Ligurian (ancient language)

Last updated

Ligurian
Native to Liguria
RegionNorthern Mediterranean Coast straddling South-east French and North-west Italian coasts, including Northern Tuscany and Corsica.
Era300 BCE (?) – 100 CE [1]
Language codes
ISO 639-3 xlg
xlg
Glottolog anci1248
Ligurian map.svg

The Ligurian language was spoken in pre-Roman times and into the Roman era by an ancient people of north-western Italy and current south-eastern France known as the Ligures.

Contents

Very little is known about ancient Ligurian; the lack of inscriptions and the unknown origin of the Ligurian people prevent its certain linguistic classification as a Pre-Indo-European [4] or an Indo-European language. [5] The linguistic hypotheses are mainly based on toponymy and onomastics.

Ancient sources regarding the Ligurians

Map of Italy and its languages. The Ligurian group is N4. The Ligurian is increasingly attested as a non-Indo-European language. Italic-map.svg
Map of Italy and its languages. The Ligurian group is N4. The Ligurian is increasingly attested as a non-Indo-European language.
Liguria in Roman Italy. Meyers b9 s0067b.jpg
Liguria in Roman Italy.
Languages in Iron Age Italy, c. 6th century BC Iron Age Italy.png
Languages in Iron Age Italy, c. 6th century BC

The question of the Ligurians' ethnolinguistic origins and identity has remained unresolved. They may have been a pre-Indo-European people; spoken an early Indo-European language, such as a third primary branch of the Italo-Celtic group or an earlier Celtic language (i.e., separate from Gaulish); and/or gradually come under increasing Gaulish and other influences.

Strabo, around the beginning of the first century, wrote of the region around the Alps: "many tribes [éthnê] occupy these mountains, all Celtic [Keltikà'] except the Ligurians; but while these Ligurians belong to a different people [hetero-ethneis], still they are similar to the Celts in their modes of life [bíois]". He also mentioned that earlier (Greek) sources referred to the Salyes (Latin Salluvii)—then the western neighbours of the Ligures—as the Ligyes, and to their territory as Ligystike. [6] Scholars of the Classical Era usually considered the Salyes to have originated as either a hybrid of Gauls and Ligures or the result of the westernmost Ligurians coming under the influence of a Celtic elite.

Even in antiquity, because of the strong similarities of the Ligures' language and culture to those of the Gaulish Celts, some Greek scholars referred to them as ΚελτολίγυεςKeltolígues ('Celto-Ligurians'). [7]

Herodotus noted that the Ligurians who lived above Massilia referred to travelling hawkers as sigunnai, [8] a word that strongly resembled the ethnonym of the Sigynnae, a nomadic tribe located at the time in Eastern Europe. However, the term may have been derogatory, and the Sigynnae are generally considered to have been Scythian (or members of another Iranian-speaking tribe).

Theories on the Ligurian language

Ligurian as a non-Celtic Indo-European language

French historian and philologist Marie Henri d'Arbois de Jubainville held that Ligurian may have been the first Indo-European language spoken in Western Europe and related to Sicel. In his work Premiers Habitants de l'Europe (2nd edition, 1889–1894), Jubainville proposed that Ligurian may have been the first Indo-European language spoken in Corsica, Sardinia, eastern Spain, southern France, and western Italy, based on the occurrence there of an apparent substrate, represented by place names ending in -asco, -asca, -usco, -osco, and -osca, as well as -inco and -inca. [9] (For examples of the Corsican toponymy cited by Jubainville, see: Prehistory of Corsica § Ligurian hypothesis.) The hypothesis of a wider Ligurian substrate has never been generally accepted or conclusively rejected.

Other linguists expanded on Jubainville's idea. Julius Pokorny adapted it as one basis of a hypothetical "Pan-Illyrian" (or "Illyro-Venetic") branch of Indo-European, supposedly found across Western Europe. Paul Kretschmer saw evidence for Ligurian in Lepontic inscriptions (although these were later generally seen as Celtic). Hans Krahe, focusing on river names, converted the concept into his theory of Old European hydronymy. [10]

Ligurian as a Celtic or Italo-Celtic language

An identification of Proto-Italo-Celtic (or "Pre-Celtic") with Ligurian was proposed by Camille Jullian (1859–1933). In 1934, Henri Hubert noted that this theory had never been widely supported or conclusively disproven. [11] (Hubert added that its standing had not been assisted by an association with another of Jullian's hypotheses, that there had also been something akin to an Italo-Celtic "unified empire".) [11] The Ligurian–Celtic question is also discussed by Guy Barruol in his 1969 paper "The Pre-Roman Peoples of South-east Gaul: Study of Historical Geography". [12]

Xavier Delamarre argues that Ligurian was a Celtic language similar to, but not the same as, Gaulish. His argument hinges on two points: firstly, the Ligurian place-name Genua (modern Genoa, located near a river mouth) is claimed by Delamarre to derive from PIE *ǵenu- 'chin, chin bone'. Many Indo-European languages use 'mouth' to mean the part of a river that meets the sea or a lake, but it is only in Celtic for which reflexes of PIE *ǵenu- mean 'mouth'. Besides Genua, which is considered Ligurian, [13] this root is found also in Genava (modern Geneva), which may be Gaulish. However, Genua and Genava may well derive from another PIE root with the form *ǵonu- 'knee' (so in Pokorny, Indogermanisches etymologisches Wörterbuch ). [14]

Another possibility may be inferred from a second point made by Delamarre: [15] according to Plutarch, in 102 BC, during the Battle of Aquae Sextiae, Ligurian troops fighting for the Roman Republic were facing the Ambrones (a Germanic tribe from Jutland), who began to shout "Ambrones!" as a battle cry. The Ligurians, hearing this as identical to an ancient alternate name for their own people (outôs kata genos onomazousi Ligues), returned the shout: "Ambrones!" No indisputable evidence has been found that the Ambrones of Jutland had partly Celtic origins, and tribes in other parts of Europe also had similar names, suggesting that either the two ethnonyms were coincidental homophones or that a more distant connection existed.[ citation needed ]

Ligurian as a Pre-Indo-European language

Scholars such as Ernst Gamillscheg, Pia Laviosa Zambotti, and Yakov Malkiel [16] [17] posit that ancient Ligurian was a pre-Indo-European language, with significant late Indo-European influence, especially Celtic (Gaulish) and Italic (Latin), superimposed on the original language.

Their thesis is that the Ligurians were survivors of the ancient pre-Indo-European populations that had occupied Europe from at least the fifth millennium BC. [18] These populations would have had languages of their own families, which they would have preserved until the onset of waves of Indo-European migration. Later, the latter would conquer the territories, imposing their culture and language on the Ligurians.

A risk of circular logic has been pointed out: if it is believed that the Ligurians are non-Celtic or indeed pre-Indo-European, and if many place names and tribal names that classical authors state are Ligurian seem to be Celtic, it is incorrect to discard all the clearly Celtic ones when collecting Ligurian words and to use this edited corpus to "demonstrate" that Ligurian is non-Celtic or non-Indo-European. [19]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Celtic languages</span> Language family

The Celtic languages are a branch of the Indo-European language family, descended from Proto-Celtic. The term "Celtic" was first used to describe this language group by Edward Lhuyd in 1707, following Paul-Yves Pezron, who made the explicit link between the Celts described by classical writers and the Welsh and Breton languages.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Taurini</span> Celto-Ligurian tribe

The Taurini were a Celto-Ligurian tribe dwelling in the upper valley of the river Po, around present-day Turin, during the Iron Age and the Roman period.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cisalpine Gaul</span> Roman province

Cisalpine Gaul was the name given, especially during the 4th and 3rd centuries BC, to a region of land inhabited by Celts (Gauls), corresponding to what is now most of northern Italy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ligures</span> Ancient ethnic group in Northern Italy

The Ligures or Ligurians were an ancient people after whom Liguria, a region of present-day north-western Italy, is named.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bituriges Cubi</span> Gallic tribe

The Bituriges Cubi were a Gallic tribe dwelling in a territory corresponding to the later province of Berry, which is named after them, during the Iron Age and the Roman period. They had a homonym tribe, the Bituriges Vivisci, in the Bordelais region, which could indicate a common origin, although there is no direct evidence of this.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lepontic language</span> Ancient Celtic language

Lepontic is an ancient Alpine Celtic language that was spoken in parts of Rhaetia and Cisalpine Gaul between 550 and 100 BC. Lepontic is attested in inscriptions found in an area centered on Lugano, Switzerland, and including the Lake Como and Lake Maggiore areas of Italy. Being a Celtic language, its name could derive from Proto-Celtic *leikwontio-.

The Volcae were a Gallic tribal confederation constituted before the raid of combined Gauls that invaded Macedonia c. 270 BC and fought the assembled Greeks at the Battle of Thermopylae in 279 BC. Tribes known by the name Volcae were found simultaneously in southern Gaul, Moravia, the Ebro valley of the Iberian Peninsula, and Galatia in Anatolia. The Volcae appear to have been part of the late La Tène material culture, and a Celtic identity has been attributed to the Volcae, based on mentions in Greek and Latin sources as well as onomastic evidence. Driven by highly mobile groups operating outside the tribal system and comprising diverse elements, the Volcae were one of the new ethnic entities formed during the Celtic military expansion at the beginning of the 3rd century BC. Collecting in the famous excursion into the Balkans, ostensibly, from the Greek point of view, to raid Delphi, a branch of the Volcae split from the main group on the way into the Balkans and joined two other tribes, the Tolistobogii and the Trocmi, to settle in central Anatolia and establish a new identity as the Galatians.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cynetes</span> Pre-Roman people of the Iberian Peninsula

The Cynetes or Conii were one of the pre-Roman peoples of the Iberian Peninsula, living in today's Algarve and Lower Alentejo regions of southern Portugal, and the southern part of Badajoz and the northwestern portions of Córdoba and Ciudad Real provinces in Spain before the 6th century BC. According to Justin's epitome, the mythical Gargoris and Habis were their founding kings.

The Reii were a Celto-Ligurian tribe dwelling in the modern department of Alpes-de-Haute-Provence during the Iron Age and the Roman period.

The Salyes or Salluvii were an ancient Celto-Ligurian people dwelling between the Durance river and the Greek colony of Massalia during the Iron Age. Although earlier writers called them 'Ligurian', Strabo used the denomination 'Celto-ligurian' in the early 1st century AD. A Celtic influence is noticeable in their religion, which centred on the cult of the tête coupée, as well as in the names of their towns and leaders. During the 2nd century BC, the Salyes were most likely at the head of a political and military confederation that united both Gallic and Ligurian tribes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cavari</span> Gallic tribal confederation

The Cavarī or Cavarēs were a Gallic tribe dwelling in the western part of modern Vaucluse, around the present-day cities of Avignon, Orange and Cavaillon, during the Roman period. They were at the head of a confederation of tribes that included the Tricastini, Segovellauni and Memini, and whose territory stretched further north along the Rhône Valley up to the Isère river.

Bellovesus is a legendary Gallic chief of the Bituriges, said to have lived ca. 600 BC. According to a legend recounted by Livy, the king Ambigatus sent his sister's sons Bellovesus and Segovesus in search of new lands to settle because of overpopulation in their homeland. While Segovesus headed towards the Hercynian Forest, Bellovesus is said to have led the Gallic invasion of the Po Valley during the legendary reign of the fifth king of Rome, Tarquinius Priscus, where he allegedly conquered the Etruscans and founded the city of Mediolanum (Milan).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prehistory of Corsica</span>

The prehistory of Corsica is analogous to the prehistories of the other islands in the Mediterranean Sea, such as Sicily, Sardinia, Malta and Cyprus, which could only be accessed by boat and featured cultures that were to some degree insular; that is, modified from the traditional Paleolithic, Mesolithic, Neolithic and Chalcolithic of European prehistoric cultures. The islands of the Aegean Sea and Crete early developed Bronze Age civilizations and are accordingly usually treated under those categories. Stone Age Crete however shares some of the features of the prehistoric Mediterranean islands.

The Caturiges were a Gallic tribe dwelling in the upper Durance valley, around present-day towns of Chorges and Embrun, during the Iron Age and the Roman period.

The Avantici were a small Gallic tribe dwelling around present-day Gap, in the western part of the modern Hautes-Alpes department, during the Roman period.

The Vediantii were a Celto-Ligurian tribe dwelling on the Mediterranean coast, near present-day Nice, during the Iron Age and the Roman period.

References

  1. Ligurian at MultiTree on the Linguist List
  2. Kruta 1991, p. 54.
  3. Kruta 1991, p. 55.
  4. "Liguri". Enciclopedie on line. Treccani.it (in Italian). Rome: Treccani -Istituto dell'Enciclopedia Italiana. 2011. Le documentazioni sulla lingua dei Liguri non ne permettono una classificazione linguistica certa (preindoeuropeo di tipo mediterraneo? Indoeuropeo di tipo celtico?).
  5. "Ligurian language". Britannica.com. 16 December 2014. Retrieved 29 August 2015.
  6. Strabo & Jones (1917), iv., p. 203.
  7. Baldi, Philip (2002). The Foundations of Latin. Walter de Gruyter. p. 112.
  8. Herodotus (1920). A. D. Godley (ed.). The Histories. Translated by Godley, A. D. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. Book 5, Chapter 9.
  9. Jubainville, H. D'Arbois de (1889). Les Premiers Habitants de l'Europe d'après les Écrivains de l'Antiquité et les Travaux des Linguistes: Seconde Édition (in French). Paris: Ernest Thorin. V.II, Book II, Chapter 9, Sections 10, 11.
  10. Mees, Bernard (2003). "A genealogy of stratigraphy theories from the Indo-European west". In Anderson, Henning (ed.). Language Contacts in Prehistory: Studies in Stratigraphy. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamin Publishing Company. pp. 11–44. ISBN   1-58811-379-5.
  11. 1 2 Hubert, Henri (2013) [1934]. The Rise of the Celts. "The History of Civilization" series. Routledge. p. 162. ISBN   9780415850414.
  12. Barruol 1969.
  13. Delamarre 2003, p. 177.
  14. Pokorny, Julius. "g^enu-1, g^neu-". Indogermanisches etymologisches Wörterbuch (in German). Archived from the original on 26 September 2007 via Leiden University Centre for Linguistics; Internet Archive.
  15. Plutarch. Caius Marius. Chapter 10, Sections 5-6.
  16. Gamillscheg, Ernst (1950). Romanen und Basken (in German). Mainz & Wiesbaden: Akademie der Wissenschaften und der Literatur in Mainz.
  17. Malkiel, Yakov (1952). "Old and New Trends in Spanish Linguistics". Studies in Philology. 49 (3): 437–458. JSTOR   4173021.
  18. Laviosa Zambotti, Pia (1943). "La civiltà dei più antichi agricoltori liguri". Rivista di Studi Liguri (in Italian). 9 (2–3): 96–108.
  19. Dyfed Lloyd Evans (2005–2011). "Celtic Gods: The Gaulish and Ligurian god, Vasio". Nemeton: The Sacred Grove. Archived from the original on 18 May 2013.

Sources