to four years in prison. [20] [21]

North Korea

There are concerns in Japan regarding North Korea and its nuclear and long-range missile capabilities, as a result of missile tests in 1993, 1998 and 2006 and an underground nuclear test in 2006. There are also controversies regarding North Korean abductions of Japanese, where Japanese citizens were abducted by North Korean agents during the 1970s and 1980s. [22]

Chongryon, the North Korea-affiliated organization for ethnic Koreans in Japan, has continually drawn controversy from the Japanese public. [23]

"Anti-Korean Wave" protest against Fuji Television's broadcasting of Korean media in Odaiba, Tokyo, 2011 (Fuji TV protest demonstration [ja]). Anti-Korean Wave Protest against Fuji Television in Odaiba, Tokyo. 2011-08-07 (2).jpg
"Anti-Korean Wave" protest against Fuji Television's broadcasting of Korean media in Odaiba, Tokyo, 2011 (Fuji TV protest demonstration  [ ja ]).

South Korea

During the 2002 FIFA World Cup, Japanese and Korean supporters clashed with one another. Both sides were known to post racist messages against each other on online bulletin boards. There were disputes on host selection as a result of the rivalry between the two nations.

The Korean Wave, or the exportation of South Korean pop culture, has created negative feelings among pockets of Japanese society. Many Japanese citizens with conservative views and some right-wing nationalist groups have organized anti-Korean Wave demonstrations via 2channel. On 9 August 2011, more than 2,000 people protested against the broadcasting of Korean dramas in front of Fuji TV's headquarters in Odaiba, Tokyo. [24] In July 2011, Japanese former actor Sousuke Takaoka was fired from his agency, Stardust Promotion, for tweeting criticisms against the influx of Korean dramas. [25] The general perception of Koreans on 2channel is negative, with users depicting them as violent, unethical, and irrational people who are a 'threat' to Japan. [26] Users often reference stereotypes of Koreans, such as the use of dogs in Korean cuisine. [27]

The United States Institute of Peace analyzed that the dispute between Japan and South Korea results from anti-Korean xenophobia. According to their analysis, Japan's repeated historical negativism, territorial disputes, and failure of diplomatic agreements are also manifestations of anti-Korean xenophobia. [28]

Kenkan

In Japanese bookstores, Kenkan (嫌韓, "Hatred for [South] Koreans") is recognized as a book genre. There are no Hyomil (혐일;嫌日;lit. Hatred for Japanese) books in South Korean bookstores; there is a segment for books specifically covering Korea under colonial rule. [29] Kenkan books grew in numbers during 2012, and slowly disappeared after a law countering hate speech was enacted in 2016. [30]

Territorial dispute

2019–2020 Japan–South Korea trade dispute

Historical revisionism

The South Korean media has accused Japanese people of continuing to support historical revisionism against Korean victims, apologizing for Chinese victims in the World War II issue of Japanese war crimes. [31] [32]

Comfort women issue

Several South Korean media have criticized that, except for some left-wing socialist political parties (mainly Social Democratic Party and Japanese Communist Party), major Japanese politicians and political parties often have historical revisionist perceptions of the comfort women issue. Fumio Kishida called on the German government to remove the Statue of Peace in Berlin, which has caused considerable controversy in South Korea. [33] [34] The Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan and the Liberal Democratic Party, have called on the South Korean government to remove the Statue of Peace, [35] with some suggesting that there was no evidence to indicate that Japanese authorities coerced Korean women into sexual slavery. [36] In 2015, the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs claimed that the issue was settled, after talks between the ministers of foreign affairs on both sides; this was overturned in 2017, when President Moon Jae-in claimed that the agreement does not settle the issue. [37]

Japanese textbook revisionism

On June 26, 1982, the textbook screening process in Japan came under scrutiny when the Japanese media and its neighboring countries covered the changes required by the Minister of Education. Experts from the ministry sought to soften textbook references to Japanese aggression before and during World War II. For example, the Japanese invasion of China in 1937 was modified to "advance". Passages described the Japanese atrocities during the fall of Nanking as a result of Chinese provocations. Pressure from China led the Ministry of Education to adopt a new authorization criterion--the "Neighboring Country Clause" (近隣諸国条項)--stating: "textbooks ought to show understanding and seek international harmony in their treatment of modern and contemporary historical events involving neighboring Asian countries." [38]

In 2006, Japanese textbooks stated that the Liancourt Rocks is Japanese territory. This island is disputed territory claimed by both Japan and South Korea. On May 9, 2007, The head of the South Korean Ministry of Education, Kim Shin-il, sent a letter of protest to Bunmei Ibuki, the Minister of Education. [39] In a speech marking the 88th anniversary of the March First Independence Movement, South Korean President Roh Moo-hyun called for Japan to correct its school textbooks on topics ranging from the "inhumane rape of comfort women" to "the Korean ownership of the Liancourt Rocks". [40] The Liberal Democratic Party, notably the Shinzo Abe administration, has been criticized for historical revisionism tendencies. [41] The Japanese Society for Historical Studies has criticized the party's intervention against textbook writers and its ban on words and phrases such as "comfort women". [42] [43]

Politics

Many major South Korean media outlets point out that the Liberal Democratic Party and its politicians express anti-Korean sentiment, and that the party's main support base is "hatred for [South] Koreans". [44] [45] [46]

A Japanese right-wing group known as Zaitokukai is organized by members on the internet and has led street demonstrations against Korean schools. [47]

On March 27, 2010, the centennial of Japan–Korean annexation, Yukio Edano, the Japanese Minister of State for Government Revitalization at the time, stated that "The invasion and colonization and China and Korea were historically inevitable. . . since China and Korea could not modernize themselves." Yukio Edano is known as a liberal politician in Japan. [48]

In the South Korean media, most Japanese people and almost all major Japanese media criticize the view of South Korean politics for being biased and for portraying or loathing South Korean liberals in a negative way. [49] [50] [a] Korean media claims that, the Asahi Shimbun , known in Japan as a Japanese liberal media outlet, reports on the South Korean liberal Moon Jae-in government using biased and insulting expressions. [51] [52]

According to Michael J. Green in January 2022, presidential candidates in the 2022 South Korean presidential election are willing to improve relations with Japan, but Japanese political leaders have analyzed that they are not. [53]

See also

Notes

  1. Most South Korean liberals take the view that the Japanese government should provide proper individual compensation for the South Korean victims of Japanese war crimes. In contrast, many Japanese take the view that the compensation issue has already been closed due to the Treaty on Basic Relations Between Japan and the Republic of Korea. This is an element of the Japan-Korea conflict.

References

  1. Tong, Kurt W.; Program, MIT Japan (1996). "Anti-Korean sentiment in Japan and its effects on Korea-Japan trade". MIT Japan Program. MIT Center for International Studies. hdl:1721.1/16581.
  2. Chinese History Record Book of Sui, Vol. 81, Liezhuan 46 : 隋書 東夷伝 第81巻列伝46 : 新羅、百濟皆以倭為大國,多珍物,並敬仰之,恆通使往來 "Silla and Baekje both take Wa to be a great country, with many rare and precious things; also [Silla and Baekje] respect and look up to them, and regularly send embassies there." "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2004-12-21. Retrieved 2006-04-29.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
  3. Korean History Record Samguk sagi  : 三國史記 新羅本紀 : 元年 三月 與倭國通好 以奈勿王子未斯欣爲質
  4. Korean History Record Samguk sagi  : 三國史記 百済本紀 : 六年夏五月 王與倭國結好 以太子腆支爲質 秋七月大閱於漢水之南  아신왕 - 삼국사기 백제본기- 디지털한국학. Archived from the original on 2008-05-12. Retrieved 2008-05-12.
  5. Korean History Record Samguk sagi :三國史記 卷第一 新羅本紀第一 始祖赫居世, 瓠公者 未詳其族姓 本倭人
  6. Sakamoto (1967:336-340)
  7. Mohan, Pankaj N (2004). "Rescuing a Stone from Nationalism: A Fresh Look at the Kwanggaeto Stele of Koguryo". Journal of Inner and East Asian Studies. 1: 89–115.
  8. 元寇 (in Japanese). Japan Knowledge. Archived from the original on 5 October 2022. Retrieved 29 January 2023.
  9. "Joint project celebrating the 50th anniversary of Japan-Mongolia diplomatic relations. Relations between Japan and Mongolia in the 13th century". National Archives of Japan. Archived from the original on 25 August 2022. Retrieved 29 January 2023.
  10. "Treaty of Annexation". USC-UCLA Joint East Asian Studies Center. Archived from the original on 11 February 2007. Retrieved 19 February 2007.
  11. "関東大震災時の朝鮮人虐殺とその後―虐殺の国家責任と民衆責任". Harvard-Yenching Institute. Retrieved 2025-12-31.
  12. "The Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923". library.brown.edu. Retrieved 2025-12-31.
  13. Cybriwsky, Roman (1991). Tokyo: The Changing Profile of an Urban Giant. London: Belhaven Press. p. 81. ISBN   978-1-85293-054-7.
  14. 조선일보 (2020-07-28). "[관동대학살 90년] "주고엔 고짓센(한국인이 발음 어려운 일본어·15엔 50전이란 뜻) 발음해봐"… 조선인 색출해 길거리서 칼·죽창 살해". 조선일보 (in Korean). Retrieved 2025-10-23.
  15. 조선일보 (2020-07-28). "[관동대학살 90년] "주고엔 고짓센(한국인이 발음 어려운 일본어·15엔 50전이란 뜻) 발음해봐"… 조선인 색출해 길거리서 칼·죽창 살해". 조선일보 (in Korean). Retrieved 2025-10-23.
  16. L, Aaron (2007-09-03). "The Tongue That Divided Life and Death. The 1923 Tokyo Earthquake and the Massacre of Koreans". Asia-Pacific Journal: Japan Focus. Retrieved 2025-12-31.
  17. 安田, 敏朗; Yasuda, Toshiaki (March 2015). "Groundless rumors as a medium : The massacre of Korean residents after the Great Kanto Earthquake and "15 yen 50 sen"". JunCture : 超域的日本文化研究. 6: 56–69. doi:10.18999/juncture.6.56. ISSN   1884-4766.
  18. Deokhyo Choi (2021). "The Empire Strikes Back from Within: Colonial Liberation and the Korean Minority Question at the Birth of Postwar Japan, 1945–47". The American Historical Review. 126 (2): 555–584. doi:10.1093/ahr/rhab199.
  19. "Anti-Korean stickers posted at several points along Shikoku pilgrimage route". Japan Today . April 11, 2014. Archived from the original on April 6, 2022.
  20. "Man given 4 years in prison for arson in Korean community in Kyoto". Kyodo News+. August 30, 2022. Retrieved 2023-09-19.
  21. Tokunaga, Takeshiro (August 30, 2022). "Man gets 4 years in prison for arson in ethnic Korean district". The Asahi Shimbun . Retrieved 2023-09-19.
  22. "Abductions of Japanese Citizens by North Korea". Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan. Retrieved 2020-11-27.
  23. Tetsuaki, Otaki (22 November 2022). "Students at Korean schools harassed over missile launches". The Asahi Shimbun . Retrieved 2023-05-05.
  24. "Japan's alt-right groups hold rallies vs. Korean pop culture". The Dong-A Ilbo . 9 August 2011. Retrieved 11 August 2011.
  25. "Hundreds of Japanese Protest Against Korean Wave". The Chosun Ilbo . 9 August 2011. Archived from the original on 12 September 2011. Retrieved 11 August 2011.
  26. Rumi Sakamoto (March 7, 2011). "'Koreans, Go Home!' Internet Nationalism in Contemporary Japan as a Digitally Mediated Subculture". The Asia-Pacific Journal: Japan Focus. University of Auckland.
  27. Mclelland, Mark (December 2008). "'Race' on the Japanese internet: discussing Korea and Koreans on '2-channeru'". New Media and Society. 10 (6): 811–829. CiteSeerX   10.1.1.691.4872 . doi:10.1177/1461444808096246. S2CID   10037117.
  28. "How to Address the Racism at the Heart of Japan-South Korea Tensions". United States Institute of Peace. 17 January 2023. Archived from the original on January 17, 2023. Retrieved 2 May 2023. Anti-Korean racism is at the heart of historic and unresolved tensions between Japan and South Korea. It will be near impossible to resolve disputes like the comfort women issue without addressing this racism. This is because the difficulty in reaching a consensus on the Japanese side often derives from the underlying tendency among many Japanese to view Koreans as "inferior" and "untrustworthy." U.S. actors, including officials, businesses and academics, should understand the consequences of the important role they have played in perpetuating such prejudice and help right this wrong. ... We tend to think of Korean-Japanese tensions in terms of topic areas, such as Japan's recurring historical denialism, the territorial dispute and the failure of diplomatic arrangements. But these tensions are largely manifestations of racism, not the cause of it, and they will persist as long as racism itself remains unaddressed.
  29. "韓国の書店で「日本ヘイト本」を探してみた結果 「韓国にヘイト本はない」はずが… (2ページ目)". PRESIDENT Online(プレジデントオンライン) (in Japanese). 2020-02-20. Retrieved 2025-08-29.
  30. "Listening:<「嫌中嫌韓」本>出版人の責務は 異議や対応を討論". 毎日新聞 (in Japanese). Retrieved 2025-08-29.
  31. 조. 준. 형. (24 July 2015). 중국 노동자 피해보상 미쓰비시, 한국 피해자는 외면하나. 연합뉴스. 연합뉴스 . Retrieved 6 March 2023.
  32. 일, 강제노역 사과 중국에만···반크 "사도광산 유네스코 등재 반대". Kyunghyang Shinmun (in Korean). 23 July 2022. Retrieved 29 November 2022.
  33. 김. 호. 준. (11 May 2022). 기시다, 독일 총리에 소녀상 철거 요청…"반응 안 좋아"(종합2보) [Kishida called on the German Chancellor to remove the Statue of Peace... Kishida said, ""[German Chancellor] did not respond well."]. 연합뉴스 .
  34. 일본 극우, 도쿄에서 '위안부 피해자 모욕' 행사 개최 ... "짐승만도 못한 짓" 비판. 경향신문 . 27 May 2022.
  35. 화이트리스트 복원도 적반하장…일본 "한국 자세에 달렸다". Kyunghyang Shinmun (in Korean). 17 March 2023. Archived from the original on 19 March 2023. 제1야당인 입헌민주당의 이즈미 겐타 대표는 이날 윤 대통령과 만나 한·일 갈등 현안인 '레이더-초계기' 문제와 소녀상 건립 문제를 언급했다고 밝혔다. 입헌민주당은 그동안 소녀상 철거를 요구해왔다.
  36. "Yoon visits Japan, seeking to restore ties amid N Korea threat". Al Jazeera . 16 March 2023. Archived from the original on 21 March 2023.
  37. 貴郎, 原川 (2024-08-04). "慰安婦問題を巡る日韓合意で「最終的かつ不可逆的な解決」 韓国は履行せず 朝日慰安婦報道取り消し10年". 産経新聞:産経ニュース (in Japanese). Retrieved 2025-08-04.
  38. Murai Atsushi, "Abolish the Textbook Authorization System", Japan Echo, (Aug. 2001): 28.
  39. "Ed. Minister Protests Distortions in Japanese Textbooks" Archived May 13, 2007, at the Wayback Machine , The Chosun Ilbo, May 10, 2007.
  40. "Roh Calls on Japan to Respect Historical Truth" Archived March 13, 2007, at the Wayback Machine , The Chosun Ilbo , Mar.2, 2007.
  41. "Shinzo Abe: Revisionist nationalist or pragmatic realist?". 2020-08-28. Retrieved 2025-08-04.
  42. 事務所 (2022-09-21). "教科書記述に対する日本政府の政治介入を憂慮する - 日本史研究会". 日本史研究会 - 京都に拠点を置く日本史研究会のサイトです。 (in Japanese). Retrieved 2025-08-04.
  43. "「従軍慰安婦」「強制連行」の記述 教科書7社なぜ訂正 どう変わる:朝日新聞". 朝日新聞 (in Japanese). 2021-10-31. Retrieved 2025-08-04.
  44. "일본 전철에 한글 표기는 낭비" 日 정치인 혐한 트윗. YTN. 22 July 2019.
  45. "한국은 약속이라는 개념이 없다"… 日정부, 혐한 분위기 팽배. 조선일보. 15 February 2021.
  46. "일방적 구애" 대일 저자세 외교…과정도 결과도 부적절했다. The Hankyoreh. 23 September 2022. 기시다 총리로선 확실한 지지기반인 '반한·혐한' 세력의 반대를 무릅쓰고, 한-일 관계 개선을 위한 정상회담에 나설 국내 정치적 동기가 약하다는 뜻이다.
  47. Martin Fackler, August 28, 2010, New Dissent in Japan Is Loudly Anti-Foreign, New York Times
  48. [서울신문][사설] 되풀이되는 日 고위직 망언 구제불능인가. Seoul Shinmun . 29 March 2010. Retrieved January 2, 2016.
  49. 아사히신문 마저도 '문재인 정권' 탓. 피렌체의 식탁. 7 January 2020. Retrieved 20 March 2023.
  50. ""문재인, 비참한 말로", "文, 목숨을 구걸하나"...벌거벗은 日언론". Seoul Shinmun . 22 April 2022. Retrieved 20 March 2023.
  51. "日 아사히, 한국은 '후미에(踏み絵)', 문 정부는 사면초가". Seoul Shinmun . 26 June 2019. Retrieved 2 May 2023.
  52. 청와대, 일본 아사히신문에 이례적으로 '무기한 출입정지'. 중앙일보. 18 May 2018. Retrieved 20 March 2023.
  53. "한국 대선 결과, 바이든 행정부 아시아 정책에 상당한 영향". Voice of America. 27 January 2022.