Same-sex marriage in Nova Scotia

Last updated

Same-sex marriage has been legal in Nova Scotia since September 24, 2004 when the province began issuing marriage licences to same-sex couples immediately following a court ruling from the Nova Scotia Supreme Court. Nova Scotia was the sixth jurisdiction in Canada and the ninth in the world, after the Netherlands, Belgium, Ontario, British Columbia, Quebec, Massachusetts, Yukon and Manitoba, to legalise same-sex marriage.

Contents

Nova Scotia has also recognised domestic partnerships offering a subset of the rights and benefits of marriage since 4 June 2001.

Domestic partnerships

On 30 November 2000, the Nova Scotia House of Assembly approved the Law Reform (2000) Act, [a] which legalised domestic partnerships, by a 43–2 vote. [2] [3] The law was assented by Lieutenant Governor Myra Freeman, and went into force on June 4, 2001. Domestic partnerships grant cohabiting couples many of the rights and obligations of marriage, including pension benefits, inheritance and the ability to divide property or other assets at separation or death. These partnerships differ from common law marriages in that they are registered with the state and the property rights of domestic partners are better defined. Both partners must be 19 or older, resident in Nova Scotia for the past 3 months, and not currently married or in a partnership with another individual. [4] Both opposite-sex and same-sex couples can enter into a domestic partnership.

30 November 2000 vote in the House of Assembly [5]
PartyVoted forVoted againstAbsent (Did not vote)
  Progressive Conservative Party
  Nova Scotia Liberal Party
  Nova Scotia New Democratic Party
Total [b] 4327

The passage of the domestic partnership legislation had followed a report by the Law Reform Commission of Nova Scotia in April 1996 that recommended changes to provincial family law. The Commission recommended modifications to the Matrimonial Property Act; "[t]he Matrimonial Property Act had been passed in 1980 as part of a general reform movement across Canada responding to an increase in the divorce rate (once divorce became easier to obtain) and the perceived unfairness under the earlier system of property division on the ending of a marriage. The Matrimonial Property Act has not been altered since 1980." It suggested the passage of a new Family Law Act which would guarantee equal division of family property between spouses and equitable sharing of responsibility for children, as well as recognize a diversity of family forms, including same-sex couples. It wrote in its report: [6]

The Family Law Act should be available to married couples and to opposite sex and same sex couples in cohabitation relationships.

In July 2001, the Nova Scotia Supreme Court concluded that the provision in the Adoption Act that prevented common-law couples from adopting was unconstitutional. The ruling legalized adoption by same-sex and opposite-sex common-law couples. Madame Justice Deborah Gass ruled that "prohibiting a joint adoption where all the evidence indicates these adults are providing optimum care and loving ... defeats the very purpose of the legislation". A spokeswoman for Egale Canada said, "It really is a victory for the expansion of the definition of family and that courts recognize families exist beyond married couples and their children." [7] [8]

Court ruling

Following the court ruling legalizing same-sex marriage in Yukon in July 2004, Sean Foreman, the chairperson of a local LGBT group, said, "We are now considering a change in strategy, to proceed with a similar application in Nova Scotia in the near future, rather than wait for the Reference ." Foreman also asked the federal and provincial attorneys general, Irwin Cotler and Michael Baker, to "immediately begin issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples". On August 13, 2004, three same-sex couples brought the suit Boutilier v. Nova Scotia (Attorney General) against the provincial and federal governments requesting that they be issued marriage licences. [9] [10] The partners who brought the suit were Brian Mombourquette and Ross Boutilier, Kim Vance and Samantha Meehan (who had married in Toronto in 2003 and sought recognition of their marriage at home in Nova Scotia), and Ron and Bryan Garnett-Doucette. The couples were represented by Foreman, also a lawyer at the law firm Wickwire Holm in Halifax. Premier John Hamm said the provincial government would not oppose the court bid. [11]

On September 24, 2004, Justice Heather Robertson of the Nova Scotia Supreme Court ruled that the same-sex marriage ban violated the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and ordered the province to recognize same-sex unions. [12] Ron and Bryan Garnett-Doucette were the first same-sex couple to obtain a marriage licence in Nova Scotia, receiving a licence in Halifax just hours after the ruling was handed down. [11] They said, "We feel really, really good. It's a great day to be a Nova Scotian." The federal and provincial governments did not oppose the ruling, continuing the trend set with the Yukon and Manitoba rulings. Attorney General Baker said, "We certainly did not want to waste taxpayers' money", and Premier Hamm said the province would abide by the court's decision. Leader of the Opposition Darrell Dexter praised the court ruling. Terrence Prendergast, the Archbishop of Halifax, condemned the court decision, stating that "marriage is a natural institution that precedes all social, legal and religious systems", "We must recognize this decision as the end of state support for marriage as we have always known it." [11]

Provincial legislation

An odd proviso to the post-ruling status was that, until a formal change to the provincial Solemnization of Marriage Act, the Minister of Justice still required the terms "husband and wife" to be used by justices of the peace in any wedding. This stance by the Justice Ministry was categorised by some as heterosexist. Shortly afterwards, following warnings of further legal action by the couples' lawyer, the policy was changed to remove that requirement. [13] The Solemnization of Marriage Act (French : Loi sur le mariage; Mi'kmaq : Malie'wuti Tplutaqan; Scottish Gaelic : Achd a' Pòsaidh), however, was not modified to this effect. In October 2017, the House of Assembly approved a bill replacing references to "husband and wife" with the gender-neutral term "spouses". [14] [15] It passed its third reading on 20 October and received royal assent by Lieutenant Governor Arthur LeBlanc six days later.

First Nations

While the Indian Act (French : Loi sur les Indiens; Mi'kmaq : Inu Tplutaqan; Scottish Gaelic : Achd Innseanach) governs many aspects of life for First Nations in Canada, it does not directly govern marriage or provide a framework for conducting customary marriages. Instead, marriage laws are primarily governed by provincial and territorial legislation. However, the Indian Act has some indirect impacts on marriage, particularly regarding band membership and property rights on reserves. [16] First Nations have deep-rooted marriage traditions, placing a strong emphasis on community, family and spiritual connections. For example, customary Mi'kmaq marriages (malie'wuti) incorporate spiritual practices such as smudging and honour songs, along with feasting and traditional dances "binding the human, natural, and Supernatural Beings of our world". [17] Same-sex unions are not explicitly prohibited by traditional Indigenous law.

While there are no records of same-sex marriages being performed in First Nations cultures in the way they are commonly defined in Western legal systems, many Indigenous communities recognize identities and relationships that may be placed on the LGBT spectrum. Among these are two-spirit individuals—people who embody both masculine and feminine qualities. In some cultures, two-spirit individuals assigned male at birth wear women's clothing and engage in household and artistic work associated with the feminine sphere. Historically, this identity sometimes allowed for unions between two people of the same biological sex. [18] The Mi'kmaq refer to two-spirit individuals as etuiwijijaqmijuinu'k. They held various important spiritual and community roles, including as helpers and knowledge-keepers. [18] [19]

Marriage statistics

The 2016 Canadian census showed that there were 2,250 same-sex couples living in Nova Scotia. [20] 126 same-sex marriages were solemnised in the province in 2017, accounting for 3% of all marriages, with 87 (69%) of these being between lesbian couples. [21]

Religious performance

In July 2019, the synod of the Anglican Church of Canada passed a resolution known as "A Word to the Church", allowing its dioceses to choose whether to bless and perform same-sex marriages. In September of the same year, Bishop Ron Cutler of the Diocese of Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island issued a pastoral letter allowing local parishes to perform same-sex marriages. [22]

Some other religious organisations also perform same-sex marriages in their places of worship, including the United Church of Canada, [23] Quakers, [24] the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Canada, [25] and the Canadian Unitarian Council. [26] The First Baptist Church in Halifax also performs same-sex marriages, and in April 2023 ordained its first married lesbian minister. [27]

See also

Notes

  1. The long title of the Act is An Act to Comply with Certain Court Decisions and to Modernize and Reform Laws in the Province. [1]
  2. The Speaker of the Nova Scotia House of Assembly, Murray Scott, votes only in case of a tied vote.

References

  1. "Bill 75. An Act to Comply with Certain Court Decisions and to Modernize and Reform Laws in the Province". Nova Scotia Legislature. 27 November 2017. Retrieved August 18, 2022.
  2. "Unions de fait". www.nsfamilylaw.ca (in French).
  3. "Matrimonial Property in Nova Scotia Suggestions for a new Family Law Act" (PDF). 1996.
  4. "Discussion Paper — Matrimonial Property in Nova Scotia – Suggestions for a New Family Law Act, 1996 CanIIDocs 105". CanLII.
  5. "First Session, Thursday, November 30, 2000". Nova Scotia Legislature. 30 November 2000. Retrieved 10 June 2025.
  6. "Matrimonial Property in Nova Scotia Suggestions for a new Family Law Act" (PDF). 1996.
  7. "Same sex couples may adopt in Nova Scotia". CBC.ca . July 10, 2001.
  8. Auld, Alison (July 10, 2001). "Ruling on adoptions leaves gays 'thrilled'". The Globe and Mail. Halifax.
  9. "Same-sex marriage in Nova Scotia, Canada". Kingston: Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance. 25 September 2004. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013. Retrieved 10 March 2011.
  10. "And Nova Scotia makes six". Equal Marriage for Same-Sex Couples. 24 September 2004. Archived from the original on 2011-04-30. Retrieved 10 March 2011.
  11. 1 2 3 "Homosexual (Same-Sex) Marriages in Canada: Province of Nova Scotia". Religious Tolerance. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013. Retrieved August 18, 2022.
  12. "Nova Scotia legalizes same-sex marriages". Ottawa: Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. 24 September 2004. Retrieved 10 March 2011.
  13. "Same-sex couples still 'husband and wife' in Nova Scotia". Ottawa: Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. 24 October 2004. Retrieved 10 March 2011.
  14. An Act to Amend Chapter 436 of the Revised Statutes, 1989, the Solemnization of Marriage Act
  15. Solemnization of Marriage Act (amended) - Bill 17
  16. "Matrimonial real property on reserve". Government of Canada. Retrieved 17 June 2025.
  17. Benwah, J. "Historical Mi'kmaq Marriage customs". Benoit First Nation. Retrieved 21 September 2025.
  18. 1 2 Sabine Lang (1998). Men as women, women as men: changing gender in Native American cultures . University of Texas Press. ISBN   0-292-74701-2.
  19. Sylliboy, John (2022). "Using L'nuwey Worldview to Conceptualize Two-spirit". Antistasis. 9 (1).
  20. "Families, households and marital status: Nova Scotia". www12.statcan.gc.ca. 8 February 2017.
  21. "Vital Statistics Annual Report: 2017" (PDF). www.beta.noascotia.ca.
  22. "A Pastoral Letter with Respect to Same Sex Marriage". Diocese of Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island.
  23. "Beliefs: Overview of Beliefs". The United Church of Canada. May 25, 2009. Archived from the original on January 30, 2016. Retrieved March 11, 2010.
  24. "Submission to the Legislative Committee on Bill C-38 (CC38)" (PDF). Canadian Friends Service Committee (Quakers). April 10, 2005. Archived from the original (PDF) on September 22, 2007. Retrieved April 18, 2021.
  25. "Evangelical Lutherans back same-sex marriage". www.winnipegfreepress.com. 23 July 2011. Archived from the original on 2016-04-28. Retrieved 2016-04-23.
  26. "Welcoming Congregation Program" (PDF). Canadian Unitarian Council. Retrieved 5 October 2024.
  27. DeMont, John (April 6, 2023). "JOHN DeMONT: How a southern woman made history at Halifax's First Baptist Church". Saltwire.