Eurasian treecreeper

Last updated

Eurasian treecreeper
Eurasian Treecreeper in the snow, cropped version.jpg
Contact calls recorded in Surrey, England
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Aves
Order: Passeriformes
Family: Certhiidae
Genus: Certhia
Species:
C. familiaris
Binomial name
Certhia familiaris
Treecreepermap.png
Green – resident all year

Blue – winter visitor only
Magenta – subspecies now often split as
Hodgson's treecreeper

Contents

The Eurasian treecreeper or common treecreeper (Certhia familiaris) is a small passerine bird also known in the British Isles, where it is the only living member of its genus, simply as treecreeper. It is similar to other treecreepers, and has a curved bill, patterned brown upperparts, whitish underparts, and long stiff tail feathers which help it creep up tree trunks. It can be most easily distinguished from the similar short-toed treecreeper, which shares much of its European range, by its different song.

The Eurasian treecreeper has nine or more subspecies which breed in different parts of its range in the Palearctic. This species is found in woodlands of all kinds, but where it overlaps with the short-toed treecreeper in western Europe it is more likely to be found in coniferous forests or at higher altitudes. It nests in tree crevices or behind bark flakes, and favours introduced giant sequoia as nest sites where they are available. The female typically lays five or six pink-speckled white eggs in the lined nest, but eggs and chicks are vulnerable to attack by woodpeckers and mammals, including squirrels.

The Eurasian treecreeper is insectivorous and climbs up tree trunks like a mouse, to search for insects which it picks from crevices in the bark with its fine curved bill. It then flies to the base of another tree with a distinctive erratic flight. This bird is solitary in winter, but may form communal roosts in cold weather.

Description

A Eurasian treecreeper climbing up a tree, leaning on its tail Certhia familiaris 1 (Martin Mecnarowski).jpg
A Eurasian treecreeper climbing up a tree, leaning on its tail

Similar in appearance, all treecreepers are small birds with streaked and spotted brown upperparts, rufous rumps and whitish underparts. They have long decurved bills, and long rigid tail feathers that provide support as they creep up tree trunks looking for insects. [2]

The Eurasian treecreeper is 12.5 cm (4.9 in) long and weighs 7.012.9  g (0.250.46  oz). It has warm brown upperparts intricately patterned with black, buff and white, and a plain brown tail. Its belly, flanks and vent area are tinged with buff. The sexes are similar, but the juvenile has duller upperparts than the adult, and its underparts are dull white with dark fine spotting on the flanks. [2]

The contact call is a very quiet, thin and high-pitched sit, but the most distinctive call is a penetrating tsree, with a vibrato quality, sometimes repeated as a series of notes. The male's song begins with srrih, srrih followed in turn by a few twittering notes, a longer descending ripple, and a whistle that falls and then rises. [2]

The range of the Eurasian treecreeper overlaps with that of several other treecreepers, which can present local identification problems. In Europe, the Eurasian treecreeper shares much of its range with the short-toed treecreeper. Compared to that species, it is whiter below, warmer and more spotted above, and has a whiter supercilium and slightly shorter bill. Visual identification, even in the hand, may be impossible for poorly marked birds. A singing treecreeper is usually identifiable, since short-toed treecreeper has a distinctive series of evenly spaced notes sounding quite different from the song of Eurasian treecreeper; however, both species have been known to sing the other's song. [2]

Three Himalayan subspecies of Eurasian treecreeper are now sometimes given full species status as Hodgson's treecreeper, for example by BirdLife International, [3] but if they are retained as subspecies of Eurasian, they have to be distinguished from three other South Asian treecreepers. The plain tail of Eurasian treecreeper differentiates it from bar-tailed treecreeper, which has a distinctive barred tail pattern, and its white throat is an obvious difference from brown-throated treecreeper. Rusty-flanked treecreeper is more difficult to separate from Eurasian, but has more contrasting cinnamon, rather than buff, flanks. [2]

The North American brown creeper has never been recorded in Europe, but an autumn vagrant would be difficult to identify, since it would not be singing, and the American species' call is much like that of Eurasian treecreeper. In appearance, brown creeper is more like short-toed than Eurasian, but a vagrant might still not be possible to identify with certainty given the similarities between the three species. [2]

Taxonomy

Short-toed treecreeper, a confusion species in Europe Boomkruiper1reversed.jpg
Short-toed treecreeper, a confusion species in Europe

The Eurasian treecreeper was first described under its current scientific name by Linnaeus in his Systema naturae in 1758. [4] The binomial name is derived from Ancient Greek kerthios, a small tree-dwelling bird described by Aristotle and others, and Latin familiaris, familiar or common. [5]

This species is one of a group of very similar typical treecreeper species, all placed in the single genus Certhia . Eight species are currently recognised, in two evolutionary lineages: a Holarctic radiation, and a southern Asian group. The Holarctic group has a more warbling song, always (except in C. familiaris from China) starting or ending with a shrill sreeh. Species in the southern group, in contrast, have a faster-paced trill without the sreeh sound. All the species have distinctive vocalizations and some subspecies have been elevated to species on the basis of their calls. [6]

The Eurasian treecreeper belongs to the northern group, along with the North American brown creeper, C. americana, the short-toed treecreeper, C. brachydactyla, of western Eurasia, and, if it is considered a separate species, Hodgson's treecreeper, C. hodgsoni, from the southern rim of the Himalayas. [7]

The brown creeper has sometimes been considered to be a subspecies of Eurasian treecreeper, but has closer affinities to short-toed treecreeper, and is normally now treated as a full species. [2] Hodgson's treecreeper is a more recent proposed split following studies of its cytochrome b mtDNA sequence and song structure that indicate that it may well be a distinct species from C. familiaris. [7]

There are nine to twelve subspecies of Eurasian treecreeper, depending on the taxonomic view taken, which are all very similar and often interbreed in areas where their ranges overlap. There is a general cline in appearance from west to east across Eurasia, with subspecies becoming greyer above and whiter below, but this trend reverses east of the Amur River. The currently recognised subspecies are as follows: [2]

SubspeciesRangeNotes [2]
C. f. britannica Great Britain and Ireland Irish treecreepers, slightly darker than British ones, have sometimes been given subspecific status
C. f. macrodactylaWestern Europe Paler above and whiter below than C. f. britannica
C. f. corsa Corsica Buff-tinged underparts and more contrasted upperparts than C. f. macrodactyla
C. f. familiaris Scandinavia and eastern Europe east to western Siberia Nominate subspecies. Paler above than C. f. macrodactyla, white underparts
C. f. dauricaEastern Siberia, northern Mongolia Paler and greyer than the nominate subspecies
C. f. orientalisAmur basin, northeast China, Korea and Hokkaido, JapanSimilar to nominate, but with stronger streaking above
C. f. japonica Japan south of HokkaidoDarker and more rufous than C. f. daurica
C. f. persicaThe Crimea and Turkey east to northern Iran Duller and less rufous than the nominate form
C. f. tianchanicaNorthwestern China and adjacent regions of the former USSR Paler and more rufous than nominate subspecies
C. f. hodgsoniWestern Himalayas of, Kashmir Often treated as a full species, Hodgson's treecreeper, C. hodgsonii. [7]
C. f. mandelliiEastern Himalayas of India, Nepal Often now treated as a subspecies of Hodgson's treecreeper
C. f. khamensisChina, Sichuan Often now treated as a subspecies of Hodgson's treecreeper

Distribution and habitat

Central European bird feeding on a trunk 474px-Certhia familiariscroppedmirror.jpg
Central European bird feeding on a trunk

The Eurasian treecreeper is the most widespread member of its genus, breeding in temperate woodlands across the Palearctic from Ireland to Japan. It prefers mature trees, and in most of Europe, where it shares its range with short-toed treecreeper, it tends to be found mainly in coniferous forest, especially spruce and fir. However, where it is the only treecreeper, as in European Russia, [2] or the British Isles, [5] it frequents broadleaved or mixed woodland in preference to conifers. It is also found in parks and large gardens.

The Eurasian treecreeper breeds down to sea level in the north of its range, but tends to be a highland species further south. In the Pyrenees it breeds above 1,370 metres (4,490 feet), in China from 400–2,100 metres (1,300–6,900 ft) and in southern Japan from 1,065–2,135 metres (3,494–7,005 ft). [2] The breeding areas have July isotherms between 1416 °C and 23–24 °C (73–75 °F) and 7273 °F). [8]

The Eurasian treecreeper is non-migratory in the milder west and south of its breeding range, but some northern birds move south in winter, and individuals breeding on mountains may descend to a lower altitude in winter. Winter movements and post-breeding dispersal may lead to vagrancy outside the normal range. Wintering migrants of the Asian subspecies have been recorded in South Korea and China, and the nominate form has been recorded west of its breeding range as far as Orkney, Scotland. The Eurasian treecreeper has also occurred as a vagrant to the Channel Islands (where the short-toed is the resident species), Majorca and the Faroe Islands. [2]

Ecology and behaviour

Breeding

Introduced redwoods are the preferred nesting trees where present. Sequoi.westonbirt.600pix.jpg
Introduced redwoods are the preferred nesting trees where present.

The Eurasian treecreeper breeds from the age of one year, nesting in tree crevices or behind bark flakes. [5] Where present, the introduced North American giant sequoia is a favourite nesting tree, since a nest cavity can be easily hollowed out in its soft bark. [9] Crevices in buildings or walls are sometimes used, and artificial nest boxes or flaps may be preferred in coniferous woodland. [2] The nest has a base of twigs, pine needles, grass or bark, and a lining of finer material such as feathers, wool, moss, lichen or spider web.

In Europe, the typical clutch of fivesix eggs is laid between March and June, but in Japan threefive eggs are laid from May to July. [2] The eggs are white with very fine pinkish speckles mainly at the broad end, [2] measure 16 mm × 12 mm (0.63 in × 0.47 in) and weigh 1.2 g (0.042 oz) of which 6% is shell. [5] The eggs are incubated by the female alone for 13–17 days until the altricial downy chicks hatch; they are then fed by both parents, but brooded by the female alone, for a further 15–17 days to fledging. [5] Juveniles return to the nest for a few nights after fledging. About 20% of pairs, mainly in the south and west, raise a second brood. [2]

Predators of treecreeper nests and young include the great spotted woodpecker, red squirrel, and small mustelids, and predation is about three times higher in fragmented landscapes than in solid blocks of woodland (32.4% against 12.0% in less fragmented woodlands). The predation rate increases with the amount of forest edge close to a nest site, and also the presence of nearby agricultural land, in both cases probably because of a higher degree of mustelid predation. [10] This species is parasitised in the nest by the moorhen flea, Dasypsyllus gallinulae. [11] The juvenile survival rate of this species is unknown, but 47.7% of adults survive each year. The typical lifespan is two years, but the maximum recorded age is eight years and ten months. [5]

Feeding

Formica rufa, a competitor for arthropod prey A formica rufa sideviewmirror.jpg
Formica rufa, a competitor for arthropod prey

The Eurasian treecreeper typically seeks invertebrate food on tree trunks, starting near the tree base and working its way up using its stiff tail feathers for support. Unlike a nuthatch, it does not come down trees head first, but flies to the base of another nearby tree. It uses its long thin bill to extract insects and spiders from crevices in the bark. Although normally found on trees, it will occasionally hunt prey items on walls, bare ground, or amongst fallen pine needles, and may add some conifer seeds to its diet in the colder months. [8]

The female Eurasian treecreeper forages primarily on the upper parts of the tree trunks, while the male uses the lower parts. A study in Finland found that if a male disappears, the unpaired female will forage at lower heights, spend less time on each tree and have shorter foraging bouts than a paired female. [12]

This bird may sometimes join mixed-species feeding flocks in winter, but it does not appear to share the resources found by accompanying tits and goldcrests, and may just be benefiting from the extra vigilance of a flock. [8] Wood ants share the same habitat as the treecreeper, and also feed on invertebrates on tree trunks. The Finnish researchers found that where the ants have been foraging, there are fewer arthropods, and male treecreepers spent a shorter time on spruce trunks visited by ants. [13]

Habits

The claws of the treecreeper allows it to attach to the trunks and branches. Certhia familiaris - 01.jpg
The claws of the treecreeper allows it to attach to the trunks and branches.

As a small woodland bird with cryptic plumage and a quiet call, the Eurasian treecreeper is easily overlooked as it hops mouse-like up a vertical trunk, progressing in short hops, using its stiff tail and widely splayed feet as support. Nevertheless, it is not wary, and is largely indifferent to the presence of humans. [2] It has a distinctive erratic and undulating flight, alternating fluttering butterfly-like wing beats with side-slips and tumbles. Migrating birds may fly by day or night, but the extent of movements is usually masked by resident populations. It is solitary in winter, but in cold weather up to a dozen or more birds will roost together in a suitable sheltered crevice. [8]

Conservation status

This species has an extensive range of about 10 million km2 (3.8 million square miles). It has a large population, including an estimated 1120 million individuals in Europe alone. Population trends have not been quantified, but the species is not believed to approach the thresholds for the population decline criterion of the IUCN Red List (declining more than 30% in ten years or three generations). For these reasons, the species is evaluated as Least Concern. [1]

It is common through much of its range, but in the northernmost areas it is rare, since it is vulnerable to hard winters, especially if its feeding is disrupted by an ice glaze on the trees or freezing rain. It is also uncommon in Turkey and the Caucasus. In the west of its range it has spread to the Outer Hebrides in Scotland, pushed further north in Norway, and first bred in the Netherlands in 1993. [2]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nuthatch</span> Genus, Sitta, of small passerine birds from the Northern Hemisphere

The nuthatches constitute a genus, Sitta, of small passerine birds belonging to the family Sittidae. Characterised by large heads, short tails, and powerful bills and feet, nuthatches advertise their territory using loud, simple songs. Most species exhibit grey or bluish upperparts and a black eye stripe.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eurasian nuthatch</span> Small passerine bird species

The Eurasian nuthatch or wood nuthatch is a small passerine bird found throughout the Palearctic and in Europe. Like other nuthatches, it is a short-tailed bird with a long bill, blue-gray upperparts and a black eye-stripe. It is a vocal bird with a repeated loud dwip call. There are more than 20 subspecies in three main groups; birds in the west of the range have orange-buff underparts and a white throat, those in Russia have whitish underparts, and those in the east have a similar appearance to European birds, but lack the white throat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Treecreeper</span> Family of birds

The treecreepers are a family, Certhiidae, of small passerine birds, widespread in wooded regions of the Northern Hemisphere and sub-Saharan Africa. The family contains eleven species in two genera, Certhia and Salpornis. Their plumage is dull-coloured, and as their name implies, they climb over the surface of trees in search of food.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Indian spotted creeper</span> Species of bird

The Indian spotted creeper is a small passerine bird, which is a member of the subfamily Salpornithinae which is placed along with the treecreepers in the family Certhiidae. This small bird has a marbled black and white plumage that makes it difficult to spot as it forages on the trunks of dark, deeply fissured trees where it picks out insect prey using its curved bill. It is found in patchily distributed localities mainly in the dry scrub and open deciduous forests of northern and central peninsular India. It does not migrate. Their inclusion along with the treecreepers is not certain and some studies find them more closely related to the nuthatches while others suggest a close relation to the wallcreeper. They lack the stiff tail feathers of treecreepers and do not use their tail for supporting them while creeping vertically along tree trunks.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eurasian wryneck</span> Species of bird

The Eurasian wryneck or northern wryneck is a species of wryneck in the woodpecker family. They mainly breed in temperate regions of Europe and Asia. Most populations are migratory, wintering in tropical Africa and in southern Asia from Iran to the Indian subcontinent, but some are resident in northwestern Africa. It is a bird of open countryside, woodland and orchards.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Australasian treecreeper</span> Family of birds

There are seven species of Australasian treecreeper in the passerine bird family Climacteridae. They are medium-small, mostly brown birds with patterning on their underparts, and all are endemic to Australia-New Guinea. They resemble, but are not closely related to, the Holarctic treecreepers. The family is one of several families identified by DNA–DNA hybridisation studies to be part of the Australo-Papuan songbird radiation. There is some molecular support for suggesting that their closest relatives are the large lyrebirds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Short-toed treecreeper</span> Species of bird

The short-toed treecreeper is a small passerine bird found in woodlands through much of the warmer regions of Europe and into north Africa. It has a generally more southerly distribution than the other European treecreeper species, the common treecreeper, with which it is easily confused where they both occur. The short-toed treecreeper tends to prefer deciduous trees and lower altitudes than its relative in these overlap areas. Although mainly sedentary, vagrants have occurred outside the breeding range.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">White-breasted nuthatch</span> Species of bird

The white-breasted nuthatch is a species of bird in the nuthatch family Sittidae. It is a medium-sized nuthatch, measuring approximately 15.5 cm (6.1 in) in length. Coloration varies somewhat along the species' range, but the upperparts are light blue-gray, with a black crown and nape in males, while females have a dark gray crown. The underparts are whitish, with a reddish tinge on the lower abdomen. Despite not being closely related, the white-breasted nuthatch and the white wagtail are very similar in plumage. The white-breasted nuthatch is a noisy bird. It has a nasal voice and often utters little cries or vocalizations, often composed of repetitions of small invariant whistles. In summer, it is an exclusively insectivorous bird, consuming a wide range of arthropods, but in winter its diet consists mainly of seeds. The nest is located in the cavity of a tree. The clutch consists of five to nine eggs, incubated for two weeks by the female, who is fed by the male. The two adults then feed the young until they fledge, and for a few weeks after that.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brown creeper</span> Species of bird

The brown creeper, also known as the American treecreeper, is a small songbird, the only North American member of the treecreeper family Certhiidae.

<i>Certhia</i> Genus of birds

Certhia is the genus of birds containing the typical treecreepers, which together with the African and Indian spotted creepers make up the family Certhiidae.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sichuan treecreeper</span> Species of bird

The Sichuan treecreeper is a rare species of bird in the treecreeper family, Certhiidae.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scarlet myzomela</span> Species of bird

The scarlet myzomela or scarlet honeyeater is a small passerine bird of the honeyeater family Meliphagidae native to Australia. It was first described by English ornithologist John Latham in 1801. At 9 to 11 cm long, it is the smallest honeyeater in Australia. It has a short tail and relatively long down-curved bill. It is sexually dimorphic; the male is a striking bright red with black wings, while the female is entirely brown. The species is more vocal than most honeyeaters, and a variety of calls have been recorded, including a bell-like tinkling.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brown treecreeper</span> Species of bird

The brown treecreeper is the largest Australasian treecreeper. The bird, endemic to eastern Australia, has a broad distribution, occupying areas from Cape York, Queensland, throughout New South Wales and Victoria to Port Augusta and the Flinders Ranges, South Australia. Prevalent nowadays between 16˚S and 38˚S, the population has contracted from the edges of its pre-European range, declining in Adelaide and Cape York. Found in a diverse range of habitats varying from coastal forests to mallee shrub-lands, the brown treecreeper often occupies eucalypt-dominated woodland habitats up to 1,000 metres (3,300 ft), avoiding areas with a dense shrubby understorey.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pied monarch</span> Species of bird

The pied monarch is a species of bird in the monarch-flycatcher family, Monarchidae. It is endemic to coastal Queensland in Australia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">White-browed treecreeper</span> Species of bird

The white-browed treecreeper is the smallest of the Australo-papuan treecreepers and sole family member adapted to arid environments. The species foraging strategy involves climbing the trunks of trees in search of invertebrate prey on and under bark. Although some populations within the species range have declined, the species IUCN conservation status is of Least Concern.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">White-throated treerunner</span> Species of bird

The white-throated treerunner is a species of bird in the family Furnariidae. It is the only species in the genus Pygarrhichas. The white-throated treerunner is about 15 cm (5.9 in) long, with a stiff and rounded tail. The upperparts are dark brown, turning red on the lower back and tail and contrasting sharply with the throat and chest of a bright white. The rest of the underparts are coarsely mottled with white. The bill is long, slightly curved upwards. The general appearance is reminiscent of a nuthatch, although they are not directly related. Like the Sittidae, Furnariidae tirelessly scours the trunks and branches of old trees for the small arthropods that make up its food, spiraling up the trunks, or sometimes moving head down. The white-throated treerunner consumes small invertebrates found on bark and nests in tree cavities. Outside of the breeding season, it may form mixed-species foraging flocks with other bird species.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hodgson's treecreeper</span> Species of bird

Hodgson's treecreeper is a small passerine bird from the southern rim of the Himalayas. Its specific distinctness from the common treecreeper was recently validated.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">African spotted creeper</span> Species of bird

The African spotted creeper is a small passerine bird, which is a member of the subfamily Salpornithinae of the treecreeper family Certhiidae. It is found in sub-Saharan Africa in open deciduous forest and mango groves. It does not migrate other than local movements.

Cryphoeca silvicola is a small species of dwarf sheet spider in the family Cybaeidae which has a Palearctic distribution. The generic name, Cryphoeca, means hidden and the specific name silvicola means "living in the woods".

References

  1. 1 2 BirdLife International (2017). "Certhia familiaris". IUCN Red List of Threatened Species . 2017: e.T22735060A111155023. doi: 10.2305/IUCN.UK.2017-1.RLTS.T22735060A111155023.en . Retrieved 12 November 2021.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Harrap, Simon; Quinn, David (1996). Tits, Nuthatches and Treecreepers. Christopher Helm. pp. 177–195. ISBN   0-7136-3964-4.
  3. "Hodgson's Treecreeper Certhia hodgsoni". BirdLife Species Factsheet. BirdLife International . Retrieved 2008-05-27.
  4. Linnaeus, C (1758). Systema naturae per regna tria naturae. Editio decima, reformata. Tomus I. (in Latin). Lars Salvius. p. 118. C. supra grisea, subtus alba, remigibus fuscis, decemris macula alba.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Treecreeper Certhia familiaris[Linnaeus, 1758]". BirdFacts. British Trust for Ornithology (BTO). Retrieved 2008-05-20.
  6. Tietze, Dieter Thomas; Martens, Jochen; Sun, Yue-Hua; Päckert, Martin (2008). "Evolutionary history of treecreeper vocalisations (Aves: Certhia)". Organisms, Diversity & Evolution. 8: 305–324. doi: 10.1016/j.ode.2008.05.001 .
  7. 1 2 3 Tietze, Dieter Thomas; Martens, Jochen; Sun, Yue-Hua (2006). "Molecular phylogeny of treecreepers (Certhia) detects hidden diversity". Ibis . 148 (3): 477–488. doi: 10.1111/j.1474-919X.2006.00547.x .
  8. 1 2 3 4 Snow, David; Perrins, Christopher M, eds. (1998). The Birds of the Western Palearctic concise edition (2 volumes). Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN   0-19-854099-X. 14111416
  9. Cocker, Mark; Mabey, Richard (2005). Birds Britannica. London: Chatto & Windus. ISBN   0-7011-6907-9. 394
  10. Huhta, Esa; Aho, Teija; Jäntti, Ari; Suorsa, Petri; Kuitunen, Markku; Nikula, Ari; Hakkarainen Harri (February 2004). "Forest Fragmentation Increases Nest Predation in the Eurasian Treecreeper". Conservation Biology. 18 (1): 148–155. doi:10.1111/j.1523-1739.2004.00270.x. S2CID   85676085.
  11. Rothschild, Miriam; Clay, Theresa (1953). Fleas, Flukes and Cuckoos. A study of bird parasites. London: Collins. p. 113.
  12. Aho, Teija; Kuitunen, Markku; Suhonen, Jukka; Hakkari, Tomi; Jäntti, Ari (July 1997). "Effects of male removal on female foraging behavior in the Eurasian treecreeper". Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. 41 (1): 49–53. doi:10.1007/s002650050362. S2CID   13001633.
  13. Aho, Teija; Kuitunen, Markku; Suhonen, Jukka; Hakkari, Tomi; Jäntti, Ari (November 1997). "Behavioural responses of Eurasian treecreepers, Certhia familiaris, to competition with ants". Animal Behaviour. 54 (5): 1283–1290. doi:10.1006/anbe.1997.0547. PMID   9398381. S2CID   6235771.