Jay McCarroll

Last updated

Jay McCarroll
Jay mccarroll.jpg
McCarroll on the set of Mare of Easttown , February 2020
Born (1974-10-11) October 11, 1974 (age 51)
Education Philadelphia University
London College of Fashion
Occupation fashion designer
Television Project Runway Season 1 (Winner)

Jay McCarroll (born October 11, 1974) is an American fashion designer best known for winning the debut season of the competitive reality television series Project Runway in 2005. He launched his first collection line "Transport" at a 2006 New York Fashion Week. The launching and making of the collection were notoriously documented in a 2009 documentary film Eleven Minutes.

Contents

Early life and career

Jay McCarroll was born the sixth child of his parents William and Nancy McCarroll of Lehman Township, Luzerne County, and has remained the youngest in the family. [1] [2] [3] One of his siblings is a sister. McCarroll was a member of the Lake-Lehman Junior/Senior High School's marching band. [2] He further attended the Philadelphia University from 1994 to 1997 but was three credits short of earning his degree. [4] Then he graduated from the University's School of Textiles in 1997. [1] He also attended the London College of Fashion. [5] He then distributed his designer clothes to Patricia Field's boutiques overseas in Amsterdam, London and Paris as well as Field's now-closed boutiques in Philadelphia. [1]

Project Runway season 1 (2004–05)

Before the finale

When he was invited via phone to an audition in spring 2004, McCarroll worked in a porn industry for around two years [1] [6] and operated a vintage clothing store in his hometown Lehman, Pennsylvania, 124 miles (200 km) north of Philadelphia. [2] [7] Two days after being cast, he rode a bus to New York City to attend the filming of the series. [5] A gay thirty-year old Pennsylvanian fashion designer himself, [8] his work throughout the season had been a mixture "of sci-fi, technicolor, and street style". [9] The series's official website nicknamed him "The Wild Card". [2]

Up to becoming a finalist, McCarroll had never won any of the season's nine total challenges. [10] Nonetheless, the judges had praised his "consistent creativity" throughout the season and leadership in the fourth challenge. McCarroll had been presented as the "most flamboyant" contestant of the season. [11] In the third challenge, the judges praised his cocktail holiday dress inspired by Art Deco. However, Wendy Pepper's dress was the judges' and sponsor Banana Republic's top choice for being easier to manufacture. [12] In the eighth challenge, when McCarroll's model failed to appear, his competitor Austin Scarlett substituted for her by wearing McCarroll's work on a runway. [11]

During the finale

For the Fashion Week, McCarroll developed a street style collection "Stereotype", influenced by music, Japanese fashion,[ which? ] and his prior work experience in the porn industry. [6] [11] The collection also used "a pastiche of colors and textures" and "featured versatile, monochromatic looks with a tech[-]y vibe." [6] [13] It also included headphones in various colors and huge amount of quilts (influenced by one of his sisters' quilting hobby). [2]

McCarroll became the series's first winner ever against the first runner-up Kara Saun and the second runner-up Wendy Pepper. [14] Several clothes of his Fashion Week collection (alongside several others of Saun's and of Pepper's) were auctioned off via the series's official website when the auction ended on March 2, 2005. The auction sales were donated to Dress for Success. [15]

After the finale

After the win, McCarroll then noticed the clause allowing the Weinstein Company to own ten percent of his brands (which were not established yet at the time). [7] Thus, he declined a $100,000 prize and a prized mentorship from the Banana Republic but, as the winner, was featured on the front cover of an Elle magazine issue. [9] (The Weinstein Company dropped the clause since then. [7] )

Post-Project Runway activities

Life in New York City (2005–07)

After winning Project Runway and then declining the cash prize and the mentorship program, McCarroll moved to New York City in mid-August 2005 in attempt to thrive in a highly competitive fashion industry for two further years. [5] [7] Before then, he received from Philadelphia University a Spirit of Design Award on May 7, 2005. [16]

McCarroll reportedly made a red carpet dress for Runway host Heidi Klum, who requested it weeks after giving birth, to wear at the 57th Annual Primetime Emmy Awards (2005). [17] However, Klum chose instead "a floral, off-the-shoulder Christian Dior frock". [18] [19] In a 2006 interview with The Record , as Klum admitted, McCarroll's red carpet gown was neither "sophisticated" nor "elegant" nor suitable "for the occasion." [20]

McCarroll briefly appeared in the second season (2005–06) of Project Runway [21] as part of an audition judging panel and then a guest challenge judge. [22] He appeared in also Project Jay, a special documentary exploring his post-Project Runway life, which aired on Bravo on February 22, 2006. Saun, Pepper, and Scarlett made cameo appearances there. [23] The removal of his intervertebral disk amid his back surgery was documented in the program. [24] By the same period, he developed a shirt for Katie Lee, then-wife of Billy Joel, and "a kimono-style dress for a member of [the] Manhattan Transfer", a musical vocal group. The "kimono-style dress" was modeled at a New York Fashion Week event, no later than the period. [25]

On September 15 of that same year, McCarroll launched his first collection "Transport" at another New York Fashion Week event. "Transport" was inspired by Archigram, a 1960s-established group of British architects whose drawings mixed "futuristic space-age elements—lots of hot-air balloons, aerodynamic flying cars, and moving streets[...]—with then-contemporary cityscapes." [26] It was inspired by also the B-52's music. [27] Due to his stance against furs, the Humane Society of the United States contributed to and sponsored McCarroll's "Transport" line and runway show. [26] Clifford Pugh of Toronto Star reported audience rave throughout the show toward McCarroll's "mod collection of balloon-print turtlenecks, V-neck balloon dresses and patchwork gowns worn by models with beehive hairdos", but Pugh found the collection not "very good". [28]

McCarroll then worked at a McDonald's-sponsored fashion show in November 2006 as a stylist and designed a dress for an R&B singer Kelis. [29] The dress was made with around three hundred gift cards, some of them crystals-sprinkled. [30] McDonald's auctioned off the dress as "part of a limited-edition ensemble" on eBay on December 18–31 of the same year. The sale of the whole bundle was donated to the Ronald McDonald House Charities (RMHC) for children needing medical care. [31]

By March 2007, some of McCarroll's designer pieces were distributed to Urban Outfitters stores. [32] [33]

Post-New York City life (2007–present)

McCarroll underwent a move back from New York City to Pennsylvania by December 2007 since his father died in the summer that same year. He further taught a fashion-related course at the Philadelphia University starting from 2007. [34] [a] By August of that same year, he had an apartment at the 72nd Street and Riverside Drive in Manhattan. [3] Until almost late 2007, he had a work studio in New York City. [34] [b]

On February 1, 2008, McCarroll's T-shirts started being sold online via exclusively the website of Camp Beverly Hills—the revived brand best known for selling summer camp clothes to then-teenagers of the 1980s. [38] He further made another cameo appearance in the fourth season (2007–08) of Project Runway alongside two other winners, Chloe Dao and Jeffrey Sebelia. [39]

In 2008, McCarroll returned to Pennsylvania and then launched one of his clothes lines via a QVC shopping program. [35] [36] He then designed pink and black T-shirts with a lemonade image, starting from $30, to benefit the Alex's Lemonade Stand Foundation for childhood cancer research. [40] [41] He donated $5 per T-shirt sold for the cause. [41] By January 2009, McCarroll reportedly lived in a house in Philadelphia. [42] He still had been a University professor in later years. [c]

McCarroll then participated in the seventh season (2010) of a VH1 reality television series Celebrity Fit Club . [46] [47] He served as one of team captains and lost 40 pounds (18 kg), the most weight lost of all participating celebrities. [48] [49] [50] He also appeared frequently in a PBS program Quilting Arts . [51]

McCarroll since then has kept his profile low. [52] [53] He worked as a Fashion Ambassador of the Hamilton Mall (Jersey Shore) in 2013–14. [54] By July 2014, he had worked as a textile designer in Philadelphia. [55] He worked for the wardrobe crew of the 2021 HBO miniseries Mare of Easttown . [53]

Eleven Minutes documentary (2009)

A 108-minute [56] documentary film Eleven Minutes, produced and directed by filmmakers Michael Selditch and Rob Tate, [57] about primarily how McCarroll's first independent New York Fashion Week show in 2006 had been made [35] [57] was screened for the 17th Annual Philadelphia Film Festival (April 3–15, 2008), [58] a Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival (Toronto) in late April 2008, [59] the Independent Film Festival Boston at the Somerville Theatre in also late April 2008, [60] the Honolulu Rainbow Film Festival in late May 2008, [61] the Cinema Diverse film festival (Palm Springs, California) in late July 2008, [62] the Calgary International Film Festival in late September 2008, [63] and the Reeling film festival (Chicago) in November 2008. [64] The film was screened for also the New York Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, & Transgender Film Festival and the San Francisco International LGBT Film Festival. [56]

Here! Films and Regent Releasing distributed the film into limited theatres of New York City, Los Angeles, Philadelphia, Phoenix (Arizona), and San Francisco on February 20, 2009. [65] On the same day, the film aired on the here! television network and was distributed as an on-demand content of the network. [66] It was then released on DVD on February 23, 2010. [67]

The Wall Street Journal film critic Joe Morgenstern found the film not as "detail[ed]" as a 1995 documentary film Unzipped about Isaac Mizrahi, yet he wrote that the film "conveys an ample sense of the process" of developing the runway show. [68] An amNewYork film critic Mina Hochberg rated it two out of four stars, writing that McCarroll's "personality is more interesting as sound bites than as a full-fledged film." [69] The Arizona Republic critic Bill Goodykoontz rated it two and a half out of five stars, i.e. between "bad" (two stars) and "fair" (three stars), writing that the film, despite having merits, is "all Jay, all the time, and that gets a little old." [70]

Los Angeles Daily News gave the film three stars, noting the film's portrayal of contrast between winning a competitive reality television series like Project Runway and surviving a "tough, competitive industry" like fashion. [71] New York Daily News critic Elizabeth Weitzman gave it also three stars, noting that "[f]ashion fanatics" would enjoy "the behind-the-scenes perspective" more than others who would see McCarroll "complaining about opportunities other struggling designers would kill for." [72]

Notes

  1. McCarroll was reported on April and July 2008 still teaching a fashion course at the Philadelphia University. [35] [36]
  2. McCarroll told the New York magazine, "I haven't been living anywhere for two years. I sleep at other people's houses. I sleep here if I'm drunk." He referred "here" to his then-studio in New York City. The magazine reported him as "homeless". [3] Nevertheless, McCarroll claimed what he said as a "joke" when the magazine issue was released. [37] He told the Philadelphia magazine that he was "homeless" in just New York City but was in progress of returning completely to Pennsylvania and still had a work studio in New York City. [34]
  3. McCarroll was reported on October 2013, April 2014, and November 2014 still teaching at Philadelphia University. [43] [44] [45]

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Wellington, Elizabeth (February 2, 2005). "Project Runway a boost for Phila. U. grad". Philadelphia Inquirer . p. C-4. ISSN   0885-6613. ProQuest   1905710354.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Medina, Regina (February 25, 2005). "Smalltown designer wins big on Project Runway". Philadelphia Daily News . Local section, p. 9. ProQuest   1905659323.
  3. 1 2 3 Sokolowski, Lisa (August 13, 2007). "From reality TV to real life: Realty winner McCarroll of Lehman Township shares info with Kitchen's Yemola". McClatchy-Tribune Business News . ProQuest   459197535.
  4. Wellington, Elizabeth (February 25, 2005). "Basking in designer's win". Philadelphia Inquirer . p. B-3. ISSN   0885-6613. ProQuest   1905655877.
  5. 1 2 3 McCarroll, Jay (July 24, 2005). "Runway winner is living the dream". Chicago Tribune (Interview). Interviewed by Wendy Donahue. Section Q, p. 2. ISSN   1085-6706. ProQuest   420236220. I'm moving to New York in three weeks.
  6. 1 2 3 Givhan, Robin (February 8, 2005). "Designers in Short Pants". The Washington Post . p. C-1. ISSN   0190-8286. ProQuest   409853895.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Senior, Jennifer (August 3, 2007). "The Near-Fame Experience" . New York . ProQuest   205104408 . Retrieved February 18, 2026.
  8. McCarroll, Jay (March 1, 2005). "He's in and he's out". The Advocate (Interview). Interviewed by Dennis Hensley. Archived from the original on September 27, 2007. Retrieved February 23, 2026.
  9. 1 2 Givhan, Robin (December 9, 2005). "Baggage on the Runway". The Washington Post . Retrieved February 23, 2026.
  10. Wellington, Elizabeth (February 23, 2005). "Pa. designer could cut it: Project Runway will pick a winner tonight". Philadelphia Inquirer . p. E-1. ISSN   0885-6613. ProQuest   1905663832.
  11. 1 2 3 Nachman, Barbara (February 10, 2005). "Best in Show". The Journal News . White Plains, New York. p. E-1. ProQuest   442710995.
  12. Ryan, Maureen (February 16, 2005). "Catwalk calls". Chicago Tribune . Tempo (5) section, p. 1. ISSN   1085-6706. ProQuest   420342608.
  13. "The Final Countdown". Women's Wear Daily . Vol. 189, no. 25. February 5, 2005. p. 36. ISSN   0149-5380. ProQuest   231101605.
  14. Aurthur, Kate (February 28, 2005). "Reality Runway Ratings". The New York Times . p. E2. ISSN   0362-4331. ProQuest   92947939, ProQuest   432992353. Among the three, Ms. Pepper, the scheming dressmaker from Virginia, was abolished first by Heidi Klum, the host.
  15. Schuler, Barbara (February 28, 2005). "The Runway winner". Newsday . Long Island, New York. p. B2. ProQuest   279875695.
  16. Kim, Myung Oak (May 4, 2005). "Winning designer advises students to follow their passions". Knight Ridder Tribune News Service . Tribune Content Agency. ProQuest   457061984.
  17. Ryan, Maureen (February 22, 2006). "Jay McCarroll's got a Project". Chicago Tribune . Tempo section, p. 3. ISSN   1085-6706. ProQuest   420413310.
  18. "Shock about frock". Gold Coast Bulletin (B Main ed.). Southport, Queensland. September 24, 2005. p. 116. ISSN   1321-3830. ProQuest   376069091.
  19. Givhan, Robin (December 15, 2005). "Designer baggage on the Runway". Toronto Star . p. E2. ISSN   0319-0781. ProQuest   438905412.
  20. Klum, Heidi (July 10, 2006). "Talking To: Heidi Klum". The Record (Interview). Interviewed by Marc Schwarz. Hackensack, New Jersey. p. F2. ProQuest   3192875132.
  21. Aurthur, Kate (December 6, 2005). "Another Catwalk for Fashion Series". The New York Times . pp. E1, E4. ISSN   0362-4331. ProQuest   92868140 (print), ProQuest   2226921057 (online).
  22. DiLuna, Amy (January 29, 2006). "Stay in the know on TV's most shameless shows". New York Daily News . Sunday Now section, p. 10. ISSN   2692-1251. ProQuest   306004777.
  23. Ryan, Maureen (February 22, 2006). "Jay McCarroll's got a Project". Chicago Tribune . Tempo section, p. 3. ISSN   1085-6706. ProQuest   420413310.
  24. McCarroll, Jay (February 28, 2006). "Short Answers: Jay McCarroll". The Advocate (Interview). Interviewed by Dennis Hensley. Los Angeles. p. 56. ISSN   0001-8996. ProQuest   215741780.
  25. McAuliffe, Josh (February 21, 2006). "Craze of the Catwalk". The Scranton Times-Tribune . Scranton, Pennsylvania. p. C-1. ISSN   1062-5844. ProQuest   276315492.
  26. 1 2 Wellington, Elizabeth (September 15, 2006). "Clothes up: It's reality-check time for local Project Runway winner Jay McCarroll, whose Transport line debuts before New York's fashion world tonight". Philadelphia Inquirer . p. E-1. ISSN   0885-6613. ProQuest   1909439813.
  27. Piazza, Jo (September 17, 2006). "Attack of the Alums!". New York Daily News . Sunday Now section, p. 9. ISSN   2692-1251. ProQuest   306072358.
  28. Pugh, Clifford (October 26, 2006). "Project Runway Good TV, not so fabulous fashion". Toronto Star (Ontario ed.). p. D3. ISSN   0319-0781. ProQuest   439070678.
  29. Wellington, Elizabeth (December 31, 2006). "'06 Fashion Countdown: The 10 Most Popular Looks of 2006". Philadelphia Inquirer . p. M-3. ISSN   0885-6613. ProQuest   1909686461.
  30. Wilson, Eric (December 14, 2006). "Big Mac with a Side of Flair". The New York Times . p. G4. ISSN   0362-4331. ProQuest   93131625.
  31. Schwarz, Marc (December 18, 2006). "What's that?". The Record . Hackensack, New Jersey. p. F4. ProQuest   3193106189.
  32. Hagwood, Rod Stafford (February 8, 2007). "Talk of the Town". South Florida Sun-Sentinel . ProQuest   387702329.
  33. Larocca, Amy (February 26, 2007). "What Happened to Jeffrey Sebelia?". New York . Vol. 40, no. 7. pp. 206, 208, 210. ISSN   0028-7369. ProQuest   205226434.
  34. 1 2 3 McCarroll, Jay (December 20, 2007). "Chatting with Jay McCarroll". Philadelphia (magazine). Retrieved March 1, 2026.
  35. 1 2 3 McCarroll, Jay (April 24, 2008). "One winner's Runway reality". Boston Globe (Interview). Interviewed by Mark Shanahan. p. D-5. ISSN   0743-1791. ProQuest   405102461.
  36. 1 2 Juska, Elise (July 23, 2008). "Project Runway Favorites: Where Are They Now?". TV Guide . Retrieved February 23, 2026.
  37. Aspinwall, Cary (November 11, 2007). "Runway villains of seasons past". McClatchy-Tribune Business News . ProQuest   458930527.
  38. Huguenin, Patrick (January 31, 2008). "Camp Echo of the '80s". New York Daily News . Thersday section, p. 37. ISSN   2692-1251. ProQuest   306163782.
  39. Dziemianowicz, Joe; Chernikoff, Leah (February 9, 2008). "Posh & Circumstance. Spice Girl Beckham Judges Final Designers at Bryant Park Project Runway Show". New York Daily News (Sports Final ed.). News section, p. 7. ISSN   2692-1251. ProQuest   306180499.
  40. Gross, Dan (November 19, 2008). "Runway Jay designs Alex's shirt". McClatchy-Tribune Business News . ProQuest   456745146.
  41. 1 2 "Style File: Jay's latest". Newsday . Long Island, New York. December 3, 2008. p. B-10. ProQuest   280302224.
  42. McCarroll, Jay (February 1, 2009). "A Taste of Runway". Los Angeles Times (Interview). Interviewed by Monica Corcoran. p. P-5. ISSN   0458-3035. ProQuest   422311163.
  43. McCutcheon, Lauren (October 27, 2013). "Grace: Our princess is back in a glam exhibit. Will Philly swoon?". Philadelphia Daily News . Features section, p. 33. ProQuest   1446724013.
  44. "Season One Winner of Project Runway to Speak at Albright College". Targeted News Service. Washington, D. C. April 7, 2014. ProQuest   1513258984.
  45. Creason, Naomi (November 22, 2014). "Project Runway winner Jay McCarroll makes fashion stop in Carlisle". TCA Regional News. Chicago: Tribune Content Agency. ProQuest   1626879437.
  46. Caramanica, Jon (February 24, 2010). "Celeb redemption keeps VH1 shows engrossing". Chicago Tribune . Live! section, p. 4. ISSN   1085-6706. ProQuest   420772340.
  47. Clack, Erin; Botelho, Renan; Teti, Julia (July 5, 2025). "Project Runway Winners: Where Are They Now?". Women's Wear Daily . Retrieved February 25, 2026.
  48. Catlin, Roger (April 4, 2010). "New This Week". Hartford Courant . p. G-5. ISSN   1047-4153. ProQuest   257398397.
  49. Newsome, Brad (September 30, 2010). "Wednesday, October 6 Pay TV". The Age . Melbourne. Green Guide section, p. 32. ISSN   2203-580X. ProQuest   755412420.
  50. "Bliss Thru Shopping: Celebrity swag". Sun Journal . Lewiston, Maine. November 26, 2010. Lewiston/Auburn Metro section. ProQuest   814335202.
  51. "Get Real with Jay McCarroll". Philadelphia Daily News . November 21, 2011. Features section, p. 31. ProQuest   905177569.
  52. Eichel, Molly (June 25, 2013). "Soap star lived wild Life as Philly teen". Philadelphia Daily News . Features section, p. 7. ProQuest   1371018220.
  53. 1 2 Chandonnet, Henry; Pomarico, Nicole (July 31, 2025). "Where Are All 20 Project Runway Winners Now? A Look at Their Lives After the Fashion Competition". People . Retrieved February 25, 2026.
  54. Gensler, Howard (June 18, 2013). "Local gossip". Philadelphia Daily News . Features section, p. 7. ProQuest   1369030627.
  55. Givhan, Robin (July 24, 2014). "Not Quite Making It Work". The Washington Post . p. C-1. ISSN   0190-8286. ProQuest   1547800113.
  56. 1 2 Scheib, Ronnie (July 28, 2008). "Eleven Minutes". Variety . Vol. 411, no. 10. Film Reviews section, p. 27. ISSN   0042-2738. ProQuest   236234484.
  57. 1 2 Hillis, Aaron (February 18, 2009). "Eleven Minutes". The Village Voice . Vol. 54, no. 8. New York City. Film section, p. 46. ISSN   0042-6180. ProQuest   232298003.
  58. Gross, Dan (March 5, 2008). "Runway Jay here for film fest". Philadelphia Daily News . Features section, p. 39. ProQuest   430447307.
  59. Salem, Rob (April 16, 2008). "Hotbox". Toronto Star . p. E-4. ISSN   0319-0781. ProQuest   439410222.
  60. Radsken, Jill (April 28, 2008). "Almost famous: Eleven Minutes might be all Runway winner McCarroll gets". McClatchy-Tribune Business News . ProQuest   465375421.
  61. "Rainbow Film Festival: This year's event features local show-queen Keisha". Honolulu Star-Bulletin . Vol. 13, no. 144. May 23, 2008. ProQuest   412387398.
  62. Salkin, Judith (July 17, 2008). "Cover story: Festival embraces gay community". The Desert Sun . p. P-10. ProQuest   439816262.
  63. Summerfield, Robin (September 16, 2008). "Calgary film festival features flicks on fashion". Calgary Herald . p. D-2. ISSN   0828-1815. ProQuest   243795153.
  64. Knight, Richard Jr. (October 31, 2008). "Gay film fest takes a mostly American approach". Chicago Tribune . Live! Movies section, p. 2. ProQuest   420764423.
  65. "Forever Fashion". The New York Times . February 19, 2009. ISSN   1553-8095. ProQuest   1858459132.
  66. Levin, Robert (February 19, 2009). "Eleven Minutes of fame". amNewYork . Vol. 7, no. 35. Schneps Media. p. 14. ProQuest   578502249.
  67. Cineman Syndicate (February 17, 2010). "DVD Releases: The Damned United, The Informant!The September Issue". The State Journal-Register . ProQuest   264943264 . Retrieved February 28, 2026. DVDs scheduled for release Tuesday (release dates subject to change). All reviews by Cineman Syndicate.
  68. Morgenstern, Joe (February 19, 2009). "Morgenstern on Film: Designer Rises in Well-Knit 11 Minutes". Dow Jones Institutional News . ProQuest   2220733373.
  69. Hochberg, Mina (February 20, 2009). "Fashion figure not doc-worthy: Eleven Minutes". amNewYork . Vol. 7, no. 36. Schneps Media. p. 18. ProQuest   578479658.
  70. Goodykoontz, Bill (February 20, 2009). "Eleven Minutes feels longer". The Arizona Republic . Phoenix, Arizona: Gannett Media. p. P-7. ISSN   0892-8711. ProQuest   239104768.
  71. "Eleven Minutes a very stylish documentary". Los Angeles Daily News . February 20, 2009. p. L-2. ProQuest   282674426.
  72. Weitzman, Elizabeth (February 20, 2009). "Short Takes: And Sew It Goes". New York Daily News . Gossip section, p. 42. ISSN   2692-1251. ProQuest   306251971.

Further reading