Closed graph theorem

This article is about closed graph theorems in general topology. For the closed graph theorem in functional analysis, see Closed graph theorem (functional analysis).

The graph of the cubic function ${\displaystyle f(x)=x^{3}-9x}$ on the interval ${\displaystyle [-4,4]}$ is closed because the function is continuous. The graph of the Heaviside function on ${\displaystyle [-2,2]}$ is not closed, because the function is not continuous.

In mathematics, the closed graph theorem may refer to one of several basic results characterizing continuous functions in terms of their graphs. Each gives conditions when functions with closed graphs are necessarily continuous.

A blog post ^[1] by T. Tao lists several closed graph theorems throughout mathematics.

Graphs and maps with closed graphs

Main article: Closed graph

If ${\displaystyle f:X\to Y}$ is a map between topological spaces then the graph of ${\displaystyle f}$ is the set ${\displaystyle \Gamma _{f}:=\{(x,f(x)):x\in X\}}$ or equivalently, $${\displaystyle \Gamma _{f}:=\{(x,y)\in X\times Y:y=f(x)\}}$$ It is said that the graph of ${\displaystyle f}$ is closed if ${\displaystyle \Gamma _{f}}$ is a closed subset of ${\displaystyle X\times Y}$ (with the product topology).

Any continuous function into a Hausdorff space has a closed graph (see § Closed graph theorem in point-set topology)

Any linear map, ${\displaystyle L:X\to Y,}$ between two topological vector spaces whose topologies are (Cauchy) complete with respect to translation invariant metrics, and if in addition (1a) ${\displaystyle L}$ is sequentially continuous in the sense of the product topology, then the map ${\displaystyle L}$ is continuous and its graph, Gr L, is necessarily closed. Conversely, if ${\displaystyle L}$ is such a linear map with, in place of (1a), the graph of ${\displaystyle L}$ is (1b) known to be closed in the Cartesian product space ${\displaystyle X\times Y}$, then ${\displaystyle L}$ is continuous and therefore necessarily sequentially continuous. ^[2]

Examples of continuous maps that do not have a closed graph

If ${\displaystyle X}$ is any space then the identity map ${\displaystyle \operatorname {Id} :X\to X}$ is continuous but its graph, which is the diagonal ${\displaystyle \Gamma _{\operatorname {Id} }:=\{(x,x):x\in X\},}$, is closed in ${\displaystyle X\times X}$ if and only if ${\displaystyle X}$ is Hausdorff. ^[3] In particular, if ${\displaystyle X}$ is not Hausdorff then ${\displaystyle \operatorname {Id} :X\to X}$ is continuous but does not have a closed graph.

Let ${\displaystyle X}$ denote the real numbers ${\displaystyle \mathbb {R} }$ with the usual Euclidean topology and let ${\displaystyle Y}$ denote ${\displaystyle \mathbb {R} }$ with the indiscrete topology (where note that ${\displaystyle Y}$ is not Hausdorff and that every function valued in ${\displaystyle Y}$ is continuous). Let ${\displaystyle f:X\to Y}$ be defined by ${\displaystyle f(0)=1}$ and ${\displaystyle f(x)=0}$ for all ${\displaystyle x\neq 0}$. Then ${\displaystyle f:X\to Y}$ is continuous but its graph is not closed in ${\displaystyle X\times Y}$. ^[4]

Closed graph theorem in point-set topology

In point-set topology, the closed graph theorem states the following:

Closed graph theorem ^[5]  — If ${\displaystyle f:X\to Y}$ is a map from a topological space ${\displaystyle X}$ into a Hausdorff space ${\displaystyle Y,}$ then the graph of ${\displaystyle f}$ is closed if ${\displaystyle f:X\to Y}$ is continuous. The converse is true when ${\displaystyle Y}$ is compact. (Note that compactness and Hausdorffness do not imply each other.)

Proof

First part: just note that the graph of ${\displaystyle f}$ is the same as the pre-image ${\displaystyle (f\times \operatorname {id} _{Y})^{-1}(D)}$ where ${\displaystyle D=\{(y,y)\mid y\in Y\}}$ is the diagonal in ${\displaystyle Y^{2}}$.

Second part:

For any open ${\displaystyle V\subset Y}$ , we check ${\displaystyle f^{-1}(V)}$ is open. So take any ${\displaystyle x\in f^{-1}(V)}$ , we construct some open neighborhood ${\displaystyle U}$ of ${\displaystyle x}$ , such that ${\displaystyle f(U)\subset V}$ .

Since the graph of ${\displaystyle f}$ is closed, for every point ${\displaystyle (x,y')}$ on the "vertical line at x", with ${\displaystyle y'\neq f(x)}$ , draw an open rectangle ${\displaystyle U_{y'}\times V_{y'}}$ disjoint from the graph of ${\displaystyle f}$ . These open rectangles, when projected to the y-axis, cover the y-axis except at ${\displaystyle f(x)}$ , so add one more set ${\displaystyle V}$.

Naively attempting to take ${\displaystyle U:=\bigcap _{y'\neq f(x)}U_{y'}}$ would construct a set containing ${\displaystyle x}$, but it is not guaranteed to be open, so we use compactness here.

Since ${\displaystyle Y}$ is compact, we can take a finite open covering of ${\displaystyle Y}$ as ${\displaystyle \{V,V_{y'_{1}},...,V_{y'_{n}}\}}$.

Now take ${\displaystyle U:=\bigcap _{i=1}^{n}U_{y'_{i}}}$. It is an open neighborhood of ${\displaystyle x}$, since it is merely a finite intersection. We claim this is the open neighborhood of ${\displaystyle U}$ that we want.

Suppose not, then there is some unruly ${\displaystyle x'\in U}$ such that ${\displaystyle f(x')\not \in V}$ , then that would imply ${\displaystyle f(x')\in V_{y'_{i}}}$ for some ${\displaystyle i}$ by open covering, but then ${\displaystyle (x',f(x'))\in U\times V_{y'_{i}}\subset U_{y'_{i}}\times V_{y'_{i}}}$ , a contradiction since it is supposed to be disjoint from the graph of ${\displaystyle f}$ .

If X, Y are compact Hausdorff spaces, then the theorem can also be deduced from the open mapping theorem for such spaces; see § Relation to the open mapping theorem.

Non-Hausdorff spaces are rarely seen, but non-compact spaces are common. An example of non-compact ${\displaystyle Y}$ is the real line, which allows the discontinuous function with closed graph ${\displaystyle f(x)={\begin{cases}{\frac {1}{x}}{\text{ if }}x\neq 0,\\0{\text{ else}}\end{cases}}}$.

Also, closed linear operators in functional analysis (linear operators with closed graphs) are typically not continuous.

For set-valued functions

Closed graph theorem for set-valued functions ^[6]  — For a Hausdorff compact range space ${\displaystyle Y}$, a set-valued function ${\displaystyle F:X\to 2^{Y}}$ has a closed graph if and only if it is upper hemicontinuous and F(x) is a closed set for all ${\displaystyle x\in X}$.

In functional analysis

Main article: Closed graph theorem (functional analysis)

If ${\displaystyle T:X\to Y}$ is a linear operator between topological vector spaces (TVSs) then we say that ${\displaystyle T}$ is a closed operator if the graph of ${\displaystyle T}$ is closed in ${\displaystyle X\times Y}$ when ${\displaystyle X\times Y}$ is endowed with the product topology.

The closed graph theorem is an important result in functional analysis that guarantees that a closed linear operator is continuous under certain conditions. The original result has been generalized many times. A well known version of the closed graph theorems is the following.

Theorem ^{[7] [8]}  — A linear map between two F-spaces (e.g. Banach spaces) is continuous if and only if its graph is closed.

The theorem is a consequence of the open mapping theorem; see § Relation to the open mapping theorem below (conversely, the open mapping theorem in turn can be deduced from the closed graph theorem).

Relation to the open mapping theorem

Often, the closed graph theorems are obtained as corollaries of the open mapping theorems in the following way. ^{[1] [9]} Let ${\displaystyle f:X\to Y}$ be any map. Then it factors as

${\displaystyle f:X{\overset {i}{\to }}\Gamma _{f}{\overset {q}{\to }}Y}$.

Now, ${\displaystyle i}$ is the inverse of the projection ${\displaystyle p:\Gamma _{f}\to X}$. So, if the open mapping theorem holds for ${\displaystyle p}$; i.e., ${\displaystyle p}$ is an open mapping, then ${\displaystyle i}$ is continuous and then ${\displaystyle f}$ is continuous (as the composition of continuous maps).

For example, the above argument applies if ${\displaystyle f}$ is a linear operator between Banach spaces with closed graph, or if ${\displaystyle f}$ is a map with closed graph between compact Hausdorff spaces.

See also

• Almost open linear map  – Map that satisfies a condition similar to that of being an open map.Pages displaying short descriptions of redirect targets
• Barrelled space  – Type of topological vector space
• Closed graph  – Graph of a map closed in the product spacePages displaying short descriptions of redirect targets
• Closed linear operator
• Discontinuous linear map
• Kakutani fixed-point theorem  – Fixed-point theorem for set-valued functions
• Open mapping theorem (functional analysis)  – Condition for a linear operator to be open
• Ursescu theorem  – Generalization of closed graph, open mapping, and uniform boundedness theorem
• Webbed space  – Space where open mapping and closed graph theorems hold
• Zariski's main theorem  – Theorem of algebraic geometry and commutative algebra

References

1. https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2012/11/20/the-closed-graph-theorem-in-various-categories/
2. Rudin 1991, p. 51-52.
3. Rudin 1991, p. 50.
4. Narici & Beckenstein 2011, pp. 459–483.
5. Munkres 2000, pp. 163–172.
6. Aliprantis, Charlambos; Kim C. Border (1999). "Chapter 17". Infinite Dimensional Analysis: A Hitchhiker's Guide (3rd ed.). Springer.
7. Schaefer & Wolff 1999, p. 78.
8. Trèves (2006), p. 173
9. https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03904

Bibliography

• Bourbaki, Nicolas (1987) [1981]. Topological Vector Spaces: Chapters 1–5. Éléments de mathématique. Translated by Eggleston, H.G.; Madan, S. Berlin New York: Springer-Verlag. ISBN   3-540-13627-4. OCLC   17499190.
• Folland, Gerald B. (1984), Real Analysis: Modern Techniques and Their Applications (1st ed.), John Wiley & Sons, ISBN   978-0-471-80958-6
• Jarchow, Hans (1981). Locally convex spaces. Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner. ISBN   978-3-519-02224-4. OCLC   8210342.
• Köthe, Gottfried (1983) [1969]. Topological Vector Spaces I. Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften. Vol. 159. Translated by Garling, D.J.H. New York: Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN   978-3-642-64988-2. MR   0248498. OCLC   840293704.
• Munkres, James R. (2000). Topology (2nd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, Inc. ISBN   978-0-13-181629-9. OCLC   42683260.
• Narici, Lawrence; Beckenstein, Edward (2011). Topological Vector Spaces. Pure and applied mathematics (Second ed.). Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. ISBN   978-1584888666. OCLC   144216834.
• Rudin, Walter (1991). Functional Analysis. International Series in Pure and Applied Mathematics. Vol. 8 (Second ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Science/Engineering/Math. ISBN   978-0-07-054236-5. OCLC   21163277.
• Schaefer, Helmut H.; Wolff, Manfred P. (1999). Topological Vector Spaces. GTM. Vol. 8 (Second ed.). New York, NY: Springer New York Imprint Springer. ISBN   978-1-4612-7155-0. OCLC   840278135.
• Trèves, François (2006) [1967]. Topological Vector Spaces, Distributions and Kernels. Mineola, N.Y.: Dover Publications. ISBN   978-0-486-45352-1. OCLC   853623322.
• Wilansky, Albert (2013). Modern Methods in Topological Vector Spaces. Mineola, New York: Dover Publications, Inc. ISBN   978-0-486-49353-4. OCLC   849801114.
• Zălinescu, Constantin (30 July 2002). Convex Analysis in General Vector Spaces . River Edge, N.J. London: World Scientific Publishing. ISBN   978-981-4488-15-0. MR   1921556. OCLC   285163112 – via Internet Archive.
• "Proof of closed graph theorem". PlanetMath .