Free Church of Scotland (Continuing)

"Free Church Continuing" redirects here. For the denomination which continued after the formation of the United Free Church, see Free Church of Scotland (since 1900).

Free Church of Scotland (Continuing)
The FC(C) church building in Staffin
Classification	Protestant
Theology	Calvinistic
Polity	Presbyterian
Associations	International Conference of Reformed Churches, Affinity
Origin	2000
Separated from	Free Church of Scotland
Congregations	25 active congregations in Scotland, 1 in Canada, 1 in Northern Ireland, and 5 overseas in the United States
Ministers	25 Ministers in post, plus 5 others not in a post.
Official website	www.freechurchcontinuing.org

The Free Church of Scotland (Continuing) (abbreviation: FC(C), Scottish Gaelic: An Eaglais Shaor Leantainneach) is a separatist Scottish Presbyterian denomination which was formed in January 2000. It claims to be the true continuation of the Free Church of Scotland, hence its name.

Formation

In 1996, Professor Donald Macleod, later to be principal of the Free Church College in Edinburgh, was acquitted of charges of sexual assault when a sheriff ruled there had been a conspiracy against him. ^[1] An organisation called the Free Church Defence Association believed that "it was wrong not to put Professor Macleod on trial in the General Assembly and that the majority has therefore departed from the principle that allegations of misconduct must be investigated not by a Committee of the General Assembly but by the whole General Assembly." ^[2] The FCDA's chairman, Rev Maurice Roberts, was suspended for contumacy in June 1999 for refusing to withdraw his claim that General Assembly in May of that year was characterised by "gross and irremediable wickedness and hypocrisy". ^[1]

In August 1999, the FCDA's magazine, Free Church Foundations, referred to "the evil of Mr Roberts' suspension". ^{[1] [3]} A deadline was set for 30 November 1999 for the FCDA to disband, which it did not. ^[4] Libels were drawn up against 22 ministers who refused to comply, and in a hearing by the Commission of Assembly on 19–20 January 2000 those libels were declared to be relevant. ^[5] The 22 ministers were suspended, and they responded by leaving the commission.

On 20 January 2000 the 'Free Church of Scotland (Continuing)' was formed when those ministers and a number of others adopted a "Declaration of Reconstitution of the historic Free Church of Scotland". ^[6] Johnston McKay suggests that although on the surface the split was about Donald Macleod, in reality it was about theology, with the FCDA "composed of people who adhere much more firmly to the Westminster Confession of Faith". ^[2]

List of Ministers Suspended by the Free Church of Scotland

Below are the list of the 22 Ministers of the Free Church of Scotland who were suspended on 20th January 2000, and became the first ministers of the Free Church of Scotland (Continuing). ^[7]

• Rev. B. H. Baxter
• Rev. Graeme Craig - Lochalsh & Glenshiel
• Rev. H. M. Ferrier
• Rev. J. A. Gillies
• Rev. James I. Gracie - North Uist & Grimsay
• Rev. John W. Keddie - Minister of Bracadale
• Rev. Donald M. Macdonald
• Rev. Kenneth Macdonald - Minister of Snizort ^[8]
• Rev. Allan I. M. Maciver - Minister of Broadford
• Rev. Malcolm Maclean (retired from North Tolsta) ^[9]
• Rev. Donald N. MacLeod (retired from Glasgow-Duke Street) ^[10]
• Rev. John MacLeod - Minister of Tarbat
• Rev. John MacLeod - Minister of Duthil-Dores
• Rev. Murdo A. N. Macleod - Minister of Harris
• Rev. William Macleod - Minister of Portree
• Rev. John Morrison - Minister of Kilmuir & Stenscholl
• Rev. Allan Murray
• Rev. David P. Murray
• Rev. John J. Murray - Minister of Lochcarron
• Rev. H. R. M. Radcliffe
• Rev. Maurice J. Roberts - Minister of Inverness Greyfriars [had been suspended by the Commission of Assembly on 24 June 1999]
• Rev. Henry J. T. Woods - Minister of Paisley

Furthermore, four other Ministers were suspended separately and became part of the Free Church of Scotland (Continuing). ^[11]

• Rev. James Frew [Suspended on 14 February]
• Rev. John J. Harding [Suspended on 24 June 1999]
• Rev. Daniel Mackinnon [Suspended on 14 February] - Minister of Kilmorack & Strathglass
• Rev. William B. Scott [Suspended on 29 February] - Minister of Dumfries

Legal issues

Following their departure, the FC(C) sought a declarator from the Court of Session as to ownership of the central funds and properties of the Church. When the appeal was sent to the Outer House of the Court of Session, Lady Paton dismissed their action without granting absolvitor. ^[5] In March 2007 the Free Church of Scotland proceeded to take legal action at Broadford, on the island of Skye, seeking to reclaim the church manse. The Free Church (Continuing) lost the action at first instance on the decision of Lord Uist, ^[12] and also lost their appeal to the Inner House of the Court of Session. ^[13]

The FC(C) expressed its intention to appeal both the above decisions, but in 2009, the International Conference of Reformed Churches noted that the FC(C) had "withdrawn its appeal of the civil matter that was pending". ^[14]

Recognition

The denomination is a member of the International Conference of Reformed Churches ^[15] and of Affinity. ^[16]

Congregations

The Free Church of Scotland (Continuing) presently has 25 functioning congregations in Scotland, as well as some overseas. ^[17] These churches belong to six presbyteries: the Northern, the Skye and Lochcarron, the United States of America, Navarre & Aragon, the Outer Hebrides and the Southern Presbyteries. ^[18] There are seven congregations and preaching stations in the United States: Atlanta metropolitan area; Washington Metro; Upstate South Carolina; Mebane, North Carolina; St. Louis, Missouri; Opelika, Alabama; Greenville, Texas; and Fredericksburg, Virginia. ^[19] There is also a congregation and a preaching station in Canada, a congregation in Northern Ireland, and a seminars and demonstration farm in Zambia. ^{[20] [21]}

Church	Location	Presbytery	Minister	Active	Web	Founded
Cross (Ness) FCSC	North Dell, Na h-Eileanan Siar	Outer Hebrides	Rev. Greg MacDonald			2000
Harris FCSC	Northton, Na h-Eileanan Siar	Outer Hebrides	Rev. James Clark			2000
Knock and Point FCSC	Garrabost, Na h-Eileanan Siar	Outer Hebrides	Vacant			2000
North Uist and Grimsay FCSC	Bayhead, Na h-Eileanan Siar	Outer Hebrides	Rev. David M Blunt			2000
Scalpay Harris FCSC	Scalpay, Na h-Eileanan Siar	Outer Hebrides	Rev. Raymond A Kemp			2000
Shawbost (Bragar)	Shawbost	Outer Hebrides	Vacant	No services. Linked with Stornoway.		2000
Stornoway FCSC	Stornoway, Na h-Eileanan Siar & Bragar	Outer Hebrides	Vacant			2000
Assynt and Eddrachillis FCSC	Scourie and Lochinver, Highland	Northern	Vacant			2000
Brora FCSC	Brora, Highland	Northern	Rev. Thomas J Buchanan			2000
Duthil-Dores FCSC	Dores, Highland	Northern	Rev. Davide Ratti			2000
Grace Reformed Church, Aberdeen	Aberdeen, Aberdeen	Northern	Rev. Timothy J McGlynn			2000
Inverness-Greyfriars FCSC	Inverness, Highland	Northern	Rev. Murdo MacIver			2000
Kilmorack and Strathglass FCSC	Beauly, Highland	Northern	Vacant			2000
Kiltearn FCSC	Evanton, Highland	Northern	Vacant	No services.		2000
Poolewe and Aultbea FCSC	Aultbea, Highland	Northern	Vacant			2000
Tarbat FCSC	Portmahomack and Inver, Highland	Northern	Vacant			2000
Bracadale & Duirinish (Struan & Waternish) FCSC	Struan and Carbost, Highland	Skye and Lochcarron	Vacant			2000
Broadford	Broadford, Skye	Skye and Lochcarron	Rev. A James MacInnes	No services.		2000
Lochalsh & Strath FCSC	Ardelve, Highland	Skye and Lochcarron	Rev. A James MacInnes			2000
Snizort FCSC	Skeabost, Highland	Skye and Lochcarron	Rev. Murdo A N Macleod			2000
Kilmuir and Stenscholl FCSC	Staffin, Highland	Skye and Lochcarron	Vacant			2000
Portree FCSC	Portree, Highland	Skye and Lochcarron	Rev. Richard R Ross			2000
Arran (Brodick) FCSC	Brodick, North Ayrshire	Southern	Vacant	No services held. Remaining members worship with local FC.		2000
Bethel Free Church, Ayr	Ayr, South Ayrshire	Southern	Rev. Graeme Craig			2000
St Columba's FCSC, Edinburgh	Edinburgh & Galashiels, Borders	Southern	Rev. James I Gracie	Has an outreach in Galashiels.		2000
Knightswood FCSC	Knightswood, Glasgow	Southern	Rev. Calum Smith			2000
Partick FCSC	Partick, Glasgow	Southern	Rev. Andrew R Allan			2000
Shettleston FCSC	Shettleston, Glasgow	Southern	Vacant			2000
Rothesay	Rothesay, Argyll and Bute	Southern	Vacant			2000
Ballyclare and Doagh FCSC	Doagh, Antrim & Portavogie, Down [Northern Ireland]	Southern	Rev. E Trevor Kirkland		Free Church (Continuing) website	2014
Cornerstone Presbyterian Church	Burlington, North Carolina	United States	Rev. Gavin Beers			2016
Dallas Presbyterian Church	Dallas	United States	Vacant			2015 as RPCNA (joined FCC in 2024)
Greenville Presbyterian Church	Greenville, South Carolina	United States	Rev. Robert D McCurley			2007
Metropolitan Presbyterian Church, Washington	Washington, D. C.	United States	Vacant	No services at present		2003
Providence Presbyterian Church	Opelika, Alabama	United States	Rev. J Logan Shelton			2023
Reformation Presbyterian Church	Atlanta, Georgia	United States	Rev. Brent C Evans			2006
Sovereign Grace Presbyterian Church, St Louis	St Louis, Missouri	United States	Rev. Jonathan Mattull			2008
Zion Presbyterian Church	Fredericksburg, Virginia	United States	Rev. Rom Prakashpalan			2024
Iglesia Reformada Continuada	Rubí, Spain	Navarre & Aragon	Rev. Jorge Ruiz Ortiz			2015
Igreja Presbiteriana de Braga	Braga, Portugal	Navarre & Aragon	Vacant			2017 (joined FCC in 2022)
Pau	Pau, France	Navarre & Aragon	Rev. Hughes Pierre			2021

Preaching Stations and Missions

Iglesia Presbiteriana Reformada de Nuevo Laredo	Nuevo Laredo, Mexico	United States	Vacant
Nobleford Presbyterian Church	Nobleford, Canada	United States	Vacant			2022
Reformed Presbyterian Mission	Vavuniya, Sri Lanka	Home & Foreign Missions Committee	Rev. Shanmugam N.V. Partheepan			2012
Westminster Presbyterian Church	Greenville, Texas	United States	Rev. Craig J. Scott			2022

Seminary

The Free Church of Scotland (Continuing) maintains a seminary on the outskirts of Inverness for the training of its ministers.

Music

The Free Church Continuing continues to hold to the exclusive use of metrical Psalms sung without instrumental accompaniment in worship, a position which the Free Church of Scotland has ceased to hold. ^[22]

See also

• John MacLeod, Principal Clerk of Assembly, Moderator of 2006 General Assembly

References

1. Templeton, Sarah-Kate (2 October 1999). "Free Church in crisis as two ministers face suspension". Sunday Herald . Retrieved 24 January 2011.
2. McKay, Johnston (21 January 2000). "A church born out of division". BBC News . Retrieved 24 January 2011.
3. Notices Archived 2012-10-17 at the Wayback Machine , Free Church Foundations. Accessed 24 January 2011.
4. McNeil, Robert (1 December 1999). "Rebels warn Free Church of their plan to break away". The Scotsman .
5. Opinion of Lady Paton, retrieved 16 June 2007
6. Act XVIII, General Assembly Acts 2000-2008 Archived 2011-07-25 at the Wayback Machine .
7. "IX - Act anent Suspension of Ministers withdrawing from Church". THE PRINCIPAL ACTS OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE Free Church of Scotland: 2000 – 2004 (PDF). Free Church of Scotland. p. 27.
8. Webmaster (26 July 2021). "Rev. Kenneth Macdonald". FCC. Retrieved 9 June 2025.
9. Silver, Fred (30 April 2020). "Rev. Malcolm MacLean". We love Stornoway. Retrieved 9 June 2025.
10. Webmaster (26 July 2021). "Rev. Donald N MacLeod". FCC. Retrieved 9 June 2025.
11. "Act VI - Act terminating sentence of Suspension on former Ministers". Acts 2000 - 2004 (PDF). Free Church of Scotland. p. 153.
12. "(First) Reverend Donald Smith, As Moderator of the General Assembly of the Free Church of Scotland + (Second) Reverend James MacIver as the Principal Clerk of the Said General Assembly v. (First) Reverend John Morrison + (Second) Peter MaCaskill + (Third) Roderick MacKay + (Fourth) Peter Matheson, 31 July 2009, Lord Uist". scotcourts.gov.uk.
13. "The Reverend Donald Smith as Moderator of the General Assembly of the Free church of Scotland and Others v. The Reverend John Morrison and Others, 12 August 2011, Lord Bonomy + Lord Drummond Young + Lord Osborne". scotcourts.gov.uk.
14. "2009 Conference Minutes" (PDF). International Conference of Reformed Churches. Archived from the original (PDF) on 27 May 2011. Retrieved 24 January 2011.
15. "Press Release". International Conference of Reformed Churches. Archived from the original on 27 May 2011. Retrieved 24 January 2011.
16. "Affinity Partners". Affinity. Archived from the original on 22 August 2006. Retrieved 24 January 2011.
17. "Congregations". FCC. Retrieved 9 May 2024.
18. "Presbyteries". freechurchcontinuing.org.
19. David Blunt. "Presbytery of United States of America". freechurchcontinuing.org.
20. "Free Church of Scotland". freekirkcontinuing.co.uk. Archived from the original on 3 April 2009.
21. "Free Church of Scotland". freekirkcontinuing.co.uk. Archived from the original on 20 November 2008.
22. "Free Church to allow music and hymns -- BBC News 19 Nov 2010 retrieved 15 April 2016".

External links

• The Free Church of Scotland (Continuing)