Presbyterianism in North America developed from the Reformed tradition of the Protestant Reformation, particularly as shaped by the theology of John Calvin and the presbyterian form of church governance established in Scotland under John Knox.[4] The tradition took root in the American colonies during the seventeenth century through Scottish and Irish immigration and the influence of English Puritans, especially in New England. In 1706, ministers led by Francis Makemie organized the first American presbytery in Philadelphia, and the formation of the Synod of Philadelphia in 1717 marked the emergence of a national Presbyterian structure. Over the following centuries, American Presbyterianism expanded rapidly while experiencing periodic divisions and reunifications driven by theological, cultural, and regional differences.[5]
Twentieth-century controversies and reform efforts
By the mid-twentieth century, these longstanding patterns of division and realignment were especially evident within the Presbyterian Church in the United States (PCUS), the Southern branch of American Presbyterianism. Debates intensified over biblical authority, confessional subscription, denominational governance, and the direction of missions and theological education. Rather than immediately pursuing separation, theological conservatives initially sought reform from within the denomination through publications, advocacy organizations, and efforts to influence denominational leadership and policy.[6] Opposition centered on concerns regarding doctrinal revision, theological trends within denominational seminaries, proposals for expanded ecumenical engagement, and discussions of potential reunion with northern Presbyterian bodies.[2]
A significant institutional development during this period was the founding of Reformed Theological Seminary in 1966. Established by conservative ministers and elders dissatisfied with existing denominational seminaries, the seminary provided theological education aligned with confessional Reformed commitments and became an important center for ministerial formation.[2]
By the late 1960s and early 1970s, many conservatives concluded that denominational structures no longer permitted meaningful reform and that separation was increasingly likely. Tensions intensified further when discussions advanced toward a proposed reunion between the PCUS and the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America (UPCUSA). Concerns that dissenting congregations might be unable to withdraw without loss of property contributed to calls for separation, accelerating the movement that culminated in the formation of the Presbyterian Church in America.[7]
Scholarly and journalistic accounts have differed in their assessment of the role racial tensions played in the denomination’s formation. While many early leaders emphasized theological and ecclesiastical concerns, later reflection within the denomination has acknowledged that its origins were shaped in part by the broader social context of the American South during the Civil Rights era.[6] In 2016, the PCA’s General Assembly formally acknowledged “corporate and historical sins” related to racial segregation and discrimination during this period.[8]
Formation of the Presbyterian Church in America
In December 1973, delegates representing approximately 260 congregations and more than 40,000 members met at Briarwood Presbyterian Church in Birmingham, Alabama to form a new denomination following their separation from the PCUS. The new body was initially organized as the National Presbyterian Church; it adopted the name Presbyterian Church in America in 1974.[7]
At its founding, the PCA organized sixteen presbyteries and adopted the Westminster Confession of Faith and Catechisms as its doctrinal standards. The denomination emphasized what it described as fidelity to Scripture, confessional Reformed theology, presbyterian polity, and commitment to evangelism and missions.[9]
During its first decade, the PCA grew rapidly through the reception of congregations withdrawing from the PCUS, surpassing 500 congregations by the late 1970s.[9]
Expansion beyond the South was accelerated by the case of Wynn Kenyon, an ordination candidate in the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America (UPCUSA) who was denied ordination after stating that he could not in good conscience participate in the ordination of women. Following the decision, which was upheld by denominational courts, several congregations and ministers in Ohio and Pennsylvania withdrew and affiliated with the PCA, forming Ascension Presbytery in 1975.[2]
By the early 1990s, the PCA had grown to more than 1,000 congregations nationwide, marking its transition from a regional to a national denomination. Subsequent growth has occurred largely through church planting, though the PCA has continued to receive congregations from other Presbyterian and Reformed bodies.[9]
The denomination maintains congregations and mission churches throughout the United States and Canada. Its historical archives are housed at the PCA Historical Center in St. Louis, Missouri.
Doctrine and practice
The title page of the 1658 printing of the Westminster Standards, the confessional standard of the PCA
The Presbyterian Church in America is a Reformed, evangelical Christian denomination whose beliefs are defined by its confessional standards and governed by presbyterian polity.
Authority of Scripture
The PCA holds that the Bible is the inspired and inerrant Word of God and the supreme authority in all matters of faith and practice. Scripture is regarded as sufficient for doctrine, worship, and the Christian life, and is interpreted within the Reformed theological tradition.[10]
The PCA recognizes two sacraments instituted by Christ: baptism and the Lord’s Supper. Baptism is administered to believers and to the children of believers, reflecting the denomination’s covenantal theology. The Lord’s Supper is understood as a means of grace, with Christ spiritually present to believers who partake in faith.[10]
Church order and ministry
The PCA practices presbyterian church governance, in which authority is exercised by elders in graded church courts (sessions, presbyteries, and the General Assembly). The denomination restricts ordination to men, based on its interpretation of Scripture regarding the offices of teaching elder, ruling elder, and deacon.[11]
Ethical and social teachings
Consistent with its confessional commitments, the PCA maintains traditional Christian positions on moral and social issues. The denomination opposes abortion[12] and euthanasia[13], affirms marriage as a covenant between one man and one woman[14], and teaches that sexual activity is properly expressed only within marriage[14]. These positions are articulated in official denominational statements and are reflected in the PCA’s standards for church membership and ordained ministry.[11] These doctrinal and ethical commitments distinguish the PCA from some other Presbyterian bodies that have taken more progressive stances on such matters, particularly the Presbyterian Church (USA).
Governance and polity
The Ordination of Elders in a Scottish Kirk by John Henry Lorimer (1891)
The Presbyterian Church in America practices presbyterianchurch governance as defined in its Book of Church Order (BCO), which sets forth the denomination’s constitution, rules of discipline, and procedures for church courts.[11] The PCA’s polity is rooted in historic American Presbyterian practice and reflects continuity with historic American Presbyterian forms of governance.[7]
Church offices
Local church officers in the PCA consist of teaching elders (pastors), ruling elders, and deacons. Teaching elders and ruling elders together comprise the session, which governs the local congregation, while deacons are responsible for ministries of mercy and service. Teaching elders and ruling elders possess equal voting authority in the church courts and jointly participate in examinations and ordinations, reflecting the PCA’s understanding of parity among elders in governance.[11]
Despite this parity, the offices are distinguished by function. Teaching elders are ordinarily responsible for preaching and administering the sacraments and typically serve as moderators of sessions. Ruling elders are members of the local congregation they serve, whereas teaching elders hold membership in their regional presbytery rather than in a particular congregation.[11]
Church courts
Church governance in the PCA is exercised through a graded system of courts. The session governs the local congregation; the presbytery oversees churches and ministers within a defined geographic region; and the General Assembly serves as the highest court of the denomination. The PCA does not utilize synods as an intermediate level of governance between presbyteries and the General Assembly.[11]
Property and association
The PCA affirms a principle of voluntary association among its congregations. Local churches retain ownership of their property, and financial support for denominational agencies and permanent committees is voluntary rather than mandatory. This structure reflects the denomination’s emphasis on local church governance within a connectional framework.[11]
Worship in the Presbyterian Church in America is shaped by the Reformed theological tradition and informed by the denomination’s understanding of Scripture. The PCA teaches that corporate worship should be conducted in accordance with biblical principles and centered on the public reading and preaching of the Bible, prayer, congregational singing, and the administration of the sacraments.[10]
Structure and elements
PCA worship services commonly emphasize expository preaching, in which sermons focus on the systematic explanation and application of biblical texts. Prayer, Scripture reading, congregational singing, and the regular celebration of the sacraments are also central elements. Within the Reformed tradition, worship is understood not only as an expression of devotion but as a means of grace through which God addresses and forms the gathered congregation.[15]
Worship styles
While united by shared theological commitments, PCA congregations exhibit a range of worship styles. Some churches employ traditional liturgies and hymnody rooted in historic Reformed practice, while others incorporate contemporary worship music and less formal service structures. Decisions regarding musical style, liturgical form, and service order are made at the local congregational level, provided that worship practices remain consistent with the denomination’s doctrinal standards and understanding of biblical authority.[11]
Theological orientation
The PCA’s approach to worship is often described as influenced by the Reformed principle that corporate worship should be regulated by Scripture. This principle informs discussion and debate within the denomination regarding appropriate forms and elements of worship, though the PCA has not mandated a single liturgical model. As a result, worship practices may vary across congregations while remaining within a shared confessional framework.[15]
Institutions and ministries
Covenant Theological Seminary
The Presbyterian Church in America maintains a network of educational institutions, denominational agencies, and affiliated ministries focused on theological education, missions, church planting, and ministries of mercy.[16]
Education and ministerial training
The PCA’s official theological seminary is Covenant Theological Seminary, located in St. Louis, Missouri. Covenant Seminary serves as the denomination’s official seminary and a major center for graduate-level theological education within the Reformed tradition, preparing candidates for ordained ministry and other forms of Christian service.[17]
The PCA conducts international mission work primarily through Mission to the World[18], a denominational agency that supports missionaries engaged in evangelism, church planting, theological education, and mercy ministries across multiple continents. Domestic missions and church planting efforts are coordinated through Mission to North America[19], which focuses on establishing new congregations, supporting existing churches, and addressing ministry needs within the United States and Canada. Campus ministry is conducted primarily through Reformed University Fellowship (RUF)[20], which operates on college and university campuses across North America and functions as the PCA’s official student ministry.
Mercy and outreach ministries
The PCA emphasizes ministries of mercy and compassion as an expression of Christian service. Through congregations, presbyteries, and denominational programs, PCA churches engage in efforts addressing poverty, disaster relief, refugee assistance, racial reconciliation, and care for vulnerable populations. While many of these ministries are locally organized, denominational agencies provide coordination, training, and resources to support this work.[21]
The Presbyterian Church in America has grown from a regional denomination at its founding in 1973 into a national body with congregations throughout the United States and Canada. As of 2024, the denomination reported approximately 400,000 members worshiping in nearly 2,000 congregations, served by more than 5,000 ordained ministers. These figures are compiled annually by the denomination’s Administrative Committee and published in its five-year statistical summaries.[22]
Following its formation, the PCA experienced sustained numerical growth through the late twentieth century, driven initially by the reception of congregations from other Presbyterian bodies and later by an expanding emphasis on church planting. Growth continued into the early twenty-first century, though at a slower pace, with periods of relative stability reflecting broader demographic trends affecting Protestant denominations in North America.[23]
While the PCA maintains congregations nationwide, it remains most heavily concentrated in the southeastern United States, reflecting its historical origins in the American South. Over time, however, the denomination has established a significant presence in the Midwest, Northeast, and West Coast, as well as in major metropolitan areas.[23]
Demographically, the PCA is among the more racially and ethnically diverse conservative Protestant denominations in the United States. Studies have estimated that approximately one-fifth of its membership is non-white, including significant African American, Hispanic, and Asian American representation.[24] Korean American congregations constitute a substantial portion of the denomination and are organized in both geographic and non-geographic presbyteries.[25] Korean American leaders have held prominent roles within the PCA and in broader evangelical institutions, including service as General Assembly moderator and as heads of national and international evangelical organizations.[26]
The denomination also includes congregations in several Canadian provinces, a presence that originated in the 1982 merger with the Reformed Presbyterian Church, Evangelical Synod and has continued through evangelism and church planting.[27]
Controversies and criticism
Like many conservative Christian denominations, the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) has faced internal debate and external criticism over matters of theology, church governance, and social ethics.
Ordination and gender roles
The PCA restricts ordination to men for the offices of teaching elder (pastor), ruling elder, and deacon, a position it understands to be grounded in its interpretation of the New Testament.[11] While women may serve in a variety of non-ordained roles, proposals to permit the ordination of women, particularly to the diaconate, have been considered at multiple General Assemblies but have not resulted in constitutional change, reflecting differing convictions among presbyteries and congregations regarding women's authority in the church.[28]
Sexuality and pastoral identity
The PCA’s teaching that sexual activity is properly expressed only within marriage between one man and one woman has been a source of public controversy, particularly in relation to the ordination of ministers who experience same-sex attraction while affirming celibacy and the denomination’s sexual ethics. Beginning in the late 2010s, debates intensified over whether ordained ministers should be permitted to describe themselves using identity terms such as “gay Christian,” even when affirming traditional sexual morality.[29]
Between 2018 and the early 2020s, multiple overtures were proposed to clarify or tighten ordination standards related to sexual identity, terminology, and self-description. These debates attracted national media attention and highlighted differing pastoral and theological approaches within the denomination. Some proposed constitutional amendments failed to receive the required approval of presbyteries, underscoring ongoing disagreement within the PCA over the relationship between personal identity, pastoral language, and ordination vows.[30]
Public statements on social issues
The PCA has issued official statements opposing abortion[12], euthanasia[13], and the redefinition of marriage[31], positions that have drawn criticism from secular commentators and religious groups holding more progressive views. Critics have argued that such stances place the denomination at odds with broader cultural trends, while PCA leaders have defended them as consistent with historic Christian teaching and the denomination’s confessional commitments.
Internal diversity and denominational tensions
Although the PCA requires adherence to the Westminster Standards, the denomination encompasses a range of theological emphases and worship practices. Observers have noted tensions between more traditional Reformed constituencies and those influenced by broader evangelical movements, particularly in areas such as worship style, engagement with contemporary culture, and approaches to pastoral ministry. These differences have periodically surfaced in denominational debates but have not resulted in formal schism.[7]
Relations with other Presbyterian denominations
The Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) is part of the broader Presbyterian and Reformed family of churches in North America and maintains selective relationships with other Presbyterian denominations. These relationships are shaped primarily by differences in confessional standards, church governance, and approaches to ordination and social issues.[7] The PCA shares historic Reformed confessions and a presbyterian form of governance with denominations such as the Orthodox Presbyterian Church (OPC). The two bodies are closely aligned doctrinally and have maintained cooperative and fraternal relations, including collaboration in publishing and educational resources, though they differ in certain practices and degrees of confessional strictness.[32]
At the denominational level, the PCA is a charter member of the North American Presbyterian and Reformed Council (NAPARC), a voluntary association of conservative Presbyterian and Reformed denominations in North America that cooperate in areas such as theological dialogue, missions, and mutual recognition of ministry.[33] The PCA also participates in the World Reformed Fellowship, an international network of Reformed churches and organizations.[34]
The PCA has limited involvement in broader ecumenical organizations and is not a member of bodies such as the World Council of Churches or the World Communion of Reformed Churches, citing theological and confessional differences. The denomination emphasizes cooperation with churches and organizations that share its Reformed confessional commitments and understanding of biblical authority. In 2022, the PCA voted to withdraw from the National Association of Evangelicals, reflecting ongoing reassessment of denominational affiliations.[35]
Frank Barker (1932–2021) – Founding pastor of Briarwood Presbyterian Church and a principal organizer of the Presbyterian Church in America’s formation in 1973.
James Montgomery Boice (1938–2000) – Pastor of Tenth Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia and a leading Reformed theologian and evangelical author.
Edmund P. Clowney (1917–2005) – Reformed theologian, educator, and influential mentor within twentieth-century American Presbyterianism.
Ligon Duncan (b. 1961) – Presbyterian minister, theologian, and former General Assembly moderator; longtime leader in confessional Reformed scholarship.
Tim Keller (1950–2023) – Founding pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City and a prominent voice in urban ministry and evangelical engagement with culture.
Morton H. Smith (1923–2017) – Founding theologian of the Presbyterian Church in America and first stated clerk of the General Assembly.
Francis Schaeffer (1912–1984) – Reformed theologian and apologist, founder of L’Abri Fellowship, and an influential figure in twentieth-century evangelical thought.
R. C. Sproul (1939–2017) – Reformed theologian, founder of Ligonier Ministries, and a major popularizer of Reformed theology in North America.
1234Nutt, Rick (1990). "The Tie That No Longer Binds: The Origins of the Presbyterian Church in America". In Coalter, Milton J.; Mulder, John M.; Weeks, Louis B. (eds.). The Confessional Mosaic: Presbyterians and Twentieth-Century Theology. Louisville, Kentucky: Westminster John Knox Press. ISBN066425151X.
↑McNeill, John T. (1954). The History and Character of Calvinism. New York: Oxford University Press.
↑Hart, D. G.; Muether, John R. (2007). Seeking a Better Country: 300 Years of American Presbyterianism. Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R Publishing. ISBN1629956546.
12345Lucas, Sean Michael (2015). For a Continuing Church: The Roots of the Presbyterian Church in America. Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R Publishing. ISBN1629951064.
↑Taylor, Roy (March 18, 2015). "PCA Affirms Biblical Marriage". byFaith Online. Presbyterian Church in America. Retrieved January 5, 2026.
↑Hart, D. G. (1994). Defending the Faith: J. Gresham Machen and the Crisis of Conservative Protestantism in Modern America. Johns Hopkins University Press.
Lucas, Sean Michael. For a Continuing Church: The Roots of the Presbyterian Church in America. Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R Publishing, 2015.
Coalter, Milton J.; Mulder, John M.; Weeks, Louis B., eds. The Confessional Mosaic: Presbyterians and Twentieth-Century Theology. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press, 1990.
Hart, D. G.; Muether, John R. Seeking a Better Country: 300 Years of American Presbyterianism. Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R Publishing, 2007.
McNeill, John T. The History and Character of Calvinism. New York: Oxford University Press, 1954.
Loetscher, Lefferts A. The Broadening Church: A Study of Theological Issues in the Presbyterian Church Since 1869. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1954.
Old, Hughes Oliphant. Worship: Reformed According to Scripture. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press, 2002.
↑Although Presbyterianism itself originated in Scotland, those denominations stand out as having a more prominent Scottish heritage and/or connection with Scottish Presbyterian denominations.
↑Those denominations allow member churches to be more diverse as regards the reformed tradition that they adhere to.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
